RESOLVED : That the application be deferred. REASON : (i) For the applicant to review the design of the proposal in light of Members comments; (ii) For the applicant to provide further detail of the materials to be used; (iii) For the applicant to provide more adequate pictorial representations of the proposals; (iv) For Members concerns regarding the committee report to be addressed.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Reference: 07/01399/FULM Application at: Barbican Centre Paragon Street York YO10 4AG For: Erection of six storey 160 bedroom 4 star hotel (revised scheme to that approved under 03/04075/GRG4). By: Golden Tulip York Ltd Application Type: Major Full Application (13 weeks) Target Date: 13 November 2007
1.0PROPOSAL
1.1This application proposes revisions to the approved scheme for a 126 bedroomed hotel on the same site.
Site History
1.2Planning permission was granted in September 2004 for the redevelopment of the existing site of the Barbican Leisure complex (ref no 03/04075/GRG4). This gave permission for an auditorium, conference centre, and residential development consisting of 240 apartments, a hotel and alterations to the existing multi-storey car park.
1.3An application to vary 9 of the 40 conditions of that consent, to allow commencement of work on site prior to compliance with those conditions, was approved in March 2006 (ref no 05/00882/GRG3). An application relating to the leisure centre building involving revisions to the alterations was approved in June 2007 (ref no 06/02632/FUL).
The Application
1.4The application site relates only to the site of the proposed hotel within the Barbican redevelopment site, and as such a new permission is sought. However the previous permission is a key material consideration and so the proposals needs to be assessed having regard to the approved scheme, which can still be implemented.
1.5The approved scheme involves the development of a 126-bed hotel including a basement with servicing rooms and 17 car parking spaces (accessed via a car elevator). The semicircular building, sited between the Barbican centre and the residential development closer to Barbican Road, would have 4 other floors, to a height of 22.5 m. The inner part would have an atrium enclosure with bedroom facing into it, a rooftop terrace and balconies on the outer semi circular elevation. The drop off area for coaches /taxis would be from Paragon Street. The total floorspace is 11,915 sq, m. The relevant differences between the proposals are: -
Application Reference Number: 07/01399/FULM Item No: Page 1 of 19 - Increase in the number of rooms with introduction of fifth floor, but without exceeding the height limited by condition of the previous permission (22.5 m). This has been achieved by reducing the floor-to-floor heights.
- An indication of the type of materials to be used on the external surfaces (not specified in the previous application).
- Removal of the roof terrace and addition of a landscaped terrace at first floor
- Removal of the basement floor to simplify construction, reducing costs and archaeological disturbance
- Removal of on site parking and car elevator
- Removal of semi circular inner atrium, lifts and creation of a green wall in external landscaped courtyard. The massing of the building is reduced as a result and all bedrooms would now have natural light and ventilation
- Redesign of main entrance and addition of an entrance atrium.
- Area between the hotel and new residential development to be landscaped to provide external paved area
- Pedestrian link created to Kent Street
- Hotel drop off area redesigned
- Balconies removed from the bedrooms
- Redesign of the elevations and main entrance within the established parameters of the massing and scale of the approved building.
- Total floorspace reduced to 9, 569 sq, m
1.6The application is accompanied by a Flood Risk assessment, Design statement, Sustainability Statement and Transport Assessment.
2.0POLICY CONTEXT
2.1Development Plan Allocation:
Areas of Archaeological Interest City Centre Area 0006
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.