CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
City of York Council
Joint Standards Committee, Friday 20 January 2012 at 3.00pm

Predetermination and Bias

Noted Committee 1 paper

Joint Standards Committee noted this item on Friday 20 January 2012. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item12

Resolved

That the report be noted. REASON: To ensure that the committee is aware of the provisions in the Localism Act.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting. Source: democracy.york.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from York's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Joint Standards Committee

Summary

1.1The report draws Members’ attention to the coming into force of provisions in the Localism Act.

Background

2.1The issue of whether a Member could participate in Council meetings having had previous involvement in an issue or previously expressed opinions on a matter was a legal bugbear for many years. The issue came before the Courts many times and decisions were reached which were not always easily reconciled with each other. As a result quite defensive legal advice was often given recommending Members not to participate whenever they had previously expressed a view.

2.2In more recent years the Courts have taken a more flexible approach acknowledging that local government decision making is different from judicial decision making. The position reached was that a Member was entitled to have a preliminary view and entitled to express that view and still participate in a decision so long as they had not absolutely closed their mind to making a different decision. The Government has sought to enshrine the position that the common law has now reached in legislation.

2.3What the Act says is that a decision-maker is not to be taken to have had, or to have appeared to have had, a closed mind when making the decision just because the decision-maker had previously done anything that directly or indirectly indicated what view the decision-maker took, or would or might take, in relation to a matter.

\\filer01b\mgdataroot\published\intranet\c00000140\m00006646\ai00027268\$0s0jdw04.doc 2.4 In the House of Lords it was pointed out that if a Councillor announces to the television news cameras outside the Council meeting that he is not interested in what is going to be said at the debate and then says nothing in the meeting, it appears that the decision could not be challenged on the basis of the Councillor’s closed mind. This goes substantially further than the existing law. It seems likely that there will be cases brought which will test exactly how far this provision goes.

2.5It remains the case that local authority decision making is bound by other principles including only acting within powers available, principles of reasonableness etc.

2.6Members of the City Council have been alerted to this provision coming into force and have been advised that the right approach is not to participate in a decision if they know that they have an absolutely fixed view on the issue.

Recommendations

3.1That the Standards Committee note this report.

Author Chief Officer Responsible for the report Author’s name: Andy Chief Officer’s Andy Docherty Docherty Title: Assistant Director of Governance Title: Assistant Director of and ICT Governance and ICT Dept: CBSS Report ü Date 9 January 2012 Ext: 1004 Approved

Background papers None

\\filer01b\mgdataroot\published\intranet\c00000140\m00006646\ai00027268\$0s0jdw04.doc

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
Predetermination and BiasReport 92 KB DownloadRead as text

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

8 of 11 attended
CB
Mrs Christine BaintonIndependent Person, in the Chair, present
AL
Mr A L DixonIndependent Person, present
MR
Mr M R HallIndependent Person, present
PC
Parish Cllr Don CrawfordParish Council Member, present
PC
Parish Cllr David ForsterParish Council Member, present
PC
Parish Cllr Brian MellorsParish Council Member, apologies
DS
Councillor David ScottVice-Chair, present
GB
Councillor George BartonCommittee Member, present
CR
Councillor Carol RuncimanCommittee Member, apologies
DT
Councillor Dave TaylorCommittee Member, apologies
AD
Councillor Andy D'AgorneSubstitute, present as substitute

More from York Joint Standards Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
24 Sep 2026 Exclusion of Press and Public (4.05 pm)That the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of the exempt versions of Annexes A and B... Decided Open
24 Sep 2026 Minutes (4.05 pm)That the minutes of the meeting of the Joint Standards Committee held on 20 July 2026 be approved and signed as a cor... Approved Open
24 Sep 2026 Member Code of Conduct (4.09 pm)No changes were necessary to the Code of Conduct. Reason: There were no changes to the Model Code following the LGA’s... Decided Open
24 Sep 2026 Review of Work Plan (4.20 pm)That the work plan be approved subject to the following additions: 19 November 2026 · Register of Members’ Interests ... Approved Open
24 Sep 2026 Monitoring Report on Complaints Received (4.21 pm)That the report be noted. Reason: To ensure that the committee is aware of current levels of activity. Noted Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies