Apologies for Absence
Councillor Tony Dean attended as a substitute.
Every time Cheshire East's minutes name Councillor Dean, as the council published it.
Councillor Tony Dean attended as a substitute.
In the interests of openness and transparency Councillor Dean declared, in relation to item 7, that he was a landlord for a property owned by his wife, within Cheshire East.
Councillor T Dean attended as a substitute for Councillor Gardiner.
In the interest of openness Cllr T Dean declared that he knew one of the planning agents but had not discussed the applications with him.
Councillor T Dean was present as substitute.
Councillor T Dean declared, in relation to agenda item 8 – Knutsford BID Proposal, that he was a Knutsford resident. Councillor D also declared that he was a Board Member of the Tatton Park Board.
Prior to the consideration of the item, following advice from the Monitoring Officer, Councillor T Dean confirmed that he would not participate in the debate nor the vote on this matter and would leave the meeting room.
Councillor T Dean did not return.
Councillor T Dean left the meeting during consideration of this application and did not return.
Councillor T Dean was present as substitute.
Councillor T Dean, in the interests of openness and transparency, declared, in relation to agenda item 11 (Options Agreement – Land at Longridge, Knutsford) that he had previously been aware of the planning application and the land options however he had no part in any decision-making to date.
In the interest of openness and transparency, Councillor Tony Dean declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 in that he formerly worked for the Environment Agency.
Councillor Dean attended as a substitute.
Councillor T Dean attended as a substitute member.
Councillor T Dean attended as a substitute.
Councillor T Dean attended as a substitute.
Councillor Tony Dean attended as subsutitute.
Councillor T Dean attended as a substitute.
Councillor T Dean attended as a substitute.
Councillor T Dean asked that, as the Council were closing three Household Waste and Recycling Centres (HWRCS) in Cheshire East, to what extent were cross boundary drawbacks and reciprocal arrangements discussed with neighbouring local authorities to improve residents’ access to HWRCs, reduce any potential impacts of rising fly tipping and provide mutually beneficial cost savings.
Councillor L Braithwaite attended as a substitute for Councillor Wilson and Councillor S Edgar attended as a substitute for Councillor Dean.
Local Plan Member Reference Group Cllr L Smetham (Cons) Cllr S Gardiner (Cons) Cllr T Dean (Cons) Cllr L Braithwaite (Lab) Cllr C Chapman (Lab) Cllr L Crane (Lab) Cllr M Warren (Ind) Section 106 Member/Officer Working Group Cllr S Gardiner (Cons) Cllr B Posnett (Cons) Cllr J Snowball (Lab) Cllr J Bratherton (Lab) Cllr D Jefferay (Ind) Cllr M Gorman (Ind) Cemeteries Strategy Member Advisory Panel Cllr N Cook (Ind) Cllr J Bratherton (Lab) Cllr J Snowball (Lab) Cllr L Smetham (Cons) Cllr H Whitaker (Cons) It was requested that Cllr L Crane also be added to the Cemeteries Strategy Member Advisory Panel.
Approve the Bollin Hill Wilmslow Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Plan (Appendix D) for adoption Cllr Dean and Cllr Posnett left the meeting and did not return.
Councillor Tony Dean addressed the committee as a visiting member in relation to the warding proposals for Knutsford.
Councillor Dean spoke in favour of the proposals from the Electoral Review Sub Committee for Knutsford, and urged the committee to vote against any new proposal to split Knutsford into a two-ward area as he felt this was not in the best interests of the local communities in Knutsford.
Councillor J Clowes proposed two amendments, seconded by Councillor T Dean which were as follows;
A statement was read out on behalf of Councillor Tony Dean (neighbouring ward councillor).
Cllr Dean read out a statement on behalf of Cllr Allen Gage which stated that this was a well-established sports site with adequate on-site parking and he did not believe that the repurposing of existing space would impact on current activities.
Cllr Gardiner, Cllr Seddon, Cllr Warren, Cllr Brooks, Cllr Buchanan and Cllr Dean declared that they were members of the Cheshire East library service.
Cllr Dean declared that his daughter-in-law worked for the library service in Cheshire West which was a combined service with Cheshire East.
- Some members felt that they did not have sufficient involvement in the production of the MTFS and were unable to make changes to the proposals - Green waste charging was controversial with residents and it was felt that many may choose not to pay - It appeared to be a change of course as there had been investment in encouraging residents to dispose of food waste in green bins - Instances of fly tipping may go unreported when on private land which would particularly affect rural areas - Concern that reducing the collection of green waste, as was done by Cheshire West, was not included in the proposal - The Council had to set a balanced budget by law and this was one of the few services within the committee’s remit that was not statutory - There was an opportunity to be environmental with the change, such as encouraging home composting and rewilding to reduce garden waste It was requested that the minutes show that the following members voted against the proposal: Cllr Tony Dean, Cllr Stewart Gardiner, Cllr Becky Posnett, Cllr Lesley Smetham and Cllr Hayley Whitaker.
Councillor A Kolker attended as a substitute for Councillor Dean.
The motion, which had been proposed by Cllr Tony Dean and seconded by Cllr Quentin Abel, proposed that Cheshire East Highways worked with Town and Parish Councils to address issues raised around existing tree planting policies.
Councillor Tony Dean, who addressed the Committee as the proposer of the Notice of Motion, encouraged Committee Members to ensure that Cheshire East Highways adopted a flexible approach when considering tree planting requests and applying the framework criteria set out in the report. It was felt that the requirement to obtain a street works permit and/or licence to plant, could be costly and potentially discourage Town and Parish Councils from planting trees.
- Cllr Dean raised concerns around the consultation process and that Committee Members had not been consulted or involved in the drawing up of the proposals before them in the report. Committee Members requested that consideration is given to future consultation to ensure there is a clear process for the Committee to be properly consulted on the proposals and detail surrounding them.
- Proposal 92: Review Waste Collection Service – Cllr Dean queried how much it would cost for a green bin to be emptied, what the current position was across the wider local authority sector and what market research had been undertaken to date.
A further request was made by Cllr Dean for the Committee to receive figures on what the backlog was and what it is now.
Councillor Tony Dean attended Committee on behalf of the Flooding Working Group which produced the report and recommendations “It’s Not Just Water”.
The Committee considered the report on the Notice of Motion relating to the Cost-of-Living Crisis which was proposed by Councillor Clowes and seconded by Councillor Tony Dean at the Full Council meeting on the 19th October 2022 . The report outlined the Council’s approach to the Cost-of-Living Crisis and the interventions that were underway . A further report around impact of interventions would be presented back to Committee at a later date.
Councillor Tony Dean, Chair of the Member Advisory Panel for Planning updated the Committee on progress to date. The Deep-Dive Planning report was now scheduled for a special committee date in October, delays had occurred due to the numbers of people who needed to be consulted.
Councillor T Dean also attended as a member of the working group and, at the Chair’s invitation, spoke on the matter.
Councillor Dean requested where possible statistics to represent a before and after analysis of single use plastic usage.
Councillor Tony Dean advised that Phase One related to the planning backlog and perceived lack of enforcement action, but was sure it would be part of the review.
Councillor Tony Dean gave a verbal update to the Committee.
Councillor Dean noted an item for potential inclusion within the would be food inspection services. He noted in the past, Members would receive a traffic light Red, Amber, Green (RAG) report and often food inspection services were rated red. The pandemic did change requirements but the Committee agreed that an update and the reinstation of the RAG report would be preferred.
Councillor T Dean attended as a substitute.
Councillor Tony Dean, the Chair of the Member Advisory Panel for Planning (MAPP), gave the Committee an update on the work to date.
Councillor Dean advised that the review had been a fair, open and inclusive process, generating over 300 comments and correspondence, 25 sessions with Planning teams and listening to staff, Brighter Futures workshops, gathering and analysing, complaints, FOIs, in-depth reviews, peer reviews, and considered the life of a planning application and new proposed ICT system.
Councillor Dean noted that Cheshire East was the busiest local authority in Northwest, and in the top five within the country and top ten in terms of volume. It was noted that there was a national difficulty in recruiting experienced planners. Progressed had been made in terms of the 2022 budget and the council having set aside £0.5million to the planning department and the staffing resource was being met temporarily via an agency to help with back log whilst the Council worked towards driving a recruitment campaign.
For Councillor Clowes - 25 Cllrs M Beanland, Cllr M Benson, Cllr J Clowes, Cllr S Davies, Cllr T Dean, Cllr S Edgar, Cllr JP Findlow, Cllr A Gage, Cllr S Gardiner, Cllr P Groves, Cllr G Hayes, Cllr S Holland, Cllr A Kolker, Cllr C Leach, Cllr A Martin, Cllr K Parkinson, Cllr P Redstone, Cllr J Saunders, Cllr M Sewart, Cllr M Simon, Cllr L Smetham, Cllr L Wardlaw, Cllr J Weatherill, Cllr J Wray and Cllr N Wylie.
Councillor Kate Parkinson was the original proposer of the Notice of Motion but was unable to attend the meeting, so Councillor Tony Dean (the original seconder) read a statement on her behalf. The statement noted the councils vision for an open, fair and green in its Corporate Plan and requested the Committee encourage the banning of single use plastic from its operations within six months, to promote the use of filtered water fountains and taps within Cheshire East and ESAR buildings and to encourage Councillors to bring their own water flasks and mugs into buildings. The recycling for mixed plastics was not always easy and often was incinerated or sent to landfill.
Councillor Tony Dean then addressed the Committee as the original seconder of the Notice of Motion, he advised the Committee that in 2018 there had been a similar Notice of Motion to eliminate Single Use plastics throughout the councils facilities management supply chain by 2020. This motion was approved and implemented but the evaluation report was never concluded.
Councillor Dean would reaffirm the requirement to remove single use plastics from operations, with the caveat that it can only be used when there is no safe equivalent for health reasons in relation to food.
Councillor Tony Dean updated the Committee on work to date. Phase 1 report is near to completion by Jayne Traverse, Executive Director of Place but will be scheduled for the June Committee. There had been a lot of work to date and there had been meetings completed with management which resulted in a lot of data and improvement ideas.
In the interest of openness in respect of application 20/4737M, Councillor T Dean declared that the applicant was known to him.
Councillor Tony Dean made a general point that as a member of the committee, he understood the areas of responsibility, however at present this committee had no influence on the budget.
Whilst Councillor Dean did comment he could lobby Finance Sub-Committee, he felt it would be more productive, before the next round of the MTFS, to attend a half-day seminar that covered the changes being proposed in order to have more influence over the areas of scrutiny for this committee.
Councillor Tony Dean updated the committee on the work of the Planning Member Advisory Panel (MAP). This MAP was sitting alongside a deep-dive full-systems review of Planning services as instigated by the Executive Director of Place. The review included staffing issues and external users of the planning service.
Councillor Dean noted that Cheshire East Council experienced one of the highest numbers of planning applications in the country with over 6,000 a year;
Currently the Executive Director of Place was leading a deep dive review of the Planning Department, in tandem with a Member Advisory Panel chaired by Councillor Tony Dean reporting to the Environment and Communities Committee.
Councillor T Dean referred to the capital strategy of the Environment and Communities Committee and asked about the scheme for the Knutsford Leisure Centre which did not appear on the list.
Councillor Tony Dean addressed the Committee and gave reassurances that the reason for him bringing this item before the Committee was an attempt to support officers through a very challenging workload.
Councillor Dean advised that since the agenda had been published he had received a large number of emails and phone calls from a variety of developers and members of the public which further highlighted the issue.
Councillor Dean was content that during agenda item 5, Mid-Year Performance Review, it had been resolved that a Member Advisory Panel (MAP) be convened to assist the work Jayne Traverse is overseeing.
Councillor Dean was content with this outcome.
In the interest of openness in respect of applications 18/2996M and 20/4682M, Councillor T Dean declared that he was known to the Tatton estate and the Chief Executive but he had not discussed the applications with him.
In respect of application 20/0113M, Councillor T Dean declared that he was a member of the Northern Planning Committee who had discussed the application and made a recommendation on which he took part in and voted on. In accordance with the Code of Conduct he left the virtual meeting prior to consideration of the application.
In the interest of openness in respect of application 20/3347M, Councillor T Dean declared that he was a Vodafone user.
In respect of application 19/2254M, Councillor T Dean declared that he had called in the application and had pre-determined it and therefore in accordance with the Code of Conduct he exercised his right to speak as Ward Councillor under the public speaking procedure and then left the virtual meeting for the remainder of the application.
( Councillor Tony Dean, the Ward Councillor, Town Councillor James McCulloch, representing Knutsford Town Council, Brian Chaplin, a Community representative on Knutsford Neighbourhood Plan, objecting and Georgina Daintith , representing the applicant attended the virtual meeting and spoke in respect of the application).
In the interest of openness in respect of application 19/3774M, Councillor T Dean declared that he used to be the Regional Director of the Environment Agency during the time when the Agency was involved closely with United Utilities in preparation of their asset management plans, however he had not been involved with this project.
In the interest of openness in respect of application 19/3950M, Councillor T Dean declared one of the speakers [name removed] was known to him and that he worked with the company who had assisted with the Neighbourhood Plan for Knutsford.
Councillor T Dean also left the meeting and returned once a decision had been made.
Councillor T Dean referred to a proposal in the draft Environmental Strategy to produce a Green Infrastructure Strategy by October 2019. He asked when this would be available to members.
Councillor T Dean noted that the proposed budget included an additional £19M government funding. He asked how much money would be spent on climate change measures and in particular the provision of a better bus service across the Borough.
Cllr Tony Dean referred to Agenda Items 8 and 9 and asked about the Council’s aim of carbon reduction and impact of climate change on these schemes. In response the Deputy Leader stated that Environmental Impact Assessments had been carried out for these schemes. The two schemes would help improve air quality by reducing traffic congestion, included cycling provision and mitigation measure for biodiversity.
It was agreed that the Environmental Impact Assessments would be forwarded to Cllr Dean.
Cllr Tony Dean referred to item 10 and asked if the draft Economic Strategy would be reviewed in light of the Council’s new environmental aims. The Portfolio Holder for Environment and Regeneration responded that the Strategy was a draft, was subject to a period of consultation and that feedback and good practice would be incorporated.
With regard to application number 18/6157M , Councillor T Dean declared that he had been a member of Knutsford Town Council when the application had originally been submitted. However, the application had been significantly amended, he had not been party to the consultations on the current version of the application and he had kept an open mind.
(Councillor T Dean, the Ward Councillor, Debbie Jamison, an objector, Brian Chaplin, representing the five Knutsford Community Groups, supporting and Sebastian Tibenham , the agent for the applicant attended the meeting and spoke in respect of the application).
Councillor T Dean commented in relation to the proposed Longridge development that the original plan had shown four accesses onto the site and that the landowner had not had regard to the restrictive covenants over the grass verge. The late realisation of this error had let to a badly-conceived plan to sell off highly valued public open space to provide one access road to the site. He added that a non-practising solicitor working for Knutsford Town Council had obtained a copy of the covenant in relation to the grass verge land and had identified the beneficiaries.
The motion was put to the meeting with the following results:- For Cllr A Arnold, Cllr G Baggot , Cllr Rachel Bailey, Cllr Rhoda Bailey, Cllr G Barton, Cllr P Bates, Cllr G Baxendale, D Bebbington , E Brooks, Cllr D Brown, C Browne, Cllr P Butterill , Cllr J Clowes , Cllr H Davenport, Cllr S Davies, Cllr M Deakin, Cllr T Dean,Cllr L Durham, Cllr S Edgar, Cllr JP Findlow , Cllr R Fletcher, Cllr H Gaddum , Cllr S Gardiner, Cllr S Gardner, Cllr L Gilbert, Cllr P Groves, Cllr J Hammond, Cllr D Hough, ... view the full minutes text for item 24.
