That the application be approved subject to the conditions outlined in the committee report. Reason: Because of the partially open character of the site the larger size of the mobile home relative to the existing would result in some limited harm to ... view the full minutes text for item 34b
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Date: 17 September 2015 Ward: Wheldrake Team: Major and Parish: Elvington Parish Council Commercial Team
Reference: 15/01113/FUL Application at: The Stables Elvington Lane Elvington York YO41 4EH For: Variation of condition 9 of permitted application 10/02082/FUL to replace existing showman's caravan with twin unit mobile home By: Mr & [name removed]: Full Application Target Date: 15 July 2015 Recommendation: Approve
1.0PROPOSAL
1.1The application is to vary condition 9 of planning permission 10/02082/FUL for the change of use of agricultural land to a site for travelling showpeople. Condition 9 states that
No more than 9 vehicles (a living showman's caravan, a living tourer caravan, 2 touring caravans, a commercial van, a hot food sales trailer, a mobile trampoline and 2 domestic vehicles) shall be stationed on the site at any one time.
1.2The variation being sought is to allow the permitted showman's living caravan listed in the condition to be replaced with a twin-unit mobile home. The applicant has offered to accept a condition restricting the length of the mobile home to no longer than 60 feet (18.29m).
1.3The condition as varied would thus be:
No more than 9 vehicles (a twin-unit mobile home not exceeding 18.29m long, a living tourer caravan, 2 touring caravans, a commercial van, a hot food sales trailer, a mobile trampoline and 2 domestic vehicles) shall be stationed on the site at any one time.
1.4The application does not seek permanent planning permission for the use nor to extend the period of consent which expires in June 2016.
Application Reference Number: 15/01113/FUL Item No: 4 b) Page 1 of 15 PLANNING HISTORY
1.5In 2011 the council refused planning permission for the change of use of agricultural land to a site for one family of travelling showpeople (the current applicants). The family comprised three adults and two children. Their vehicles comprised a living showman's caravan, a living tourer caravan, 2 touring caravans, a commercial van, a hot food sales trailer, a mobile trampoline and 2 domestic vehicles. Whilst acknowledging a shortage of travelling showpeople's sites in the York area and the needs of the applicants' family for a suitable site the application was refused due to harm to the Green Belt and impact on the attractive rural character of the area.
1.6At the subsequent appeal the inspector found, among other things, that:
The use of the land, including the stationing of caravans, was inappropriate development in the green belt and would be harmful to its openness, to which he attributed substantial weight; The loss of openness as a result of the proposal would be considerable, to which he attached significant weight; The proposal would be harmful to the purposes of the Green Belt (moderate weight) and harmful to the character and appearance of the area (moderate weight).
1.7The inspector weighed this harm against the factors in favour of the proposal:
The need for sites generally (significant weight); The need of the appellants for a site (significant weight); The lack of alternative sites (significant weight); The educational and medical needs of the appellants (moderate weight); and The location of the site (some weight).
1.8He concluded that the case was finely balanced with the factors against the proposal being broadly in balance with those in favour. He found that the substantial harm to Green Belt objectives was such that the other considerations did not amount to very special circumstances that would justify the grant of permanent planning permission. However, given the lack of alternatives sites at that time and the potential for sites to be brought forward in the longer term through the development plan process, a temporary consent would be appropriate, subject to conditions. He therefore allowed the appeal. The consent was limited to five years only and made personal to the family of the appellants.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.