Said17 Jun 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (tavies taxies, campbeltown)
Councillor Hardie agreed with his fellow Councillors, advising that given there were no objectors and the fall in numbers in provision of vehicles in the area, he too was happy to approve the licence. DECISION The Committee unanimously agreed to grant a Taxi Car Licence to [name removed] and noted that he would receive written confirmation of this within 7 days. (Reference: Report by Head of Legal and Regulatory Support, submitted)
Said9 Jun 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings)
Civic government (scotland) act 1982 section 41: application for a temporary public entertainment licence (tiree music festival cic)
Councillor Hardie advised that from a public safety perspective, he would feel more reassured by a police presence and indicated support for granting the Application subject to the inclusion of the conditions outlined at paragraph 5.1 of the report.
Asked22 May 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Short-term Let Hearings)
Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence to k lowe, flat 2/32, 28 west clyde street, helensburgh
Councillor Hardie asked the Objector, [name removed], if he stayed in either of his properties within the building? [name removed] responded that he lives in one of the flats and had recently sold the other.
Asked22 May 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Short-term Let Hearings)
Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence to k lowe, flat 2/32, 28 west clyde street, helensburgh
Councillor Hardie then asked [name removed] if he thought there would be a privacy issue should the licence be granted? [name removed] responded yes and that would be due to the volume of people if the property was let on a regular basis, if only occasionally let then possibly not.
Said22 May 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Short-term Let Hearings)
Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence to c connelly, altnafearn, shore road, kames, tighnabruaich
Councillor Hardie agreed with Councillor Green and would support the additional condition of having a contactable person living within a 10 mile radius of the property.
Seconded20 May 2026Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Mr brian mangan: change of use of existing private/family use pod to short term letting accommodation: 11 etive park, north connel (ref: 26/00161/pp)
Moved by Councillor Liz McCabe, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie.
Said8 Dec 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land west of helenslea, tighnabruaich (ref: 25/0009/lrb)
Councillor Hardie commented that he thought the paperwork provided was very comprehensive and said that the Objectors’ letters had clarified the roads issue for him. He said he did not require any further information.
Named8 Dec 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land west of helenslea, tighnabruaich (ref: 25/0009/lrb)
Councillor Green said he was of a similar mind to Councillor Hardie at this point.
Moved8 Dec 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land west of helenslea, tighnabruaich (ref: 25/0009/lrb)
He said he was mindful of Councillor Brown looking for more information and before he and Councillor Hardie moved to make a decision on the application without Councillor Brown have the opportunity of obtaining this further information, he asked Councillor Brown if she would want to make any further comment in support of obtaining further information.
Said8 Dec 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land west of helenslea, tighnabruaich (ref: 25/0009/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that when he considered the Review, he examined the following:
Said8 Dec 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land west of helenslea, tighnabruaich (ref: 25/0009/lrb)
Councillor Hardie said he found these arguments comprehensive and his main reason for refusing along with the other evidence before him.
Named8 Dec 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land west of helenslea, tighnabruaich (ref: 25/0009/lrb)
Councillor Brown said she supported the view put forward by Councillor Hardie .
Named8 Dec 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land west of helenslea, tighnabruaich (ref: 25/0009/lrb)
Councillor Green commented that Councillor Hardie had presented a very thorough argument. He said that he would also like to add the following observations - He said he thought it was notable that there was previous use on the site, however, that was nearly 30 years ago. He commented that a lot had changed since that time with more households now having more than one car and that the size of cars had increased.
Named8 Dec 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land west of helenslea, tighnabruaich (ref: 25/0009/lrb)
Councillor Green confirmed that he was minded to support Councillor Hardie ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Said2 Sep 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)
Councillor Hardie advised that he would be interested to find out whether it was the Council or Kilfinan Community Forest Company that owned the access road as from reading the paperwork within the pack, he was not clear on the ownership.
Said2 Sep 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)
Councillor Hardie agreed that it would not have a considerable amount of bearing on a decision and that this was just a general interest he had for himself.
Said2 Sep 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)
Councillor Hardie confirmed that he had enough information before him to come to a decision today.
Said2 Sep 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)
Councillor Hardie advised that when he considered the Review, he examined the following:
Said2 Sep 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land south of kilfinan community forest caravan and west of hafton house, tighnabruaich (ref: 20/01429/pp)
Councillor Hardie advised that having examined these key considerations, he had come to the conclusion that it seemed evident that the issue of the road, and the main reason for the initial rejection, was intractable in his opinion. He said he would agree with the Planning Officer's reason for refusal as stated in the report of handling: - that the development would be detrimental to traffic safety as the existing private access road has design constraints so it does not have the capacity for the development of an additional dwelling house without commensurate improvements to the access road.
Said20 Aug 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (c lenehan, oban)
Councillor Hardie said that based on the Applicant’s written submission he would like to grant this licence.
Seconded20 Aug 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Gb wind farm limited: erection of a 120 metre high meteorological mast for a temporary period of up to 4 years: land approximately 2.1 km northwest of dunoon and 1.5km southwest of sandbank (ref: 24/01926/pp)
Moved by Councillor Kieron Green, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie .
Said10 Jun 2025Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Public question time
Councillor Hardie advised that he was happy to meet with constituents to discuss this matter and would welcome them at his surgery.
Said5 Jun 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: seaview, bruichladdich, isle of islay, argyll, pa49 7un (ref: 25/0004/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that when he considered the Review, he examined the following:
Named5 Jun 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: seaview, bruichladdich, isle of islay, argyll, pa49 7un (ref: 25/0004/lrb)
Councillor Hampsey advised that while understanding what Councillor Hardie had said, he had concerns. He referred to Section 25 of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 which required that all decisions be made in accordance with the Development Plan unless material considerations indicated otherwise. He advised that despite the case being made here, he thought the Local Review Body should comply with the Act, but he would like to hear the views of the other Members in respect of any material consideration.
Named5 Jun 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: seaview, bruichladdich, isle of islay, argyll, pa49 7un (ref: 25/0004/lrb)
Councillor Hardie read out the following Motion:
Moved5 Jun 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: seaview, bruichladdich, isle of islay, argyll, pa49 7un (ref: 25/0004/lrb)
He said that he had noted there have been different fences here in the past and, while some may have had less of a visual impact, it was his view that the condition proposed by Councillor Hardie in respect of painting the fence, would help considerably with that visual impact. He referred to other industrial units in the nearby vicinity and commented that this was not a Conservation Area with uniform building styles. He advised on that basis, he thought having a degree of flexibility here to meet the needs of the Applicant, would be appropriate.
Named5 Jun 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: seaview, bruichladdich, isle of islay, argyll, pa49 7un (ref: 25/0004/lrb)
[name removed] confirmed that the Motion put forward by Councillor Hardie was competent and the Members of the LRB unanimously agreed to support it.
Said26 May 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (s jackson, flat 1/3, 50 marine road, port bannatyne, isle of bute)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie noted that this had been a well-run and organised short-term let before and that he saw no problem in accepting this application.
Named21 May 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (r hassan, helensburgh)
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Hardie referred to Police Scotland asking for the suspension of his licence as they did not think [name removed] was a fit and proper person to be the holder of the licence. He asked [name removed] to comment on that. [name removed] said he thought it was untrue to say he was not a fit and proper person.
Said7 Apr 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: rhu house, rhu road, port charlotte, isle of islay, pa48 7tp (ref: 25/0003/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that he had considered what the grounds for Review were, whether or not there was any new evidence admitted and whether or not there were any procedural errors. He said that having considered all the evidence before him he could see no reason to grant this application and that he agreed with the Planning Officer’s decision to refuse this application for the reasons detailed at page 51 of the Agenda pack for today’s meeting.
Named7 Apr 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: rhu house, rhu road, port charlotte, isle of islay, pa48 7tp (ref: 25/0003/lrb)
Councillor Green said that he was largely in agreement with Councillor Hardie . He referred to guidance available locally and nationally from different organisations in terms of how sensitive buildings should be treated. He advised that he would have expected these guidelines to be followed in this instance, in terms of timber framing and double glazing, and that he was disappointed to see this had not been done.
Named7 Apr 2025Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: rhu house, rhu road, port charlotte, isle of islay, pa48 7tp (ref: 25/0003/lrb)
Councillor Wallace confirmed that he was in agreement with both Councillor Hardie and Councillor Green.
Seconded19 Mar 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Cala management limited: variation of condition 4 relative to planning permission in principle reference 23/00145/pp - amendment to wording of condition 4 in relation to road improvements: land north of cardross primary school, barrs road, cardross (kirkton farm) (ref: 24/02193/pp)
Moved by Councillor Paul Kennedy, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie .
Said19 Feb 2025Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982, the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (m and p kolodziejczjk, flat 1, 10 stevenson street, oban)
Councillor Hardie expressed his concern about the remit of this Committee. He said that as it stood they had approved every short-term licence application that had come before them. He questioned the point of these hearings.
Said12 Nov 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land north of rockmount, portincaple (ref: 24/0016/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that having read all the papers he was minded to refuse the application due to significant road safety concerns as detailed in the Report of Handling.
Named12 Nov 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land north of rockmount, portincaple (ref: 24/0016/lrb)
Councillor Brown agreed with the statements made by Councillor Hardie and stated she was also minded to refuse the application.
Seconded27 Aug 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: 24/0004/LRB: Plot 2, Achnacairn, North Connel (Ref: 22/01950/PPP)
Councillor Brown moved the following Motion, which was seconded by Councillor Hardie – There is a general presumption in favour of development within this area of North Connel, established by current policy but this is qualified by the requirement to ensure that developments accord with the existing and established pattern of development and do not result in an unacceptable environmental, servicing or access impact, with an overwhelming emphasis on respecting the character and setting of the area into which the individual development proposal is to be located, taking account of local spacing, layout, densities, privacy and amenity standards.
Seconded27 Aug 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: 24/0004/LRB: Plot 2, Achnacairn, North Connel (Ref: 22/01950/PPP)
(Motion by Councillor Jan Brown, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie, tabled)
Said6 Aug 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short-term let licence (m downie, flat 2/1, 7 argyll terrace, kirn, dunoon)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie said he would be happy to grant this licence and noted that one of the Objectors had had her issues resolved.
Said28 Jun 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: plot 2, achnacairn, north connel (ref: 24/0004/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that he agreed with Councillor Blair and Councillor Brown. [name removed] advised that if the Local Review Body were minded to approve the application they may wish to request model conditions and reasons that could be applied to an approval and seek advice on competent motion to approve the application.
Named11 Jun 2024Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Appointments to outside organisations
Helensburgh and Lomond Locality Planning Group Councillor Fiona Howard Gourock, Dunoon and Kilcreggan Harbour Reference Group Councillor Mark Irvine Dunbartonshire Educational Trust Councillor Fiona Howard Glasgow Airport Consultative Committee Councillor Graham Hardie - subject to confirmation of acceptance of the appointment.
Said27 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: plot 2, achnacairn, north connel (ref: 24/0004/lrb)
Councillor Hardie agreed with Councillor Brown and said that on reflection some of the arguments made by planning were watertight but advised that he wanted to see how the proposed development was contrary to the row of established representative properties.
Said22 May 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (m s shields, helensburgh)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie agreed that the demand for taxis was there and that certain aspects of Helensburgh were booming. He confirmed that he supported this application.
Said16 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Andrews Garage, Tighnabruaich, PA21 2DS (Ref: 24/0003/LRB)
Councillor Hardie advised that he felt he had sufficient information to come to a decision.
Said16 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Andrews Garage, Tighnabruaich, PA21 2DS (Ref: 24/0003/LRB)
Councillor Hardie advised that having considered the information before him, he agreed with the decision of the Planning authority to refuse the application.
Named16 May 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Andrews Garage, Tighnabruaich, PA21 2DS (Ref: 24/0003/LRB)
Councillor Irvine advised that he was in agreement with Councillor Hardie, particularly in relation to the design principles. He advised that he felt the size, scale and massing of the proposal was wholly inappropriate for the area and as such he too agreed with the decision of the Planning authority to refuse the application. The Chair advised that there were a number of issues which concerned him in relation to this application, particularly the design and layout and the contaminated land.
Said26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (gowanlea, kilchattan bay, isle of bute)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie agreed that the applicant had done everything to address the Objectors concerns and he has happy to support the application.
Said26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (h kinnaird, luss)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie stated that the applicant was professional, organised and dealt with concerns quickly and had no problem in the licence being granted.
Asked26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (c bray, rhu)
Councillor Hardie asked the objector if he had any issues with noise at unsociable hours. The objector advised that where his residence is in relation to the short term let he would not hear any noise from that area.
Named26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (c bray, rhu)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie having listened to both sides advised he had no problem with agreeing to grant the licence with the conditions attached.
Named26 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (c bray, rhu)
Councillor Irvine wished that all applicants were as accommodating and considerate and agreed with Councillor Hardie that the licence should be granted with conditions.
Named20 Mar 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Graham Hardie, in relation to item 3 (CIVIC GOVERNMENT (SCOTLAND) ACT 1982: APPLICATION FOR A GRANT OF A TAXI CAR LICENCE: M SOHAIL, CARDROSS) on the agenda, advised that he knew the applicant well. He advised that he would leave the meeting during discussion and deliberation of the item.
Said29 Feb 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Land South East of Islay House, Glencruitten, Oban, PA34 4QB (Ref: 24/0001/LRB)
Councillor Hardie advised that he felt he had sufficient information to come to a decision.
Said29 Feb 2024Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Land South East of Islay House, Glencruitten, Oban, PA34 4QB (Ref: 24/0001/LRB)
Councillor Hardie advised that having considered the information before him, he agreed with the decision of the Planning authority to refuse the application. He advised that it was his intention to move that the application be refused as he too considered that the proposed development was contrary to NPF4 Policy 9 as underpinned by LDP Policies LDP STRAT 1, LDP DM 1, SG LDP ENV 14 and SG LDP HOU 1 and Policy 01 of pLDP2. He advised that in his opinion the Planning authority’s reasons for refusal, as outlined on page 46 of the agenda pack, were robust and concrete and he could see no obvious avenue for challenging their decision.
Named22 Feb 2024Argyll and Bute Council
Political management arrangements
Decision The Council – 1. agreed to appoint Councillor Fiona Howard as an Argyll and Bute Council representative on the Live Argyll Board; and 2. agreed to appoint Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie as a Trustee to the Blindcraft Trust Fund.
Said21 Feb 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a late hours catering licence: b almheimed, rothesay
Councillor Hardie also agreed and happy to go with the recommendations from Environmental Health.
Moved21 Feb 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Mr shaun sinclair: erection of cafÉ with associated landscaping including a viewpoint, seating, interpretive sign and play park: land west of inverlusragan, connel (ref: 21/01583/pp)
Moved by Councillor Graham Hardie, seconded ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Said24 Jan 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi car licence number 6685 (j macintyre, oban)
Councillor Hardie advised that he agreed with his fellow Councillors. He said that following the decision taken at the previous hearing, he thought the licence should be suspended with immediate effect for the duration of the licence.
Said24 Jan 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (number 6662) (j macintyre, oban)
Councillor Hardie agreed with his fellow Councillors and confirmed that he would be happy to see the immediate suspension of the licence. Councillors Wallace and Hampsey also agreed to the immediate suspension of the licence. DECISION The Committee unanimously agreed to suspend [name removed] Licence (No 6662) with immediate effect for the unexpired portion of the licence.
Named24 Jan 2024Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (p mcdougall, helensburgh)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie referred to a slight over provision of taxis in the Helensburgh and Lomond area but advised that he believed the Applicant would be well suited to this job and that he would be happy to grant the licence.
Said12 Dec 2023Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Public Question Time
Councillor Hardie advised [name removed] to pass the specific details onto him and he would contact the Head of Roads on her behalf.
Named23 Nov 2023Argyll and Bute Council
Political management arrangements
Appoints Councillor Graham Hardie to the vacant position on the Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee.
Said22 Nov 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (n petkov, garelochhead)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie advised that being on the ground in Helensburgh he was aware that there was a shortage of taxis at night time. He advised that even though there may be a slight over provision, he would be happy to grant this application.
Named22 Nov 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (n petkov, garelochhead)
Councillor Armour agreed with Councillor Hardie and advised that if there was a problem there would have been objections to this application.
Named22 Nov 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (n petkov, garelochhead)
Councillor Philand was of a similar mind and commented that Councillor Hardie would know best how things were there. He also referred to there being no objections to the application and advised that he would be happy to grant the licence.
Said11 Sep 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)
Councillor Hardie also advised that he had sufficient information. He referred to comments submitted by the Objector not raising any new information.
Said11 Sep 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)
Councillor Hardie confirmed that he remained of the view that as long as Transport Scotland objected he was minded to reject this application.
