Apologies for Absence
Executive Mayor Jason Perry and Cllr Jason Cummings had both given apologies, with Cllr Andy Stranack and Cllr Robert Ward attending as a reserve Members.
Every time Croydon's minutes name Councillor Cummings, as the council published it.
Executive Mayor Jason Perry and Cllr Jason Cummings had both given apologies, with Cllr Andy Stranack and Cllr Robert Ward attending as a reserve Members.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Non-Statutory Deputy Mayor and Cabinet Member for Finance, emphasised the suitability of this particular facility for the services to operate from the location. The co-location of the services supported the Council to ensure the right services were in the right place and helped maximise the utilisation of assets that the Council was retaining.
Councillor Cummings noted that the last financial monitoring report considered by Cabinet had been the Period 10 monitoring report and that the provisional year-end outturn showed only limited variance from the position previously reported. The consistency was welcomed between the in-year monitoring and the final outturn position, observing that in many local authorities significant changes can emerge at year-end which were not reflected in earlier monitoring reports.
Councillor Cummings stated that, as the Council entered its annual cycle of budget setting and financial monitoring, it was important to undertake a renewed process of challenge and rigorous scrutiny of the Council's financial position and future Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS).
Councillor Cummings therefore welcomed the strategy's focus on demand management, explaining that demand management was not about reducing service levels but about reducing the need for services through prevention, earlier intervention and different approaches to service delivery. Such an approach had the potential to improve outcomes for residents while simultaneously reducing costs.
Cllr Cummings highlighted that a key theme within the strategy was the ... view the full minutes text for item 60/26
• Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance • Conrad Hall, Corporate Director of Resources and Section 151 Officer • Allister Bannin, Director of Finance and Deputy Section 151 Officer An introduction was provided by the Cabinet Member and the Corporate Director, which outlined the context behind the development of the Financial Strategy. It was noted that the previous year had seen a number of significant changes, including the introduction and implementation of the Stabilisation Plan, a change in the Council's intervention model, the appointment of a new Section 151 Officer and Council elections. As a result, it had not been possible to develop a longer-term financial strategy at that time.
Cllr Lynne Hale, Statutory Deputy Mayor, and Cllr Jason Cummings, Non-Statutory Deputy Mayor, both made a personal financial interest declaration with regards to Agenda Item 12 (Members Allowances). The members both withdrew during the consideration and voting of item 12.
Cllr Lynne Hale and Cllr Jason Cummings both left the Council Chamber for the duration of the item, due to earlier Declarations of Interest.
Cllr Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance, introduced the Annual Treasury Management Review 2025-26 and thanked the Council's Treasury Management and Finance officers for their work throughout the financial year and advised that the report had been prepared in accordance with the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) Treasury Management Code and Prudential Code requirements.
Cllr Jason Cummings and Cllr Andy Stranack.
- · Executive Mayor Jason Perry · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Elaine Jackson – Interim Chief Executive · Conrad Hall – Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer During his introduction of the report, the Executive Mayor expressed his gratitude at being re-elected for a second term and reaffirmed his commitment to serving the residents of Croydon.
- Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance Elaine Jackson – Interim Chief Executive Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer The Cabinet Member introduced the Period 10 Financial Monitoring Report, noting that between period 9 and 10, the Council’s financial position improved by £1.1m, resulting in a forecast underspend of £27.3m. This aligned with the in-year stabilisation plan target, which had been achieved.
Councillor Cummings addressed the committee as the referring Ward Councillor. After the speakers had finished, the Committee deliberated.
Chris Scarr and Councillor Cummings spoke in support of the application.
Cllr Cummings and Committee noted a presentation would be well received at the meeting.
Cllr Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance, highlighted that in each period during the financial year the Council had improved the previous position. This was testament to the amount of work undertaken by departments to meet their targets, savings and deliver the stabilisation plan.
Cllr King noted only a two-sentence reference to the High Court judgment in the report and had been right and proper for Cllr Cummings to verbally update Cabinet and members of the public as to the financial impact - both for the current year and for the MTFS.
- · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Conrad Hall – Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer · Susmita Sen – Corporate Director for Housing · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer · Beatrice Cingtho-Taylor - Director of Housing, Homelessness Prevention & Accommodation · Gina Clarke - Head of Corporate, Commercial & Planning Law During the introduction to the report by Councillor Jason Cummings, it was noted that this represents an improvement of £0.5m on the previous period, attributable to improvements in Sustainable Communities, Regeneration and Economic Recovery (SCRER) and Resources directorates. It was also highlighted that the four housing actions in the Stabilisation Plan table had been split following a previous request by the Committee. The cost for Unaccompanied Asylum Seeking Children (UASC) and Unaccompanied Asylum Seeking Young People had also been separated following a request from the Committee.
Councillor Cummings noted that legal risks were complex, as assessments were based on confidential legal advice. He confirmed that the LTN case had been well known and that he had received regular briefings. He suggested that the Committee hold a Part B session with the Monitoring Officer to review significant legal cases and consider whether the process for adding such risks to the register was functioning effectively.
A Member asked whether other similar cases existed; Councillor Cummings reiterated that such matters could only be discussed confidentially.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance addressed the Committee and reflected on the Council’s recent history regarding the production and audit of its accounts.
Councillor Cummings emphasised that it represented significant progress for the Council to be in a position to discuss the previous year’s accounts, which was something that had not been possible for several years due to the combined impact of Croydon’s historic financial challenges and the wider national backlog in local authority audits.
Councillor Cummings noted that those legacy issues continued to affect the current audit, particularly in relation to opening balances and other areas highlighted within the report.
Drawing Members’ attention to the Audit Findings Report, he quoted the statement on page 6 which acknowledged that management had demonstrated “positive efforts to support the 2024/25 audit and allow it to progress significantly and the process of rebuilding assurance to commence effectively.” Councillor Cummings stressed that this marked the beginning of that rebuilding process. While the Council would not achieve a fully audited, fully assured set of accounts this year and was unlikely to do so for at least a couple of years, substantial progress had been made.
Councillor Cummings concluded by recognising the considerable work already undertaken and the significant work that still lay ahead for the Council.
Cllr Cummings highlighted that given the Council’s financial challenges there were still many positives in the proposals. Paragraph 5.9 detailed the parks budget – which had historically not existed in the Council. With some level of capital financing going into the parks the growth in the number of parks with green flags was being supported.
Cllr Cummings noted that the levels of capitalisation directions falling in the years of the current administration was due to the true state of the finances only being understood when taking ... view the full minutes text for item 22/26
Cllr Cummings advised that the report had been considered by the Audit Governance Committee, 29th January 2026, before consideration at Cabinet and onto Council.
- · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Elaine Jackson – Interim Chief Executive · Jenny Rowlands – Assistant Chief Executive · Conrad Hall – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance and Deputy Section 151 Officer · Stuart Collins – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Annette McPartland – Corporate Director for Adults · Venetia Reid-Baptiste – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration & Economic Recovery · Susmita Sen – Corporate Director for Housing At the start of this item the Committee agreed to accept the recommendation made by the Homes Sub-Committee, during its consideration of the Budget, which would be submitted to the Cabinet alongside any recommendation arising from this meeting.
The Chair thanks Councillor Jason Cummings, Conrad Hall and Allister Bannin for the time they had taken to brief the Committee on the budget in both January and February.
Councillor Jason Cummings introduced the report, thanking Scrutiny for their level of engagement with the budget to date. During the introduction the following was noted: - · The Committee was advised that Council Tax would rise by 4.99% in the next financial year, which was broadly in line with most of local government and within the Government’s cap.
Cllr Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance, advised that the visibility of the Council’s risk register and how the risks were managed was an important part of the operation of this Council In had been raised in various historic governance reports that the Council's attitude towards risk management, visibility and appetite was something the Council needed to address. The report being received at Cabinet partly addressed the issues.
Cllr Cummings provided apologies with Cllr Ward attending as reserve Member.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, in moving the recommendations, reported that the Annual Treasury Management Review for 2024–2025 had been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) Codes of Practice. He stated that the report reviewed the Council’s treasury borrowing and investment activity during the year and confirmed compliance with the Treasury Management Strategy Statement, the Prudential Indicators, and the CIPFA Prudential Code.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings reported that the Mid-Year Treasury Management Review covered activity during the first six months of the 2025–2026 financial year. He confirmed that the report had been prepared in accordance with CIPFA requirements and reviewed compliance with the same indicators and controls as the annual review.
Councillor Jason Cummings was invited to open the debate.
Councillor Jason Cummings stated that he had first been elected to the Council in 2010 and outlined the changes in political control since that time, noting that a consistent feature throughout had been cross-party agreement that Croydon was underfunded by the national local government funding formula.
Councillor Cummings explained that the Council’s submission to the Government’s Fair Funding consultation had therefore focused on specific changes to the formula. He cited the example of deprivation measures failing to take housing costs into account, noting that while 15% of households in London were classed as being in poverty before housing costs, this rose to 26% once housing costs were included, making London the highest in the country.
The approach to the Scrutiny’s Budget Review and deep-dives was being revised and would be informed through engagement with Cllr Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance, and the Deputy Section 151 Officer.
Cllr Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance, stated that whilst excellent progress had been made so far - it was still not enough – as £27.3m was the target contained within the stabilisation plan. However, all indications were that positive progress would continue as the year progressed.
Cllr Cummings noted, above any inflation applied, the variance would have ensured full cost recovery or been adjusted to align with the market.
Cllr Cummings responded that the bereavement services increase was aligned to seeking full cost-recovery. Allister Bannin, Director of Finance, wished to remind the public that resident in receipt of benefits could apply to the Department of Works & Pensions (DWP) for financial support regarding funeral costs e.g., cost of burials or cremation.
Cllr Cummings outlined that the report had been through Audit & Governance Committee. The report was interesting for anyone wishing to understand the impacts of the debt Croydon was holding and advised Members to read the report before consideration at Full Council.
Cllr King and Cllr Cummings expressed that regardless of the election outcome, the timely permanent recruitment of a Chief Executive would be a challenge and priority for any administration post-elections.
Cllr Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance, highlighted that the last Scrutiny meeting had been positive and believed that reassurances on the matters discussed had been fully provided.
Cllr Cummings welcomed a £800,000 improvement in terms of the Council’s position versus budget at P5 versus P4. Improvements were through Adult Social Care & Health and the Assistant Chief Executive directorates. Overall the Council was on-track in terms of Stabilisation Plan savings, and indications suggested that improvement would be seen in period 6 from CYPE and Housing.
Cllr Cummings acknowledged the positivity of the conversation and suggestion by Cllr King - and that the Executive had agreed to adopt the reporting principle.
Cllr Cummings explained the MTFS report contained a significant number of assumptions and forecasts, around macroeconomic factors such as inflation and The Fair funding reforms settlement.
The following people were in attendance at the meeting for this item: - · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Elaine Jackson – Acting Chief Executive · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Stuart Collins – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Annette McPartland – Corporate Director for Adult Social Care & Health · Susmita Sen – Corporate Director for Housing · Venetia Reid-Baptiste – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration and Economic Recovery · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer · Sharon Godman – Director of Transformation · Alan Layton – Head of Transformation · Chris Archibald – Transformation Management Office · Barbara Grant – Programme Manager The item was introduced by the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, who informed the Committee that there had been a slight improvement since the previous period’s report. A forecast underspend of £22.6m was now anticipated, representing an improvement of £800,000 compared to the previous period. This was primarily due to an improvement in the Adult Social Care budget, alongside other smaller changes.
The following people were in attendance at the meeting for this item: - · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Elaine Jackson – Acting Chief Executive · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Stuart Collins – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Annette McPartland – Corporate Director for Adult Social Care & Health · Susmita Sen – Corporate Director for Housing · Venetia Reid-Baptiste – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration and Economic Recovery · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer · Sharon Godman – Director of Transformation · Alan Layton – Head of Transformation · Chris Archibald – Transformation Management Office · Barbara Grant – Programme Manager The item was introduced by the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, who informed the Committee that work continued at pace on the Transformation Programme, and was the backbone of the Council’s savings strategy. It was noted that the year had been challenging in terms of getting up to speed. The introduction of the Stabilisation Plan had led to some delays and a lack of focus, as the Council had limited capacity.
- · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Elaine Jackson – Acting Chief Executive · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Stuart Collins – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Annette McPartland – Corporate Director for Adult Social Care & Health · Susmita Sen – Corporate Director for Housing · Venetia Reid-Baptiste – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration and Economic Recovery · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer · Sharon Godman – Director of Transformation · Alan Layton – Head of Transformation The item was introduced by the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, who informed the Committee that · It was noted that a significant number of variables fed into the Medium-Term Financial Strategy (MTFS).
Councillor Jason Cummings explained that plans were still being developed, and noted that although climate-related work is important, it is not the Council’s most immediate priority given Croydon’s broader ... view the full minutes text for item 31/25
Cllr Cummings responded to the financial performance reporting frequency concern raised, explaining that duplication in reporting was happening due to the timings of Cabinet meetings, and was now being removed.
Cllr Cummings explained that Croydon had historically managed companies poorly. The report detailed where weak areas had been addressed and that company filings were now correctly being undertaken. As detailed in the report, the Parks Charity issue in terms of accessing the Chairty Commission website was now resolved.
Cllr Cummings highlighted that the report was considered at Audit & Governance on the 18 th September 2025, with significant discussion and positive debate – a recording was available online.
The report demonstrated how the Council manages debt, external / internal borrowing and those potential limits and indicators around debt and Cllr Cummings again advised members of the public to read the report - as was the definitive listing of debt related figures and provided the actual picture of what was happening related to debt.
Cllr Cummings advised that the debt and borrowing don’t have the same meaning - the level of borrowing the Council has can vary depending on how treasury management is working i.e., whether good terms for external debts exists, approach to internal debt. Overall debt levels may not increase whilst the structure of borrowing may have changed - the whole report needs to be read to understood the overall picture.
Cllr Cummings said it was pleasing to see positive movement in terms of overall financial position and forecast. £5.3m of improvement is between corporate items and departments. Being £21.8 million under spent was good – however not good enough, as the clear target for the stabilisation plan is to reach £27.3m in savings.
Cllr Cummings wished to highlight that the positive CQC result, along with the Council’s and Directorate’s good financial performance demonstrated that savings and efficiencies could be delivered whilst improving services to residents.
Whilst the offer from Cllr Cummings in terms of providing general updates to Members was welcomed, casual and adhoc updates was not an acceptable replacements to formal updated from Statutory Officers.
The Executive Mayor passed the question to Cllr Cummings adding that it was believed the proposed reporting frequency aligned to the process established under the previous administration.
Cllr Cummings advised that whilst the report was the second reported to Cabinet this financial year, the majority of London Boroughs had received only a single report – noting, another financial monitoring report was also scheduled for the next Cabinet meeting.
Cllr Cummings had understood the extension to be for four years and sought clarification on why this had apparently changed. Allister explained that the two-year extension was proposed by the Independent Chair and confirmed that such a term is compliant—it does not have to be a four-year appointment.
Cllr Cummings highlighted that Paul Dossett from Grant Thornton (External Auditors) had stated at Audit that he considered Croydon’s governance procedures around the audit function to be in the top 25% of councils, which provides reassurance.
Cllr Cummings also commented that it would be unlikely to find someone with both the experience of [name removed] and his knowledge of Croydon’s recent history.
Cllr Cummings supported the extension, while agreeing with Cllr King that more information should have been included in the report and that it should have been presented to the Committee earlier.
Cllr Cummings in response to Cllr Ben-Hassel’s update provided clarity that earlier implementation of the non-pay inflation and allocation compared to previous years was unrelated to the Stabilisation Plan and just reflected improvements in the running of Finance.
Cllr Cummings, state the report was published in August, in accordance with a commitment to publish monitoring reports earlier than the corresponding Cabinet meeting. Whilst Period 3 was being finalised the report will report a further underspend position.
Cllr Cummings advised that many items in the Stabilisation Plan savings table would turn to completed as the year progressed and hoped that a few projects would over-achieve their targets - pursuing further saving where possible and not simply stop once the target was achieved.
Cllr Cummings stated that the £25m was an aspiration not to use the growth. The in-year forecasting for growth did subsequently shows the demand and pressure did exist and was reallocated to ... view the full minutes text for item 61/25
The following people were in attendance at the meeting for this item: - · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer The item was introduced by the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, who provided the following overview:
Councillor Jason Cummings added that the Constitution Working Group had committed to consulting the Chair and considering his views when deciding on changes to the Committee’s remit.
Councillor Cummings stated that there may need to be some consideration in future regarding the point in the electoral cycle that the appointment or extension of the tenure of the Independent Chair was made, as the Appointments & Disciplinary Committee would potentially decide for the next four years ahead of a set of elections.
Councillor Cummings stated that he would raise the question on whether there was a limit on the number of times that someone’s term could be extended at the next Appointments & Disciplinary Committee meeting.
Councillor Cummings welcomed the external auditors’ recognition of Croydon’s governance improvements, noting that past financial failures were rooted in poor governance. He said the external validation should reassure Members, officers, and residents that current financial difficulties were not caused by governance issues.
Councillor Cummings emphasised that while past issues could not be changed, the outcome of the current audit was within the Council’s control. He stressed the political importance of ensuring the accounts were in a position for public scrutiny ahead of key events next year.
Councillor Cummings urged officers and auditors to escalate any risks to meeting the backstop deadline, noting that both he and the Mayor were available for support.
Councillor Cummings stressed the need to leave the Council in the best possible position, regardless of future political changes, and stated that there was strong political and officer commitment to meeting the deadline. The Corporate Director of Resources & Section 151 Officer emphasised the importance of close collaboration between the audit and corporate finance teams, with a rapid escalation process in place. Regular meetings were held with senior leadership, including the Chief Executive, and could be convened at short notice if issues arose.
Cllr Jason Cummings (attending online - and therefore unable to vote), Cllr Leila Ben-Hassel, Annette McPartland, Susmita Sen and Katerine Kerswell.
Cllr Cummings commented that whilst being disappointed with any Council overspends the finances were consistent with those seen in other Councils and Croydon was not an outlier.
Cllr Cummings stated that Croydon’s 2025/26 financial performance monitoring report would be released within 2 weeks – but with no such significant over-spends anticipated. Officers were working hard to control demand, manage costs whilst budget control panels continued to operate in the authority.
Councillor Jason Cummings, the Cabinet Member for Finance, replied that without significant government intervention, the position could not be resolved.
[name removed] expressed concern about the ongoing impact on residents, to which Councillor Cummings agreed, noting that both previous and current governments had declined assistance.
Cllr Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance, stated that the key question was whether the Council could deliver the proposed level of change and savings. It was believed it was achievable and supported the plan but stressed that this was the limit of what could reasonably be delivered within a year.
Cllr Cummings warned that pushing further would be reckless, given the already high level of risk.
Cllr Cummings acknowledged that the report reflected a retrospective view due to the timing of Cabinet meetings. However, it had been published in line with the Council’s approach of releasing financial performance reports ahead of meeting agenda publication dates.
Cllr Cummings noted an improvement in departmental overspend, which had decreased by £1.2 million.
Cllr Cummings confirmed there would be no Period 11 report, and the year-end position would be presented at the July Cabinet meeting. No significant changes or surprises were anticipated in that report.
Cllr Cummings responded that saving trackers relating to transformation programmes were appended to the period monitoring reports, and each of the scrutiny sub-committee had committed to focus on the transformation and stabilisation plan monitoring.
Cllr Cummings advised that many Council’s did not account for growth in demand last year, however, Croydon had now budgeted for the anticipated increases seen last year, similar to other London Councils. Jane West advised that once the first monthly report was approved, it would be published online.
Cllr Cummings in response to Cllr Young’s question, confirmed that the first monitoring report would not be as late as last year, and that points raised regarding more information around the transformation programmes in monitoring reports would be considered and reflected upon.
- · Executive Mayor Jason Perry · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer The item was introduced by the Executive Mayor, Jason Perry, during which it was noted that significant progress had been made in rebuilding the Council. This could be evidenced by external validation, including the recent Ofsted review, the LGA Peer Review, the Social Housing Regulator lifting its regulatory notice, and the forthcoming CQC report.
- · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer The first question from the Committee concerned the likely direction of travel for the year-end budget. It was confirmed that work was underway to prepare the Outturn Report, which would be considered at the next meeting of the Scrutiny & Overview Committee on 22 July 2025. Early indicators were reported to be positive, showing an improvement compared to Period 10.
