CouncilMonitor
194 principal councils 228,996 meetings since 2000 2.8 million official papers archived Straight from each council's own publication system
People/Argyll and Bute/Councillor Andrew Kain
AK

Councillor Andrew Kain

Depute Provost Vice Chair of Oban, Lorn and the Isles Area CommitteeVice-Chair, Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee
Follow Councillor Kain's committeesAn email when their committees meet and decide
74%meetings attended162 of 219 since 2022, apologies 35
79times in the minutesAsked 6, said 34, moved 1, seconded 8
37recorded votes at their meetingsTheir own vote is named only where the minutes list it
1declarations at meetingsLeft the room for 1 item
12committees in the last year1 as Chair or Vice-Chair

On the record

Every time Argyll and Bute's minutes name Councillor Kain, as the council published it.

Named23 Sep 2026Argyll and Bute Council

Political management arrangements

Appoints Cllr Andrew Kain as Depute Provost of Argyll and Bute;
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Council, 23 Sep 2026, item 5Open the meeting
Said17 Sep 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Short-term Let Hearings)

Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence to h & g kahale, flat 2/1, 70 ardbeg road, rothesay, isle of bute

Councillor Kain commented that on this occasion this seemed to be something that should fall out of the short-term let legislation in respect of letting a property while away on holiday. He said that a review of the short-term let policy was required but that he had no objection to this application.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Short-term Let Hearings), 17 Sep 2026, item 3Open the meeting
Seconded9 Sep 2026Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Argyll Square Project: Consolidated Financial Report and Delivery Update

This was seconded by Councillor Kain.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 9 Sep 2026, item 8Open the meeting
Said14 Aug 2026Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Land North East of Glenmachrie, Glenegedale, Isle of Islay (Ref: 26/0003/LRB)

Councillor Kain agreed with the Chair, advising that there would be many implications for the surrounding area if they were to go against Officer recommendations.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 14 Aug 2026, item 3Open the meeting
Named24 Jun 2026Argyll and Bute Council

Political management arrangements

Decision The Council – 1.      appointed Councillor Andrew Kain to the Policy and Resources Committee in place of Councillor Audrey Forrest;
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Council, 24 Jun 2026, item 11Open the meeting
Said9 Jun 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)

Civic government (scotland) act 1982 section 41: application for a temporary public entertainment licence (tiree music festival cic)

DEBATE Councillor Kain outlined his extensive experience of over 40 years working with police forces across the UK. He advised that threat assessments are inherently imprecise and rely significantly on the experience and judgement of those undertaking them. He referred to the level of policing previously considered acceptable in circumstances where large numbers of people were unpoliced and questioned whether the current requirement for six officers was proportionate.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings), 9 Jun 2026, item 3Open the meeting
Said9 Jun 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)

Civic government (scotland) act 1982 section 41: application for a temporary public entertainment licence (tiree music festival cic)

Councillor Kain advised that in his opinion, the Applicant had demonstrated, over a number of years, the ability to undertake appropriate risk assessments and manage events effectively through the use of private security. He summed up by advising that providing that the current risk assessment adequately addresses all likely scenarios, he could see no reason why the Application should not be granted.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings), 9 Jun 2026, item 3Open the meeting
Asked20 May 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)

Civic government (scotland) act 1982 section 41: application for a temporary public entertainment licence (tiree music festival cic)

Councillor Kain sought and received agreement from [name removed] that it was the case that there was a certain degree of self-policing within an island community and that during events the community policed itself. [name removed] also agreed that there were a higher proportion of retired Police Officers living on islands and that proportionally there were fewer incidents on islands.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings), 20 May 2026, item 3Open the meeting
Said20 May 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)

Civic government (scotland) act 1982 section 41: application for a temporary public entertainment licence (tiree music festival cic)

Councillor Kain suggested that the numbers required by Police Scotland were more than excessive due to the history of the festival and the island. Superintendent Stirling advised that it came down to public safety.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings), 20 May 2026, item 3Open the meeting
Said20 May 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)

Civic government (scotland) act 1982 section 41: application for a temporary public entertainment licence (tiree music festival cic)

Councillor Kain commented that these numbers seemed excessive and suggested that they would be more applicable for an urban community or a gang fight.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings), 20 May 2026, item 3Open the meeting
Said11 Mar 2026Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Public question time

Councillor Kain highlighted that he is very engaged in this subject and that as far as he is aware the legal requirement allows the Council to take into account the economics and practicalities of it and that it would not be appropriate to disadvantage the majority to placate the minority.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 11 Mar 2026, item 4Open the meeting
Seconded11 Mar 2026Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Oban pva flood risk management update

Moved by Councillor Green, seconded by Councillor Kain.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 11 Mar 2026, item 7Open the meeting
Said2 Sep 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)

Councillor Kain advised that he did not require any further information.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 2 Sep 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Said2 Sep 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)

Councillor Kain advised that he had nothing additional to add.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 2 Sep 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Asked20 Aug 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of street traders licence (c morris, campbeltown)

Councillor Kain sought and received confirmation from Sergeant Rusden that Police Scotland had submitted their letter of representation as the Applicant had failed to disclose his conviction on his application form and they wanted the Committee to be aware of the offences.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 20 Aug 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Asked20 Aug 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of street traders licence (c morris, campbeltown)

Councillor Kain sought and received confirmation from Sergeant Rusden that [name removed] was 16 years old at the time of the offences.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 20 Aug 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Said2 Jun 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land east of taliesin west, garelochhead (ref: 24/0008/lrb)

Councillor Kain advised that he was conflicted and would reluctantly go along with the proposal to refuse. He commented that the implications of OSPAs were onerous in many respects, but he would leave that for another day.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 2 Jun 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Said30 May 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: former coastguard station, southend (ref: 24/0018/lrb)

Both Councillor Howard and Councillor Kain confirmed they felt they had enough information to come to a decision on the review.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 30 May 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Said30 May 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: former coastguard station, southend (ref: 24/0018/lrb)

Councillor Kain advised that he was content with it being approved. He referred to some of the comments on page 15 of the agenda pack around the suitability of the plot in relation to its size. He advised that the size of the plot was larger than the standard size of a housing plot and that he was minded to approve the application.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 30 May 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Named30 May 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: former coastguard station, southend (ref: 24/0018/lrb)

Councillor Howard agreed with Councillor Kain advising that the proposed building was more attractive than an empty coastguard shed and would therefore enhance the area rather than detract from it. She advised that she could not see any reason to refuse the application.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 30 May 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Declared21 May 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Declarations of interest

Councillor Andrew Kain declared a financial interest in planning application reference 23/01938/PP as he was the Applicant. He left the meeting and took no part in the consideration of this application which is dealt with at item 4 of this Minute.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 21 May 2025, item 2Open the meeting
Named24 Apr 2025Argyll and Bute Council

Political management arrangements

Decision The Council agreed to appoint Councillor Andrew Kain to the Oban Common Good Fund.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Council, 24 Apr 2025, item 9Open the meeting
Named19 Feb 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (m and p kolodziejczjk, flat 1, 10 stevenson street, oban)

DEBATE Councillor Kain , who had seconded the Motion to continue consideration of the application, confirmed that he did not have a competent Motion to refuse the application. He advised that his mind had not changed in this regard and asked for more time to draft a Motion for consideration.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 19 Feb 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Named19 Feb 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (m and p kolodziejczjk, flat 1, 10 stevenson street, oban)

The Chair ruled, and the Committee agreed to adjourn the meeting for 10 minutes at 10.10 am to allow Councillor Kain to consider wording for a competent Motion to refuse the application.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 19 Feb 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Named19 Feb 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (m and p kolodziejczjk, flat 1, 10 stevenson street, oban)

Councillor Kain read out his Motion, which was deemed not to be competent by Officers. The Council’s Solicitor, [name removed], advised that the view of Legal Services remained unchanged from the previous meeting. He referred to the recommended conditions in the report and said that the Committee had agreed that these were reasonable, proportionate and enforceable.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 19 Feb 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Named19 Feb 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (m and p kolodziejczjk, flat 1, 10 stevenson street, oban)

