That the minutes of the Hearings Sub-Committee meeting held on 19 December 2016 be approved as a correct record and then signed by the Chair. Matters Arising – Members’ consideration of planning applications The Chair drew Members’ attention to a letter that had been sent by a member of the public to members of the committee. The letter included suggested arrangements that could be put in place when Members were dealing with planning applications to address some of the issues that had been raised during consideration of a recent complaint. Members gave consideration to the suggestions and agreed that: · Consideration should be given to the putting in place of guidance in respect of Planning Site Visits and how these would be conducted. This guidance should be made available on the Council’s website and at the site visits 1 . · The Joint Standards Committee would review the Members’ Code of Conduct and consider whether any revisions were required. · The Chair of a committee should continue to be responsible for notifying public speakers when, in accordance with the Council’s Public Participation Scheme, they had reached their three-minute time allocation. Members did, however, recognise that it could be off-putting for speakers to be interrupted to be notified that their time allocation was nearing completion. For this reason Members recommended that the possibility of purchasing a traffic-light timing system be explored 2 . · That, in the training provided to Members of the Planning Committees, the importance of ensuring that Members avoided acting in a way that gave the perception that they were not giving full consideration to an application be highlighted. Chairs of Planning Committees could also make reference to this at the start of the meetings 3 . That, at the next meeting, feedback be given on the progress made in actioning the suggestions that had been put forward.
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting.Source: democracy.york.gov.uk
Meeting Joint Standards Committee Hearings Sub- Committee Date 19 December 2016 Present Councillors Cannon, Runciman (Chair) and Kramm In attendance [name removed] – Independent Person [name removed] – Independent Person [name removed] – Deputy Monitoring Officer [name removed] – Investigating Officer [name removed] – Complainant [name removed] – Complainant Councillor Galvin – Subject Member
4. Declarations of Interest
Members were asked to declare any personal interests not included on the Register of Interests, any prejudicial interests or any disclosable pecuniary interests which they may have in respect of business on the agenda. None were declared.
5. Complaint against a Member of City of York Council
Consideration was given to a complaint brought by [name removed], [name removed] and [name removed] against Councillor Galvin, a City of York Councillor. The complaint related to the behaviour of Councillor Galvin at a planning site visit on 9 March 2016, and at a meeting of the Planning Sub- Committee on 7 April 2016.
The matter had been referred to the Hearings Sub-Committee for determination following an investigation.
Introductions were carried out and the procedure for the hearing was explained.
Determining factual disputes
Copies of the investigator’s report and the written submissions received had been circulated to the Panel and to the parties prior to the meeting. During the meeting the Panel took advice from the Independent Persons. The investigating officer presented her report and responded to questions.
[name removed] presented his case and responded to questions.
[[name removed] arrived at the meeting at 10:25am and introductions were carried out for her benefit]
[name removed] presented her case and responded to questions.
Councillor Galvin presented his case and responded to questions.
[The parties, press and public left the meeting at 11.25am whilst the Panel deliberated in private]
The Panel gave consideration to the following allegations of breaches of the Code of Conduct:
(a) At the Planning Sub-Committee meeting on 7 April 2016, Councillor Galvin, being both a Governor of York Hospital and a Member of Council, had a conflict of interest in agenda items 3(a) and (b) and should not have taken part in the meeting.
(b) That Councillor Galvin acted with bias at the meeting.
(c) At the meeting Councillor Galvin failed to treat those present with respect, and bullied and intimidated them.
(d) At the site visit on 9 March 2016, Councillor Galvin failed to treat members of the public who were present with respect, bullied, swore and intimidated them.
Panel’s Findings
Having considered the written documentation and the verbal representations made at the meeting, the Panel
Resolved: (i) That, in respect of allegation (a) – Councillor Galvin’s alleged conflict of interest, the Panel was satisfied that Councillor Galvin did not have a prejudicial interest in the planning application and the Panel therefore found no breach of Part 2 of the Code. He had sought the advice of the Monitoring Officer and had acted in accordance with this guidance. Whilst the Panel noted the advice in the Governors Code of Conduct, they believed that there was a lack of clarity and prominence given to the clause Governors must “act in the best interests of the Trust at all times”. The Panel also noted that the sale of Groves Chapel would realise funds well below the threshold for Governor approval.
(ii) That, in respect of allegation (b) – Councillor Galvin’s alleged bias at the Planning Committee meeting, the Panel did not believe that Councillor Galvin had acted with bias at the meeting and therefore there had been no breach of the Code. The Panel noted that all speakers at the Planning Committee meeting had had the opportunity to put forward their views and the Panel agreed with the Investigating Officer that there had not been bias on the part of Councillor Galvin.
Read every report as text, not just the decision
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
Exclusion of Press and Public (4.05 pm)That the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of the exempt versions of Annexes A and B...
Member Code of Conduct (4.09 pm)No changes were necessary to the Code of Conduct. Reason: There were no changes to the Model Code following the LGA’s...
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Necessary
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Always on
Analytics
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.