Future delivery of the Council's Housing Stock Condition Survey
Councillor Kirkham left the meeting at 10.40 am.
Every time Bolsover's minutes name Councillor Kirkham, as the council published it.
Councillor Kirkham left the meeting at 10.40 am.
The application had been referred to the Committee for determination following a call-in request from Councillor Tom Kirkham.
Councillor Tom Kirkham raised concerns with aspects of the application.
Councillor Kirkham entered the meeting at this point.
Moved by Councillor Tom Kirkham and seconded by Councillor Cathy Jeffery RESOLVED that 1) the Internal Audit Charter be agreed, 2) the be reviewed annually or sooner in the event of any significant changes to the Internal Audit function or the GIAS.
Councillor Tom Kirkham highlighted that the Auditors had raised issues in respect of material errors on the group accounts on page 33 and that residents were concerned about the perceived rising costs and issues with big building projects such as the Crematorium and regeneration projects.
In view of the Dragonfly Review being almost complete and need to review this report Councillor Tom Kirkham questioned whether it would be possible to arrange an Extraordinary meeting to review and discuss these together with the Auditors .
Moved by Councillor Duncan Haywood and seconded by Councillor Tom Kirkham and RESOLVED to recommend the disestablishment of the Employment and Personnel Committee to Council.
Councillor Tom Kirkham asked for an example of these type of changes and the Monitoring Officer cited there could be changes in the functions and roles of Directors or officers which could not currently be updated during reviews. It was purely about enabling the tidying up of the constitution and not allocation of new powers.
Councillor Tom Kirkham requested an update on the two complaints which had no information and the Monitoring Officer confirmed that he had agreed with the complainants that he would speak to the councillor concerned about the matter.
In response to a question the Monitoring Officer confirmed that discussion had taken place about the membership and attendance of Councillor Tom Kirkham at the Local Growth Scrutiny Committee. As he was now Junior Cabinet Member for Growth he would be replaced on the committee at Annual Council.
Councillor Tom Kirkham sought clarity on the continued scrutiny of Dragonfly Shareholder Board updates at Local Growth Scrutiny Committee, with the reduced number of meetings how would updates and the findings of the independent review be reported?
Councillor Tom Kirkham asked whether the membership and scope of the Shareholders Board could include more councillors?
Councillor Tom Kirkham suggested that as housing was a priority for the Council, more homes should be built and perhaps this could be extended into buying properties as well?
Councillor Tom Kirkham confirmed that a large proportion of funding for the LEPs traditionally went to the cities such as Nottingham and Derby and that Bolsover District Council may be better placed with other similar sized organisations such as Bassetlaw and Mansfield to have more say and equitable share of funding.
Moved by Councillor Tom Kirkham and seconded by Councillor Will Fletcher RESOLVED that the report be noted.
Moved by Councillor Tom Kirkham and seconded by Councillor Jane Yates RESOLVED that Members review the Programme contact the Scrutiny Officer should they have any queries regarding future meetings.
Councillor Tom Kirkham declared an interest in Pleasley Pit Trust.
Councillor Tom Kirkham moved to reject the recommendations within the report which was seconded by Councillor Justin Gilbody and following a vote it was RESOLVED that the recommendations in the report be rejected and not to change the rules relating to the granting of dispensations.
Councillor Tom Kirkham declared that he was a member of the Pleasley Park and Vale Conservation Area Joint Working Group.
Councillor Kirkham queried what provisions were in place to ensure the Council still received value for money and the same level of transparency as in open tenders when awarding contracts to Dragonfly. The Monitoring Officer replied that each case would be considered on its own merits, and if it were in the best interest of the Council or if it were more appropriate to go out to full tender.
Councillor Kirkham noted that a key element of the Service Level Agreement with Dragonfly related to value for money and the performance of Dragonfly and Members had been advised they would receive updates from the Monitoring Officer regarding the Dragonfly Shareholder Board. However, Members had not received these updates nor seen agendas and minutes from the meetings. He added that if the Council was going to award directly to Dragonfly, and as a wholly owned company of the Council, Members were to help steer and direct it to the Council’s priorities and also have more of a say in Dragonfly, then Members needed to see the agendas and Minutes and be able to attend Shareholder Board meetings.
Councillor Tom Kirkham, Chair of Local Growth Scrutiny Committee, provided an update to Members on the work that had been recently undertaken by the Committee.
Councillor Tom Kirkham provided Members of the Committee with background information in relation to the Skills Hub. The appendices attached to the report contained previous Executive and Local Growth Scrutiny Committee reports and also the relevant information relating to the call in of the item.
Councillor Tom Kirkham expressed his interest in being a Member on the Shareholder Board.
Moved by Councillor Tom Kirkham and seconded by Councillor Duncan Haywood.
Moved by Councillor Tom Kirkham and seconded by Councillor Will Fletcher RESOLVED that the draft Bolsover District Area Tourism Strategy and action plan be submitted to Executive for approval.
Moved by Councillor Tom Kirkham and seconded by Councillor Phil Smith RESOLVED that the List of Key Decisions and items to be considered in private document be noted.
A vote was held on the appointment of Chair of the Local Growth Scrutiny Committee, nominations had been received for both Councillor Tom Kirkham and Councillor Deborah Watson.
Councillor Tom Kirkham was appointed as Chair of the Local Growth Scrutiny Committee.
Moved by Councillor Tom Kirkham and seconded by Councillor David Dixon.
In addition to this, the Monitoring Officer advised Members of an email sent to Councillor Tom Kirkham from the potential d elivery partner for Proposal 2 but again this provided no further commitment from them.
Councillor Tom Kirkham abstained from voting.
Moved by Councillor Tom Kirkham and seconded by Councillor David Dixon.
Moved by Councillor Jen Wilson and seconded by Councillor Tom Kirkham.
Councillor Tom Kirkham questioned why Proposal 1 had been chosen as the preferred site for the Future Skills Hub. He stated that in his opinion, Proposal 2 was the better option and that the officer’s report indicated that this site would have a bigger impact. He requested more clarity of the decision made by Executive.
Councillor Tom Kirkham read out a message from Councillor Derek Adams, a signatory of the Notice of Call-In Request, commenting on the need to create a relationship with providers (as per Proposal 2) that were willing to develop post-16 education provision within the District.
Councillor Tom Kirkham agreed with this approach in part but felt that all four Frameworks needed review due to the length of time since publication (2016). He also felt that there were lots of cross-cutting issues that could be further highlighted.
It was noted that a glamping pods had recently set up in the Stanfree area and there was the potential to redevelop part of the Oxcroft Miners Welfare site Cllr Kirkham queried the planned delivery via Prop Tech II and the Digital Planning improvements.
Councillor Tom Kirkham believed it would be beneficial for current Audit Members to undergo Audit refresher training in order to better support the 2023 intake of elected Members.
(Head of Finance and Resources/Governance Manager) Councillor Tom Kirkham left the meeting at this point.
Question submitted by Councillor Tom Kirkham to the Leader of the Council;
As a Pleasley Parish Councillor, Councillor Kirkham firstly spoke about Caroline Randall - She was the first female chair that we had at the council and shortly after being elected she found out she was ill – she fought the illness with bravery and courage – she was somebody who would go out of their way to do anything for anybody and she raised money during her illness and continued to attend meetings and she will be missed.
I thought this would be interesting for Councillors to know Chair, and hopefully that will help Councillor Kirkham and the residents of Glapwell to understand that there are benefits derived from that particular decision.
Supplementary Question form Councillor Kirkham;
Councillor Tom Kirkham queried if there were any future plans to put monitoring points in around areas such as schools.
In response to a question from Councillor Tom Kirkham in relation to the Government’s Levelling Up agenda, the Assistant Director of Finance & Resources replied that the Council was currently unsure of what impact this would have on the Council’s finances.
Councillor Tom Kirkham asked which policies were in place to cover teams who had officers with long-term sickness absence. The HR and Organisational Development Manager explained that there was a Sickness Absence Policy in place, and managers were asked for ways they can be supported.
Councillor Tom Kirkham left the meeting during the following item of business.
Councillor Tom Kirkham asked the UNISON representatives how many of their members had been struggling with mental health and finance in the pandemic. Kevin Shillitto (UNISON) explained that unions nationwide had been receiving increased requests for support.
Prevent and Relief Homelessness Enable Supported Housing/Housing with Care for People with Physical Disability/Mental ill health/Domestic Violence/Complex Needs Older People’s Housing Accommodation and Support Support Care Leavers Support Armed Forces Personnel and their Families Disabled Facilities Grant /Home Improvements/Energy Efficiency Councillor Tom Kirkham asked how the Housing Strategy worked in terms of Bolsover Homes providing different types of housing to meet demand. The Housing Policy and Intelligence Officer explained that the Strategy was a document to highlight overarching housing need and to show external companies what the Council was doing in terms of Housing, and a document to seek funding opportunities rather than a document to directly address housing need demand for individual sites. The Head of Property Services & Housing Repairs added that whenever a site was put forward for housing use, the officers in Housing Needs were always consulted with on how many would need to be provided.
Councillor Tom Kirkham asked the Chair if he could pay tribute to the late Councillor James Watson before the formal part of the meeting ended, and she granted his request.
Councillor Tom Kirkham spoke about how Councillor James Watson was a Member of Growth Committee and had been a great help during the call-in review of the sale of land at Glapwell in 2020.
The Chair thanked Councillor Tom Kirkham for his warm tribute and added that her thoughts were with the family of Councillor James Watson.
Councillor Tom Kirkham referred to the section titled ‘Pensions’ in the summary of audit work in the report, and asked if pensions would be impacted by COVID-19. Mark Surridge informed Members that it would have an impact on pension fund assets in the short-term because the market value of the assets in the middle of the pandemic was sometimes unknown. He added that the long-term impact would not be fully understood until the Mazars tri-annual review in three years.
The two recommendations were moved by Councillor Jim Clifton and seconded by Councillor Tom Kirkham.
Moved by Councillor James Watson and seconded by Councillor Tom Kirkham that a scoping exercise in relation to a review of the relationship and contracts awarded to Robert Woodhead, be undertaken by Committee at its meeting in November.
Committee heard from the three signatories to the call in, starting with Councillor Tricia Clough as the lead signatory, followed by Councillor Tom Kirkham and Councillor Anne Clarke.
Councillor Tom Kirkham referred to the Leader of the Council’s new Corporate Vision and asked if the proposed Framework in the Risk Management Strategy ... view the full minutes text for item 590.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Kirkham attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Kirkham's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Kirkham was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 3 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Kirkham declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 Nov 2024 | Local Growth Scrutiny Committee, item LOC23-24/25 | Councillor Tom Kirkham declared an interest in Pleasley Pit Trust. | |
| 29 Apr 2024 | Local Growth Scrutiny Committee, item LOC52-21/22 | Councillor Tom Kirkham declared that he was a member of the Pleasley Park and Vale Conservation Area Joint Working Group. |
Where Councillor Kirkham sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Mar 2021 | 5 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Local Growth Scrutiny Committee | Vice-Chair | Aug 2022 | 4 | |
| Audit Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2020 | 2 | |
| Growth Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2021 | 1 | |
| Audit & Corporate Overview Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jul 2022 | 1 | |
| Union / Employee Consultation Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.