CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
Dec20Tuesday

Audit and Governance Committee

YorkHeldPapers from democracy.york.gov.uk
Tuesday 20 December 2016, 5.30pmHeld 3624 days ago.
The Thornton Room - Ground FloorWest Offices (G039). Open to the public.
9 items, 20 papersAbout 15 MB, led by Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16.
No exempt items listedEvery item is due to be heard in public.
This meeting was held20 December 2016
9items
20papers
6decisions
–exempt
Running order, sized by papersItem 41 to 49
ReportsProcedureExempt parts

The agenda, item by item

What the committee will consider, in order, with every paper attached to its item. Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16 is the main business.

41
Procedure

Declarations of Interest

At this point in the meeting, Members are asked to declare: any personal interests not included on the Register of Interests any prejudicial interests or any disclosable pecuniary interests which they might have in respect of business on this agenda.

42
Report

Minutes

To approve and sign the minutes of the meeting of the Audit & Governance Committee held on 7 December 2016. :

Decision: That the minutes of the meeting held on 7 December 2016 be approved and then signed by the Chair as a correct record. Decision page

1 paper, 108 KBSearch inside with Pro
ReportMinutes108 KBDownload
43
Procedure

Public Participation

It is at this point in the meeting that members of the public who have registered their wish to speak can do so. The deadline for registering is by 5:00pm on Monday 19 December 2016 . To register please contact the Democracy Officer for the meeting, on the details at the foot of this agenda. Filming, Recording or Webcasting Meetings Please note this meeting will be filmed and webcast and that includes any registered...

44
Report

Programme/Project Management Update Report

View the declarations of interest for item 44. The purpose of this report is to present to the Audit and Governance Committee an update on the project management framework, to update on areas of the framework that are being strengthened and to provide an update on the major or “Large” projects.

Decision: That the update on the programme and project management be noted. Reason: To ensure that the committee is kept updated on key programme and project activity. Decision page

2 papers, 593 KBSearch inside with Pro
AppendixAppendix A: Update of Large Projects500 KBDownload
ReportProgramme/Project Management Update Report93 KBDownload
45
Report

Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report

This report provides an update on progress made in delivering the internal audit workplan for 2016/17 and on current counter fraud activity.

Decision: It was agreed that further information on this audit plan variation would be circulated to Members following the meeting. 1 Referring to a further matter that had been raised under the Public Participation item, Members sought confirmation that a contract was in place between the Council and Veritau. They were informed that a current contract was in place and had not been breached. Referring to the “reasonable assurance” opinion that had been given to the audit on the Use of Interims... Decision page

6 papers, 1.5 MBSearch inside with Pro
AppendixAppendix 1: Audits Completed132 KBDownload
ReportAudit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report157 KBDownload
ReportHousing Rents audit report274 KBDownload
ReportPetty Cash Audit Report319 KBDownload
ReportSt Paul's Nursery School Audit Report317 KBDownload
ReportUse of Interims Specialists and Consultants Audit Report302 KBDownload
46
Report

Mazars Annual Audit Letter 2015/16

View the declarations of interest for item 46. The paper attached at Annex A from Mazars – the Council’s external auditors – summarises the outcome of their audit of the Council’s 2015/16 annual accounts and their work on the value for money conclusion.

Decision: That the matters set out in the Annual Audit report presented by Mazars be noted. Reason: To ensure Members are aware of Mazars’ progress in delivering their responsibilities as external auditors. Decision page

2 papers, 1.9 MBSearch inside with Pro
AppendixAppendix A: Annual Audit Letter1.7 MBDownload
ReportMazars Annual Audit Letter 2015/16161 KBDownload
47
Report

Mazars Audit Progress Report

The paper attached at Annex A of this paper reports on the progress of Mazars in delivering their responsibilities as the Council’s external auditors.

Decision: That the matters set out in the progress report be noted. Reason: To ensure that Members are aware of Mazars’ progress in delivering their responsibilities as external auditors. Decision page

2 papers, 1.4 MBSearch inside with Pro
AppendixAppendix A: Mazars Audit Progress Report1.3 MBDownload
ReportMazars Audit Progress Report80 KBDownload
48
ReportMain business

Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16

View the declarations of interest for item 48. The paper attached at Annex A of this report from Mazars, the Council’s external auditors, considers whether the Council’s arrangements over some of the major programmes of work are effective in terms of governance, management of risk and project delivery.

