That the Members of the Young Person’s Working Group make the following comments to the Executive Members for Children’s Services and Youth and Social Inclusion: 1. That, due to the Council’s Constitution, the Children’s and Young People’s Champion should be an elected Member, as the Constitution could not easily be changed 2. That Councillor Scott’s term as Children’s and Young People’s Champion be extended until May 2008 until the process of selection has been approved 3. That the election of the Children’s and Young Person’s Champion be moved to May rather than October 4. That Officers bring a report to the next meeting of the Young Person’s Working Group ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Report of the Director of Learning, Culture and Children’s Services.
Options for the selection of the Children and Young People’s Champion.
Summary 1. This report reviews the process used in 2006 to select a Champion for Children and Young People and seeks views from the Young People’s Working Group on whether there is a need to introduce any changes into the system for 2007.
Background 2. The post of Champion for Children and Young People for the City of York was established through the constitution of the Council as a member appointment. The first Champion was appointed for a one year term of office during the school year 2006 – 07. One thousand six hundred (1,600) children and young people were involved in a process of selection that started in April 2006 and was completed during the summer term. The selection process was undertaken through school councils, making use of the annual primary and secondary school council conferences as an opportunity to debate the issues and vote on the candidates. The opportunity to participate was also extended to all secondary schools in the City through a DVD and small resource pack. Four secondary schools involved their wider school community in this way. The selection process was run on a very short timescale, because of the timing of the school council conferences.
3. Although the appointment has been a success, some criticisms were made of the selection process, most notably that there were no clear election rules, as a consequence of which young people did not all have a similar understanding of the process or an equal opportunity to make their voice heard. There was also a lack of clarity about the conduct of the hustings and the publication of election material.
4. This review was also asked to consider whether the post might be opened up to an independent person, rather than an elected member. Each of these issues is considered below, and a series of options proposed for discussion by the Young People’s Working Group. Constitutionally, a decision can only be made by EMAP, and the recommendations of the working group will be reported to the next EMAP on the 19 July. Elected Member or independent person? 5. The champion holds a position with no power and is expected to be impartial. In many ways it reflects, at the local level, the role of Al Aynsley-Green, the children’s commissioner for England, at a national level. An elected member may have time to visit schools during the day and have considerable influence within the council. Elected members also bring with them the authority of having already put themselves up for election and being genuine democratically elected representatives.
6. The case for an independent person as champion is that they are self evidently impartial and, although they may not have the power of an elected member, they would bring a different perspective to the Executive Member for Youth and Social Inclusion with whom they would be expected to work very closely.
7. Should the decision be taken to appoint an independent person, it is felt this role requires someone with a connection with young people e.g. someone at school, university, or someone working with young people in a voluntary or paid role. The individual taking this role needs to have time to talk to young people at schools through the school councils and take this information forward and work with the Executive Member. The champion would be supported by an officer.
Selection or election? 8. The argument in favour of an election is that it would provide children and young people with the opportunity to experience an election process in full by registering, and having a ballot card, polling station and ballot box.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.