Oral questions from councillors
12.15 Councillor Osborne replied, t here's a comprehensive written question that was answered from Councillor Carol Theobald, which talks about the delay I can forward you on that response.
Every time Brighton and Hove's minutes name Councillor Theobald, as the council published it.
12.15 Councillor Osborne replied, t here's a comprehensive written question that was answered from Councillor Carol Theobald, which talks about the delay I can forward you on that response.
2.2 Councillor Theobald presented a petition which had been signed by 125 people and called for the reinstatement of City in Bloom.
2.3 The Mayor thanked Councillor Theobald and stated that the petition would be referred to the Environment, Transport & Sustainability Committee for consideration.
46.4 In response to Councillor C Theobald, the Head of Library Service explained that when the library changes were reviewed, monitoring work would be undertaken to ensure the new library system was meeting the needs of the library users.
46.13 Councillor C Theobald stated that the Carnegie building was historic with listed fixtures, and it should be made a recommendation to ensure these were retained.
31.1 The minutes of the previous meeting were agreed, with the addition of one comment from Councillor Theobald about healthchecks .
71.9 Councillor C Theobald stated that she shared some of the concerns expressed by Councillor Smith and hoped that a robust business case would be required.
He therefore invited Councillor Theobald to speak to his letter.
136.5 Councillor Theobald stated that he fully supported the aims of the deputation and believed that the availability of the old police station provided a once ain a life time opportunity that should not be missed. He welcomed the intention to have a heritage centre and believed a delay of six months would not affect the current proposal for the building to be converted into housing.
Note: Councillor Theobald spoke to his letter as part of the consideration of the deputation regarding the old police station which is recorded in the preceding item (Item 136 above.)
Councillor Theobald also drew Members’ attention to the free Healthchecks that were being offered; she had had a check herself and found it very worthwhile.
Councillor Simson was in attendance in substitution for Councillor C Theobald.
“ As Councillor Theobald will be aware, it was this administration that re-established the King Alfred project in 2012, following many years of inactivity from the previous administration. In a relatively short period we confirmed the city’s priorities for the new Sports Centre, and the type of enabling development needed to help deliver it, and set out the process by which the council would seek to appoint a development partner.
145.5 The Executive Director for Finance & Resources stated the payment of professional fees differed across the organisation for various reasons and she would provide Councillor Theobald with further information following the meeting.
Proposed by: Councillor Vanessa Brown Seconded by: Councillor Carol Theobald 50.3 Councillors Brown and C Theobald stated that the Opposition spokesperson’s had been consulted in the past and they sure that this would happen in respect of future events they wanted to ensure that this was agreed formally.
51.15 Councillor C Theobald considered that a strong case had been made for this event to continue and had been impressed by the arguments put forward by those who had spoken in support of its continuance.
53.4 Councillor C Theobald sought confirmation that neighbouring Ward Councillors in Withdean had also been fully consulted and also expressed concern regarding the potential for noise nuisance to occur if there were after event parties after the event ceased at11.00pm.The relatively narrow access/egress arrangements were also a cause for concern as at end of the event a number of vehicles/pedestrians would be trying to leave the site at the same time, arrangements to ensure reinstatement of the site post event ,particularly bearing in mind potential effect on the water table in the event of wet weather also needed to be made.
54.9 Councillor C Theobald referred to the charges for use of the Royal Pavilion, these were very high when it was taken into account that the constituent elements of the package e.g., the cost of catering, charge for the ceremony etc., were in addition to venue hire.
Councillor Theobald also considered that the venue might be more attractive if it would be possible for its capacity to be increased from 90 to 100. It was explained that the capacity for the State Dining Room had been set at 90 in order to comply with fire regulations. That capacity could be increased by hiring the Music Room too but an additional charge was payable for that.
Councillor Theobald wanted the minutes to be amended to show that she had asked for a panel to be held looking at whether there could be a kitchen on the RSCH new development. She felt that it was important that patients had food that was as locally sourced and as fresh as possible.
58.4 Councillor Theobald stated that he hoped there could be flexibility in the plot sizes available. He asked if discussions with the Allotment Federation were ongoing.
58.6 Councillor Theobald noted his support for the Chair’s statement.
62.3 Councillor Theobald queried the necessity of producing the report and its consideration by Committee.
Councillor Theobald stated that he had a number of doubts about the instigation of quiet areas amongst others; the contradiction in designating a quiet area in a space that had a number of events such as the Royal Pavilion and how quiet areas would be enforced.
63.9 Councillor Theobald noted that if 44% of residents had completed the consultation, it might be expected that the 56% that had not would be in favour of the introduction of communal refuse collection.
She was not sure about whether there was any difference for organisations and individuals and would therefore provide a written response for Councillor Theobald.
71.7 Councillor C Theobald stated that it was important to continue to provide information from key sites, such as the Royal Pavilion. She sought clarification regarding the impact of the proposals for those staff immediately affected by them. The Head of Tourism and Leisure stated that it was not envisaged that there would be any compulsory redundancies as a result of the changes proposed.
Councillor C Theobald agreed that a balanced approach was needed.
74.5 Councillor C Theobald stated that she supported the draft brief as forming the basis of a public consultation and to seek to preserve this unique and historic building.
76.5 Councillor C Theobald stated that her only concern was that if the CIL rates were set too high it could lead to attempts at overdevelopment or could discourage development altogether.
77.3 Councillor C Theobald was disappointed to note the state of neglect of some of the City’s buildings such as the Hippodrome, The Astoria and Marlborough House, she hoped that action to facilitate improvements to their current state of repair could be effected in the near future.
65.19 Councillor Theobald expressed his support for the Concept Scheme and his thanks to the Senior Project Manager and his team for their work on the project thus far and how the design had appreciated or included a broad spectrum of opinion.
Councillor Theobald believed that the Valley Gardens area was currently underused, in a very poor condition and lacking in smooth transition for pedestrians and cyclists.
59.2 Councillor Theobald wished to suggest a panel into looking at kitchen provision in the new 3T development, as this could be used to provide fresh, nutritional and locally sourced meals. The Chair commented that HOSC had looked at this issue in the past so it would not be a priority to look at it again at present, but that the suggestion would be noted.
47.7 Councillor Theobald thanked the Head of Projects and Strategy for his detailed briefings on what was a complex matter.
48.6 Councillor Theobald noted that he had written to the Secretary of State in support of funding and he was pleased that this had been received from central government.
Councillor Theobald agreed that the loss of 271 parking spaces was very high and he felt this needed to be re-examined.
40(b) Declarations of interest 40.2 Councillor Theobald declared a pecuniary interest in Item 51 related to his ownership of property in the specified area and would leave the Chamber during consideration of the item.
a ) Brighton & Hove (Brills Lane) (Prohibition of Driving) Order 20** (TRO-21b-2012) b) Brighton & Hove (East Street) (Prohibition of Driving) Order 20** (TRO-21c-2012) c) Brighton & Hove (Prince Albert Street) (Prohibition of Driving) Order 20** (TRO-21d-2012) d) Brighton & Hove (Ship Street) (Prohibition of Driving and One-Way Traffic ) Order 20** (TRO-21e-2012) e) Brighton & Hove (Old Town) (Weight Restriction) Order 20** (TRO-21f-2012) f) Brighton & Hove Various Controlled Parking Zones Consolidation Order 2008 Amendment Order No .* * 20** (TRO-21g-2012) g) Brighton & Hove (Waiting & Loading/Unloading Restrictions and Parking Places) Consolidation Order 2008 Amendment Order No .* * 20** (TRO-21h-2012) For: 5 Against: 4 Note: Councillor Theobald was not present during discussion or voting on the item having declared a pecuniary interest.
48.8 Councillor Theobald stated that, just as the Brighton Station Gateway scheme had been deferred on the basis of concerns raised, so should any decision on the 20mph scheme. He added that he did not believe there was sufficient support for a blanket scheme and that a ‘cluster’ scheme would be more popular.
Councillor Theobald agreed with the concerns raised regarding taxi passengers and safety at bus stops at night. However, he added that he could not support the Labour & Co-Operative motion as he believed a scheme in that form would cost more to implement due to the need for more signage and a list of roads was not present.
48.16 Councillor Theobald moved the following motion on behalf of the Conservative Group:
48.18 The Chair put the motion moved by Councillor Theobald to the vote with the following result:
49.3 Councillor Theobald also praised the report author for his engagement and the briefings he had provided to his party.
Councillor Theobald noted that he supported the recommendations to delay work to conduct further work on what were extremely difficult issues.
50.3 Councillor Theobald noted he was concerned that reducing the lanes to one on Dyke Road could lead to chaos. He asked several questions regarding the placement of the loading bay southwards of Dyke Road and the possible restrictions on the large delivery vehicle that often presented an obstacle to traffic going northwards.
51.2 Councillor Theobald asked how the scheme would be advertised.
52.3 Councillor Theobald stated he agreed with the comments made by Councillor Lepper and Downs Infant School on the matter.
Councillor Theobald noted his concern for the knock on effect of the proposals in surrounding areas and the continuing extension of parking zones in the city in general.
54.5 Councillor Theobald stated that he was disappointed in the removal of the 3 hour tariff in the Laines Car Park and other areas to a 2 or 4 hour tariff. He believed people had been tricked into paying more as they would automatically choose a longer stay as a safety measure.
46a Declarations of Substitutes 46.1 Councillor Wealls was present in substitution for Councillor C Theobald.
38.5 Councillor C Theobald expressed her support for the recommendations and the way different proposals were suggested for different buildings. The Royal Pavilion was itself a marvellous building.
41.5 Councillor C Theobald stated that any improvements to or developments which would encourage greater use of the Volks Railway would also be welcomed.
42.7 Councillor C Theobald noted that it was intended that the sand sculpture exhibition was intended to operate for broadly the same period as that during which the Volks Railway was in operation.
Councillor Theobald also enquired regarding longer term plans both for construction of a temporary coach park and to enhance and improve the Volks Railway.
44.7 Councillor C Theobald stated the she considered it was very important that this matter be clarified as she had understood that an agreement had been entered into with the football club. She cited their important contribution to the city which she felt should be supported.
1 a) Declarations of Substitutes 1.1 Councillor Cox was present in substitution for Councillor Carol Theobald and Councillor Lepper was present in substitution for Councillor Fitch.
270.3 Councillor Theobald welcomed the report and stated that he supported the project; however he was concerned about the use of council tax payers’ money to enable the loan to the development company and asked for clarification on how this would be secured.
95.4 Councillor Carol Theobald said that the figures were still high – even though they were proportionally less than the regional and national averages – and stated that the Government were taking measures to mitigate the situation. The Leader noted that the effect of unemployment was greater on women.
96.4 Councillor Carol Theobald highlighted some of the schemes that the Government was funding to address youth unemployment.
97.5 Councillor Carol Theobald noted that the i360 was a good scheme for the seafront, and it was clarified that if successful the prospective loan period would be approximately 11 years. The Leader also highlighted that the scheme would provide approximately 180 jobs in its construction and running.
98.4 Councillor Carol Theobald said that she welcomed the report, and hoped future applications would, at least, be able to protect the façade of the building.
Councillor Carol Theobald also noted the improvements made to the Brighton Centre, and said that there were further structural works to be completed.
99.6 Councillor Carol Theobald also asked questions in relation to the West Pier and the i360 project; in response it was explained that it was important to deliver the i360 project before considering other projects that may not necessarily compliment the i360. Once this was completed there would be an opportunity to discuss the necessity of a second pier, given that much of the heritage aspects of the West Pier had unfortunately been lost.
So, we are proposing the compromise of a “peak hours only” loading prohibition on one side of the road between Holland Road and Montpelier Road). 94v.3 Councillor Theobald stated that the petitioner had made valid points and asked Councillor West to reject the proposals. He believed a more flexible approach on this issue was successfully operated in other countries in mainland Europe.
100.5 Councillor Theobald asked if the skate park would still be located in the northern area of the park.
100.7 Councillor Theobald asked if there would be further report on the skate park to a future meeting with a health and safety risk assessment.
101.4 Councillor Theobald asked for an update as to the £237,000 earmarked for open access land in Ditchling Rise.
102.6 Councillor Theobald asked how turnings would be managed if a lane was removed from Lewes Road, how utility company work would be managed whilst the work was ongoing and if measures would be introduced to the south of the Vogue Gyratory as well as the north.
104.3 Councillor Theobald enquired as to the timescale of the scheme.
105.6 Councillor Theobald asked for a deferral of the decision for a loading ban on Western Road for further consideration or to introduce measures on both sides of the road.
75.7 In response to a question from Cllr C Theobald about resource implications of this initiative, the committee was told that the introduction of practice-based teams would lead to a small reduction in nursing staff requirement – 3 FTE posts. Other savings would arise from the use of more appropriate staffing – currently, too many service users were supported by inappropriately senior staff (e.g. nurses providing non-nursing services).
76.8 In response to a question from Cllr C Theobald on maternity/paediatrics, members were told that this was likely to be a very significant issue going forward, with the need to balance people’s reasonable expectations of locally accessible services with a configuration of services that accords with guidance from the Royal Colleges on optimum unit size.
70.5 Councillor Theobald was concerned that Goldsmid Ward would have to travel out of the ward to vote, but accepted that as it was mainly a residential area that there was nowhere for a polling station.
71.3 Councillor Theobald felt that the level of sickness was high and was double the level of private sector employees, and asked if relaxing the procedures would help reduce the level of sickness. The Head of Human Resources suggested that it was not a relaxation of procedures, but rather a different emphasis to the issue. It was hoped that the procedures would improve the sickness level.
72.2 Councillor Theobald agreed with the proposed timetable, but asked if in future the dates of the political party conferences could be noted to ensure that no meetings were scheduled during those dates.
73.2 Councillor Theobald said that termination of the agreement had been expected, but had concerns over where the planning meetings would be held.
Councillor Theobald was advised that the meetings would be held in Midhurst, unless there were a high number of residents involved in a matter when an alternative more locally based venue would be considered.
Councillor Theobald was concerned that Midhurst was difficult to travel due, with a lack of public transport, and felt that an alternative venue such as Arundel should be considered. The Chair asked if those comments could be passed to the SDNPA. RESOLVED That the Governance Committee recommend that Council agrees that the Agency Agreement dated 21 June 2011 between South Downs National Park Authority and the Council relating to the provision of planning services in Brighton and Hove be terminated on a date to be agreed by the South Downs National Park Authority and the Strategic Director, Place.
75.4 Councillor Theobald noted paragraph 3.7 of the report which referred to the system of ‘earn back’.
Councillor Theobald was advised that the council didn’t operate performance related pay and so ‘earn back’ could not be implemented.
77.5 Councillor Theobald thanked everyone who was involved in this matter.
Councillor Theobald noted that it was proposed that the Policy and Resources Committee have ten members, but given the expected workload it would be more appropriate to have twelve members. The previous Policy & Resources Committee had fifteen members.
Councillor Theobald moved an amendment to the suggested recommendation.
77.9 Councillor Theobald noted that there would be an Environment & Sustainability Committee and a Transport Committee, and suggested that as there would as there would be a crossover between the two committee, and some items may need to go to both committees, that it would more efficient to combine the two to form one committee.
218.3 Councillor Theobald welcomed the report and asked for more information to be provided in relation to the proposed community banking approach.
222.5 The Chair noted that officers would provide Councillor Theobald with a briefing on the points raised and stated that he wished to thank everyone involved in the development of and bringing forward of the strategy. He then put the recommendations to the Cabinet for agreement.
Declarations of substitutes Cllr Graham Cox for Cllr Carol Theobald.
He stated that he would ensure Councillor Theobald received a written explanation as to how the situation had changed and its impact for the council.
He stated that he would ask officers to prepare a briefing note for Councillor Theobald on the matter.
71.4 Councillor Carol Theobald asked if there was any evidence to explain if those 18-24 year olds in employment were in jobs that they wanted to be in. The Economic Research and Project Support Officer explained that there were issues in relation to underemployment of graduates, and it was important that entry level positions were created and freed up for graduates.
71.7 Councillor Carol Theobald noted that much of the changes in the wage inequality could be due to the increased number of women working and the increased number who were now the sole earner in households. She went on to note that increased costs to energy and fuel affected everyone, and expressed concern about the number of residents of the city below the poverty line.
72.4 Councillor Carol Theobald stated her view that the 20% figure did not go far enough, and there was the need to keep work in the city for residents.
73.3 Councillor Carol Theobald welcomed the new legislation and acknowledged that further details were still yet to be forthcoming.
73.4 Councillor Carol Theobald also asked if the Council would be coordinating between bodies in relation to the proposals for neighbourhood planning, and Officers explained that they would need to wait for further guidance before this work could begin.
74.3 Councillor Carol Theobald asked how this work would be funded, and the Leader explained it was necessary to wait for further guidance.
75.3 Councillor Carol Theobald highlighted that funding could be needed for affordable housing, and in response the Head of Planning and Public Protection, Martin Randall, confirmed that the approach currently used by the Council would not be downgraded, but it was important to ensure funding was allocated properly.
