Annual Review of Adult Social Care Charging Policy 2023-24
28.5 Councillor Appich had proposed the amendment and it had been seconded by Councillor Robins. Both Councillors were invited to speak to their proposed amendments.
Every time Brighton and Hove's minutes name Councillor Robins, as the council published it.
28.5 Councillor Appich had proposed the amendment and it had been seconded by Councillor Robins. Both Councillors were invited to speak to their proposed amendments.
2.1 requests a briefing is sent to the Procurement Advisory Board before the specification and award criteria are finalised to enable members to comment on the proposed approach; and 2.2 delegates authority to the Executive Director of Health & Adult Social Care to award the contracts to the successful bidders for an initial term of five years with the option to extend the contracts for a further period of up to three years subject to satisfactory delivery and performance; and 2.3 delegates authority to the Executive Director of Health & Adult Social Care toadminister future award of contracts, in accordance with relevant procurement specification, in order to address provider performance issues or provider failure to ensure continuity of service and meet statutory requirements under the Care Act 2014; and 2.4 requests a report is brought to the June ASCPH Sub-Committee meeting with an update on the award and progress of contracts, with a further report to come before committee one year from commencement of contracts with information on how the contracts are working and on the effectiveness of the new service(s) in relation to the previous arrangements.” The amendment was proposed by Councillor Appich and seconded by Councillor Robins and they were invited to speak in support of their amendment.
15.4 The Chair, Councillor Nield invited Councillor Robins to introduce the Labour Group amendment set out below, Councillor Appich who had seconded the proposed amendment was then invited to speak in support.
Proposed by: Cllr Appich Seconded by: Cllr Robins 15.4 Councillor Appich referred to concerns which had arisen in relation to service delivery arrangements in respect of the Old Brewery site in Portslade. Issues in respect of this matter were still under investigation by the Chief Executive and there were concerns that contracts, including this one should not be let without sufficient oversight and sign off by the appropriate overarching committees beforehand.
15.5 Councillor Robins concurred with all the points raised by Councillor Appich.
15.10 Councillor Robins stated that he disagreed that there would be an unacceptable delay considering that it was very important for Members to be confident that adequate mechanisms were in place.
7.5 Cllr Robins asked why the report referenced the potential for advertising revenue to be lost, when reducing obesity is a health imperative. [name removed] responded that it is important for all impacts to be thoroughly explored when considering making changes to policy.
7.8 Cllr Robins added that deprivation was also a key factor: it is much easier for people living comfortable lives to make healthy eating choices than for people in stressful situations with little time or money to spare.
7.9 Cllr Robins queried why the proposal was to bring a report to January 2023 ASCPH. [name removed] responded that the next scheduled ASCPH meeting will be in September 2022, which would be too soon to report back, and that January 2023 is the next meeting following this. However, the project group will have finished its work well before January 2023.
8.10 In response to a question from Cllr Robins on plans to reduce the carbon impact of homecare services, [name removed] told members that this was something being explored as part of the homecare procurement process. The council is looking at innovative ways to reduce carbon emissions from car use, e.g. by more use of electric vehicles, or by requiring providers to focus on serving specific geographies in order to reduce the distance carers are required to travel between calls. [name removed] added that the current inflationary pressures being felt by homecare workers (e.g. rising petrol prices) were being addressed through additional Fair Cost of Care funding.
Councillor Robins substituted for Councillor Brennan b) Declarations of Interest:
62.6 Councillor Alan Robins noted that Sussex Police acknowledge complaints regarding short term lets and commented that some lets allow families to stay at home.
65.6 Councillor Alan Robins was informed that the current works are carried out by small contractors, not subcontractors and this would continue after the transfer.
46.15 Councillor Robins noted that Members should consider the plan as a whole rather than support parts and not others. He expressed that budget savings needed to be made from within the.
Councillor Robins agreed with Councillor Greenbaum and added that he was pleased to keep an attraction on the Dalton’s Bastion site.
53.3 It was clarified for to Councillor Robins that the original toll booths on the i360 site had deteriorated; therefore, they were being reconstructed.
At Council, Cllr Alan Robins noted the long-held links between Brighton Museum & Art Gallery and the Society, and referred to current collaborative projects such as the Whitehawk Community Archaeology project (which I understand is being considered for an award by the Council for British Archaeology).
32.5 Councillor Robins thanked Officers for the report and noted the many areas of excellent work that the report highlighted and sought to achieve. He noted that just because Hove Library was purpose built this was not a reason in itself to retain the service from that location; like the Chair he reiterated that the service would be moved, not closed.
33.6 Councillor Robins noted that he sat on the existing management board; he explained there was already drive and enthusiasm to progress this work.
20.14 Councillor Robins noted his support for the report and echoed the importance of working closely with the cricket club;
23.4 Councillor Robins highlighted it was important to understand how different industries operated in practise, and made particular example of the construction industry.
6.4 In response to a query from Councillor Robins the petitioner explained that they opposed development on greenfield sites; whilst they were in favour of development on brownfield sites they felt this needed proper traffic assessments.
8.5 In response to Councillor Robins it was clarified by Officers that no policy needed to be applied to these decisions; instead the legislation set out the criteria that had to be met; if this were done then the local authority had to approve the area becoming a neighbourhood forum.
10.2 It was confirmed for Councillor Robins that the buildings were included under both land registry name and any colloquial name – the example of Portslade Police Station was referenced.
11.4 Councillor Robins welcomed the proposals and noted this would add to the tourist offer in the city.
71.12 Councillor Robins stated that he considered it would be regrettable if this scheme and that currently underway to revitalise Saltdean Lido were to compromise one another, so that ultimately only one of them could succeed.
He noted that Councillor Robins had previously raised the matter at the committee. He therefore proposed that a report be brought back to the next meeting on the matter and the option for a heritage centre.
2.1 Councillor Robins declared that he was substituting for Councillor Pissaridou. Mia Brown declared that she was substituting for Graham Bartlett. There were no declarations of interest. 2.2 In accordance with section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, it was considered whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of any items contained in the agenda, having regard to the nature of the business to be transacted and the nature of the proceedings and the likelihood as to whether, if members of the press and public were present, there would be disclosure to them of confidential or exempt information as defined in section 100I (1) of the said Act.
56.7 Councillor Robins referred to the use of buff mortar as referred to in the report and it was explained that when works were undertaken materials were used to mirror the existing as far as it was practicable to do so.
57.7 Councillor Robins sought clarification of the powers that the Forum would have once set up and concluded that it was not appropriate for a decision to be taken as matters stood.
58.7 Councillor Robins welcomed the level of detail set out in the report stated that he hoped that Easthill Park could be considered for inclusion at a future date.
60.6 Councillor Robins stated that he came from a gypsy background, those who had ceased to travel still recognised their heritage and in his view it was very important that the community was properly consulted in respect of any proposals/provision. He sought confirmation that arrangements were in place to ensure that this community was properly consulted. The Head of City Planning and Development confirmed the consultation arrangements which were in place.
1(a) Declaration of Substitutes 1.1 Councillor Cox was present in substitution for Councillor Simson , Councillo Mitchell was present in substitution for Councillor Pissaridou and Councillor Robins was present in substitution for Councillor Lepper.
11.5 In response to Councillor Robins the Service Manager explained that if a young person went into custody they were more likely to re-offend, and managing young people through the community was considered important to addressing reoffending.
12.11 Councillor Robins noted that it was important parents were properly consulted through the process.
169.1 The Chair noted that Councillor Robins had submitted a letter for consideration in regard to the Old Police Station in St. Andrew’s Road, Portslade.
He welcomed Councillor Robins to the meeting and invited him to come forward and to address the committee.
169.2 Councillor Robins thanked the Chair and referred to his letter that had been included in the agenda. He stated that the local community believed that consideration should be given to enabling the old police station to be used as a community facility and become a heritage attraction rather than simply for housing. He therefore asked that the local community be given time to determine whether there was sufficient interest to retain the building as a community asset and secure its future.
169.3 The Chair thanked Councillor Robins and noted that there had been a change in circumstances which provided a three month window of opportunity for alternative proposals for the use of the building to be brought forward. He stated that it was the Administration’s view remained that the building/land should be used for necessary housing provision.
He would also ensure that a full written response was sent to Councillor Robins.
This would be monitored and a workshop would take place in March, which would bring together local services to look at the specific issues around support for this group since the change in the national definition to include them. 30.10 Peter Castleton, Community Safety Manager, Casework, confirmed that there were good links between the council and a number of other services with regard to dealing with anti-social behaviour 30.11 Councillor Robins referred to the section on Neighbourhoods and Quality of Life. He noted that posters highlighting theft from cars were appearing on lampposts in his neighbourhood. As a result he had received concerned emails from his constituents.
Councillor Robins questioned whether the posters were helpful or causing unnecessary worry. 30.12 Chief Superintendent Nev Kemp explained that the purpose of the posters was to make people aware of vehicle crime hotspots and were targeted in appropriate locations. Over 50% of thefts were from unsecured vehicles. 40% of property thefts were from unsecured properties.
She looked forward to seeing the detail on the website. 34.8 Councillor Robins stated that he was saddened by casual racism, homophobia and disability abuse. He was aware that people often did not feel comfortable about reporting such behaviour and wondered if there was a case for education. The Chair replied that it was about education and a firm response when people were caught out. 34.9 The Commissioner for Community Safety explained that there were excellent education programmes within schools to inform children about faiths and countries of origin.
21.25 Councillor Robins said that he felt that self regulation was a key recommendation.
3.2 Cllr Robins also commented that there seemed to be a defensive attitude by some attendees, the scrutiny panel hadn’t made any decisions yet and would hear evidence from everyone before making recommendations. They were not saying what was right or wrong.
113.6 Councillor Robins said that he had found the panel process a very poignant one. He had had personal experiences which had led him close to becoming homelessness in the past; it was just a matter of luck.
Councillor Robins asked how victims were helped. He was advised that appointing one case officer to liaise with the victim had been transformative; contact was made with 24-48 hours and regular contact was maintained thereafter.
17.6 Councillor Robins referred to the issue of fire safety, and said he had spoken with a fire officer who had informed him that walls covered in numerous coats of paint could itself be a fire hazard and asked if that was an issue being considered by the authority.
75.5 Councillor Robins asked whether the tests to ascertain potential internal decay of the tree had been conducted and whether there would be a continuing re-inspection of the safety and condition of the tree.
76.3 Councillor Robins asked if any problems with loading on the south side of Edward Street might arise.
77.4 Councillor Robins stated that he supported the comments made by the Chair. The project had a difficult brief and the best outcome had been reached.
78.9 Councillor Robins noted that 274 of the 385 responses in favour at the consultation stage had also come from 3 of 12 roads and had skewed the figures.
Councillor Robins stated that he believed that the measures should apply to only the roads affected.
54.9 Councillor Robins was concerned that an MP not from the city, or someone who was not a ward councillor could consider a complaint about an issue they knew nothing about.
56.4 Councillor Robins noted that tenant satisfaction with repairs was 99.03%, and asked how that had been measured. [name removed] said that when a job had been completed tenants were given a feedback form for them to complete. There were a number of comments from the Sub-Committee that asking people to provide feedback either straight away, or to give the completed form to the contractor, could lead to the satisfaction level not being truly reflective.
65.6 Councillor Robins stated he had found difficulty in visualising how he would drive from Edward Street to New England Road under the new proposals.
65.20 Councillor Robins stated that the Concept Scheme was very good and essential in an area at the heart of the city.
32 A Declarations of Substitute Members 32.1 Councillor Robins declared that he was substituting for Councillor Wilson.
The Director of Adult Social Services replied that the EIA had been completed and could be circulated. 38.15 Councillor Robins asked for details of the electronic monitoring system and the lay assessor’s scheme. The Head of Performance & Contracting explained that lay assessors were trained people who provided an objective view of the quality of the service. The electronic monitoring system had a range of functions.
47.5 Councillor Robins agreed with comments previously made that the cost of a public inquiry could not be justified. He added that he did not feel there was an urgent need to modify the area.
48.2 Councillor Robins formally moved an additional recommendation (2.3) from the Labour & Co-Operative Group as follows:
48.14 Councillor Robins relayed that he made a living through driving and had never been convinced that 20mph limits improved safety. He stated that there were parallels with this scheme and the parking charges in London Road where he felt concerns had not been listened to and the scheme implemented regardless.
Councillor Robins stated that the taxi trade and bus company were telling the Committee that the scheme would not work and they should listen.
For: 5 Against: 5 48.19 Therefore, the motion was not carried 48.20 The Chair then put the following motion moved by Councillor Robins to the vote with the following result:
50.9 Councillor Robins stated that he was encouraged and reassured that the Chair had met with blind and visually impaired people as he had been fearful of the impact of these proposals on these groups. He stated that he would appreciate regular updates as to the works and liaison with visually impaired people.
Councillor Robins enquired as to the difference between a courtesy crossing and a zebra crossing.
53.3 Councillor Robins stated that he was worried the council was consulting early because of the domino effect of parking displacement.
Councillor Robins felt an innovative new system should be looked at and expressed his belief that parking zones were full because of use by residents not displacement.
53.5 Councillor Robins replied that Councillor Hamilton had made this request which was more based on fear of the effects of displacement than a need for a parking scheme in their ward.
53.8 Councillor Robins stated he made the point that the current system did not seem to be providing solutions and that a new methodology needed to be looked at.
36.1 Substitutes – Councillor Les Hamilton was subbing for Councillor Alan Robins.
25.6 Councillor Robins noted that the tables in the report had a column for ‘Service Pledge’, and asked what that referred to. Officers advised that following consultation with tenants a few years ago, the authority had made a pledge that certain things would be undertaken. It was agree that a list of those pledges would be circulated to members of the Sub Committee.
It should now read “Councillor Farrow informed the Committee that he had received an invitation to the meeting on 21 March as Chair of the Woodingdean Tenants’ and Residents’ Association”. 99.2 Paragraph 91.10 – Councillor Robins stated that the reference to family should be replaced with Parents . 99.3 Paragraph 92.11 – Agreed to insert the word “surveyed” to the first line “…96% of tenants surveyed….”.
He had reminded councillors they were not bound to vote in the same way as tenant representatives. 99.6 Councillor Robins reminded members that the Senior Lawyer had clarified the legal position regarding voting at the HMCC.
Councillor Robins declared that he was substituting for Councillor Pissaridou .
91.10 Councillor Robins recounted his personal experience of coping as a young person without parents. He had been able live with friends and get work. He expressed concern for young people who did not have a job, friends or a community to help them.
94.12 Councillor Robins asked about the fitting of fire doors for leaseholders. The Leasehold Manager explained all exterior doors had to be fire and smoke proof for 30 minutes. With regard to the fitting of fire doors there were different situations for leaseholders in Brighton and Hove.
John Melson reported that Hi Rise Action Group welcomed the revised handbook. 95.4 Councillor Robins mentioned that the advice about condensation was often contradictory. For example, people were advised to keep a constant level of heat throughout the home, and to open windows.
Councillor Robins thought that washing mould off with bleach was not a good solution.
97.7 Councillor Robins mentioned that one of the most combustible items in common ways was the build up of paint coats on walls. He was able to give advice on fire retardant coatings/paints if necessary.
Councillor Hamilton declared that he was attending as a substitute for Councillor Robins. 65B Declarations of Interests 65.2 Councillor Randall, Councillor Summers, Heather Hayes and Ted Harman de clared a personal interest in any discussion on the LDV as they are Board Members of Brighton and Hove Seaside Community Homes (the Local Delivery Vehicle). 65C Exclusion of the Press and Public 65.3 In accordance with section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, it was considered whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of any items contained in the agenda, having regard to the nature of the business to be transacted and the nature of the proceedings and the likelihood as to whether, if members of the press and public were present, there would be disclosure to them of confidential or exempt information as defined in section 100I (1) of the said Act.
Sheppard for attending the meeting and presenting the petition and invited Councillor Robins to come forward and present his petition.
154.4 Councillor Robins thanked the Chair and stated that the petition had been signed by 147 people calling for two all-through Primary Schools at Portslade Infant and St. Nicholas Junior School. He stated that he was pleased to present the petition on behalf of the hard working people in Portslade and asked that continued consultations with parents and schools is maintained should the expansions be approved.
154.5 The Chair thanked Councillor Robins for attending the meeting and presenting the petition.
130.6 The Chair invited Councillor Robins to present his petition.
130.7 Councillor Robins thanked the Chair and presented a petition signed by 493 residents requesting action to be taken to address the shortfall of junior school places in Portslade.
130.8 The Chair thanked Councillor Robins for attending the meeting and stated that the petition would be taken into consideration as part of the consultation process and a report on the outcome would be brought to a meeting in the New Year.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Robins attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Robins's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Robins was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 5 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Robins declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Feb 2015 | Joint Children, Young People & Skills and Health & Wellbeing Board, item 2 | 2.1 Councillor Robins declared that he was substituting for Councillor Pissaridou. Mia Brown declared that she was substituting for Graham Bartlett. There were no declarations of interest. 2.2 In accordance with section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, it was considered whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of any items contained in the agenda, having regard to the nature of the business to be transacted and the nature of the proceedings and the likelihood as to whether, if members of the press and public were present, there would be disclosure to them of confidential or exempt information as defined in section 100I (1) of the said Act. | |
| 28 Jan 2013 | Adult Care & Health Committee, item 32 | 32 A Declarations of Substitute Members 32.1 Councillor Robins declared that he was substituting for Councillor Wilson. | |
| 24 Apr 2012 | Audit Committee, item 74 | Councillor Robins declared that he was substituting for Councillor Pissaridou . |
Where Councillor Robins sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2024 | 3 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 3 | 10 Dec 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.