Bc/24/7 overview and scrutiny committee annual report 2023/24 and draft work plan 2024/25
26.1 The Chair invited Councillor McLaren, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, to introduce Paper BC/24/7.
Every time Babergh & Mid Suffolk's minutes name Councillor McLaren, as the council published it.
26.1 The Chair invited Councillor McLaren, Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, to introduce Paper BC/24/7.
26.2 Councillor McLaren introduced Paper BC/24/7 and its appendices and PROPOSED the recommendation as detailed in the report.
Councillor McLaren and the Lead Officer for Overview and Scrutiny responded that members’ approach to scrutinising the Safety Partnership was strengthened by any ongoing issues within their Wards.
Councillor McLaren noted Councillor Holt’s comment.
Councillor McLaren agreed with Councillor Holt’s point.
107.5 Councillor McLaren queried why the challenges and goals for Babergh and Mid Suffolk were different. The Cabinet Member for Housing responded that there was a significant difference in the housing need and community resources available in both districts meaning that different approaches had to be designed.
107.10 Councillor McLaren requested that Ward Members be included in discussions about ensuring customer support was accessible to all residents, particularly those in rural areas. 107.11 Councillor Saw questioned if any interim measures had been put in place should the Council no longer receive the household support fund. The Cabinet Member for Housing responded that work was currently underway to formulate mitigation measures and that discussions had taken place with neighbouring authorities regarding a collaborative approach to tackling homelessness.
6.9 Councillor McLaren queried the vacancy ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
8.3 Councillor McLaren asked if this topic should be looked into by a task and finish group rather than the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. The Lead Officer for Overview and Scrutiny responded that data would need to be gathered first and the potential item fully scoped before a decision could be made on the best method to review.
20.4 Councillor Mary McLaren queried appendix A in relation to the funding allocated to social prescribing and whether ward members received a breakdown of costs incurred for elections for parish councils.
7.5 Councillor McLaren queried the costs of running the Partnership. The Corporate Manager for Communities responded that the Partnership did not have a formal budget, that there was access to a small funding pot which community groups could bid for, and that there was currently no data on how much Officer time, and its associated financial worth, is dedicated to working on the Partnership.
7.6 Councillor McLaren further questioned if there was an order of priority for how certain incidents of hate crime are dealt with.
Councillor Mary McLaren substituted for Councillor Osborne.
102.3 Councillor McLaren questioned if there had been a minimum price included in the marketing offer and the Director for Economic Growth and Climate change advised Members that it had been an informal tender and open marketing process, and that in order not to restrict the number of bids, there had not been a minimum price set for the house. 102.4 Councillor Arthey referred to the Option 2.1 in the report and queried that if the preferred bidder withdrew, would the Council then be able to move forward with the project detailed in Option 2.1. The Regeneration and Capital Projects Officer responded that consideration could be given to alternative bids, as detailed in the recommendation 3.3 in the report.
97.3 Councillor McLaren referred to the Council’s use of short - term external experts and those used on a regular basis such as auditors and asked whether a breakdown of the costs could be provided. 97.4 The Director of Corporate Resources responded that this level of details were not included in the report, but that a response would be provided outside of the meeting.
97.5 Councillor McLaren queried when the benefits of the solar panels installed at the Leisure Centre could be seen in the General Fund Budget.
98.3 Councillor McLaren seconded the recommendations.
98.4 Councillor McLaren referred to the increase in rents for sheltered housing and whether additional resources would be available to manage issues around the rent increase and for any support for anxious residents.
99.5 Councillor McLaren queried the term hereditament in the report in relation to charity shops.
CMU1 – Cabinet Member for Communities and Wellbeing The Chair invited Councillor McLaren – Cabinet Member for Communities & Wellbeing to introduce paper CMU1.
Councillor McLaren conveyed her satisfaction with relations between Babergh and Abbeycroft Leisure, and stated that meetings are held on a quarterly basis.
42.4 Councillor McLaren asked if it was too soon to know any auditing outcomes of any potential fraud in covid grant programme applications from businesses.
62.4 Councillor McLaren questioned what form the 4-yearly routine inspection would take. The Housing Transformation Manager responded that the Regulator could carry out inspections, and that the new regulations had reduced the 28- days-notice to 48 hours.
62.5 In response to Councillor McLaren’s questions regarding the memberships of the Tenancy Board Councillor Osborne detailed the arrangements for meetings memberships and the work undertaken to increase membership and to engage with younger people. 62.6 In a response to further questions from Councillor McLaren regarding the Tenancy Board the Housing Transformation Manager explained that a role profile had been developed as part of the strategy, and that the board currently operated as both a consultative body and a scrutiny body, which tenancy experts had stated should be separate. Therefore, the tenant board and terms of reference require further development.
62.7 Councillor McLaren questioned how tenants did not have digital literacy would be able to access the My Home Bulletin and retrieve reports. The Housing Transformation Manager explained that the My Home Bulletin was introduced in 2019 in a response to a tenant satisfactory survey. The bulletin was produced electronically on a monthly basis and paper copies were available upon request.
53.7 Councillor McLaren queried whether the Virtual High Street had impacted on the foot fall in the high street. The Director for Economic Growth and Climate Change responded that as the Virtual High Street was a complementary enterprise, she did not anticipate that the Virtual High Street would have an impact on parking spaces in Sudbury and Hadleigh.
23.1 The Chair invited Councillor McLaren to introduce Paper BC/22/8.
23.3 Councillor McLaren replied that this was because a member of the public had raised concerns regarding the Shared Legal Services costs.
23.6 Councillor McLaren replied that the recommendation from Overview and Scrutiny regarding the index linked increase of funding for Citizens Advice was due to be presented at the September Cabinet Meeting.
23.8 Councillor McLaren stated that there was some misunderstanding regarding the call-in process and detailed the 3 options available.
23.9 The Chair thanked Councillor McLaren for her report.
5.4 Councillor McLaren proposed that a site visit be undertaken for both applications.
101.1 Councillor McLaren referred Councillors to paper BC/21/36 and requested that any questions were sent to her by email.
103.6 Councillor McLaren enquired what the Council or councillors could do to enable and empower parish and town councils regarding the new Code of Conduct.
106.9 Councillor McLaren asked if an increase in pay would mean an increase in responsibilities and if there were any corporate competencies.
100.12 Councillor McLaren seconded the motion.
59.1 The Case Officer presented Members with a request for a site visit from Councillor McLaren and gave a short presentation regarding application DC/21/01802 – Land South of Honeysuckle Cottage, Little Orchard, Holbrook.
59.5 Councillor McLaren responded to a question from Members regarding the reason for requesting a site visit.
The Chairman requested that, in the absence of Councillor McLaren, any questions should be emailed directly to Councillor McLaren.
Councillors Sue Ayres substituted for Councillor Mary McLaren.
37.8 Councillor Busby queried why the funding was charged to the Transformation Fund and not to the Babergh Parking Budget, to which the Assistant Director for Environment and Commercial Partnerships responded that this was based on the advice she had received. 37.9 Councillor McLaren queried how the Parking Strategy would assess parking on grass verges and how work would be undertaken to engage with the Planning Committee. In addition, she also queried how the Council could influence motorist’s behaviours in relation to responsible parking.
22.1 Councillor McLaren introduced the report and apologised for not highlighting the footnote at the bottom of the report which stated that the June meeting had become inquorate at 1.27pm with all of the items of business still outstanding being transferred until the July meeting.
22.2 Councillor McLaren then invited questions from Councillors.
22.6 In response, Councillor McLaren stated that she felt that Task and Finish Groups should be very focussed on the tasks that they were scrutinising and that the Joint Committee should think very carefully before setting up Joint Task and Finish Groups.
22.7 The Chairman thanked Councillor McLaren for her report.
85.4 Councillor Mary McLaren asked whether there was a map to view the open spaces and whether Parish Councils and District Councillors would be asked to participate in providing information.
84.6 Councillor Mary McLaren queried who was responsible for the maintenance of roadside verges and how this would affect the planning committees and their decision-making process.
88.6 Councillor McLaren raised the topic of SALC (Suffolk Association of Local Councils) and their support for Parish Council’s within the Districts. The Corporate Manager for Governance and Civic Office advised Members that the scope of any scrutiny would be limited as SALC was a private organisation and not under the control of the Council.
24.3 The Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, Councillor McLaren, asked if the Cabinet would be able to have further engagement with Holbrook community and the Holbrook Academy in relation to the Holbrook Academy Sports Centre.
9.6 Councillor McLaren queried what action would be taken to ensure digital inclusion for residents. The Assistant Director provided details of the programmes of work which were being considered and advised that details of these would be shared with Members over the coming months.
He felt that scrutiny was an essential and productive process and had been left in the capable hands of Councillor McLaren.
15.2 Councillor McLaren informed Council that several items had been added to the workplan following the meeting on 24th May 2021. This included training for the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and for all Councillors to keep up to date with Overview and Scrutiny and its objectives, with additional bespoke training on Overview and Scrutiny skills.
15.4 In response to a question from Councillor Simon Barrett, Councillor McLaren informed Council that ideas and proposals from Members would be looked at in relation to the Work Plan.
60.5 Councillor McLaren thought that remote meeting missed the interaction between members, which made it easier to contribute to a debate.
Councillor McLaren declared a local non-pecuniary interest in Item 8, in her role as a member of the Western Suffolk Community Safety Partnership.
5.9 Councillor McLaren stated that the report was comprehensive, however, she felt that the subsidy of parking had been a major point for residents, and that the remainder of the report had been overlooked. She asked if this had been taken into consideration in preparing the report. She also asked how long Babergh had been subsidising car parking in Sudbury.
6.4 Councillor McLaren referred to page 47, bullet point 6.6, in relation to the Public Realm service, which was being brough in-house and asked if there were other services, which could be brought inhouse.
6.6 Councillor McLaren then queried the use of external consultants and Councillor Ward explained that external consultants were only used when necessary to provide specialism and skills for specific projects, which the Council’s officers could not provide.
7.6 Councillor McLaren referred to the national reports of thousands of council houses standing empty and asked if an update could be provided for the number of empty houses and garages across the District.
7.8 Councillor McLaren asked if the Council would provide ‘pods’ for rough sleepers, similar to Ipswich Borough Council.
19.10 Councillor McLaren queried whether allocations of cases were based on geographical areas and the officers responded that the Districts were divided into east and west and that each area had three teams allocated on a geographical basis.
In response to further questions from Councillor McLaren, the officers confirmed that some areas such as Stowmarket and Sudbury received more complaints than other areas.
By 8 votes and 3 abstentions For Against Abstain Councillor Sian Dawson x Councillor Jane Gould x Councillor Lavinia Hadingham x Councillor John Matthissen x Councillor Margaret Maybury x Councillor Alastair McCraw x Councillor Mary McLaren x Councillor David Muller x Councillor Adrian Osborne x Councillor Keith Scarff x Councillor Keith Welham x Total 8 None 3 It was
45.1 Members discussed both Workplans and the upcoming review of the Committee’s work. 45.2 Councillor McLaren provided a summary of a CIPFA Webinar which she thought had been informative and useful when undertaking scrutiny. She would forward the presentation and questions and answers from the meeting to Members.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor McLaren attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor McLaren's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor McLaren was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Babergh & Mid Suffolk has not published attendance for Councillor McLaren's meetings yet.
What Councillor McLaren declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Mar 2021 | Joint Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 39 | Councillor McLaren declared a local non-pecuniary interest in Item 8, in her role as a member of the Western Suffolk Community Safety Partnership. |
Where Councillor McLaren sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor McLaren yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.