Jos/25/12 to confirm the minutes of the joint meeting held on 18 september 2025
41.1 Councillor Caston proposed that the minutes of the meeting be confirmed and signed as a true record, which was seconded by Councillor Scarff.
Every time Babergh & Mid Suffolk's minutes name Councillor Caston, as the council published it.
41.1 Councillor Caston proposed that the minutes of the meeting be confirmed and signed as a true record, which was seconded by Councillor Scarff.
14.1 Councillor Osborne proposed that the minutes of the joint meeting on 16 June be confirmed as a true record, which was seconded by Councillor Caston.
15.1 Councillor Scarff proposed that the minutes of the Mid Suffolk meeting on 19 June be confirmed as a true record, which was seconded by Councillor Caston.
3.1 Councillor Caston proposed that the minutes of the meeting be confirmed and signed as a true record.
117.9 Councillor Caston thanked the CIL team for their guidance throughout the process and commented on the benefits that CIL has on local communities.
118.16 Councillor Caston highlighted the difficulties in identifying homelessness, and the complexity of the cases, and commented that the strategy would help to address these issues.
82.3 Councillor Caston asked for clarification on paragraph 1.6 in appendix C of the report.
82.6 During the debate Councillor Caston outlined that the report was useful to see what was going on in the Council and highlighted how successful the CIFCO investment had been.
85.7 Councillor Caston stated that he was against the proposal as there were few times where there would not be sufficient time ahead of the meeting to read the agenda.
88.7 Councillor Caston stated that he supported the scheme but raised concerns about the use of reserves to fund the project.
Councillor Caston seconded this motion.
47.1 Councillor Caston and Councillor Whyman declared an interest in item JOS/23/27 due to being private landlords.
52.8 Councillor Caston queried how much impact the cost of living crisis, coupled with a lack of available rental properties at affordable prices and the rural geography of the districts, was having on meeting targets and being able to deliver an effective strategy. The Corporate Manager for Housing Solutions responded that it was likely impossible to end rough sleeping as a whole due to the number of factors leading people to become ... view the full minutes text for item 52.
Councillor Caston seconded the motion.
71.8 Councillor Caston outlined that whilst the net gain of 10% biodiversity increase seemed a small amount, it needed to work for all developments so they would not get overturned at appeal. Additionally, the Joint Local Plan was what the Council needed, the SPDs were what the Council could ask for.
55.1 The Chair invited Councillor Caston, Chair of Overview and Scrutiny Committee, to introduce his report to Council.
Councillor Caston responded that whilst he was not at the meeting there were discussions around these issues, and that as the planning authority it was the Council’s job to ensure that the infrastructure was in place in new developments.
58.3 Councillor Caston asked for clarification on the change of wording at paragraph 7.1 as set out in the recommendations. The Monitoring Officer responded that this was to add more inclusive language by changing ‘his’ and ‘her’ to read ‘they’.
60.5 Councillor Caston thanked the Interim Director for Law and Governance for his work over the past year and wished him the best for the future.
Application Number Representations From DC/21/04711 Caroline Wolton (Bramford Parish Council) Anne Raymond (Objector) Martin Crack (Supporter) Darren Cuming (Applicant) Councillor James Caston (Ward Member)
59.12 Members considered the representation from Ward Member Councillor James Caston, who spoke against the application.
39.3 Councillor Caston referred to the environmental implications in the report and questioned the Joint Audit and Standard Committee’s recommendation to Cabinet to filter investments through ESG, and the Joint Audit and Standards Committee’s recognition that any decision to withdraw funds should be balanced against financial prudence.
40.5 Councillor Caston commented that CIFCO was a great legacy for the Council, that the management of the portfolio was excellent and that he was impressed by the EPC improvement works.
45.3 Councillor Caston asked for clarification on the allocations for qualifying groups. The Corporate Manager – Governance and Civic Office responded that a post would be allocated to each qualifying political group, however groups were not required to appoint to this role.
7.9 Councillor Caston questioned how proactively the Partnership could work to resolve issues concerning violence against women and girls (VAWG), particularly within schools. The SCC Head of Community Safety responded that secondary schools had a statutory obligation to provide “healthy relationship” sessions for students. The Corporate Manager for Communities further responded that there was a co-opted education member on the Partnership.
98.3 Councillor Caston questioned about vehicle depreciation costs and if vehicles were depreciated to zero or to a point where they could then be sold off. The Finance Business Partner responded that vehicles were depreciated to a zero value.
98.7 Councillor Caston questioned about the possibility of acquiring assets that are used non-frequently that could be shared between multiple local authorities alongside the possibility of privately contracting out assets when they are not in use by the Councils. The Director for Operations responded that there was scope for both possibilities to be explored.
93.15 Councillor Caston proposed that the application be approved as detailed in the Officer’s recommendation.
63.6 Councillor Caston and Councillor Ekpenyong accepted the amendments to the recommendations.
18.6 Councillor Caston questioned how the online survey had been promoted and how was it ensured that the responses were diverse.
19.9 Councillor Caston questioned whether the change to a 100% reduction would effect Suffolk County Council services as savings in administrative costs would only benefit the district councils.
20.1 Councillor James Caston left the meeting at 12:15pm.
22.1 Apologies were received from Councillor James Caston 22.2 Councillor Barry Humphreys substituted for Councillor James Caston
12.1 Councillor Caston declared that he was the Ward Member for application number DC/21/05468 and confirmed that he would not debate or vote on the item.
A pplication Number R epresentations From D C/22/01535 Philip Cobbold (Agent) Councillor Andrew Mellen (Ward Member) DC/22/00661 Nick Davey (Agent) Councillor John Field (Ward Member) DC/21/05468 Jane Every (Parish Council) William Petersen (Objector) Neil Waterson (Applicant) Councillor James Caston (Ward Member)
19.10 Councillor Caston proposed that the application be approved as detailed in the Officer recommendation along with the additional condition in the tabled papers regarding landscaping mound details and an additional condition for a parking management plan as determined by the committee.
20.3 Councillor Caston declared himself as the Ward Member for this application and confirmed that he would not debate or vote on the item.
20.11 Members considered the representation from Councillor James Caston who spoke as the Ward Member.
109.1 Councillor Caston declared a local non-pecuniary interest in respect of application number DC/21/05669 as he is the Ward Member.
Councillor Caston confirmed that he would not debate or vote on the application.
Application Number Representations From DC/21/06315 Jane Challis (Parish Clerk) Chris Pitt (Objector) Councillor Rowland Warboys (Ward Member) DC/21/05669 Jane Every (Parish Clerk) Chris Smith (Agent) Councillor James Caston (Ward Member) DC/22/00494 Councillor Julie Flatman (Ward Member) DC/22/00349 Councillor Dave Muller (Ward Member)
91.7 Councillor James Caston proposed that the application be approved as detailed in the officer recommendation.
94.6 Councillor James Caston seconded the proposal.
DC/21/03430 Stonham Aspal Parish Council Phil Cobbold (Agent) Councillor Suzie Morley (Ward Member) DC/21/01220 Laura Dudley-Smith (Agent) Councillor James Caston (Ward Member) DC/21/03315 Martin Price (Agent) Councillor Kathie Guthrie (Ward Member) DC/21/02068 Councillor Jill Wilshaw (Wyverstone Parish Council) Sam Harrison (Agent) Councillor Andrew Mellen (Ward Member)
77.7 The Chair read out a statement from Ward Member, Councillor James Caston, who was unable to attend the meeting.
Councillor Rick Meyer substituted for Councillor James Caston.
Councillor Tim Passmore Substituted for Councillor James Caston.
88.5 Councillor Caston raised the topic of online Complaints which had been overhauled in the past 3 years and whether an information bulletin on this could be presented to the Committee on the current situation and progress of this area.
22.9 Councillor James Caston proposed that the application be approved as set out in the Officer recommendation with the additional informative note as follows:
23.8 Councillor James Caston seconded this motion.
11.2 Councillor James Caston subsituted for Councillor Tim Passmore.
8.10 Councillor Caston seconded the motion.
8.13 Councillor Hadingham and Councillor Caston confirmed acceptance of the additional conditions, and also landscaping option B.
9.8 In response to a question from Councillor Caston the agent provided details of the plans for use of solar panels on the site.
10.10 Councillor Caston proposed that the application be approved as per the officer recommendation however a seconder was not found.
Councillor James Caston substituted for Councillor Richard Meyer.
7.1 On the proposal of Councillor Caston and seconded by Councillor Morley, It was
87.11 Councillor James Caston seconded the proposal.
DC/21/00662 David Etchells-Butler (Norton Parish Council) Andrew Sedgewick (Objector) Steve Bean (Supporter) Philip Cobbold (Agent) Cllr Wendy Turner (Ward Member) Cllr Harry Richardson (Ward Member) DC/20/05586 Caroline Wolton (Bramford Parish Council) Albert Horn (Objector) Lauren Parsons (Agent) Cllr James Caston (Ward Member)
77.11 Members considered the representation from Councillor James Caston who spoke against the application.
Councillor Richard Meyer substituted for Councillor James Caston.
Councillor James Caston declared a non-pecuniary interest as he had been present at a meeting with Bellway Homes regarding a different non-related application.
Councillor Guthrie, Councillor Caston, Councillor Humphreys, Councillor Gould, Councillor Norris and Councillor Warboys declared they had been lobbied on application numbers DC/19/05956 and DC/20/01110.
64.15 Members continued to debate the application on issues including: sustainability, housing allocation numbers, the potential flood risk, 64.16 Councillor Caston proposed that the application be approved as detailed in the officer recommendation with the additional conditions as follows:
Councillor James Caston declared a Local Non-Pecuniary interest in application 1856/17 as he knew the landowner as a friend and in the interests of transparency would not be take part in the consideration of the application.
Councillor James Caston declared a personal site visit for application DC/18/00861.
Site Location BARHAM- Land North West of, Church Lane, Barham, Suffolk Applicant Pigeon investment management Ltd and [name removed] 9.2 Prior to the commencement of the application Councillor James Caston left the meeting for application 1856/17 only.
10.2 It was noted that during the break Councillor Andrew Stringer left the meeting and Councillor James Caston re-joined the Committee following the completion of application 1856/17.
47.2 Councillor Muller provided a summary of the Report and MOVED the recommendations in the Report, which was SECONDED by Councillor Caston.
Councillor James Caston joined the meeting at 09:44 and indicated that he had no declarations to make on the applications before the committee.
A short break was taken between 09:45-09:48 to ensure that Councillor Caston could be heard in the meeting.
40.13 Councillor James Caston proposed that the application be refused as detailed in the officer recommendation.
41.3 Councillor James Caston declared that he had been lobbied on application DC/20/01110.
41.13 Councillor James Caston proposed that the application be approved as detailed in the officer recommendation with the additional conditions as follows:
Councillor James Caston seconded the motion.
19.8 Councillor James Caston proposed the officer recommendation of approval.
Councillor James Caston be appointed as a member of Development Control A Planning Committee (to replace Councillor Richardson) The proposals were put to Members for the vote and the vote was CARRIED It was
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Caston attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Caston's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Caston was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Babergh & Mid Suffolk has not published attendance for Councillor Caston's meetings yet.
What Councillor Caston declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 Jul 2022 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee B, item 12 | 12.1 Councillor Caston declared that he was the Ward Member for application number DC/21/05468 and confirmed that he would not debate or vote on the item. | |
| 6 Jul 2022 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee B, item 20 | 20.3 Councillor Caston declared himself as the Ward Member for this application and confirmed that he would not debate or vote on the item. | |
| 23 Mar 2022 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee B, item 109 | 109.1 Councillor Caston declared a local non-pecuniary interest in respect of application number DC/21/05669 as he is the Ward Member. | |
| 3 Mar 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee B, item 57 | Councillor James Caston declared a non-pecuniary interest as he had been present at a meeting with Bellway Homes regarding a different non-related application. | |
| 27 Jan 2021 | Mid Suffolk Planning Referrals Committee, item 2 | Councillor James Caston declared a Local Non-Pecuniary interest in application 1856/17 as he knew the landowner as a friend and in the interests of transparency would not be take part in the consideration of the application. | |
| 27 Jan 2021 | Mid Suffolk Planning Referrals Committee, item 4 | Councillor James Caston declared a personal site visit for application DC/18/00861. | |
| 6 Jan 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee B, item 41 | 41.3 Councillor James Caston declared that he had been lobbied on application DC/20/01110. |
Where Councillor Caston sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Caston yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.