Questions from members of the council
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo asked Councillor Gribble whether the Bedford Day rider ticket offered by Stagecoach was available for the residents of Radwell, Felmersham and Sharnbrook.
Every time Bedford's minutes name Councillor McMurdo, as the council published it.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo asked Councillor Gribble whether the Bedford Day rider ticket offered by Stagecoach was available for the residents of Radwell, Felmersham and Sharnbrook.
Councillor McMurdo – Statement Councillor McMurdo stated that he was already aware of the answer.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and the Speaker seconded, that the report be received and the recommendation therein be approved.
Councillor McMurdo - Question Councillor McMurdo commented that, regardless of the description of the situation, be ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
In response to a question from Councillor McMurdo regarding the absence of links to the updated Schools’ Personnel Handbook, and why the updates had not been brought to the Committee prior to the legislation coming into effect, the Head of Human Resources and Organisational Development advised that the timing of Committee meetings, together with the finalisation of legislation and associated guidance, had impacted reporting timescales. It was explained that the changes reflected statutory requirements and had therefore been incorporated directly into the Schools’ Personnel Handbook following consultation with the Trade Unions. ... view the full minutes text for item 21.
Councillor Vann moved, and Councillor McMurdo seconded, that Tim Caswell, a Councillor of the Borough, be elected Speaker of the Council for the Municipal Year 2026/27.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo sought confirmation that the Council was no longer financing Blue Peris and White Peris and that this had taken effect from the end of September.
Councillor McMurdo – Supplementary Question Councillor McMurdo asked whether it was the case that the Council had no financial exposure to the sites at all, specifically liability for any property defects.
Councillor McMurdo – Statement Councillor McMurdo commented that his sources had advised that there was still some activity going on and the properties were not in a good state of repair. He expressed disappointment that the decision had been made to dispose of these even though for a very small amount of money the Council could have kept them going. The property was on the market for around £500,000 and there had not been much interest.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo referred to social media posts arising from missed waste collections. Waste collection had historically been a very high performing and well-regarded service, and the addition of food waste collection was to be welcomed. However, there currently seemed to be a lot of missed collections, for a variety of reasons.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo stated that it was his understanding that route optimisation had been undertaken; however, he questioned whether this took into account the tonnage and amount of collection. That day specifically it appeared there were a lot of comments around the volume of green waste that has been collected. It did not appear there was that much growing quickly at the moment , so he was surprised that this had been impacted.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Could this committee consider undertaking a thorough review of primary care provision in Bedford, including areas outside the north which seem to receive priority attention? I believe improvement is needed not just across the borough, but also in Milton Keynes, Hertfordshire, Central Bedfordshire, Northamptonshire, etc. Is it within the committee's scope to examine primary care, including services beyond GP surgeries; and if so, can we add this to the work programme for the next municipal year, especially with recent organisational changes within the Integrated Care Board and a clean sheet to assess community needs?
Councillor McMurdo – Statement It is important to consider primary care, especially as we develop facilities such as GP surgeries in Wootton and Wixams. In my opinion, the current premises are not adequately prepared for future needs. We should strive to establish effective medical hubs.
Should it be determined that the Committee’s previous recommendations did not address the concerns raised by Councillor McMurdo, it was proposed that the Committee re-examined the scope of its review concerning Primary Care Access.
It will explore the possibility of introducing a controlled parking zone (CPZ) covering all streets in the area.” In response to a question from Councillor McMurdo regarding the cost of the consultation, Councillor Gribble advised that a written response would be provided.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Gambold seconded that the report be acknowledged.
Councillor McMurdo gave an accompanying presentation, highlighting the following:
Councillor McMurdo concluded the presentation by thanking the Service Director for the Bedfordshire Pension Fund, the Section 151 Officer and the team responsible for supporting the pensions function. He placed on record his thanks to two long-standing members of staff, Andy Watkins, the previous Section 151 Officer, and Andrew Robertson, Senior Democratic Services Officer, as well as recognising the contributions of the Members of the Pension Fund Committee, including the Council’s own representatives, Councillors Gambold, Sawyer and Valentine.
There being no other items of business, the Deputy Speaker declared the meeting closed at 8.47 pm APPENDIX Written responses to questions asked at the meeting Response from Councillor Gribble to Councillor McMurdo regarding the cost of the Black Tom CPZ consultation “As approx.
costs £10k for consultation depending on how many homes and streets involved, however the cost of implementing, i.e. signs, posts, traffic orders, line markings, staffing costs could be anything from £100K-£150K depending on the final agreed scheme.” Response from Councillor Gribble to Councillor McMurdo detailing spend on white/yellow lining this year and last financial year “Lining is put back as part of the overall surfacing schemes when we resurface a road so it would be quite a time-consuming exercise to go back and take this off every bills of quantities and drawing for the last 3-4 years.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo wished to place on record that he was very serious about the robustness of the Council's financial position, resources, morale within staff and those that were in the supply chain and providing good services, especially as so many of them were members of the local community. He welcomed the opening remarks made by the Mayor and asked the Mayor to clarify that he was committed to being transparent, collaborative and leaving no stone unturned.
In response to a question from Councillor McMurdo regarding the late publication of the report, the Service Director for Governance and Monitoring Officer advised that Members could request a procedural motion for an adjournment if they did not believe they had sufficient time to consider and make an informed decision on the Council Tax resolution.
Councillor McMurdo requested that his comments on the hostility of the budget-setting process, in comparison to all others since he had been elected to the Council in 2003, be recorded and he thanked Officers for their work in enabling the Council to be in a position to set the Council Tax at this meeting.
In response to questions from Councillor McMurdo, the Mayor confirmed that there had been no changes to the Council Tax Reduction Scheme and that charges for green waste collection were not being progressed at this time.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo made reference to correspondence exchanged between himself and Councillor Gribble back in September 2025 that had culminated in an email on 13 January 2026.
Councillor McMurdo – Supplementary Question Councillor McMurdo queried whether it was a continued intention to reduce highway maintenance more generally in the rural areas.
Councillor McMurdo highlighted his concerns about due process and whether the motion was accurate in referring concerns to the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, rather than the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the report be received and the recommendation therein be approved.
Councillor McMurdo gave an accompanying presentation during which it was noted that:
Councillor McMurdo placed on record his thanks to the Pensions Team and Members of the Pension Fund Committee.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo requested clarification of statements made at the last Full Council meeting on 15 January 2025 pertaining to the proposed multi-storey car park near Bedford Hospital.
After hearing that this would have to be funded by the NHS, Councillor McMurdo had contacted the relevant agencies. He had been advised by East West Rail Company that there was no expectation for the hospital to provide any capital funding for this. He had also contacted the hospital trust and had been advised that this was problematic in that spend had to be approved through the Department for Health and Social Care through a capital and infrastructure approval process.
Councillor McMurdo – Statement Councillor McMurdo stated that this was not his understanding of the situation and that capital funding was not expected. He cautioned against making comments that could be construed as scaremongering and feared that this is what had happened in this instance.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo, commenting that he had had to attend several meetings in an attempt to receive a response from the Mayor to his question, asked again about the statement posted by the Mayor on social media about the impact of the introduction of 4 hours free car parking in the town centre and an alleged increase in visits to the town centre of 1 million per month. In the Mayor’s absence, he asked where this figure had been derived from.
Councillor McMurdo – Statement Councillor McMurdo stated that it was alarming that figures could be put in the public domain that ... view the full minutes text for item 77.
Councillor McMurdo referred to a question asked by [name removed] about flood risk and possible lowering of the track near the Ouse.
Prior to the submission of Councillor Gribble’s motion, Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Vann seconded, to continue the sitting of Full Council over four hours, until the conclusion of business, in accordance with Full Council Procedure Rule 22. This was carried.
Conservative Group Councillor Coombes to fill the vacancies on Budget & Corporate Services Overview & Scrutiny Committee and Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee Councillor Sira to replace Councillor Gambold on Budget & Corporate Services Overview & Scrutiny Committee Councillor Gambold to fill the vacancy on Environment & Sustainable Communities Overview & Scrutiny Committee Councillor Mahboob Din would fill the Independent vacancy on Adult Services Overview & Scrutiny Committee Councillor McMurdo would fill the Independent vacancy on Health Overview & Scrutiny Committee The appointments were agreed.
Councillor McMurdo – Question In the Mayor’s absence, Councillor McMurdo asked the Deputy Mayor whether he agreed that the Executive had approved the fees and charges for the year commencing 1 January 2025 at its last meeting on 20 November 2024.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo referred to page 16 of the Minutes, which detailed the discussion of the proposed fees and charges for 2025. He further queried whether, in the Deputy Mayor’s view, it was his understanding that it was an Executive function to both agree the fees and charges and to ensure that these were properly executed.
Councillor McMurdo – Statement Councillor McMurdo commented that, whilst in the Minute it did refer to minor amendments being delegated to Officers, as far as he was concerned, it was a function of the Executive. He added that the Mayor was on record as stating that other Councillors had voted for the increases and had also attempted to deflect the issue by stating that town centre visits had increased by “up to 1 million visits per month” as a result of the four hour free parking.
Councillor McMurdo expressed the view that this was absurd, as an increase of that magnitude would be in the region of 30,000 to 40,000 additional movements in and out of the Council’s car parks per day. He invited the Mayor to respond to his observations on this statement.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo, noting that his second question had been for Councillor Spice, prefaced this by stating that he would be happy to accept a written response in her absence.
At page 8 of the bundle, the Minutes recorded the question asked by Councillor McMurdo at the last meeting about the demise of Bedford BID. He asked whether the Executive had had the opportunity to reflect on the comments he had made regarding the benefits of a Business Improvement District and the reasons behind the Council’s campaign against the renewal of the BID and whether it had considered its position in the late summer/autumn on this issue.
Councillor McMurdo – Supplementary Question Councillor McMurdo added that he could not recall the Council previously making a declaration before a decision was made, as had been the case in this circumstance, on a matter of such importance, with both Councillor Spice and the Mayor himself making comments prior to the ballot opposing the BID.
Councillor McMurdo made a statement on the above application.) (c) Erection of a two-storey teaching block to facilitate a 1FE school expansion (circa 300 pupils), and all associated car and cycle parking, hard and soft landscaping and associated infrastructure: Bedford Academy Mile Road Bedford MK42 9TR – Bedford Borough Council ( 24/00216/MDC3 – Item 2 on the Schedule ) The Chief Officer – Planning, Infrastructure & Economic Growth provided an update to condition numbers 5 and 8 with regard to the implementation period of the relevant details and to add a plan reference.
Therefore, the Parish Council will need to take a view on whether the speed limit will need to be 20mph or 30mph.” Councillor McMurdo thanked [name removed] for attending the meeting to introduce her petition.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Sawyer seconded, that the report be received and the recommendation therein be approved.
As part of his introduction to the report, Councillor McMurdo gave a presentation on the pension fund, including its composition, governance arrangements, performance, regulatory changes, investments and transition to responsible investments.
Councillor McMurdo highlighted that the Fund remained a signatory of the Stewardship Code.
In response to questions from Councillor Bywater on the level of investment in companies profiting from fossil fuel extraction, mining and other environmentally questionable practices, Councillor McMurdo commented that he was happy to provide information or meet with Councillor Bywater outsider of the meeting. The Council’s commitments did not extend to Bedfordshire Pension Fund, which was an independent entity.
Councillor McMurdo emphasised the importance placed on fiduciary duty, and in abiding with that, the Pension Fund was investing for several decades in the future.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo asked the Mayor, in light of comments he had made in support of the reinstatement of the Rural Affairs Committee at previous meetings, whether he would be acting upon these.
Councillor McMurdo – Supplementary Question Councillor McMurdo asked for clarification of the Mayor’s response.
Councillor McMurdo – Statement Councillor McMurdo expressed surprise at the comments made by the Mayor, the likes of which he had not heard during his years of service.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo sought assurances from the Mayor that, as the only registered trustee of a particular charity, as he was not in a position to manage this individually in any way, that this would be rectified as this was worrying from a governance standpoint. He had requested Officers to urgently call a meeting in order that other trustees could be appointed so that the role could be undertaken in accordance with the statutory obligations on the trust board. He asked when a meeting of the Mayor’s Charity would be called so that this situation could be resolved.
Councillor McMurdo – Supplementary Question Councillor McMurdo ... view the full minutes text for item 105.
Councillor McMurdo asked the Mayor if he had been invited to, and attended, the Boar’s Head Ceremony at the Swan Hotel on Boxing Day, to which the Mayor confirmed that he had.
That Councillor McMurdo be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal year.
Councillor McMurdo sought confirmation that these guidelines applied to all school staff, not just teaching staff, as this had not made clear in the covering report.
The Speaker moved and Councillor McMurdo seconded, that the outcome of the elections of Councillors on 4 May 2023, as set out in the report of the Chief Executive, be noted.
In response to a question from Councillor McMurdo, Councillor Vann confirmed that the Residential Extensions New Dwelling and Small Infill Development Policy was on the work programme of the Council’s Planning Policy Team for review following the completion of the Local Plan 2040 process.
Councillor McMurdo expressed the view that the scale of development proposed for Sharnbrook necessitated an additional two forms of entry at primary stage.
Councillor McMurdo advised that the Government had announced an additional fuel payment of £400 for households without a direct relationship to an electricity supplier, such as those living in park homes and care homes.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo asked the Mayor if he was aware that the Home Office had decided to use Sharnbrook Hotel, on Park Lane, as a refugee centre.
Councillor McMurdo – Short Statement Councillor McMurdo stated that he would be following this with great interest and that he was appalled to learn that the location had been chosen for what was being termed an “asylum hotel”. He had already contacted the local MP, Richard Fuller, who had responded and agreed that the location was unsuitable.
Councillor McMurdo was currently in the process of establishing a meeting of community leaders in Sharnbrook, including the Headteachers , GPs and others to discuss and highlight their concerns about the use of the proposed location in the way suggested.
The local flood group in Turvey were also wholesome in their praise for the Officer’s from the Borough, and I would also like to pass my thanks to them and Councillor McMurdo for pushing the EA into meeting with residents and myself on site. The problem has not gone away and the EA, after meeting on site in Turvey have gone to scope out how to rectify the sluice gate issues once water levels are lower. The gate has been stuck and not maintained for many months – some believe even years – what can we as a Borough do collectively to get a better response from the EA when impending disasters are highlighted?
The Chief Officer for Environment expressed his gratitude to the Council and its staff for all their hard work, and Councillor McMurdo wished to record his thanks for their ability to also deal with an incident which occurred with one of the three refuse vehicles on the A6. The Chief Officer for Environment also acknowledged the importance of fine tuning the collection and improving collection points for future bulky waste collections.
The Mayor – Question The Mayor asked Councillor McMurdo to provide an update on flood defences, specifically the sluice gates near Turvey Mill.
This view was supported by Councillor McMurdo.
Councillor McMurdo expressed his thanks to the Planning Policy Team and others in the Environment Directorate that had supported the development of the Local Plan 2040. He quoted from the inspection report on the Local Plan 2030 from December 2019 and commented on the importance of Neighbourhood Plans within the Council’s planning policy framework and recognised the significant efforts made by Parish Councils and local volunteers to produce these documents that had helped to identify development that would contribute to the Council’s five year land supply as required in the National Planning Policy Framework.
Councillor McMurdo reiterated his support for the Neighbourhood Planning process and thanked all those involved, recognising that it provided additional protection for rural communities.
(a) Joint Committee Organisation Representatives The Wixams Joint Corporate Issues Liaison Panel Councillors Coombes, Gallagher, Hill and Sultan (b) Advisory Forum Organisation Representatives Bedford Borough Admissions ForumCouncillor Valentine Portfolio Holder: Education and Children’s Services Bedford Borough Schools Forum Councillors Headley (Portfolio Holder for Finance, Risk and Welfare) and Valentine Portfolio Holder: Education and Children’s Services Treasury Management Advisory Panel The Mayor, Councillor Headley as Portfolio Holder for Finance, Risk and Welfare and Members of the Budget and Corporate Services Overview and Scrutiny Committee (c) Other Groups Organisation Representatives Corporate Parenting Panel Partnership GroupCouncillors Bywater, Hendrickx, Meader, Valentine (Portfolio Holder for Education and Children’s Services) and Walker (d) Outside Bodies Organisation Representatives Age UK Bedfordshire Councillor Crofts Anglian (Great Ouse) Regional Flood and Coastal Committee Councillor McMurdo Bedford and District Citizens Advice Bureau Management Committee Councillor Moon Bedford and District Gardeners’ Association Councillor Solomon Bedford Business Improvement District Councillor Royden Bedford & Milton Keynes Waterways Consortium Councillor McMurdo Bedford Philharmonia Trust Councillor Vann Bedfordshire Rural Communities Charity Councillors Crofts, Hill, Jackson and Moon Cauldwell Community Association’s
Both Councillor Atkins and Councillor McMurdo, as the Council’s representative on and Chair of the Bedfordshire and River Ivel Internal Drainage Board and a Member of the Regional Flood and Coastal Committee, recommended that Members read the Action Plan in detail and to re-familiarise themselves with the Section 19 report arising from the flood events of Christmas 2020.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Gambold seconded, that his biannual report to Full Council as Chair of the Pension Fund Committee be received and the recommendation therein be adopted.
Councillor McMurdo gave a presentation to accompany the report which included information on governance arrangements, investments, responsible investments and administration. The Bedfordshire Local Government Pension Scheme operated on behalf of 209 Employers and had a fund value of £2.9 billion. The administration of the scheme was highly regarded.
Councillor McMurdo thanked his fellow Pension Fund Committee Members for their assistance and support and requested that his thanks to the Pensions Team be recorded.
Councillor McMurdo reiterated his support for Neighbourhood Plans, particularly in the light of adverse comments being directed towards the Council about the reliance of the Council’s Local Plan upon local communities agreeing to the making of such plans.
As such, he referred the question to Councillor McMurdo as Chair of the Pension Fund Committee and commented that this issue was likely to be discussed later in the meeting as it was part of the motion submitted by Councillor Foley.
Councillor McMurdo had written formally to Luton Borough Council in his capacity as Chair of the Pension Fund and he expressed concern that the complete divestment, which would include investments in aviation, may have a devastating social and economic impact for that Council and the area it served. The Fund sought a fair and just transition away from investment in fossil fuels in a timely and appropriate fashion.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo asked Councillor Foley to confirm, as he would not be present in the meeting when Councillor Foley’s motion was discussed, that the date of 2025 for a move ... view the full minutes text for item 74.
Councillor McMurdo commented that he was encouraged by the number of Parish Councils who were adopting Neighbourhood Plans as, in addition to strengthening the Council’s position in relation to its five-year land supply as identified in the Local Plan 2030, it also offered protection to local areas, and he commended the making of the Plan accordingly.
Councillor McMurdo thanked [name removed] for organising this petition as the Council was keen to hear from residents and users of the facilities. He added that some of the comments made particularly resonated with him as the Portfolio Holder for Leisure and Culture. There had been ongoing discussions with Fusion around the contract and performance management.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Hill seconded, that Council asked the Executive to (1) continue to manage the contract with the provider, Fusion Lifestyle, and reopen its facilities as soon as they are confident that the necessary management arrangements and risk assessments concerning COVID-19 are in place in order to sustain the continued protection of the communities within the Borough; (2) revert to the Action Plan as agreed in December 2019 and ensure delivery of the service was in line with what the contract calls for taking ... view the full minutes text for item 125.
The Mayor moved and Councillor McMurdo seconded that the presentation be received.
Councillor McMurdo provided an update on the flood events and action that had been taken, as flood prevention was an important part of the Council’s role as a Lead Local Flood Authority.
Councillor McMurdo moved, and Councillor Weir seconded, that “the Council receive the petition, and acknowledge all the good work that consistently exists in protecting our residents and businesses in the Borough. The Council will set up a water management forum to include Councillors that will facilitate the promotion of good practice in and around our communities in relation to flood risk and communicate effectively with all partners and communities on all aspects of water management.” On the motion being put to the meeting, the Speaker declared it to be carried.
(Councillor McMurdo made a statement on the above application.) (d) Proposed extensions & alterations to Public House & residential development of 4 dwellings consisting of 2 three bed & 2 four bed dwellings with associated parking and access: The Chequers Inn High Street Yielden Bedford MK44 1AW – F&L Group - [name removed] (18/00949/FUL – Item 1 on the Schedule ) The Chief Officer – Planning & Infrastructure Development confirmed that the application had previously been deferred for negotiations.
Councillor McMurdo recognised the effort put in by all school staff, both teaching and support staff, during this difficult time.
Councillor McMurdo introduced his report and gave a presentation providing an update on the Bedfordshire Pension Fund. The presentation included information on the number of employers in the scheme, the geographical spread of members, the valuation of the Fund as at 31 December 2019, the Fund’ s investment and performance and involvement with pooling via Border to Coast Pensions Partnership and responsible investment.
Councillor McMurdo requested that his thanks to the Members of the Pensions Committee, the Fund Administrator and Fund Manager, the administration team and to [name removed], who after many years of serving as an employer representative, was standing down from the Committee, be recorded.
Councillor McMurdo moved and the Councillor Gambold seconded that the report be received.
In response to a question about responsible investment, Councillor McMurdo emphasised that the Pension Fund’s policy was engagement over divestment, as the Fund had a fiduciary duty to pay its liabilities.
(Note: In accordance with the ‘Right to Speak’ Scheme the Committee heard representations from an objector.) (Note: although not a Member of the Committee and he did not take part in this item, Councillor McMurdo disclosed a local interest in this application as he knew the owner of the garage.) (d) Erection of Advanced Manufacturing Facility under Use Class E(g) and associated works: Colworth Science Park Colworth Road Sharnbrook Bedfordshire MK44 1LQ - AG Colworth Park BV - [name removed] (20/02360/MAF – Item 5 on the Schedule) The Chief Officer – Planning & Infrastructure Development provided an update as follows:
In response to a question from Councillor McMurdo, the Mayor confirmed that the disposal of assets over a certain value required Executive approval.
Councillor McMurdo, as the Council’s appointed representative on the Environment Agency Regional Flooding Committee, commented that this was a long-standing issue dating back to 1985.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo referred to an email that had been sent to Members prior to the meeting suggesting that microphones be shared to reduce the feedback that had recently been experienced. He questioned whether this was sensible given the current epidemic and asked the Mayor to execute the purchase of a replacement system as soon as possible.
Reply by Councillor McMurdo (Portfolio Holder for Leisure and Culture) Councillor McMurdo echoed the thanks to the staff in the Corn Exchange and in other areas of the Council, such as ICT, for supporting this show.
Councillor McMurdo introduced his report and gave a presentation on flood risk management and response in Bedford Borough in response to questions raised by Councillor Wootton at the meeting of Full Council held on 15 January 2020.
Councillor McMurdo moved and he Mayor seconded that the report be received.
Councillor McMurdo referred to a consultation response requesting that information was made available in Plain English.
Councillor McMurdo introduced his report and gave a presentation providing an update on the Bedfordshire Pension Fund.
Councillor McMurdo moved and the Mayor seconded that the report be received.
Licensing Authority: Bedford Borough Council (as Licensing Authority) (represented by Mark Everett, Registration Officer (Licensing Compliance)) Interested Parties: Venessa Bolton (Objector), Bernard Green (Objector), John Greevy (Objector), Derek Hart (Objector), Dianne Hart (Objector), Julie Latimer (Objector), William Pinfold (Objector), David Waterfield (Objector), Heather Wildsmith (Objector), Councillor Doug McMurdo (Ward Councillor), and Helen Glanville (Sharnbrook Parish Council). (b) Application to be Determined The Hearing was to consider an application for the grant of a Premises Licence in respect of Tofte Manor Open Space, Souldrop Road, Sharnbrook, Bedford, MK44 1HH.
[name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) [name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) [name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) [name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) [name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) [name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) [name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) [name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) [name removed] (Local Resident – Objector) Councillor D McMurdo (Ward Councillor – Objector) [name removed] (Sharnbrook Parish Council – Objector) [name removed] (Environmental Health – Observing) [name removed] (Observing) [name removed] (Observing) [name removed] (Observing) [name removed] (Bedfordshire Police – Observing) [name removed] (Observing) Preliminary Points The Chair confirmed that Members of the Sub-Committee had been asked to attend a site visit at Tofte Manor, as well as the surrounding area, so that it could be seen from the residents’ perspective.
Councillor McMurdo, whilst placing on record his support of the Plan, expressed concerns on behalf of the rural area of the Borough, particularly Sharnbrook, as the area he represented as Ward Councillor. The proposed growth of the village by 500 homes would cause pressure on already strained highways infrastructure.
Reply by Councillor McMurdo, the Portfolio Holder for Leisure and Culture Councillor McMurdo confirmed that he was already in discussions with [name removed] in this respect.
In response to a question from Members of the Board, Cllr McMurdo commented that Government criteria required all pension funds to invest in infrastructure and that funds previously allocated to Trilogy, and currently allocated to a passive LGIM fund, were due to be transferred to Border to Coast Pensions Partnership (BCCP). The Committee had agreed to allocate 5% of the Bedfordshire Pension Fund (BPF) to the BCPP Infrastructure Fund at this time.
Cllr McMurdo confirmed that the Committee placed a high priority on ensuring that investments were ethical.
Cllr McMurdo commented that there was a need to agree a confidentiality agreement to be signed by all Chairs in relation to the consideration of commercially sensitive papers in the course of meetings.
(Note: In accordance with the ‘Right to Speak’ Scheme the Committee heard representations from objectors.) (Councillor McMurdo made a statement on the above application.) (c) Change of use and conversion of Baptist Chapel from B1 offices to residential accommodation (C3) including internal alterations and the removal of some headstones within the grounds: 27 High Street Sharnbrook Bedford MK44 1PG. (18/01772/LBC – Item 3 on the Schedule) RESOLVED :
It was moved by the Mayor and seconded by Councillor Rider that the Council’s appreciation of Councillor McMurdo for the excellent work he had undertaken as Speaker of the Council during the Municipal Year 2018/19 be recorded.
The Mayor and Councillors Coombes, Oliver and Meader also expressed on behalf of their Groups, appreciation to Councillor McMurdo for his work as Speaker.
There being no other nominations for the office of Speaker, the Speaker declared Councillor McMurdo to be elected.
Councillor McMurdo then made and subscribed the statutory Declaration of Acceptance of Office and presided over the remainder of the meeting, as Speaker.
(1) Request for review of all aspects of highway safety relating to the A6 northwards from Paula Radcliffe Way, Bedford to the Northamptonshire County boundary Councillor McMurdo introduced a petition consisting of 72 signatures from residents of Sharnbrook Ward and the surrounding area which requested the Council to review all aspects of highway safety relating to the A6 northwards from Paula Radcliffe Way, Bedford to the Northamptonshire County boundary.
In introducing the petition, Councillor McMurdo advised that he had started the petition as a result of a petition attracting over 500 signatures that was being directed through a channel which would bypass the Council.
Councillor McMurdo advised that a safety audit of this part of the A6 had been undertaken over three years ago by Amey , the Council’s contractors at the time and requested that another assessment of the A6 from Paula Radcliffe and the Northamptonshire County boundary be completed, with particular consideration being given to the junctions at Templars Way, Sharnbrook and Park Lane, Sharnbrook, which was often referred to as the smallest dual carriageway in the country.
Councillor Royden moved, and Councillor McMurdo seconded, that that the Council should note that works were currently programmed to take place on the A6 at Souldrop on 26 February to 6 March and night time resurfacing works between the 6-9 March to tackle accidents on the A6 at Souldrop , most involving motorcyclists overtaking and then colliding with right-turning vehicles. Site observations have shown that northbound vehicles undertake using the existing auxillary lane to bypass vehicles waiting to turn right near the filling station. The measures included double white lining with reflective road studs, removal of the existing auxiliary turning, rumble strips, resurfacing of the junction and upgrade to street lighting, etc.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Thank you [name removed] for allowing me to ask the questions. A very good evening to you and Members of the Executive. I have two questions.
Cllr McMurdo, whilst acknowledging the need for the Council to revise its senior management structure to align with the Digital Operating Model and to achieve the financial savings required, sought an assurance that appropriate arrangements were being put in place to manage the significant changes associated with implementing the new corporate structure. The Chair noted that the Committee, at its meeting held on 22 March 2017, had likewise registered its concerns at the potential risks associated with the loss of experience and corporate memory and had emphasised the importance of making transitional arrangements to mitigate potential risks in this area. The Chief Executive confirmed that appropriate arrangements were being put in place to manage the change process and to transfer skills and knowledge, as required.
There being no other nominations for the office of Deputy Speaker, the Speaker declared Councillor McMurdo to be appointed.
The Speaker sought nominations from Council Members to represent the Bedfordshire Pension Fund at the Joint Committee meetings and Councillor S Hunt proposed and Councillor W Hunt seconded that Councillor McMurdo be nominated.
Having requested further nominations and there being none, the Speaker declared Councillor McMurdo to be duly appointed.
The Chair was pleased to welcome Councillor McMurdo, as Chair of the Bedfordshire Pensions Fund Committee (BPFC), together with the Pension Fund Administrator and the Head of Pensions, who were attending the meeting in order to respond to any questions and comments from Members regarding the proposed pooling arrangements as part of BCPP.
Councillor McMurdo moved and Councillor Gambold seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
That Councillor McMurdo be appointed Vice-Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
That Councillor McMurdo be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor McMurdo asked the Committee to ensure in future that, throughout its reports, references to people or areas of the Borough be clearly identified. He cited examples in the reports before the Committee at this meeting including one in the Homelessness Strategy and Review agenda item where the report referred to Bedford based agencies and organisations implying that none existed in the rural parts of the Borough when one was, for example, based in Carlton.
Councillor McMurdo asked that reports should indicate as necessary whether the town of Bedford itself, the rural areas of the Borough or the Borough as a whole was being referred to.
Councillor McMurdo – Question On 9 March 2016 the northern part of the Borough suffered from a high level of rainfall amounting to 40 millimetres over a 24 hour period. Can the Portfolio Holder provide an update on how the local Flood Authority assisted local communities?
Councillor McMurdo – Supplementary Question The flooding in Riseley High Street was particularly serious and to see flood waters to a depth of one metre was upsetting. Does the Portfolio Holder agree that partners and organisations must be mindful of the risks of flooding which are here to stay?
Councillor McMurdo – Statement I would like to thank Officers and all agencies involved that helped the community following the excessive rainfall on 9 March 2016, which was devastating for all those affected. I would reiterate that flooding was an issue which was here to stay and would highlight that some parts of the urban area which were affected by flooding were not the responsibility of the Environment Agency as these were ... view the full minutes text for item 119.
Councillor McMurdo moved and Councillor S Hunt seconded that the report be received.
Councillor McMurdo – Statement I previously attended meetings of the Environment Agency, as the Council’s representative up until May/June 2015. I have also been meeting with Officers in the Council’s Resilience Team to discuss the flooding issues and will report back to the Portfolio Holder on this matter.
The Mayor – Question Would the Deputy Mayor join me in congratulating Councillor McMurdo on his appointment to the Chair of the Internal Drainage Board?
Reply by Councillor Royden (Portfolio Holder for Environment and Transport) Councillor Royden responded that he would like to add his congratulations to Councillor McMurdo and was pleased that he had been recognised by the ... view the full minutes text for item 73.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Councillor McMurdo sought and received agreement from the Committee that they were content for him to be put forward as a member of the Local Authority Pension Fund Forum (LAPFF) Executive.
That Councillor McMurdo be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor McMurdo asked if the Committee was aware that public planning files could now only be viewed at the Council’s Customer Service Centre. Whilst this was not necessarily a problem, he had taken up a lot of the Customer Advisor’s time at the desk but had only been able to view comments on planning applications received from statutory consultees and neighbours, not any responses made to those comments by applicants. The Chair advised that she was not aware of this issue.
Councillor McMurdo also asked, as this was the last meeting of the Committee before the Local Elections, about the position in relation to any applications deferred to enable Members to carry out a site inspection.
Councillor McMurdo moved and Councillor Olney seconded that the report be received.
Councillors Mingay, S Hunt and Olney (on behalf of Councillor McMurdo) and the Mayor each paid tribute to the life and work of the late Councillor Pearson.
That Councillor McMurdo be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Following a request at the meeting of Full Council held on 26 March 2014, Councillor McMurdo gave a presentation to the Committee on his work with the Environment Agency in his role as the Council’s representative on the Anglia (Central) Regional Flood and Coastal Committee.
Councillor McMurdo highlighted issues relating to permitted development in flood plain and riparian ownership and the consequent increase to flood risk to people and property.
In response to questions, Councillor McMurdo advised that the Environment Agency had recognised its weaknesses and had removed one of its layers so that it could become more responsive in future.
In response to a further question, Councillor McMurdo confirmed that the Environment Agency was responsible for monitoring levels of pollution in main rivers.
Reply by Councillor McMurdo (Portfolio Holder for Leisure and Culture) Councillor McMurdo responded that he would liaise with Officers in Members’ Services and make arrangements to attend the relevant Committee.
Councillor McMurdo moved and the Councillor S Hunt seconded that the report be received and that the recommendation be adopted.
Councillor McMurdo acknowledged Trevor Roff ’s role as Pension Fund Administrator since the Council had become an Unitary Authority and wished to place on record his thanks for the work he had undertaken during that time.
Councillor McMurdo commented that he understood that Central Bedfordshire Council, in December 2013, had withdrawn from the Bedfordshire Energy and Recycling project ( BEaR ) and he enquired whether there would be any impact from their withdrawal on the Local Plan which was under consideration.
That Councillor McMurdo be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor McMurdo referred to the weekly lists of planning applications which were circulated electronically and asked if it would be possible for a link to the individual applications to be included.
Councillor McMurdo expressed concern that the former County Council had not set aside a provision for the outstanding claim and had not advised the Borough Council of this liability. He added that it was important to learn lessons from the contract so that these issues did reoccur in the future.
Councillor McMurdo expressed his thanks to the Officers responsible for Service Areas within his Portfolio and had been encouraged that the outstanding debt owed by Central Bedfordshire Council had reduced significantly.
That Councillor McMurdo be elected Chair of the Committee for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor McMurdo commented that the Council had been able to maintain the Blue Peris Outdoor Education Centre during difficult challenges, particularly in discretionary services and he added that the service planned to break even by the end of the year. He took the opportunity to thank all staff concerned in Leisure Services.
(Note: The Mayor and Councillor Royden were not present for the discussion on this question having each disclosed a personal and prejudicial interest in this matter.) Councillor McMurdo – Question You will be aware that I spoke with Milton Ernest Parish Council regarding the incinerator issue before the Executive meeting held on 7 December 2011?
Reply by Councillor Sawyer (Chair of the Executive meeting held on 7 December 2011 when the item relating to the Rookery South (Resource Recovery Facility) Order 2011 was discussed) Councillor Sawyer responded that he did not recollect that Councillor McMurdo had spoken on this particular issue.
Councillor McMurdo – Statement I can confirm that I did liaise with the Parish Council on this matter.
Councillor Wootton - Question I would like to know, how many thousands of pounds of Council money you spent, the week of the organised walk with the concerned Conservative Group Members and Councillor McMurdo, in order to improve the C44 that still no children have, or will ever use. We are concerned that considering that whilst there will be no savings made by cutting the Roxton school bus, are you spending taxpayers money on putting up additional road signs, butchering trees and widening paths when no-one will ever ... view the full minutes text for item 84.
Councillor McMurdo moved and Councillor S Hunt seconded that the report be received.
Councillor McMurdo referred to the lack of provision for ... view the full minutes text for item 75.
11/00547/S73 (Schedule) Councillor Wootton Personal and Prejudicial – he had two children who were pupils at Rushmoor School Absent (In addition, Councillor McMurdo, who was present as a ward member in the Public Gallery to speak on Application 11/00549/LBC (Minute 9(l) below), disclosed a personal and prejudicial interest in Application 10/02204/DC3 (Minute 9(b) below) as he was the relevant Portfolio Holder. He left the meeting during the discussion and decision making and voting on this item.) Chair
Councillor McMurdo requested written details of the Council’s Planning Service Policy on consultation of planning applications to Parish Councils.
The Mayor moved and Councillor McMurdo seconded that the report of the Director of Finance and Corporate Services be received and that the recommendations be adopted.
Councillor McMurdo commented that the decision by a neighbouring Authority to remove support for Outdoor Education had had a consequent effect on council taxpayers.
Councillor McMurdo moved and Councillor S Hunt seconded that the report be received.
Councillor McMurdo – Question Has the criteria for Rural Grants as set out at Appendix A to report item 5 been amended?
Councillor McMurdo – Question One of the reasons for refusal for a grant to Sharnbrook Parish Council was that it had received in excess of £93,000 of rural grant funding since 2001. Which criteria does this refusal relate to?
“Levels of past funding by the Borough to individual Parish Council areas and Parish precepts may be taken in to account in assessing new grant requests.” Councillor McMurdo – Statement I would suggest that in future, if there is a revised issue of criteria, it might help to include the date of its issue. The Mayor – Question Would it be possible to include in future lists of grants approved, a figure to represent the level of grant awarded per number of electors in the Parish?
Councillor McMurdo - Question Could the Portfolio Holder for Children’s Services update the Council following the Remit meeting relating to the School Reorganisation Review which took place on 27 January 2010?
Councillor McMurdo – Statement I was aware of the press release, however, I would make the comment that issues such as these should be notified direct to Members as soon as possible.
Councillor McMurdo - Question With regard to the proposed merger between Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire Police, I found an article from the Welwyn and Hatfield Times which stated that the local MP had launched a campaign to stop the merger. What is the Borough Council doing to keep in touch with the Police Authority’s proposals?
That Councillor McMurdo be appointed Vice-Chair of the Board for the remainder of the current Municipal Year.
Councillor McMurdo reported that earlier in the current Municipal Year he had requested that a review of gritting be carried out. Since 18 December 2009 to the current time the weather had been bad. He considered it remiss that the review had not been carried out as it was several years since the criteria for gritting in adverse weather conditions had been decided.
Councillor McMurdo – Question I note that leaves have been collected recently in the urban area. Will this also take place in rural areas?
In response to a question from Councillor McMurdo on how the Committee would review the salting of roads, the Head of Highways advised that the Winter Maintenance Plan for 2009 had already been agreed. However, a wider review of the Maintenance Plan was proposed and the Committee would be able to review the proposals before the Plan for 2010 was approved.
Councillor McMurdo expressed concern that not enough importance had been given to the rural areas in previous years when agreeing the Winter Maintenance Plan.
The Mayor moved, and Councillor McMurdo seconded, that Margaret Davey of 61 Waterloo Road, Bedford, a Councillor of the Borough, be appointed Deputy Speaker of the Council for the Municipal Year 2009/10.
Councillor Brandon moved, and Councillor McMurdo seconded, that Councillor Davey be appointed to serve on the Joint Selection Committee. On the motions being put to the meeting, the Speaker declared them to be carried.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor McMurdo attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor McMurdo's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor McMurdo was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 16 of 22 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor McMurdo declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 Jan 2021 | Planning Committee, item 117 | (Note: In accordance with the ‘Right to Speak’ Scheme the Committee heard representations from an objector.) (Note: although not a Member of the Committee and he did not take part in this item, Councillor McMurdo disclosed a local interest in this application as he knew the owner of the garage.) (d) Erection of Advanced Manufacturing Facility under Use Class E(g) and associated works: Colworth Science Park Colworth Road Sharnbrook Bedfordshire MK44 1LQ - AG Colworth Park BV - [name removed] (20/02360/MAF – Item 5 on the Schedule) The Chief Officer – Planning & Infrastructure Development provided an update as follows: | Took no part |
Where Councillor McMurdo sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full Council | Committee Member | Jul 2009 | 6 | |
| Pension Fund Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2009 | 5 | |
| Executive | Observer | Jan 2026 | 3 | |
| Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 3 | |
| Finance and Improvement Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2026 | 3 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| Primary and Secondary Education | Committee Member | Mar 2026 | 2 | |
| Industry Estate Management Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 1 | 12 Jan 2027 |
| General Purposes Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 1 | 12 Jan 2027 |
| Environment, Regeneration and Corporate Services Policy Review and Development Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2009 | 2 | |
| Audit Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2009 | 1 | |
| Rural Affairs Committee | Non-elected, non-voting | Sep 2009 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.