CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Oct9Wednesday

Area Planning Sub-Committee

YorkHeldPapers from democracy.york.gov.uk
Wednesday 9 October 2013, 2.00pmHeld 4791 days ago.
The George Hudson Board Room - 1st Floor West Offices (F045) Open to the public.
12 items, 14 papersAbout 2.7 MB, led by Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL].
No exempt items listedEvery item is due to be heard in public.
This meeting was held9 October 2013
12items
14papers
7decisions
–exempt
Running order, sized by papersItem 1 to 30
ReportsProcedureExempt parts

The agenda, item by item

What the committee will consider, in order, with every paper attached to its item. Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL] is the main business.

1
Procedure

Site Visited

Attended by Reason for Visit Harlestone, 14 York Road Councillors McIlveen, Gillies, Watson and Galvin As the officer recommendation was to approve and objections had been received Fulford Grange, Grange Garth Councillors McIlveen, Gillies, Watson and Galvin As the officer recommendation was to approve and objections had been received 40 Tranby Avenue Councillors McIlveen, Gillies, Watson and Galvin As the officer...

23
Procedure

Declarations of Interest

At this point in the meeting, Members are asked to declare: any personal interests not included on the Register of Interests any prejudicial interests or any disclosable pecuniary interests which they may have in respect of business on this agenda.

24
Procedure

Exclusion of Press and Public

To consider excluding the public and press from the meeting during consideration of annexes to agenda item 7 on the grounds that these are classed as exempt under Paragraphs 1,2 and 6 of Schedule 12A to Section 100A of the Local Government Act 1972, as amended by the Local Government (Access to information) (Variation) Order 2006.

Decision: That the public and press be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of annexes to agenda Item 7 (minute item 29 refers) on the grounds that these are classed as exempt under Paragraphs 1,2 and 6 of Schedule 12A to Section 100A of the Local Government Act 1972, as amended by the Local Government (Access to Information) (Variation) Order 2006). Decision page

25
Report

Minutes

To approve and sign the minutes of the last meeting of the Area Planning Sub-Committee held on Thursday 5 September 2013. :

Decision: That the minutes of the Area Planning Sub-Committee held on Thursday 5 September be approved subject to the amendment to the wording at minute item 22 to reflect that the Council Tax Student Exemptions should be updated on a yearly basis. Decision page

1 paper, 138 KBSearch inside with Pro
PackMinutes138 KBDownload
26
Procedure

Public Participation

At this point in the meeting members of the public who have registered their wish to speak regarding an item on the agenda or an issue within the Sub-Committee’s remit can do so. Anyone who wishes to register or requires further information is requested to contact the Democracy Officer on the contact details listed at the foot of this agenda. The deadline for registering is Tuesday 8 October 2013 at 5.00 pm .

27
Procedure

Plans List

To determine the following planning applications:

27a
ReportMain business

Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]

Erection of dormer bungalow to rear (resubmission). [ Strensall ] [Site Visit]

Decision: That the application be refused. Reasons: It is considered that the proposed development, by virtue of its siting , design, size and massing would harm the character and appearance of Strensall Conservation Area. The site is undeveloped and provides an open character and sense of space around existing dwellings which is considered the key characteristic of this part of Strensall Conservation Area. The proposed dwelling would erode this sense of space, particularly from views along West End, ...... Decision page

2 papers, 295 KBSearch inside with Pro
ReportHarlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]130 KBDownload
ReportHarlestone.pdf165 KBDownload
27b
Report

Fulford Grange, Grange Garth, York. YO10 4BS [13/02757/FUL)

View the declarations of interest for item 27b Single storey extension to northern elevation and conservatory to southern elevation of existing annexe within the grounds of Fulford Grange. [Fishergate ] [Site Visit]

Decision: That the application be approved subject to the conditions listed in the committee report and the following additional condition: The tree shown on Drawing no.12:70:10 rev D as being retained, shall be retained. In the event that the tree is found to be dead, dying or dangerous it shall be replaced by an appropriate species of tree and in a location to be agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority in the first planting season following the existing tree being removed. Thereafter the... Decision page

2 papers, 251 KBSearch inside with Pro
ReportFulford Grange, Grange Garth, York. YO10 4BS [13/02757/FUL)87 KBDownload
ReportFulford Grange.pdf164 KBDownload
27c
Report