Councillor T Dean, on behalf of Knutsford Town Council, spoke in support of the application. The Town Council had made the application after being approached by members of the public who were using the path when it was blocked off by a fence – this path offered a more level access to King Street from Old Market Place Car Park. The evidence supplied showed that the path had been used by the public as of right and without interruption for 20 years and was therefore deemed dedicated.
In the interest of openness in respect of application 16/4136M, Councillor T Dean declared that was known to all of the speakers by virtue of being a colleague of [name removed] and also having attended meetings with [name removed] , the agent for the applicant and [name removed], the applicant always being present with either an Officer of Cheshire East Council or an Officer of Knutsford Town Council. He also recalled having attended a meeting when the application was first considered by Knutsford Town Council, however when the Town Council reconsidered the application at a meeting earlier in the week he chose not to use his vote in order for him to facilitate being able to speak and vote at the meeting today. He did not believe his position had been prejudiced by these decisions.
Accordingly, a recorded vote was carried out in respect of this item, with the following results:- For Cllr C Andrew, Cllr A Arnold, Cllr G Baggott , Cllr D Bailey, Cllr Rachel Bailey, Cllr Rhoda Bailey, Cllr P Bates, Cllr G Baxendale, Cllr M Beanland , Cllr D Bebbington , Cllr S Brookfield, Cllr E Brooks, Cllr D Brown, Cllr C Browne, Cllr B Burkhill , Cllr P Butterill , Cllr S Carter, Cllr C Chapman, Cllr J Clowes , Cllr S Corcoran, Cllr H Davenport, Cllr S Davies, Cllr M Deakin, Cllr Tony Dean, Cllr B Dooley, Cllr L Durham, Cllr S Edgar, Cllr I Faseyi , Cllr JP Findlow , Cllr R Fletcher, Cllr D Flude , Cllr T Fox, Cllr S Gardiner, Cllr S Gardner, Cllr M Grant, Cllr P Groves, Cllr J Hammond, Cllr M Hardy, Cllr A Harewood, Cllr G Hayes, Cllr S Hogben , Cllr D Hough, Cllr O Hunter, Cllr J Jackson, Cllr L Jeuda , Cllr A Kolker , Cllr J Macrae , Cllr D Mahon, Cllr N Mannion , Cllr D Marren , Cllr A Martin, Cllr R Menlove , Cllr G Merry, Cllr A Moran, Cllr B Moran, Cllr H Murray, Cllr D Newton, Cllr M Parsons, Cllr S Pochin , Cllr J Rhodes, Cllr B Roberts, Cllr J Saunders, Cllr Sewart , Cllr M Simon, Cllr D Stockton, Cllr A Stott, Cllr G Wait, Cllr B Walmsley, Cllr G Walton, Cllr L Wardlaw , Cllr M Warren, Cllr J Weatherill , Cllr H Wells-Bradshaw , Cllr G Williams, Cllr J Wray.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Dean attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Dean's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Dean was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 6 of 18 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Dean declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 30 Apr 2026 | Corporate Policy Committee, item 2 | In the interests of openness and transparency Councillor Dean declared, in relation to item 7, that he was a landlord for a property owned by his wife, within Cheshire East. | |
| 22 Apr 2026 | Northern Planning Committee, item 48 | In the interest of openness Cllr T Dean declared that he knew one of the planning agents but had not discussed the applications with him. | |
| 6 Aug 2025 | Corporate Policy Committee, item 18 | Councillor T Dean declared, in relation to agenda item 8 – Knutsford BID Proposal, that he was a Knutsford resident. Councillor D also declared that he was a Board Member of the Tatton Park Board. | |
| 2 Jun 2025 | Finance Sub-Committee, item 2 | Councillor T Dean, in the interests of openness and transparency, declared, in relation to agenda item 11 (Options Agreement – Land at Longridge, Knutsford) that he had previously been aware of the planning application and the land options however he had no part in any decision-making to date. | |
| 13 Mar 2025 | Scrutiny Committee, item 34 | In the interest of openness and transparency, Councillor Tony Dean declared a non-pecuniary interest in item 5 in that he formerly worked for the Environment Agency. | |
| 27 Jul 2023 | Environment and Communities Committee, item 85 | Cllr Gardiner, Cllr Seddon, Cllr Warren, Cllr Brooks, Cllr Buchanan and Cllr Dean declared that they were members of the Cheshire East library service. | |
| 27 Jul 2023 | Environment and Communities Committee, item 85 | Cllr Dean declared that his daughter-in-law worked for the library service in Cheshire West which was a combined service with Cheshire East. | |
| 23 Feb 2022 | Northern Planning Committee, item 51 | In the interest of openness in respect of application 20/4737M, Councillor T Dean declared that the applicant was known to him. | |
| 15 Jan 2021 | Strategic Planning Board, item 64 | In the interest of openness in respect of applications 18/2996M and 20/4682M, Councillor T Dean declared that he was known to the Tatton estate and the Chief Executive but he had not discussed the applications with him. | |
| 15 Jan 2021 | Strategic Planning Board, item 64 | In respect of application 20/0113M, Councillor T Dean declared that he was a member of the Northern Planning Committee who had discussed the application and made a recommendation on which he took part in and voted on. In accordance with the Code of Conduct he left the virtual meeting prior to consideration of the application. | Stayed and took part |
| 13 Jan 2021 | Northern Planning Committee, item 59 | In the interest of openness in respect of application 20/3347M, Councillor T Dean declared that he was a Vodafone user. | |
| 17 Jun 2020 | Northern Planning Committee, item 2 | In respect of application 19/2254M, Councillor T Dean declared that he had called in the application and had pre-determined it and therefore in accordance with the Code of Conduct he exercised his right to speak as Ward Councillor under the public speaking procedure and then left the virtual meeting for the remainder of the application. | |
| 12 Feb 2020 | Northern Planning Committee, item 69 | In the interest of openness in respect of application 19/3774M, Councillor T Dean declared that he used to be the Regional Director of the Environment Agency during the time when the Agency was involved closely with United Utilities in preparation of their asset management plans, however he had not been involved with this project. | |
| 15 Jan 2020 | Northern Planning Committee, item 61 | In the interest of openness in respect of application 19/3950M, Councillor T Dean declared one of the speakers [name removed] was known to him and that he worked with the company who had assisted with the Neighbourhood Plan for Knutsford. | |
| 5 Jun 2019 | Northern Planning Committee, item 2 | With regard to application number 18/6157M , Councillor T Dean declared that he had been a member of Knutsford Town Council when the application had originally been submitted. However, the application had been significantly amended, he had not been party to the consultations on the current version of the application and he had kept an open mind. | |
| 11 Jan 2017 | Northern Planning Committee, item 66 | In the interest of openness in respect of application 16/4136M, Councillor T Dean declared that was known to all of the speakers by virtue of being a colleague of [name removed] and also having attended meetings with [name removed] , the agent for the applicant and [name removed], the applicant always being present with either an Officer of Cheshire East Council or an Officer of Knutsford Town Council. He also recalled having attended a meeting when the application was first considered by Knutsford Town Council, however when the Town Council reconsidered the application at a meeting earlier in the week he chose not to use his vote in order for him to facilitate being able to speak and vote at the meeting today. He did not believe his position had been prejudiced by these decisions. |
Where Councillor Dean sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Northern Planning Committee | Committee Member | Apr 2002 | 7 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| General Appeals Sub Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2025 | 5 | 25 Nov 2026 |
| Appointments Committee | Committee Member | Aug 2021 | 4 | |
| Strategic Planning Board | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | |
| Council | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 2 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Southern Planning Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2025 | 1 | 2 Dec 2026 |
| Corporate Policy Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.