2 papers, 2.3 MBSearch inside with Pro
AppendixAppendix A: Value for Money Review Report2.2 MBDownload
ReportMazars Value for Money Review 2015/16119 KBDownload
49
Report

Audit and Governance Committee Forward Plan

This paper presents the future plan of reports expected to be presented to the committee during the forthcoming year to September 2017.

Decision: That the committee’s Forward Plan for the period up to September 2017 be approved subject to the inclusion of the following additional agenda items: Audit Procurement Report to be presented to the committee as soon as possible after completion of the investigation (February 2017 if possible). Report on current procurement arrangements and procedures. Report on the actions arising from the School Governance Internal Audit Report and the implications for City of York Council. Implementation of... Decision page

2 papers, 185 KBSearch inside with Pro
AppendixAppendix 1: Forward Plan64 KBDownload
ReportAudit and Governance Committee Forward Plan121 KBDownload
Read inside all 20 papersPro opens every page, searches every appendix, and keeps the papers if the council removes them.

The main business: Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16

Item 48 is where most of this meeting's papers sit: 2 papers, about 2.3 MB.

Item 48

Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16

View the declarations of interest for item 48. The paper attached at Annex A of this report from Mazars, the Council’s external auditors, considers whether the Council’s arrangements over some of the major programmes of work are effective in terms of governance, management of risk and project delivery.

What is in the pack2 papers, about 2.3 MB
Appendix A
Value for Money Review ReportSupporting paper
2.2 MB
Report
Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16The report to the committee
119 KB
Read and search every page of this itemPro opens all 2 papers, and keeps them if the council removes them.

How this item got here

This is the first time this subject appears in the meetings we have read.

20 December 2016Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16This meeting.

Every paper for this meeting

All 20 papers in one list, with the item each belongs to, its size, and our copy of it. Download any paper from our archive once signed in; read and search it here with Pro.

PaperSizeOur copy
Agenda frontsheetItem
182 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Agenda reports packItem
7.1 MB
Kept 14 Oct
Printed minutesItem
165 KB
Kept 14 Oct
MinutesItem 42, Minutes
108 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Update of Large ProjectsAppendix A, item 44, Programme/Project Management Update Report
500 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Programme/Project Management Update ReportItem 44, Programme/Project Management Update Report
93 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Audits CompletedAppendix 1, item 45, Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report
132 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring ReportItem 45, Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report
157 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Housing Rents audit reportItem 45, Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report
274 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Petty Cash Audit ReportItem 45, Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report
319 KB
Kept 14 Oct
St Paul's Nursery School Audit ReportItem 45, Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report
317 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Use of Interims Specialists and Consultants Audit ReportItem 45, Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring Report
302 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Annual Audit LetterAppendix A, item 46, Mazars Annual Audit Letter 2015/16
1.7 MB
Kept 14 Oct
Mazars Annual Audit Letter 2015/16Item 46, Mazars Annual Audit Letter 2015/16
161 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Mazars Audit Progress ReportAppendix A, item 47, Mazars Audit Progress Report
1.3 MB
Kept 14 Oct
Mazars Audit Progress ReportItem 47, Mazars Audit Progress Report
80 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Value for Money Review ReportAppendix A, item 48, Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16
2.2 MB
Kept 14 Oct
Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16Item 48, Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16
119 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Forward PlanAppendix 1, item 49, Audit and Governance Committee Forward Plan
64 KB
Kept 14 Oct
Audit and Governance Committee Forward PlanItem 49, Audit and Governance Committee Forward Plan
121 KB
Kept 14 Oct

Last time, and what carried over

The committee last met on 7 December 2016. 1 of its items lead into this meeting; 6 items are new. Point at any item to follow a thread. Procedural items are left out.

Dec7
7 December 201612 items, 22 papers
Held
carried over
Dec20
20 December 20169 items, 20 papers
Held
32
MinutesTo approve and sign the minutes of the meeting of the Audit &...
34
Implementation of actions arising from the Internal Audit Report on Health and SafetyThis report responds to the specific issues identified in the...
35
Sickness Absence Management Update ReportThis report responds to the specific issues identified in the...
36
Information Governance and Freedom of Information Report (including information security)This report provides Members with an update on the following issues...
37
Scrutiny of Treasury Management Midyear Review and Prudential Indicators 2016/17This paper presents the Treasury Management Mid Year Review and...
38
Audit and Governance Committee Forward Plan to September 2017This paper presents the future plan of reports expected to be...
39
Appointment of External AuditorsThis report details the changes to the arrangements for appointing...
40
Local Code of Corporate GovernanceThis report provides a review of the Code of Corporate Governance...
42
MinutesNew this time
44
Programme/Project Management Update ReportNew this time
45
Audit and Counter Fraud Monitoring ReportNew this time
46
Mazars Annual Audit Letter 2015/16New this time
47
Mazars Audit Progress ReportNew this time
48
Mazars Value for Money Review 2015/16New this time
49
Audit and Governance Committee Forward PlanThis paper presents the future plan of reports expected to be...

The threads

  • Audit and Governance Committee Forward Plan to September 2017 leads to item 49, Audit and Governance Committee Forward Plan

Not carried over

Implementation of actions arising from the Internal Audit Report on Health and Safety, Sickness Absence Management Update Report, Information Governance and Freedom of Information Report (including information security), Scrutiny of Treasury Management Midyear Review and Prudential Indicators 2016/17 and 2 more do not return this time.

See the 7 December meeting

This committee over time

Every Audit and Governance Committee meeting we have read, the dates it has set for the future, and each time those dates have changed.

153 meetings, 2006 to 2027Dot size shows the number of papers
20062009201220152018202120242027
HeldThis meeting
MeetingItemsPapers
6 Jan 2027Wednesday
0items
0papers
UpcomingOpen
21 Oct 2026Wednesday
12items
44papers
HeldOpen
16 Sep 2026Wednesday
9items
25papers
HeldOpen
22 Jul 2026Wednesday
15items
57papers
HeldOpen
6 May 2026Wednesday
10items
29papers
HeldOpen
11 Mar 2026Wednesday
14items
50papers
HeldOpen
28 Jan 2026Wednesday
13items
56papers
HeldOpen
12 Nov 2025Wednesday
12items
38papers
HeldOpen
3 Sep 2025Wednesday
9items
40papers
HeldOpen
30 Jul 2025Wednesday
15items
52papers
HeldOpen
14 May 2025Wednesday
12items
41papers
HeldOpen
17 Mar 2025Monday
11items
43papers
HeldOpen
29 Jan 2025Wednesday
13items
52papers
HeldOpen
27 Nov 2024Wednesday
13items
50papers
HeldOpen
14 Oct 2024Monday
7items
22papers
HeldOpen
4 Sep 2024Wednesday
9items
46papers
HeldOpen
8 Aug 2024Thursday
6items
17papers
HeldOpen
31 Jul 2024Wednesday
11items
35papers
HeldOpen
9 Jul 2024Tuesday
6items
25papers
HeldOpen
22 May 2024Wednesday
8items
31papers
HeldOpen
20 Mar 2024Wednesday
3items
9papers
HeldOpen
28 Feb 2024Wednesday
12items
35papers
HeldOpen
31 Jan 2024Wednesday
11items
49papers
HeldOpen
29 Nov 2023Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
8 Nov 2023Wednesday
15items
53papers
HeldOpen
12 Sep 2023Tuesday
10items
34papers
HeldOpen
19 Jul 2023Wednesday
12items
38papers
HeldOpen
15 Mar 2023Wednesday
9items
37papers
HeldOpen
7 Feb 2023Tuesday
4items
11papers
HeldOpen
18 Jan 2023Wednesday
9items
40papers
HeldOpen
4 Jan 2023Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
30 Nov 2022Wednesday
10items
41papers
HeldOpen
19 Oct 2022Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
7 Sep 2022Wednesday
8items
36papers
HeldOpen
13 Jul 2022Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
29 Jun 2022Wednesday
9items
39papers
HeldOpen
6 Apr 2022Wednesday
9items
38papers
HeldOpen
9 Mar 2022Wednesday
7items
25papers
HeldOpen
2 Feb 2022Wednesday
11items
28papers
HeldOpen
21 Jan 2022Friday
9items
38papers
HeldOpen
1 Dec 2021Wednesday
9items
31papers
HeldOpen
16 Nov 2021Tuesday
6items
23papers
HeldOpen
20 Oct 2021Wednesday
8items
33papers
HeldOpen
29 Sep 2021Wednesday
7items
24papers
HeldOpen
8 Sep 2021Wednesday
6items
16papers
HeldOpen
28 Jul 2021Wednesday
9items
31papers
HeldOpen
16 Jun 2021Wednesday
10items
42papers
HeldOpen
28 Apr 2021Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
14 Apr 2021Wednesday
9items
41papers
HeldOpen
31 Mar 2021Wednesday
6items
16papers
HeldOpen
10 Mar 2021Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
17 Feb 2021Wednesday
7items
32papers
HeldOpen
28 Jan 2021Thursday
7items
21papers
HeldOpen
30 Nov 2020Monday
6items
29papers
HeldOpen
20 Nov 2020Friday
8items
21papers
HeldOpen
28 Sep 2020Monday
7items
11papers
HeldOpen
15 Jul 2020Wednesday
10items
23papers
HeldOpen
8 Apr 2020Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
11 Mar 2020Wednesday
7items
10papers
HeldOpen
5 Feb 2020Wednesday
13items
20papers
HeldOpen
4 Dec 2019Wednesday
13items
34papers
HeldOpen
18 Sep 2019Wednesday
11items
31papers
HeldOpen
29 Jul 2019Monday
6items
10papers
HeldOpen
19 Jun 2019Wednesday
13items
26papers
HeldOpen
6 Mar 2019Wednesday
10items
23papers
HeldOpen
6 Feb 2019Wednesday
15items
32papers
HeldOpen
5 Dec 2018Wednesday
11items
31papers
HeldOpen
19 Sep 2018Wednesday
9items
26papers
HeldOpen
26 Jul 2018Thursday
8items
18papers
HeldOpen
27 Jun 2018Wednesday
11items
21papers
HeldOpen
20 Jun 2018Wednesday
5items
5papers
HeldOpen
30 Apr 2018Monday
5items
6papers
HeldOpen
11 Apr 2018Wednesday
10items
26papers
HeldOpen
7 Feb 2018Wednesday
10items
16papers
HeldOpen
6 Dec 2017Wednesday
13items
33papers
HeldOpen
20 Sep 2017Wednesday
12items
27papers
HeldOpen
19 Jul 2017Wednesday
9items
17papers
HeldOpen
21 Jun 2017Wednesday
11items
26papers
HeldOpen
3 May 2017Wednesday
7items
17papers
HeldOpen
5 Apr 2017Wednesday
8items
15papers
HeldOpen
22 Feb 2017Wednesday
8items
12papers
HeldOpen
8 Feb 2017Wednesday
11items
16papers
HeldOpen
20 Dec 2016Tuesday, this meeting
9items
20papers
7 Dec 2016Wednesday
12items
22papers
HeldOpen
28 Sep 2016Wednesday
11items
24papers
HeldOpen
27 Jul 2016Wednesday
8items
16papers
HeldOpen
22 Jun 2016Wednesday
13items
29papers
HeldOpen
10 May 2016Tuesday
14items
28papers
HeldOpen
13 Apr 2016Wednesday
9items
17papers
HeldOpen
10 Feb 2016Wednesday
12items
15papers
HeldOpen
9 Dec 2015Wednesday
12items
27papers
HeldOpen
23 Sep 2015Wednesday
15items
26papers
HeldOpen
29 Jul 2015Wednesday
9items
24papers
HeldOpen
24 Jun 2015Wednesday
11items
22papers
HeldOpen
25 Mar 2015Wednesday
9items
17papers
HeldOpen
11 Feb 2015Wednesday
22items
37papers
HeldOpen
15 Jan 2015Thursday
3items
6papers
HeldOpen
10 Dec 2014Wednesday
15items
28papers
HeldOpen
2 Oct 2014Thursday
3items
4papers
HeldOpen
2 Oct 2014Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
24 Sep 2014Wednesday
15items
31papers
HeldOpen
30 Jul 2014Wednesday
8items
19papers
HeldOpen
25 Jun 2014Wednesday
16items
28papers
HeldOpen
1 May 2014Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
16 Apr 2014Wednesday
13items
24papers
HeldOpen
12 Feb 2014Wednesday
17items
25papers
HeldOpen
11 Dec 2013Wednesday
8items
12papers
HeldOpen
6 Nov 2013Wednesday
15items
27papers
HeldOpen
26 Sep 2013Thursday
8items
14papers
HeldOpen
31 Jul 2013Wednesday
8items
15papers
HeldOpen
9 Jul 2013Tuesday
15items
27papers
HeldOpen
27 Jun 2013Thursday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
17 Apr 2013Wednesday
9items
18papers
HeldOpen
19 Mar 2013Tuesday
14items
19papers
HeldOpen
13 Feb 2013Wednesday
13items
16papers
HeldOpen
12 Dec 2012Wednesday
11items
23papers
HeldOpen
27 Sep 2012Thursday
9items
19papers
HeldOpen
25 Jul 2012Wednesday
7items
13papers
HeldOpen
28 Jun 2012Thursday
8items
19papers
HeldOpen
2 Apr 2012Monday
12items
22papers
HeldOpen
19 Mar 2012Monday
4items
3papers
HeldOpen
13 Feb 2012Monday
16items
25papers
HeldOpen
5 Dec 2011Monday
10items
18papers
HeldOpen
29 Sep 2011Thursday
10items
20papers
HeldOpen
26 Jul 2011Tuesday
13items
20papers
HeldOpen
28 Jun 2011Tuesday
10items
16papers
HeldOpen
19 Apr 2011Tuesday
13items
24papers
HeldOpen
14 Feb 2011Monday
17items
27papers
HeldOpen
6 Dec 2010Monday
17items
32papers
HeldOpen
29 Sep 2010Wednesday
18items
26papers
HeldOpen
28 Jul 2010Wednesday
15items
17papers
HeldOpen
29 Jun 2010Tuesday
9items
18papers
HeldOpen
26 Apr 2010Monday
17items
32papers
HeldOpen
15 Feb 2010Monday
13items
25papers
HeldOpen
21 Dec 2009Monday
20items
29papers
HeldOpen
4 Nov 2009Wednesday
5items
9papers
HeldOpen
21 Sep 2009Monday
20items
31papers
HeldOpen
29 Jun 2009Monday
15items
38papers
HeldOpen
31 Mar 2009Tuesday
12items
28papers
HeldOpen
13 Jan 2009Tuesday
19items
24papers
HeldOpen
24 Sep 2008Wednesday
12items
18papers
HeldOpen
26 Jun 2008Thursday
10items
16papers
HeldOpen
13 May 2008Tuesday
14items
36papers
HeldOpen
15 Jan 2008Tuesday
13items
31papers
HeldOpen
24 Sep 2007Monday
13items
22papers
HeldOpen
25 Jun 2007Monday
8items
22papers
HeldOpen
3 Apr 2007Tuesday
9items
24papers
HeldOpen
31 Jan 2007Wednesday
8items
20papers
HeldOpen
4 Oct 2006Wednesday
13items
17papers
HeldOpen
25 Sep 2006Monday
4items
6papers
HeldOpen
12 Jul 2006Wednesday
0items
0papers
HeldOpen
26 Jun 2006Monday
7items
11papers
HeldOpen
6 Jun 2006Tuesday
15items
16papers
HeldOpen