40 Tranby Avenue, Osbaldwick, York. YO10 3NB [13/02931/FUL]

Change of use from dwelling house (Use Class C3) to house in multiple occupation (Use Class C4) with single storey side extension and erection of cycle/bin store (resubmission). [ Osbaldwick ] [Site Visit]

Decision: That the application be approved. Reason: Class C4 HMO's can typically accommodate between 3 and 6 people. The proposed property has 4 bedrooms and it is envisaged that it would accommodate 4 people. Two car parking spaces are considered adequate for the use. The number of existing HMO's within 100m and within the neighbourhood is significantly less than the threshold at which the proposal should be refused. It is recognised that the property has a small rear garden; however, it is considered... Decision page

2 papers, 244 KBSearch inside with Pro
Report40 Tranby Avenue, Osbaldwick, York. YO10 3NB [13/02931/FUL]92 KBDownload
Report40 Tranby Avenue.pdf152 KBDownload
28
Report

Appeals Performance and Decision Summaries

This report (presented to both Planning Committee and the Sub Committee) informs Members of the Council’s performance in relation to appeals determined by the Planning Inspectorate from 1 st July to 30 th September 2013, and provides a summary of the salient points from appeals determined in that period. A list of outstanding appeals to date of writing is also included.

Decision: That the report be noted. Reason: To inform Members of the current position in relation to planning appeals against the Council’s decisions as determined by the Planning Inspectorate Decision page

3 papers, 143 KBSearch inside with Pro
AppendixAppendix A: Appeal Summaries 1 10 13 to 30 9 1339 KBDownload
AppendixAppendix B: Outstanding appeals to 1 10 1319 KBDownload
ReportAppeals Performance and Decision Summaries85 KBDownload
29
Report

Enforcement Cases Update

Members will consider a report which provides a continuing quarterly update on the number of enforcement cases currently outstanding. If Members have any specific queries or questions regarding enforcement cases, please e-mail or telephone Andy Blain, or Matthew Parkinson by 5pm on Tuesday 8 October 2013 if possible so that Officers can bring any necessary information to the meeting. If Members identify any cases on...

Decision: That the report be noted. REASON: To update Members on the number of outstanding Enforcement cases within the Sub-Committee area. Decision page

ReportEnforcement Cases Update96 KBDownload
30
Procedure

Urgent Business

Any other business which the Chair considers urgent under the Local Government Act 1972.

Read inside all 14 papersPro opens every page, searches every appendix, and keeps the papers if the council removes them.

The main business: Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]

Item 27a is where most of this meeting's papers sit: 2 papers, about 295 KB.

Item 27a

Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]

Erection of dormer bungalow to rear (resubmission). [ Strensall ] [Site Visit]

What is in the pack2 papers, about 295 KB
Report
Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]The report to the committee
130 KB
Report
Harlestone.pdfThe report to the committee
165 KB
Read and search every page of this itemPro opens all 2 papers, and keeps them if the council removes them.

How this item got here

This committee has dealt with the subject before.

5 September 2013Great Outdoors, Stirling Road, York, YO30 4XY (13/01670/FULM)Change of use from non food retail (use class A1) to a commercial gym (use class D2) and alterations to existing car park. [ Skelton, Rawcliffe...
5 September 2013Former Civic Amenity Site, Beckfield Lane, York (13/01833/FULM)Erection of 18no. dwellinghouses and 9no. apartments with associated works following demolition of existing buildings. [ Acomb Ward] [Site Visit]
5 September 20131 Foxthorn Paddock, York, YO10 5HJ (13/01327/FUL)Two storey side and single storey rear extensions (resubmission). [Hull Road Ward]
9 October 2013Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]This meeting.

Every paper for this meeting

All 14 papers in one list, with the item each belongs to, its size, and our copy of it. Download any paper from our archive once signed in; read and search it here with Pro.

