Operational Review of Allocations Plan & Request to review the Allocations Policy.
56.3 Amendment to recommendations: Proposed by Councillor Grimshaw and seconded by Councillor Williams.
Every time Brighton and Hove's minutes name Councillor Williams, as the council published it.
56.3 Amendment to recommendations: Proposed by Councillor Grimshaw and seconded by Councillor Williams.
60.5 Councillor Gibson introduced the amendment, which was seconded by Councillor Williams.
Councillor Williams declared they were a members of the Land Trust.
Debate 37.1 Councillor Williams considered as Ward Councillor there were a number of difficulties on the estate and the council needed to act quicker. The Assistant Director Housing Needs & Supply considered that three months was not slow, the rapid response strategy was ongoing and the council has moved as fast as possible.
Councillor Williams introduced the Labour Group amendment.
Debate 39.6 Councillor Williams stated they were not comfortable with the argument and did not support the motion.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 40.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the impact on the lower paid was understood and the council will support those who are struggling.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 41.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the specialist project would use suitable local business were possible the contractors were required to provide local social value.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 42.2 Councillor Williams was informed that rents for the existing tenants would be lower, and the service charges would be higher.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 43.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the council were using an existing framework for the project and the contractors have already gone through the procurement process and will be explored as first option.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 44.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the tenants will be from the council waiting list and be able to access the maximum housing allowance.
45.4 Councillor Williams was informed that the contracts run for 4 years with 3 additional years. The council are able to pull out after 4 years, giving 3 years to find a new contractor. It was noted that a lot of quality checking takes place and works would be reduced if a contractor were not providing good quality.
The chair invited Councillor Williams to introduce the Labour Group amendments.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 26.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the lead officer on the report had left the authority and the council were still dependant on the availability of consultants. The tier one census data was released this year. The HMO (Homes of Multiple Occupancy) licensing scheme is still in place, even though it was intended to be short term lasting 5 years.
26.8 Councillor Williams requested that costs be reported back to the committee.
26.9 Councillor Williams proposed the Labour Group amendments to the recommendations and was seconded by Councillor Fowler.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 27.2 Councillor Williams was informed that evicted residents commonly go to relatives or friends. If residents evicted end up on the street, they receive support from outreach service.
Councillor Williams considered the service was improving slowly but surely.
Councillor Williams seconded the amendment and stated that the considered submitting the report to a future meeting would allow officers more time and noted that pre and post COVID conditions were very different.
Councillor Williams proposed the amended motion and stated that they wanted to stop unlawful discrimination, and this needed to be tackled. The Equality Act of 2010 was against discrimination and Shelter charity had exposed actions by landlords and letting agents. Renters have been asked to present high earning guarantors or six months rent upfront.
Councillor Williams understood Councillor Meadows point and noted that this was a complicated process for renters and signposting to support services was wanted.
9.3 Councillor Williams was informed that the report does not cover everything, and the response will be multi agency.
10.5 Councillor Williams was informed that solar panels are being looked at and there is a programme running this year. Commercial roofs are an issue and systems are being trailed. Pilot schemes have been carried out.
11.5 Councillor Williams commented that some rent arears may be due to Universal Credit taking a long time to process a request and residents of Seaside Homes suffer from the benefits cap.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 12.2 Councillor Williams congratulated the officers on the report.
13.3 Councillor Williams noted that all three political parties were represented on the Housing Supply Board and Councillor Meadows was welcome to the join the meetings.
Answers to Committee Member Questions 14.2 Councillor Williams stated they were aware of the issues surrounding procurement and expressed their thanks for getting the process underway.
(b) Declarations of Interest: Councillor Williams stated they were a member of ACORN and on the board of Seaside Homes.
65.11 Councillor Williams considered that housing rights in the UK were being eroded and noted that the right to housing is not in UK law. The market needs restraining, with a rapid expansion of rentals as in London. The government won’t heed calls, but the Labour group will.
66.3 Councillor Williams considered evidence gathering was good, but they were concerned at the process and ask that the committee Members had oversight.
67.6 Councillor Williams was informed that they will receive a written response regarding the replacement window programme. The most urgent issues are looked into first at this time. The councillor was requested to let the officers know of any particular cases .
68.4 Councillor Williams was informed that the emergency accommodation standards are set in all new contracts and the accommodation is inspected. It was noted that some persons have no recourse to public funds, and there is no homogenous group. The council has different powers available to support these persons in this complex area.
68.8 Councillor Williams noted that the HRB were not a decision making body and were only advisory and they would welcome the minutes at committee.
68.14 Councillor Williams noted the Emergency Accommodation Charter was presented to the committee some time ago and then COVID arrived. The councillor supported the charter.
53.8 Councillor Williams seconded the amendment to the Notice of Motion and stated that it was good to recognise the tragic death and pause and review the situation.
53.12 Councillor Williams stated that the amendment was not about party politics.
54.6 Councillor Williams raised questions relating to mutual exchange programme, empty homes strategy and number of complaints relating to AirBnB’s. The councillor was informed that the AirBnB complaint numbers would be sent later after the meeting, the empty homes strategy was as responsive as possible and supportive with funding where possible. The Head of Tenancy Services informed the councillor that the mutual exchanges were mostly under a year, around 9 months to complete, with often 12 at one time, to be completed within the 42 days statutory deadline.
55.4 Councillor Williams raised a question relating to social rents and was informed that there a number of schemes the maximum use was being gained from each one.
55.8 Councillor Williams raised a question relating to tenant service charges and was informed that the charges were different for each building.
56.3 Councillor Williams raised questions relating to monitoring of contract and consultations. The councillor was informed that all contracts are monitored for performance which starts at the beginning of the procurement process. The contract will contain conditions relating to underperformance and termination.
(1) Councillor Williams 5.2 Councillor Williams asked, what is the administration is providing for those subjected to fuel poverty, which there are many considering the huge hike in fuel prices that we are experiencing, and we know that this is hitting the most vulnerable in our city. I do know that there are some government measures, but what are we doing as a Council is what I'd like to know?
5.4 Councillor Williams asked a supplementary question, I'm aware of all the initiatives that are going on in the city and I applaud all of them. Well, what I'm asking now is this is happening now. We can't wait for the future.
(b) Declarations of Interest: Councillor Williams declared she was a member of ACORN.
This housing committee agrees that a database of rogue landlords where action has been successfully taken should be made available on Brighton & Hove council website in accordance with s 4.5 of Rogue Landlord Enforcement Guidance for Local Authorities Proposer Councillor Gill Williams, Seconder Councillor Theresa Fowler Sources:
https://www.theargus.co.uk/homes/property/news/19582869.almost-half-private-renters-south-east-victim-illegal-acts-landlords/ https://www.nrla.org.uk/news/chronic-failure-to-tackle-rogue-landlords-puts-tenants-at-risk 38.2 Councillor Williams proposed the motion to the committee and asked for a data base of convicted landlords and noted that many are good and valued in the city. The NRLA have urged councils to use powers to stop rogue and criminal landlords and the council needs to send a strong message to landlords.
38.7 Councillor Williams noted that the national data base had been successful and that only prosecuted landlords were on that list. It was hoped that Brighton and Hove City Council would share a link to the national data base.
40.5 Councillor Williams raised a question relating consultations and was informed that ward councillors are being consulted on individual properties and this is ongoing.
41.6 Councillor Williams raised questions relating to selling properties whilst undergoing repair works, costs and lease extensions and was informed that the council has purchased 256 properties, the costs will be modelled to project total sum and the extension of leases is not covered by this report.
Answers to Committee Members Questions 42.2 Councillor Williams raised a question relating to progress and was informed that feedback will be given to the committee and updates were being given to residents via the Home-In magazine along with talking to residents directly. Contact will be improved when the new IT system is installed next year.
Answers to Questions from Committee Members 43.2 Councillor Williams raised concerns regarding social housing rents and was informed by Sam Smith that the rents have not yet been decided and this was being currently being looked into.
Councillor Williams declared she was a member of ACORN and on the board of Seaside Homes.
Councillor Williams thanked the speakers for the deputation and noted they knew of residents who had waited fourteen months for a carpet.
Questions 24.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the council were looking at the Local Government association advice programme.
24.6 Councillor Williams proposed the amendment to the recommendations and stated that the council needs to commit to introducing selective licensing. The Citizens Advice Bureaux (CAB) can help the council with information and resources have been found, the landlords of the city will benefit.
25.4 Councillor Williams was informed that the residents and leaseholders were engaged before COVID-19, however this was not possible during the pandemic. Resident inspectors are continuing to give feedback.
Questions 26.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the process of procurement does not allow those applying to specify whether companies are local. It was noted that the system required would be specialised and local businesses are offered help and support to make a bid.
27.5 Councillor Williams noted the 42% of social housing lets to homeless people and noted the government should stop the right-to-buy scheme.
28.5 Councillor Williams was informed that tenants in arrears are helped with discretionary house payments and given support by other council directorates, and back dated benefits can help. The council look at the whole picture, in the round and help residents to consolidate debts. The ability to move-on when in arrears depends on the situation, there is no general way forward to assist tenants move-on.
(b) Declarations of Interest: Councillor Williams declared she was a member of ACORN.
I would ask Cllr Williams who signed this off to have it retracted. These meals were "distributed to accommodation".
Proposer - Councillor David Gibson Seconder - Councillor Gill Williams 6.2 Councillor Williams introduced the Notice of Motion.
We will therefore ask officers to seek evidence and learn from other local authorities where selective licencing schemes have been introduced and will invite tenants’ 6.6 Councillor Williams introduced the Notice of Motion.
7.3 Councillor Williams was informed that works carried out on properties were overseen by the council and a review is to commence soon so quality can be looked at and standards raised.
Questions 9.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the engagement process in July would include vulnerable people and the engagement process would be on going through out the development of the site. Lettings will be carried out carefully through the management plan and security will be installed via CCTV.
Debate 9.4 Councillor Williams stated they supported the recommendations.
Questions 10.2 Councillor Williams was informed that parking and one unit would be lost to the development if a community space was included in the proposals. The viability of the project would be affected if the number of units were reduced. It was noted that the are several community spaces in the area.
145.5 Councillor Williams noted that a walk around with officers was of benefit for the councillors and the residents and would welcome the development of this practice.
146.3 Councillor Williams extended a vote of gratitude to Emily Ashmore and Jenny Knight for their outstanding work and was sorry to see them leave.
146.7 Councillor Williams proposed and introduced the amendments and stated that they considered the amendments to strengthen the recommendations.
148.4 Councillor Williams was informed that the main support for tenants related to benefits and income issues. Other organisations, such as Money Advice Plus also supported tenant with specialist’s advice. Online support has been given during lockdown on budgeting finances, learning and volunteering to improve wellbeing.
Debate 127.4 Councillor Williams considered that a full report from the Fire Service on the fire at Pankhurst Avenue would be very important, as would be a complete breakdown of financial situation regarding in house services. The councillor considered the post of an early intervention officer was much needed. It was noted that there had been excellent reports of the adult learning at Whitehawk and considered this money well spent.
131.2 Councillor Williams was informed that local businesses are used to carry out works.
133.2 Councillor Williams was informed that the procurement would be balanced with local businesses on the register being contacted.
135.3 Councillor Williams expressed concerns relating to what has been termed ‘Secret SWEP’ and was informed that it had been agreed that more communications were required to inform rough sleepers when Severe Weather Emergency Protocol (SWEP) accommodation was open. It was noted that cold weather units will remain open until March 2021 and 8 out of 10 persons moving forward with resolutions. The last two are resisting help.
135.8 Councillor Williams noted that the Homeless Reduction Board has dealt with many issues, including some raised at committee today and board members will report back to councillors via political groups.
113.5 Councillor Williams was informed that the Council does ensure that accommodation is in place at the other end of reconnections through the Council and St Mongo’s. East and West Sussex are working with Brighton and Hove to ensure the accommodation is suitable. The Council will continue to support those in need after the government set date of 20 September 2020.
113.8 Councillor Williams noted the report was very detailed and a living document, where information could be included later. The Councillor supported the report.
Debate 114.5 Councillor Williams considered they understood the issues as the pandemic was still in place. The Councillor requested that each resident be dealt with on a case-by-case basis and noted the allocations policy was very necessary and was happy for the revue next year.
Debate 115.6 Councillor Williams wanted to note that there was no criticism of the current service provider and the general budget would show savings.
101.8 Councillor Williams was informed that the HRA £41m takes into account government funding, the cost of the proposed properties will not be a future burden on HRA. The homes will be built quickly if agreement is reached. The homes will be 50/50 with Hyde and BHCC.
101.15 Councillor Williams noted that the economy had changed since 2017 and agreed that the Right-to-buy was a concern and agreed that the amendment was good.
99.8 Councillor Williams thanked the officers for the report and agreed that a review of the applications policy would be beneficial.] 99.9 The Chair put the recommendations to the vote and they were agreed unanimously.
100.2 Councillor Williams thanked the officers for the report and considered the information good news and stated their support.
101.7 Councillor Williams expressed concerns relating to evictions and requested that they were not issued. The Councillor was informed that the council were not currently issuing notices of eviction. It was noted that the council sometimes need residents to understand the nature of their arears and serving a notice can be a way of flagging the seriousness of the situation and instigating a conversation with the council.
103.4 Councillor Williams was proud of the work done and considered that the unions should be involved whenever possible and not bypassed.
Councillor Williams stated that officers could not have worked harder. The Head of Housing Needs stated 150 people had been moved and officers were working flat out. Talks are underway with the Ministry of Housing relating to grant funding.
Councillor Williams stated that they knew the presenter of the Brighton Students Union deputation.
We are immensely grateful to Councillor Gill Williams for the support she has offered as well. It has been incredibly valuable, and it deeply appreciated by the thousands of students we represent. Students, who are the very heart of this campaign, have also been directly lobbying providers and landlord through resources we have developed for them to use.
74.2 The Chair, Councillor Williams thanked the presenter - Rami Badrie for the deputation from Brighton Students Union and noted that local landlords have been written to requesting they support student residents. The Councillor applauded those landlords who have already shown helped students. It was noted that the Shadow Minister for Education and the Shadow Minster for Housing have been written to on this matter.
75(d).6 Councillor Williams stated that those affected by domestic abuse will be supported with accommodation if they step forward and make themselves known.
Councillor Wares was informed that the by Councillor Williams that the Administration promised to build at least 800 homes. It was noted by the Property Programme & Business Manager, that office requirements throughout the city would be kept under review and that 6 th Form College at Portslade had a significant amount of time built in to access need.
Ventilation and heating repairs and maintenance will be covered by Mears Group PLC. 45.6 Councillor Gill Williams stated that they had been working closely with those affected by the recent fire in a block of flats and will make sure that action will be taken to ensure the safety of residents who live in the city.
28.5 The Chair, Councillor Gill Williams, wanted to express their support for the Pankhurst Avenue residents affected by the fire. This was reiterated by all the committee Members.
33.8 The Chair, Councillor Gill Williams stated they appreciated comments.
Nominations were received for Councillor Gill Williams from Councillor Peter Atkinson, seconded by Councillor Theresa Fowler.
The Committee agreed to appoint Councillor Gill Williams to the Chair.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Williams attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Williams's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Williams was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 6 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Williams declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Nov 2022 | Housing Committee, item 33 | Councillor Williams declared they were a members of the Land Trust. | |
| 17 Nov 2021 | Housing Committee, item 32 | (b) Declarations of Interest: Councillor Williams declared she was a member of ACORN. | |
| 22 Sep 2021 | Housing Committee, item 17 | Councillor Williams declared she was a member of ACORN and on the board of Seaside Homes. | |
| 23 Jun 2021 | Housing Committee, item 1 | (b) Declarations of Interest: Councillor Williams declared she was a member of ACORN. |
Where Councillor Williams sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2024 | 3 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 3 | 10 Dec 2026 |
| Housing Management Panel: East Area | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 | |
| Audit, Standards & General Purposes Committee | Councillor | Sep 2025 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.