Follow the Audit and Governance Committee

Choose what you want to hear about. The preview is built from this committee's real papers and changes, so you can see what would have reached you.

What should we tell you?

York, Audit and Governance Committee

Audit and Governance Committee: 3 kinds of updateYork, sent the same day
PDF
20 papers published for 20 DecemberMazars Value for Money Review 2015/16 and 19 more papers
DAT
Meeting dates updatedAny date added, moved or dropped
DEC
Decisions from 20 DecemberThe committee's resolutions, the day they are recorded
ABC
"mazars" found in 4 papersMazars Annual Audit Letter 2015/16 and Mazars Audit Progress Report
Each update links to the paper and the council's own copy
Free: one weekly alert. Pro: every option, the same day. Pro Plus: straight into your own systems.

Free

One alert, sent weekly, on titles and decisions.

£0for good
  • 1 alert, weekly summary
  • Titles and decisions
  • Link to every official paper
Save this alert free
Most chosen

Pro

Unlimited alerts the same day, searching every page.

£99per user a month
  • Unlimited alerts, same day
  • Matches inside every page and appendix
  • Every council, not just this one

Pro Plus

Your team, with every match pushed into your own tools.

£449a month, 3 users included
  • Everything in Pro, for 3 users
  • Alerts as webhooks into Slack or a CRM
  • API key and bulk export of this council

Data licence

Every council's records in your own products and research.

£12,000a year, from
  • Unlimited API and full archive delivery
  • Rights to use the data in your products
  • Back to 2000, every council
Talk to us

Never miss what this committee decides

Papers, decisions and date changes for the Audit and Governance Committee, and every other committee you follow, the day they appear.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies