Declarations of Interest
Councillor C Boles declared an interest in planning application 73392, Rose & Crown Inn, 36 Manchester Old Road, Bury, BL9 0TR as he knew an objector to the application.
Every time Bury's minutes name Councillor Boles, as the council published it.
Councillor C Boles declared an interest in planning application 73392, Rose & Crown Inn, 36 Manchester Old Road, Bury, BL9 0TR as he knew an objector to the application.
Councillor Boles sought clarification regarding the role of Connexions and the support available for students at risk of becoming NEET.
Councillor Boles sought clarification regarding transition data for children educated within alternative provision settings.
Councillor Boles also asked for an update on the tracking and completion of annual Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP) reviews.
Cllr Boles welcomed the positive progress reported but questioned how the proposed write-off of the High Needs Block deficit would contribute to improving outcomes for children and young people.
Councillor Boles asked what impact the change had had locally. Ben Dunne reported that NEET figures had improved and that the Council had not experienced an increase in NEET young people, unlike some other Greater Manchester authorities. Jeanette Richards added that the development of enhanced post?16 provision had also strengthened outcomes and mitigated potential negative impacts.
Councillor Boles then asked for assurance that the school ... view the full minutes text for item 101.
Councillor Boles asked what lessons had been learned so far and what advice could be offered to other areas. In response, Collette Radcliffe stressed the importance of knowing and understanding the local community.
Councillor Boles asked for an update on the development of B Bot AI. Jeanette Richards reported that three local offers will be hosted through B Bot AI, designed to support diverse community needs. She confirmed that SEND information has been prioritised initially and that the system is expected to go live in April, after which additional local offers will be added.
Councillor Boles concluded by stating he felt reassured by the update and welcomed the positive performance reflected in the winter preparedness report.
Cllr Boles asked how Healthwatch manages public expectations when passing on feedback, querying whether additional context is provided where certain issues fall outside Healthwatch’s remit. Andrew advised he could not give a definitive answer at present but would take this away and provide a more detailed response.
A further question from Cllr Boles addressed inconsistent access to GP services and whether poor administration across practices in Bury contributed to this. Jon Hobday explained that triangulation of qualitative data with wider system information helps determine whether issues are isolated or reflect a broader trend. Will Blandamer added that Healthwatch had supported a focus group on GP administration, and the committee requested further detail on sample size and triangulation.
Cllr Boles asked who was responsible for producing the statutory action plan due in October.
Cllr Boles asked who else should be included in the process who is not yet involved. Sian stated that people with lived experience need a stronger voice in both shaping and continuously influencing the service, and consideration is needed as to how this representation can be strengthened strategically.
Cllr Boles sought reassurance about the Fast Food SPD and shared concerns about gambling harms. A request was made for more data, particularly exploring links between gambling and homelessness and whether this should inform future commissioning. Jon confirmed that Bury does not currently commission a gambling-specific service due to limited funding, although GMCA plays a coordination role.
More funding has been received to do more innovative work including earlier education with the younger generation Councillor Boles queried how can we be assured that those voices of BAME women who are 3 times more likely to die in childbirth, and Asian women who are twice as likely to die in childbirth, are included in service redesign?
Councillor Boles also queried the responsibility of hospitals as well?
Councillor Boles queried assurance for young people transitioning to adult services.
Councillor Boles asked how attendance and engagement at the Strengthening Outcomes Board would be maintained to ensure it remains effective.
Cllr Boles raised issues around primary care capacity, and Stuart acknowledged the pressures on general practice but noted the opportunities created by supporting people to remain well at home.
During discussion, Councillor Boles queried potential delays in the rollout of Family Hubs and whether any work had been undertaken on asset management and reconfiguration. Will Blandamer confirmed that work is progressing with children’s services and that an estates framework is being developed to support delivery.
Councillor Boles asked what learning was taken from complaints and whether this would improve outcomes.
Councillor C Boles declared a prejudicial interest in relation to the planning applications on the agenda, 70213, Conversion of existing public house to 5 no.
Councillor Boles left the meeting during deliberations on these applications.
Councillor Boles asked about support for carers managing increasingly complex cases. Adrian Crook explained that the new supervision framework allows staff to access support flexibly and efficiently.
Councillor Boles raised concerns regarding the level of assurance that NHS partners would provide in supporting the improvement plan. In response, Will Blandamer confirmed that he would continue to work closely with NHS colleagues to ensure robust support for looked-after children and broader SEND services.
Councillor McBriar and Councillor Boles confirmed their interest, and it was agreed that meetings would begin at 6:00pm.
Councillor Boles asked about the safeguarding assurances linked to the attendance pledge. Janet responded that regular stakeholder meetings are now well attended, ... view the full minutes text for item 64.
Councillor Boles raised concerns about whether Project Safety Valve had helped local authorities regain financial control over SEND. Robert Arrowsmith responded that while there has been no national improvement, locally the PSV programme has supported investment in provision and helped shift some support into mainstream schools. However, the rising number of EHCPs remains the key driver of the deficit.
Councillor Boles pressed further, asking whether it was feasible to regain financial control. Robert Arrowsmith acknowledged that it would be a long and slow process, and that rapid change is unlikely due to the complexity of the system. He noted that the upcoming changes in the autumn could bring about systemic reform.
Councillor Boles suggested that members review the LGA report, which includes a proposal for writing off high needs deficits. He offered to circulate this to members.
During the discussion, Councillor Boles asked whether there were any partners with whom relationships could be improved. Will responded that while local relationships are strong, there is room for improvement with out-of-borough partners, such as Manchester Foundation Trust and Bolton. He also noted that the first 1,000 days of a child’s life remain an area for development, despite generally strong relationships with GPs, VCFA, and the hospice.
Councillor Boles raised concerns about the future of safeguarding if responsibilities were moved away from the ICB. Will acknowledged these concerns and emphasised the importance of safeguarding roles, noting that NHS Greater Manchester will retain statutory safeguarding responsibilities for both adults and children. He explained that the question remains whether safeguarding is best delivered centrally or locally.
During the discussion, Councillor Boles raised a question regarding the reduction in overdue reviews, noting a 39% improvement and asking whether there was a plan to reach zero. Adrian Crook responded that while progress was commendable, achieving zero was not realistic due to the scale and complexity of adult social care, which involves 71 statutory functions.
pharmacy, dentistry, and primary care Elective care and winter preparedness Healthwatch involvement in access-related work Contributions from Adrian Crook on adult social care Joint committee work across children’s and adults’ services (suggested by Cllr Boles) Communications support (suggested by Cllr Frith) Public service reform and expanded cabinet roles under the mayoral model
It was moved by Councillor Vernon and seconded by Councillor FitzGerald, supported by Councillor Boles and it was agreed, that Council:
There was no substitute representative for Councillor Boles.
Councillor Boles inquired about the challenges in the next three months. Jo Aldham responded that the main challenge is engaging with residents and ensuring they are aware of the campaign. Patients and family members need to be informed and encouraged to participate.
Councillor Boles focused on measuring impacts and challenges, questioning how to scrutinize effectively and ensure the voice and lived experience of children are captured. An action was noted to gather feedback from children on the impact of SEND items directly.
Councillor Boles discussed creative solutions to address the problems faced by children, highlighting the importance of feeling safe and supported.
Councillor Boles inquired about the CAHMS response and action plan. Will Blandamer discussed the CAHMS platforms and executive plan for the ICB, expressing confidence in the report's outcome.
Looking ahead, Councillor Boles suggested focusing on the CAHMS within the locality plan and prioritizing the SEND partnership in Bury.
Councillor Boles asked about the positive outcomes of increased social work staff recruitment.
Councillor Boles questioned the effectiveness of community engagement and the support for youth services. The response noted that the partnership works with youth services to engage young people and support community initiatives. Funding opportunities are available, and efforts are made to ensure that community groups are aware of and can access these funds.
Councillor Boles inquired about the impact of EHCPs on educational outcomes. Wendy Young explained that EHCPs are crucial for accurately reflecting the special educational needs of children and ensuring they receive appropriate support.
Councillor Boles asked whether the council sees schools leaving the local authority to join a trust as a negative reflection. The response highlighted that the decision to convert is ultimately made by the governing body, and the council's role is to present the facts and support schools in making informed decisions.
Councillor Boles asked about the council’s actions on Healthwatch’s recommendations, specifically regarding setting up helplines for prescription-related queries.
Councillor Boles inquired about harmonizing the IVF offer across the Greater Manchester Integrated Care Partnership. [name removed] explained that while the offer is consistent across the 10 Greater Manchester localities according to NICE guidelines, the number of cycles varies.
A question from Councillor Boles around the SEND inspection identifying a need for training was discussed and a response was given that a strategic workforce strategy was being developed to assist with SEND. Integrated workforce is working across both adult and children’s services to work out if a similar workforce integrated strategy could be developed across services.
- Not In School national campaign Councillor Boles opened up for question from members the following points were raised.
Councillor Boles reminded all members that the council provides a full training course around the virtual school, and advised members that the resources are there if support is required around this.
· Councillor Boles referred to the current campaign being promoted reminding patients to bring their own medicine when being admitted into hospital and asked if information around this could be shared with elected members.
Councillor Boles made a declaration of interest in all matters under consideration due to his employment with an educational Alternative Provider in a neighbouring Borough.
It was moved by Councillor Vernon and seconded by Councillor FitzGerald, supported by Councillor Boles and it was agreed:
Councillor Boles raised a matter highlighted in the SEND Task and Finish Group regarding the cost-benefit analysis of lowering the age threshold from five to allow children to start school in the September with their peers.
Councillor Boles ended the meeting by taking the opportunity to thank members of the Committee for their attendance, involvement and support to the Committee for the municipal year.
Councillor L Ryder acted as a substitute representative for Councillor Boles.
The Chair reported that a matter arising would involve the committee escalating the query made by Councillor Boles about homosexual women having to pay for IVF cycles when NHS policy was to all be treated the same.
Councillor Boles concluded that this is a positive approach but the concern is seeing the action.
Councillor Boles advised the consultation with Children and Young People is welcomed and asked for thoughts on expanding further to primary school children. In response members were informed Healthwatch would be keen to engage with schools to gather information however some vulnerable children feel cautious is certain settings and safeguarding would need to be taken into account. ... view the full minutes text for item HSC.7
Councillor Boles questioned what scrutiny of the Greater Manchester Integrated Care Partnership to look like going forward. In response Warren Heppolette , Chief Officer for Strategy & Innovation for NHS Greater Manchester advised focus should be on bringing the system together and how integration is working and locating a set of measures relevant to residents from Bury to improve outcomes. Adrian Crook, Director of Community Commissioning advised there is a range of measures set by the integrated care partnership that relate to the missions with the overarching one being improving population health (20+5).
Councillor C Boles declared an interest in planning application 68055, Land at Springside Road, Bury . H e had family friends that lived in the same area. He had not commented on the application and would remain in the meeting during deliberation of this application.
Councillor Boles, Chair of the Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee provided an update on the Foster Carers recommendation which went to Cabinet on 15 th March 2023.
Councillor Hayes asked a question about communications on behalf of Councillor Boles who had needed to leave the meeting. Will Blandamer reported that engagement was conducted with the youth council and he was not sure of communication campaigns involving Instagram which had been suggested and would look into any clinical risk with the use of such channels.
Councillor Boles opened to questions from members.
Councillor Boles questioned the timescales and progress of improvement.
Councillor Boles questioned about the reports reference to commissioning a graphic designer. Jeanette Richards, Executive Director Children and Young People advised that £10,000 has been awarded from Greater Manchester for our publicity campaign and this will be funded from that pot of money.
Councillor Boles questioned what working closely with schools in practice. In response Isobel Booler, Director of Education and Skills advised it depends on the school.
As it was the last meeting of the municipal year Councillor Smith firstly wanted to place on record thanks to Councillor Boles as Chair of the Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee.
In addition Councillor Boles, Chair of the Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee wished to note that the Committee is powerful and this year we have put children and their outcomes at the forefront of questions.
· Cllr Boles questioned about the increase in Education Health and Care Plans and stated we have more people than ever before with them, he asked if this a concern for future overspend and what reassurances do we have that these monies provided to schools are spent effectively.
Councillor Boles thanked officers and Councillor Tariq for their updates and opened to questions.
Councillor Boles as Chair of the Committee thanked members for their contributions.
Councillor Boles asked about advertising costs and if they will be reviewed following alternative methods used. In response Sean Walsh, Director of Social Care Practice advised all methods of recruitment and advertisement is being reviewed constantly. The social media footprint is being worked on and is a relatively cost-effective option currently.
Councillor Boles thanked everyone for their attendance.
Councillor Boles thanked all who attended this evening and advised a training session has recently taken place that highlighted the importance of lived experience at Scrutiny.
The Chair, Councillor Boles advised that a copy of the question and response will be made available on the Council Web Site.
· Fees have not changed much for 12 years · Foster carers have stood the pandemic with no support · Independent fostering agencies offer more money to foster Children · Families who foster children need money to support the children to have the same as their peers · Communication between services needs to improve · We need to be involved in decision making to put forward personal views Councillor Boles thanked Brian for his powerful contribution to the meeting and wished to move on to questions from the committee.
Councillor Boles thanked report authors and members for the questions and answers given.
Councillor Boles raised that the Social Worker visit has now taken place and members can provide updates under item 7, Social Care Recruitment.
Councillor Boles, Chair of the Committee advised that a representative from the Foster Carers Association will be attending the next Committee to provide input.
In addition, Councillor Boles provided an offer to [name removed] that if residents would like to email him directly regarding matters to be raised at the Committee they can do so, and he would be happy for one person to attend and represent a group of people if they are unable to attend in person so their lived experience is discussed.
The Chair, Councillor Boles advised that a copy of the question and response will be made available on the Council Web Site.
In addition, Councillor Boles asked if members of the Committee wished to share feedback following the visit to Bury’s Social Workers that took place on 07 th September 2022, Councillor Whitby, Georgia Murphy, and Helen Chadwick attended the visit. Feedback from the session was:
On behalf of the Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Boles, Chair took the opportunity to congratulate those who have recently undertaken their exams this year and the teachers involved.
Councillor Boles, Chair of the Committee took the opportunity to highlight that a similar report will be coming to the next Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee and a representative from the Foster Carers Association will be invited to that meeting.
In addition, Councillor Boles recommended that members review the Independent Review into Children’s Social Care Report in advance of the meeting.
In summary Councillor Boles sought assurances that the recruitment drive and support work to improve the number of Social Workers is also mirrored for Foster Carers.
Councillor Boles, Chair asked if [name removed] has a supplementary question. In response [name removed] asked; I would remind you that I’ve not had a response within 10 weeks. Do you think it’s appropriate to revisit those time frames and make immediate improvement?
Councillor Boles, Chair of that Committee outlined that in Green Paper it documented that parents were not clear what to expect from a Local Authority. He asked what we can do to clearly explain the offer a Local Authority can provide. In response Michael Kemp, advised that within the document of a graduated response it provides an outline of what teachers, Schools and parents can expect from a Local Authority.
Councillor Boles declared a personal interest as he works at a school, which also has a site in Bury.
Councillor Boles declared both a prejudicial interest in planning applications 66745 and 66746 due to a family member owning a property in the vicinity of the application location.
Councillor Boles left the meeting during deliberation of the applications.
Councillor Boles declared a personal interest in the Conservative NOM as a teacher employed in the Borough.
Councillor Boles declared a personal interest as he was employed by a Bolton school which also has a site in Bury.
Councillor Boles clarified that whilst the report discusses the drop in demand for primary schools it is not reflected in Bury East and Moorside.
Councillor Boles declared a personal interest as he was employed by a Bolton school which also has a site in Bury.
Councillor Ciaron Boles declared a prejudicial interest in application number 66822 as a relative lives close to the premises in question and stated that he would leave the meeting during consideration of the application.
Ward Councillor Elected Ramsbottom Councillor Tom Pilkington North Manor Councillor Roger Brown and Councillor Liam Dean Tottington Councillor Luis McBriar Elton Councillor Jack Rydeheard Moorside Councillor Ciaron Boles and Councillor Kevin Peel East Councillor Ummrana Farooq Church Councillor Jordan Lewis Redvales Councillor Shaheena Haroon Unsworth Councillor Nathan Boroda Radcliffe East Councillor Carol Birchmore Radcliffe North Councillor Jo Lancaster Radcliffe West Councillor Gareth Staples-Jones Pilkington Park Councillor Russell Bernstein Besses Councillor Lucy Smith Holyrood Councillor Steven Wright St Mary’s Councillor Sam Butler Sedgley Councillor Debbie Quinn
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Boles attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 Sep 2024 | Council | Recommendations of cabinet and council committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Nov 2022 | Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee | Foster carers | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 Jul 2022 | Council | Emergency motion - castle armoury | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Boles was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 24 of 31 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Boles declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Oct 2026 | Planning Control Committee, item PCC.2 | Councillor C Boles declared an interest in planning application 73392, Rose & Crown Inn, 36 Manchester Old Road, Bury, BL9 0TR as he knew an objector to the application. | |
| 21 Oct 2025 | Planning Control Committee, item PCC.2 | Councillor C Boles declared a prejudicial interest in relation to the planning applications on the agenda, 70213, Conversion of existing public house to 5 no. | |
| 29 Aug 2023 | Planning Control Committee, item PCC.2 | Councillor C Boles declared an interest in planning application 68055, Land at Springside Road, Bury . H e had family friends that lived in the same area. He had not commented on the application and would remain in the meeting during deliberation of this application. | |
| 23 Mar 2022 | Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Councillor Boles declared a personal interest as he works at a school, which also has a site in Bury. | |
| 22 Feb 2022 | Planning Control Committee, item PCC.2 | Councillor Boles declared both a prejudicial interest in planning applications 66745 and 66746 due to a family member owning a property in the vicinity of the application location. | |
| 19 Jan 2022 | Council, item C. 44 | Councillor Boles declared a personal interest in the Conservative NOM as a teacher employed in the Borough. | |
| 4 Nov 2021 | Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee, item 1 | Councillor Boles declared a personal interest as he was employed by a Bolton school which also has a site in Bury. | |
| 7 Sep 2021 | Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee, item CYPSC.1 | Councillor Boles declared a personal interest as he was employed by a Bolton school which also has a site in Bury. | |
| 27 Jul 2021 | Planning Control Committee, item PCC.1 | Councillor Ciaron Boles declared a prejudicial interest in application number 66822 as a relative lives close to the premises in question and stated that he would leave the meeting during consideration of the application. |
Where Councillor Boles sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planning Control Committee | Committee Member | May 2021 | 61 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Jul 2021 | 46 | |
| Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Sep 2021 | 27 | 6 Jan 2027 |
| Health Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2023 | 20 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2023 | 2 | 24 Nov 2026 |
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Mar 2023 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.