Named20 May 2026Council
Appointment of the Leader of the Council
This was instead followed by Councillor Lorber formally moving the nomination of Councillor Georgiou to the office of Leader of the Council along with an amendment to the term of office for the position, on the basis that any appointment be for a one rather than four year term of office.
Said23 Feb 2026Council
Procedural Motion - Conduct of Business
Prior to being put to the vote, Councillor Lorber (as Leader of the Liberal Democrats Group) spoke to highlight his objection to the proposed timing for the length of his speech in response to the Leader having moved the budget proposals, during the budget debate. As a result of the concerns expressed, he therefore moved an amendment to the proposed timings outlined within the procedural motion designed to provide the Leaders of all Opposition Groups with up to 10 minutes each to speak when responding to the budget and moving their alternative proposals.
Named23 Feb 2026Council
Members' Allowance Scheme Annual Review 2026-27
Having thanked Councillor Mili Patel, the Mayor then drew members attention to an amendment submitted by Councillor Lorber on behalf of the Liberal Democrats Group to the proposed Members Allowance Scheme, which had been circulated in advance of the meeting.
Said23 Feb 2026Council
Members' Allowance Scheme Annual Review 2026-27
In moving the amendment, Councillor Lorber felt it important to reflect on the nature of the budget debate which had been undertaken at the meeting and current financial pressures being experienced by the Council, which he felt supported the need for a wider review of expenditure across a number of areas including the provision of Special Responsibility Allowances relating to a number of positions within the current members allowance scheme which it was also felt reflected the need for a wider democratic reset.
Moved23 Feb 2026Council
Members' Allowance Scheme Annual Review 2026-27
On this basis, the amendment moved by Councillor Lorber was as follows:
Named23 Feb 2026Council
Members' Allowance Scheme Annual Review 2026-27
The Mayor thanked Councillor Lorber for moving the amendment before inviting other members to speak, with the following contribution received.
Named23 Feb 2026Council
Members' Allowance Scheme Annual Review 2026-27
With no other members indicating they wished to speak the Mayor then invited Councillor Mili Patel (as mover of the report) followed by Councillor Lorber (as mover of the amendment) to exercise their right of reply.
Said13 Jan 2026Council
Representation of Political Groups on Committees
In commenting on the nature of the meeting, Councillor Lorber highlighted his concern at the need to have convened an Extraordinary meeting for the purpose of confirming the outcome of the political balance review given the time and resource involved. Given the concerns outlined, he felt these supported the need for a change in regulations enabling either a simpler process to be followed in seeking to approve the changes based on a process of consultation between the Groups or the meeting to be held online and hoped members would support the need for continued lobbying on such an approach.
Named10 Nov 2025Council
Non Cabinet Members' Debate
Members were advised that the motion submitted as the basis for the debate had been circulated with the agenda and that the time available for the debate was 25 minutes before inviting Councillor Lorber to introduce the motion which had been submitted (on behalf of the Liberal Democrats Group) as the basis for the Non-Cabinet Member debate.
Named10 Nov 2025Council
Non Cabinet Members' Debate
In introducing the motion, Councillor Lorber began by highlighting concern at the delay in delivery of the change promised by the government following the last election in terms of the financial support that local authorities such as Brent urgently required. As a result, it was pointed out that the Council was still awaiting provision of the multi-year funding settlements needed to plan ahead and invest efficiently, with the motion moved as the basis for the debate seeking to outline the resulting impact of the ongoing uncertainty on the ability to invest in essential services and rebuild local infrastructure.
Said10 Nov 2025Council
Non Cabinet Members' Debate
Referring to the Council’s own budget forecasts, Councillor Lorber outlined how these had shown continued shortfalls in funding for street maintenance, waste and recycling, local infrastructure and adult and children’s social care with demand and costs continuing to increase making it more challenging to prioritise those issues being highlighted by residents as concerns.
Said10 Nov 2025Council
Non Cabinet Members' Debate
In recognising the additional burdens being placed on local authorities and the lack of supporting funding in relation to the increased demand on temporary accommodation, Adult and Children’s Social Care and challenges needing to be address in health and social care provision, Councillor Lorber advised the motion was therefore calling on the Council to use its influence in calling for the government to honour their commitment to the provision of multi-year financial settlements, the fair funding review alongside greater flexibility to raise and manage revenue locally in order to provide greater stability and certainty on the essential investment required to deliver clean and safe neighbourhoods and effective public services that worked. On this basis the motion was moved as the basis of the debate.
Named10 Nov 2025Council
Non Cabinet Members' Debate
The Mayor thanked Councillor Lorber for introducing the motion and then opened the debate for contributions from other members.
Declared4 Nov 2025Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interests
Similarly, Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest in respect of Agenda Item 8: Voluntary, Community and Social Enterprise (VCSE) sector in Brent, noting that he served as a trustee for a number of charities operating within Brent.
Declared15 Sep 2025Council
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest in respect of Agenda Item 9.2 (Liberal Democrats Motion – Standing United against Racism & Xenophobia in Brent) and Agenda Item 14 (Non Cabinet Member Debate – Deterrence, Integration & Accommodation Impacts of Illegal Immigration on Brent) as someone who had initially entered the UK as a refugee.
Said15 Sep 2025Council
Non Cabinet Members' Debate
Opening the debate Councillor Lorber spoke first, highlighting what he felt to be the misinformed nature of the motion presented and request made to the Conservative Group in advance of the meeting for them ... view the full minutes text for item 15.
Asked7 Jul 2025Council
Mayor's Announcements
In raising a Point of Order on the basis of the appointment process for the Deputy Mayor, Councillor Lorber sought further explanation on the reason for the vacancy having occurred and ongoing role and requirement for a Deputy Mayor, given this had been the second successive year in which a change in appointment had been required. In response, Marsha Henry (as Director of Law) confirmed that the appointment of the Deputy Mayor was a decision made by the Mayor. Under Standing Order 27(b) the Mayor was required to provide written notice of the appointment, which had been received, with the matter then reported to Council and the appointment a constitutional requirement.
Said7 Jul 2025Council
Appointments to Committees and Outside Bodies and Appointment of Chairs/Vice Chairs
In response to a Point of Order raised by Councillor Lorber in relation to the filling of vacancies identified within the appointments outlined, Marsha Henry (as Director of Law) advised that these remained seats to be filled by the Labour Group and were being held vacant in advance of appointments being made in due course.
Named14 May 2025Council
Representation of Political Groups on Committees
In response to clarification sought by Councillor Lorber regarding the current size of the Labour Group, Marsha Henry (as Director of Law) confirmed that this remained as set out in the report with their currently being no members of the group identified as serving in an independent capacity.
Said14 May 2025Council
Appointment to Committees and Outside Bodies including the appointment of Chairs & Vice-Chairs
In opening the debate Councillor Lorber highlighted his concern at the current arrangements relating to the allocation of Chairs on the Councils Scrutiny Committees. In referring to the importance of scrutiny as a key element in a healthy functioning democracy he felt there was a need to ensure, in seeking to deliver a strong, credible and effective scrutiny function, that it remained as independent as possible from the Executive. In order to safeguard the effectiveness, democratic accountability and independence of Brent’s scrutiny function and reflect what he regarded as good practice elsewhere, he advised the Liberal Democrats were seeking to move an amendment to the proposed allocation of seats outlined within report requiring that the Chairs of the existing Scrutiny Committees should be Opposition Group appointments.
Said14 May 2025Council
Appointment to Committees and Outside Bodies including the appointment of Chairs & Vice-Chairs
In response to clarification sought by the Chief Executive on the precise nature of the proposed amendment, Councillor Lorber advised the Liberal Democrats were seeking to amend the relevant Standing Order (49ii) within Part 2 (Procedural Rules) of the Constitution in order to provide that the Chairs of the Scrutiny Committees should be Opposition Group appointments.
Declared3 Apr 2025Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interests
Councillor Lorber declared an interest in respect of Agenda Item 3: Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee Decision - Operational Property matters and restricted covenants at 776-778 Harrow Road as a Trustee of the Friends of Barham Library.
Named3 Apr 2025Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interests
Members were advised that Councillor Lorber had been provided with advice in advance of the meeting which was reiterated by Marsha Henry (Director of Law), that he should consider whether he ... view the full minutes text for item 2.
Named3 Apr 2025Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee Decision - Operational Property matters and restricted covenants at 776-778 Harrow Road
Having clarified the basis of the call-in, the Chair then proceeded to invite Councillor Lorber to outline the reasons for the call-in as representative of the members who had supported its submission.
Said3 Apr 2025Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee Decision - Operational Property matters and restricted covenants at 776-778 Harrow Road
In presenting the call-in, Councillor Lorber highlighted the following key issues as the basis for which the decision had been called-in:
Named3 Apr 2025Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee Decision - Operational Property matters and restricted covenants at 776-778 Harrow Road
In representing the members who had called in the decision, Councillor Lorber began by outlining a number of concerns regarding the conduct of the Barham Park Trust and the administration of the charity's affairs and highlighted the strength of feeling locally in opposition to the proposed modification of the restrictive covenant impacting on 776 & 778 Harrow Road, as demonstrated by a petition with over 700 signatories calling on the Council to protect Barham Park and not lift the covenant.
Said3 Apr 2025Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee Decision - Operational Property matters and restricted covenants at 776-778 Harrow Road
Councillor Lorber expressed his dissatisfaction at being denied the opportunity to speak at the last meeting of the Trust by the Chair of the Barham Park Trust Committee and importance of adhering to guidance provided to Councils when acting as trustees of charities. It was emphasised that councillors were expected to be embedded within the local community and to understand the community's sentiments. However, it was felt the repeated refusal of councillors serving on the Trust Committee to listen to community members and their representatives indicated a fundamental flaw in the process and governance arrangements for the Trust.
Said27 Feb 2025Council
Procedural Motion - Conduct of Business
Prior to being put to the vote, Councillor Lorber spoke (as Leader of the Liberal Democrats Group) to highlight his objection to the proposed change in timing for Group Leaders speeches during the budget debate, which he felt required further explanation and should have been subject to prior consultation with the respective Group Leaders.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Procedural Motion - Conduct of Business
Following a request from Councillor Lorber, under Standing Order 43 (f), the names of the Liberal Democrats Group members who voted against the ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Appointments to Committees and Outside Bodies
· Councillor Charlie Clinton to replace Councillor Paul Lorber as a full member with Councillor Paul Lorber to fill the vacancy as one of the Liberal Democrats two substitute members.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Appointments to Committees and Outside Bodies
· Councillor Paul Lorber to replace the Liberal Democrat vacancy as full member with Councillor Charlie Clinton to replace Councillor Paul Lorber as one of the Liberal Democrats two substitute members.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Appointments to Committees and Outside Bodies
· Councillor Charlie Clinton to replace Councillor Paul Lorber as the Liberal Democrats full member.
Named27 Feb 2025Council
Appointments to Committees and Outside Bodies
(e) Resources & Public Realm Scrutiny Committee – Councillor Paul Lorber to replace the Liberal Democrat vacancy as full member with Councillor Charlie Clinton to replace Councillor Paul Lorber as one of the Liberal Democrats two substitute members.
Said27 Feb 2025Council
Members' Allowance Scheme Annual Review 2025-26
As a further contribution, Councillor Lorber also spoke (as Leader of the Liberal Democrats Group) to highlight what he felt was a need for any increase in allowances to be self-funding and supported by savings achieved through a reduction and consolidation in Cabinet Member positions to reflect and align with the recent restructure of the Council’s senior management team. In reviewing the overall impact of the proposed change on the allowance budget, further clarification was also sought on the extent to which the saving identified during 2024-25 in relation to the Members Allowance scheme and had been delivered.
Named10 Feb 2025Cabinet
Review of working age Council Tax Support Scheme for 2025-26
Prior to considering the report, Councillor Muhammed Butt (as Leader of the Council) advised that he had accepted a request from Councillor Lorber to speak on the proposals being presented for consideration in relation to the Council Tax Support (CTS) Scheme.
Named10 Feb 2025Cabinet
Review of working age Council Tax Support Scheme for 2025-26
In addressing Cabinet, Councillor Lorber began by highlighting the significant impact he felt the proposed changes to the Council Tax Support Scheme would have on local residents already struggling as a result of the cost-of-living crisis. In considering mitigations to the impact of the proposed changes, he suggested that the Universal Credit system should not be used as the basis of the backdating rules for new CTS claims as the system was not felt to work effectively.
Said10 Feb 2025Cabinet
Review of working age Council Tax Support Scheme for 2025-26
Councillor Lorber also felt there had not been enough time to make residents aware of the changes to allow them to make any necessary adjustments, with concerns expressed about the extent and meaningfulness of the consultation process undertaken given the preferred option which had been identified as the basis of that process, following the initial modelling undertaken.
Named10 Feb 2025Cabinet
Review of working age Council Tax Support Scheme for 2025-26
In highlighting the responses provided as part of the consultation, including those by Brent Citizens Advice, Councillor Lorber ended by urging Cabinet when considering the proposals and impact locally to consider, as a minimum, increasing the level of the financial hardship Support Fund from £1.5m to £3m.
Named10 Feb 2025Cabinet
Budget & Council Tax 2025-26
As a further contribution the Leader then invited Councillor Lorber to speak who took the opportunity, in also recognising the financial crisis faced by local government, to highlight the £150m reserve of Strategic Community Infrastructure Levy (SCIL) funding held in Brent.
Said10 Feb 2025Cabinet
Budget & Council Tax 2025-26
Whilst aware of the restrictions in the permitted use of this funding, Councillor Lorber felt stronger representations needed to be made to the Government in seeking to ease the restrictions and provide greater flexibility and autonomy in how the Council could use this funding given the wider pressures and demands faced by key local services and in ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Asked18 Nov 2024Council
Mayor's Announcements (including any petitions received)
In raising a Point of Order on the basis of the appointment process for the Deputy Mayor, Councillor Lorber sought further clarification from the Corporate Director Law & Governance on the constitutional requirements regarding the need for advance notice to have been provided on the agenda and ability for the appointment to be made part way through the year. Concern was also expressed at no reason being provided for the vacancy having occurred. In response, Debra Norman (as Corporate Director Law & Governance) confirmed that the appointment of the Deputy Mayor was a decision made by the Mayor.
Named5 Nov 2024Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Apologies for absence and clarification of alternate members
Butt, Councillor Shah and Councillor Georgiou (with Councillor Lorber attending as a substitute).
Declared2 Oct 2024Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interests
Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest in respect of Agenda Item 3: Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee decisions (10 September 2024) - Strategic & Operational Property Matters relating to Barham Park Estate as a Director and Trustee of the Friends of Barham Library who occupied Unit 4 in the Barham Park building. In addition, he advised he was also a Trustee of the Friends of Barham Park and had a close association with other tenant organisations currently occupying the Barham Park building including Barham Veterans Club and Tamu Samaj UK. He also advised he had previously been approached by the applicant in relation to the planning application for the site at 776 & 778 Harrow Road.
Said2 Oct 2024Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interests
Referring to advice he had received in advance of the meeting from the Corporate Director Law & Governance, Councillor Lorber advised that having spoken to present the call-in he would then withdraw from the meeting for the duration of the item.
Named2 Oct 2024Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee decisions (10 September 2024) - Strategic & Operational Property Matters relating to Barham Park Estate
Having clarified the basis of the call-in, the Chair then proceeded to invite Councillor Lorber to outline the reasons for the call-in as representative of the members who had supported its submission.
Said2 Oct 2024Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee decisions (10 September 2024) - Strategic & Operational Property Matters relating to Barham Park Estate
In presenting the call-in, Councillor Lorber highlighted the following key issues as the basis for which the decision had been called-in:
Said2 Oct 2024Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee decisions (10 September 2024) - Strategic & Operational Property Matters relating to Barham Park Estate
Councillor Lorber highlighted what was ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Named19 Sep 2024Council
Treasury Management Outturn Report 2023-24
In highlighting the role of banks in terms of the level of investment and borrowing activity undertaken in support of the Council’s Treasury Management activity Councillor Lorber took the opportunity to express concern at the ongoing closure of high street bank branches and lack of progress being made in the roll out of banking hubs across the sector given the impact on local residents. As such he highlighted what he felt was a need for ongoing lobbying and pressure to be applied across the sector, supported by local authorities to address the issue.
Named9 Sep 2024Cabinet
Petitions (if any)
Impact of event days hosted at Wembley Stadium Councillor Muhammed Butt (as Leader of the Council) welcomed Councillor Lorber to the meeting, who had been invited to speak in support of a petition containing 274 signatures requesting that the Council actively consult with, and take into account , the concerns of local residents and businesses regarding the impact created by any increase permitted in the number of large events at Wembley Stadium on the surrounding area.
Named9 Sep 2024Cabinet
Petitions (if any)
In introducing the petition, Councillor Lorber began by highlighting the impact Wembley Stadium had on a large part of Brent.
Said9 Sep 2024Cabinet
Petitions (if any)
Referring to the planning application due to be considered by Brent’s Planning Committee on 11 September 2024 seeking a permanent increase in the number of permitted events hosted at the Stadium, Councillor Lorber advised that the signatories of the petition felt the Council needed to be well informed on the potential impacts of the proposed increase and to consult and engage local residents and businesses beyond the usual planning process and requirements. As an example, reference was made to the public consultation that had been undertaken when Tottenham Hotspur Football Club had submitted their application to temporarily increase event days at the Stadium in order to host premier league fixtures whereas, he pointed out, the current application from Wembley Stadium would mean a permanent increase in the number of events they were able to host.
Said9 Sep 2024Cabinet
Petitions (if any)
Detailing the impact of event days at Wembley Stadium on residents, Councillor Lorber advised Cabinet that people living in the area felt impeded, with buses diverted and road closures impacting movement throughout the whole day and not only during the period of the event itself, citing the recent example of the Taylor Swift concerts hosted over a period of 6 days at the Stadium. These had involved road closures and bus diversions from midday during each of the 5 event days with residents also experiencing difficulties accessing tube services.
Said9 Sep 2024Cabinet
Petitions (if any)
In his capacity as ward member for Sudbury, Councillor Lorber also outlined the impact on a family within his ward whose access to carers for their elderly mother had been adversely affected due to travel disruption experienced as a result of an event being hosted at the Stadium.
Named9 Sep 2024Cabinet
Petitions (if any)
Outlining the history of event days at the stadium, Councillor Lorber detailed the increase from the 37 large events permitted in the original business case for the new Stadium to the 46 large events now permitted and the current planning application seeking a further increase to 54 large events and similar increase for small events from 51 to 60. Considering this change, he felt that the Council had a responsibility to review the impact the stadium had on the daily lives of Brent residents and hold a public meeting where local residents could have their say and the Council could respond accordingly.
Named9 Sep 2024Cabinet
Petitions (if any)
In response, Councillor Tatler (as Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning and Growth) thanked Councillor Lorber for attending Cabinet in order to ensure the views of those supporting the petition were ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Named22 May 2024Council
Review of Arrangements for "Call In" of Executive decisions to Scrutiny Committees
Having introduced the report, the Mayor then invited Councillor Lorber (on behalf of the Liberal Democrats Group) to move an amendment to the report submitted prior to the meeting seeking approval to alternative arrangements for the number of members required to submit a valid call -in in response to the review of current arrangements.
Named22 May 2024Council
Review of Arrangements for "Call In" of Executive decisions to Scrutiny Committees
In moving the amendment, Councillor Lorber began by highlighting what he felt had been the lack of justification for the change proposed within the report presented by the Leader of the Council on the basis of the review which had been undertaken and expressed concern at the impact this would have at further reducing the ability of non-executive members to hold the Executive to account as part of an effective and democratic scrutiny process.
Said22 May 2024Council
Review of Arrangements for "Call In" of Executive decisions to Scrutiny Committees
Highlighting the need to maintain a strong and effective scrutiny function along with the need to maintain a meaningful ability for any member or political group to be able to call-in decisions for review as part of the balance provided in the current governance arrangements, Councillor Lorber felt it important to outline the value of recent call-in and scrutiny activity, including a focus on the Morland Gardens/Altamira development and changes to the Council’s street cleansing and recycling arrangements, as a means of ensuring the decisions made had been based on sound information and advice. Having taken account of the current review on the arrangements for call-in he advised that the amendment being moved on behalf of the Liberal Democrats Group was therefore seeking the following alternative changes to the call-in provisions:
Asked29 Feb 2024Council
Auditor's Annual Report on the London Borough of Brent
In response to the outline of the audit process provided, Councillor Lorber sought further detail as to whether this had included any review of arrangements for the management and recovery of debt owed to the Council, management of the Council’s commercial property portfolio (given specific concerns ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Said29 Feb 2024Council
Treasury Management Mid-Year Report 2023-2024
In responding to the report, Councillor Lorber highlighted the complexities involved in terms of overall management of the strategy given the current economic challenges and trends identified, which he felt also required consideration moving forward in terms of the potential impact any change in Government nationally may have on tax and borrowing requirements.
Said24 Jan 2024Barham Park Trust Committee
Barham Park Trust Accounts 22/23 - Outputs from a high-level review commissioned by the Chief Executive of Brent Council
In considering the report, the Trust Committee noted that the consultancy based review had been established to meet the following objectives (a) To independently and objectively review concerns raised by Councillor Lorber in respect of the accuracy of the Barham Park Trust accounts for the year ended 31 March 2023, to determine whether any errors or misstatements had been presented within the accounts; and (b) To review the responses provided by officers in respect of the concerns raised by Councillor Lorber regarding the accounts, to determine whether these provided accurate and sufficient information/detail.
Named24 Jan 2024Barham Park Trust Committee
Barham Park Trust Accounts 22/23 - Outputs from a high-level review commissioned by the Chief Executive of Brent Council
In terms of stakeholder engagement on the high-level review, clarification was provided that whilst Councillor Lorber, as both a ward councillor and Trustee of the Friends of Barham Library, had raised the initial concerns regarding accuracy of the accounts he had not been involved in the detailed review process or preparation of the report presented to the Trust as a result.
Named18 Dec 2023Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Cabinet decision (16 November 23) - Sudbury Town Residents Association (STRA) application for Neighbourhood Forum status
Having clarified the basis of the call-in, the Chair then proceeded to invite Councillor Lorber to outline the reasons for the call-in as representative of the members who had supported its submission.
Said18 Dec 2023Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Cabinet decision (16 November 23) - Sudbury Town Residents Association (STRA) application for Neighbourhood Forum status
In presenting the call-in, Councillor Lorber highlighted the following key issues for the Committee as a basis for the call-in which had been submitted:
Said18 Dec 2023Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Cabinet decision (16 November 23) - Sudbury Town Residents Association (STRA) application for Neighbourhood Forum status
· On the basis of the concerns raised Councillor Lorber felt the original decision taken to refuse the application needed to be referred back to Cabinet for re-consideration.
Named18 Dec 2023Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Cabinet decision (16 November 23) - Sudbury Town Residents Association (STRA) application for Neighbourhood Forum status
The Chair thanked Councillor Lorber for presenting the call-in and invited Committee Members to ask any clarifying queries they had.
