Resolved
That the application be approved. Reason: The 11 principal buildings are of high aesthetic and historic value and, in spite of their previous adaptation for use as offices, the original layouts and details can be enjoyed and understood. The former coach house/stables is mainly of evidential value. The buildings have been empty for over 18months and they appear neglected and "at risk". Current proposals would secure a viable future and offer a range of dwelling types with potentially 24hr occupation at the heart of the "cultural quarter" which is otherwise quiet at night. The majority of internal alterations would conserve the special architectural and historic interest of the interiors, though the challenges of converting and upgrading the larger buildings into flats have resulted in loss of some spatial quality in a few instances (as identified above). In these cases the new interventions have been introduced so that they are capable of being reversed and details of inserted elements have been designed to compensate for some loss of historic legibility. Removing the large scale uncharacteristic C20th extensions would enhance the rear elevations and enable small gardens/yards to be recreated. The new boundary onto Library Lane would be infilled with mews style apartments above garages. The new buildings would preserve the dominance of the terrace in views and enhance their immediate setting to the rear. Proposals would also safeguard the exceptional architectural and townscape interest of the buildings within the Conservation Area. As such the application is recommended for approval, subject to conditions detailed above.