Resolved
That the application be approved subject to the conditions listed in the report. Reason: i. The proposed access to allow works at Clifton Ings will have an adverse impact on the Green Belt, open space and biodiversity. The intention is for site restoration following the works and therefore the harm would not be permanent. The role of the Friends of Rawcliffe in managing the area will be in jeopardy and their funding will be lost; however this cannot be avoided through the planning process (we cannot specify that a certain 3 rd party be required to manage the site). Officers are content that planning conditions can secure a reasonable level of mitigation over time; the responsibility of which will lie with the applicants/developer; the EA. Conditions are proposed to manage and minimise the effect on biodiversity during the works and for comprehensive long term management. The site will be restored to its previous appearance. ii. Other options for the access route have legitimately been ruled out due to the scale and type of construction vehicles involved with the flood defence works. iii. With regards the impact on the Green Belt the NPPF states that very special circumstances’ will not exist unless the potential harm to the Green Belt by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm resulting from the proposal, is clearly outweighed by other considerations. With regards the natural environment the NPPF advises planning decisions should minimise impacts on, and providing net gains for, biodiversity. iv. The current barrier bank has issues with stability which significantly impacts on the operation and effectiveness of the flood defence, particularly for any consecutive flood events. The existing standard of protection of the barrier bank is 2% AEP (2 in 100 year flood events). The scheme would ensure that up to 2039 (taking into account climate change) the barrier would protect during the 1 in 100 year flood event / 1% AEP. The proposals will reduce flood risk for 134 properties, and the local area, which will subsequently be defended against the 1 in 100 year flood (plus climate change). v. To facili tate the flood defence works and secure adequate mitigation through conditions are deemed to constitute very special circumstances outweigh the identified harm; the temporary harm to habitats, the openness of the Green Belt and landscape character of the a rea, and its role as open space which would occur during the period of works.