Seconded23 Aug 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a street trader licence
Moved by Councillor Kieron Green, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie. Amendmen t To agree to continue consideration of this application until the conclusion of the pending court case on 9 October 2023 and to bring the matter back to the PPSL Committee on 18 October 2023.
Asked23 Aug 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (currie taxis, alexandria)
Councillor Hardie sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he believed there was a lack of taxis in the town at certain times. He said it tended to be quieter during the week, during the day. He advised that there tended to be more taxis available during the day compared to at night as there were limited drivers working at night.
Said14 Aug 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land north of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that he understood what Councillor Kain had said but based on the expert opinion of Transport Scotland as statutory consultee, he would recommend refusal of this application.
Said24 May 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (s mcintyre-stewart, garelochhead)
Councillor Hardie advised that being a Helensburgh Ward Councillor, he could see for himself in the evenings that people were waiting at the rank outside the station.
Said10 May 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land noth of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that it was his view that the application should be rejected based on the reasons outlined on page 51 of the Agenda pack as detailed below:
Said10 May 2023Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land noth of swallowtale, achnagoul, inveraray (ref: 23/0003/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that he remained of the view that this application should be rejected for the reasons previously outlined.
Moved19 Apr 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a street trader licence (n judson, salen, aros, isle of mull)
Moved by Councillor Graham Hardie, seconded by Councillor Fiona Howard.
Said22 Mar 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (k hail, bonhill, alexandria)
Councillor Hardie commented that he was quite surprised when he recently travelled through Helensburgh to see a queue of people waiting at the main taxi rank at Helensburgh Central station with no sign of any taxis. He said that he believed there was a shortage of taxis in the town especially at the weekends when it was busy.
Said22 Mar 2023Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a street trader licence (n judson, salen, aros, isle of mull)
Councillor Hardie advised that as there were 10 “spent” convictions he thought it was essential that the Committee hear about them.
Said14 Mar 2023Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Public Question Time
Councillor Hardie advised that the Audit and Scrutiny Committee ,of which he is a Member, are currently conducting a scrutiny review in relation to consultation processes. He advised that he would be keen to hear from [name removed] on her experiences which he could then input into the scrutiny review.
Named14 Mar 2023Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Appointment to Glasgow Airport Consultative Committee
Decision The Helensburgh and Lomond Area Committee appointed Councillor Graham Hardie as the Council representative on the Glasgow Airport Consultative Committee.
Asked17 Aug 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (c fox, oban)
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Hardie asked if there had been an influx of tourists to Oban this summer since the Covid restrictions had been lifted. [name removed] said there had definitely been an increase in the past year. He advised that as a whole, people he had spoken to, particularly tourists, were having difficulty finding accommodation in town with a lot of people staying out with, as far as Ledaig , which was 10 to 15 miles away from Oban.
Asked17 Aug 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: applicant for grant of a taxi car licence (j young, dunbeg, oban)
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Hardie asked the Solicitor if she could confirm the number of Taxi Car Licences in the Oban area since the LSVA survey had taken place. [name removed] confirmed that at the time of the survey there had been 42 Taxi Car Licences in the Oban, Lorn and the Isles area. She advised that there were currently 38.
Asked17 Aug 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (s mcintyre-stewart, garelochhead)
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Graham Hardie enquired as to whether there had been an increase in business following the recent rail disruptions. [name removed] advised that there had been an increase. He explained that people seem to be able to get to Helensburgh but were experiencing difficulties in getting home at the end of the day, and this had led to a number of taxis being away from the area for long periods of time, leaving a gap at the rank, particularly in the evening.
Said17 Aug 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (s mcintyre-stewart, garelochhead)
Councillor Hardie, noting that he was a Councillor in the Helensburgh area, agreed with Councillor Green’s comments and advised that he would be happy to grant the application.
Declared30 Jun 2022Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Declarations of interest
Councillor Hardie declared a non-financial interest, by virtue of knowing the Applicant personally. He left the meeting at this point and took no further part in discussions.
Said22 Jun 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for renewal of taxi driver licence number 2810 (a mathieson, campbeltown)
Councillor Hardie said he appreciated [name removed] honesty in declaring these offences on his application form. He commended [name removed] for that and confirmed that he would support his application.
Declared22 Jun 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Graham Hardie declared a non-financial interest in this application as he knew the Applicant personally. He left the meeting and took no part in the determination of this application.
Seconded22 Jun 2022Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Scottish sea farms ltd: modification of fin fish farm (atlantic salmon) from 9 x 80m circumference cages to 14 x 100m circumference cages, including increasing biomass to 2350 tonnes and installation of replacement feed barge: dunstaffnage fish farm, north of ganavan hill, dunbeg (ref: 20/02358/mff)
Moved by Councillor Kieron Green, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie.
Seconded14 Jun 2022Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Appointments to Outside Organisations
Councillor Corry was proposed by Councillor Mulvaney, seconded by Councillor Hardie.
Named19 May 2022Argyll and Bute Council
Political management arrangements
· Bute and Cowal - invites nominations from the Opposition groups (Cllr Audrey Forrest) · Helensburgh and Lomond - Cllr Graham Hardie · Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands - invites nominations from the Opposition groups (Cllr Dougie McFadzean) · Oban, Lorn and the Isles - Cllr Amanda Hampsey Agrees that Cllr Robin Currie and Cllr John McAlpine will join the CPP Management Committee.
Named19 May 2022Argyll and Bute Council
Appointments of outside bodies
Amendment To accept the Motion by Councillor Robin Currie, seconded by Councillor Gary Mulvaney, subject to amending the appointments of the following outside bodies – NHS Highland Board – substitute Cllr Garret Corner for Cllr Dougie Philand Argyll and Bute Renewables Alliance (ABRA) – substitute Cllr Robin Currie for Cllr Mark Irvine Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority Board – substitute Cllr Graham Hardie for Cllr Iain Shonny Paterson Moved by Councillor Jim Lynch seconded by Councillor Mark Irvine.
Said21 Mar 2022Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land south west of letrualt farmhouse, letrualt farm lane, rhu, g84 (ref: 21/0007/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that the site visit had helped him to clarify his decision on the application before him. He said he felt the road issues that the Roads Officer had identified in both her report and at the site, could be suitably and satisfactorily addressed by conditions; however with regard to the green belt, he said he got a much clearer understanding of the issue as raised by the Planners at the site visit. He advised that the fact that the green belt boundaries at Letrualt Farm in the proposed LDP2 were different from those in the adopted LDP 2015, and as this change has been specifically objected to, this meant that this element of the proposed LDP2 could not be given weight as a material consideration in relation to the current application.
Seconded21 Mar 2022Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land south west of letrualt farmhouse, letrualt farm lane, rhu, g84 (ref: 21/0007/lrb)
This was seconded by Councillor Hardie and also supported by Councillor Forrest.
Said10 Mar 2022Community Services Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Graham Hardie noted in relation to item 6 (Argyll & Bute HSCP – Performance Report January 2022) on the Agenda that he was appointed to the role of non-Executive Member of NHS Highland Board by the Council. Having taken note of the updated Standards Commission Guidance in relation to declarations (issued on 7 December 2021) with specific reference to section 5.4(c) he did not consider that he had a relevant connection and as such would remain the meeting and speak and vote on this report.
Declared24 Feb 2022Argyll and Bute Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Hardie declared a non-financial interest in item 5 of the Agenda (Budgeting Pack 2022/23) by virtue of his appointment by the Council to the NHS Highland Board and Live Argyll Board. He advised that with reference to the Standards Commission Guidance in relation to declarations and specifically Section 5.4 (c) of the Councillors Code of Conduct he did not consider he had a relevant connection and as such would remain in the meeting and speak and vote on this item of Business.
Said9 Feb 2022Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land south west of letrualt farmhouse, letrualt farm lane, rhu, g84 (ref: 21/0007/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that he would like to have a site visit so that he could view the private road access and the green belt boundary.
Said16 Dec 2021Community Services Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Graham Hardie noted in relation to item 7 (Argyll & Bute HSCP – Performance Report) and item 8 (Argyll & Bute HSCP Annual Performance Report 2020/21) on the Agenda that he was appointed to the role of non-Executive Member of NHS Highland Board by the Council. Having taken note of the updated Standards Commission Guidance in relation to declarations (issued on 7 December 2021) with specific reference to section 5.4(c) he did not consider that he had a relevant connection and as such would remain the meeting and speak and vote on these reports.
Named6 Dec 2021Community Council Conduct Review Panel
Appointment of chair
It was unanimously agreed to appoint Councillor Graham Hardie as Chair of this Conduct Review Panel.
Named6 Dec 2021Community Council Conduct Review Panel
Tarbert and skipness community council - complaint referral
Having assumed the role of Chair, Councillor Hardie invited the Governance Manager to outline the procedure that would be followed. He then advised that the first task was to establish whether members of the Panel had sufficient information before them to discuss and determine the subject of the complaint. The Panel agreed that they had sufficient information to determine the complaint referral before them.
Declared25 Aug 2021Community Services Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie declared a non-financial interest in the report dealt with at item 6 on the Agenda (Argyll & Bute HSCP – Performance Report June 2021) as he was appointed to the role of non-Executive Member with NHS Highland by the Council.
Declared25 Aug 2021Community Services Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Hardie also declared a non-financial interest in the reports dealt with item 7a on the Agenda (Live Argyll – Monitoring and Performance Reporting – Update Report) and 7b on the Agenda (Live Argyll Annual Report 2020/21) as he was appointed to the Board of Live Argyll by the Council.
Named25 Aug 2021Community Services Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Hardie claimed the benefit of the dispensation contained at Section 5.18(2) of the Councillors Code of Conduct to enable him to remain in the meeting and speak and vote on these reports.
Named19 Aug 2021Helensburgh and Lomond Area Community Planning Group
Welcome and apologies
Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie;
Said18 Aug 2021Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver's licence (no. 6206) (d collier, dunoon)
DEBATE Councillor Hardie advised that if the Chief Constable was calling for the immediate suspension of the licence he trusted the judgement of the Chief Constable and thought that the Committee should suspend the licence.
Seconded23 Jun 2021Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Mr campbell mackellar: erection of two industrial units for class 4 business: mull of kintyre industrial estate, albyn road, campbeltown (ref: 21/00700/pp)
Moved by Councillor Rory Colville, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie.
Seconded17 Jun 2021Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land ne of kildonald cottage, campbeltown (ref: 21/0001/lrb)
This Motion was seconded by Councillor Hardie and also supported by Councillor McCuish.
Said17 Jun 2021Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land ne of kildonald cottage, campbeltown (ref: 21/0001/lrb)
Councillor Hardie said that this was his original decision at the first meeting and so he was happy to support this decision today.
Asked17 Jun 2021Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Public Question Time
Councillor Hardie asked if it may be useful for signs to be in place around Helensburgh asking people to take their litter home if the bins were full, as had been utilised in the National Park. [name removed] advised that a lot of people travelling to the area were coming by train or car and were reluctant to take rubbish with them, noting that ideally people would take their rubbish home with them but in catering to tourists coming to the area it would be more beneficial to have an increased provision of suitable places to dispose of litter available.
Said11 May 2021Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land ne of kildonald cottage, campbeltown (ref: 21/0001/lrb)
Councillor Hardie confirmed that he had enough information before him.
Said11 May 2021Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land ne of kildonald cottage, campbeltown (ref: 21/0001/lrb)
Councillor Hardie confirmed that having reviewed all the information before him he had come to the conclusion that the proposal should be rejected for the reasons detailed on page 18 of the Agenda Pack, section R which stated “ The proposal is not consistent with the relevant provisions of the Local Development Plan regarding siting within the Countryside Zone and an Area of Panoramic Quality contrary to policies LDP DM1, LDP STRAT 1 and LDP 3. The application does not meet the criteria set out in policy LDP DM 1 for housing in the countryside as the site is not infill or rounding off.
Named11 May 2021Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: land ne of kildonald cottage, campbeltown (ref: 21/0001/lrb)
There are no material considerations which warrant departure from these provisions.” Councillor Kinniburgh acknowledged that the information contained within the planning report could lead Councillor Hardie to that conclusion. However, he advised that following receipt of the further information which he would like to request, he believed that some of these aspects may provide the LRB with material considerations which would allow for a departure to the provisions of the Local Development Plan.
Named15 Apr 2021Argyll and Bute Council
Political management arrangements
Appointed Councillor Graham Hardie to the Licensing Board.
Asked17 Mar 2021Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (no. 5977) (r graham, campbeltown)
Councillor Hardie sought and received confirmation that 2 of the charges against [name removed] were under Section 38 of the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010 – breach of the peace aggravated by sexual orientation. Sgt McGinnis explained that this was when there was threatening or abusive behaviour by way of making reference to someone’s sexual orientation and that it became a hate crime.
Declared25 Feb 2021Argyll and Bute Council
Declarations of interest
Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie declared a non-financial interest in item 5 of the Agenda (Budgeting Pack 2021/22) by virtue of his appointment by the Council to the Live Argyll Board. He claimed the dispensation contained at Section 5.18 (2) of the Councillors Code of Conduct to allow him to remain in the meeting and to speak and vote on this item of Business.
Named20 Jan 2021Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for renewal of taxi driver licence number 5890 (j cameron, dunoon)
Councillor Hardie referred to [name removed] paying for the insurance policy and asked [name removed] if he was no longer insured, had he not noticed that money was no longer coming out of his bank account. [name removed] explained that he continued to pay the insurance payments not realising his car had been taken off the multi car insurance policy. He advised that all notifications in respect of the policy were sent to his ex-partner as she had set it up.
Named21 Oct 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Bute island foods ltd: erection of food production facility and associated works (revised proposal relative to planning application reference 20/00333/pp to incorporate removal of new access onto barone road, use of existing access onto mea
Motion Amendment Cllr G Blair Cllr R Colville Cllr M J Devon Cllr G Freeman Cllr L Douglas Cllr G A Hardie Cllr A Forrest Cllr D Kinniburgh Cllr R McCuish Cllr D MacMillan Cllr J Moffat Cllr S Taylor Cllr R Trail The Motion was carried by 8 votes to 5 and the Committee resolved accordingly.
Named21 Oct 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Bute island foods ltd: erection of food production facility and associated works (revised proposal relative to planning application reference 20/00333/pp to incorporate removal of new access onto barone road, use of existing access onto mea
Motion Amendment Cllr R Colville Cllr G Blair Cllr G Freeman Cllr M J Devon Cllr G A Hardie Cllr L Douglas Cllr D Kinniburgh Cllr A Forrest Cllr D MacMillan Cllr J Moffat Cllr R McCuish Cllr S Taylor Cllr R Trail The Motion was carried by 8 votes to 5 and the Committee resolved accordingly.
Named23 Sep 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
D hill property ltd: residential development comprising 101 dwellinghouses including formation of vehicular accesses, landscaping, open space and play areas: land west of alexander street, dunoon (ref: 19/01456/pp)
A vote was taken by calling the roll and Members voted as follows – Motion Amendment Councillor Rory Colville Councillor Mary Jean Devon Councillor George Freeman Councillor Lorna Douglas Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie Councillor Audrey Forrest Councillor David Kinniburgh Councillor Jean Moffat Councillor Donald MacMillan Councillor Sandy Taylor Councillor Alistair Redman Councillor Richard Trail The Motion was carried by 7 votes to 5 and the Committee resolved accordingly.
Named23 Sep 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
John rapallini: variation of condition 2 relative to planning permission reference 17/01756/pp to extend permitted opening hours to beer garden: clyde bar, 62 west clyde street, helensburgh (ref: 20/01028/pp)
Moved Councillor Rory Colville, seconded Councillor Graham Hardie.
Seconded23 Sep 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
John rapallini: variation of condition 2 relative to planning permission reference 17/01756/pp to extend permitted opening hours to beer garden: clyde bar, 62 west clyde street, helensburgh (ref: 20/01028/pp)
Decision The Committee agreed to refuse planning permission for the reasons outlined within the amendment by Councillor Rory Colville, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie.
Named23 Sep 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Indicative regional spatial strategy
The vote was taken by calling the roll and Members voted as follows – Motion Amendment Councillor Rory Colville Councillor Lorna Douglas Councillor Audrey Forrest Councillor George Freeman Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie Councillor Jean Moffat Councillor David Kinniburgh Councillor Donald MacMillan Councillor Alistair Redman Councillor Sandy Taylor Councillor Richard Trail.
Said23 Sep 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (no. 4274) (d macintyre, oban)
Councillor Hardie agreed with Councillor Devon and advised he shared Councillor Blair’s concerns. He advised that he would be inclined to suspend the licence on the back of the request by the Police. [name removed] advised that the role of the Police was to be a complainer and that they were required to make a case to the Committee to back up the complaint.
Named21 Aug 2020Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: erection of dwellinghouse at land at huf haus, balmory road, ascog, isle of bute (ref: 20/0010/lrb)
Both Councillor Hardie and Councillor Redman agreed that they had.
Said21 Aug 2020Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: erection of dwellinghouse at land at huf haus, balmory road, ascog, isle of bute (ref: 20/0010/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that having considered all evidence he was in agreement with the Planning Officer that neither the application nor the proposed exceptional case meets the criteria of the LDP. He advised that on the basis of the conclusion on page 36 of the agenda pack, which he read out, he was minded to refuse the Notice of Review request.
Named21 Aug 2020Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: erection of dwellinghouse at land at huf haus, balmory road, ascog, isle of bute (ref: 20/0010/lrb)
The Chair, Councillor Kinniburgh advised that he too was minded to refuse the request on the same basis as Councillor Hardie that the grounds that neither the application nor the proposed exceptional case met the criteria of the LDP. He advised that he believed that the applicants were aware that the request was against the LDP due to the comments made in their representation at page 49 of the agenda pack that ‘it is relatively easy to justify refusal using the prescribed guidelines’. He had also noted that there had been a study/review undertaken and the designation of the previous ROAs that had been had identified as having no further capacity to absorb new development in the open landscape were re-designated as ‘countryside’.
Seconded21 Aug 2020Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: erection of dwellinghouse at land at huf haus, balmory road, ascog, isle of bute (ref: 20/0010/lrb)
This was seconded by Councillor Hardie.
Named19 Aug 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Mr pelham olive: erection of 12 dwellinghouses, alterations to vehicular access and installation of private drainage system: land east of lochside, portincaple (ref: 20/00094/pp)
Motion Amendment Cllr R Currie Cllr R Colville Cllr M J Devon Cllr G A Hardie Cllr L Douglas Cllr D Kinniburgh Cllr A Forrest Cllr R McCuish Cllr G Freeman Cllr A Redman Cllr J Moffat Cllr S Taylor Cllr R Trail The Amendment was carried by 7 votes to 6 and the Committee resolved accordingly.
Moved19 Aug 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
John rapallini: variation of condition 2 relative to planning permission reference 17/01756/pp to extend permitted opening hours to beer garden: clyde bar, 62 west clyde street, helensburgh (ref: 20/01028/pp)
Moved by Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie, seconded by Councillor Sandy Taylor A vote was taken by calling the roll.
Named19 Aug 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
John rapallini: variation of condition 2 relative to planning permission reference 17/01756/pp to extend permitted opening hours to beer garden: clyde bar, 62 west clyde street, helensburgh (ref: 20/01028/pp)
Motion Amendment 1 Amendment 2 Cllr R Currie Cllr R Colville Cllr G A Hardie Cllr G Freeman Cllr A Forrest Cllr S Taylor Cllr D Kinniburgh Cllr R McCuish Cllr A Redman Cllr J Moffat On there being an equality of votes for the Motion and Amendment 1, Amendment 2 was dropped and a further vote was taken between the Motion and Amendment 1.
Named19 Aug 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Pre-determination planning hearing arrangements during covid-19 response period
Motion Amendment Cllr R Colville Cllr G Freeman Cllr R Currie Cllr A Redman Cllr L Douglas Cllr A Forrest Cllr G A Hardie Cllr D Kinniburgh Cllr R McCuish Cllr J Moffat Cllr S Taylor Cllr R Trail The Motion was carried by 10 votes to 2 and the Committee resolved accordingly.
Named19 Aug 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Mr pelham olive: erection of 12 dwellinghouses, alterations to vehicular access and installation of private drainage system: land east of lochside, portincaple (ref: 20/00094/pp)
Motion Amendment Cllr R Colville Cllr L Douglas Cllr R Currie Cllr G Freeman Cllr A Forrest Cllr J Moffat Cllr G A Hardie Cllr S Taylor Cllr D Kinniburgh Cllr R McCuish Cllr A Redman Cllr R Trail The Motion was carried by 8 votes to 4 and the Committee resolved accordingly.
Said4 Aug 2020Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: anchor cottage, crinan, lochgilphead, pa31 8sw (ref: 20/0009/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that having read all the reports he too felt there was sufficient evidence to make a judgement today.
Said4 Aug 2020Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: anchor cottage, crinan, lochgilphead, pa31 8sw (ref: 20/0009/lrb)
Councillor Hardie advised that having considered all the evidence before him he agreed with the Planning Officer’s recommendation and conclusion and would wish to reject this appeal for the reasons provided in the original Planning report of handling.
Named4 Aug 2020Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: anchor cottage, crinan, lochgilphead, pa31 8sw (ref: 20/0009/lrb)
He advised that for that reason he was inclined to support Councillor Hardie. He commented that in fairness to the Applicant it may be photographic evidence but he had no reason to doubt the Roads Officer’s view that 2 metres from the edge of the road could not be achieved at that location. He said that the only mitigation would be to hold a site visit to confirm that.
Declared24 Jun 2020Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie declared a non-financial interest at item 3 (Helensburgh Waterfront Development (HWD) – Contract Award and Full Business Case) as a Board Member of Live Argyll. He claimed the benefit of the Standards Commission Dispensation as this is a Council appointment and advised that he would remain in the meeting and take part in the discussion and decision.
Named22 Jun 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (no. 4274) (d macintyre, oban)
Motion Amendment Councillor Rory Colville Councillor Gordon Blair Councillor Robin Currie Councillor Lorna Douglas Councillor Mary-Jean Devon Councillor George Freeman Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie Councillor David Kinniburgh Councillor Jean Moffat Councillor Alastair Redman Councillor Sandy Taylor Councillor Richard Trail The Motion was carried by 9 votes to 3 and the Committee resolved accordingly.
Declared17 Jun 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie declared a non-financial interest in item 4 of the Agenda (Planning Application Reference: 19/00253/PP) as his wife knew the Applicant and family. He left the meeting and took no part in the consideration of this application.
Asked19 Feb 2020Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi driver's licence (s fox, oban)
Councillor Hardie sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that before and after his conviction he has worked at Sanda Quarry.
Said19 Jun 2019Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi operator licence (j strachan, oban)
Councillor Hardie advised that he had been speaking to his colleague Councillor Devon who had advised that she felt there were not enough wheelchair accessible vehicles in Oban. He pointed out that there had been no objections to this application and confirmed that he had no hesitation in approving the application.
Said19 Jun 2019Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of private hire car operator licence (islay tuk tuk limited, london)
Councillor Hardie pointed out that the objector painted a different picture regarding demand for taxis on Islay and he asked [name removed] to comment. [name removed] said that he has used this taxi business before and was charged £25 to travel from his home to Port Ellen. He advised that another taxi business charged £15 for the same journey and he suggested that perhaps the objector’s pricing was the reason for a lack of demand for his service.
Asked3 Jun 2019Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (no. 3735) (w tucker, innellan, dunoon)
Councillor Hardie sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he had previously been a taxi driver for Inverclyde for 10 years and that he was now a taxi driver for Argyll and Bute and has held this licence for 19 years.
Said8 Feb 2019Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
Consider notice of review request: 18/0007/lrb - plot 2, land north west of ashlea, croft drive, oban
The Chair asked members for their views and Councillor Hardie said he believed the planning decision was correct to refuse this as overdevelopment and so he was minded to refuse the application on the same grounds as the original decision.
Declared21 Jun 2018Helensburgh & Lomond Area Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Hardie declared a non-financial interest in relation to item 17 Helensburgh Waterfront Development because he is a Board member of Live Argyll, he claimed the benefit of the dispensation contained at Section 5.16 of the Standard’s Commission Guidance and dispensation note to enable him to speak and vote. He also advised that he would take no part in the PPSL Committee consideration on this matter.
Seconded16 May 2018Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Taylor wimpey, west scotland: erection of 4 dwellinghouses: former hermitage academy (land in between school house and turnbull pavilion), redgauntlet road, helensburgh (ref: 18/00354/pp)
Moved by Councillor George Freeman, seconded by Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie By a show of hands vote the Motion was carried by 9 votes to 4 and the Committee resolved accordingly.
Asked16 May 2018Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi driver's licence (j berry, dumbarton)
Councillor Hardie asked [name removed] if he had any evidence that there was an economic downturn in Helensburgh. [name removed] said that there was plenty of evidence but he did not have any in front of him. He pointed out that the latest census had indicated a drop in the population and he advised that the expansion of the Faslane Naval Base was a number of years away.
Named26 Apr 2018Argyll and Bute Council
Apologies for absence
The Provost offered the Councils congratulations to Councillor Hardie on his recent marriage and wished him all the best for the future.
Seconded5 Apr 2018Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Pre-determination hearing - mr graham macqueen: erection of recreational hut (retrospective): land approximately 830 metres northeast of atlantic bridge, clachan seil (ref: 17/02438/pp)
Moved by Councillor Robin Currie, seconded by Councillor Graham Archibald Hardie.
Said21 Mar 2018Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee
Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of private hire car operator licence (glasgow coach drivers limited, glasgow)
Councillor Hardie agreed with Councillor Trail. He said that he admired the Applicant’s entrepreneurship.
Said8 Feb 2018Argyll and Bute Local Review Body
CONSIDER NOTICE OF REVIEW REQUEST: Erection of dwelling-house, installation of sceptic tank and soakaway and formation of vehicular access at land North of North Craigruadh, Tayinloan, Argyll, PA29 6XF
Councillor Hardie agreed that a site visit would be beneficial to obtain a better view of the suburbanisation of an urban area as outlined in the reasons for refusal.
Named18 May 2017Argyll and Bute Council
Appointments to outside bodies
Cttee Cllr Robin Currie PA23BID Board Cllr Jim Anderson Argyll and Bute Local Biodiversity Partnership Cllr Rory Colville Argyll, Lomond and the Islands Energy Agency Mgt Board Cllr Robin Currie, Cllr Jim Findlay Argyll and Bute Renewables Alliance Cllr Aileen Morton Argyll and Bute Agriculture Forum Cllr Jamie McGrigor , Cllr John Armour Argyll and the Isles Coast and Countryside Trust Cllr Jamie McGrigor Argyll and the Isles Strategic Tourism Partnership Cllr Aileen Morton KIMO ( Kommuners International Kiljorganisation ) Cllr Jean Moffat Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority Board Cllr Ellen Morton, Cllr Barbara Morgan Scottish Liaison Group on Radioactive Waste Management Cllr Jamie McGrigor Scottish Councils Committee on Radioactive Substances Cllr Alastair Redman West of Scotland Archaeology Service Joint Committee Cllr Alastair Redman, one sub TBC Argyll and Bute Economic Forum Cllrs Aileen Morton, Gary Mulvaney A83 Taskforce Cllr Roddy McCuish , Cllr Ellen Morton, Cllr Bobby Good, Cllr Donald Kelly Argyll and Bute Care and Repair Agency Cllr Robin Currie, Cllr Elaine Robertson Fyne Homes Group Cllr Len Scoullar Argyll Community Housing Association Cllr Donnie MacMillan Cllr Roddy McCuish Cllr Iain Paterson Convention of the Highlands and Islands Cllr Aileen Morton Programme Monitoring Committee Cllr Aileen Morton Scottish Islands Federation Cllr Robin Currie, Cllr Anne Horn Islands Strategic Group Cllr Aileen Morton Scottish Government Forum Against Po
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.