Report of the audit committee
Councillor Masud moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the Local Code of Corporate Governance be adopted.
Every time Bedford's minutes name Councillor Sawyer, as the council published it.
Councillor Masud moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the Local Code of Corporate Governance be adopted.
In response to a comment from Councillor Foley regarding the effectiveness of the Finance and Improvement Committee, Councillor Sawyer advised that the report was a snapshot of the moment in time when it was drafted and considered, so did not necessarily reflect the current position.
Councillor Sawyer commented that the Council needed to be reflecting best practice and that the majority of Town and Parish Councils used the Borough Council’s Code of Conduct as their Code of Conduct. He was therefore hopeful that any changes made to the Borough Council’s Code of Conduct in response to this consultation would be incorporated by Parish and Town Councils.
Councillor Foley will be substituting for Councillor Bywater, Councillor Weir will be substituting for Councillor Gambold and Councillor Headley will be substituting for Councillor Sawyer.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the report be received and the recommendation therein be approved.
Councillor Sawyer took the opportunity to thank the Interim Monitoring Officer for all his extensive work in dealing with the complaints. He re-iterated that the business of Standards was to investigate complaints and reflecting on the issue being discussed, it would be in the best interest of parish residents that the conduct of parish council meetings was improved.
Councillor Sawyer requested a clarification of exempt information as set out in the Minutes of the previous meeting. The Interim Monitoring Officer confirmed that information was identified as exempt as defined in Paragraph 3 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Local Government Act 1972, as it related to the business affairs of a person or organisation, which also included that of the Authority.
Councillor Sawyer questioned whether at some stage it would be possible for the Council to make a public statement in relation to the ending of the contract referred to in the schedule. The Interim Monitoring Officer advised that the intention of the Act was that the information would remain exempt indefinitely, however the Regulations concerning a Freedom of Information request was different and could include commercially sensitive information, for which there was a public interest test. Information in this case could be time sensitive, therefore at some point the information might become disclosable.
Councillor Nawaz moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the report be received and the recommendation to adopt the Local Code of Corporate Governance be approved.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the report be received and the recommendation therein be approved.
That Councillor Sawyer be elected Chair for the meeting.
Councillor Sawyer added that where the recommendations had not been resolved that an expected completion date should be provided in the report. The Team leader Internal Audit advised that the detailed report to Officers on the Pension Investments had a timeline for each recommendation, however Internal Audit would bring an action plan, with progress against the recommendations, back to the Committee in six months.
Councillor Sawyer pointed out a typographical error in the table in paragraph 5.5 which should state “ 85+ days”.
Councillor Sawyer moved, and Gambold seconded, that the Annual Audit Report 2022/23 be received.
In introducing the report, Councillor Sawyer referred to the delay to the audit of the Statement of Accounts and the change of the external auditors from Ernst and Young to KPMG.
The Speaker moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the report be received and the recommendation therein be approved.
That Councillor Sawyer be appointed Vice-Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor Sawyer – Short Statement This clearly is very important, a key part of business for this Committee is making sure that interests are registered and appropriately disclosed in Council meetings as necessary. The substantive item on the agenda tonight on dispensations really proves that point. I know the deadline I believe is a week or two weeks ago, but can I suggest to the Monitoring Officer that she should use political Group Leaders as means of making sure that all Members of the Council go through the process where that has not been done for the individuals that she mentioned.
Councillor Sawyer concurred that it was important that interests were properly disclosed and dispensed with, where appropriate. The reports referred to three specific Full Council agenda items cited as General , whereby one clear example of declaring interests was Member Allowances.
Councillor Sawyer commented that the audit should have been concluded by the end of November 2022 (seven months late). The Chief Finance Officer advised that EY would be auditing a further year and then the audits would be taken over by KPMG. She anticipated that audit of the Accounts would continue to be late according to the legal timeframe.
(Note: Councillors Headley and McMurdo disclosed local interests in this item as Members of the Bedfordshire Local Pension Fund, and Councillor Sawyer disclosed a local interest in the same item as his wife is a member of the Fund.)
Councillor Sawyer commented that it was difficult to benchmark the various Pools at this early stage, however it would be useful to know the level of salaries being paid to officials, as well as the costs they incurred. The Fund Administrator suggested that the matter could be discussed further at Agenda Item no. 19 (Minute 83 below).
Councillor Sawyer commented that the alignment of the front, middle and back services was a good concept and the transformation programme as a whole was well tried. He felt that it was very important that services across the Council were made more efficient where possible and clarification of how to deal with enquires from members of the public was improved upon to ensure that the public accessed the services that they needed as quickly as possible. The Chair agreed with this comment; however, stated that his only concern by bringing together the frontline functions was that there was likely to be a single digitalised function and it was felt that this had the possibility to alienate members of the public trying to access relevant services.
RESOLVED That Cllr Sawyer be appointed as Vice-Chair for the ensuing municipal year.
Councillor Sawyer noted that the employer contribution rate would be moving from 17.8% to 19.2%. [name removed] confirmed that this would be the average contribution.
The Council’s Pay Policy Statement Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Oliver seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
Councillor Sawyer proposed an amendment to the first recommendation of the Independent Remuneration Panel’s report as follows:
Report to update in respect of the Constitution Working Group Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Moon seconded that the report be received and the recommendations included therein be adopted.
That Councillor Sawyer be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
(a) The Council’s Pay Policy Statement 2018/19 Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Wootton seconded that the report be received and the recommendations be adopted.
Councillor Sawyer presented the report which set out the Council’s Pay Policy as required by the Localism Act 2011. The Pay Policy described how the Council paid and rewarded its employees. The legislation was in addition to the Local Government Transparency Code 2014 which required the Council to produce and publish organisation structures, salaries and responsibilities in relation to senior staff.
Proposed Terms of Reference for Bedford Local Pension Board Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Wootton seconded that the report be received and the recommendations be adopted.
Community Governance Review of Stewartby , Wixams and Elstow Parishes Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Wootton seconded that the report be received and the recommendations be adopted.
Councillor Sawyer moved, and Councillor Moon seconded, that the report of the Independent Remuneration Panel be received and that the Members Allowances Scheme for 2018/19 should be unchanged from that applying in 2017/18, with an amendment to the proposal set out in the report as follows:
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Oliver seconded that the report be received and that the recommendations be adopted.
In response to a question from a Member of the Committee, the Chief Executive advised of his expectation that, notwithstanding the fact that the Chair of the General Purposes Committee for 2017/2018 would not be elected until after the Extraordinary meeting of the Council, Cllr Sawyer would present the Committee report arising from this meeting to the Extraordinary Council given that he had chaired this meeting.
(a) Local Government Pensions Scheme Pooling Arrangements – Joint Committee Proposal Councillor Sawyer moved, and Councillor Hill seconded, that the report be received and that the recommendations be adopted. On the motion being put to the meeting, the Speaker declared it to be carried.
That Councillor Sawyer be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
(a) Updated Contract Procedure Rules Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Hill seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
That Councillor Sawyer be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
(a) The Council’s Pay Policy Statement Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Hill seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
(i) Councillor Mingay in place of Councillor Fensome on the Children’s Services Overview & Scrutiny Committee (ii) Councillor Wootton in place of Councillor Fensome on the Planning Committee (iii) Councillor Sawyer in place of Councillor Merryman on the Planning Committee (iv) Dominic Cox in place of Heather Moulder as NHS England’s representative on the Bedford Borough Health & Wellbeing Board.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Oliver seconded that the reports be received and that for 2015/16 Members Allowances be frozen at the level currently paid.
That Councillor Sawyer be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
(a) Council’s Pay Policy Statement 2014/2015 Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Hill seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
(b) Public Involvement in the Planning Process Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Gerard seconded that the report be received and, with the consent of the Council, moved that the recommendation be adopted with the addition of the following words to the Procedure Rule: “ on the agenda for consideration by Members” after “ except Planning Committee in relation to Planning applications” On the motion as amended being put to the meeting, the Speaker declared it to be carried.
“FC34 APPLICATION OF FULL COUNCIL PROCEDURE RULES TO COMMITTEES 34.1 The Procedure Rules listed below shall, with any necessary modifications, apply to Committee and Sub-Committee meetings and to meetings of any other body to which Section 100E of the Local Government Act 1972 applies, or is deemed by the Council to apply:………………………………… FC28 Public Question time (except Planning Committee in relation to Planning applications on the agenda for consideration by Members )” (c) Terms of Reference of the Budget Scrutiny Committee Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Hill seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
(d) Amendment to Full Council Procedure Rules – Requirements for Recorded Votes at Budget Meetings Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Hill seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
(a) Council’s Pay Policy Statement Councillor Vann moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Vann seconded that the recommendation be amended to read as follows (amendments underlined):
Councillor Sawyer echoed the comments made by Councillor Oliver and re-iterated that OFSTED had raised their performance expectations. He acknowledged the “Adequate” rating in all four categories which was something that the Authority could be justifiably proud when many other Authorities had received only “Inadequate” ratings. He paid credit to the new senior leadership Team in Children’s Services Directorate and their significant achievement.
Councillor Sawyer added that protection of children was essential and that they should be properly safeguarded.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Education) Councillor Sawyer responded that the Council was currently consulting on strengthening the partnership between the Local Authority and its schools and would be setting out its strategy for improving education in the Borough. The strategy would seek to improve attainment and GCSE results to above the national average. He added that resources needed to be directed in the correct areas in order to achieve this.
Councillor Sawyer commented that the strategy was still out for consultation, however, he had received some positive feedback.
The Speaker moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that the Calendar of Meetings for 2013/2014 be approved.
Councillor Vann moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Education) Councillor Sawyer responded that Academies did have the power to change the catchment area for their school as they required. However, before doing so they had to confirm that an expansion in their school numbers would not require capital funding to create additional school buildings. In addition they would also need to have a standard of teaching which would attract additional children.
Councillor Sawyer added that it was the Council’s aspiration that all children in the Borough should have a quality education provided by a local school. He confirmed that the Council was seeking further collaboration with schools and Academies to improve standards generally.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Education) Councillor Sawyer responded that he was unaware of any Academies in the Borough being selective and it was clear that where this occurred in other areas, the Department for Education would try to stop this practice.
Councillor Sawyer advised that he would do what he could in relation to this matter within the powers available.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Education) Councillor Sawyer responded that the matter related to a consultation document which had only been issued this week. He commented that there would be positive and negative issues with any ... view the full minutes text for item 102.
The Mayor moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the report of the Director of Finance and Corporate Services be received and that the recommendations be adopted. On the motion being put to the meeting, the Speaker declared it to be carried.
(ii) review and amend as appropriate the Guidance to Members as set out in Part 16 of the Constitution.” Councillor Sawyer seconded the motion, as altered to include the additional recommendation.
Councillor Sawyer moved, and Councillor Hill seconded that the report be received and that recommendations 2.1 and 2.2 be adopted.
Councillor Sawyer, as Portfolio Holder for Education and Lead Member for Children’s Services, commented that the review reflected the enormous amount of work which had been carried out by the Committee and he thanked those Members and the Officer team for bringing the review to the Executive.
Councillor Sawyer advised that the work relating to some of the recommendations was already in place and the Council already offered support to all maintained schools in the Borough through schools standards intervention work, however, this was prioritised in accordance with the available resources. In addition with regard to some of the recommendations, it was noted that the Council only had limited powers and could only express a view and it was for the School Governors to take responsibility.
Councillor Sawyer moved, and Councillor Headley seconded, that Sylvia Anne Gillard of 140 Putnoe Street, Bedford, a Councillor of the Borough, be elected Speaker of the Council for the Municipal Year 2012/13.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Royden seconded that the report of the Assistant Chief Executive (Governance) be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Oliver seconded, that:
The Speaker moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the Mayor and Councillors Atkins and Holland be appointed to serve on the Joint Selection Committee. On the motion being put to the meeting, the Speaker declared it to be carried.
The Speaker then moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that Councillors Atkins and Holland be nominated for appointment to the Bedfordshire Police Authority until the establishment of the new Police Commissioner and Police and Crime Panel in November 2012.
The Speaker moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the Calendar of Meetings for 2012/13 as submitted, be approved.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Merryman seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
In response, Councillor Sawyer, the Portfolio Holder for Education, advised that it would be prudent to wait until the end of the consultation period before considering this.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Hill seconded that the advice received be accepted and that no further action be taken in relation to the petition which requested the Council to enforce the covenant on the former Bird in Hand Public House in Brickhill , Bedford.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (in the absence of the Mayor and Portfolio Holder for Environment and Transport) Councillor Sawyer responded that he would provide a written answer to the question.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Chair of the Executive meeting held on 7 December 2011 when the item relating to the Rookery South (Resource Recovery Facility) Order 2011 was discussed) Councillor Sawyer responded that he did not recollect that Councillor McMurdo had spoken on this particular issue.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Oliver seconded that the reports be received and that Council reject the recommendations in the Independent Remuneration Panel’s report for changes to the current Scheme, so that for 2012/13, the current allowances continue to be paid subject to Committee Spokespersons not being eligible for a Committee Spokesperson Special Responsibility Allowance (SRA) if they were from the same political group as the Committee’s Chair.
Conferment of Titles of Honorary Alderman and Honorary Alderwoman of the Borough of Bedford Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Royden seconded that the recommendation from the General Purposes Committee to confer the title of Honorary Alderman on former Councillor Jim Brandon and the title of Honorary Alderwoman on former Councillor Attenborough, be adopted.
Councillor Sawyer moved and the Mayor seconded that:
The Speaker moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the nominations for membership of the Council’s Committees, following the review of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee structure, as received from the various Political Groups and tabled at the meeting be approved and that the Head of Members’ Services be authorised to give effect to any outstanding appointments, following notification by Group Leaders.
That Councillor Sawyer be elected Chair of the Committee for the current ensuing Municipal Year.
Whilst it was noted that the political balance rules applied to Sub-Committees of the Council, Councillor Sawyer proposed the following allocation of places, which was seconded by Councillor Atkins:
Councillor Sawyer moved, and Councillor Merryman seconded, that Sylvia Anne Gillard of 140 Putnoe Street, Bedford, a Councillor of the Borough, be appointed Deputy Speaker of the Council for the Municipal Year 2011/12.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Royden seconded, that:
Councillor Sawyer moved, and Councillor Royden seconded, that the Mayor and Councillor Holland be appointed to serve on the Joint Selection Committee.
Councillor Sawyer then moved, and the Mayor seconded, that Councillor Holland be nominated for appointment to the Bedfordshire Police Authority and that the Council’s second place on the Police Authority be allocated to the Labour Group.
(c) Capital Investment Strategy Councillor Headley moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
(a) Review of Financial Procedure Rules Councillor Merryman moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
(b) Review of Contract Procedure Rules Councillor Merryman moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
Councillor Merryman moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that the report be received.
Councillor Sawyer disclosed a personal interest in this item being a member of the governing bodies of Biddenham Upper School and Newnham Middle School ( i ) Admissions Criteria Members were informed that the governing bodies of the following schools had consulted on changes to their admissions criteria set out at Appendix A to the report:
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio for Children’s Services) Councillor Sawyer responded that he did not have the performance results to hand, however, he agreed that there would be room for improvement.
Councillor Charsley moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that Councillor Rider be appointed to the Standards Committee for the remainder of the Municipal Year.
Councillor Sawyer introduced his joint report with the Executive Director for Children’s Services, Schools and Families which set out that on 1 November 2010, the Mayor had agreed to the publication of proposals to revoke the plans for structural change in respect of the majority of schools within the Borough. The statutory proposals had been published on 14 November 2010 and the six week period during which comments and objections could be made in response to the statutory notices had ended on 26 December 2010.
Councillor Sawyer advised that all nine responses which had been received had supported the revocation proposals.
In introducing the report, Councillor Sawyer advised that originally the Council had proposed to restructure education in the Borough from a three tier system to a two tier system which was predicated on the funding which should have been available through the Building Schools for the Future programme. As this programme had been stopped by the new coalition Government, the Borough Council had been unable to proceed in accordance with its original plans. Therefore the Council had had to publish notices to revoke the original plans following consultation with the schools and the dioceses.
Councillor Sawyer explained that the whole process of revocation had taken many months, but the Council had a duty to comply with legal advice and adhere to regulations and, had it not done so, this could have resulted in a legal challenge which would have been costly to local taxpayers. Members of the Executive were supportive of the action taken by the Council and this had been confirmed by the Department for Education as the correct approach.
Councillor Sawyer commented that the Big Society was a powerful concept. Recently he had witnessed examples, on a visit to the Cherry Trees Nursery, where staff were working with volunteers in a proactive way to great effect. He added that he was convinced that the nursery school had the ability to move forward despite the recent budget cuts and would be able to achieve a balanced budget.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Children’s Services Portfolio) Firstly I want to acknowledge publically the high quality of nursery education across the Borough, which is essential in providing children with a good start in early years’ schooling.
Councillor Sawyer introduced his joint report with the Executive Director of Children’s Services, Schools and Families which set out that originally the Borough Council had been required to implement an Early Years Single Funding Formula (EYSFF) for all schools and settings, offering the free early years entitlement for three and four year olds from 1 April 2010. In order to achieve this, a number of actions including initial and full formal consultations had been undertaken and a funding methodology proposed.
In introducing the report, Councillor Sawyer also referred to the response given to Councillor Oliver’s question earlier on the agenda (see Minute 74 above).
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services) Councillor Sawyer responded that following the removal of BSF funding, the Council had to revise its plans. The policy was now that the Council would only pursue a change of education system subject to the views of the local community. There were a wide range of views within each community, but, it was important to reach a local solution for the future education of children in the Borough and it was essential that all children within the Borough received the highest quality education.
Councillor Sawyer advised that the six week period during which comments and objections could be made in response to the statutory notices had ended on 25 February 2010 and 75 comments or objections had been received.
Councillor Sawyer advised the Executive that following publication of the statutory notices the Strategy for Change Part 1 for Building Schools for the Future (BSF) had been submitted to Partnerships for Schools ( PfS ) and a Remit meeting had confirmed that the Council was in the BSF programme and therefore the Council’s proposals warranted funding. An outline business case would be submitted to PfS in November 2010.
In introducing the report, Councillor Sawyer emphasised that there had been five main themes to the comments/objections which were:
Councillor Sawyer commented that in the main, communities had accepted the proposals for change and they were now keen to see the changes delivered as soon as possible.
In relation to the serious concerns regarding traffic and parking outside of schools, Councillor Sawyer acknowledged these concerns and the necessity to solve these problems. He added that some suggestions had already been received and he commented that the Council would need to ensure that local residents, who might be affected by the traffic problems, were also considered. A key requirement for the development of any school site was the production of a Green Travel Plan which would encourage walking/cycling to school and providing safer routes for children.
Councillor Sawyer confirmed that the Council would continue to listen to comments and suggestions received throughout the preparations towards the implementation of the two tier system of education.
In response to a question regarding concerns which had been expressed at meetings held to discuss the current parking problems at Camestone Lower School, Councillor Sawyer acknowledged the serious concerns in relation to this particular school and advised that the Council would be working with the school and community to seek to solve the problems. He reiterated that the Council would be receptive to receiving details of any particular ... view the full minutes text for item 108.
Councillor Sawyer asked how the Committee could keep track of and follow up Internal Audit recommendations arising from reports on service areas following the decision at the last meeting that the Head of Internal Audit should advise the relevant Portfolio Holders and the Committee of the completion and signing off of internal audits. He asked if reports could be copied to Portfolio Holders and Committee Members, which could then be followed up with the Head of Internal Audit if appropriate.
(a) Bedford Borough Children’s Trust Children and Young People’s Plan 2010-13 Councillor Sawyer moved and the Mayor seconded that the report be received and that the recommendations be adopted.
Councillor Sawyer introduced the report of the Executive Director for Children’s Services, Schools and Families which included the first Children and Young People’s Plan for Bedford Borough for the Bedford Borough Children’s Trust. This would set out the work of the Partnership from 1 April 2010 – 31 March 2013 in order to improve outcomes for children and young people in Bedford Borough.
In introducing the report, Councillor Sawyer advised that this was an ambitious Plan and acknowledged that it had been a major team effort to produce the document in a relatively short space of time. He took the opportunity to thank all those involved in preparing this first Children and Young People’s Plan.
Councillor Sawyer emphasised that the Plan was “owned” by the Bedford Borough Children’s Trust, which was the body tasked with looking after children, rather than by the Borough Council. The aspirations contained within the Plan could only be achieved through partnership working with other agencies such as the Police and Health Service.
Councillor Sawyer referred the Executive to the revised Appendix 2 (Equality Impact Assessment) which had included further clarification from the original document which had been circulated with the agenda. He added that it was also proposed to make some minor textual amendments before the Plan was submitted to Full Council.
Councillor Sawyer introduced the report of the Executive Director for Children’s Services, Schools and Families which set out the proposed arrangements for Bedford Borough’s new Local Safeguarding Children Board (LSCB) to meet its statutory new role from 2010. The Assistant Director (Vulnerable Children and Children’s Social Care) emphasised the need, following the creation of the two new Unitary Authorities , for two new LSCB’s in order to ensure effective oversight of the safeguarding of children and young people in their respective areas. The Assistant Director advised that a number of shared services would be maintained below Board level, as partner agencies would have found it difficult to resource a duplicated service in the sub-region.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services) The budget proposals include the removal of the subsidy for the Early Birds Nursery as this is considered unsustainable. A great deal of work has been carried out to ensure an ongoing nursery provision in Queens Park throughout the Summer and for continued nursery care from September 2010. It is proposed that the closure of the Early Birds Nursery will be delayed until July 2010 which will ensure less disruption for the children starting school in September 2010 and will allow time for parents to make other arrangements for nursery care.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services) There was indeed a Remit meeting with the Partnerships for Schools and subsequently a press release was issued. The Council is now officially part of the Building Schools for the Future (BSF) Programme which means it is on the list to receive funding. It is expected that the Council will receive around £300m to transform schools and education in the Borough.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services) All parents have been previously written to by the Council regarding the proposed closure of the Nursery, however, it is accepted that there will be some disruption. The Council recognises the difficulties this will cause, however, it will ensure that there is adequate provision for Nursery places. Reply by the Mayor The Council has to find substantial savings across a range of services and unfortunately the financial loss being incurred by the Early Birds Nursery cannot be sustained.
Councillor Sawyer introduced his joint report with the Executive Director for Children’s Services, Schools and Families which set out the process and results of the consultation which had been carried out in relation to the future of special school provision within the Borough.
In introducing the report, Councillor Sawyer commented that this was a very important decision before the Executive, perhaps even more important than the decision taken on the school organisation review. The reason being that if children with special needs were not content in school, this would naturally affect their entire family, some of whom were the most vulnerable in society. The proposals under consideration included the provision of new state of the art facilities and this was vital as many of the existing buildings were no longer fit for purpose.
Councillor Sawyer advised that over 1,000 consultation documents had been issued and that by the closure of the consultation period on 6 November 2009, 258 paper and electronic responses had been received from parents, school pupils, staff and governors and from other stakeholders.
The responses had been analysed and were set out in the report, however, Councillor Sawyer emphasised the importance of the need to give consideration to the individual issues raised. Concerns had been expressed regarding the safety of children and the ability of staff to protect those children requiring the most attention. He added that it was possible to manage special schools and respond to a wide range of disabilities in a successful manner.
Councillor Sawyer confirmed that Option 1 of the consultation was being recommended to the Executive and one of the main strengths of the proposals included the opportunity for the inclusion of children in mainstream schools. It was noted that Biddenham Upper School had already made positive arrangements for the inclusion of pupils from the St John’s School.
Councillor Sawyer emphasised that it was important that parents had their concerns addressed as they naturally wished to obtain the best possible outcome for their children at school. The following responses were provided to questions from Members:
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services) I will send you a detailed written response.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services) Thank you. We have given an undertaking that no Lower Schools will be closed as a result of the programme before us this evening. In terms of funding, there is no doubt that we would like to be able to invest more money in our Lower Schools or Primary Schools should we choose to make the change tonight, but we do believe that we can make that change successfully based on the funding set out in the report.
The Mayor moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that the report be received and the recommendations be adopted.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services) Targets have already been set for all schools for 2010 and the targets are currently being considered for 2011. I would share your concern that standards should be raised whichever decision is taken. The Council is totally committed to the current and future generations of children and wants to see them achieve higher standards.
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services) The project has been costed on the basis of being awarded an estimated £300m of BSF funding, however, the final amount is not known at this stage. The project plan has been produced with in-built flexibility, including contingencies if certain elements are not forthcoming. There will be a need to ensure that funding is maximised and to manage the project within the funding levels achieved.
The Clerk reported that Councillor Sawyer had replaced Councillor Walker as the Borough Council’s non-voting observer at meetings of the Forum and that [name removed] would no longer be able to represent upper school governors as his tenure of office as a governor at Wootton Upper School was due to end before the next meeting of the Forum.
Councillor Sawyer, Ward Member for the area, whilst welcoming the proposals, expressed concerns about the transport implications for the area given that the 50,000 patients registered at the five current practices would, under the proposal, attend the same site.
Councillor Sawyer explained that many of the residents in his Ward already experienced problems with people connected with Bedford School and that he could only see the situation being much worse if the proposal for the GP Centre went ahead. He was particularly concerned about road safety issues given that Kimbolton Road, adjacent to the site, was narrow and was used by large numbers of pedestrians and cyclists as well as cars, buses and HGVs .
Councillor Sawyer, Chair of Scrutiny Committee, introduced the reference from the Committee and advised that it had felt that the reasons listed in the ‘call-in’ notice had been valid. The Committee had been concerned regarding the apparent lack of consultation and there had been clear evidence that this had been inadequate. The Committee had recommended that a more detailed and robust consultation should be undertaken before any decision on the future of the park and ride service was made.
That Councillor Sawyer be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor Hodgson moved and Councillor Sawyer seconded that:
08/01119/FUL – Minute No. 40(h) Councillor Sawyer Personal and Prejudicial – Councillor Sawyer knows [name removed], who exercised the right to speak on this item, personally.
Councillor Hodgson moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that Anita Joan Gerard of 26 Whitbread Avenue, Bedford, MK42 9DY, a Councillor of the Borough, be elected Speaker of the Council for the Municipal Year 2008/09.
Councillor Sawyer moved and Councillor Attenborough seconded that the report be received and that:
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Sawyer attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Sawyer's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Sawyer was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 9 of 12 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Sawyer declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 May 2023 | Full Council, item 14 | (Note: Councillors Headley and McMurdo disclosed local interests in this item as Members of the Bedfordshire Local Pension Fund, and Councillor Sawyer disclosed a local interest in the same item as his wife is a member of the Fund.) | |
| 1 Apr 2011 | Bedford Borough Admissions Forum, item 23 | Councillor Sawyer disclosed a personal interest in this item being a member of the governing bodies of Biddenham Upper School and Newnham Middle School ( i ) Admissions Criteria Members were informed that the governing bodies of the following schools had consulted on changes to their admissions criteria set out at Appendix A to the report: |
Where Councillor Sawyer sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full Council | Committee Member | Jun 2008 | 10 | |
| Audit Committee | Vice-Chair | Jun 2008 | 5 | |
| Pension Fund Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 4 | |
| Standards Committee | Vice-Chair | Mar 2026 | 1 | |
| Implementation Executive | Committee Member | Jul 2008 | 6 | |
| Scrutiny Committee | Chair | May 2009 | 3 | |
| Executive | Committee Member | Dec 2008 | 2 | |
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2008 | 1 | |
| Adult Social Care and Health Policy Review and Development Committee | Non-elected, non-voting | Oct 2009 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.