He advised that the Motion put forward by Councillor Kain to refuse the application could be challengeable.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 19 Feb 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Said19 Feb 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (m and p kolodziejczjk, flat 1, 10 stevenson street, oban)

Councillor Kain said it was his view there was a mismatch within the Council structures and that there could be foreseeable consequences.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 19 Feb 2025, item 3Open the meeting
Said11 Dec 2024Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Public question time

Councillor Kain stated that discussion over the outcome of a visitor levy was premature in the extreme. To compare with major cities and other areas in Europe in our diverse and fragile economy here and by imposing a levy and thinking that it will solve our problems on funding of different issues that are necessary across the council area is premature. He commented that the council has a range of very diverse communities, between the islands and the mainland and with different costings and needs across the communities this will raise major conflict on how the monies raised are apportioned between them.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 11 Dec 2024, item 4Open the meeting
Said14 Oct 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land west of strathholm, clachan, tarbert (ref: 24/0009/lrb)

Councillor Kain also agreed but wanted it to be noted that there appeared to be a lot of confusion in the process between SEPA and the Planning Service.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 14 Oct 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Named10 Oct 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: rosebank, breadalbane street, tobermory, isle of mull, pa75 6pd (ref: 24/0012/lrb)

(Reference: Further written information from the Applicant, the Design and Conservation Officer and the Planning Officer; letter of support from Councillor Kain and comments on this from the Planning Officer, submitted)
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 10 Oct 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Said1 Oct 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Land East of Taliesin West, Garelochhead (Ref: 24/0008/LRB)

Councillor Kain advised that he agreed with Councillor Brown, however he felt that the concerns being raised in relation to the OSPA were excessive. He advised that he felt that the plans that had been outlined by the Applicant in relation to the landscaping of the land and taking into consideration the comments of the Local Biodiversity Project Officer, gave him reassurance that this would be undertaken in a way that he would be comfortable with.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 1 Oct 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Seconded1 Oct 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Land East of Taliesin West, Garelochhead (Ref: 24/0008/LRB)

This was seconded by Councillor Kain.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 1 Oct 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Seconded11 Sep 2024Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Oban, Lorn and the Isles Area Committee - 12 June 2024

This was seconded by Councillor Kain.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 11 Sep 2024, item 3aOpen the meeting
Named11 Sep 2024Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Public question time

Councillor Kain reflected that this may be a blanket ban for security reasons in terms of military use but that was a guess.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 11 Sep 2024, item 4Open the meeting
Named3 Sep 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: rosebank, breadalbane street, tobermory, isle of mull, pa75 6pd (ref: 24/0012/lrb)

Before proceeding further he invited [name removed] to advise of a late letter of support received from Councillor Andrew Kain.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 3 Sep 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Named3 Sep 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: rosebank, breadalbane street, tobermory, isle of mull, pa75 6pd (ref: 24/0012/lrb)

[name removed] advised that on 20 August 2024 a letter of support was received from Councillor Kain.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 3 Sep 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Named3 Sep 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: rosebank, breadalbane street, tobermory, isle of mull, pa75 6pd (ref: 24/0012/lrb)

She further advised that Councillor Kain did not comment on the original planning application and, in terms of the Regulations, if the Members of the LRB wished to consider this correspondence as part of the LRB process it would have to be treated as new information with all interested parties being given the opportunity of commenting on it.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 3 Sep 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Named3 Sep 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: rosebank, breadalbane street, tobermory, isle of mull, pa75 6pd (ref: 24/0012/lrb)

1.      to take the late letter of support from Councillor Andrew Kain into the process and noted that all interested parties would be given the opportunity of commenting on this new information;
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 3 Sep 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Said6 Aug 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (a johnston, ghillies croft cabin, rothesay)

Councillor Kain noted that the Cabin had planning permission to be used as an office and workshop. He asked [name removed] if it had ever been used as an office or workshop. He also asked why guest pamphlets were being prepared before planning permission for change of use had been granted.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 6 Aug 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Named6 Aug 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (a johnston, ghillies croft cabin, rothesay)

Councillor Kain referred to a degree of confusion with the two regimes. [name removed] confirmed that he was clear in his mind that until he had his planning application for change of  ...  view the full minutes text for item 3.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 6 Aug 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Said20 Jun 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land west of strathholm, clachan, tarbert (ref: 24/0009/lrb)

Councillor Kain said he felt he had enough information.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 20 Jun 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Seconded12 Jun 2024Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Oban Town Centre, North Active Travel Report

This was moved by Councillor McKenzie and seconded by Councillor Kain, and was unanimously agreed by the Committee.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 12 Jun 2024, item 10Open the meeting
Seconded12 Jun 2024Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Supporting Communities Fund - Applications

Moved by Councillor McKenzie and seconded by Councillor Kain.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 12 Jun 2024, item 11Open the meeting
Named21 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land at coultorsay farm, bruichladdich, isle of islay (ref: 24/0006/lrb)

Councillor Kain disagreed with the comments made by Councillor Irvine. He made reference to the Council having had declared a housing crisis early the previous year, and the housing emergency that had been declared across the country. He advised that the Scottish Government and the Council were trying to address depopulation, and as housing for workers was relevant now, this proposal could assist with this.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 21 May 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Said21 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land at coultorsay farm, bruichladdich, isle of islay (ref: 24/0006/lrb)

Councillor Kain highlighted that the Applicants had indicated that they were willing to put conditions on the development to ensure that the use of the buildings was constrained. He said that he had an issue with a statement made by the planning officer that the development had an urban character, whereby a previous officer had indicated that it would be okay.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 21 May 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Said21 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land at coultorsay farm, bruichladdich, isle of islay (ref: 24/0006/lrb)

Councillor Kain said that in regards planning, there was a need to have perspective in terms of context. He advised that the population of Islay was around 3200, and had that been stable throughout its history then it could maybe have been considered as urban character but the Council was trying to reverse depopulation. He told the Panel that in 1830, the population on Islay had been 13,600, which was 4 times what it was now and therefore there was nothing to impede this in context.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 21 May 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Said21 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land at coultorsay farm, bruichladdich, isle of islay (ref: 24/0006/lrb)

Councillor Kain said that he had been given no reason to change his view, and that they were now faced with the issue that planning was now becoming a barrier to achieving both Council objectives and Government objectives. He repeated the population figures he had given from the present time and from 1830, highlighting that the population had been declining ever since then. He said that one of only ways to reverse depopulation was with housing provision, adding that employers could not get housing for their employees on Islay.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 21 May 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Said21 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land at coultorsay farm, bruichladdich, isle of islay (ref: 24/0006/lrb)

Councillor Kain agreed that families were now structured differently and said that it was economic circumstances that had driven decline. He advised that it was down to the whisky trade, and that the development of the blue economy was bringing business to all islands but employers were constrained as there wasn’t the housing for new employees. He said the economic potential was there but was constrained by lack of house building.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 21 May 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Asked26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (h kinnaird, luss)

MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Kain asked the applicant what he defined as early intervention as per 4.7 of the report. The applicant advised that he could be at the property within 30 mins or there is family closer by that could be in attendance in about 7 mins.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 26 Mar 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Said26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (h kinnaird, luss)

Councillor Kain added that stating times with regard to early intervention must be achievable and also asked what reasonable steps would be takens to ensure that no more than 10 people turn up to the property. The applicant stated that they meet guests on arrival, there are noise monitors and CCTV cameras fitted, but would welcome any other suggestions that would alleviate any issues.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 26 Mar 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Named26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (h kinnaird, luss)

Councillor Kain supported the application but to put achievable response times to any issues that arise.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 26 Mar 2024, item 3Open the meeting
Seconded21 Feb 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Mr shaun sinclair: erection of cafÉ with associated landscaping including a viewpoint, seating, interpretive sign and play park: land west of inverlusragan, connel (ref: 21/01583/pp)

Moved by Councillor Amanda Hampsey, seconded by Councillor Andrew Kain.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 21 Feb 2024, item 4Open the meeting
Moved23 Nov 2023Argyll and Bute Council

Notice of motion under standing order 13

Moved by Councillor Andrew Kain , seconded by Councillor Yvonne McNeilly .
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Council, 23 Nov 2023, item 17Open the meeting
Named8 Nov 2023Oban Lorn & the Isles Area Community Planning Group

Report by Luing Community Council

Councillor Kain offered to facilitate someone from Roads and Infrastructure to get in touch with the Community Council to discuss and offer technical advice.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & the Isles Area Community Planning Group, 8 Nov 2023, item 9bOpen the meeting
Said11 Sep 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Kain advised that he had sufficient information before him to proceed with determining the application today. He advised that he had a Motion that he would like to put forward at the appropriate time.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 11 Sep 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Named11 Sep 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

The Members of the LRB agreed to take the comments submitted by the Objector into consideration and Councillor Hampsey invited Councillor Kain to present his Motion.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 11 Sep 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said14 Aug 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Kain said that he had sufficient information. He advised that from what he had read he felt there were inconsistencies between the information provided by Transport Scotland and the Applicant’s Agent. He referred, in particular, to the number of expected two way vehicle movements per day from an additional dwelling, with Transport Scotland advising this would be 5 or 6 trips and the Applicant’s Agent advising it would be 2 or 3 trips.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 14 Aug 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said14 Aug 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Kain advised that he did not think the objections put forward by Transport Scotland ‘stacked up’.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 14 Aug 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Named14 Aug 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Hardie advised that he understood what Councillor Kain had said but based on the expert opinion of Transport Scotland as statutory consultee, he would recommend refusal of this application.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 14 Aug 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said14 Aug 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Kain advised that he took the same view as the Applicant’s Engineer.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 14 Aug 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Named14 Aug 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Hampsey advised that she had visited the site herself after the previous LRB meeting and was of the same opinion as Councillor Kain.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 14 Aug 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Named14 Jun 2023Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Public question time

The questions will be put to the relevant department and Councillor Kain will request that the response is issued timeously.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 14 Jun 2023, item 7Open the meeting
Said10 May 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land noth of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Kain advised that while he did not disagree with these conclusions he did have some concerns. He commented that there appeared to be contradictions between the views of Planning and Transport Scotland. He referred to the requirement for the access road to be brought up to an adoptable standard if there were more than 5 dwellings.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 10 May 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said10 May 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land noth of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Kain expressed his concern at the length of time it had taken for the application to be processed and for the lack of flexibility to accommodate the development. He pointed out that this was a brownfield site and not a greenfield site. He sought advice from [name removed].
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 10 May 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said10 May 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land noth of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

[name removed] referred to the issues raised by Councillor Kain and advised that further information could be sought from Planning Officers and Transport Scotland with regards to signage. He advised that permission would require to be sought for signage to be erected as it would not be on land owned by the Applicant and suggested that confirmation on whether or not it would be possible to erect the signage could be sought from Transport Scotland. He further advised that if the Members of the LRB were minded to approve the application they would need time to seek advice on preparing a competent Motion to approve which detailed justification for departing from planning policies.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 10 May 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said10 May 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land noth of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Kain agreed that he would like to request this further information from both Planning and Transport Scotland and put forward the following Motion which was subsequently seconded by Councillor Hampsey .
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 10 May 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said10 May 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body

Consider notice of review request: land noth of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)

Councillor Kain advised that he would wait until the above information was received before deciding whether or not he would like a site inspection.
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, 10 May 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Named30 Mar 2023Oban Common Good Fund

Apologies

In the absence of Councillor Andrew Kain (Chair), the Trustees agreed that Councillor Kieron Green would Chair the meeting.
From the council's minutes: Oban Common Good Fund, 30 Mar 2023, item 1Open the meeting
Named8 Mar 2023Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Pupil voice

On behalf of the Oban, Lorn and the Isles Area Committee, Councillor Kain , wished the pupils all the very best wishes for their futures.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 8 Mar 2023, item 7Open the meeting
Named2 Mar 2023Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee

Rest and be thankful update

(Reference:   Report by Executive Director with responsibility for Roads and Infrastructure Services dated January 2023, submitted; and Motion by Councillor Andrew Kain , seconded by Councillor Donald Kelly, tabled)
From the council's minutes: Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee, 2 Mar 2023, item 7Open the meeting
Asked18 Jan 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a street trader licence (g plumb, dalmally)

MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Kain asked [name removed] to outline what the assault related to. [name removed] advised that he and a friend went to Wales for a night out and water sports. A friend of his friend also came along on the night out and that he did not know him at this point.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 18 Jan 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Said18 Jan 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a street trader licence (g plumb, dalmally)

Councillor Kain commented on the conviction being extreme for one punch. He asked [name removed] if there were other charges. [name removed] advised that due to the person having the fight first being a friend of his friend, and as he had fought with the same person, his offence was put together with what the other person was charged with.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 18 Jan 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Asked18 Jan 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee

Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi driver licence (k oliphant-smith, dunoon)

Councillor Kain sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he received his Taxi Driver Licence for the Isle of Man last year.
From the council's minutes: Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, 18 Jan 2023, item 3Open the meeting
Seconded30 Jun 2022Argyll and Bute Council

Notice of motion under standing order 13

Moved by Councillor MacPherson, seconded by Councillor Kain .
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Council, 30 Jun 2022, item 14Open the meeting
Named21 Jun 2022Oban Common Good Fund

Appointment of Chair to Oban Common Good Fund

Decision It was agreed that Councillor Andrew Kain would be appointed as Chair of the Oban Common Good Fund.
From the council's minutes: Oban Common Good Fund, 21 Jun 2022, item 4Open the meeting
Said15 Jun 2022Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee

Public question time

Councillor Kain advised the Area Committee that he had been appointed as Chair of the Harbour Board and he would be happy to take forward the concerns of OCHDA and is committed to ensuring that all lines of communication with the public would be open.
From the council's minutes: Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee, 15 Jun 2022, item 4Open the meeting
Named19 May 2022Argyll and Bute Council

Political management arrangements

Appendix 1 - Policy Lead Councillor Appointments Name Policy Lead Role Depute Policy Lead Cllr Kieron Green Planning and Regulatory Services   Cllr Amanda Hampsey Cllr Amanda Hampsey Care Services Cllr Kieron Green Cllr Andrew Kain Roads and Transport Cllr   Tommy Macpherson Cllr Ross Moreland Climate Change and Environment Services Cllr Peter Wallace Cllr John McAlpine Community Planning and Corporate Services Cllr Paul Kennedy Cllr Robin Currie Economy and Rural Growth   Cllr John McAlpine Cllr Gary Mulvaney Finance and Commercial Services   Cllr William Sinclair Cllr Yvonne McNeilly Education Cllr Daniel Hampsey Cllr Liz McCabe Islands and Business Development Cllr Graham Hardie Appendix 2 - Membership of Committees Community Services Environment, Development and Infrastructure Policy and Resources Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Cllr Yvonne McNeilly (Chair) Cllr Robin Currie (Chair) Cllr Robin Currie (Chair) Cllr Kieron Green (Chair) Cllr Daniel Hampsey (Vice Chair) Cllr Andrew Kain (Vice Chair) Cllr Gary Mulvaney (Vice Chair) Cllr Amanda Hampsey (Vice Chair) Cllr Paul Kennedy Cllr John McAlpine Cllr Kieron Green Cllr Andrew Kain Cllr Andrew Kain Cllr Ross Moreland Cllr Amanda Hampsey Cllr Graham Hardie Cllr Gemma Penfold Cllr Andrew Vennard Cllr Andrew Kain Cllr Liz McCabe Cllr Garret Corner Cllr Tommy Macpherson Cllr Ross Moreland Cllr Paul Kennedy Cllr Graham Hardie Cllr Peter Wallace Cllr John McAlpine Cllr Peter Wallace Cllr Liz McCabe Cllr Garret Corner
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Council, 19 May 2022, item 10Open the meeting
Named19 May 2022Argyll and Bute Council

Appointments of outside bodies

Appendix 1 - Appointments to Outside Bodies Organisation Representative/s and status NHS Highland Board Cllr Garret Corner University of the Highlands and Islands Foundation Committee Cllr Yvonne McNeilly SOILLSE National Network for Gaelic Research Consultative Committee Cllr Robin Currie Ionaid Chaluim Chille - Gaelic Centre, Islay Cllr Robin Currie PA23BID Board (Dunoon) Cllr Ross Moreland Isle of Bute BID Board One representative Nadair Trust (Scottish Natural Heritage) Cllr Kieron Green Argyll and Bute Local Biodiversity Partnership Cllr Kieron Green Argyll, Lomond and the Islands Energy Agency ( ALIEnergy ) Management Board Cllr Garret Corner Cllr Ross Moreland Argyll and Bute Renewables Alliance (ABRA) Cllr Robin Currie Argyll and the Isles Coast and Countryside Trust Cllr Ross Moreland   - representative Cllr Peter Wallace - substitute Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority Board Cllr William Sinclair Cllr Graham Hardie Scottish Liaison Group on Radioactive Waste Management Cllr Ross Moreland Scottish Councils Committee on Radioactive Substances Cllr Ross Moreland West of Scotland Archaeology Service Joint Committee Cllr Ross Moreland - representative Cllr Peter Wallace - substitute Clyde Marine Planning Partnership Cllr Kieron Green Clyde and Lomond Local Plan Flood District Cllr Daniel Hampsey Highland and Argyll Local Plan Flood District Cllr Andrew Kain Argyll and Bute Care and Repair Agency Cllr Graham Hardie Cllr Garret Corner Fyne Homes Group Cll
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Council, 19 May 2022, item 18Open the meeting
Named19 May 2022Argyll and Bute Council

Employee joint consultative committee

o    Cllr Kieron Green o    Cllr Amanda Hampsey o    Cllr Andrew Kain o    Cllr Ross Moreland o    Cllr John McAlpine o    Cllr Gary Mulvaney o    Cllr Yvonne McNeilly o    Cllr Liz McCabe ·          Cllr Jim Lynch, Leader of the SNP, the largest Opposition Group (Ref: Report by Executive Director with responsibility for Legal and Regulatory Support dated 5 May 2022, submitted)
From the council's minutes: Argyll and Bute Council, 19 May 2022, item 19Open the meeting

Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.

Votes at their meetings

Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Kain attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.

DateMeetingItemTheir voteResultCount
17 Jun 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (tavies taxies, campbeltown)CarriedUnanimous
20 May 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (c mckay, oban)CarriedUnanimous
11 May 2026Oban Common Good FundLorn Volleyball ClubCarriedUnanimous
11 May 2026Oban Common Good FundNorth Argyll Cycle ClubCarriedUnanimous
11 May 2026Oban Common Good FundOban Gaelic ChoirCarriedUnanimous
11 May 2026Oban Common Good FundOban Photographic ClubCarriedUnanimous
11 May 2026Oban Common Good FundOban Youth CafeCarriedUnanimous
19 Mar 2026Argyll and Bute Harbour BoardApologies for absenceCarriedUnanimous
16 Mar 2026Oban Common Good FundAppointment of chairCarriedUnanimous
16 Mar 2026Oban Common Good FundOban common good fund banking arrangementsCarriedUnanimous
2 Sep 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review BodyConsider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)CarriedUnanimous
20 Aug 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (c lenehan, oban)CarriedUnanimous
29 May 2025Oban Common Good FundOban Bowling ClubCarriedUnanimous
29 May 2025Oban Common Good FundContinued Application - Nevis Community Radio LtdCarriedUnanimous
29 May 2025Oban Common Good FundContinued Application - Oban Community CouncilCarriedUnanimous
24 Apr 2025Argyll and Bute CouncilProposal to review the scheme for the establishment of community councils in argyll and buteCarriedUnanimous
16 Jan 2025Community Council Conduct Review PanelAppointment of chairCarriedUnanimous
19 Jun 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (f pacitti, dunbeg)CarriedUnanimous
12 Jun 2024Oban Lorn & The Isles Area CommitteeOban Town Centre, North Active Travel ReportCarriedUnanimous
22 May 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (m s shields, helensburgh)CarriedUnanimous
26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (gowanlea, kilchattan bay, isle of bute)CarriedUnanimous
26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (h kinnaird, luss)CarriedUnanimous
20 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for a grant of a taxi car licence: m sohail, cardrossCarriedUnanimous
16 Feb 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic Government (Scotland) Act 1982, The Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 (Licensing of Short-term Lets) Order 2022: Application for Grant of a Short Term Let LicenceCarriedUnanimous
20 Sep 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licenceCarriedUnanimous
13 Sep 2023Oban Lorn & The Isles Area CommitteeNotice of motion under standing order 13CarriedUnanimous
23 Aug 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (currie taxis, alexandria)CarriedUnanimous
21 Aug 2023Oban Common Good FundAtlantis LeisureCarriedUnanimous
22 May 2023Oban Common Good FundSoroba Community EnterpriseCarriedUnanimous
22 Mar 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (number 6556) (a simpson, dunoon)CarriedUnanimous
22 Mar 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (k hail, bonhill, alexandria)CarriedUnanimous
17 Aug 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (c fox, oban)CarriedUnanimous
17 Aug 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: applicant for grant of a taxi car licence (j young, dunbeg, oban)CarriedUnanimous
17 Aug 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (s mcintyre-stewart, garelochhead)CarriedUnanimous
3 Aug 2022Oban Common Good FundCruachanside Cammanachd Shinty ClubCarriedUnanimous
22 Jun 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeCivic government (scotland) act 1982: application for renewal of taxi driver licence number 2810 (a mathieson, campbeltown)CarriedUnanimous
15 Jun 2022Oban Lorn & The Isles Area CommitteePublic question timeCarriedUnanimous
Hover an item for the minutes' own words. Most councils record the count, not each councillor's vote.