PaperSizeOur copy
Agenda frontsheetItem
167 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Agenda reports packItem
1.3 MB
Kept 1 Oct
Printed minutesItem
85 KB
Kept 1 Oct
MinutesItem 25, Minutes
138 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]Item 27a, Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]
130 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Harlestone.pdfItem 27a, Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]
165 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Fulford Grange, Grange Garth, York. YO10 4BS [13/02757/FUL)Item 27b, Fulford Grange, Grange Garth, York. YO10 4BS [13/02757/FUL)
87 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Fulford Grange.pdfItem 27b, Fulford Grange, Grange Garth, York. YO10 4BS [13/02757/FUL)
164 KB
Kept 1 Oct
40 Tranby Avenue, Osbaldwick, York. YO10 3NB [13/02931/FUL]Item 27c, 40 Tranby Avenue, Osbaldwick, York. YO10 3NB [13/02931/FUL]
92 KB
Kept 1 Oct
40 Tranby Avenue.pdfItem 27c, 40 Tranby Avenue, Osbaldwick, York. YO10 3NB [13/02931/FUL]
152 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Appeal Summaries 1 10 13 to 30 9 13Appendix A, item 28, Appeals Performance and Decision Summaries
39 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Outstanding appeals to 1 10 13Appendix B, item 28, Appeals Performance and Decision Summaries
19 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Appeals Performance and Decision SummariesItem 28, Appeals Performance and Decision Summaries
85 KB
Kept 1 Oct
Enforcement Cases UpdateItem 29, Enforcement Cases Update
96 KB
Kept 1 Oct

Last time, and what carried over

The committee last met on 5 September 2013. 4 of its items lead into this meeting; 3 items are new. Point at any item to follow a thread. Procedural items are left out.

Sep5
5 September 201312 items, 16 papers
Held
carried over
Oct9
9 October 201312 items, 14 papers
Held
19
MinutesTo approve and sign the minutes of the last meeting of the Planning...
21a
1 Foxthorn Paddock, York, YO10 5HJ (13/01327/FUL)Two storey side and single storey rear extensions (resubmission)....
21b
Former Civic Amenity Site, Beckfield Lane, York (13/01833/FULM)Erection of 18no. dwellinghouses and 9no. apartments with associated...
21c
Great Outdoors, Stirling Road, York, YO30 4XY (13/01670/FULM)Change of use from non food retail (use class A1) to a commercial gym...
21d
Wills and Ellis Garage, Boroughbridge Road, York, YO26 6QD (13/02439/OUT)Outline application for demolition of existing buildings and erection...
21e
2 - 16 Piccadilly, York (13/02559/FULM)Change of use of existing ground floor retail units to either retail...
21f
1 Allendale, York, YO24 2SF (13/02155/FUL)Single storey side extension. [ Dringhouses and Woodthorpe Ward]
25
MinutesNew this time
27a
Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]Erection of dormer bungalow to rear (resubmission). [ Strensall ]...
27b
Fulford Grange, Grange Garth, York. YO10 4BS [13/02757/FUL)View the declarations of interest for item 27b Single storey...
27c
40 Tranby Avenue, Osbaldwick, York. YO10 3NB [13/02931/FUL]Change of use from dwelling house (Use Class C3) to house in multiple...
28
Appeals Performance and Decision SummariesNew this time
29
Enforcement Cases UpdateNew this time

The threads

  • 1 Foxthorn Paddock, York, YO10 5HJ (13/01327/FUL) leads to item 27a, Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]
  • 1 Foxthorn Paddock, York, YO10 5HJ (13/01327/FUL) leads to item 27b, Fulford Grange, Grange Garth, York. YO10 4BS [13/02757/FUL)
  • 1 Foxthorn Paddock, York, YO10 5HJ (13/01327/FUL) leads to item 27c, 40 Tranby Avenue, Osbaldwick, York. YO10 3NB [13/02931/FUL]
  • Great Outdoors, Stirling Road, York, YO30 4XY (13/01670/FULM) leads to item 27a, Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]
  • Wills and Ellis Garage, Boroughbridge Road, York, YO26 6QD (13/02439/OUT) leads to item 27a, Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]
  • 1 Allendale, York, YO24 2SF (13/02155/FUL) leads to item 27a, Harlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL]
  • 1 Allendale, York, YO24 2SF (13/02155/FUL) leads to item 27b, Fulford Grange, Grange Garth, York. YO10 4BS [13/02757/FUL)
  • 1 Allendale, York, YO24 2SF (13/02155/FUL) leads to item 27c, 40 Tranby Avenue, Osbaldwick, York. YO10 3NB [13/02931/FUL]

Not carried over

Former Civic Amenity Site, Beckfield Lane, York (13/01833/FULM), 2 - 16 Piccadilly, York (13/02559/FULM) do not return this time.

See the 5 September meeting

This committee over time

Every Area Planning Sub-Committee meeting we have read, the dates it has set for the future, and each time those dates have changed.

121 meetings, 2013 to 2022Dot size shows the number of papers
20132015201720192021
HeldThis meeting
MeetingItemsPapers
28 Apr 2022Thursday
7items
18papers
HeldOpen
14 Apr 2022Thursday
6items
11papers
HeldOpen
10 Mar 2022Thursday
6items
11papers
HeldOpen
16 Feb 2022Wednesday
7items
18papers
HeldOpen
27 Jan 2022Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
20 Jan 2022Thursday
8items
18papers
HeldOpen
8 Dec 2021Wednesday
7items
15papers
HeldOpen
30 Nov 2021Tuesday
6items
13papers
HeldOpen
25 Nov 2021Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
11 Nov 2021Thursday
5items
10papers
HeldOpen
13 Oct 2021Wednesday
10items
27papers
HeldOpen
16 Sep 2021Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
9 Sep 2021Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
19 Aug 2021Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
12 Aug 2021Thursday
7items
15papers
HeldOpen
8 Jul 2021Thursday
7items
20papers
HeldOpen
23 Jun 2021Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
10 Jun 2021Thursday
6items
13papers
HeldOpen
26 May 2021Wednesday
5items
11papers
HeldOpen
13 May 2021Thursday
5items
11papers
HeldOpen
21 Apr 2021Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
15 Apr 2021Thursday
6items
15papers
HeldOpen
30 Mar 2021Tuesday
10items
26papers
HeldOpen
24 Mar 2021Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
11 Mar 2021Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
24 Feb 2021Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
18 Feb 2021Thursday
6items
12papers
HeldOpen
27 Jan 2021Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
21 Jan 2021Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
23 Dec 2020Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
10 Dec 2020Thursday
6items
13papers
HeldOpen
25 Nov 2020Wednesday
8items
18papers
HeldOpen
11 Nov 2020Wednesday
5items
14papers
HeldOpen
15 Oct 2020Thursday
7items
16papers
HeldOpen
17 Sep 2020Thursday
8items
13papers
HeldOpen
20 Aug 2020Thursday
10items
16papers
HeldOpen
5 Aug 2020Wednesday
9items
16papers
HeldOpen
16 Jul 2020Thursday
7items
14papers
HeldOpen
18 Jun 2020Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
7 May 2020Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
16 Apr 2020Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
5 Mar 2020Thursday
13items
20papers
HeldOpen
6 Feb 2020Thursday
8items
12papers
HeldOpen
9 Jan 2020Thursday
8items
13papers
HeldOpen
5 Dec 2019Thursday
10items
18papers
HeldOpen
7 Nov 2019Thursday
7items
9papers
HeldOpen
3 Oct 2019Thursday
9items
13papers
HeldOpen
5 Sep 2019Thursday
9items
13papers
HeldOpen
8 Aug 2019Thursday
7items
15papers
HeldOpen
4 Jul 2019Thursday
8items
12papers
HeldOpen
6 Jun 2019Thursday
14items
22papers
HeldOpen
4 Apr 2019Thursday
6items
6papers
HeldOpen
20 Mar 2019Wednesday
15items
26papers
HeldOpen
7 Feb 2019Thursday
10items
16papers
HeldOpen
10 Jan 2019Thursday
5items
8papers
HeldOpen
6 Dec 2018Thursday
11items
19papers
HeldOpen
8 Nov 2018Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
4 Oct 2018Thursday
8items
13papers
HeldOpen
6 Sep 2018Thursday
13items
19papers
HeldOpen
9 Aug 2018Thursday
11items
19papers
HeldOpen
5 Jul 2018Thursday
9items
14papers
HeldOpen
7 Jun 2018Thursday
12items
18papers
HeldOpen
3 May 2018Thursday
10items
15papers
HeldOpen
5 Apr 2018Thursday
10items
14papers
HeldOpen
8 Mar 2018Thursday
7items
8papers
HeldOpen
7 Feb 2018Wednesday
9items
11papers
HeldOpen
11 Jan 2018Thursday
10items
14papers
HeldOpen
30 Nov 2017Thursday
12items
20papers
HeldOpen
9 Nov 2017Thursday
11items
16papers
HeldOpen
5 Oct 2017Thursday
11items
15papers
HeldOpen
7 Sep 2017Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
10 Aug 2017Thursday
15items
24papers
HeldOpen
6 Jul 2017Thursday
12items
18papers
HeldOpen
8 Jun 2017Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
4 May 2017Thursday
9items
14papers
HeldOpen
6 Apr 2017Thursday
10items
15papers
HeldOpen
2 Mar 2017Thursday
12items
17papers
HeldOpen
2 Feb 2017Thursday
14items
22papers
HeldOpen
5 Jan 2017Thursday
16items
38papers
HeldOpen
1 Dec 2016Thursday
12items
20papers
HeldOpen
3 Nov 2016Thursday
9items
12papers
HeldOpen
6 Oct 2016Thursday
15items
33papers
HeldOpen
8 Sep 2016Thursday
21items
42papers
HeldOpen
4 Aug 2016Thursday
15items
29papers
HeldOpen
7 Jul 2016Thursday
9items
12papers
HeldOpen
9 Jun 2016Thursday
11items
22papers
HeldOpen
5 May 2016Thursday
9items
14papers
HeldOpen
7 Apr 2016Thursday
7items
11papers
HeldOpen
10 Mar 2016Thursday
11items
17papers
HeldOpen
4 Feb 2016Thursday
12items
21papers
HeldOpen
7 Jan 2016Thursday
8items
16papers
HeldOpen
3 Dec 2015Thursday
13items
22papers
HeldOpen
5 Nov 2015Thursday
11items
20papers
HeldOpen
15 Oct 2015Thursday
14items
23papers
HeldOpen
3 Sep 2015Thursday
11items
17papers
HeldOpen
6 Aug 2015Thursday
10items
12papers
HeldOpen
9 Jul 2015Thursday
7items
8papers
HeldOpen
11 Jun 2015Thursday
18items
36papers
HeldOpen
9 Apr 2015Thursday
7items
5papers
HeldOpen
5 Mar 2015Thursday
14items
25papers
HeldOpen
5 Feb 2015Thursday
13items
18papers
HeldOpen
8 Jan 2015Thursday
12items
20papers
HeldOpen
4 Dec 2014Thursday
7items
11papers
HeldOpen
6 Nov 2014Thursday
8items
12papers
HeldOpen
8 Oct 2014Wednesday
11items
13papers
HeldOpen
4 Sep 2014Thursday
9items
10papers
HeldOpen
7 Aug 2014Thursday
12items
19papers
HeldOpen
3 Jul 2014Thursday
11items
13papers
HeldOpen
5 Jun 2014Thursday
12items
17papers
HeldOpen
8 May 2014Thursday
10items
16papers
HeldOpen
10 Apr 2014Thursday
10items
12papers
HeldOpen
6 Mar 2014Thursday
9items
11papers
HeldOpen
6 Feb 2014Thursday
18items
31papers
HeldOpen
9 Jan 2014Thursday
10items
13papers
HeldOpen
5 Dec 2013Thursday
8items
8papers
HeldOpen
7 Nov 2013Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
9 Oct 2013Wednesday, this meeting
12items
14papers
5 Sep 2013Thursday
12items
16papers
HeldOpen
8 Aug 2013Thursday
13items
21papers
HeldOpen
4 Jul 2013Thursday
15items
19papers
HeldOpen
6 Jun 2013Thursday
25items
43papers
HeldOpen

Follow the Area Planning Sub-Committee

Choose what you want to hear about. The preview is built from this committee's real papers and changes, so you can see what would have reached you.

What should we tell you?

York, Area Planning Sub-Committee

Area Planning Sub-Committee: 3 kinds of updateYork, sent the same day
PDF
14 papers published for 9 OctoberHarlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL] and 13 more papers
DAT
Meeting dates updatedAny date added, moved or dropped
DEC
Decisions from 9 OctoberThe committee's resolutions, the day they are recorded
ABC
"harlestone" found in 2 papersHarlestone, 14 York Road, Strensall, York. YO32 5UN [13/02383/FUL] and Harlestone.pdf
Each update links to the paper and the council's own copy
Free: one weekly alert. Pro: every option, the same day. Pro Plus: straight into your own systems.

Free

One alert, sent weekly, on titles and decisions.

£0for good
  • 1 alert, weekly summary
  • Titles and decisions
  • Link to every official paper
Save this alert free
Most chosen

Pro

Unlimited alerts the same day, searching every page.

£99per user a month
  • Unlimited alerts, same day
  • Matches inside every page and appendix
  • Every council, not just this one

Pro Plus

Your team, with every match pushed into your own tools.

£449a month, 3 users included
  • Everything in Pro, for 3 users
  • Alerts as webhooks into Slack or a CRM
  • API key and bulk export of this council

Data licence

Every council's records in your own products and research.

£12,000a year, from
  • Unlimited API and full archive delivery
  • Rights to use the data in your products
  • Back to 2000, every council
Talk to us

Never miss what this committee decides

Papers, decisions and date changes for the Area Planning Sub-Committee, and every other committee you follow, the day they appear.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies