Community Engagement Task Group decided this item on Wednesday 20 February 2013. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
i ) That Task Group Members attend the next informal meeting of the Residents Association Federation on Thursday 7 March at 11am and the Parish Council Liaison Group meeting on Wednesday 13 March at 2pm to discuss the review findings to date. ii) That the next Task Group meeting be arranged for Wednesday 3 April at 4.45pm. iii) That an Officer from the Corporate Communications Team be invited to attend the next meeting to outline the processes used in providing information for residents. iv) That Task Group members provide a verbal update to the Corporate and Scrutiny Management Committee at their next meeting on 11 March 2013. REASON: To progress the work on this review in line with scrutiny procedures and protocols.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Improving Community Engagement Scrutiny Review – Interim Report
Background to Review
1. In September 2012, having considered a scrutiny topic submitted by Cllr Barnes on ‘Engaging the Disaffected’, the Committee agreed to undertake a scrutiny review to look at the issues affecting levels of community engagement across the city, in the following three areas:
i. Community Engagement ii. CYC Customer Services iii. Financial Inclusion
2. A Task Group was set up to scope and carry out the work on the review on behalf of the full committee.
Information Gathered
3. Members agreed it would be useful to carry out a comparison between two wards with differing levels of deprivation and reasons for lack of engagement, and agreed to focus their review on Heworth & Rural West wards.
4. Initially, the Task Group considered profile information on the two wards and compared levels of deprivation across those wards identified from the initial findings from the Big York Survey 2012.
5. The Big York Survey 2012 (BYS) The BYS is a key component in meeting the objective in the council plan of being completely in touch with our communities. The results of the survey also provide key insight into the progress, understanding and public perception of the council’s work to deliver the council plan priorities, and are used to help inform decisions around the allocation of resources and budget setting. 6. Due to the low number of responses from the two chosen wards, the Task Group agreed to group those two wards with similar wards, and use findings from those ward groupings to support their work on the review – see agreed ward groups below:
7. In December 2012, the Task Group looked at the detailed results from the BYS 2012 together with a Cabinet report highlighting the concerns arising e.g.: • Understanding of Protecting Vulnerable People priority - A higher than anticipated proportion of ‘don’t know’ responses in relation to perceptions of progress on some of the council’s priority areas, particularly around protecting vulnerable people. • Supply of affordable housing - 46% said that the supply of affordable decent housing needed improving. • Jobs Progression Options - one third of people were concerned that people had to commute out of York to work and 45% felt they would personally have to commute out of the York area to develop their career. 8. The Task Group learnt that action was already underway to address those concerns and therefore agreed there was no need for scrutiny to duplicate that work.
9. However, the BYS also showed that in regard to ‘Influence on local area’, only 29% of people agreed they could influence decisions affecting their local area, compared to 42% who disagreed, with 28% being neutral on the matter. The Task Group were therefore keen to understand how the Council planned to address this, particularly in wards containing Parish Councils, where there are no plans to develop a Community Contract (see paragraphs 23-25 below).
10. As a result on their initial investigation, the Task Group agreed the following review remit:
To identify ways of empowering people and improving community engagement Objectives:
a. To improve communications between CYC and Parish Councils b. To improve communications in non-Parish Council areas.
i - Community Engagement
11. Community engagement is very important to a healthy political system. The more engaged a community is in how it is governed, the more it is likely to get out of those who govern it.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.