Resolved
That the report of the Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee be noted. Reason: To update Members on the work of the committee.
Council noted this item on Thursday 21 March 2019. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.
Resolved
That the report of the Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee be noted. Reason: To update Members on the work of the committee.
Appendix A
City Of York Council Extract from Committee Minutes
Meeting Customer and Corporate Services Scrutiny Management Committee Date 11 March 2019 Present Councillors Williams (Chair), Galvin (Vice- Chair), N Barnes, D'Agorne, Douglas, Fenton, Gates, Looker and Reid
Part B - Matters Referred To Council
53. Scrutiny Operations and Functions Review - Draft Final Report
[See also under Part A]
Members considered a Draft Final Report which presented them with information gathered by the Task Group set up to undertake a review of scrutiny operations and functions, together with its conclusions and recommendations.
During discussion of the report, and the review more widely, Members stressed that the proposed recommendations were not controversial, but a key conclusion was that a cultural change within CYC was needed if Scrutiny is to function more effectively moving forward.
One Member felt that removing pre-decision call-in was a mistake, as no replacement for this function had been proposed in the report. Other Members felt strongly that, whilst well intentioned, pre-decision call-in had proved a frustrating process. They stated that ‘Calling-in’ an item was considered adversarial and that, if Members were involved at an early stage, and scrutiny was working effectively, this function was not necessary.
The Committee acknowledged that whilst scrutiny was ‘owned’ by Members, the review had been concerned with achieving greater engagement with the whole process by all. Finally, they commented that the move to monthly meetings would allow Members the time to engage with topics earlier and in greater depth. The Committee thanked those Members involved in the Task Group and the Officers who had supported them.
Recommendation: That Council approve the following changes, in line with constitutional requirements:
i. That the Health, Housing and Adult Social Care Policy and Scrutiny Committee be split into:
Health and Adult Social Care policy and Scrutiny Committee; and Housing and Safer Neighbourhoods Policy and Scrutiny Committee.
Reason: The Committee’s extended remit is too large to allow effective scrutiny.
ii. That the Economy and Place Policy Development and Scrutiny Committees are rejoined.
Reason: To end the uncertainty around the roles of each committee and to provide Economy and Place with a comprehensive scrutiny function.
iii. That the Pre-Decision Call-In process be removed from the Constitution.
Reason: To encourage a more timely and pro-active approach to pre-decision scrutiny.
Councillor Dafydd Williams, Chair [The meeting started at 5.35 pm and finished at 6.50 pm].
Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.
PDF |
CSMC Part B MinuteReport | 2 pages | DownloadRead as text |
PDF |
Report of the Chair of the Customer & Corporate Services Scrutiny Management CommitteeReport | 5 pages | Download |
Follow Council at York and we tell you when its next papers are published, before the meeting rather than after it.
| Meeting | Decision | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Sep 2026 | MinutesThat the minutes of the Extraordinary Council Meeting and Ordinary Council Meeting held on 16 July 2026, be approved ... | Approved | Open |
| 17 Sep 2026 | PetitionsResolved – That the petitions log be updated accordingly and the level of progress tracked by the Corporate Scrutiny ... | Decided | Open |
| 17 Sep 2026 | Recommendations of ExecutiveIn relation to the overall programme, that Council approves the adjustments resulting in a reduction in the 2026/27 b... | Approved | Open |
| 17 Sep 2026 | Annual Report of the Chair of Audit and Governance Committee 2025/26That Council notes the Annual Report of the Chair of Audit and Governance Committee covering the 2025/26 municipal ye... | Decided | Open |
| 17 Sep 2026 | Update to Pay Policy Statement 2026/2027That Council approves the updated Pay Policy Statement for 2026 – 2027. Reason: In order to fulfil the requirements o... | Approved | Open |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.