That the application be refused. REASON: (i) Because of the height, bulk, mass and location of the proposed block of dwellings adjacent Sunningdale Close, this particular element of the development would result in overshadowing, would have an overbearing effect and would impact upon the outlook on no.18, 19 and 20 Sunningdale Close thereby harming their existing living conditions. As a consequence the proposal fails to satisfy national planning guidance PPS1 and PPG3 and also policies GP1 of the City of York Draft Local Plan (incorporating 4th set of changes) - 2005. (ii) The proposal is undermined by the lack of a full landscape plan and specification as part of the design of the scheme. As a consequence the proposal fails to provide for a planned and integrated landscaping scheme. The outcome of which is a development which would be dominated by dwellings, car parking and hard surfacing. As such the proposal would not be compatible with the well established suburban character of the area and is therefore contrary to national planning guidance PPS1 and PPG3 and also policies GP1, GP9 and ... view the full minutes text for item 26a
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Reference: 06/01739/REMM Application at: Northfield School Beckfield Lane York YO26 5RQ For: Reserved matters application for residential development comprising 37 houses and 20 apartments, new changing facility and public open space. (to which 05/00320/GRG3 relates) By: Barratt Homes (York) Application Type: Major Reserved Matters Application (13w) Target Date: 22 November 2006
1.0PROPOSAL
1.1Previously outline planning permission was granted for the development of this site in 2005. The outline approval only considered development of the site in principle and also means of access. All other matters (siting, design, external appearance and landscaping) were reserved for future consideration. The proposal, as originally submitted, was for development of the school built footprint area, the vacant youth club and a small part of the playing fields for residential development. A new changing room building and car parking area were proposed on the playing field with a new access taken from Greensborough Avenue for users of the pitches. The proposal was then amended to delete the Greensborough Avenue access and locate the changing facility etc in place of the vacant youth club building.
1.2This reserved matters application as submitted seeks approval for the remaining 4 matters, siting, design, external appearance and landscaping. It is proposed to erect 57 dwellings on the site. 37 of the dwellings will be houses and 20 will be flats. It is also proposed to: (i) Form car-parking and garages for the associated dwellings; (ii) Erect independent cycle storage and bin storage facilities; (iii) Form a LEAP (Local Equipped Area for Play); (iv) Create football pitch provision for Carr Vikings Football Club and the community; (v) Form car-parking provision and changing room facilities for Carr Vikings; (vi) Create areas of open space; and (vii) Provide 25% affordable housing.
1.4Northfield School was previously used as a special needs school. However following the Council's Review of Special Education Needs the school become surplus to requirements. The Council has adopted a policy to increase the extent to which children with special education needs are educated in mainstream schools. As a result pupils from Northfield School were relocated to new facilities at Hob Moor School and Applefields (Galtres) School.
1.5SITE
The overall site area including playing fields is approximately 2.42ha. Almost half of the site accommodates the predominately single storey school buildings, hardstanding areas and former youth club buildings. The actual defined area which is to be developed is 1.00 ha. The site is located relatively close to Beckfield Lane but is set back from this road by approximately 90.00m. The site is consequently bounded by dwellings to three boundaries.
Application Reference Number: 06/01739/REMM Item No: a Page 1 of 14 To the north (Melwood Grove), south (Prestwick Court and Greensborough Avenue) and the east (Sunningdale Close). To the west is open countryside. There is also a council depot adjacent the site to the southeast boundary.
1.6HISTORY
Previously outline planning permission (05/00320/GRG3) was granted on the 2nd November 2005 for residential development and a new changing facility building. A S106 agreement was entered into with the developer regarding provision of affordable housing and provision of open space.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.