Pre-decision scrutiny of executive reports
Councillor Marlow proposed that the Executive be recommended to defer consideration of the report until September 2026 to enable further exploration of other options.
Every time Bromley's minutes name Councillor Marlow, as the council published it.
Councillor Marlow proposed that the Executive be recommended to defer consideration of the report until September 2026 to enable further exploration of other options.
Councillor Marlow proposed that recommendation 2.2 be amended as follows:
Councillor Marlow then proposed a vote of thanks to the Portfolio Holder, Councillor Page, for all her hard work and commitment in the role over the last few years.
The Chairman welcomed Councillor Christopher Marlow, who had recently joined the Committee, and thanked Councillor Chris Price, who had left the membership.
The Chairman welcomed Councillor Christopher Marlow to his first Public Protection and Enforcement PDS Committee meeting.
The Portfolio Holder, Councillor Christopher Marlow, made the following statement – Central Library Relocation:
The recommendations as amended above were moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow and seconded by Councillor Colin Smith.
CSD25026 A motion to agree that the Council Tax Support Scheme from 2025/26 increases the Discretionary Hardship Fund to £260k per annum was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Colin Smith and CARRIED.
Report CSD25027 A motion to approve the Capital Strategy for 2025/26 to 2028/29, including an increase of £29.1m in relation to a new scheme and supplementary capital estimates to be added to the Capital Programme as detailed in section 5 of the attached report was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Colin Smith and CARRIED.
Report CSD25028 A motion to (1) Note the Treasury Management performance report for the third quarter of 2024/25 and (2) Agree to adopt the Treasury Management Statement and the Annual Investment Strategy for 2025/26 including: (a) the Prudential Indicators for the period 2025/26 to 2027/28 (Annex 1 of Appendix 4); and (b) the Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) Policy Statement (paragraph 2.5 of Appendix 4) was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Colin Smith and CARRIED.
Report CSD25029 A motion to approve the following: (i) A flat 2% pay increase on all salary points and rates for Council staff (excluding teachers who are covered by a separate statutory pay negotiating process) for 2025/26; (ii) An increase of 2% to the Merited Rewards for 2025/26 bringing the total to £420k for rewarding staff for exceptional performance and (iii) that the Trade Unions’ pay claim for staff be rejected (see para 3.12 to the report and attached Appendices) and to note that, as in the previous years since coming out of the nationally/regionally negotiated frameworks, Bromley staff will receive the 2025/26 pay increase in time for the April pay, was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow and seconded by Councillor Pauline Tunnicliffe.
Report CSD25030 A motion to approve the 2025/26 Pay Policy Statement was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Pauline Tunnicliffe and CARRIED.
The Portfolio Holder for Resources, Commissioning and Contracts Management, Councillor Christopher Marlow, attended the meeting to respond to questions from the Committee.
Councillor Marlow had previously circulated a written update to the Committee outlining activity across the Portfolio. The Portfolio Holder then responded to questions, making the following comments:
Report CSD24131 A motion to approve the following changes to the Capital Programme was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Yvonne Bear and CARRIED .
Report CSD24133 A motion to note the Treasury Management performance for the second quarter of 2024/25 and approve the 2024/25 prudential indicators as set out in Appendix 4 to the report was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Colin Smith and CARRIED.
The motion was seconded by Councillor Marlow, put to the vote and CARRIED.
was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Yvonne Bear and CARRIED .
Report CSD24102 A motion to receive and note the 2024 Annual Report of the Local Pension Board was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Michael Tickner and CARRIED .
The Portfolio Holder for Resources, Commissioning and Contracts Management, Councillor Christopher Marlow, attended the meeting to respond to questions from the Committee.
Councillor Marlow had previously circulated a written update to the Committee outlining activity across the Portfolio. The Portfolio Holder then responded to questions, making the following comments:
The motion was seconded by Councillor Christopher Marlow, put to the vote and CARRIED unanimously.
Report CSD23098 A motion to agree that a sum of £2,000k be set aside as a contribution to the Building Infrastructure earmarked reserve as detailed in paragraph 3.8.2 of the report was moved by Cllr Christopher Marlow, seconded by Cllr Colin Smith and CARRIED .
Report CSD23096 A motion that Emma Downie and Chloe West be appointed as Employer Representatives to the Local Pension Board for four year terms of office commencing on 17 th July 2023 was moved by Cllr Keith Onslow, seconded by Cllr Christopher Marlow and CARRIED .
Councillor Christopher Marlow declared that his employer’s pension fund was invested with Fidelity International.
Report CSD23052 A motion to agree the release of £2m from the Health reserve for the ICB as detailed in paragraph 3.10 of the report to the Executive as moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Colin Smith and CARRIED .
Report CSD23032 A motion to approve the Council Tax Support Scheme 2023/24, increasing the Discretionary Hardship Fund to £225 per annum and noting that from 2023/24 the Scheme will only be revised to incorporate any changes required by legislation and/or as a result of the annual uprating of benefits – public consultation will only be undertaken in future years when a fundamental change to the scheme is proposed - was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by councillor Colin Smith and CARRIED .
A motion to ( i ) approve the new schemes and other changes to the programme identified in the report, (ii) approve the refinancing of the Council’s existing Housing Schemes through long-term borrowing of £49.2m, (iii) approve the use of up to £10m of earmarked revenue reserves to support funding of the Council’s capital programme and (iv) agree that all new and existing Housing Schemes should be funded by long term borrowing, was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Colin Smith and CARRIED .
Report CSD23036 A motion to note the Treasury Management performance report for the third quarter of 2022/23 and agree to adopt the Treasury Management Statement and Annual Investment Strategy for 2023/24 including (i) the Prudential Indicators for the period 2023/24 to 2025/26, (ii) the Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) policy statement and (iii) revised minimum credit ratings for Housing Associations (BBB+) and Corporate Bonds (BBB+) was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Colin Smith and CARRIED .
A motion to approve ( i ) a flat 2% pay increase for all staff (excluding teachers who are covered by a separate statutory pay negotiating process) in response to the unexpected spiralling inflation post the 2022/3 pay award agreed by full Council; the increase would be effective from 1st April 2023; (ii) a flat 5.75% pay increase for all staff (excluding teachers who are covered by a separate statutory pay negotiating process) for 2023/24; (iii) an additional £200k towards Merited Rewards, for 2023/24, bringing the total to £400k for rewarding staff for exceptional performance; (iv) that the Trade Unions’ pay claim for staff be rejected (see paragraph 3.12 of the report and attached appendices) and to note that, as in the previous years since coming out of the nationally/regionally negotiated frameworks, Bromley staff will receive the 2023/24 pay increase in time for the April pay, was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Pauline Tunnicliffe and CARRIED .
A motion to approve the 2023/24 Pay Policy Statement as recommended was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Pauline Tunnicliffe and CARRIED .
Report CSD22133 A motion to note the report and approve the 2022/23 prudential indicators was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Cllr Colin Smith and CARRIED.
Report CSD22136 A motion to approve an increase of £23,970k to the Capital Programme, in particular an increase of £3,000 in relation to the budget for depot improvement and £20,970 for the preferred option for the capital budget for the Civic Centre redevelopment scheme, was moved by Cllr Christopher Marlow, seconded by Cllr Colin Smith and CARRIED .
Report CSD22139 A motion to approve the recommendation to note the report and approve expenditure of £3,000k for the delivery of Operational Estate Strategy workstreams was moved by Cllr Christopher Marlow and seconded by Cllr Colin Smith.
A motion to note the part 2 information in this report was moved by Cllr Christopher Marlow, seconded by Cllr Colin Smith and CARRIED .
A motion to note the part 2 information in the report was moved by Cllr Christopher Marlow, seconded by Cllr Colin Smith and CARRIED .
The motion was seconded by Councillor Christopher Marlow, put to the vote and CARRIED unanimously.
Cllr Marlow (Ward Councillor) read out a brief statement on behalf of himself and the other Ward Councillors—Cllr Charles Joel and Councillor Robert Evans.
Councillor Marlow sent apologies and attended virtually.
It was noted that Councillor Marlow had chaired this group and that conclusions were drawn and recommendations carried forward. It had been determined that Section 106 matters would be discussed by individual PDS committees. The original working group had been wound up approximately 18 months to two years ago.
The following statements were made at the request of Councillors Simon Jeal and Alisa Igoe - (A) Planning for an Economic Downturn Councillor Christopher Marlow, Portfolio Holder for Resources, Commissioning and Contract Management, made a statement in response to a request to explain how the Council would plan for an economic downturn over the next twelve months. He rejected the premise of the request, stating that the greatest risk was higher inflation, with much of the Council’s expenditure indexed to inflation, but its income limited. Sustained high inflation without an increase in income from Government or a higher Council Tax would cause a decline in the Council’s financial strength.
Report CSD22084 A motion to approve the following recommendations from the Executive was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Tony Owen and CARRIED.
was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Tony Owen and CARRIED .
Report CSD22051 A motion to receive and note the Annual Policy Development and Scrutiny Report 2021/22 was moved by Councillor Christopher Marlow, seconded by Councillor Simon Fawthrop and CARRIED.
Councillor Kate Lymer – Portfolio Holder for Children, Education & Families Councillor Diane Smith – Portfolio Holder for Adult Care & Health Councillor Angela Page – Portfolio Holder for Public Protection & Enforcement Councillor Yvonne Bear – Portfolio Holder for Renewal, Recreation & Housing Councillor Christopher Marlow – Portfolio Holder for Resources, Commissioning & Contract Management Councillor Aisha Cuthbert – Portfolio Holder for Sustainability, Green Services & Open spaces Councillor Nicholas Bennett – Portfolio Holder for Transport, Highways & Road Safety RESOLVED that the appointments made by the Leader of the Council, as set out above, be noted.
(A) Ukraine The following motion was moved by Councillor Kira Gabbert and seconded by Councillor Christopher Marlow - “This Council is saddened and appalled by the unprovoked Russian invasion of Ukraine, which has caused horrific devastation, the loss of many innocent lives and an escalating humanitarian crisis with millions of Ukrainians forced to leave their homes.
Councillor Christopher Marlow joined the meeting online.
The Chairman of the Committee, Cllr Christopher Marlow, reported that members had commented that the cost of the system should not be inflated by over-specification. The decision involved a change to the Capital Programme which required Executive approval. RESOLVED that (1) The proposal set out in the report to initiate and complete the procurement of a solar PV installation at the North Block, Civic Centre at an estimated whole life contract value of £119k, using the Council’s s.106 Carbon Offsetting Fund (COF) to finance the project, be approved; system design to meet these criteria is stipulated in the contract specification.
Councillor Marlow, local Ward Councillor, addressed the Committee explaining that, in his view, the Officer’s report provided an excellent assessment of the application, and he supported the Officer recommendation of refusal for 4 key reasons:
As a result of the above, Councillor Marlow encouraged the Committee to support the Officer recommendation and refuse the application.
Her Majesty the Queen – Platinum Jubilee The following motion was moved by Cllr Nicholas Bennett JP and seconded by Cllr Christopher Marlow - “This Council requests that His Worship the Mayor make a loyal address to Her Majesty the Queen as follows: The Mayor and councillors meeting on February 28th 2022 send on behalf of the Council and the people of the London Borough of Bromley their loyal greetings and best wishes to Her Majesty on the historic occasion of Her Majesty's Platinum Jubilee. We thank Your Majesty for your devoted service to the United Kingdom and Commonwealth for seventy years and pray for your good health in the coming years.” The motion was CARRIED . (B) Ade Adetosoye CBE ?
Cllr Marlow reported that the Office for National Statistics (ONS) had recently published a ... view the full minutes text for item 166.
A statement was read out from Cllr Christopher Marlow, Chairman of Executive, Resources and Contracts PDS Committee and ward member for Farnborough and Crofton. The statement is attached to these minutes as Appendix A.
The Chairman of the Committee, Councillor Christopher Marlow, thanked members of the public and Flightpath Watch for their submissions and stated his view that BHAL had not demonstrated full compliance with the NAP. He recognised that some Councillors had emphasised the importance of the thriving airport to the borough’s economy, but he felt that there was an issue of trust, that many people felt that the Airport had not kept to its commitments. He had therefore proposed amendments to the recommendations to require the Airport to provide further information by 30 th June 2022.
(A) Boundary Charge To be moved by Cllr Kieran Terry and seconded by Cllr Christopher Marlow.
Cllr Christopher Marlow joined the meeting online.
The Chairman of the PDS Committee, Cllr Christopher Marlow, pointed out to the Executive that Bromley’s scheme was already more generous than some in London, and in the consultation responses there was not a clear majority in favour of making it more generous.
The Ward Member for the Crofton Road Cycle Scheme (Cllr Marlow) stated that the scheme had taken 10 months to complete which was longer than expected and had resulted in significant disruption to residents over an extended time frame. He was hoping that guarantees could be made that this sort of thing would not happen again and asked if the Riney representatives wanted to make any comments to the public who were in the public gallery, many of whom were affected residents.
This scheme was a matter of significant public interest and it was noted that Ward Councillor Christopher Marlow would be addressing the Committee on this matter.
Councillor Marlow (Ward Member) thanked the Chairman for the opportunity to respond as the only Ward Councillor on the Committee.
Cllr Marlow stated that due to the demographics of the Farnborough and Crofton Ward, the Ward Councillors were of the view that cycling would never be significant in this Ward and resultantly the pedestrian and cycling route project did not represent good value for money. Although it was the case that funding from this project did not come directly from Bromley taxpayers, it was still the case that all Councillors had a duty to safeguard the public purse.
Cllr Marlow pointed out that the scheme had been supported by the PDS Committee and authorised by the Portfolio Holder without the support of Ward Councillors.
Cllr Marlow paid tribute to the hard work of the Crofton Residents’ Association (CRA) which had resulted in positive changes to the scheme being made. This included the alteration of the stretch of road from Crofton Lane to Locksbottom was altered which meant that as well as providing cycling infrastructure, a renovated foot path was also installed. Another significant positive change was the provision of additional zebra crossings.
Cllr Marlow commented on the consultation and construction process. There had been a two stage consultation process in 2017 and 2019. He said that the second consultation process that had taken place in 2019 could have been made more inclusive.
Cllr Marlow stated that the Rain Gardens that were due to incorporate much of the scheme’s vegetation had been left empty for months and that Crofton Road was now significantly narrower as a result of the scheme. He said that if a bus was parked by York Rise, it was now very difficult for other vehicles to pass safely. This was exacerbated when a driver changeover was taking place—this was now being looked into by TfL.
The following motions had been submitted for discussion at this meeting - (A) Boundary Charge To be moved by Cllr Kieran Terry and seconded by Cllr Christopher Marlow.
The Chairman of the Executive, Resources and Contracts PDS Committee, Councillor Christopher Marlow, stated that his Committee would be considering a report on Covid costs and expenditure at their meeting in October.
Cllr Christopher Marlow confirmed that he agreed with his ward colleague.
The report had been scrutinised by the Executive, Resources and Contracts PDS Committee on 25 th May 2021 and the Chairman, Councillor Christopher Marlow, provided a summary of the Committee’s debate.
Councillor Marlow began by commenting that there had been no consultation with ward members in the southern part of the borough whose residents were disproportionately affected by the airport. He had written to members in eight wards and members from six wards had responded to him indicating considerable local interest. He recognised that decisions about the airport also needed to be made in the interests of the whole borough, but he requested that in future the ward members in Bromley Common and Keston, Petts Wood and Knoll, Farnborough and Crofton, Chelsfield and Pratts Bottom, Darwin and Biggin Hill wards should be consulted on proposals relating to the Airport with a noise impact; the Leader stated that he had already agreed that this should happen.
Councillor Marlow summarised the issues considered by the PDS Committee, and set out the main areas of concern. The first issue was trust and the Council’s overall relationship with the airport – it was considered that the application was a breach of previous commitments and a “red line” for most members; it was also contrary to the Court of Appeal judgement in 2002. There was a feeling that the Airport was trying to achieve its aims by a salami-slicing approach.
Report CSD21036 A motion to receive the Annual Scrutiny Report for 2020/21 was moved by Councillor Simon Fawthrop, seconded by Councillor Christopher Marlow and CARRIED.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Marlow attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Marlow's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Marlow was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 5 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Marlow declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24 May 2023 | Pensions Committee, item 2 | Councillor Christopher Marlow declared that his employer’s pension fund was invested with Fidelity International. |
Where Councillor Marlow sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Dec 2022 | 4 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Executive, Resources and Contracts Policy Development and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | 23 Nov 2026 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.