RESOLVED : That the application be approved, subject to the approval of the Secretary of State, and subject to the conditions outlined in the report. REASON: T he proposal, subject to the conditions outlined in the report , would not cause undue harm to interests of acknowledged importance, with particular reference to the character and appearance of the conservation area. As such the proposal complies with Planning Policy Guidance Note 15: Planning and Historic Environment, Policy E4 of the North Yorkshire County Structure Plan (Alteration No.3 Adopted 1995) and Policies HE3 and HE5 of the City of York Draft Local Plan (incorporating 4th set of changes).
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Reference: 06/02838/CAC Application at: The Fishergate Centre 4 Fishergate York YO10 4FB For: Demolition of non listed building in a Conservation Area By: City Of York Council Application Type: Conservation Area Consent Target Date: 23 February 2007
1.0PROPOSAL
1.1This application relates to a two storey unlisted building of traditional brick/tile construction that fronts onto Fishergate. It dates to the early twentieth century. It lies within the Central Historic Core Conservation Area.
1.2The application is for Conservation Area Consent to totally demolish the building to allow for the redevelopment of the site for use as a homeless persons hostel. The full planning application is currently before the Council for determination (ref: 06/02837/GRG3).
1.3A justification statement has been submitted to support the application. This highlights the condition of the building, which has structural defects and is currently stabilised by wall ties. It contains explanation on the difficulties with retaining the building in use and the merits of the alternative proposals. The former points to the need to improve the access to the site to meet highway requirements, which would require the partial demolition of the existing structure, and the difficulties posed by the configuration of small spaces internally and costly reconfiguration of these as well as the raising of the floor level to protect it from flooding. The latter points to the improved vehicular access, more energy efficient building and raising of most of the floor level.
2.0POLICY CONTEXT
2.1Development Plan Allocation:
Areas of Archaeological Interest City Centre Area 0006
Conservation Area New Walk / Terry Avenue 0033
Conservation Area Central Historic Core 0038
City Boundary York City Boundary 0001
Application Reference Number: 06/02838/CAC Item No: Page 1 of 7 DC Area Teams East Area (1) 0003
Floodzone 2 Flood Zone 2 CONF
Floodzone 3 Flood Zone 3
Listed Buildings Grade 2; The Mason's Arms 6 Fishergate York YO1 4AB 0994
2.2Policies:
CYHE3 Conservation Areas
CYHE5 Demolition of Listed Buildings and Buildings in Conservation Areas
3.0CONSULTATIONS
3.1Internal
3.1.1 Environment, Conservation, Sustainable Development
(i) Conservation
Commenting on ORIGINAL Plans:-
The building is situated within the central historic core conservation area, close to the SW boundary which is defined by the frontage buildings onto Fishergate. The front of the building steps forward of The Mason's Arms, which is a listed building, grade II. The line of buildings in this location offers strong enclosure of mainly two storeys onto the street. The majority of buildings are C19th with the cluster which turns the corner exhibiting greater variety of age and form, dating from the early C19th to 1935 (which is the recorded date of the public house).
The frontage building is considered to make a neutral to positive contribution to the conservation area, mainly as part of the group. Although the building is not typical of the are it has some intrinsic interest as an early C20th century industrial/commercial building. Nevertheless the frontage has some architectural quality and interest which includes a deep cornice, decorative brickwork around the openings, some corbelling at mid height, and small paned windows over larger openings, use of bull-nosed brickwork.
The supporting statement draws attention to the sub-standard access conditions, and the poor structural condition of the building, and the requirement to provide a change in level within this zone of the site to avoid flood risk. In addition there is the overall perceived wider community benefit of the new use. Given these factors,
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.