CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
City of York Council
Council, Thursday 27 March 2025 at 6.30pm

Recommendations of the Executive: Review of the City of York Council Scrutiny Function (7:54 pm)

Approved Committee 8 papers

Council approved this item on Thursday 27 March 2025. Below is the council's own wording, with the papers it was decided on.

Item79

Resolved

That the above recommendations be approved. Action Required 1. Note approval of the recommendations and take any action required. BR/LT
Word for word from the decision York published for this meeting. Source: democracy.york.gov.uk

Follow this further

Built from York's papers

What the report saysPro

Report to Council

City of York Council Committee Minutes

Meeting Executive Date 11 March 2025 Present Councillors Douglas (Chair), Kilbane (Vice- Chair), Lomas, Pavlovic, Ravilious, Steels- Walshaw and Webb Apologies Councillors Kent

Part B Minute – Recommendation to Council

89. Review of the City of York Council Scrutiny Function (17:37)

The Head of Democratic Governance introduced the report and the 12 recommendations which had been considered by the Council’s Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee.

The Chair of Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee welcomed the review of scrutiny functions at the Council. He noted that the survey of Councillors showed a need for improvements and that this offered the opportunity to get back to the basics of scrutiny. He welcomed the opportunity for a working group to develop the proposals in the recommendations, noting the need for this to be Councillor owned and Councillor lead. He confirmed that Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee supported the recommendations, outside of recommendation 8 which there was not a consensus on the number of Scrutiny Committees and recommendation 3, which the Committee did not support the move to having named substitutes for meetings.

The Executive Leader agreed with the Corporate Services, Climate Change and Scrutiny Management Committee’s suggestions to not adopt recommendation 3. In relation to Recommendation 8 she proposed the Council reduce the number of Councillors on Scrutiny Committee’s to 9 and to move to 3 Committees, an overarching Scrutiny Committee (including calling-in functions), a Place Committee, and a People Committee (to include Housing). It was proposed these changes take effect at the 2025 Annual General Meeting and be reviewed in 12 months. Finally, she noted that the working group to be established in accordance with recommendation 1 be a cross-party working group.

Recommended:

i. That Council endorse the proposed actions as set out in Annex B in respect of Scrutiny Review Report recommendations 1-2, 4-7 and 9-12, noting that a cross-party working group will be established to lead on and oversee the work; ii. To recommend that, in respect of recommendation 8 of the Scrutiny Review Report, Full Council resolves to implement a revised Scrutiny structure, comprising an overarching Scrutiny Committee (including calling- in functions) with nine seats, a Place Committee with nine seats, and a People Committee (to include Housing) with nine seats. These changes to take effect at the 2025 Annual General Meeting and will be reviewed in 12 months; iii. To recommend to Council that Recommendation 3 of the Scrutiny Review Report is not adopted.

Reason: To seek Full Council’s approval for changes to how Scrutiny operates at the Council.

Cllr Douglas Chair [The meeting started at 4.32 pm and finished at 5.56 pm].

Read every report as text, not just the decision

Pro opens the officer report behind each decision, searchable and quotable, across every council we cover.

Papers for this item

Kept in our archive, download once signed in
PDF
York Scrutiny Impact ReportAppendix A 1.1 MB Download
PDF
Scrutiny Impact Review Action PlanAppendix B 237 KB Download
PDF
Recommendations of the Executive: Review of the City of York Council Scrutiny Function (7:54 pm)Report 270 KB DownloadRead as text
PDF
Review of the City of York Scrutiny Function Council 27 March 2025Report 187 KB Download
PDF
View as HTML (79./2) 62 KBReport 62 KB Copy on its way
PDF
View as HTML (79./3) 100 KBAppendix 100 KB Copy on its way
PDF
View as HTML (79./4) 49 KBAppendix 49 KB Copy on its way
PDF
View item 79. as HTML 25 KBReport 25 KB Copy on its way

At this meeting

Whole meeting

Who was there

44 of 45 attended
NA
Councillor Nigel AyreCommittee Member, present
AB
Councillor Anna BaxterCommittee Member, present
BB
Councillor Ben BurtonCommittee Member, present
JB
Councillor Jane BurtonCommittee Member, present
TC
Councillor Tony ClarkeCommittee Member, present
JC
Councillor Jo ColesCommittee Member, present
JC
Councillor Jonny CrawshawCommittee Member, present
CC
Councillor Chris CullwickCommittee Member, present
IC
Councillor Ian CuthbertsonCommittee Member, present
CD
Councillor Claire DouglasCommittee Member, present
SF
Councillor Stephen FentonCommittee Member, present
TF
Councillor Tony FisherCommittee Member, present

All 45 on the meeting page

On this subject at York

Search all
  1. Recommendations of the Executive: Review of the City of York Council Scrutiny Function (7:54 pm)This decision
  2. Recommendations of ExecutiveApproved
  3. Recommendations of ExecutiveApproved
  4. Recommendations of Executive (8.28pm)Approved
  5. Recommendations of Executive in relation to the Capital Programme - Monitor 3 2025/26Approved
  6. Recommendations of ExecutiveApproved

More from York Council

All decisions
MeetingDecisionOutcome
17 Sep 2026 MinutesThat the minutes of the Extraordinary Council Meeting and Ordinary Council Meeting held on 16 July 2026, be approved ... Approved Open
17 Sep 2026 PetitionsResolved – That the petitions log be updated accordingly and the level of progress tracked by the Corporate Scrutiny ... Decided Open
17 Sep 2026 Recommendations of ExecutiveIn relation to the overall programme, that Council approves the adjustments resulting in a reduction in the 2026/27 b... Approved Open
17 Sep 2026 Annual Report of the Chair of Audit and Governance Committee 2025/26That Council notes the Annual Report of the Chair of Audit and Governance Committee covering the 2025/26 municipal ye... Decided Open
17 Sep 2026 Update to Pay Policy Statement 2026/2027That Council approves the updated Pay Policy Statement for 2026 – 2027. Reason: In order to fulfil the requirements o... Approved Open

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies