Political management arrangements
Appoints Cllr Jan Brown as Provost of Argyll and Bute;
Every time Argyll and Bute's minutes name Councillor Brown, as the council published it.
Appoints Cllr Jan Brown as Provost of Argyll and Bute;
Appoints Cllr Jan Brown to the Policy and Resources Committee;
As the meeting was being held on a hybrid basis, the vote required to be taken by calling the roll, and Members voted as follows – Motion Amendment No Vote Cllr Armour Cllr Corner Cllr A Hampsey Cllr Blair Cllr Corry Cllr D Hampsey Cllr Brown Cllr McCabe Cllr Campbell-Sturgess Cllr Mulvaney Cllr Green Cllr Penfold Cllr Horn Cllr Redman Cllr Howard Cllr Vennard Cllr Hume Cllr Wallace Cllr Irvine Cllr Kain Cllr Kennedy Cllr Kennedy-Boyle Cllr Martin Cllr MacQuire Cllr McFadzean Cllr Moreland Cllr Paterson Cllr Sinclair Decision The Motion was carried by 18 votes to 8 votes, with 2 no votes, and the Council appointed Councillor Jan Brown as Provost of Argyll and Bute.
Councillor Brown referred to the first reason for refusal of the planning application and advised that having read through the paperwork provided, she said the photographs did not show enough of the site area. She said she would like to see what development there was in the surrounding area and that she would also like more information on what was meant by ribbon development.
Councillor Green sought and received confirmation from Councillor Brown that she would like to request this further information from the Planning Officer and that it would be helpful to receive photographs and a plan showing where the proposed development would be in context with other settlements up to a mile away with an explanation why this could lead to ribbon development.
Councillor Brown said it would be helpful to see where the other houses were and why this development could not be included with them.
Moved by Councillor Jan Brown, seconded by Councillor Jim Lynch.
Considers and approves that the revised proposed Visitor levy Scheme goes out to a formal 12-week consultation Moved by Councillor Jan Brown, seconded by Councillor Ross Moreland.
Councillor Brown asked the Applicant if she would have a property manager in the vicinity. [name removed] responded that she had a manager who lived minutes away from the property and would meet and greet the visitors and that she herself would also be contactable. [name removed] confirmed that she was also willing to let the neighbours have the contact details for the manager and herself.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he would like to join the family business and also provide an income for himself out with the family business. He advised that he planned to work for himself from the taxi rank and assist the family business through the telephone calls they received. He confirmed that the family business only operated through telephone calls.
Councillor Brown said she had no issues with this application and that she would be happy to approve the licence. The Chair sought and received confirmation from all the Members of the Committee that they would like to grant this application. DECISION The Committee unanimously agreed to grant a Taxi Car Licence to [name removed] and noted that he would receive written confirmation of this within 7 days.
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Brown noted that [name removed] had indicated in her application form that she would be available to work 7 days a week from 8.00 am to 8.00 pm.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that she believed there was a need for taxi drivers during these times in Oban. [name removed] advised that she would be happy to sit at the rank and put these hours in. She said that at the moment she worked 7.00 am – 5.00 pm and was not given the opportunity to work in the evenings.
Councillor Brown agreed with her fellow Councillors. She said it was nice to hear someone was keen to drive a taxi around in Oban and she wished the Applicant all the best. DECISION The Committee unanimously agreed to grant a Taxi Car Licence to [name removed] and noted that she would receive written confirmation of this within 7 days.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he would do a mix of day and night work up to 40 hours a week.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that the problem he experienced with his shoulder would not affect his driving. He commented that if he had an operation it would take up to 9 months to recover if he wished to continue as a window cleaner. He advised that he would only need 6 – 8 weeks recovery time to enable him to drive.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that she would advertise her business on Facebook on the Information Oban page. She advised that coming from the islands she knew of family and friends who regularly required taxis early in the morning and so she felt she would be of help there.
Councillor Jan Brown advised that the application in respect of High Brenfield Wind Farm was within her Ward area. She advised that she has had no involvement in this application and that she would remain in the meeting and take part the consideration of this report which is dealt with at Item 6 of this Minute.
Councillor Brown said she had a number of questions regarding the roads issue and about the actual site itself, which used to be a builder’s yard but was no longer there and had not been commissioned for some time. She questioned whether the Applicant had issues now with accessing the site and if there were currently any issues experienced by service vehicles using the road. She said that she was of a mind to support the reason for refusal.
He said he was mindful of Councillor Brown looking for more information and before he and Councillor Hardie moved to make a decision on the application without Councillor Brown have the opportunity of obtaining this further information, he asked Councillor Brown if she would want to make any further comment in support of obtaining further information.
Councillor Brown said that she had just been looking for further information purely for clarification purposes. She agreed that the paperwork provided was very comprehensive and that she believed the objections were valid. She acknowledged that there were a lot more cars on the roads and that she had just wondered if anyone had difficulty with the Applicant using the road at the moment and if there were issues for service vehicles accessing the road.
Councillor Brown said she supported the view put forward by Councillor Hardie .
Councillor Brown advised that she thought the site inspection had been really helpful. She said it was good to see what it looked like and she noted that it was on the hill side rather than the field below it. She advised that she felt that the LRB had to be mindful of SEPA’s holding objection.
Appendix A ARGYLL AND BUTE LOCAL REVIEW BODY NOTE OF MEETING OF SITE INSPECTION RE CASE 25/0008/LRB LAND SOUTH EAST OF ELDERSLIE, OBAN WEDNESDAY 8 OCTOBER 2025 In attendance Councillor Gordon Blair, Argyll and Bute LRB (Chair) Councillor Jan Brown, Argyll and Bute LRB Councillor Fiona Howard, Argyll and Bute LRB Fiona Scott, Planning Officer Graham MacEachen, Applicant Iain Jackson, Governance, Risk and Safety Manager (Adviser Fiona McCallum, Committee Services Officer (Minutes) The Argyll and Bute Local Review Body (LRB) agreed on 8 September 2025 to conduct an accompanied site inspection. The purpose of the site inspection was to view the layout and location of the site in order to determine what the flooding issues were.
Councillor Brown said that she would welcome a site visit to see what was being talked about here. She advised that she appreciated all the submissions that had been made from Planning, SEPA and the Council’s Flooding Adviser, but would like to view the layout and location of the site.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that [name removed] was applying for a Street Trader’s Licence for his current employment. He advised that the business was looking to grow with vans sited in multiple locations. They were looking to invest in [name removed] so that he could manage food and trade from one of these vans.
Councillor Brown asked [name removed] if he could explain his circumstances at the time of the offences. [name removed] advised that there were reasons for his past mistakes. He said he was drinking heavily and that it was not a good time for him.
Councillor Brown referred to [name removed] advising earlier that there were plans to work in various locations across Campbeltown, but he was now saying that [name removed] would work at the one location. [name removed] explained that [name removed] would work in one location and that the business was looking to expand with more vans which would lead to more workers each with their own street trader’s licence.
Moved by Councillor Amanda Hampsey , seconded by Councillor Jan Brown.
Councillor Brown agreed that the site visit had been very good.
Councillor Brown referred to [name removed] concerns about the bins and sought reassurance from [name removed] that his concerns would be addressed. [name removed] advised that she had noted [name removed] response and advised that she’d had no previous knowledge of these issues happening in the past. She said that [name removed] could have contacted her direct at the time but that he never had.
Councillor Brown asked [name removed] what procedures would be put in place to prevent these issues arising in the future. [name removed] confirmed that she had been in touch with the Council about receiving labels to put on the bins and she was advised that this service was only available to business that paid non-domestic rates. [name removed] confirmed that she would arrange to label the bins herself so that guests would know which bin and recycling box belonged to Flat 1/3.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he was still with his partner.
Councillor Brown said the offences were quite serious, especially the first one. She asked if alcohol was involved. [name removed] said there was.
Councillor Brown commented that [name removed] did not appear to be apologetic about the incidents and that he did not appear to be professional in his private life. She asked [name removed] if he was a Jekyll and Hyde character, a different person in private to what he was at work. [name removed] said this was not the case.
This Motion was unanimously supported by Councillor Brown and Councillor McCabe.
Moved by Councillor Jan Brown, seconded by Councillor Fiona Howard.
Councillor Brown advised that she would like to see the site with the Roads Officer in attendance so that they could explain the issues they had with this proposed development.
Councillor Jan Brown advised that she knew Community Councillor Michael Russell but did not consider that she had a relevant connection which would affect her decision making and as such would remain in the meeting.
Councillor Brown asked if the notification for the meeting on 10 June 2024 had been advertised on the community noticeboards and [name removed] advised that it had been, but not in sufficient time as prescribed by the Standing Orders.
Councillor Brown then asked if the Community Council had an email contact list which [name removed] stated they did not, but they would consider utilising that method of communication.
Councillor Brown stated that she was familiar with the areas where the noticeboards were situated and enquired why a Community Councillor could not place the notices. [name removed] advised that they recognised that some critical administrative duties were lacking and it was one of the reasons they would be employing a secretary.
Councillor Brown enquired if the paperwork for the next meeting had been placed ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Councillor Brown agreed with Councillor Armour and said that due to no one saying that the Committee were over providing cars in the area, she would be happy to approve this application.
Councillor Brown said she felt the onus should be on the applicant to ensure due diligence in respect of making sure title deeds supported the proposal.
Councillor Jan Brown advised that she knew Community Councillor Michael Russell but did not consider that she had a relevant connection which would affect her decision making and as such would remain in the meeting.
Councillor Brown agreed with the statements made by Councillor Hardie and stated she was also minded to refuse the application.
Councillor Brown stated that she felt she had enough information to come to a decision. She advised that she had considered requesting a site visit but now felt it was not necessary due to all the information they have before them.
Councillor Brown stated that she failed to see why they couldn’t leave the condition on as the applicant had stated she did not wish to use the property as a short-term let.
Councillor Wallace seconded that and Councillor Brown confirmed that she was also happy to support that given that planning would be consulted in any future application for a change of use or short-term let licence.
Councillor Brown advised that she had found the site inspection hugely beneficial and had enabled her to see where the proposed development was going to be situated and how it would fit into the wider landscape. She advised that any concerns she may have had around flooding had been dealt with, however the concerns she previously had around the OSPA remained. She advised that while she felt that the proposed development could be accommodated within the OSPA, consideration would require to be given to appropriate conditions if Members were minded to approve the application.
Councillor Kain advised that he agreed with Councillor Brown, however he felt that the concerns being raised in relation to the OSPA were excessive. He advised that he felt that the plans that had been outlined by the Applicant in relation to the landscaping of the land and taking into consideration the comments of the Local Biodiversity Project Officer, gave him reassurance that this would be undertaken in a way that he would be comfortable with.
Having taking cognisance of the views of the other Members of the LRB and the advice provided by [name removed], Councillor Brown moved that in order to give due regard to the possibility of approving the Notice for Review request, the LRB should seek further information from the Planning authority around the process for obtaining a Section 75 Agreement to ensure that the Public Realm enhancements are maintained in perpetuity; seek draft conditions that could be attached to the application should the LRB determine that it is appropriate to approve the Notice of Review request and continue consideration of the request to allow Members time to seek advice on preparing a competent Motion to approve, if they are so minded.
Councillor Brown moved the following Motion, which was seconded by Councillor Hardie – There is a general presumption in favour of development within this area of North Connel, established by current policy but this is qualified by the requirement to ensure that developments accord with the existing and established pattern of development and do not result in an unacceptable environmental, servicing or access impact, with an overwhelming emphasis on respecting the character and setting of the area into which the individual development proposal is to be located, taking account of local spacing, layout, densities, privacy and amenity standards.
(Motion by Councillor Jan Brown, seconded by Councillor Graham Hardie, tabled)
Councillor Brown said that after viewing the site she would like more clarification on the options available to the Local Review Body. She said that she understood the definition of backfill but was not understanding it in the context of this development as it seemed to be a different standard to the other housing developments that they had looked at. The Chair advised that the Local Review Body would require to have another meeting to put forward a proposal to accept the application with conditions attached.
Councillor Hardie advised that he agreed with Councillor Blair and Councillor Brown. [name removed] advised that if the Local Review Body were minded to approve the application they may wish to request model conditions and reasons that could be applied to an approval and seek advice on competent motion to approve the application.
Councillor Brown said that she understood the reasons for backfilling but the site didn’t look like other backfill sites in the area and would like the opportunity to seek to prepare a motion to grant the application.
[name removed] advised that this would be a departure from planning policy and advised Councillor Brown that she would require to consider the position around how that particular site may be acceptable and why she thought the policy did not apply to that site. He advised that she could seek assistance in preparing a Motion once she had formed some ideas around her justification for departure from planning policy. [name removed] explained the timescales around asking for further information in respect of model conditions and reasons.
Councillor Brown sought confirmation that this was planning permission in principle and if approved the applicant would require to apply for full planning permission. [name removed] advised that this would be the case.
Councillors Blair and Hardie advised that they agreed with Councillor Brown seeking the opportunity to prepare a motion to approve the application. Decision The Argyll and Bute Local Review Body – 1. agreed to request, from the Planning Authority, model conditions and reasons that could accompany an approval; and 2. agreed to continue consideration of the application to allow for the opportunity to seek to prepare a competent motion to approve the application.
Councillor Jan Brown advised in relation to item 10 of the agenda ( ACHA Stock Restructure Proposals ) that she had been appointed to the ACHA Board by the Council. Having taken note of the Standards Commission Guidance in relation to declarations (issued on 7 December 2021), with specific reference to section 5.4(c), she did not consider that she had a relevant connection and as such would remain in the meeting.
a) Joint Depute Leader – Cllr Ross Moreland b) Vice Chair, Environment, Development, and Infrastructure Committee – Cllr Ross Moreland c) Policy and Resources Committee - Cllr Luna Martin d) Environment, Development, and Infrastructure Committee - Cllr Jan Brown e) Employee Joint Consultative Committee - Cllr Math Campbell-Sturgess f) COSLA Community Wellbeing Board – Cllr Ross Moreland g) COSLA Scottish Joint Council for Local Government Employees - Cllr William Sinclair h) A83 Taskforce - Cllr William Sinclair i) Argyll and Bute Renewables Alliance – Cllr Jim Lynch;
2. noted that Cllr Jan Brown was standing down from the Community Services Committee with immediate effect, leaving a vacancy on that Committee;
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from the Council’s Solicitor that there were currently 50 taxis in the Oban, Lorn and the Isles area. [name removed] pointed out that in respect of the LVSA survey report the Committee had taken the decision in January 2024 to no longer take this survey into consideration in respect of this area. She advised that when the survey was carried out there were 52 taxis in the Oban, Lorn and the Isles area.
DEBATE Councillor Brown advised that she had no issues with this and would be happy to approve the application.
2. to appoint Councillor Jan Brown to the Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands Locality Planning Group;
3. to appoint Councillor Jan Brown to Urras Achadh An Droighinn /The Auchindrain Trust;
4. to appoint Councillor Jan Brown to the Argyll and Bute Renewables Trust (formerly the Windfarm Trust);
Councillor Brown advised that she felt she didn’t have sufficient information before her to come to a decision. She said that it was difficult to picture the backland development referred to by planning specifically as planning permission had been granted for plot 1.
Councillor Hardie agreed with Councillor Brown and said that on reflection some of the arguments made by planning were watertight but advised that he wanted to see how the proposed development was contrary to the row of established representative properties.
Councillor Brown said that she had wanted definition around what was a cluster and what was a settlement, and that her questions had been answered in that there was no definitive definition of a cluster. She advised that following the site visit she did not feel that the house would be part of a cluster as she had observed houses further on from the site that were part of a cluster. She said that she would like an opportunity to prepare a motion to approve planning permission.