Declared20 Nov 2023Council
Declarations of Interest
(a) Agenda Item 12.1 Resources & Public Realm Scrutiny Committee – Chair’s Update: Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest as a member of the Friends of Barham Park and Director and Trustee of Barham Community Library given reference within the update report to the outcome of the call-in considered by the Scrutiny Committee on the Barham Park Trust Accounts 2022-23.
Said20 Nov 2023Council
Statement of Gambling Principles 2024-2027
In supporting the concerns highlighted regarding the limitations currently placed on the relevant matters that could be taken into account when considering applications in relation to gambling premises, Councillor Lorber also felt it important to recognise the role of the current and previous governments in supporting de-regulation of the gambling industry, with a need highlighted for the Council to take a strong stance in seeking to oppose these type of licenses .
Named20 Nov 2023Council
Changes to the Constitution
Referring to the changes proposed in relation to speaking rights at Planning Committee meetings, Councillor Lorber also took the opportunity to highlight what he felt was an additional need to consider allowing members of the public who had spoken in objection to an application the ability to sum up at the end of the associated debate, prior to any final decision being made by the Committee. Based on experience, he felt this would further enhance public engagement and participation in the process.
Named26 Oct 2023Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of interests
Councillor Lorber (in representing the members who had called-in the decision due to be considered at the meeting) declared a personal interest as a member of the Friends of Barham Park Group and Director and Trustee of Barham Community Library.
Named26 Oct 2023Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee - Barham Park Trust Annual Report & Accounts 2022 - 23
Having clarified the basis of the call-in, the Chair then proceeded to invite Councillor Lorber to outline the reasons for the call-in as representative of the members who had supported its submission.
Said26 Oct 2023Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee - Barham Park Trust Annual Report & Accounts 2022 - 23
In presenting the call-in, Councillor Lorber highlighted the following key issues for the Committee:
Named26 Oct 2023Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Call-In: Barham Park Trust Committee - Barham Park Trust Annual Report & Accounts 2022 - 23
The Chair thanked Councillor Lorber for presenting the call-in and then proceeded to invite Councillor Tatler, Deputy ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Named26 Sep 2023Barham Park Trust Committee
Matters Arising (if any)
NOTED the receipt of written submissions from Francis Henry and Councillor Lorber in advance of the meeting relating to the Strategic Property Review considered at the previous meeting. It was confirmed that comments received in relation to the background and establishment of the restrictive covenant were subject to review by officers.
Named26 Sep 2023Barham Park Trust Committee
Barham Park Trust Annual Report and Accounts 2022/23
· Having noted receipt of the written submissions from Councillor Lorber and Francis Henry (as Chair of Friends of Barham Park) relating to presentation of the Trust Accounts, Ravinder Jassar (Deputy Director of Finance) advised that it was felt the various issues raised had either been addressed directly through the member enquiry process or within the report included on the Trust agenda. On this basis, and with the Accounts having also been subject to independent examination, it was felt the Trust Committee would be able to proceed on the basis of the recommendations set out in the report.
Declared18 Sep 2023Council
Declarations of Interest
· Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest as a Director and Trustee of Barham Park Community Library given the reference to Barham Park within the motion.
Named18 Sep 2023Council
Petitions (if any)
The Mayor advised that she had accepted a request for a petition to be presented at the meeting by Councillor Lorber, representing local residents , which contained 1170 signatures and related to the Protection of Brents Parks and Open Spaces .
Named18 Sep 2023Council
Petitions (if any)
As no objections were raised on the approach outlined, the Mayor invited Councillor Lorber to present the petition.
Said18 Sep 2023Council
Petitions (if any)
In presenting the petition, Councillor Lorber highlighted his focus on Barham Park given concerns identified as to how it was felt proposals presented at the recent meeting of the Barham Park Trust Committee would set an unwelcome precedent not only in terms of the risk to the Council’s long established Core Strategy of protecting and safeguarding Brent parks and open spaces but also in relation to local neighbourhood planning.
Said18 Sep 2023Council
Petitions (if any)
Given approval of the recent planning application relating to development of the housing site located along the north-west corner of Barham Park and the Trust’s recent agreement to progress negotiations on the possible variation of the restrictive covenant protecting against development on that site, Councillor Lorber felt the petition also served to highlight the level of concern expressed about the need to protect parks and open spaces across the borough from potential future development.
Named18 Sep 2023Council
Petitions (if any)
In concluding presentation of the petition, Councillor Lorber called on all members to recognise the strength of local feeling and prioritise the preservation and promotion of the borough’s parks and open spaces as valuable and vital assets for local communities across the borough.
Named18 Sep 2023Council
Petitions (if any)
Having thanked Councillor Lorber for presenting the petition, the Mayor then invited Councillor Tatler (as Cabinet Member for Regeneration, Planning & Growth) to respond.
Said18 Sep 2023Council
Changes to the Constitution
Councillor Lorber also spoke in relation to the proposed amendment to Standing Order 42, expressing concern at the current rules relating to the submission of amendments on motions which he pointed out had caused the issue at the previous Council meeting that now required clarification.
Moved18 Sep 2023Council
Changes to the Constitution
In view of the concerns which had been raised by both Opposition Groups relating to the use and timing of amendments and the criteria regarding their content, Councillor Lorber moved a further amendment in relation to Standing Order 42 relating to the Rules of Debate at Full Council Meetings seeking to prevent the submission of any amendment on motions which had been submitted for debate at Council meetings, with members (he pointed out) already having the ability to vote against motions they did not support.
Moved18 Sep 2023Council
Changes to the Constitution
In response to the proposal moved by Councillor Lorber, the Mayor advised that the usual process for dealing with matters such as these would have been for it to be considered by the Constitutional Working Group, prior to being raised at Full Council. On this basis, she ruled that consideration of the proposal should take place once it had been subject to consideration at the Constitutional Working Group.
Declared10 Jul 2023Council
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 15.2 (Liberal Democrats motion (Protecting, Preserving and Promoting Parks and Open Spaces in Brent) as a Director and Trustee of Barham Community Library given the reference to Barham Park within the motion.
Named17 May 2023Council
Appointment to Committees and Outside Bodies including the appointment of Chairs & Vice-Chairs
As an initial contribution Councillor Georgiou began by advising of a correction to the Liberal Democrats membership on the Resources & Public Realm Scrutiny Committee (as detailed within Appendix 1 of the report) which he confirmed should have been listed as himself rather than Councillor Lorber.
Named17 May 2023Council
Appointment to Committees and Outside Bodies including the appointment of Chairs & Vice-Chairs
As a final contribution, Councillor Lorber also speaking in support of the proposed amendment advised that whilst not seeking to politicise Brent Connects meetings the proposal moved by Councillor Georgiou on behalf of the Liberal Democrats had been designed to ensure a more balanced focus within the current structure on the areas covered and better reflect, on a democratically accountable basis, local ward councillor representation across each area.
Named15 Dec 2022Resources and Public Realm Scrutiny Committee
Redefining Local Services: Update on the Integrated Street Cleansing, Waste Collections and Winter Maintenance Services Contract Procurement Programme
The Chair also advised that she had received a late request to speak prior to the meeting from Councillor Lorber , which she would allow if time permitted:
Said21 Nov 2022Council
Changes to the Constitution
Councillor Lorber also spoke to request minor additional changes he was keen to see included to assist in clarifying the Code of Practice, which included within section 2 (Principles of Planning & Decision Making) clarity around application of the Code to members and also reference to other councillors being included as part of the list Committee members should not allow themselves to be influenced by.
Said21 Nov 2022Council
Motions
Councillor Lorber, speaking in support of the motion, felt that further consideration was required in relation to the use of asphalt for the repair and replacement of footways, given its effectiveness and impact in terms of surface water pooling and run off. Reflecting on specific issues in his own ward, he highlighted the issues caused by uneven footway surfaces and pooling of surface water, which he felt not only increased flood risks but also caused potential hazards for elderly and disabled residents.
Named21 Nov 2022Council
Motions
In concluding his comments, Councillor Lorber also took the opportunity to highlight concerns regarding the potential environmental impacts of what he felt was overdevelopment being permitted in front and back gardens and other green spaces across Brent.
Named5 Sep 2022Barham Park Trust Committee
Public representations
Councillor Lorber (representing the Friends of Barham Library) was the first to address the Trust Committee highlighting a number of property related issues relating to the current building on the estate. These included concerns in relation to out-dated signage around the complex and arrangements for the Fire Alarm test, which he advised were in addition to the points raised in a separate email submitted prior to the meeting regarding the provision of public toilet facilities, progress in a final decision being made on the use of Unit 7 and the potential use of alternative renewable energy sources.
Named5 Sep 2022Barham Park Trust Committee
Public representations
Having thanked Councillor Lorber for his comments, Councillor Muhammed Butt advised that a written response on the various matters raised would need to be provided following the meeting. He then moved on to welcome Debbie Howe (Project Manager Dementia Hubs Brent) and invited her to address the meeting.
Named18 Jul 2022Cabinet
Medium Term Financial Outlook
Prior to consideration of the main report, Councillor Muhammed Butt (Leader of the Council) invited Councillor Lorber, who had requested to speak on the item, to address the meeting.
Asked18 Jul 2022Cabinet
Medium Term Financial Outlook
Referring to section 6.9 of the report, Councillor Lorber sought further details on the status of the additional scheme which it was reported had been added to the Capital Programme pipeline relating to the redevelopment of the Alperton Community Centre. Having noted the figure included in relation to the scheme (£0.8m), details were sought on any discussions with other interested parties along with any internal project work undertaken and the estimates and assumptions on which the pipeline figure within the report had been based. In addition, concerns were highlighted (following a question raised at the Full Council meeting on 11 July 22) regarding the engagement of ward councillors and the local community in the process and development of proposals relating to the site.
Said18 Jul 2022General Purposes Committee
Stopping Up Order - Aylesbury Street
Councillor Lorber requested that his name to be recorded as voting against the above decision.
Named11 Jul 2022Council
Non Cabinet Members' Debate
Having been invited to move the amendment, Councillor Georgiou advised that Councillor Lorber would be speaking on behalf of the Liberal Democrat Group.
Said11 Jul 2022Council
Non Cabinet Members' Debate
In moving the amendment Councillor Lorber advised that whilst the Liberal Democrat Group fully supported the need for urgent action to be taken in addressing the Cost of Living crisis by the Government, especially in relation to energy prices, he felt there was also a need for ... view the full minutes text for item 14.
Named30 May 2022Cabinet
Authority to Award Contracts for the Purchase of Gas and Electricity (October 2022 to September 2024)
Cabinet NOTED the comments made by Councillor Lorber who had requested to speak at the meeting in respect of the item.
Named30 May 2022Cabinet
Authority to Award Contracts for the Purchase of Gas and Electricity (October 2022 to September 2024)
In addressing Cabinet, Councillor Lorber referred to section 3.2 of the report and sought further details on the basis of the decision taken in 2020 to provide for a two rather than four year energy supply period under the procurement framework along with an outline of any associated financial implications given the current and unprecedented increase in wholesale energy costs.
Named18 May 2022Council
Annual Review of Constitution
Councillor Lorber in responding and expressing concern at the amendment moved by the Leader of the Council highlighted what he felt was the case for greater rather than more restricted participation by opposition councillors in the scrutiny process in order to maintain independence of the function and important role it played in being able to hold the Council’s Executive to account. Highlighting a need for effective scrutiny to come prior to decisions being made by the Executive rather than after being taken he outlined what he considered to be the need for greater transparency, challenge and public accountability in the decision making process and to provide scrutiny with the necessary independence and power to achieve that, which it was felt the amendment moved by the Leader of the Council would undermine.
Moved18 May 2022Council
Annual Review of Constitution
Given the views expressed, Councillor Lorber moved a further amendment at the meeting which sought to retain Standing Order 49 (iii) and amend it by requiring the Chair of each Scrutiny Committee to be allocated to the opposition group(s) with Standing Order 4 also waived to enable the change to come into immediate effect during the meeting. In moving the amendment he pointed out this reflected existing practice in a number of other local authorities and what he believed was also the intention of the original legislation which had established the scrutiny arrangements within local government.
Said3 Mar 2014Council
The 2014/15 Budget and Council Tax
Councillor Lorber responded by criticising Councillor Butt for blaming somebody else when the past Labour government was responsible for the war in Iraq, bailing out the banks and reducing the number of Police Community Support Officers. Locally the Labour council had stopped parking scratch cards, overseen a reduction in the condition of the local environment and lost the trust of local communities by closing half the borough’s libraries. He referred to his tabled amendments to the budget which proposed additional expenditure on libraries, highways, parking, street cleaning and waste management, festivals and events, school crossing patrols and the introduction of a Council Tax discount for ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Said3 Mar 2014Council
Motions
Councillor Lorber spoke against suspending standing orders and stated that if this was done he would no longer take part in any cross party co-operation on reviewing the constitution.
Moved20 Jan 2014Council
Proposed Local Council Tax Support Scheme for 2013/14
Councillor Lorber moved a suspension of standing orders to allow officers to introduce the report given its complexity, length and the fact that councillors had not previously had the chance to ask questions on it. This was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Asked20 Jan 2014Council
Proposed Local Council Tax Support Scheme for 2013/14
Councillor Lorber asked if it was correct that none of the contingency sum of £800,000 built into the scheme had so far been required. In reply it was explained that the scheme was intend as a two year scheme and costed accordingly to take account of the growth in claim numbers that might be experienced in both the first and second years.
Moved20 Jan 2014Council
Re-open Brent's closed libraries
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and Councillors Cheese and Hopkins’ names by stating that while some of the old library buildings had been taken out of wider community use, there were still four buildings that could be used to provide community and library facilities. These could all provide places of study for young people who were promised replacement facilities but none had been provided.
Said20 Jan 2014Council
Re-open Brent's closed libraries
Councillor Lorber outlined the actions needed to bring this about. In support of the motion it was added that the pop up library at Kensal Rise had proved successful and had brought communities together. It was submitted that local people wanted their local libraries back and the provision of the new library in the Civic Centre was not accessible to many people.
Named9 Jan 2014Standards Committee
Independent Investigator's report following an allegation of a breach of the Code of Conduct
The report from the Monitoring Officer presented the Standards Committee with the Independent Investigator’s report in relation to allegations that Councillor Paul Lorber breached the Code of Conduct. The independent report was commissioned by the Monitoring Officer in accordance with the decision of this Committee on 17 October 2013 that an investigation should take place.
Named9 Jan 2014Standards Committee
Independent Investigator's report following an allegation of a breach of the Code of Conduct
Fiona Ledden (Monitoring Officer) advised that the report from the Independent Investigator came to the conclusion that Councillor Lorber had not breached the Code of Conduct in the email exchanges with [name removed] of ACAVA during 8and 22 September 2013 over the use of Barham Park Buildings, Sudbury. It was now for members to consider the report, to decide whether or not to accept the findings and, whether or not there were any lessons the authority could learn.
Named9 Jan 2014Standards Committee
Independent Investigator's report following an allegation of a breach of the Code of Conduct
On balance, [name removed] found that Councillor Lorber had not disclosed any confidential information and while his tone and choice of language may be cause for concern, it did not amount to disrespect.
Named9 Jan 2014Standards Committee
Independent Investigator's report following an allegation of a breach of the Code of Conduct
It was felt that Councillor Lorber was acting as a community representative and had not sought to use his position improperly to confer advantage.
Named18 Nov 2013Council
First reading debate on the 2014/15 - 2017/18 budget
Councillor Lorber referred to the reference to difficult times and reminded the meeting that such times had been identified back in 2008 when the Administration at that time was advised that whatever Government was next elected there would be a substantial reduction in funding for local government. A programme was therefore embarked upon which included re-organising the Council and making efficiencies. This was the beginning of the One Council programme referred to by the Leader.
Named18 Nov 2013Council
First reading debate on the 2014/15 - 2017/18 budget
Councillor Lorber referred to the report which stated that regardless of the ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Moved18 Nov 2013Council
Cleaner streets in Brent
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his name which sought to call on the Executive to improve the cleanliness of the streets. He submitted that the condition of the borough’s streets had deteriorated and that the new public realm contract would not deal with the problem. A new approach was needed with increased enforcement to make examples of those people who polluted the streets.
Moved18 Nov 2013Council
Parking
Councillor Lorber moved an amendment to the motion seeking to note that high parking charges were harming the local economy, to establish a working Group to review the Wembley Event day scheme and proposing alternative charging arrangements.
Named14 Oct 2013Executive
Deputation - award of the contract for Public Realm Services
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) reminded the Executive that he had wished to raise this issue at a recent meeting of the Full Council but it had been ruled out of order. He expressed concern at the absence of competition in the procurement process which had resulted in the process going ahead with fewer than the six bidders in contrast to views expressed on competition at the recent Labour Party Conference.
Named14 Oct 2013Executive
Deputation - award of the contract for Public Realm Services
Referring to the detail of the contract, Councillor Lorber made reference to the requirement for residents to place bins close to the kerb which, in his experience, discouraged the contractor from returning them to the correct household and caused inconvenience.
Said14 Oct 2013Executive
Deputation - award of the contract for Public Realm Services
Councillor Lorber also expressed concern at the intention to have banded collection times in town centres and felt this would have an adverse effect on people who went to work during the day. He also felt that environmental promotion should be the responsibility of the council as policy maker, not the contractor.
Said14 Oct 2013Executive
Leasing of Buildings, Barham Park, 656-660 Harrow Road, Sudbury HA0 2HB
Councillor Lorber (Ward Councillor, Leader of the Opposition) expressed regret that the Vets and the Club had only recently had sight of the report and had not had the opportunity for proper discussion; indeed there had been no consultation since February 2013. They were only recently advised that they would no longer have use of the Card Room. This was in contrast with indications given 18 months previously and also agreements negotiated with the former Parks Manager which had involved free lets and evening use.
Asked14 Oct 2013Executive
Leasing of Buildings, Barham Park, 656-660 Harrow Road, Sudbury HA0 2HB
Councillor Lorber questioned the need to enter into a leasing arrangement, and the motivation behind the proposal to seek planning permission for change of use to allow leasing to the charity ACAVA. He drew attention to the former library sites at Kensal Rise and Cricklewood where planning permission had been refused due to the loss of community space. He also questioned the assessment of the market rent which now was assessed to be one third of an earlier independent assessment and whether it could have been set at a level that was more beneficial to the Trust.
Said14 Oct 2013Executive
Leasing of Buildings, Barham Park, 656-660 Harrow Road, Sudbury HA0 2HB
Councillor Lorber urged the Executive to defer consideration of the report so that proper consideration could be given. [name removed] (Sudbury resident) questioned the proposed legal arrangements for the use of the park depot and whether these would create difficulties in the future.
Said10 Oct 2013Highways Committee
Sudbury CPZ review petition
Councillor Lorber stated that majority of the residents endorsed the current operational hours from 08:00am-6:30pm which had deterred commuter parking, non-residential long term parking and improved road safety.
Said10 Oct 2013Highways Committee
Sudbury CPZ review petition
Councillor Lorber added that residents had however expressed genuine concerns about the charges for permits.
Said9 Oct 2013One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber advised that he was a member of Barham Park Library campaign
Declared9 Sep 2013Council
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared a non-disclosable interest by virtue of being associated with the Friends of Barham Park.
Said16 Jul 2013Highways Committee
Sudbury and Harrow Road Bus Stop Petition
Councillor Lorber stated that the relocation of the bus stop was carried out without adequate information as the review consultation did not point out that the bus stop would be relocated. He also stated that the new location was a major inconvenience to bus ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Named15 Jul 2013Executive
Annual parking report
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) regretted that the report did not include any comparative data with PCN charges over previous years. He also felt that Brent’s expenditure of parking surplus on street lighting was outside of the provisions of the Road Traffic Act 1984.
Named15 Jul 2013Executive
Annual parking report
Additionally, Councillor Lorber called for a review of the hours of operation which he considered to be excessive with drivers being penalised all day on empty roads and long after the events concerned have ended. He made reference to a petition to this effect due to come before the Highways Committee the following evening.
Said15 Jul 2013Executive
Capital Contribution to West London Waste Authority
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) raised questions on the terms of the loan and considered that the there was insufficient information available to make a decision at this stage. Mick Bowden (Deputy Director of Finance) advised that negotiations were still on going and repayment terms being considered. The position would become clearer once the number of boroughs involved was confirmed.
Named4 Jul 2013General Purposes Committee
Matters arising
Councillor Lorber drew members’ attention to the discussion set out in the minutes of the meeting held on 28 March 2013 regarding the pay multiple; the ratio between the highest paid salary and the lowest/median average salary of the council’s workforce.
Asked4 Jul 2013General Purposes Committee
Matters arising
Councillor Lorber queried whether there were any implications for senior officer pay of the 1:9 ratio between the highest and lowest salary as shown in the Pay Policy Statement agreed by Council on 25 February 2013. Cara Davani (Interim Operational Director HR) advised that an explanatory note had been circulated on this issue following the Council meeting on 25 February. With regard to the Chief Executive position, it had been clarified at the Council meeting that the intention was to use a starting salary of less that the maximum salary agreed, to bring it into line with the 1:9 ratio.
Asked4 Jul 2013General Purposes Committee
Hay management contract
Noting the current arrangements for the award of annual salary increments, Councillor Lorber queried why increments were not paid following 12 month’s service, irrespective of start date. Cara Davani explained that the present arrangements ensured a minimum of six month’s service prior to an increment being paid; this was historic practice in Brent and common practice elsewhere. Following further discussion it was agreed that a report setting out the pros and cons of awarding increments on the anniversary of employees’ start dates be submitted to the committee.
Said24 Jun 2013Council
Establishment of the Brent Health and Wellbeing Board
Councillor Lorber urged Council not to accept lifting the proportionality rules because he felt the credibility of the board would be undermined if all three political groups on the Council were not represented on the board. He stated that as much business as possible put before the board should be dealt with in public by as wide a representative body as possible. He questioned where the opportunity would be for the opposition to challenge its work if there was only minimal opposition representation on the board.
Moved24 Jun 2013Council
Review of and changes to the constitution
Councillor Lorber moved that the sub-committee proposed in Standing Order 77A ( vi ) be five members politically balanced as 3-1-1. This was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Said24 Jun 2013Council
Appointment of permanent Chief Executive
Councillor Lorber argued for the appointment of a permanent Chief Executive and against the continuation of an interim appointment.
Moved24 Jun 2013Council
Enforcement against dog-fouling and fly-tipping
Councillor Lorber moved the suspension of standing orders to allow councillors to challenge the officers’ legal advice. This was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Named24 Jun 2013Council
Brent Housing Partnership Board
Councillor Lorber submitted that for Brent Housing Partnership to be regarded as a credible organisation it needed to have representation from all three of the political groups on the Council. He referred to the past when the Conservative Group had been happy to accept a place but only now that the place was being taken away did it submit a motion on the matter.
Said22 Apr 2013Executive
Travel Assistance Policy for young people
The Director of Children and Families replying a question from Councillor Lorber highlighted that the new arrangements introduced an annual review and would help promote independence looking at each child’s individual needs.
Named22 Apr 2013Executive
Disposal of land adjoining 19 Elms Gardens, Elms Court, Sudbury and establishment of a replacement allotment site at Gladstone Park Gardens, Dollis Hill
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition, Sudbury Ward councillor) endorsed the tributes paid to residents for their work in clearing the site. He also welcomed the proposed change to the recommendations for the lease to now comprise Stage One and Stage Two, an indication of the confidence placed in the residents.
Named22 Apr 2013Executive
Disposal of land adjoining 19 Elms Gardens, Elms Court, Sudbury and establishment of a replacement allotment site at Gladstone Park Gardens, Dollis Hill
Councillor Lorber made reference to the funding earmarked for the replacement site at Gladstone Park and suggested that costs could be reduced were residents to follow the example of Sudbury Elms Residents Association and get involved in the creation of a new site. He also requested that the Sudbury area should benefit from the disposal of the land sale and that any housing development should be complementary and sensitive to the existing accommodation.
Named22 Apr 2013Executive
Community Right to Challenge
In response to a request from Councillor Lorber to extend the bidding window from the proposed 1 May to 30 June, the Director of Legal and Procurement commented that community organisations had been consulted, the timescales were similar to those adopted in other boroughs and there was a need for certainty around service provision.
Said11 Mar 2013Executive
On-street parking tariffs
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) stated that the decision to increase charges from September 2012 had already cost residents £100,000 and now, only a few months later, additional charges were being considered. He felt that the council was taking advantage of people, particularly those living in streets where only on street was feasible.
Named11 Mar 2013Executive
On-street parking tariffs
Councillor Lorber drew attention to the adverse environmental impact of driveway parking as more and more residents destroyed pavements and gardens to create off street parking. Excessive parking charges also had an adverse effect on local businesses with there being found to be a 24% reduction in parking as a result of the increases. This resulted in a loss in business income and many businesses having to close, leaving the high streets to the bookmakers and fast food establishments. 15 minutes free parking was too short a time to be useful and he queried the level of charge that would apply thereafter.
Named25 Feb 2013Council
The 2013/14 Budget and Council Tax
Councillor Lorber submitted that much of what the budget aimed to achieve was in fact funded by the Government and was generally supported. He spoke against aspects of the proposed budget and moved an amendment which was circulated around the chamber, which proposed a number of alternatives to the proposed budget. He also referred to the advanced planning for the difficult economic circumstances undertaken by the previous Administration which was now delivering the majority of the savings needed.
Declared21 Feb 2013Planning Committee
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared that he was a Director and a Trustee of Barham Park Library.
Named13 Feb 2013Barham Park Trust Committee
Matters arising
Councillor Lorber reiterated the concern that he had raised at the previous meeting that the accounts presented to the meeting for 2011/12 were not sufficiently detailed to enable the committee to approve them.
Said22 Jan 2013General Purposes Committee
Calculation of Council Tax Base 2013/14
Councillor Lorber commented that he felt that 96% was a bit low and that whilst it might ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Declared21 Jan 2013Council
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared a non disclosable interest in item 6 by virtue of being a trustee of Friends of Barham Library.
Said21 Jan 2013Council
Credit unions
Councillor Lorber expressed support for Credit Unions and referred to what he thought was the related issue of the proliferation of betting shops, which had made it easier for people to gamble.
Asked21 Jan 2013Council
Credit unions
Councillor Lorber asked how CUBE had been selected out of all the credit unions operating and whether a proper selection process had been undertaken. He felt it was important that the Council did what it could to ensure people received proper advice about debt.
Named14 Jan 2013Executive
Green Charter monitoring report
In response to a question from Councillor Lorber on policy proposals for car parking at the new Civic Centre due to open later in the year, the Director of Regeneration and Major Projects undertook to provide the timetable.
Named14 Jan 2013Executive
School Expansion (Secondary) Programme 2012-16
In response to a question from Councillor Lorber, Councillor Crane confirmed that all schools were being considered for potential expansion and achievable plans would be put forward.
Named14 Jan 2013Executive
London Living Wage
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) drew members’ attention to the financial implications and the cost difference between current wage levels and LLW within existing contracts which was estimated to be £9.1m. He expressed the view that the Executive should at this stage, have the option to include the necessary provision for the forthcoming budget process.
Said8 Jan 2013Barham Park Trust Committee
Barham Park - Accounts and Annual Reports
Councillor Lorber (Ward Councillor, Sudbury) stated that the accounts presented for 2011/12 were not sufficiently detailed to enable the committee to make an informed decision to approve them. As an example, he noted that there was no information on the rental payments made by the council for use of buildings within Barham Park. Mick Bowden confirmed that the accounts met the requirements set out by the Charity Commission.
Named10 Dec 2012Council
Local Council Tax Support Scheme and Changes to Council Tax Discounts and Exemptions
Councillor Lorber re-iterated that the budgeted surplus was unnecessary and if the collection rate was not achieved that would reflect on the performance of the Council, not individual tax payers. He moved amendments to the scheme which sought to adjust upwards the savings cut-off, protect non-dependents in receipt of job seekers allowance for the first twelve months from their first claim and set a lower minimum contribution rate.
Named19 Nov 2012Council
Mayor's announcements
Councillor Lorber paid tribute to the work of Jeff Bartley, Environmental Projects and Policy Manager, who passed away on 12 November 2012.
Moved19 Nov 2012Council
Changes to Constitution
Councillor Lorber proposed an amendment to the recommendations which he felt would remove an anomaly in that there was no provision in the constitution for the appointment of interim senior officers.
Said19 Nov 2012Council
Number 18 bus route
Councillor Lorber added that the matter had been raised in the past with the then Mayor of London, Ken Livingstone, and suggested that the current Mayor of London should be approached about this.
Moved19 Nov 2012Council
Recruitment of permanent Chief Executive and Director of Finance
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and the names of Councillors Ashraf, Beck, Brown, Hopkins and Hunter which sought to require options for the restructure of the Corporate Management Team to be brought forward. He expressed concern that members had not been given any information about the recent loss of the Council’s Chief Executive and Director of Finance and that this presented an opportunity to review the Council’s management structure.
Said19 Nov 2012Council
The living wage
Councillor Lorber stated that his party supported the living wage and had also sought to assist those on low incomes through changes in the tax system. However, he noted that the Council’s commitment to paying the living wage excluded those working in the social care sector.
Said12 Nov 2012Executive
The future administration and governance of Barham Park Trust
Councillor Lorber (Ward Councillor, Sudbury) expressed the view that the Trust should meet frequently, three or four times, particularly in its first year, to address concerns raised by and with the Charity Commission which, he felt, should have been set out in the report. He felt the Trust would give officers a clear direction emphasising that the Park should not be treated as a council asset.
Moved10 Sep 2012Council
Procedural motions
Councillor Lorber moved a procedural motion that sought to require the Leader of the Council to make a statement on the position of the Chief Executive and allow other members to comment.
Asked10 Sep 2012Council
Procedural motions
Councillor Lorber asked that a recorded vote be taken. The procedural motion was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Named10 Sep 2012Council
Loan sharks
In supporting the motion, Councillor Lorber referred to what he saw as a lack of consistency on many issues regarding debt, one being the expansion of gambling outlets on the high streets. He stated this aspect also needed to be tackled and felt that it was a shameful error on the part of the last government to allow the proliferation of gambling outlets.
Asked20 Aug 2012Executive
Food Growing and Allotments Strategy
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) sought clarification of the allotments sites affected by the strategy and also the future of Elms Gardens Allotments.
Named20 Aug 2012Executive
Food Growing and Allotments Strategy
The Director of Environment and Neighbourhood Services advised that one of the disused allotment sites referred to in the report was near the Vale Farm Sports Centre and Councillor Lorber was advised that discussions with residents on the future of Elms Gardens allotments were being led by the Regeneration and Major Projects department and would be announced once finalised.
Said20 Aug 2012Executive
Outcome of the Strategic Review of the Brent Schools Portfolio
Councillor Lorber raised the absence of reference to Hopscotch Nursery, currently based in Winkworth Hall, Chevening Road, NW6 who were lobbying for permanent premises to be identified, Winkworth Hall having been declared surplus to requirements. He suggested that the Executive should consider whether the Hall could be used as a temporary school.
Asked20 Aug 2012Executive
Brent Housing Partnership
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) questioned the reason for the delay in the introduction of the new arrangements and felt that all political groups on the council should be represented on the Board.
Declared9 Jul 2012Council
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Cheese declared a non-prejudicial interest by virtue of his membership of the Kilburn Locality Advisory Board Councillor Lorber declared a non-prejudicial interest by virtue of being a director and trustee of Friends of Barham Library.
Moved9 Jul 2012Council
More democratic decision-making for Brent Council
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and Councillors Beck, Cummins, Hunter and CJ Patel’s names which sought to bring forward proposals for a modernised committee system of governance to come into force following the 2013 Annual Council meeting.
Said9 Jul 2012Council
More democratic decision-making for Brent Council
Councillor Lorber expressed the view that this was a proposal that had cross party support across the country. The choice was to have a centralised form of governance or a more democratic system. He felt the public was extremely confused on how decisions were taken by the Executive when there was little debate or challenge on the decisions being taken.
Moved9 Jul 2012Council
Accident and Emergency services
Councillor Lorber moved an amendment to the motion which sought to substantially add to it by referring back to the previous Labour government’s policies. He pointed out that the performance of different hospitals varied greatly and that studies had shown that to create specialised hospitals was the only option if standards were to be improved. It was not viable to spread resources so thinly that it became a lottery as to the level of service people received when visiting hospital.
Said9 Jul 2012Council
Accident and Emergency services
Councillor Lorber stated that the problem for A&E services was that the great majority of people that visited the service had been taken off the streets in a drunken state.
Named9 Jul 2012Council
Accident and Emergency services
Councillor Colwill supported the points made by Councillor Lorber. He stated that in 2009/10 the then Labour government had plans to close local hospitals. He added that it was the Labour government that had started the health reforms and referred to some of the changes that had then been proposed which, he felt, had adversely impacted on elderly people.
Moved9 Jul 2012Council
By elections
Councillor Lorber moved an amendment to the motion submitted which sought to recognise the dedication of Brent’s Liberal Democrat councillors, which was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Said9 Jul 2012Council
New standards regime under Localism Act
Councillor Lorber stated that there was no barrier to establishing the Standards Committee on the basis of equal representation from each of the political groups if there was unanimous agreement and he felt it was wrong for one party to have a majority on the committee.
Named12 Jun 2012One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
The One Council Programme - First Update - 2012/13
Councillor Lorber drew attention to the reference in the report to increase useage of libraries and proposed that the report be amended to reflect the programme being about savings only.
Asked12 Jun 2012One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
The One Council Programme - First Update - 2012/13
Councillor Lorber asked that his assent be recorded.
Moved12 Jun 2012One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
One Council Overview and Scrutiny work programme
Councillor Lorber proposed that the effective support of voluntary libraries be added to the programme in the light of recent events. Members of the Committee queried how the item contributed to the One Council projects. It was clarified that pop up libraries did not form part of the Brent library transformation programme and that work was currently being undertaken to help facilitate discussions between Kensal Rise Library campaigners and All Souls College.
Declared21 May 2012Executive
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest in the item relating to the Libraries Transformation Project as a Trustee and Director of the Friends of Barham Library.
Said21 May 2012Executive
Deputations - progress report on the Libraries Transformation Project
Councillor Lorber (Sudbury Ward councillor, Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group) reported that library facilities were being provided by volunteers from the former Barham Library premises, benefiting children from across the community. Regarding the transformation project, he referred to the increase in the estimated cost of refurbishment of Kilburn Library from £117,000 to more than half a million pounds and questioned the extent to which, had this been known last year, it would have impacted on decision-making. He referred to mounting on-going costs which he considered must also be having an adverse effect on budget estimates.
Said21 May 2012Executive
Deputations - progress report on the Libraries Transformation Project
Councillor Lorber also raised the matter of the shortage ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Named17 May 2012Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in of Executive decisions from the meeting of the Executive held on 23 April 2012
The Chair invited Councillor Lorber, one of the councillors who had called in this item, to summarise the reasons for the call in.
Named17 May 2012Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in of Executive decisions from the meeting of the Executive held on 23 April 2012
Councillor Lorber began by stating that the report that went to the Executive lacked clarity in a number of areas. He felt that the subsequent supplementary briefing that had been circulated to the committee had partially resolved this, however some outstanding issues remained. He then drew Members’ attention to the reasons for call in and suggested action for the committee to take as set out in the agenda.
Named16 May 2012Council
To elect the Mayor of the Borough for the municipal year 2012/2013
Councillor Lorber nominated Councillor Cheese and this was seconded by Councillor Hunter.
Moved16 May 2012Council
Notification of appointments to the Executive and appointments to committees and other bodies
Councillor Lorber moved that the Council’s appointments to Brent Housing Partnership should comprise two Labour councillors, 1 Liberal Democrat councillor and one Conservative councillor. This was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Named2 May 2012Standards Committee
Allegation of a breach of the Code of Conduct
The committee met to consider allegations against Councillor Ann John (Leader of the Labour Group) made by Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group). Members had before them the covering report and supplementary report which outlined the allegations. Attached to the supplementary report was a report by an independent investigator.
Said14 Mar 2012Planning Committee
Ground and first floors, 967 Harrow Road, Wembley HA0 2SF (Ref. 11/3205)
In accordance with the provisions of the Planning Code of Practice, Councillor Lorber , ward member, stated that he had been approached by objectors and the local residents.
Said14 Mar 2012Planning Committee
Ground and first floors, 967 Harrow Road, Wembley HA0 2SF (Ref. 11/3205)
Councillor Lorber stated that the rear access to the site would create difficulties for vehicle movement. The situation would be made worse in terms of enforcement as the area was not within a controlled parking zone (CPZ). He therefore emphasised the need to retain the closure of the rear access.
Said14 Mar 2012Planning Committee
Ground and first floors, 967 Harrow Road, Wembley HA0 2SF (Ref. 11/3205)
Councillor Lorber urged members to defer the application and request the applicant to submit a revised scheme.
Said12 Mar 2012Executive
Barham Park Improvements
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group) addressed the meeting in relation to the report from the Director of Environment and Neighbourhood Services which provided an update on potential improvements to Barham Park and sought approval for a feasibility study into the future use of Barham Park buildings and options for improving the space.
Asked12 Mar 2012Executive
Barham Park Improvements
Councillor Lorber questioned whether expenditure of £30,000 a feasibility study was a good use of the Charity’s funding particularly as a number of studies had been commissioned over the years. He felt that the proceeds from the disposal of the associated cottages was a capital receipt which belonged to the Trust and questioned the implication in the report that compliance with terms of use stipulated by the Trust was optional.
Named12 Mar 2012Executive
Barham Park Improvements
Councillor Lorber put that the council’s use of the park and buildings had to be regularised, that every day spent empty was a financial loss to the Charity and asked that approaches from voluntary organisations to occupy the premises be taken seriously. He stated that the Children’s Centre on the site was at risk following the closure of Barham Library and urged the Executive to listen to the community.
Named27 Feb 2012Council
Mayor's announcements (including any petitions received)
Councillor Lorber paid tribute to Councillor Castle and expressed gratitude on behalf of his group for the messages of sympathy he had received.
Said27 Feb 2012Council
The 2012/13 Budget and Council Tax
Councillor Lorber spoke against aspects of the proposed budget and moved an amendment which was circulated around the chamber, which proposed a number of alternatives to the proposed budget.
Named27 Feb 2012Council
The 2012/13 Budget and Council Tax
The Council voted en bloc on the amendments circulated by Councillor Lorber which was declared LOST.
Asked7 Feb 2012Highways Committee
Proposed changes to charging and other arrangements for Preston Road Car Park
Councillor Lorber queried the ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Declared1 Feb 2012Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared an interest as a member of Friends of Barham Library, however he did not consider the interest to be prejudicial and remained in attendance to discuss and vote at the meeting.
Asked25 Jan 2012One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Performance report for quarter 2, 2011-12
Councillor Lorber sought more information on what areas had overspent. He raised the issue of illegal sub-letting of council properties and asked if the council was taking any steps to address this and also to use as an opportunity to recover any income.
Asked24 Jan 2012General Purposes Committee
Calculation of Council Tax Base 2012/13
In the ensuing discussion, Councillor Lorber queried why the collection rate had been set for 97.5% for the past two years and put forward an amended motion for the collection rate to be increased to 98%. In response, David Huberman clarified that a higher collection rate could lead to a shortfall in collection which could result in a deficit in the following year if the rate was not achieved. He emphasised the need to strike a balance and in arriving at the recommended rate, the Council’s external auditors had paid close attention to collection assumptions to avoid making an over-optimistic assumption.
Named24 Jan 2012General Purposes Committee
Calculation of Council Tax Base 2012/13
Members voted on the amended motion in the name of Councillor Lorber which was declared lost.
Declared23 Jan 2012Council
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared an interest in those items that dealt with the library service by virtue of being a director of the Friends of Barham Library.
Moved23 Jan 2012Council
Library, museum and archive provision while Willesden Library Centre is closed
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in the name of the Liberal Democrat Group by claiming that many people were angry that during the consultation on the closure of six libraries no mention was made of the demolition of the Willesden Green centre. It was now not clear what temporary library facility would be provided during the construction of the new Willesden Green centre and he felt the obvious alternative was to keep open those libraries close to Willesden Green, such as the Cricklewood library, during the construction period.
Named23 Jan 2012Council
Library, museum and archive provision while Willesden Library Centre is closed
Councillor Lorber also made mention of how the Brent museum had begun with the Barham bequest. It was the 75th anniversary of the death of Titus Barham and he felt it would be appropriate to relocate the bequest back into the Barham library.
Moved23 Jan 2012Council
Early bird fares
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in the name of the Liberal Democrat Group. Following a vote the motion was declared CARRIED.
Said23 Jan 2012Council
Parking restrictions
Councillor Lorber stated that this was an issue the Executive needed to further consider. He felt there were ways to support traders across the borough and suggested that 30 minutes free parking might be a good idea. He appreciated that this would have an impact on the parking account but felt a longer term view needed to be taken in the interests of encouraging businesses into the area.
Said23 Jan 2012Council
Proposed privatisation of London Fire Brigade
Councillor Lorber stated that this matter had already been raised by Liberal Democrat Assembly members. He did not feel that the Council was qualified to deal with the issue and pointed out that all political parties had at some time considered privatisation of some public services. Members had justifiable concerns and it was important that adequate service standards were set.
Said21 Nov 2011Council
Motion - School crossing service
In moving the motion, Councillor Lorber stated that he had wanted overview and scrutiny to consider the decisions of the Executive because he was not sure how many councillors understood what had been agreed. He felt it was confusing and, in describing the outcome, asked what it was thought the response would be when a school crossing patrol was removed. He believed there to be four vacancies at the present time but was unsure when the new scheme was due to become operational.
Said21 Nov 2011Council
Motion - School crossing service
Councillor Lorber felt it would have been better if he had been allowed to call-in the decisions so that non-Executive members could properly discuss the issues in the way it was envisaged when overview and scrutiny was introduced. He felt the overview and scrutiny process was not used properly in Brent and if it had been on this occasion it would have come up with a better result than the Executive had.
Declared21 Nov 2011Council
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest in item 10 - Motions, by virtue of being a trustee and director of Friends of Barham Library.
Said21 Nov 2011Council
First Reading debate on the 2012/13 - 2015/16 budget
· employment · neighbourhood services · services for young people · social care and health · regeneration · diversity and democracy Councillor Lorber stated that the situation faced by the Council was a result of the past Labour government's legacy. He backed this up by stating that there was a two year time lag behind all policy decisions meaning the current situation was the result of decisions taken by the last government. He submitted that the Council was fortunate that the previous Council administration had introduced the One Council programme which now allowed the Council to deliver a balanced budget.
Named21 Nov 2011Council
First Reading debate on the 2012/13 - 2015/16 budget
Councillor Lorber did not feel it was all bad news by referring to a three year Council Tax freeze being made possible, a £25M award from the Government to address the shortage in school places and low interest rates meaning the cost of the Council's borrowing was cheaper. He criticised the administration for believing it knew better and did not listen to the views of local people. He referred to the cuts to the library service and school crossing patrols which affected young people and the cuts in street cleansing which had resulted in overflowing litter bins.
Said21 Nov 2011Council
Waste and recycling success
Councillor Lorber stated that, contrary to what Councillor Powney had said, everyone agreed about the need to increase recycling, but not on how to go about it. He referred to the different colour bins being filled with the wrong material because the Council had failed to get the correct messages across to local residents. This contributed to the worsening condition of Brent streets and he challenged the administration to carry out a consultation with residents on what they thought of the current street sweeping arrangements to test if they viewed them as a success or failure.
Moved21 Nov 2011Council
Waste and recycling success
Councillor Lorber moved an amendment to the motion which sought to remove reference to the success of the new arrangements being attributed to the Council's leadership. Following a vote the amendment was declared LOST.
Moved21 Nov 2011Council
Fairs fare
An amendment to the motion was moved by Councillor Lorber which sought changes to the motion which included removing reference to welcoming the proposed fare package. Following a vote the amendment was declared LOST. The motion was put to the vote and declared CARRIED.
Moved21 Nov 2011Council
School places
An amendment to the motion was moved by Councillor Lorber seeking to insert reference to the role of the Minister of State for Children and Families.
Moved21 Nov 2011Council
Brent library service
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his name and the names of Councillors Ashraf and Brown by firstly paying tribute to the hundreds of residents for the campaign they had supported to save the six libraries that had been closed and urged that the administration listen to their voices. He submitted that a policy of closure rather than transformation was being pursued. He referred to the planned closure of the Willesden library for up to two years while the site was redeveloped during which time alternative premises would be needed and criticised the decision to be closing nearby libraries now.
Said21 Nov 2011Council
Brent library service
Councillor Lorber felt that some boroughs smaller than Brent had shown the way in keeping open more libraries by co-locating them in buildings with other facilities.
Moved21 Nov 2011Council
Police Community Support officers
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated on behalf of himself and Councillors Brown and Beck which sought to request the Executive to use the money saved by the delay in filling Police Community Support Officer posts for crime reduction measures. Following a vote the motion was declared LOST.
Moved21 Nov 2011Council
Dirty streets
Councillor Lorber moved the motion on behalf of himself and Councillors Ashraf, Beck and Brown which sought to ask the Executive to take action to clean up the streets of Brent. Following a vote the motion was declared LOST.
Said21 Nov 2011Council
Police numbers
Councillor Lorber felt care needed to be taken when discussing crime and the fear of crime. He referred to a recent photo opportunity by the GLA Assembly member for Brent and Harrow wearing a 'Not Another Drop' t-shirt when the Council had recently cut the funding to this campaign. He expressed an interest in the number of additional Police Community Support Officers recruited to the borough which had recently been reduced.
Moved21 Nov 2011Council
Regeneration funding
An amendment was moved by Councillor Lorber on behalf of the Liberal Democrat Group which was accepted. Following a vote the amended motion was declared CARRIED.
Named19 Sep 2011Executive
Petitions - school crossing patrols
Present at the meeting in support of two of the petitions were Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) and [name removed]. The petitions were in response to a consultation exercise that had taken place earlier in the year and the report from the Director of Environment and Neighbourhood Services explained that the proposals now before members were significantly different from those originally proposed.
Said19 Sep 2011Executive
Petitions - school crossing patrols
Councillor Lorber presented the petitions entitled 'Save Brent's Lollipops' supporting the retention of school crossings in the borough in particular in the Sudbury area and in the vicinity of Convent of Jesus and Mary Infants, Park Avenue and High Road Willesden.
Said19 Sep 2011Executive
Petitions - school crossing patrols
Councillor Lorber stated that for parents, safety was paramount. Over the years the council had worked hard to reduce the number of accidents and to remove school crossing patrols would turn the clock back. He felt that the revised proposals set out in the report, namely to ensure that priority sites continued to be covered but to reduce the number through natural wastage, re-assigning staff from lower priority sites, were insupportable and questioned the basis for the risk evaluation statistics which he felt did not take into account all the risk factors in a location.
Said19 Sep 2011Executive
Petitions - school crossing patrols
Councillor Lorber also felt that contrary to indications in the report, infant schools did require patrols as frequently one adult was in charge of a number of children all walking to school. He felt that the Executive were not being presented with a solution that ensured safety.
Asked14 Sep 2011One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Work Programme and Task Group Scope
During discussion, Councillor Lorber sought further details on what the task group was seeking to achieve. He suggested that it was the responsibility of the Brent Fairtrade Network to obtain Fairtrade status and that the Network was aware that it needed to ensure that a greater number of faith groups and schools were involved as it had been informed that this was the reason it had not achieved Fairtrade status in previous attempts. He therefore suggested that the Network did not need a task group set up to support these efforts.
Moved12 Sep 2011Council
Supporting Cricklewood and its residents (Outer London Fund)
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and Councillors Leaman, Matthews and Brown's names which was put to the vote and declared CARRIED.
Moved12 Sep 2011Council
August riots
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and Councillors Allie, Brown and Beck's names which was put to the vote and declared CARRIED.
Moved12 Sep 2011Council
Libraries - working with the community
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and Councillors Brown, Beck and Castle's names which called for the Council to suspend the library closure programme and work with interested local groups to secure the future of the six libraries under threat. The motion was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Said12 Sep 2011Council
Civil disorder
Councillor Lorber felt a moment of reflection was needed so that findings of fact could be considered. It was clear that the police had misjudged the situation in Tottenham that had led up to the riots and he felt that unfortunately it could not be assumed that such rioting would not happen again. History showed that rioting was a frequent event in relatively recent times.
Said12 Sep 2011Council
Civil disorder
Councillor Lorber felt one aspect the troubles had highlighted was the need for a responsible press which did not mislead people in the hunt for a good story.
Named3 Aug 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Additional street cleansing savings
Councillor Lorber referred to the reasons for the call in of this item as set out in the agenda and expressed concern that the proposals represented the second reduction in the street cleaning budget this year and that this would impact upon the ability to maintain clean streets. He felt it was desirable to continue with the present street cleansing arrangements and he enquired whether any alternative options had been considered.
Said3 Aug 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Additional street cleansing savings
During discussion by Members, Councillor Lorber commented that there had been extensive consultation prior to the waste management and street cleansing contract agreed in 2007 and the views expressed by the residents had influenced the nature of the contract. He suggested that the present proposals reversed many initiatives that residents had supported. Clarification was sought with regard to the change in frequency of sweeps as set out in item 3.3 of the report and what streets were classified as Zone 5 and why these changes were not going to be introduced at the same time as the proposed changes as set out in 3.10 of the report.
Asked3 Aug 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Additional street cleansing savings
Councillor Lorber asked what steps would be taken to ensure that the regular sweeps would include cleaning away leaf fall. Officers were asked to comment if there were any risk in the proposals in terms of not meeting duties with regard to the Environmental Act and associated legislation and what were the implications if reports from Keep Britain Tidy ... view the full minutes text for item 4a
Named3 Aug 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Future funding of an events programme
Councillor Lorber referred Members to the reasons for the call in of this item as set out in the agenda. He felt that the original intention of the proposals to make financial savings was now being justified on grounds of equality legislation which he questioned. In addition, he sought further explanation as to what defined a faith based event, as some of these were inclusive to the whole community.
Asked3 Aug 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Future funding of an events programme
Councillor Lorber questioned whether holding council corporate events was the best approach in holding events and suggested that local organisations were better placed to undertake this as they had more experience and expertise in organising such events and that funds would be better used by providing support to these organisations.
Named27 Jul 2011Highways Committee
Response to petition against the proposed increase in residents parking charges
The petition was presented by Councillor Lorber (Group Leader) who stated that that the Executive took a decision to introduce the changes subject to consultation and delegated the final decision to officers. The decision should have been called in for scrutiny and whilst being scrutinised, the decision could not be implemented. He continued that controlled parking schemes (CPZ) were introduced as a self funding schemes aimed at protecting local residents from unauthorised parking in their areas.
Named27 Jul 2011Highways Committee
Response to petition against the proposed increase in residents parking charges
Councillor Lorber concluded that the substantial increase in charges was not supported by local residents as it undermined democratic process.
Named18 Jul 2011Executive
Future funding of an events programme
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) referred to the diverse nature of his ward and to the many festivals that had been celebrated over the years. He challenged the description of the events as religious and stated that they were inclusive, inviting the whole community and gave an opportunity to improve relations.
Asked18 Jul 2011Executive
Future funding of an events programme
Councillor Lorber asked for details of the equalities concerns referred to earlier in the meeting and questioned whether other events could also be affected such as Black History Month and Fireworks Night. He also felt that the matter should be raised at Full Council.
Moved11 Jul 2011Council
Proliferation of betting shops
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and Councillors Allie, Brown and CJ Patel's names which was put to the vote and declared CARRIED.
Moved11 Jul 2011Council
Cutting back-office functions, not libraries
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and Councillors Ashraf, Beck, Castle, Green, Hashmi, Leaman, Matthews and CJ Patel's names which called for management structures to be cut in order to save the money needed to keep six libraries open. The motion was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Moved11 Jul 2011Council
School crossing patrols
Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his and Councillors Allie, Ashraf, Brown, Hunter, CJ Patel and Sneddon's names which called on the Council to abandon proposals to withdraw some school crossing patrols. The motion was put to the vote and declared LOST.
Said6 Jul 2011One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Housing needs transformation project
During Members’ discussion, Councillor Lorber commented on the large number of customers in category D of the housing waiting list and he enquired what advice were they given at the outset and did handling the number of cases of this type burden the council with additional costs. It was queried whether the length of time on the housing waiting list was still a factor in determining progress on it.
Asked6 Jul 2011One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Housing needs transformation project
Councillor Lorber sought clarification as to whether the council would have the authority to effectively eliminate category D from the housing waiting list.
Asked6 Jul 2011One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Housing needs transformation project
In respect of categories A and B, Councillor Lorber asked about the proportion of customers that made bids through Locata . Details were sought with regard to the extent of changes in commissioning and was the customer journey objective working effectively.
Asked6 Jul 2011One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
One Council programme update
During discussion, Councillor Lorber enquired about the RAG status of the waste and street cleaning review and commented that residents had yet to receive direct information of the changes to the service that would commence on 1 October. He asked how the message would ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Asked6 Jul 2011One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Car repair and spray painting garages task group report
During discussion, Councillor Lorber enquired what measures were being undertaken to ensure that other relevant service areas were aware of the problems that can be caused by such garages and added that the problems can remain even after they have been reported.
Said6 Jul 2011One Council Overview and Scrutiny Committee
One Council Overview and Scrutiny work programme
During discussion, Councillor Lorber commented that a report on renewing the agreement with Brent Housing Partnership (BHP) was shortly to be considered by the Executive.
Named8 Jun 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in of Executive decisions from the meeting of the Executive held on 23 May 2011
The Chair invited Councillor Lorber, one of the councillors who had call in the decisions, to summarise the reasons for the call in.
Named8 Jun 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in of Executive decisions from the meeting of the Executive held on 23 May 2011
Councillor Lorber referred to the reasons for the call in as set out in the agenda and highlighted some additional points, emphasising the importance the service provided at Crawford Avenue and Clement Close short break respite centre units. He felt that the implications of closing Crawford Avenue needed further consideration. Whilst acknowledging that facilities for the service needed to be improved and the decision to relocate to the Village School had been made over a year ago, the original proposals had been to close the Crawford Avenue and Clement Close units only after the Village School was open and fully operational.
Named8 Jun 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in of Executive decisions from the meeting of the Executive held on 23 May 2011
Councillor Lorber therefore felt the Crawford Avenue closure was premature and suggested that alternative ways of achieving the improvement and saving objectives should be considered in view of the closure’s impact on service users and carers.
Said23 May 2011Executive
Update on the implementation of the Libraries Transformation Project
Councillor Lorber (Leader of the Opposition) addressed the Executive and referred to the discussion at the meeting of the Call in Overview and Scrutiny Committee. He put that the report before members did not fully address concerns as the 2011 exam period did not end in July but only after students had received their results and had had the opportunity to retake and improve grades where necessary. He sought clarification on the number of students expected to re-sit exams and expressed the view that after the closure of six libraries the remaining facilities would be insufficient.
Declared27 Apr 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared an interest as director of Friends of Barham Library in relation to item 4, however the interest was not considered prejudicial and he remained present to consider and vote on this item.
Named27 Apr 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in of Executive decisions from the meeting of the Executive held on 11 April 2011
At the invitation of the Chair, Councillor Lorber, one of the councillors who had called in this item, was invited to summarise the reasons for call in for his group. He emphasised the need to look at the alternative options proposed by the various organisations for libraries proposed for closure to continue to remain open in more detail, to take into greater account these alternative proposals for future library provision which will safeguard the libraries from the threat of closure and to address concerns in respect of the consultation that had been undertaken.
Said27 Apr 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Call-in of Executive decisions from the meeting of the Executive held on 11 April 2011
Councillor Lorber added that all the issues in respect of the decision made should be considered, in particular the impact it will have on young people.
Declared13 Apr 2011Council
Declarations of personal and prejudicial interests
Councillor Lorber declared a personal interest in the item on the summons by virtue of being a Director of Friends of Barham Library and a trustee of a related charitable trust.
Said13 Apr 2011Council
Motion - Saving Brent's Libraries
Opening the debate, Councillor Lorber stated that there had been a long consultation exercise at the end of which the Executive had decided to ignore the views expressed. He added that local people had rejected the proposals which had been recycled from time gone by.
Said13 Apr 2011Council
Motion - Saving Brent's Libraries
Councillor Lorber stated that there were clear alternatives and that these would be scrutinised when the Executive decisions were called-in. The project would result in large parts of the borough not being served by a library. He explained that the previous administration had supported the provision of a new library in the civic centre on the basis that it would be an additional library and that was why there had been investment in libraries during this time.
Said13 Apr 2011Council
Motion - Saving Brent's Libraries
It was the responsibility of local councillors to speak out for their area and Councillor Lorber stated that Liberal Democrat councillors would work with the community to re-establish any library that was closed. He moved the motion circulated.
Said23 Mar 2011Highways Committee
Petition for the Restoration of the Watford Road Bus Stop
Councillor Lorber , ward member, stated that the relocation of bus stop was carried out without the knowledge of ward councillors and residents and requested that in future ward members be alerted to such issues so that they could disseminate it to local residents. He enquired as to the assessment made including accident statistics before the decision to relocate the bus stop was undertaken. In response, Tim Jackson stated that the decision which was made by Tfl was based on potential rather than actual accident statistics.
Named2 Mar 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Restructuring of Children's Centre buildings/provision in Brent
Councillor Lorber, a councillor who had called in this item, summarised the reasons for call in and sought further details with regard to the present funding situation and whether the spending cuts would affect other relevant bodies as well as the council. He also asked for an explanation as to the basis on which the reduction in funding rested. Clarification was sought as to whether the £2.25m savings identified was a decision specifically made by the council.
Said28 Feb 2011Council
The 2011/12 Budget and Council Tax
Councillor Lorber spoke to the meeting and moved an amendment which proposed a number of alternative proposals to the proposed budget.
Moved28 Feb 2011Council
Motions
Give libraries a chance Councillor Lorber moved the motion submitted by the Liberal Democrat Group.
Said15 Feb 2011Executive
Reference of item considered by Call in Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Councillor Lorber (ward councillor) emphasised the Call in Committee’s wish to have in place at the outset conditions on the sale of the land to ensure that any development would be suitable for the area.
Said9 Feb 2011Highways Committee
Petition for the review of one way system, Maybank Avenue
Councillor Lorber , ward member, stated that the scheme was introduced in order to overcome the traffic problems and accidents in the area. In his view, the scheme had been successful in terms of accident and traffic reduction although with a slight inconvenience to some residents.
Said9 Feb 2011Highways Committee
Petition for the review of one way system, Maybank Avenue
Additionally Councillor Lorber added that as the local Sudbury Primary School was being expanded there was every reason to maintain the one way. He therefore endorsed the officer’s recommendation.
Said2 Feb 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
De-commissioning of the Mental Health Community Networks Day Care Service
Councillor Lorber, one of the councillors who had called in this item, introduced the reasons for call in and expressed concern that an important service was proposed for closure, especially as there were also proposals to close day centres. He felt that there would be immediate implications in de-commissioning this service and could place some 185 clients at high risk.
Asked2 Feb 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
De-commissioning of the Mental Health Community Networks Day Care Service
Councillor Lorber asked if a budget was available to support the clients and what was the evidence to show the benefits of the proposals. He also enquired whether a support group would be available to the client’s carers.
Said2 Feb 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Former park keepers' houses at 776 and 778 Harrow Road - disposal in open market
Councillor Lorber, one of the councillors who had called in this item, stated that the issue of disposing of the properties had been an issue for some time. Whilst he understood that the reason for disposing of the two houses was to raise funds to invest in Barham Park. However, the original proposals to sell the properties to a local housing association to provide housing from residents being decanted from Barham Park Estate had now been changed to sell the site to the by auction to the highest bidder.
Said2 Feb 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Former park keepers' houses at 776 and 778 Harrow Road - disposal in open market
Councillor Lorber expressed concern that without conditions being attached to the sale of the site, it could to lead to undesirable developments such as high storey blocks which would be opposed by local residents. He added that this issue was of particular concern as there were proposals for seven to nine storey block of flats in a site adjacent to this one.
Said2 Feb 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Former park keepers' houses at 776 and 778 Harrow Road - disposal in open market
Councillor Lorber stated that although the site was of significant financial value now, it may ... view the full minutes text for item 4c
Asked24 Jan 2011Council
Questions from the Opposition and other Non Executive Members
Councillor Lorber asked if the Executive would support the campaign to save Kensal Rise library.
Named24 Jan 2011Council
Questions from the Opposition and other Non Executive Members
Councillor Lorber referred to a document produced by consultants in 2004 advising the then Labour administration on the closure of libraries. He then referred to the refurbished libraries at Preston and Neasden which were now faced with closure.
Named24 Jan 2011Council
Questions from the Opposition and other Non Executive Members
Councillor Lorber claimed that people were only talked to by the Council and were not allowed to comment. He contrasted this with the 2008/12 library strategy produced by the last administration which outlined a commitment to the library service. He added that the proposals were destroying the principle that libraries should be local facilities.
Moved24 Jan 2011Council
Motions
Save Brent Libraries Councillor Lorber moved the motion circulated in his name which sought to note that the Liberal Democrats in 2006 scrapped plans to close libraries, believed that a local library was an important community asset and calling on the Executive not to close six libraries.
Said5 Jan 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Adult Social Care Direct Services review
Councillor Lorber, one of the councillors who had call in this item, explained that it had been because he wished that the committee consider the alternative proposals that had been made by Brent carers. He stated that the carers had felt that their views had not been sufficiently considered and neither had the item been considered in the detail they felt was necessary at the Executive meeting held on 13 December 2010.
Said5 Jan 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Fees and Charges
Councillor Lorber, one of the councillors who had called in the item, commented that he felt the proposals had been drafted over a relatively short period of time which included some substantial fee increases in some cases, whilst other fee changes were being proposed to start earlier, from January or February as opposed to the beginning of the new financial year. He felt that fee and charges increases would have major implications in some areas, such as sports activities and in shopping areas. Members then discussed the item.
Said5 Jan 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Fees and Charges
Councillor Lorber stated that the service to address rat infestation had been free because of environmental health reasons and he enquired what the consequences would be of introducing a £95 charge. He felt that rat infestation was a big problem in the borough, especially near shopping centres and that this represented a retrograde step. He asked what fees and charges changes required consultation with users, such as for allotments.
Said5 Jan 2011Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Fees and Charges
Councillor Lorber commented that the loss of take up in using services because of the increased charges could mean a fall in income and he asked whether this had been taken into consideration when devising the proposals. He queried the reasons for the difference in charges between on and off-street parking and asked when a review of the proposed fees and charges would take place to assess the impact both financially and on services.
Said13 Dec 2010Executive
Reference from Call in Overview and Scrutiny Committee - waste collection and strategy
Councillor Lorber (who had chaired the Call in Overview and Scrutiny Committee) stated that it was felt that the Executive should be more concerned over whether waste products ended up in the Third World for recycling. He was also concerned at the cost of new waste bins that would only serve to confuse residents and take up additional space.
Said9 Dec 2010Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Authority to agree recommendations from the London Councils to manage projected overspend on the Taxicard Scheme
Councillor Lorber suggested that the financial situation may not be as bad as initially thought and he enquired whether there were ongoing meetings to discuss this issue. He also asked whether the financial figures reported were the latest figures.
Named9 Dec 2010Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Authority to agree recommendations from the London Councils to manage projected overspend on the Taxicard Scheme
Members decided against a proposal from Councillor Lorber that the Executive be presented with report updating them on the financial situation with regard to the Taxicard Scheme.
Named30 Nov 2010Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair
Councillor Lorber and Councillor Kabir were nominated.
Named30 Nov 2010Call In Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Election of Chair
Both nominations were put to the vote and Councillor Lorber was declared the Chair for this meeting.
Named22 Nov 2010Council
First Reading Debate on the 2011-2012 to 2014-2015 Budget and Medium Term Financial Plan
Councillor Lorber referred to a past Labour government in the 1980’s having to approach the International Monetary Fund for assistance and he accused the last ... view the full minutes text for item 9.
Said15 Nov 2010Executive
Disposal of former allotment site adjacent to 19 Elms Gardens, Sudbury, and establishment of new replacement allotment site at Gladstone Park Gardens
Councillor Lorber (ward councillor) addressed the Executive in support of local residents who were against the proposals.
Named15 Nov 2010Executive
Disposal of former allotment site adjacent to 19 Elms Gardens, Sudbury, and establishment of new replacement allotment site at Gladstone Park Gardens
Referring to the case that had been put earlier in the meeting, Councillor Lorber recognised that the council had to balance priorities but now that the community were making a claim for the retention of the allotment site he felt that the Administration should reverse the original decision to develop the site, as it had done on a similar occasion.
Said15 Nov 2010Executive
Disposal of former allotment site adjacent to 19 Elms Gardens, Sudbury, and establishment of new replacement allotment site at Gladstone Park Gardens
Councillor Lorber suggested the need for a coherent policy on how to deal with land in residential areas which residents feel should be used for other purposes. He felt that the situation should now be reviewed in the light of developments in other parts of the borough and questioned the recommendation to dispose of the site whether or not the proposed disposal to a housing association proceeded.
Named15 Nov 2010Executive
Disposal of former allotment site adjacent to 19 Elms Gardens, Sudbury, and establishment of new replacement allotment site at Gladstone Park Gardens
Councillor Lorber put that the area was lacking in public open space and that available money was being spent on an educational site in another part of the borough that would not benefit Sudbury residents.
Asked15 Nov 2010Executive
Disposal of former allotment site adjacent to 19 Elms Gardens, Sudbury, and establishment of new replacement allotment site at Gladstone Park Gardens
Councillor Lorber asked the Executive to take time to consider the many issues that had been raised.
Named15 Nov 2010Executive
Libraries Transformation project
Councillor Lorber referred to improvements that had taken place in Barham Library and Neasden Library involving shared facilities and the recent redevelopment of Harlesden Library with the benefit of lottery funding. He expressed a wish that the consultation would be meaningful, take into account all users who would be affected including schools and those with low incomes and ensure that all options were presented clearly.
Named13 Sep 2010Council
Motions
Councillor Lorber referred to the time when controlled parking zones (CPZs) were first introduced with the aim of protecting residents living close to stations and shopping areas and the first permit was free. Thereafter charges were levied in order to recover the costs of administration. The intention was not to use them as a means of raising income.
Named11 Aug 2010General Purposes Committee
Rising to the challenges: re-shaping Brent Council to deliver the new Administration's priorities
In response to questions from Councillor Lorber on the proposal to delete the Business Transformation department and how its work would be taken forward without a senior director in post at what could be considered a critical time, the Chief Executive stated that views had been expressed during the consultation on the size of the corporate centre which he did not necessarily accept as front line services had been safeguarded however there would have been a need to review the Business Transformation Department in the near future. The proposal to make the civic centre team, working on the largest council project, part of the new Regeneration and Major Projects Department had eroded a critical part of the Business Transformation Department. Additionally, most of the business management of the transformation programme was being carried out by the Policy and Regeneration Unit.
Said11 Aug 2010Forward Plan Select Committee
Modernisation of Direct Services
During Members’ discussion, Councillor Lorber commented that there was concern that the consultation period was commencing in August when many people may be on their summer holidays and he asked if each consultation meeting would be all inclusive or targeted at particular groups. He also enquired whether the proposals intended to provide more than one Day Centre.
Said11 Aug 2010Forward Plan Select Committee
Criteria for Transport Services
Councillor Lorber commented that the proposals to review the assessment and provision of transport annually covered a long period and queried whether any suitable measures were in place to take account of change in circumstances for users. He suggested that the eligibility criteria should be carefully considered and that there be processes in place to take account of situations such as change in circumstances.
Said11 Aug 2010Forward Plan Select Committee
Budget Strategy 2011/12 to 2014/15
Councillor Lorber commented that there had long been concerns that Brent’s official population was underestimated and stated that information from Brent GPs had revealed that there were over 300,000 patients in Brent. Although it was unlikely that all patients necessarily lived in Brent, it suggested that Brent’s population was higher than the official figures, however it was difficult to provide the necessary evidence to the Government that the population was greater.
Showing the latest 300 of 366.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.