Learning Disabilities Accommodation Services
164.5 In response to Councillor Sykes it clarified that where the buildings were in Council ownership they would likely be designated for different use or disposed of.
Every time Brighton and Hove's minutes name Councillor Sykes, as the council published it.
164.5 In response to Councillor Sykes it clarified that where the buildings were in Council ownership they would likely be designated for different use or disposed of.
166.4 Councillor Sykes stated that the proposals in the report made good practical sense. In response to queries the Chief Executive clarified that the new Executive Director for Neighbourhoods, Communities & Housing would be focused on much closer work with communities in the city as part of how services were delivered.
167.6 In response to Councillor Sykes it was clarified that the newly created Lead Member for Planning Strategy would also be the Deputy Chair of the Economic Development & Culture Committee and therefore no additional special responsibility allowances would be created.
167.7 In response to further queries from Councillor Sykes it was explained that work was being undertaken to consider greater Member oversight of the work around the Prevent agenda, and any Members that required further information could be briefed.
170.3 In response to Councillor Sykes the Assistant Chief Executive explained that the report was seeking permission to begin the process to understand the specification that would eventually go to tender. The buildings in the portfolio would be agreed in the specification. In relation to the viability it was noted that this would also be considered by the Member Procurement Advisory Board.
171.5 Councillor Sykes welcomed the report and asked the sustainability accreditation of the arena be pushed and explored as much as possible to ensure this was an attraction to the venue in an increasingly sustainability conscious world.
144.2 In response to Councillor Sykes it was explained that the authority had made additional borrowing this year as monitoring of the market had allowed the Council to take advantage of very favourable rates; cash flow was mapped out of future to ensure it was maintained.
145.7 It was confirmed for Councillor Sykes that the list at paragraph 3.8 was all of those that would be considered for investment.
146.2 In response to Councillor Sykes it was explained that Officers had considered the available technology to use photovoltaic panels to heat water in schools; however, the current model of payback did not make this feasible.
147.3 In response to queries from Councillor Sykes the following responses were given.
152.3 In response to Councillor Sykes it was explained that this type of modelling could consider a range of rents options as it was not subject to the same regulatory constraints.
121.3 Councillor Sykes highlighted pension fund contributions, raising queries in relation to the accuracy of the figures; Officers agreed that this would be checked and the outcome of this communicated to Members.
121.8 Councillor Sykes also praised Officers for the work they had undertaken on the budget. He went to highlight his disappointment with the level of consultation that had been undertaken, and noted there had been no formal budget Scrutiny meeting. He stated that the cuts approach was ‘chaotic’ and there was impact identified on protected groups; he added that better scrutiny of the medium term financial strategy during the financial year could better help protect services during the budget setting phase.
124.3 In response to Councillor Sykes the Assistant Chief Executive explained that the Brighton Centre operated as a commercial venture; the manager there would be working to keep up the profile during the run in to the Waterfront redevelopment and there was inbuilt flexibility in the charging policy.
124.4 In response to Councillor Sykes the Head of Libraries explained that historically the authority had differed from comparator authorities by not having fees for children and young people, and the proposed fees was being partially used as a means to address the shortfall in income, there was also a reduction each year in income from traditional charges – the alternative solution would be to consider a reduction in spending on new books.
125.2 In response to Councillor Sykes it was explained that the improved position in relation to the council tax outturn for 2015/16 related to lower than forecast Council Tax Reduction ( CTR ) discounts; lower student exemptions awards; higher than forecast property numbers, band increases and reduction in bad debt provision – this had been reflected in the January 2016 Council Tax Base report. The reduction in the number of CTR claimants would be factored into the calculation for next year.
127.2 In response to Councillor Sykes it was explained that recycling and waste removal were high on the agenda for local business, and there was work ongoing with both City Clean and local sustainable waste service providers. Work was being undertaken to deliver savings to the business community and as well as the potential buying power for the authority to start commercial waste collection services.
130.5 In response to Councillor Sykes it was explained that the South Downs National Park were still expressing a strong desire to lease office space at the site, and they were seen as an ‘anchor tenant’.
103.2 Councillor Sykes welcomed the improved position in relation to the budget; however, he felt that the manner in which the base position emerged late in the financial year made it harder to make decisions around issues such the Council Tax Reduction (CTR) Scheme. He was of the view that the Administration could have done more work to look at how an improved base position would help reduce the CTR liability.
104.2 Councillor Sykes asked questions in relation to charity relief of business rates and it was agreed that a full response would be circulated to the Committee after the meeting.
107.3 In response to concerns raised by Councillor Sykes the Head of Law explained that the Orbis model would increase the recruitment power of the body, as practising public sector law had become less attractive in recent years, by providing ‘branded recognition’ and economies of scale. Orbis Public Law would also create increased capacity as it would be able to call on the resources of other authorities and provide the potential to further grow the service.
108.3 Councillor Sykes noted he had no concerns with the procurement process, but felt the principle of housing people in temporary accommodation further away from the city could make Brighton & Hove a less diverse place.
109.3 Councillor Sykes highlighted that the authority had been the first in the country to be receive Silver in the Food for Life Award, and it was important this be maintained. In response to a further question the Executive Director confirmed that both streams of the process could run in parallel: the procurement and the exploration of alternative service delivery models.
80.3 Councillor Sykes commented that the report was good news for the Council’s budget position, but it was clear there was still some risk. He expressed concern that some of the measures were not sustainable in the long term, such as holding positions vacant and delaying maintenance works to buildings.
In response to questions from Councillor Sykes the Executive Director for Adult’s Services explained that the Resource Allocation Budget was set up to work out indicative budget options as budgets and options changed to become more personalised – where someone had an indicative budget and the need could not be met it was necessary to ensure there was budget to do this.
81.2 Councillor Sykes highlighted that the difficult budget position before the Council was the direct result of policy from National Government; however, the situation had been made worse both the Labour and Conservative Groups backing a Council Tax freeze during the previous Green Administration leading to under inflation Council Tax rises;
Councillor Sykes also asked that the Leader do more to challenge Central Government on the difficult financial position for the authority.
81.5 Councillor Mac Cafferty echoed the remarks made by Councillor Sykes, and went on to state that the Administration were front loading cuts without enough consultation; he felt this approach was too much and too soon. In relation to consultation he stated that a proposed Green amendment at the June meeting of the Committee had not been agreed and the Administration were seeking to impose some of the biggest cuts to the budget with reduced consultation. He also expressed concern in relation to changes to the libraries services and subsidised bus services, and argued that many of the poorest families in the city would be hardest hits by budget savings.
82.4 Councillor Sykes stated that the report needed to be considered in the context of the reduction in support from Central Government and the impact would be felt by the poorest families in the city; he highlighted the further complication of the issue when personal allowances were considered. He stated that increasing the minimum liability made it more difficult for families when Council Tax was increased and reduced the flexibility to be more creative with how Council Tax operated.
85.6 Councillor Sykes highlighted that it was important the Council entered the arrangements as an equal partner, and he asked Officers to consider any arrangements using the same 10-1 ratio that the Council operated for salaries of the highest and lowest paid employee.
87.2 In response to Councillor Sykes the Interim Executive Director clarified that an in-house service had been considered; however, the insurance implications as well as the regulation of the industry ruled out this option.
88.2 Councillor Sykes highlighted that this change had arisen form change in Central Government policy.
Councillor Sykes noted his agreement with the comments made by Councillor A. Norman and added that such language could cause unnecessary panic and alarm.
67.6 In response to Councillor Sykes the Acting Executive Director for Environment, Development & Housing confirmed there was pressure on the temporary accommodation budget as this was demand lead; however, some lower cost lease accommodation was coming forward through the procurement exercise undertaken earlier in the year.
68.6 Councillor Sykes noted his support for the report, but requested assurance in relation to the level of risk involved.
69.5 Councillor Sykes seconded the amendment and stated that full consultation needed to include the option of maintaining the existing to make the exercise truly open and honest for the service users.
70.4 Councillor Sykes seconded the amendment, and added that it sought to provide a full and honest consultation; especially given the strength of feeling around changes from service users.
50.3 Councillor Sykes noted his support for this approach, and in response to a query it was confirmed that the proposed scheme would be cost neutral for the Council.
52.4 In response to Councillor Sykes it was clarified by Officers that the ethos behind the programme was to use smaller providers for different elements, as opposed to one large provider; in relation to Orbis it was clarified that the decision on this joint working would be the subject of a decision to a later meeting of the Committee. In response to further queries it was added that work would be undertaken to match customers to their need digitally instead of this going through Officers to shorten as many transaction as possible; there was evidence of this providing savings from the work undertaken by other authorities.
55.4 Councillor Sykes noted the importance of this project and welcomed the cross-party support of the financing scheme.
22.3 In response to Councillor Sykes it was confirmed that the funds in the dedicated schools grant were ring-fenced for priorities relating to schools and school support.
22.4 In response to a further query from Councillor Sykes that it was clarified that there were pressures on budgets in Children’s Services that related to child protection, this was similar to the trend being seen nationally. The Children’s Services Assistant Director provided assurance that the department was working hard towards a recovery plan. The recent Osted inspection had provided assurance that the thresholds were correct to ensure the right level of support was in place.
23.2 In response to Councillor Sykes the Interim Executive Director confirmed that the authorised limit was the maximum level of borrowing that could be outstanding at any one time; this limit was set by statute as part of the Local Government Act 2003. It was also confirmed that there were no proposed changes or cuts to the Treasury Management Team.
24.6 The Chair noted there was an amendment from the Green Group detailed in Addendum Two and invited Councillor Sykes to speak to his amendment.
24.7 Councillor Sykes highlighted that whilst he agreed with aspects of the papers he had concerns in a number of areas. It was his view that this approach would allow for privatisation of services in the organisation. He went on to add that there was little difference in the approach between the administration and the Conservative Group and stated his view that this would likely lead to a Council Tax freeze for the next financial year.
Councillor Sykes explained that this had not been identified, but would have to be considered further if the amendment was carried.
27.13 Councillor Sykes noted that when in administration the Green Group had provided as much information as possible to the December meeting of the Committee to give a good picture of the initial proposals for the next financial year. The amendment would allow enough information to be gathered to see if it was appropriate to propose a Council Tax increase that would trigger a referendum.
25.2 In response to Councillor Sykes it was clarified that there was standardised process to be followed in relation to waivers; the Head of Law added that the new Procurement Board would be able to look at value for money in contracts.
27.4 Councillor Sykes welcomed the report and noted his support for the content; however, he emphasised that much of this work had started under the previous Green administration and highlighted there should be some recognition of the work that had already taken place.
29.2 It was clarified for Councillor Sykes that that closer working with other authorities in the Greater Brighton area remained an option; the focus on Orbis had been at the request of the Committee in March.
30.3 In response to Councillor Sykes it was clarified that an in-house service was an option in the report; however, it remained high cost, legally complex and was an unlikely option for the authority to take forward.
31.2 Councillor Sykes commended the work of the International Team, and noted his personal interest in the flood prevention work at Portslade.
33.2 It was confirmed for Councillor Sykes that the sale price had included the uplifted value of the land.
37.2 In response to concerns raised about policing levels by Councillor Sykes the Chair noted that these types of issues could be considered by the new Neighbourhoods, Communities & Equalities Committee. The Director of Public Health also noted that there had been changes to the recording of crime.
Notices of Motion 7.5 The Notice of Motion as listed in the agenda, in relation to a ‘Temporary Travellers Site’ was proposed by Councillor Mac Cafferty, and seconded by Councillor Sykes.
8.4 Councillor Sykes made remarks in relation to the position of TBM Month 2 in the previous financial year; he cautioned that there should not be an assumption any overspend would rectify itself by the end of the financial year, and added that the increasingly challenging VFM position; the pressure on Adults’ Services and welfare reform would all have an increasing impact.
9.2 In response to Councillor Sykes the Executive Director confirmed that free-schools and academies undertook their own maintenance work.
156.2 Councillor Sykes stated it was vital that works progress to avoid the liabilities becoming too great, much of this would need judgements from Officers, but there were elements of the budget that could be offset by future funding. The Chair noted that the Workstyles programme would reduce the number of operational buildings for the Council.
157.2 Councillor Sykes explained that there were two elements of the report: to make more sense of internal charges and recharges and explore the SEBS option further, it was noted that some central services were currently well streamlined and the authority performed well In CIPFA benchmarking.
106.2 Councillor Sykes thanked the excellent work of the Treasury Management Team, and noted that the list of UK banks had been expanded; he recommended the report to the Committee.
161.2 Councillor Sykes explained he had formally proposed the report and thanked Officers for the work, whilst he agreed with much of the analysis that had been undertaken by the petitioner and the impact of Central Government cuts, he was not of the view there was a concrete proposal that could be taken forward. The Chair noted that any new system of local taxation would need to come forward from Central Government.
138.3 Councillor Sykes stated that he wished to place on record his apologies for an error that had resulted in a press release being issued on the 5 th February which detailed budgetary information that had not been made available to Members of the Committee as was only due for release on the 6 th February. He then stated that he believed it was an excellent report and thanked the officers involved in producing it. He hoped that the proposed increase of 5.9% which would require a referendum to be held would be supported as this provided a level or resources to maintain services and manage the effects of the cuts to local government funding.
140.3 Councillor Sykes welcomed the report and thanked the officers involved in producing the report. He particularly noted the impact the capital programme had on jobs, homes and the income stream within the city for 2015/16.
Councillor Sykes thanked Officers for the report, and also the Executive Directors for their work in enabling the projected overspend to come down from £6m to £2m and then further with the release of unallocated resources. He noted that significant pressures remained in Adult and Children’s services and that the budget proposals had taken these into consideration and he hoped that they would be supported.
116.2 Councillor Shanks moved an amendment, on behalf of the Green Group, which was seconded by Councillor Sykes.
117.2 Councillor Sykes welcomed the improvement in the overall position from that of one month ago, and noted this was due to sensible changes and an increase in the number of homes being built. He went on to add that a significant contribution was from changes to the Council Tax Reduction Scheme, and that this change had been supported by the opposition parties, but opposed by the administration.
118.2 Councillor Sykes proposed an amendment on behalf of the Green Group that would allocate £ 33k to protect discretionary rates for charities and not for profit organisations that would otherwise be disproportionately affected.
119.4 Councillor Sykes noted the dedication and skill of the staff working in this area; in response to a question the Assistant Director explained that the success was due to the management of the programme, and the balance between the delegated team and the partnership work.
123.2 Councillor Sykes noted that the decision not to destroy the building had been made by local referendum after the building’s purchase in 1850; he noted the crucial work undertaken by the Major Projects Team.
6.5 The Chair noted the Notice of Motion as listed in the agenda, and formally proposed the motion himself which was seconded by Councillor by Councillor Sykes. The Committee then debated the motion.
7.2 Councillor Sykes thanked Officers for the work that had gone into the report, and noted that the underspend was good news which showed the change of position since the 2014/15 budget had been agreed. The pressure area in relation to the Code of Connection provision was also noted.
7.8 Councillor Sykes noted the late receipt of £400k from central government, and stated that this was contrary to good financial planning; the Chair agreed with this, but Councillor A. Norman noted that in her experience local authority finance had always been complicated.
8.2 Councillor Sykes referenced the enormity of the challenge for the Council stating that the budget would reduce by £90M in the next 5 years, and last year the value for money programme had delivered £9.4M of savings. The report referenced the need for strength in central services to monitor and push this process, and there would be an expanded group of elected Members involved to oversee it.
12.4 Councillor Sykes agreed with the comments made by Councillor Randall, and referenced the report to note that the work was recognised by the trade unions and workers forums.
Kitcat nominated Councillor West and this was seconded by Councillor Sykes.
(a) Declarations of Substitutes 164.1 Councillor Sykes declared that he was attending the meeting as a substitute for Councillor Littman.
Councillor Sykes said that he too had gained a lot from the panel.
17.6 Councillor Sykes (who was a member of the Panel) told OSC members that the Panel had worked well with a good use of time – 3 meetings as opposed to 7 last year. He praised the input of Community Works and the smooth running of the Panel.
44 A Declarations of Substitute Members 44.1 Councillor Sykes declared that he was substituting for Councillor Phillips. 44B Declarations of Interests 44.2 There were none. 44C Exclusion of the Press and Public 44.3 In accordance with section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, it was considered whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of any items contained in the agenda, having regard to the nature of the business to be transacted and the nature of the proceedings and the likelihood as to whether, if members of the press and public were present, there would be disclosure to them of confidential or exempt information as defined in section 100I (1) of the said Act.
Geraldine Hoban replied that the budget could be transferred or the CCG could keep the budget and pick up the cost of prescribing. 50.5 Councillor Sykes asked if the spend on the Community Care budget was a blip or part of a trend.
[name removed] replied that provision of the building would impact on the cost of the service. 52.6 Councillor Mears stressed that it would be useful if the Property & Design Team provided a list of possible council buildings. 52.7 Councillor Sykes agreed that a report should be brought back to the Committee.
53.2 Councillor Sykes referred to the Brunswick Older Peoples Project and asked when documentation would become available regarding its ongoing performance. The Commissioning Manager explained that there would be a seven day service at St Johns in future. The befriending service would be increased within the same financial envelope.
61.5 Councillor Sykes re-iterated Councillor Mitchell’s concern for adequate provision of resources.
Councillor Sykes referred in particular to the rise in food business premises.
(a) Petitions (i) Opportunity to improve residents’ car and cycle parking, Eaton Road, Hove- Councillor Sykes 63.1 The petitioner did not attend the meeting therefore a response was provided in writing and is set out below. At the request of a member of the Committee, the response was also read out at the meeting.
46.6 Councillor Sykes stated that he welcomed the report which highlighted some of the important services provided by the council. He added that he believed there were problems in authorities where these services were provided by the private sector alone.
Councillor Sykes supplemented that he welcomed the re-introduction of free training for underage sales.
47.2 Councillor Sykes asked if it was likely that the revised scheme would simply lead to people predominately using the car park in the hours that it was free of charge resulting in previous problems re-appearing.
48.7 As ward councillor for the area, Councillor Sykes stated that Brunswick and Adelaide had lost 30 spaces out of 1300 for the trail which equated to approximately 3%. Recycling rates during the trail had increased steadily and that initial concerns about loss of parking and been allayed when the scheme was in practice.
He asked Councillor Sykes if the communal recycling trial had improved street cleanliness in Brunswick & Adelaide.
48.11 Councillor Sykes clarified that it had been significantly popular particularly as Brunswick & Adelaide had very narrow streets.
82.6 Councillor Sykes noted that 75 per cent of the scoring system for the outsourcing of the Audit Commission was based on service cost. He asked if the work undertaken by the firm would be as comprehensive as the current operation.
85.2 Councillor Sykes asked if there would be any change in emphasis in the 2012/13 Audit Plan compared to previous years.
64.3 Councillor Sykes enquired as to how trends were measured if budget demands were volatile.
60a Declarations of Substitutes Councillor Sykes was substituting for Councillor Powell and Councillor MacCafferty for Councillor Littman.
Councillor Ollie Sykes emphasised the importance of both a political and technical lead from the Sustainability Team on climate change issues. He said the European Programme ‘Coastal Communities 2150’ would be relevant to this work.
39.9 Councillor Ollie Sykes, Deputy Chair asked about the validity of the life cycle analysis methodology. Anaerobic Digestion had additional economic and environmental benefits that had not been modelled, he said. It was ‘the way forward’ and more sutainable .
Substitutions were as follows, Cllr Ann Norman for Cllr Vanessa Brown, Cllr Jeane Lepper for Cllr Warren Morgan and Cllr Ollie Sykes for Cllr Matt Follett.
1a Declaration of Substitutes 1.1 Councillor Summers declared that she was substituting for Councillor Sykes.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Sykes attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Sykes's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Sykes was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 8 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Sykes declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 May 2014 | Policy & Resources Committee (pre 2015), item 164 | (a) Declarations of Substitutes 164.1 Councillor Sykes declared that he was attending the meeting as a substitute for Councillor Littman. | |
| 20 Jan 2014 | Adult Care & Health Committee, item 44 | 44 A Declarations of Substitute Members 44.1 Councillor Sykes declared that he was substituting for Councillor Phillips. 44B Declarations of Interests 44.2 There were none. 44C Exclusion of the Press and Public 44.3 In accordance with section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972, it was considered whether the press and public should be excluded from the meeting during the consideration of any items contained in the agenda, having regard to the nature of the business to be transacted and the nature of the proceedings and the likelihood as to whether, if members of the press and public were present, there would be disclosure to them of confidential or exempt information as defined in section 100I (1) of the said Act. |
Where Councillor Sykes sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Place Overview & Scrutiny | Committee Member | Sep 2025 | 3 | 20 Jan 2027 |
| Council | Committee Member | Dec 2025 | 2 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Licensing Panel (Licensing Act 2003 Functions) | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | |
| Licensing Committee (Non Licensing Act 2003 Functions) | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Licensing Committee (Licensing Act 2003 Functions) | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Audit Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2011 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.