CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
City of York Council
Planning Main, Thursday 24 September 2009 at 4.30pm

Appeals Performance

Approved Planning 2 papers

Planning Main approved this item on Thursday 24 September 2009. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item19

Resolved

That the Committee approve Option A to receive quarterly reports with the annex of case summaries as presented. 1. REASON: So that Members can continue to be appraised of appeal decisions within the City of York council area and be informed of the planning issues surrounding each case for future reference in determining planning applications.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting. Source: democracy.york.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from York's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Planning Main

East Area Planning Sub Committee 10th September 2009

West and City Centre Area Planning Sub 17th September 2009 Committee Planning Committee 24th September 2009

Appeals Performance

Summary 1 This report (presented to both Sub Committees and Main Planning Committee) informs Members of the Council’s performance in relation to appeals determined by the Planning Inspectorate in the 12-month and 3 month periods to 31st July 2009 and provides a summary of the salient points from appeals determined in the 3 month period. Going forward it is intended that a quarterly report will be presented to regularly update Members on appeals determined in the previous 3 month period.

Background 2 Appeals statistics are collated by the Planning Inspectorate on a quarterly basis. Whilst the percentage of appeals allowed against the Council’s decision is no longer a Best Value Performance Indicator, it has been used to abate the amount of Housing and Planning Delivery Grant (HPDG) received by an Authority performing badly against the average appeals performance. To date, there has been no abatement of this Counci’s level of HPDG as a result of appeals performance, as performance has been close to the national average for a number of years.

3 Members will be aware that appeal decisions are currently circulated directly to Members when received. However the decisions are not accompanied by an analysis of appeal performance or a case summary. The summaries of appeals determined in the last 3 months to 31st July 2009 at Annex A of the report is provided following requests from Members for a precis of the relevant points for future reference in considering applications. Details as to whether the application was dealt with under delegated powers or Committee (and in those cases the original officer recommendation) is included with each summary. 4 As this is the first appeals performance report, it contains statistics on appeals decided in the 12 months to 31st July, as well as the 3 month period as below. Whilst the Inspectorate breaks down the appeals by type in reporting performance, the table below includes all types of appeals such as those against refusal of planing permission, against conditions of approval, enforcement notices, listed building applications and lawful development certificates. The intention is to present updates on appeal performance with summaries on a quarterly basis.

Fig 1 : Appeals Decided by the Planning Inspectorate For 12 and 3 months to 31st July 2009

East Area West Area Combined 12 mths 3 mths 12 mths 3 mths 12 mths 3 mths Allowed 7 0 15 3 22 3 % Allowed 21.21% 0% 45.45% 50% 33.33% 27.27% Part Allowed 2 0 2 2 4 2 % Part Allowed 6.1% 0% 6.1% 33.33% 6.1% 18.18% Dismissed 24 5 16 1 40 6 % Dismissed 72.27% 100% 48.48% 16.66% 60.61% 45.45% Total Determined 33 5 33 6 66 11 Withdrawn 2 1 2 1 4 2

Analysis 5 The table shows that for the year up 31st July 2009, a total of 66 appeals relating to CYC decisions were determined by the Inspectorate. Of those, 33.33% were allowed and 6.1% part-allowed (e.g in the case of an Advertisement Consent application for a shop, an Inspector may approve a fascia sign but not a hanging sign). This rate of appeals allowed is about the current national average. However for the last 3 months of the period, the proportion allowed was 27.27%, which is a notable improvement.

6 Whilst the number of appeals is very similar for the two teams, there is a discrepency between the number of appeals allowed in each area. The figures were to some extent affected by the upholding of a contentious triple appeal in the West area at Stud Farm in Middlethorpe during this period.

Consultation 7 This is essentially an information report for Members and therefore no consultation has taken place regarding its content.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
summaries 1.5.09 to 31.7.09Appendix A 90 KB Download
PDF
Appeals PerformanceReport 81 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

16 of 18 attended
RW
Councillor Richard WatsonChair, present
AD
Councillor Andy D'AgorneCommittee Member, present
PF
Councillor Paul FirthCommittee Member, present
CF
Councillor Christina FunnellCommittee Member, present
DH
Councillor David HortonCommittee Member, apologies
BH
Councillor Ben HudsonCommittee Member, present
KH
Councillor Keith HymanCommittee Member, present
CJ
Councillor Ceredig Jamieson-BallCommittee Member, present
RM
Councillor Richard MooreCommittee Member, present
JM
Councillor Jonathan MorleyCommittee Member, present
RP
Councillor Roger PierceCommittee Member, present
RP
Councillor Ruth PotterVice-Chair, present

All 18 on the meeting page

On this subject at York

Search all
  1. Appeals PerformanceThis decision
  2. Appeals Performance and Decision SummariesNoted
  3. Appeals Performance and Decision SummariesNoted
  4. Appeals Performance and Decision SummariesNoted
  5. Appeals Performance and Decision SummariesNoted
  6. Appeals Performance and Decision SummariesNoted

More from York Planning Main

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
5 May 2022 MinutesThat subject to the addition of Cllrs Melly and Ayre to the list of apologies, the minutes of the last meeting held o... Approved Open
7 Apr 2022 Minutesi. That the minutes of the meeting held on 3 February 2022 be approved and then signed by the chair as a correct reco... Approved Open
3 Mar 2022 MinutesThat the minutes of the last meeting held on 3 February 2022 be approved at the next meeting. Approved Open
3 Mar 2022 Lindum Group Limited, York Road, Elvington, York YO41 4EP [21/01709/REMM]That the application be approved subject to the conditions listed in the report and the addition of an informative in... Approved Open
3 Feb 2022 MinutesThat, subject to the amendment stated above, the minutes of the last meeting held on 6 January 2022 be approved and s... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies