Procedural Business
26(a) Declaration of Substitutes 26.1 Cllr Sue Shanks attended as substitute for Cllr Pete West.
Every time Brighton and Hove's minutes name Councillor Shanks, as the council published it.
26(a) Declaration of Substitutes 26.1 Cllr Sue Shanks attended as substitute for Cllr Pete West.
33. 4 Cllr Shanks voted against the resolution, having argued that a direct award to the current provider could have been made instead and would be a better option given the excellent track record of the current provider and the need to manage procurement costs.
15.6 Councillor Shanks queried whether this matter had already been considered by considered and agreed in principle by the Procurement Advisory Board and the implications of any potential delay. 15.7 It was explained that logistical issues could arise if following conversations with providers there was delay and or the need to convene another special meeting of the Sub Committee. The approach suggested aimed to provide an agile means of providing services. In order to make this “work” timings were crucial, a further update report could be brought forward to a future meeting of the Sub Committee.
15.8 Councillor Shanks stated that she did not consider that it was appropriate for the Committee to become involved in who the individual contracts were let to, Members did not have expertise in procurement. Delays could compromise the whole process.
Greater delays would result if something went wrong and contracts that had been let broke down further down the line. 15.11 Councillor Shanks stated that for clarity it would be beneficial for each of the recommendations set out in the report were voted on separately. Therefore recommendations 2.1 and 2.2 were voted on and agreed unanimously.
(a) Declaration of Substitutes: Councillor Barnett substituted for Councillor Mears, Councillor Shanks substituted for Councillor Hugh-Jones, Councillor Grimshaw substituted for Councillor Mcintosh (b) Declarations of Interest: Councillors Williams, Grimshaw and Osborne stated they were members of ACORN.
Cllr Shanks agreed and confirmed there would be discussions with housing and other departments on this, I’ve heard nothing since. In Health Scrutiny Healthwatch said they are ready and willing to investigate. Today's report states there were almost 300 evictions in 20/21- 21/22 for those living in homeless accommodations.
25.4 Councillor Shanks was informed that the residents know about grants via the council website and references from partner organisations.
26.4 Councillor Shanks was informed that the landlords need to adhere to standards and the enforcement team will make site visits to ensure improvements are made. There is online advice for residents regarding letting standards. It was noted that there is a difference between standards and management practices.
7.3 In response to a question from Cllr Shanks on ways to combat child obesity, [name removed] told members that direct support to families is important, as is ensuring that healthy eating options are available at school etc. and encouraging physical activity. However, there is abundant evidence to show that the advertising of fast food has a significant impact on behaviour.
7.10 Cllr Shanks noted that there is a Health & Wellbeing Board meeting scheduled for November 2022, and proposed an amendment to report recommendation (3):
8.9 Cllr Shanks asked when the council would receive Government funding to support the coming changes in care. [name removed] responded that the Government has announced a series of funds which local areas can bid for, although guidance in a number of areas has yet to be released. The council has been allocated £800K over three years to support transition to the new care arrangements, although 75% of this must be passported to providers (details of this are included in the Fair Cost of Care report also on the June 2022 ASCPH agenda).
Councillor Shanks, Chair of the Health & Wellbeing Board gave the following response:
I want to ask Councillor Shanks how this re-commission will involve service users and their carers in a real and meaningful way so their views are at the heart of the recommission?
Reply from Councillor Shanks, Chair of the Health & Wellbeing Board I think that's a very important point. We are recommissioning and it's going to bethe first quarter of 2023. I will go back to check what the process is because I do think user involvement in all our services is really important.
Arrangements for The Meeting 30.1 Before proceeding to the formal business of the meeting, the Deputy Chair, Councillor Shanks explained that the Chair, Councillor Nield had needed to give her apologies for that afternoon’s meeting and that in her absence she would be Chairing the meeting.
30.2 Councillor Shanks went on to explain that in line with current Government guidance the decision making process would rest solely with the Members of the Committee who were present in the Council Chamber and were accompanied by key officers. Other presenting officers would be involved in the meeting via Microsoft Teams. It was noted that this meeting was being webcast and would be available for repeated future viewing.
39.9 The Chair, Councillor Shanks, noted the comments made and stated that prior to approval of budgets in February of each year Members would not necessarily expect to see a budget as each meeting of a Sub Committee. However, she was in agreement that it was appropriate for these matters to be scrutinised and for that information to be provided to the Sub Committee.
I'll ask my colleague, Councillor Shanks if she's willing to have that discussion there. We of course do what we can around young people's mental health and we do run the schools’ wellbeing service. But the CCG commission CAHMS and we don't have oversight of that.
26.5 Councillor Shanks noted that approach recommended had been looked at and would be reviewed in the context of the new Bill referred to, clearly, the local trust had been providing well to date. She was mindful however that all service delivery was just beginning to emerge from Covid and that the level of funding envisaged was the same as that for delivery currently, querying whether that would be sufficient.
27.5 Councillor Shanks stated that the current arrangements provided a good service and that she was therefore happy to support the report recommendations.
In response to questions by Councillor Shanks regarding her understanding that the White Paper would remove the obligation for competitive tendering to take place under certain circumstances it was confirmed that it remained the intention for this to remain an option in relation to local delivery. Reference was made to anticipated changes in procurement law which could impact on future contracts and the Executive Director, Health and Adult Social Care agreed to provide a covering note providing an update on the current position to the next scheduled meeting of the Sub Committee.
28.4 Councillor Shanks considered it disappointing that the council was unable to set its own rates for Housing Benefits. It was explained that discussions on this issue had taken place at national level a few years previously but had not progressed.
1(a) Declaration of Substitutes 1.1 It was noted that Councillor Shanks, the Deputy Chair, would be Chairing the meeting in place of Councillor Nield 1(b) Declarations of Interests 1.2 There were none.
We, the undersigned, welcome the governments of the world decision to follow the science, and call on them to reduce health inequalities by publicly funding research into interventions that use psychical effects, (psi) complementary and alternative medicine (cam) indigenous systems of shamanic medicine, Indian Ayurveda, traditional Chinese medicine, and other drug free interventions that prevent and alleviate suffering, and call for those treatments that are found to be evidence-based to be integrated into public healthcare systems, and funded so that no patients are excluded by inability to pay.” (2 signatures) “This is part of a worldwide movement to shift the materialist paradigm to the holistic one, and the medical model to the bio psych social one, see http://www.aapsglobal.com ” 4.2 The Chair, Councillor Shanks, invited [name removed] to present his petition following which she responded in the following terms:
The Chair, Councillor Shanks concurred in that view.
9.6 The Chair, Councillor Shanks, confirmed that she was aware of the detailed discussions which had taken place and the level of engagement which had occurred.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Shanks attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Shanks's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Shanks was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 8 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Shanks declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Shanks in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Shanks sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Committee | Committee Member | Jan 2026 | 4 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Feb 2024 | 3 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| People Overview & Scrutiny | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.