Attendance

Meetings Councillor Kain was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.

Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
66 of 97
Argyll and Bute Council
22 of 22
Oban Common Good Fund
9 of 13
Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
11 of 12
Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee
10 of 11
Oban Lorn & The Isles Area Committee
11 of 11
Policy and Resources Committee
7 of 10
Argyll and Bute Harbour Board
8 of 9
Argyll and Bute Licensing Board
2 of 8
Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)
5 of 8
Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Short-term Let Hearings)
3 of 5
Budget Pack
0 of 4
Community Services Committee
4 of 5
Argyll Islands Sounding Board
2 of 2
Community Council Conduct Review Panel
2 of 2
Last 12 monthsPresent Apologies Absent
Dec
Jan
Feb
+1
Apr
May
+4
Jul
Aug
+2
Oct
Nov

Present at 32 of 54 meetings in the last 12 months.

Declarations of interest

What Councillor Kain declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.

DateWhereWhat the minutes sayWhat happened
21 May 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee, item 2Councillor Andrew Kain declared a financial interest in planning application reference 23/01938/PP as he was the Applicant. He left the meeting and took no part in the consideration of this application which is dealt with at item 4 of this Minute.Left the room
Hover a line for the full wording.

Committees and roles

Where Councillor Kain sits, from the attendance records.

CommitteeRoleSinceMeetingsNext meeting
Planning, Protective Services and Licensing CommitteeMemberJun 202297
Argyll and Bute CouncilMemberMay 20222225 Nov 2026
Oban Common Good FundMemberJun 202213
Argyll and Bute Local Review BodyMemberMay 20231219 Nov 2026
Environment, Development and Infrastructure CommitteeMemberJun 202211
Oban Lorn & The Isles Area CommitteeVice-ChairJun 202211
Policy and Resources CommitteeMemberJun 202210
Argyll and Bute Harbour BoardMemberAug 20229
Argyll and Bute Licensing BoardMemberFeb 2025824 Nov 2026
Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)MemberMay 20268
Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Short-term Let Hearings)MemberMay 20265
Budget PackMemberFeb 20234
Community Services CommitteeMemberAug 20225
Argyll Islands Sounding BoardMemberMay 20232
Community Council Conduct Review PanelMemberJan 20252
Committees with no meeting in the last year are shown faded.

We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies