CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
City of York Council
Area Planning Sub-Committee, Thursday 7 July 2016 at 4.30pm

42 Millfield Lane, York, YO10 3AF (16/01097/FUL)

Refused Planning 2 papers

Area Planning Sub-Committee refused this item on Thursday 7 July 2016. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item8b

Resolved

That the application be refused. Reason: 1. It is considered that by reason of their scale massing and design the proposed extensions would not be subservient to the original dwelling and would have a harmful unduly dominant and overbearing impact on its surroundings, particularly when viewed from Millfield Lane. The proposal is therefore in conflict with paragraph 17 of the National Planning Policy Framework, Policies GP1 and H7 of the Development Control Local Plan and the guidance contained within the House Extensions and Alterations Supplementary Planning Guidance. 2. The proposed first floor rear part of the proposed extensions by reason of its height, massing and location would appear as an oppressive, over-dominant structure when viewed from the both neighbouring properties and would result in a significant loss of daylight and afternoon sunlight to the adjoining property at no.44 Millfield Lane. The proposal is therefore in conflict with paragraph 17 of the National Planning Policy Framework, Policies GP1 and H7 of the Development Control Local Plan and the guidance contained within the House Extensions and Alterations Supplementary Planning Guidance. 3. The increased number of occupants at this suburban semi-detached dwelling is considered to be likely to result in a significant cumulative impact on the residential character of the street taking into account the existing high level of houses in multiple occupation along the street within 100m of the application site and within the wider neighbourhood. The size of the store is inadequate to provide accommodation for 8 cycles and the waste and recycling storage for the number of residents proposed. This cumulative increase will have a harmful impact on the living conditions of local residents and the residential character of the area from additional littering and accumulation of rubbish in the front garden; noises between dwellings and in the street at all times and especially at night and increased parking pressures. This is contrary to paragraph 17 of the National Planning Policy Framework and Development Control Local Plan policy GP1 which states that development proposals will respect the local environment, provide individual storage space for waste recycling and litter collection and policy T4 which requires cycle parking in accordance with the published standards in order to maintain and promote cycle usage in order to reduce dependence on the car.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting. Source: democracy.york.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from York's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Area Planning Sub-Committee, 8 pages

COMMITTEE REPORT

Date: 7 July 2016 Ward: Hull Road Team: Major and Parish: Hull Road Planning Commercial Team Panel

Reference: 16/01097/FUL Application at: 42 Millfield Lane York YO10 3AF For: Change of use from small House in Multiple Occupation (use class C4) to large House in Multiple Occupation, two storey side and rear extensions, single storey rear extension and dormers to side and rear By: [name removed]: Full Application Target Date: 1 July 2016 Recommendation: Refuse

1.0PROPOSAL

1.1This application seeks consent to change an existing 5.no bedroom, small house in multiple occupation (Use Class C4) into an 8.no bedroom large house in multiple occupation (Use Class Sui Generis) and erect a two storey side and rear extension, a single storey rear extension and dormers to side and rear, on a semi-detached dwelling, at 42 Millfield Lane, Hull Road.

1.2A request to call the application in was made by Councillor Barnes on the grounds outlined in his objection letter summarised in section 3 below.

Relevant Property History

1.3A Certificate of Lawful Use for a small house in multiple occupation (Use Class C4) was granted on this property CYC Ref.16/00294/CLU - dated 07.04.2016.

2.0POLICY CONTEXT

2.1Policies:

CYGP1 Design CYH7 Residential extensions CYT4 Cycle Parking Standards

Application Reference Number: 16/01097/FUL Item No: 4b Page 1 of 8 3.0 CONSULTATIONS

Highway Network Management

3.1Highways confirmed there would be off-road parking for 3.no vehicles, following development. There were no objections in this respect. However, secure cycle storage has only been provided for 4.no units. They would require cycle storage on a one for one basis and this would mean 8.no secure cycle storage spaces.

Planning and Environmental Management

3.2Within 100m of the property 18.8% of properties registered as HMO's, Neighbourhood Level - 24.6% of properties registered as HMO's.

Ward Councillor

3.3Councillor Barnes objected to the application on the following grounds:

 Massively overburden the land on which the property exists  Impact adversely on local parking  Result in greater number of 'comings and goings'  Additional burden on refuse collection  Extensions would dramatically alter and change the shape of the dwelling

Neighbour Notification and Publicity

3.4Three letters have been received, objecting to the application on the following grounds:

 Combined scale and massing too great  Parking provision out of character at such a density  Detracts from availability of affordable family homes  Abundance of designated student accommodation exists and is in the pipeline  Neighbour amenity would be adversely affected  Concern over local parking issues  Increased noise and 'comings and goings'  Problems over refuse storage/collection  Could lead to a 'terracing effect' on semi-detached properties  Road safety issues - property on a blind summit  Design and Access Statement replicates that submitted for a 5.no bedroom HMO  Would remove front to rear outside access.

Application Reference Number: 16/01097/FUL Item No: 4b Page 2 of 8 Hull Road Planning Panel

3.5No response received.

4.0APPRAISAL

KEY ISSUES

4.1The key issues, in the assessment of this proposal, are the impact of the proposed extensions on the character of the host building and the impact of the proposed extensions and change of use on the amenities of nearby residents.

POLICY CONTEXT

4.2The National Planning Policy Framework (March 2012) sets out the Government's overarching planning policies at its heart is a presumption in favour of sustainable development. A core planning principle set out in Paragraph 17 is that planning should always seek to secure high quality design and a good standard of amenity for all existing and future occupants of land and buildings.

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
42 Millfield Lane, York, YO10 3AF (16/01097/FUL)Report 8 pages DownloadRead as text
PDF
42 Millfield Lane.pdfReport 1 pages Download

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

10 of 14 attended
JG
Councillor John GalvinChair, present
HS
Councillor Hilary ShepherdVice-Chair, present
DC
Councillor David CarrCommittee Member, apologies
DC
Councillor Denise CraghillCommittee Member, present
IG
Councillor Ian GilliesCommittee Member, present
SH
Councillor Susan HunterCommittee Member, present
MC
Councillor Mary CannonCommittee Member, present
JL
Councillor Janet LookerCommittee Member, apologies
JF
Councillor James FlindersCommittee Member, present
SM
Councillor Suzie MercerCommittee Member, present
KO
Councillor Keith OrrellCommittee Member, present
TR
Councillor Tony RichardsonSubstitute, present as substitute

All 14 on the meeting page

On this subject at York

Search all
  1. 42 Millfield Lane, York, YO10 3AF (16/01097/FUL)This decision
  2. Proposed Telecommunications Equipment, Millfield Lane, Nether Poppleton, York [21/01067/TCMAS]Approved
  3. London Ebor Developments Plc, Millfield Business Centre, Millfield Lane, Nether Poppleton, York [16/02545/FULM]Approved
  4. London Ebor Developments Plc, Millfield Business Centre, Millfield Lane, Nether Poppleton, York [18/02080/FULM]Approved
  5. Cherry Tree Cottage, Millfield Lane, Nether Poppleton, York, YO26 6NX (17/01507/FUL)Refused
  6. 42 Millfield Lane, York, YO10 3AF (16/01745/FUL)Approved

More from York Area Planning Sub-Committee

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
28 Apr 2022 MinutesThat the minutes of the Area Planning Sub-Committee meeting held on 14 April 2022be approved and signed by the Chair ... Approved Open
28 Apr 2022 Former B and M Stores Site, Stirling Road [21_02220_FULM]That the application be approved subject to the conditions in the report and the amendment to condition 21 which spec... Approved Open
28 Apr 2022 Land Comprising Field At 463582 452080 Murton Way [21/00415/FULM]That the application be approved subject to the conditions, including a ‘Grampian’ condition regarding groundwater te... Approved Open
28 Apr 2022 Church House, 10 - 14 Ogleforth, York YO1 7JG [21/00601/FULM]To APPROVE the application subject to the completion of a Section 106 agreement and the conditions as set out in the ... Approved Open
14 Apr 2022 MinutesThat the minutes of the Area Planning Sub-Committee meeting held on 16 February and 10 March 2022be approved and then... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies