Apologies for absence/substitutions
24.2 Councillor Overett substituted for Councillor Mansel, and Councillor Lay substituted for Councillor Elkin.
Every time Babergh & Mid Suffolk's minutes name Councillor Mansel, as the council published it.
24.2 Councillor Overett substituted for Councillor Mansel, and Councillor Lay substituted for Councillor Elkin.
26.3 During the debate Councillor Mansel stated that she supported the motion but raised concern that something needed to be done now and there was no time scale on the development of a new environmental strategy.
113.4 Councillor Mansel stated that the deal gave a small proportion of funding to the County Council and had doubts on the tiny proportion of the budget, she raised concern on whether voters would understand the significance of voting for the leader, all seems to be a work in progress and is all an unknown. She raised concern that the example deals were all urban areas and not rural like Suffolk, lack of involvement with parishes, what will change with this deal, not the right answer for Suffolk.
117.7 Councillor Mansel agreed that with Councillor Scarff’s comments on the Working Group and commented on the importance on having a flexible framework in place for Communities to be able to use the funding available.
118.15 Councillor Mansel commented that the report was clear, and that the strategy would meet the five identified strategies.
119.4 In response to queries from Councillor Mansel queried regarding the recommendations in the report, the Head of Elections and Land Charges clarified that when the report was previously presented to Council in 2023, Council reserved the right to approve the recommendations and therefore it was being presented to Council for final comments, and would return to Council once more before final publication. The Head of Elections and Land Charges confirmed that the errors contained in the appendix would be addressed.
97.2 Councillor Mansel declared an interest as an owner of a second property in the district.
112.1 In respect of application number DC/23/01323, Councillor Mansel advised the Committee that she was previously the Event Director for Chilton Fields Park Run and had attended stakeholder meetings.
Councillor Mansel confirmed that she is no longer involved in the organisation but does take part as a participant.
83.3 During the debate Councillor Mansel welcomed the plan and the thread of sustainability throughout, and she praised the process for including communities.
84.3 Councillor Mansel queried why Elmswell had two unequal groups of 25 and 2537 who used the same polling station and why this was spilt. The Corporate Manager – Electoral Services responded that during the administration of an election the Returning Officer can split a polling station into different polling places, and these would be evenly distributed at the time of an election.
85.4 Councillor Mansel welcomed the Special Responsibility Allowance as training was a requirement to sit on the committee and named substitutes provided a consistency of membership and continuity in the committee, especially in cases where applications are deferred.
87.5 Councillor Mansel questioned what the timescales between package 1 and package 2 would be.
87.6 Councillor Mansel further questioned whether there would be improvements to the car park, including EV charging points, under the scheme.
87.12 Councillor Mansel highlighted that this was a step in the right direction, however the rest of the community such as young adults and young families needed to be considered, and collaborative working with sports providers on inclusion of all abilities was a necessity.
95.3 Councillor Mansel praised the motion and outlined that whilst the service had improved, the timing of services was not ideal.
96.4 Councillor Mansel questioned whether the motion went far enough in encouraging the flood authority to consider the impact of storms in the future, especially in relation to planning applications.
96.13 Councillor Mansel left the meeting at 21:05 pm.
Councillor Stringer responded that this time scale was normal and needed to fit the timetable of the inspector, and time is needed to thoroughly consider responses from the public and developers. 70.4 Councillor Mansel queried whether the timetable could be reviewed ahead of 2026.
70.5 During the debate Councillor Mansel outlined that it had been a long process to get to this point, and that the plan would add certainty to the decision-making process. Additionally, she was happy with the SPDs and their possibilities, and seeing results from the process.
71.11 Councillor Mansel welcomed the Joint Local Plan and whilst Part 2 was still needed, Part 1 set out a basis to make planning decisions. She added that the Joint Local Plan was an improvement on the 1998 plan and was compliant with the NPPF and land supply, and that she hoped that Members would participate in the development of ... view the full minutes text for item 71.
56.5 Councillor Mansel questioned if there was a timeline for the supplementary planning document. The Director for Planning and Building Control said he would respond to this outside of the meeting.
57.2 Councillor Mansel proposed the recommendations as set out in the report.
Councillor Mansel accepted the amendment.
57.11 Councillor Mansel praised the work of the Community Governance Working Group for the thorough job they had done. She added that whilst it was difficult to know how many people would respond to the consultation, it would be ensured that those who would be affected by the change would be reached. Additionally, town and parish councils were aware of the consultation and could do their own publicity for the consultation.
58.4 Councillor Mansel asked if the use of inclusive wording would extend to all Council documents in addition to the constitution. The Monitoring Officer responded that this was in progress.
59.3 Councillor Mansel asked if a digital copy of the timetable could be available to Councillors. The Corporate Manager for Governance and Civic Office responded that there were currently issues with firewalls preventing this, however when the system is updated this would be looked into .
60.3 Councillor Mansel questioned whether a full-time replacement was being sought. The Deputy Chief Executive responded that the advert for the position had closed, and interviews had been scheduled.
Councillor Mansel seconded the recommendation.
Application Number Representations From DC/23/01494 Jonathan Cooper (Applicant) DC/22/03681 Dave Gillingham (Supporter) Councillor Nicholas Hardingham (Ward Member) DC/22/03761 Keith Welham (Objector) Leslie Short (Agent) Councillor Rachel Eburne (Ward Member) Councillor Janet Pearson (Ward Member) DC/23/01076 Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Councillor Jen Overett (Ward Member)
14.3 As Councillor Mansel was the Ward Member for application number DC/23/01076, Councillor Hadingham, the Vice Chair, chaired the Committee for the duration of the application.
14.7 Members considered the representation from Ward member Councillor Sarah Mansel.
15.1 Councillor Mansel resumed the Chair for the remainder of the meeting.
16.1 Councillor Mansel proposed that the meeting went into closed session.
111.1 Councillor Mansel requested that the minutes be amended to reflect that the guillotine vote was a majority vote not a unanimous vote.
The recommendations were Proposed by Councillor Burn and Seconded by Councillor Mansel.
85.1 The Governance Officer confirmed that paragraph 75.1 of the minutes had been corrected to include the representation from Councillor Mansel in respect of application number DC/22/04002.
Application Number Representations From DC/22/03966 David Jones (Agent) Ian Fieldhouse (Applicant) Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Councillor Helen Geake (Ward Member) DC/21/06333 Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Councillor Helen Geake (Ward Member)
83.7 Members considered the representation from Councillor Sarah Mansel who spoke as the Ward Member.
84.4 Members considered the representation from Councillor Sarah Mansel who spoke as the Ward Member.
57.5 The Chair invited Councillor Mansel to speak on the item, as Ward Member for Elmswell.
Question 1 - Councillor Mansel to Councillor Flatman, Cabinet Member for Communities, Health and Wellbeing Is the Council offering help and support to village halls, parish councils and other community groups to facilitate social gathering in heated communal spaces during this period of soaring energy prices and as winter approaches?
53.5 Councillor Mansel asked if there was a timescale for the resolution for Cabinet to carry out further works to replace car parking demands with alternatives by looking at other areas that have done so successfully.
A pplication Number R epresentations From D C/21/06825 Richard Baldwin (Objector) Tom Roseblade (Agent) Councillor Jessica Fleming (Ward Member – Statement) DC/21/06379 Peter Dow (Elmswell Parish Council) Phil Cobbold (Agent) Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Councillor Helen Geake (Ward Member – Statement)
1.2 Councillor Welham substituted for Councillor Mansel.
Application Number Representations From DC/22/02252 Bob Cracknell (Objector) Jenny Davidson (Applicant) Councillor Dave Muller (Ward Member) Councillor Terence Carter (Ward Member) DC/22/01615 Peter Dow (Elmswell Parish Council) Alex Clark (Applicant) Councillor Helen Geake (Ward Member) Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) DC/21/04476 Paul Fox (Applicant) Councillor David Burn (Ward Member) Councillor Andrew Stringer (Ward Member)
9.11 The Ward Member Councillor Geake read out a statement from Ward Member Councillor Mansel who was unable to attend the meeting.
147.4 Councillor Mansel declared a local non-pecuniary interest in respect of application number DC/21/06966 as she owns a property on Onehouse Road.
148.2 Councillor Meyer, Councillor Eburne and Councillor Mansel declared that they had been lobbied in respect of application number DC/21/06882.
149.1 Councillor Meyer and Councillor Mansel declared personal site visits in respect of DC/21/06966.
155.8 Councillor Mansel seconded the proposal.
Application Number Representations From DC/21/01132 Julia Ewans (Parish Council Representative) James Alflatt (Agent) Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Councillor Helen Geake (Ward Member) DC/21/02927 Martin Last (Agent) Councillor Mike Norris (Ward Member)
116.14 Members considered the representation from Councillor Sarah Mansel who spoke as the Ward Member.
98.1 Councillor Mansel declared personal site visits in respect of application numbers DC/21/02956 and DC/21/03589.
Application Number Representations From DC/21/02956 Peter Dow (Parish Council Representative) James Bailey (Agent) Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Councillor Helen Geake (Ward Member) DC/21/03589 Beverly Brady (Objector) Councillor Suzie Morley (Ward Member) DC/21/02927 Item Withdrawn DC/21/02047 Odile Vladon (Parish Council Representative) Steven Bainbridge (Agent) Councillor Julie Flatman (Ward Member) DC/21/01048 James Platt (Agent) Councillor Andrew Stringer (Ward Member) DC/21/05100 Lucy Smith (Agent) Councillor Gerard Brewster (Ward Member) Councillor Keith Scarff (Ward Member) The Chair advised the Committee that application number DC/21/02927 had been withdrawn by Officers.
102.9 Members considered the representation from Councillor Mansel who spoke as the Ward Member.
107.11 Councillor Mansel proposed that the application be approved as detailed in the officer recommendation and with an additional condition relating to a replacement tree.
84.1 Councillor Mansel declared a personal site visit in respect of application number DC/21/03589.
72.1 Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a personal site visit in respect of application number DC/21/02068.
Councillor Mansel sought clarification on the recommendations in the report.
Councillor Mansel asked for clarification regarding the categories referred to in paragraph 4.11 of the report. In response, Nigel Golder confirmed that the leisure sector was included under the section of the chart titled alternatives. The Assistant Director for Assets and Investments advised that this could be amended for future reports.
On the proposal of Councillor Matthissen and seconded by Councillor Eburne, a nomination for Councillor Mansel to be appointed Vice-Chairman of Development Control Committee A was tabled.
54.3 Councillor Rowland Warboys substituted for Councillor Mansel.
37.1 Councillor Mansel moved that application numbers DC/20/05587 and DC/20/05763 be deferred at this point in the meeting.
Councillor Sarah Mansel substituted for Councillor Terence Carter.
84.8 Councillor Sarah Mansel queried whether the mapping software would show only Council owned land, and that Public open space was discussed at the Council’s Planning Committees, and how were Planning Enforcement getting involved.
86.4 Councillor Sarah Mansel commented on the poor transport services across Mid Suffolk and that there needed to be a joined-up approach to this issue.
86.11 the motion was lost 86.12 Councillor Sarah Mansel proposed that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee does create a task and finish group for the scoping of transport in the districts 86.13 Councillor Keith Scarff seconded the motion.
88.3 Councillor Mansel queried the timing of the West Suffolk Community Safety Partnership review and whether the timing of this could be reviewed so that officers did not have to create multiple reports.
14.1 Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a personal site visit in respect of application numbers DC/19/05740 and DC/19/05741.
19.11 Councillor Mansel seconded the proposal.
20.8 Councillor Sarah Mansel proposed that the application be approved as detailed in updated officer recommendation as detailed in the tabled papers with the additions points below:
24.4 Councillor Sarah Mansel proposed that the application be refused for the same reasons as application DC/21/00248 as follows:
10.5 Councillor Mansel queried the number of Councillors from Mid Suffolk District Council and Babergh District Council, as the number of political groups in each authority differs.
Application Number Representations From DC/21/02564 Cllr Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Cllr Helen Geake ( Parish Council representative and Ward Member) DC/21/00366 Tony Kilbee ( Parish Council Representative) Andrew Cardy (Objector) Philip Cobbold (Agent) Cllr Andrew Mellen (Ward Member)
8.5 Members considered the representation from the Ward Member Councillor Sarah Mansel who spoke in favour of the application.
9.12 Councillor Sarah Mansel proposed refusal for the reason as follows:
15.2 Councillor Mansel asked Councillor Welham if he thought that the recommendations from Overview and Scrutiny Committee during the last year to Council, had been followed through in a timely and appropriate manner.
DC/19/02656 Neil Waterson (Applicant) Cllr Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Cllr Helen Geake (Ward Member) DC/20/05587 None
86.6 Members considered the representation from the Ward Member Councillor Sarah Mansel.
Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a Local Non-Pecuniary interest in application DC/21/00662 as discussions of development on the Hawes lane site started when she was Ward Member for the area.
The Chairman advised Members that Councillor Warboys and Councillor Mansel had identified some inaccuracies in the Minutes and those amendments had been made to the Minutes.
Councillor Mansel queried the timeliness of the Minutes of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee?
Councillor Mansel stated that it was extremely pleasing that there was flexibility within the scheme for community projects to get the funding they need.
Councillor Mansel queried the links to the report as they appeared to be linked to the Babergh report.
In response, Councillor Whitehead informed Councillor Mansel that his understanding was that the report had yet to be published and would be published later in the year to meet the report deadline.
Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a Local Non-Pecuniary interest in application DC/20/05912 as an event director of Chilton Fields Parkrun.
66.7 Councillor Sarah Mansel proposed that the application be approved as detailed in the officer recommendation.
Councillor Sarah Mansel to Councillor David Burn, Cabinet Member for Planning The Healthy Homes Act calls for a set of Healthy Homes Principles to be made law and as such part of national planning policy. Since advising officers of this initiative in January we have not heard anything more. Will ... view the full minutes text for item 60.
62.9 Councillor Mansel said that the Council should be committed to build its own housing for social rent and not only affordable rent, which was only a reduction to 80% of the rent. Some tenants could not afford this. Mid Suffolk District Council had a high tenancy rent in comparison to income.
53.10 Following a question from Councillor Mansel, the Area Planning Manager provided clarification of whether CIL monies could be used towards the improvements in transport infrastructure and drainage systems.
Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a Local Non-Pecuniary interest as she had undertaken informal discussions regarding the sustainability of the proposed dwellings.
Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a personal site visit for application DC/18/00861 and the surrounding area.
45.5 Councillor Warboys queried if there was a space for feedback to indicate if a case had been settled satisfactorily or not. 45.6 Councillor Mansel commented that residents had felt frustrated as they had not even received an automated response when submitting cases and the Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee responded that the new software logged every case and assigned a case officer.
47.6 Councillor Mansel asked for clarification for paragraph 2.3 of the report, for the debt yield activity for borrowing rates and whether the Council would not be able to borrow at lower rates. The Assistant Director – Corporate Resources explained that the Council would be able to access loans from the PWLB and that in 2021/22 there would not be anything in the Capital Programme that would be subject to yield activities, so the Council would be able to borrow. Since the announcement about the changes to PWLB lending the rate had been reduced by 1% bringing it back down to competitive levels.
Councillor Matthissen and Councillor Mansel declared personal site visits in respect of application number DC/18/02146.
DC/18/02146 Peter Dow (Elmswell Parish Council) James Bailey (Agent) Victoria Balboa (Highways Consultant) Cllr Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Cllr Helen Geake (Ward Member) via email DC/20/03704 Peter Emberson (Objector) Cllr Suzie Morley (Ward Member) DC/20/04296 Steven Bates (Objector) Laura Dudley-Smith (Agent) Sarah Cornwell (Applicant) Cllr Tim Passmore (Ward Member) Cllr John Whitehead (Ward Member) DC/20/04630 Cllr Richard Meyer (Ward Member)
41.12 Members considered the representation from Councillor Sarah Mansel, who spoke as a Ward Member.
This was seconded by Councillor Mansel.
Councillor Hadingham, Councillor Mansel and Councillor Meyer declared that they had visited the site for application DC/20/03632.
29.9 Councillor Mansel seconded the proposal for recommendation.
22.9 Councillor Mansel asked if consideration had been made for an extension of the minimum consultation period due to the Christmas period and the Covid-19 Pandemic.
Application Number Representations From DC/20/01677 Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Councillor Helen Geake (Ward Member) DC/20/01175 Nick Davey (Applicant) Councillor John Field (Ward Member) DC/20/03026 Andrew Owen (Applicant) Councillor Sarah Mansel (Ward Member) Councillor Helen Geake (Ward Member)
17.5 Members considered the representation from Ward Members Councillor Sarah Mansel and Councillor Helen Geake, who spoke against the application.
19.6 Members considered the representation from the Ward Members, Councillor Sarah Mansel and Councillor Helen Geake.
8.3 The Leader of the Council invited the Ward Member for Woolpit, Councillor Mansel, to speak.
8.4 Councillor Mansel expressed support for the recommendations in the report.
2.1 Councillor Matthissen proposed Councillor Rowland Warboys and was seconded by Councillor Mansel.
10.3 Councillor Eburne PROPOSED that Councillor Welham be appointed substitute for Suffolk Flood Risk Management Scrutiny Sub Committee and that Councillor Sarah Mansel be appointed as substitute for Suffolk Health Scrutiny Committee.
19.20 Councillor Sarah Mansel proposed that the application be approved as detailed in the officer recommendation with the additional conditions as follows:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Mansel attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Mansel's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Mansel was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Babergh & Mid Suffolk has not published attendance for Councillor Mansel's meetings yet.
What Councillor Mansel declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Feb 2024 | Mid Suffolk Council, item 97 | 97.2 Councillor Mansel declared an interest as an owner of a second property in the district. | |
| 6 Apr 2022 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 147 | 147.4 Councillor Mansel declared a local non-pecuniary interest in respect of application number DC/21/06966 as she owns a property on Onehouse Road. | |
| 6 Apr 2022 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 148 | 148.2 Councillor Meyer, Councillor Eburne and Councillor Mansel declared that they had been lobbied in respect of application number DC/21/06882. | |
| 6 Apr 2022 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 149 | 149.1 Councillor Meyer and Councillor Mansel declared personal site visits in respect of DC/21/06966. | |
| 8 Dec 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 98 | 98.1 Councillor Mansel declared personal site visits in respect of application numbers DC/21/02956 and DC/21/03589. | |
| 10 Nov 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 84 | 84.1 Councillor Mansel declared a personal site visit in respect of application number DC/21/03589. | |
| 13 Oct 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 72 | 72.1 Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a personal site visit in respect of application number DC/21/02068. | |
| 23 Jun 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 14 | 14.1 Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a personal site visit in respect of application numbers DC/19/05740 and DC/19/05741. | |
| 14 Apr 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 70 | Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a Local Non-Pecuniary interest in application DC/21/00662 as discussions of development on the Hawes lane site started when she was Ward Member for the area. | |
| 17 Mar 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 57 | Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a Local Non-Pecuniary interest in application DC/20/05912 as an event director of Chilton Fields Parkrun. | |
| 27 Jan 2021 | Mid Suffolk Planning Referrals Committee, item 2 | Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a Local Non-Pecuniary interest as she had undertaken informal discussions regarding the sustainability of the proposed dwellings. | |
| 27 Jan 2021 | Mid Suffolk Planning Referrals Committee, item 4 | Councillor Sarah Mansel declared a personal site visit for application DC/18/00861 and the surrounding area. | |
| 20 Jan 2021 | Mid Suffolk Development Control Committee A, item 37 | Councillor Matthissen and Councillor Mansel declared personal site visits in respect of application number DC/18/02146. |
Where Councillor Mansel sits, from the attendance records.
No committee attendance recorded for Councillor Mansel yet.
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.