Outside body appointments
As Cllr Kathy Bance was already the BTTA chairperson elect she did not need to serve as a Council representative. The Chairman offered to circulate a request for another Member to fill the fourth place.
Every time Bromley's minutes name Councillor Bance, as the council published it.
As Cllr Kathy Bance was already the BTTA chairperson elect she did not need to serve as a Council representative. The Chairman offered to circulate a request for another Member to fill the fourth place.
It was also moved by Councillor Kathy Bance and seconded by Councillor Ruth McGregor that Councillor Simon Jeal be appointed Mayor of the Borough.
Committee member, Councillor Kathy Bance, expressed her thanks to the Chairman for his excellent Chairmanship and service, and to Officers on the committee for their hard work in keeping Bromley safe.
(A) Violence Against Women and Girls The following motion was proposed by Councillor Kathy Bance and seconded by Councillor Alisa Igoe:
2 Councillors 1 Cllr Mark Brock (CON) 2 Cllr Peter Dean (CON) 3 Cllr Simon Fawthrop (CON) 4 Cllr Charles Joel (CON) 5 Cllr Keith Onslow (CON) 6 Cllr Will Rowlands (CON) 7 Cllr Chris Price (LAB) 8 Cllr Ryan Thomson (LAB) 9 Cllr Will Connolly (LDEM) 10 Cllr Sophie Dunbar (BH IND) (iii) PLANS SUB-COMMITTEE NO. 3 Councillors 1 Cllr Jonathan Andrews (CON) 2 Cllr Dr Sunil Gupta (CON) 3 Cllr Christine Harris (CON) 4 Cllr Alexa Michael (CON) 5 Cllr Tony Owen (CON) 6 Cllr Alisa Igoe (LAB) 7 Cllr Julie Ireland (LDEM) 8 Cllr Mark Smith (CHIS) 9 Cllr Shaun Slator (IND) (iv) PLANS SUB-COMMITTEE NO. 4 Councillors 1 Cllr Felicity Bainbridge (CON) 2 Cllr Peter Dean (CON) 3 Cllr Simon Fawthrop (CON) 4 Cllr Charles Joel (CON) 5 Cllr Keith Onslow (CON) 6 Cllr Will Rowlands (CON) 7 Cllr Kevin Kennedy-Brooks (LAB) 8 Cllr Kathy Bance (LAB) 9 Cllr Sam Webber (LDEM)
The following amendments to the schedule were made – (i) Councillors Dunbar and Price to be added to Plans 2 (ii) Councillor Bance to be added to Plans 4 (iii) Chairman and Vice-Chairman of Standards Committee to be appointed at the first meeting.
Some members suggested that the Council should commit to paying at least the London Living Wage for all its staff, and Cllr Kathy Bance requested further information about the roles that attracted these lowest salaries. Officers confirmed that the Council did comply with the statutory National Minimum Wage and contended that it was important not to undermine pay differentials and the job evaluation scheme by distorting the lowest grades. The Council did face recruitment and retention challenges, but these were for professionals such as social workers, engineers and planners, not lower paid staff.
A proposal to increase the basic allowance by 4.5%, increase the allowances for the Chairmen of the Audit and Risk Management and Pensions Committees to match those for PDS Committee Chairmen, remove the allowances for Executive Assistants and retain all other allowances at the current level, transferring the saving of £61k to the Council’s Welfare fund, was moved by Cllr Simon Jeal and seconded by Cllr Kathy Bance, but not supported.
(B) Housing Associations The following motion was moved by Cllr Tony McPartlan and seconded by Cllr Kathy Bance - “This Council recognises the important work Bromley's ... view the full minutes text for item 57.
Two oral questions had been received from a member of the public and one had been carried over from Cllr Kathy Bance. The questioners were not present on the night and so the questions were dealt with as written responses which will be appended to the minutes.
The Chairman moved that the application be refused and this was seconded by Cllr Bance. Members, having considered the report, objections and representations RESOLVED that the application be REFUSED for the following reasons:
Councillor Kennedy-Brooks and Ward Councillor Kathy Bance moved that the application be Deferred.
This had been motioned earlier by Councillor Bance. A Member wondered why an application of this nature could come to Committee without a site visit.
It was noted that Cllr Kathy Bance had previously highlighted issues with the Penge CID.
[name removed] had since spoken directly with Cllr Bance concerning this matter.
The Task and Finish Group also consisted of Cllr Kathy Bance, Cllr Mike Botting, Sharon Baldwin and the Assistant Director for Public Protection and Safety. The aim of the Group was to re-define the terms of reference for scrutiny of the Safer Bromley Partnership Board by the PP&E PDS Committee. The Group also looked at the type of data that should be provided by the police.
Cllr Owen and Cllr Bance thought that a deferral would be the best option.
Councillor Bance noted that it had been decided not to issue CPNs to homeless people who were begging, which in genuine cases appeared to be the right approach. However, there were incidences in Bromley High Street where people were not genuinely homeless and they were begging aggressively and generally causing a nuisance of themselves. She asked why this was not being picked up and dealt with; she asked that the matter be given higher priority in ... view the full minutes text for item 20.
Councillor Kathy Bance agreed with Councillor Brooks and moved refusal.
Councillor Kathy Bance seconded refusal.
A motion to refuse the application on planning grounds was put forward by Councillor Bance which was seconded by Councillor Michael.
Councillor Bance supported the refusal of the application, noting that the tree bordered a conservation area, and provided relief to local residents from noise and pollution.
Councillor Bance moved that the application be refused, and this was seconded by Councillor Tony Owen.
Councillor Bance agreed with the view of Councillor Harris.
Councillor Kathy Bance attended as alternate.
Councillor Kathy Bance declared that she had grandchildren who attended schools in the Borough.
Councillor Kathy Bance reported that the Ward Members for Clock House Ward had no objection to the application.
Councillor Kathy Bance declared that she had grandchildren in 6 Bromley Schools.
Councillor Kathy Bance asked whether the arrears were related to housing benefit payments.
Cllr Evans explained that the original idea for a mental health champion had been raised by Cllr Kathy Bance at Full Council. He noted that other boroughs had mental health champions.
He suggested that Cllr Kathy Bance be considered for the role of MHC, as this was an area in which she had a keen interest.
Cllr Evans proposed that Cllr Bance be co-opted as a member of the new working group.
Comments from Ward Member for Penge and Cator , Councillor Kathy Bance, in support of Option A were ... view the full minutes text for item 55.
(OUTLINE APPLICATION with all matters reserved.) Ward Member, Councillor Bance , acknowledged that this application ... view the full minutes text for item 25.2 Bromley Common and Keston
Councillor Bance considered that some brownfield sites in Bromley could be developed and the Council’s response did nothing to meet NPPF in regard to attaining housing targets.
· Councillor Kathy Bance to replace Councillor Peter Fookes on General Purposes and Licensing Committee.
Councillor Bance ... view the full minutes text for item 27.13 Bromley Common and Keston Conservation Area
The Chairman welcomed Councillor Bance to the Committee.
(2) Councillor Kathy Bance replaces Councillor Peter Fookes as a member of the Licensing Sub-Committee, subject to Councillor Bance being appointed to General Purposes and Licensing Committee by Council on 23 rd February 2015.
Councillor Bance shared [name removed] concerns and pointed out that since the closure of Anerley Library had been approved, no discussions had taken place with regard to the introduction of a much needed community hub in Anerley.
Councillor Bance was informed that due to the current condition of Anerley Town Hall, it was necessary for a structural survey to be carried out. Discussions concerning a viable offer were currently being held and the project was continuing.
Councillor Bance stated that during the forthcoming Municipal Year, Members should make a commitment to ensure that all World War I Memorials and their surrounding areas be cleaned and tidied. The Assistant Director for Leisure and Culture agreed that assessments for the work would be carried out on each Memorial and an updating report showing the results of the assessments would be submitted to the next meeting of the PDS Committee.
Referring to the environmental monitoring visits on page 119, Councillor Bance reported that she had constantly attempted to get environmental issues resolved without success. In this respect, the RAG status should be amber and she considered the plan should be written with more openness.
Councillor Bance requested an update on the former Anerley Town Hall. Members were informed that this was a Council-owned building which was beginning to fall away at the front. Costs quoted in tenders received for carrying out works to the building had all been substantially higher than expected.
Councillor Fookes advised that he would be a member of Plans Sub-Committees Nos 1 & 3 and Councillor Bance would be on Nos 2 & 4.
Councillor Bance was assured that all areas of Penge Town Centre would be included in the Initiative.
Councillor Bance reported that Penge was very well suited for a mix of social housing however, as a Member of Plans Sub-Committee No. 4, she was aware that developers avoided the requirement to provide affordable housing by ensuring the development did not exceed the legal threshold.
Councillor Bance was of the view that the lack of affordable housing was, in part, due to the mindset and planning of developers. She welcomed the establishment of a Working Group.
In response to a statement from Councillor Bance, the Deputy Chief Planner agreed to provide Members with information on the outcome of on-going enforcement action.
Councillor Kathy Bance enquired whether there was an increased use of real nappies. In response, the Environment Development Manager indicated that Bromley was good on this and their use was good for parents financially as well as for the environment.
3) PCSOs The following Motion was proposed by Councillor Katherine Bance and seconded by Councillor Peter Fookes:- “This Council notes the loss of 60 Police Community Support Officers in the Borough and calls on the Mayor of London to urgently restore the number of PCSOs patrolling Bromley’s streets to 160.” An amended Motion, moved by Councillor Tim Stevens and seconded by Councillor Stephen Carr, as set out below was proposed:- “This Council notes the loss of 59 Police Community Support Officers in the Borough who have gone to begin training to become full time Police Officers, and welcomes all party support calling on the Mayor and Commissioner to make sure Bromley goes back up to its full allocation of 141 Police Community Support Officers as quickly as possible.” Councillor Bance confirmed her acceptance of the amendment.
Members supported the recommendations to the Portfolio Holder and Councillor Kathy Bance offered thanks for the matter being taken forward.
Concerning the latest consultation results as tabled and in view of only one response received from Newlands Park which was opposed to the scheme with Pay and Display bays outside the shops, Councillor Bance expressed a wish for further consultation, indicating her support for some quick turnaround parking at the location.
Councillor Bance also felt that there was a lot of restricted parking in Lyndon Grove in view of the number of houses. The Portfolio Holder was supportive of working with local ward Members to achieve the maximum amount of parking spaces.
[name removed] confirmed to Councillor Kathy Bance that the outreach in Penge would possibly take place this year.
Councillor Fortune asked if [name removed] could email/write to both he, as a Ward Councillor for Cray Valley East, and Councillor Bance, as a Ward Councillor for Penge and Cator about the work of the organisations referred to.
ii) NHS The following Motion was proposed by Councillor Peter Fookes and seconded by Councillor Kathy Bance:- “This Council calls on the Coalition Government to abandon it's proposed reforms to the NHS and to ensure that under the next proposals that in the interests of patients, costs and accountability that local councils have a major role in the future of health care delivery.” A Motion was moved by Councillor Arthur and seconded by Councillor Carr that the above Motion on the NHS should more appropriately be referred to the next meeting of the Adult and Community Services PDS Committee for consideration in the light of the latest developments.
Councillor Kathy Bance sought clarification that no decision had been taken to cut the parks service and the Head of Parks and Greenspace explained that budget heads were known for the service and that formal consultation would begin shortly.
Referring to casualty reduction, Councillor Bance enquired how schemes were selected and a brief explanation was provided by the Head of Traffic and Road Safety. The Portfolio Holder also referred to support that could be provided by Safer Neighbourhood Teams and the Chairman asked that the Police be invited ... view the full minutes text for item 94d
Councillor Kathy Bance as a ward Councillor for the area expressed her support for the recommendations, noting however that a number of residents at Sycamore House had not supported the proposal. RESOLVED that the Portfolio Holder be recommended to:
Councillor Bance declared a prejudicial interest in item 12 – Motion: Community Infrastructure Levy and left the room during consideration and discussion of this matter.
(Councillor Bance left the Council Chamber during consideration of this item.)
Councillor Kathy Bance asked about the scope for making further savings such as leaving road pot holes unrepaired. The Director indicated that without regular maintenance the highways asset would further deteriorate leaving a major repair cost for the future.
Responding to a further question from Councillor Bance on waste costs for schools, the Director explained that schools would be charged total costs i.e. collection and disposal costs (schools were already charged for collection costs). The Portfolio Holder also explained that a number of secondary schools were likely to become academies and would then be expected to have responsibility for their own waste collection and disposal arrangements.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bance attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Bance's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Bance was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 7 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Bance declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Jul 2018 | Children, Education and Families Policy Development and Scrutiny Committee, item 3 | Councillor Kathy Bance declared that she had grandchildren who attended schools in the Borough. | |
| 25 May 2016 | Children, Education and Families Policy Development and Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Councillor Kathy Bance declared that she had grandchildren in 6 Bromley Schools. | |
| 28 Feb 2011 | Council, item 44 | Councillor Bance declared a prejudicial interest in item 12 – Motion: Community Infrastructure Levy and left the room during consideration and discussion of this matter. | Left the room |
Where Councillor Bance sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Dec 2022 | 4 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| General Purposes and Licensing Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | |
| Licensing Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 | |
| Environment and Community Services Policy Development and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.