Councillor Armour agreed with Councillor Brown adding that the site visit had been very helpful. He referred to having looked at what was further along from the site which looked very much like a cluster and seeing where the proposed building would be, he did not feel that it would be as visible as others in the surrounding area.
He advised that he was minded to agree with Councillor Brown to look to find motion to approve the application.
Councillor Brown agreed saying that the site was set back from the road Decision The Argyll and Bute Local Review Body, as they were minded to grant the application, agreed to continue consideration of the Review to allow for an opportunity to seek to prepare a competent Motion to justify approval of planning permission in principle.
Having noted that Councillor Brown had originally been selected as a member of the Local Review Body to consider the case outlined at agenda item 3 (Consider Notice of Review Request: 50 Charlotte Street, Helensburgh, G84 7SR (Ref: 24/0005/LRB)), the Governance, Risk and Safety Manager advised that Councillor Mark Irvine was in attendance in her place as she was unable to attend due to attending the funeral of Councillor Robin Currie. It was noted that in terms of the process, as advance notice had been given and as the case had not yet been considered by the Local Review Body, that this was an acceptable way of ensuring that the Local Review Body was quorate and the meeting could proceed.
Decision The Council agreed to appoint Councillor Jan Brown to the position of Depute Provost of the Council.
Councillor Brown stated that the applicant had shown great restraint and willingness to be co-operative and to be responsible owners and operators. Happy to support the approval of the licence.
Councillor Brown asked for clarification on how many people could actually sleep in the property as the application stated that there were 3 double beds, plus a double bedroom which amounts to 8 persons that could sleep there. The applicant advised that there was also a sofa bed in the living room area which would sleep 2.
Councillor Brown also asked where the notices were displayed and where the applicant was based in relation to the Old Mill. The applicant advised that Notices were displayed on the front gate of the property and that he lives in Balloch.
Councillor Brown asked the applicant’s agent how many properties they managed. [name removed] responded that they manage 83 properties.
Councillor Brown advised that she did have some concerns regarding noise, but will support the approval of the licence as long at the applicant carries out resolving any issues as he has said.
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Brown asked if in the last 5 years that the flat has operated as an Air BnB if any mail has went missing or has there been any anti-social behaviour. Applicants responded that nothing has ever been raised to them. Objector responded by advising that an item was stolen from an outside shed but it was difficult to know if any mail had went missing.
Councillor Brown asked the objector if he knew if the theft related to the short term let. He did not know.
Councillor Brown asked both applicant and objector if there had been a discussion around installation of a secure mail box. The applicants stated that they had offered to arrange for a door to be put on the mail box to secure it, however, there are often parcels left outside the property.
Councillor Brown advised that she had a number of questions for the Planning Authority around development clusters. She said that she was not sure if the houses referred to in the agenda pack were all in one cluster and said that she would like to know how many houses qualif ied as a cluster.
Councillor Brown referred to the p ictures in the agenda pack from both the applicant and the Plann ing Authority and advised that she had difficulty visualising from these pictures why the Planning Authority h ad refused the application on spatial grounds .
Councillor Brown advised she w ould like site visit to see how the development clusters fit into the surrounding area.
Councillor Armour agreed with Councillor Brown and said he felt a site visit was essential; adding that he would need to see the development clusters on the ground to understand fully. He advised that t he only way to make a fair decision would be to have a site visit.
Councillor Brown noted that the property was a sit in restaurant as well as a take-away and asked if the restaurant closed earlier than the take-away. The Applicant advised that the restaurant has facilities for 12 individuals to sit in and that there is no toilet in situ. Last orders are taken at 10.30pm and in the event that the Late Hours Catering Licence is granted then restaurant orders would be up until 10.30pm and thereafter take-away only.
Councillor Brown looked for clarification that the Applicant already had a taxi driver licence and was only applying for a taxi operator licence. This was confirmed by [name removed].
DEBATE Councillor Brown said that [name removed] had taken a number of precautions and the matter of anti-social behaviour very seriously, adding that as the Objector had not come along to air his grievances she was minded to recommend that the licence be granted.
Councillor McCabe agreed with Councillor Brown and wished [name removed] luck.
Councillor Brown enquired how the Applicant policies the use of kayaks and water sports, ensuring that guests have brought their own lifejackets and buoyancy aids. [name removed] advised that kayaks were locked in sheds and only made available when it was clear that appropriate provisions had been met. He advised that safety was paramount and that this was a strict requirement when agreeing what provisions were required.
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Brown sought advice from the Council’s Solicitor as to whether it was pertinent for the Committee to approve this application if they were so minded. [name removed] advised that she was in agreement with the Applicant’s lawyer and that the issue could be pursued in another forum if required. She advised that it would be competent for the Committee to determine the application.
Councillor Brown advised that having heard earlier submissions in relation to the reliance of the Objector on deliveries as the area is so remote, advised that the same could be said of delivery drivers. She further advised that her understanding of the necessity for the gates was to prevent unauthorised access to the track. She asked the Objector, whether in his opinion, the gates would therefore help in maintaining the track.
Councillor Brown confirmed that she too would support the immediate suspension of the licence.
Councillor Brown also agreed with her fellow Councillors.
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he had a taxi driver licence and that he was now applying for his own taxi car licence. [name removed] advised that he would like to work for himself as it would bring him a higher income.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that the car he would use had not been used as a taxi before. He said that the previous vehicle was a Toyota and this was a Ford Focus.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that if this licence was granted he would arrange for his vehicle to be inspected prior to using it and that he would also need to arrange for a meter to be fitted and a taxi sign displayed. SUMMING UP Applicant [name removed] advised that he would be extremely grateful if he was granted this licence as it would be life changing for him. He said that he enjoyed the job and that it would be a full time career for him.
Councillor Brown advised that she would also like to approve the application.
Councillor Brown advised that she had sufficient information to come to a decision on the Review, having had the opportunity to view the development in context of the surrounding area (Note of Site Visit attached as Appendix 1) and having received the additional information as requested. She advised that she intended to move a Motion, as she believed that it would be possible to approve the Review.
Councillor Brown moved the following motion:- The reason for refusal of this application was an objection from the roads department in relation intensification of use of the private road and road safety issues related to that.
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he held 2 Private Hire Licences and wanted to change one of these for a public taxi licence.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he proposed to work from Helenburgh as there was no demand in Garelochhead for a public hire. He advised that over the last couple of years 3 more licences have been issued for the Garelochhead area and he said it was a fact that there was not enough work there, with only the odd person wanting to pre book. He said there was no real need for a public hire there so he planned to mainly work from Helensburgh where a lot of work was generated from the Naval Base.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that there were currently 51 taxi licences in the Helensburgh and Lomond area. She advised that when the LVSA survey was carried out there were 48 taxis and since then 5 have lapsed, 14 have been granted and 6 have been surrendered, bringing the total to 51.
Councillor Brown also agreed with her fellow Councillors and advised that she could see no reason not to permit this licence.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that between their neighbour and the 2 ladies, there would always be someone on call to deal with any issues that may arise. [name removed] said that he would be very surprised if there were any issues as they would carefully vet anyone that would come to stay.
Councillor Brown referred to concerns raised about parking and commented on the photographs supplied in the Agenda pack which showed 2 cars, with one butting out onto the road. [name removed] said that there was plenty of space to park properly off road and manoeuvre safely. He hoped that cars would be parked behind the byre.
Councillor Brown agreed that it would have been good to have heard from the Objectors. She advised that she saw no reason to object to this application.
Councillor Brown advised that she did not feel that she had sufficient information to come to a decision on the Review.
Councillor Brown advised that she’d appreciate further information on the length of the private access track and also whether the Roads officer had taken into consideration the Bed and Breakfast property that was already in operation when making his assessment of the proposed development.
Councillor Brown advised that she would welcome a site visit to view the proposed development in context.
Councillor Jan Brown declared a non-financial interest in agenda item 13 (Supporting Communities Fund 2023/24) on the basis that she works alongside one of the applicants, Community Cycle Ardrishaig . She advised that she did not consider the connection to be significant and as such would remain in the meeting and take part in discussion and decision on this item.
Councillor Brown referred to [name removed] working in Bonhill and running a taxi there. She asked [name removed], if he was granted this licence, would he continue to work in both areas. [name removed] said that he could possibly keep his other licence if he was able to get another driver and, if that was not possible, he would surrender his other licence when it was due for renewal in July.
Moved by Councillor John Armour, seconded by Councillor Jan Brown. Amendment The Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands Area Committee:- 1. agree to Package B as outlined in paragraph 3.3 of the report;
Councillor Brown advised that she would like time to consider the additional comments.
Councillor Brown advised that she was minded to agree with the Planning Officer that the application for Planning Permission be refused, purely down to the size of the building. She advised that the video highlighted the size of the structure in comparison to its surroundings and that in her opinion could not be considered as “like for like” with the previous building that had already been demolished. With this in mind, she advised that she had no option but to refuse the application.
He agreed with Councillor Brown that the building could not be considered as “like for like” with what had previously been in its place, and that reluctantly he found that he could not support the application either.
Councillor Brown referred to part 5 of the application which referred to the ownership of land where the burger van would be sited. She noted that [name removed] had indicated he was not the owner of the land. She sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he had received permission from the land owner via an email.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he had his Food Hygiene certificate from Environmental Health. He advised that there was another couple of courses he would like to do to improve things and that he also had the experience of working in catering vans for 3 or 4 years.
Councillor Brown asked [name removed] what days and times he would operate as this detail was not filled out on the application form. [name removed] said he was not sure yet and that he needed to work out when the best times would be for business. He said he was thinking about working Thursdays – Sundays from 8 am.
Councillor Brown asked [name removed] if the disposal of a suspended prison sentence for 48 weeks and compensation of £1,000 was just for him or if the other person got the same. [name removed] said the other person got a longer suspended sentence of a few more weeks. He did not receive a fine as he was on benefits and that he was given community service.
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Brown referred to [name removed] conviction in 2014 which resulted in him being banned from driving for 6 years. She sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that this ban was lifted in 2020 and that he had only been driving regularly for the past 2 years and that this would be 3 years in April 2023.
Councillor Jan Brown declared a non-financial interest in item 14 of the agenda (Strategic Housing Investment Plan (SHIP) 2023/24 – 2027/28) by virtue of her Council appointment to the Board of ACHA.
Councillor Brown agreed that there was a lot of information in the pack and thought that there was enough information.
Councillor Brown commented that the pictures provided were good but acknowledged that depending on the angle the pictures were taken this could either be beneficial or detrimental to the case.
MEMBERS’ QUESTIONS Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he was 60 years of age and had held a driving licence since he was 18 years old. He also confirmed that he had been driving taxis for 20 years.
Councillor Brown sought and received confirmation from [name removed] that he previously had points on his driving licence for speeding.
Appointment to the Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands Area Community Planning Group Motion To appoint Councillor Armour, Councillor McFadzean and Councillor Brown to the Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands Area Community Planning Group.
Moved by Councillor Armour seconded by Councillor Brown.
Appointment to Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands Locality Planning Group To appoint Councillor Jan Brown to the Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands Locality Planning Group.
· Argyll Community Housing Association - one representative (Cllr Jan Brown) · Live Argyll Board - one representative (Cllr Ian MacQuire ) · Isle of Bute BID Board - one representative (Cllr Reeni Kennedy-Boyle ) · Scottish Islands Federation - one representative (Cllr Dougie McFadzean) · A83 Taskforce - two representatives (Cllrs Ian Paterson and Donald Kelly) · Clyde, Kintyre and the Islands Ferry Stakeholder Group - two representatives (Cllrs John Armour and Dougie McFadzean) · Argyll, Lochaber, Skye and Small Isles Ferry Stakeholder Group - two representatives (Cllrs Jim Lynch and Julie McKenzie) Requests that the Governance team prepare reports for the first meetings of each Area Committee outlining details of area-based outside bodies to which committees may wish to make appointments.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Brown attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 May 2026 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings) | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (c mckay, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Mar 2026 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (e livingstone, taynuilt) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Mar 2026 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (s macintyre, dunbeg, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 18 Mar 2026 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (l marshall, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Aug 2025 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (c lenehan, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 1 May 2025 | Argyll and Bute Local Review Body | Consider notice of review request: glenaros annexe, drummore road, oban, pa34 4jl (ref: 25/0002/lrb) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Apr 2025 | Argyll and Bute Council | Proposal to review the scheme for the establishment of community councils in argyll and bute | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jan 2025 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (c fox, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jan 2025 | Community Council Conduct Review Panel | Appointment of chair | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 19 Jun 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (f pacitti, dunbeg) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (gowanlea, kilchattan bay, isle of bute) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: the civic government (scotland) act 1982 (licensing of short-term lets) order 2022: application for grant of a short term let licence (h kinnaird, luss) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Feb 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982, The Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 (Licensing of Short-term Lets) Order 2022: Application for Grant of a Short Term Let Licence | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Feb 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Mark Watson, Pier Cottage, Glen Striven Estate, Toward, Dunoon | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Feb 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Mark Watson, The Point, Glen Striven Estate, Toward, Dunoon PA23 7UN | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi car licence number 6685 (j macintyre, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (number 6662) (j macintyre, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2024 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (p mcdougall, helensburgh) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Sep 2023 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Aug 2023 | Community Council Conduct Review Panel | Appointment of chair | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Aug 2023 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (currie taxis, alexandria) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 May 2023 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (s mcintyre-stewart, garelochhead) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Mar 2023 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: request for suspension of taxi driver licence (number 6556) (a simpson, dunoon) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Mar 2023 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of taxi car licence (k hail, bonhill, alexandria) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Jan 2023 | Argyll and Bute Local Review Body | Consider notice of review request: the camp, crossapol, isle of tiree, pa77 6up (ref: 22/0002/lrb) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Aug 2022 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (c fox, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Aug 2022 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: applicant for grant of a taxi car licence (j young, dunbeg, oban) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 17 Aug 2022 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (s mcintyre-stewart, garelochhead) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2022 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for renewal of taxi driver licence number 2810 (a mathieson, campbeltown) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 22 Jun 2022 | Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Civic government (scotland) act 1982: application for grant of a taxi car licence (c stroud, ballygrant, islay) | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Brown was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 27 of 46 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Brown declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Jun 2023 | Mid Argyll, Kintyre & the Islands Area Committee, item 2 | Councillor Jan Brown declared a non-financial interest in agenda item 13 (Supporting Communities Fund 2023/24) on the basis that she works alongside one of the applicants, Community Cycle Ardrishaig . She advised that she did not consider the connection to be significant and as such would remain in the meeting and take part in discussion and decision on this item. | |
| 29 Sep 2022 | Argyll and Bute Council, item 2 | Councillor Jan Brown declared a non-financial interest in item 14 of the agenda (Strategic Housing Investment Plan (SHIP) 2023/24 – 2027/28) by virtue of her Council appointment to the Board of ACHA. |
Where Councillor Brown sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee | Member | Jun 2022 | 97 | |
| Argyll and Bute Council | Chair | May 2022 | 22 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Argyll and Bute Licensing Board | Member | Jun 2022 | 16 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Argyll and Bute Local Review Body | Member | Jun 2022 | 13 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Mid Argyll, Kintyre & the Islands Area Committee | Member | Jun 2022 | 11 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Civic Hearings) | Member | May 2026 | 8 | |
| Planning, Protective Services and Licensing Committee (Short-term Let Hearings) | Member | May 2026 | 5 | |
| Budget Pack | Member | Feb 2023 | 4 | |
| Community Services Committee | Member | Jun 2024 | 4 | |
| Argyll and Bute Windfarm and Renewables Trust | Member | Sep 2023 | 2 | |
| Environment, Development and Infrastructure Committee | Member | Jun 2022 | 7 | |
| Community Council Conduct Review Panel | Member | Aug 2023 | 3 | |
| Mid Argyll, Kintyre and the Islands Area Community Planning Group | Member | May 2024 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.