77.4 Councillor Carol Theobald welcomed the update, and noted it was important that this type of work continue.
80.2 Councillor Carol Theobald asked if there had been any success in relation to takeaways near secondary schools, and the Leader explained there were limitations in relation to planning, and it was difficult to stop mobile units; however, this remained an important public health issue.
81.6 Councillor Carol Theobald welcomed the proposed use of the site for parking provision and the potential for a park and ride facility. In relation to the timescales it was highlighted that application had been received by the Council was expected to be heard by the Planning Committee next month.
82.4 Councillor Carol Theobald noted she was pleased to see the ongoing success of the sector in the city. She went on to add that there was the possibility of breaking larger offices down into smaller units, and asked a question specifically in relation to the problems with recruiting graduates to the sector. [name removed] responded that the sector needed a range of staff and many small businesses were less inclined to hire staff without experience, or those with skills not yet fully adapted to the workplace.
62.3 In answer to questions from Cllr Carol Theobald on local feeding rates, the committee was told that rates had improved in recent years, with 80+ of new mothers in the city breast-feeding. It was difficult to say whether the average length of time that new mothers fed for had also increased, but this was likely.
71.7 Councillor Theobald noted his disagreement that the authority had been disproportionately hit by the central government austerity measures. He believed the administration were implementing savings in the wrong areas in particular toward the business sector. He suggested the subsidy provided to allotment holders was a historic one to assist people in improving their health and it should be maintained.
72.3 Councillor Theobald suggested that this policy could lead to more unauthorised encampments. He also believed the costs of the service provision to official sites should be paid for by the Travellers based there.
Councillor Theobald also commented that the financial implications of the report were of a poor standard and out-dated.
72.4 Councillor West replied that the report recommended savings to a contract agreed by Councillor Theobald when he was Cabinet Member for Environment.
73.8 Councillor Theobald thanked officers for the report and welcomed the extension of the maximum length of stay on Preston Avenue.
However, Councillor Theobald noted his disappointment that the first hour of stay was not free of charge.
73.10 Councillor Theobald replied that he disagreed with a surplus in principle and that any deficit arising from the cost of providing the first hour of parking free of charge should be met by the central parks budget.
74.5 Councillor Theobald enquired as to the likelihood of Palmeira Square and Brunswick Square participating in the measures in the future.
49a Declaration of Substitutes 49a.1 Councillor Bowden attended as a substitute for Councillor Kennedy Councillor Cobb attended as a substitute for Councillor Theobald 49b Declarations of Interest 49b.1 There were none.
41(a) Declarations of Interests 41a.1 Councillor C Theobald declared a personal, but non-prejudicial, interest in Item 56, a report of the Strategic Director, Place concerning updated background studies for the Local Development Framework City Wide Plan, as her son was an Associate Director at CBRE who had conducted the retail study. 41(b) Exclusion of Press and Public 41b.1 In accordance with section 100A of the Local Government Act 1972 (“the Act”), the Cabinet Member considered whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting during an item of business on the grounds that it was likely, in view of the business to be transacted or the nature of the proceedings, that if members of the press and public were present during that item, there would be disclosure to them of confidential information (as defined in section 100A(3) of the Act) or exempt information (as defined in section 100I(I) of the Act). 41b.2 RESOLVED - That the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of Item 59 onwards.
51.5 Councillor C Theobald also welcomed the CESP and stated that limited progress on the city’s major projects had prevented jobs being created. She requested more information on the role of the Local Enterprise Partnership (LEP) in the CESP.
52.6 In response to a question from Councillor C Theobald regarding the council’s financial contribution to the project, the Economic Development Manager explained that there was no direct cost and that staff time to oversee it was valued at €43,960.50 over the life of the project, and that the council would get this money back. She advised that WSCC had agreed to provide a €50,000 in addition to staff time.
53.5 Councillor C Theobald welcomed the increased number of women in high earning jobs and noted that those in middle income occupations were often the first to lose out when the labour market was under pressure.
55.5 Councillor C Theobald welcomed the proposed PPS and advised that the Conservative Group had submitted its own response to the consultation. She stated that provision of a permanent site would make it easier to move people on from unauthorised encampments and that it was important to treat all people equally in terms of accommodation and not be seen to be prioritising the needs of gypsies and travellers.
In response to a comment from Councillor C Theobald regarding convenience goods outlets, she explained that such outlets were finding a way in because planning permission was not required for a change of use in such cases.
57.4 Councillor C Theobald questioned whether the CIL would bring in more funding that the section 106 regime and advised that the council had to be careful not to deter developers.
58.5 Councillor C Theobald asked how many schemes the SPD would apply to given that some extensions did not require planning permission. She welcomed the SPD, but noted that it would be difficult to prevent residents from thinking they could copy bad extensions on other properties.
3.1 Councillor Kennedy praised Councillor Theobald in recognition of his work as Cabinet Member during the last four last years and noted that h e had chaired his Cabinet Member Meetings openly, encouraging debate and participation from Members and the public. She advised that the new Cabinet Members looked forward to continuing to encourage participation at meetings and to working openly and collaboratively with all Groups over the coming months.
6b.10 Councillor Theobald noted that Councillor Davey had stated that the Trust would assess parking needs for hospital staff, but that Full Council had recommended that the council work with the Trust; he advised that it was vital that both parties be involved.
12.6 Councillor Theobald noted that Central Government was proposing to allow issues, such as the number of dwellings, to be determined locally .
13.4 Councillor Theobald emphasised the importance of consultation and noted that the ward councillors were supportive of the final document.
16.6 In response to questions from Councillor Theobald, the Lead Commissioner explained that the consultation was part of a citywide review of all supported bus routes and that comments from all parts of the community were welcomed, including those where there may be demand for a new route. He added that the new contracts were designed to support competition.
17.3 Councillor Theobald noted that it was often frustrating that someone had to be injured before a crossing could be installed; he welcomed the new methodology and praised the work of the ECSOSC.
216.2 Councillor Theobald noted the request for officers to undertake a detailed analysis scheme by scheme and examine how to reduce the overall number of vehicles on the city streets and how to facilitate resident parking without causing displacement. He confirmed that a citywide parking review was planned for later in the year and that it would look at various aspects of controlled parking and consider requests from residents and ward councillors to review existing parking schemes. Residents and businesses, ward councillors and other stakeholders would be consulted as part of the review.
“Why is there no Management Plan in place for Blaker's Park despite two years of requests from the Friends of Blaker’s Park, and when will the Council start the community consultation process for such a plan?” 217.3 Councillor Theobald had circulated the following response:
218a.3 Councillor Theobald stated that Brighton and Hove was a special place for trees, with the national elm collection which had international significance. The city also had 12,000 street trees and the council was committed to increasing that number. The council worked with Trees for Cities on planting schemes, such as Warren Plantation in Woodingdean and East Brighton Park and significant planting in had also taken place in Stanmer Park, with more planned for the future.
Councillor Theobald advised that trees were important for many environmental reasons, as well as preventing cars from parking on grass verges.
220.3 In response to questions from Councillor Mitchell, Councillor Theobald confirmed that the council would be submitting a bid to the Government’s Local Sustainable Transport Fund by the deadline of 18 April and that if any new 20mph zones were to be implemented, they would be funded from the allocation for ‘Road Safety Engineering’.
194.3 Councillor Theobald advised that details of the first year of the investment programme would be considered by the Cabinet on 7 April 2011, and not solely by himself as stated in paragraph 5.1 of the report.
194.6 Councillor Theobald stated that the Plan was comprehensive and detailed a clear strategy. The first year of investment would be considered by the new Council alongside the Plan after the elections, and years two and three would follow later in 2011; the Plan was intentionally flexible to enable implementation as per the will on the new Council.
Councillor Theobald reported that the Cabinet would receive a presentation at its next meeting on the new transport model purchased by the council, which would make it possible to see the effect of transport schemes on other parts of the city prior to implementation.
Councillor Theobald noted that the council had the award for Car Park of the Year for the Lanes Car Park and stated that the Administration had achieved a lot in the last four years.
194.9 In response to questions from Councillor Randall, Councillor Theobald advised that work on transport integration and ‘park and ride’ proposals were ongoing.
196.9 Councillor Theobald noted that the Town Hall had received no investment for a number of years and that the aim was to improve the building for residents.
“ Can Councillor Theobald please provide me with figures for the following:
178.7 In response to a query from Councillor Theobald about possible Environmental Health issues raised by residents in the future, the Acting Assistant Head of Law advised that the conditions in the scheme would not prevent such issues being investigated and that Hyde would be responsible for addressing them. He added that Hyde could look at other similar developments and would rely on their own experts to prevent problems arising.
178.11 Councillor Theobald stated that he felt that the agreed scheme placed greater emphasis on the housing development and that he was unsure whether it represented the best use of the site.
164.2 In response to a query from Councillor Theobald concerning parking income, the Director of Finance explained that the information in Appendix 6 related to the Medium Term Financial Strategy and represented future predictions based on financial modelling.
164.16 In response to comments from Councillor Hamilton in relation to residents’ parking permits, Councillor Theobald advised the proposals represented a 7% reduction. He added that frontline services that mattered to residents, such as parks and CityClean , had been protected and value for money had been achieved through schemes like refurbishment of The Lanes car park.
170.11 Councillor Theobald suggested that the Cabinet meet after consideration of the issues by the Planning Committee.
171.4 Councillor Theobald stated that he was pleased to see progress in relation to the site and that a hotel development was appropriate for the site.
Councillor Theobald was unwell and on behalf of the whole Committee the Chairman wished him well.
It was noted that Councillor Theobald had been unable to answer questions due to meeting procedure rules, and not because he was incapable of answering them.
2.20 Councillor Lepper felt that if members of the public viewed clips 1 to 4 and then viewed clip 5, they might assume that Councillor Theobald was stating an inability to answer questions put in clips 1-4, whereas in fact he was stating that he was unable to answer due to complex Council procedure rules.
(2) The Panel does not agree with the Officer’s findings in respect of paragraph 3 in that Councillor Kitcat did fail to treat Councillor Theobald with respect in terms of using the 5 th clip to show Councillor Theobald in an unflattering light, which was out-of-context and did not seek to explain fully the circumstances that led to the comment.
203.8 Councillor Theobald explained that he shared some of the frustration in relation to the cycle lanes; the Administration had inherited them and had immediately called for a review as they represented a new layout for the city, which was difficult for some residents to understand. He confirmed that the cycle lanes were checked against nationally applied safety criteria for motorists, cyclists and pedestrians and were under regular review. He advised that the council was in the process of making some changes to the cycle lanes, including improving visibility.
203.9 The Chairman confirmed that Councillor Theobald would contact [name removed] once proposed changes had been drawn up. She added that the original plans for the cycle routes had been approved by the Environment Committee under the previous constitutional arrangements.
Declaration of interest Councillor Melanie Davis, Councillor Rachel Fryer and Councillor Carol Theobald all declared an interest as members of the Arts Commission.
56.3 Councillor Pidgeon declared that he was substituting for Councillor Theobald.
106.7 Councillor Theobald advised that he had listened to the comments both in support and in opposition to the proposed scheme and reiterated that the safety concerns were too significant to proceed with the scheme. He added that he would provide opposition Members with further information in relation to the remaining funding. 106.8 RESOLVED - That having considered the information and the reasons set out in the report, the Cabinet Member accepted the following recommendation:
4.8 Councillor Theobald stated that at the last Budget Council (25 February 2010) the Conservatives alone voted for an additional £100 000 per year for the Winter Service Plan and a one off £204 000 payment.
4.9 Councillor Theobald placed on record his gratitude, admiration and thanks to staff who were on standby or who worked through the night or who went beyond their contracted duties (such as Cityparks and Cityclean workers) to help the community with jobs such as clearing pavements.
4.10 Councillor Theobald noted that community groups such as the Hollingbury LAT had commented on the real community spirit of people who helped during the snow.
193.6 Councillor Theobald explained that the targets within the strategy were set at a realistic and achievable level.
194.5 Councillor Theobald advised that while planning and licensing departments did work closely, efforts would be increased to ensure a more joined-up approach.
198.3 In response to a question from Councillor Randall, Councillor Theobald confirmed that £400,000 of the £2.2 million had been spent to date.
A report will be considered at the Environment Cabinet Member Meeting detailing other schemes that will come forward.” 172.6 Councillor Theobald confirmed that the funding was still available and would be re-profiled.
Is he aware that the local Transport Act 2008 contains provisions such as Quality Contracts that allow Local Authorities more control over bus services and will he be taking advantage of these opportunities to provide an improved bus service to people of Brighton & Hove?" 172.8 The following response from Councillor Theobald had been circulated:
175.13 Councillor Theobald explained that the budget proposals for the Environment Directorate savings would achieve savings of £1.63m, in addition to absorbing £1.7m in relation to service pressures. He advised that funding had been identified to fund ongoing seafront maintenance, gum removal and winter maintenance and that additional investment would be made into Hove Lagoon. He added that the proposed transport model would be very important for the city.
44.1 Environment Cabinet Member Councillor Theobald outlined some of the completed public place improvements and current street scene work in the City. He answered questions on transport; and managing the expectations of pedestrians, cyclists, car -, van-, taxi- and bus- drivers. The results of the consultation on the Old Shoreham Road Cycle Lane were due to be reported to Environment CMM soon, he said.
44.2 Councillor Theobald gave reasons why a new Transport Model was required. He pointed out some advantages of the Cumulative Impact Area and new provisions under Licensing legislation, that allowed for more control over licensed premises.
44.3 Asked whether responses were always provided to deputations and petitions, Councillor Theobald replied that he was pleased to have feedback from the public. He said that answers to environment issues could take some time to supply; however he would look into any case of undue delay that was brought to his attention.
45.4 Councillor Theobald said it would be unrealistic and impractical to try to grit every road but the 40% gritting coverage of the road network exceeds the 24% target set by the Audit Commission target. He explained the WSP priorities within the city and how additional staff were called in to aid in carrying them out.
Councillor Theobald was in contact with officers throughout the Christmas period and was aware of the considerable amount of work they were doing around the clock. He reminded the committee that such weather had been unprecedented and the sub zero day time temperatures and low level of traffic on the roads had affected the effectiveness of the gritting process.
The members were Councillor Mel Davis, Council Rachel Fryer, and Councillor Carol Theobald.
37.2 Councillor Mrs Theobald declared that she was substituting for Councillor Theobald.
132.6 Councillor Theobald also reported positive performance in relation to NI47 the number of people killed or seriously injured in road traffic accidents and NI95c levels of graffiti.
28.7 Councillor Theobald referred to a briefing paper that had been received by School Governors concerning PFI contracts in the City and suggested that this may have been the source of the concern raised. He stated that Cabinet Members were unaware of any issues around this matter. The Chairman noted that Cabinet Members were unaware of any risks arising in this matter and felt that it could be reviewed by the Committee at a later date if a risk did become apparent.
29.5 Councillor Theobald noted the adjusted misstatements in the accounts listed at appendix 2 and asked if these adjustments resulted in a better financial position for the Council. The Audit Commission replied that the overall deficit had been overstated by £7.2 million, but the misstatements were not cash items and so did not affect the Council’s financial position in real terms. He added that there had been very few amendments in terms of cash on the balance sheets.
29.6 Councillor Theobald asked if the Council’s assets were valued independently, especially in terms of car parks. The Assistant Director of Financial Services stated that they were and that one fifth of all the Council’s assets were valued each year, whilst the entirety of the housing stock was valued yearly.
29.7 Councillor Theobald asked if there was a difference in the Council’s valuation of the car parks compared with the Audit Commissions valuation. The Audit Commission agreed that there was an adjustment, but this was linked to the errors created when the transaction was input into the new system.
29.12 Councillor Theobald was concerned about the increase in the Audit Commission’s fee and noted that the Council had no option but to use the Audit Commission. He felt this was unfair and related poorly to efficient use of resources.
Councillor Theobald asked why the Audit Commission had raised the fee for 2008/09.
1.2 Councillor Pidgeon declared that he was substituting for Councillor Theobald.
112.7 Councillor Theobald expressed dissatisfaction that there was not an opportunity to dispute the fee. He stated that Sussex Police had written to the Audit Commission previously regarding high Audit Fees, without success, and so was not confident that this procedure would produce results for the Council.
"Could Cllr Theobald provide the Cabinet meeting with details of the 'stopper' that I'm told is going to be fitted to communal bins without foot pedals? Could he provide:
· And the estimated cost of adding these stoppers to all bins without foot pedals?" 202.8 The following response from Councillor Theobald had been circulated:
“Would you please comment on the timescale for rolling out the new mechanism and the associated costs?” 202.10 Councillor Theobald gave the following response:
"Could Cllr Theobald provide the litres of fuel used per month by CityClean for waste collection in January, February and March 2008 and also for January, February and March 2009?" 202.12 Councillor Theobald explained that a written response would be provided to this question as officers would need to undertake a detailed investigation to obtain the answer.
208.4 In response to queries, Councillor Theobald confirmed that the Friends of Parks groups had and would continue to be involved in the project, and that the council was already in receipt of the section 106 funding for play at the Level. He added that the project would complement ongoing work carried out by the council’s park department.
175 a Declarations of Interests 175a.1 Councillor Theobald declared a personal interest in item 190 as a relative was an employee of a consultancy firm used by the council.
69.2 Councillor Mrs C Theobald declared that she was substituting for Councillor Theobald.
23.1 Evidence from Councillor Carol Theobald (CD), Chairman of the Licensing Committee and Tim Nichols (TN), Head of Environment and Licensing 23.2 CT informed the panel that there was ongoing work in schools educating pupils on the affects that alcohol has and that generally, under 18’s do not obtain their alcohol from licensed premises.
"Would Councillor Theobald please tell us how many more of the new street signs will be erected in this authority's area?" 91.2 The Cabinet Member stated that, in accordance with council policy, new street signs would be replaced as and when they were needed. The council did not have a set number of replacements per year.
‘ “Could Councillor Theobald provide, in detail, any arrangements for measuring the levels of waste and recycling collected during and after the introduction of communal bins to the city centre?” 148.3 In Councillor Theobalds ’ absence the Chairman replied:
He asked on what Constitution basis Councillor Theobald could ignore recommendations agreed in September 2007 by the Environment Committee that recycling rates would be measured.
126.3 Councillor Theobald gave the following response:
126.8 ‘Why have the collection days been changing from week to week, what effect will this have on collections over the Christmas period and what is the cost of the additional work that has been carried out on Saturdays?’ 126.9 Councillor Theobald replied:
132.2 Councillor Theobald noted concerns raised by Councillor Mitchell regarding dealing with waste from London. He noted that GOSE were advising on the issue.
88.2 The Chairman approved an additional recommendation moved by Councillor Theobald that ‘“Objects to policy T3 which encourages the consideration of road charging in regional hubs, and considers that road charging schemes are neither appropriate nor desirable for Brighton & Hove.” 88.3 Cabinet agreed the additional recommendation which became xii of the resolution noted below.
92.3 Councillor Theobald welcomed the report and the support of the Chairman.
15A Declarations of Substitutes 15.1 Councillor Simson declared that she was attending the meeting as a Substitute Member for Councillor Theobald and would be Chairman.
It was agreed that legal advice would be taken on this matter and advice given to Cllr Duncan and Cllr Theobald, who was also a member of the Police Authority, for future meetings. 22.3 Cllr Smart asked where the funding would come from if participatory budgeting was introduced. [name removed] confirmed that the proposal was that it would come from the Command Unit Funding Stream and will go to the decision making process. If allocated next year it will go to the Sussex Police Authority and it would be their decision whether it went to the pooled budget for crime prevention.
55.3 ‘Recalling strong advice given by the Conservation Advisory Group, as endorsed by English Heritage and ICOMOS, and given the absence, from the Report on Communal Bins, of recommended environmental impact assessments for the proposed Communal Bin positions - on what specific basis is it considered that the Council's Statutory Duties under Conservation, Listed Buildings and Highways legislation has been evidentially discharged and fairly recorded for democratic and public scrutiny as well as to underpin robust defence of exposure to Ombudsman or Court processes and as a basis for assessment of contested deferred decisions and other changes in historic areas?’ 55.4 The Chairman invited Councillor Theobald to respond.
Councillor Theobald replied as follows:
Chavasse in an exchange with Councillor Theobald then posed two further questions and a number of additional points;;
55.14 Councillor Theobald confirmed that the areas proposed to be excluded from communal bins (Sussex Square, Lewes Crescent, Chichester Terrace and Arundel Terrace, Brunswick Square and Brunswick Terrace, Adelaide Crescent / Palmeira Square) would indeed be excluded, rather than re-consulted.
55.15 Councillor Theobald concluded that the decision about the frequency of collections was not a Cabinet decision nor related to the report in question. The decision to alter the frequency of collections had been delegated to the Director of Environment and had been taken in consideration of to resource and operational issues.
As the Seafront heritage squares and terraces are being taken out of the communal bins roll-out in recognition of their special status, could the Member of the Environment tell us if he is prepared to exempt Nizell's Avenue and these exceptional gardens for the same reason?” 56.3 Councillor Theobald replied:
56.6 Councillor Theobald offered a written response.
63.6 In response to queries from Councillor Mitchell as regards funding the restoration of the Bandstand, Councillor Theobald noted the following. That previous attempts to gain funding from English Heritage had failed and that the additional allocation of 70K to the project was for improved lighting in the area.
63.7 Responding to comments from Councillor Mitchell about the state of Madeira Drive, Councillor Theobald noted that funding for repairs to the Madeira Lift was being sought. He added that the Strategic Plan developed for such issues would assist in determining priorities and setting budgets.
63.9 Councillor Theobald noted that detail would be provided at a future Environment Cabinet Member Meeting.
67.1 The Cabinet considered a report of the Director of Environment that requested approval of an extension of the communal bin scheme in central parts of the city, following consultation with residents, ward councillors, and interested parties (for copy see minute book). 67.2 Councillor Theobald noted the petition presented earlier in the meeting in opposition to the proposals. He also noted letters of support from residents of Brunswick Square and requests from neighbouring areas for the introduction of communal bins. He had also received letters from persons initially against the proposal who were now in favour.
67.5 Councillor Theobald noted that there were no negative impacts on recycling in relation to the proposals and offered a written response to Councillor Kitcat detailing this.
Councillor Theobald refuted that the consultation had been flawed noting the roughly equal amount of response for and against the proposals.
67.9 Councillor Theobald noted that that the change to the frequency of collections was not directly related to the proposals as regards communal bins. However, he noted that he did not feel it appropriate that some areas of the city should have twice weekly collections while other areas did not. He added that he was happy to speak with the Ward Councillors about the situation at any time.
67.10 The Chairman suggested that Councillor Theobald clarify the details as pertaining to the change to the frequency of collections with Councillor Watkins away from the meeting.
67.12 Councillor Theobald felt that there had been more than adequate publicity surrounding the proposals; this was evidenced by the correspondence that Members had received.
67.14 Councillor Theobald confirmed that Sussex Square, Lewes Crescent, Chichester Terrace, Arundel Terrace, Brunswick Square, Brunswick Terrace, Adelaide Crescent and Palmeria Square were excluded from the scheme.
67.18 Councillor Theobald recalled the initial resistance to the scheme and noted that many of those initially opposed had been convinced of the benefits following a period of adjustment. He commended officers for their extensive work in this area.
68.3 Councillor Theobald noted the extensive nature of the refurbishments and the increasing costs of raw materials.
23.1 Councillor Theobald said he was pleased to have an opportunity to speak about the Environment service area, covering waste collection and disposal, parks and green spaces, planning, transport, and public safety plus other key areas of work. He spoke about a number of key issues including:
23.8 The Chairman thanked Councillor Theobald for an interesting overview and for contributing positively to the relationship between decision-making and scrutiny functions.
27.3 The Director of Environment told the meeting that Councillor Theobald had brought forward the issue of the City’s allotments as a matter that the Committee may wish to consider for a Scrutiny Review. The Support Officer would add this as a possible item to the Committee’s Work Plan 27.4 Regarding the topic of a detailed Scrutiny Review the Committee agreed that a further meeting be convened of the working group, Councillors Morgan, Janio and Davey .
16.10 The Chairman invited Councillor Theobald to address the meeting.
16.11 Councillor Theobald detailed the legal and historical background to the issue, including the Travellers Strategy, refurbishment of the Horsdean site and the need for a permanent site.
16.12 At the invitation of the Chairman Councillor Gill Mitchell asked Councillor Theobald questions on Public engagement and consultation prior to the decision The Decision-making Process and Planning aspects of the decision Post-decision-making activities 16.13 In her view, there had been the barest of Information available for ward councillors with the shortest of deadlines.
16.15 Councillor Mitchell asked Councillor Theobald if he was aware that after the decision, residents received consultation letters with only 2 questions and only 1 day to reply. She said the letter included no map and no information on the proposals.
16.18 As he had a prejudicial interest as Cabinet Member Councillor Theobald left the Council Chamber while the call-in request was being determined.
49.2 Councillor Theobald detailed the legal and historical background to the issue, noting the supportive stance of the council as a whole to the provision of a site. He noted general support for the revised Travellers Strategy and the improvements that had been carried out to the Horsdean transit site which had been in a poor condition.
49.3 Councillor Theobald noted the additional strength that a permanent site would afford any legal processes and concluded that, in recognition of the extreme sensitivities the issue would be subject to vigorous consultation.
She and Councillor Theobald pledged to be as fully engaged with this process as their workload would allow.
‘To again allay public concerns and the circulation of rumours, and to allow sufficient opportunity for public consideration and democratic preparations, would the Cabinet Member please urgently confirm, to this Meeting, the now intended date for the publication of the completed Report and Recommendations on proposals to extend Communal Bins and to change long existing collection arrangements - early publication being in accordance with the Environment Committee resolution Item 55.12 2, whereby the analysed results of the Consultation will be reported back for consideration alongside any associated recommendations for changes to established collection systems?’ 29.3 The Chairman invited Councillor Theobald to respond.
Councillor Theobald replied as follows:
29.6 Councillor Theobald thanked [name removed] for his question and following a further exchange to clarify some points made above responded that the decisions would be made in an open and accountable way, taking note of the consultation undertaken. Many of the rumours and concerns as detailed above would be dealt with in the report submitted for consideration.
Yours sincerely …’ 33.7 The Chairman invited Councillor Theobald to respond.
39.8 Councillor Theobald accepted Councillor Mitchells’ comment in regard to an increase in domestic burglaries, but noted that on the whole crime was reducing.
39.9 Councillor Theobald noted comments about the dirtiness of pavements in the city centre, but noted the positive impact of communal bins and the move to encourage business premises to wash the pavement areas that they were responsible for. He added that he remained to be convinced that there was a cost effective solution to the issue.
15.2 In response to questions from Councillor Mitchell, Councillor Theobald reported that repairs to the Bandstand would not jeopardise current budget projections.
18.4 In response to questions from Councillor Mitchell about the development of car-free housing, Councillor Theobald commented that each development would be considered individually and that a blanket policy would not be appropriate.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Theobald attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Theobald's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Theobald was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 7 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Theobald declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Jan 2013 | Transport Committee, item 40 | 40(b) Declarations of interest 40.2 Councillor Theobald declared a pecuniary interest in Item 51 related to his ownership of property in the specified area and would leave the Chamber during consideration of the item. | |
| 3 Nov 2011 | Planning, Employment, Economy & Regeneration Cabinet Member Meeting, item 41 | 41(a) Declarations of Interests 41a.1 Councillor C Theobald declared a personal, but non-prejudicial, interest in Item 56, a report of the Strategic Director, Place concerning updated background studies for the Local Development Framework City Wide Plan, as her son was an Associate Director at CBRE who had conducted the retail study. 41(b) Exclusion of Press and Public 41b.1 In accordance with section 100A of the Local Government Act 1972 (“the Act”), the Cabinet Member considered whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting during an item of business on the grounds that it was likely, in view of the business to be transacted or the nature of the proceedings, that if members of the press and public were present during that item, there would be disclosure to them of confidential information (as defined in section 100A(3) of the Act) or exempt information (as defined in section 100I(I) of the Act). 41b.2 RESOLVED - That the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of Item 59 onwards. | |
| 12 Mar 2009 | Cabinet (pre 2012), item 175 | 175 a Declarations of Interests 175a.1 Councillor Theobald declared a personal interest in item 190 as a relative was an employee of a consultancy firm used by the council. |
Where Councillor Theobald sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 4 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2024 | 3 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Housing Management Panel: North Area | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.