The following people were in attendance at the meeting for this item: - • Executive Mayor Jason Perry • Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance • Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive • Elaine Jackson – Assistant Chief Executive • Stuart Collins – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education • Nazeya Hussain - Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration & Economic Recovery • Annette McPartland - Corporate Director for Adult Social Care & Health • Susmita Sen - Corporate Director for Housing • Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer • Sharon Godman – Director of Transformation • Alan Layton – Head of Transformation • Carol Squires – Director of Policy, Programmes & Performance • Harry Phinda – Special Projects Lead • Tony McArdle – Chair of the Improvement & Assurance Panel • Brian Roberts – Member of the Improvement & Assurance Panel The item was introduced by the Executive Mayor, Jason Perry, and the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings. During the introduction, it was emphasised that the Council had made significant progress since the election of the Executive Mayor in 2022. Notably, 95% of the Improvement and Assurance Panel’s Exit Strategy had been delivered, including a range
Councillor Jason Cummings was present.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings advised the cost and quality of services were considered alongside social value during contract tender and this policy provided a structured approach to this to ensure the benefits were maximised, ensuring every £ spent on contracts provided maximum social value.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings confirmed the policy would be embedded as stated and would not return to Cabinet to reflect the changes suggested. It was clarified that the data quoted regarding contract values advertised was from one available source and the total value of contracts in Croydon was considerably different. The maximisation of Social Value would be realised via contract performance management and through increasing the visibility of social value to Members, Officers and to the public.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised the overall change between Period 8 and Period 9 was £0.3 million.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings responded that the assertion the figures were unchecked was a dismissal of all the efforts being undertaken to rectify the situation by the council's staff and not reflective of issues within the sector. A significant overspend was not anticipated in the next financial year, based upon the forecasting, however external changes could occur. The Executive Mayor and Cabinet RESOLVED to;
Questions to the Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Jason Cummings extended his sincere appreciation to the Finance Team for their time, effort, and commitment in producing the budget, praising their ... view the full minutes text for item 175/24
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings advised of the key role of Scrutiny in scrutinising the budget setting process and Scrutiny forming a key part of the assurance process. The presence of risk regarding the Council's transformation plans was clarified as being inherent in such projects and while there was risk involved, creating a more efficient Council ... view the full minutes text for item 5/24
Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Cummings added that in response to questions about capacity at Scrutiny and Overview Committee it had been advised that every work stream within the transformation plan included an assessment of the councils internal capacity to deliver. These were supplemented by identification of areas where interdependencies existed, and coordination was required. These requirements were built into the costings included in the report.
£505.8 million Housing Revenue Account (HRA) Capital Programme aimed to improve living conditions and provide affordable housing Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings advised the focus of the programme was to keep borrowing levels under control by securing external grants to fund projects and ensuring activities did not increase borrowing or cost taxpayers more. Only health and safety related projects or ‘invest to save’ options were included ensuring any spending was essential and beneficial. Examples included Zodiac House and the street lighting improvements as these projects would generate net benefits by reducing borrowing costs over time.
Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Jason Cummings responded that it was possible to vary the MRP with approval from the central government. The Council has regular discussions with Ministry for Housing Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) and the capital strategy had been shared. Whilst there had been conversations regarding the treatment of MRP, owing to issues seen at other Council's and the long-term impact of less debt being paid down each year this had not been pursued and there was no variation to the MRP policy.
Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Jason Cummings highlighted section 1.2 of the report which provided a summary of the Council's Treasury Management objectives. Considerations of MRP and the Council's utlisation of reserves were also included. The Council’s Capital Financing Requirement (CFR) and the impact of exceptional financial support were also outlined in the report.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings confirmed the report highlighted a £0.2 million improvement in the General Fund year-end forecast. The main changes were due to increased temporary accommodation costs, particularly for nightly lets, mostly offset by the £3.9 million earmarked reserves use from the Oracle Improvement Programme.
Councillor Cummings advised many Financial Recovery Plan actions were supporting cost mitigations against further rises. For example, presentation rates in Temporary Accommodation and Homelessness where the Council had previously housed 60%, had through improvement actions been reduced to 25%. This had resulted in a £15 million mitigation of costs.
The following people were in attendance at the meeting for this item: - · Executive Mayor Jason Perry · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Stuart Collins – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Elaine Jackson – Assistant Chief Executive · Annette McPartland - Corporate Director for Adult Social Care & Health · Susmita Sen - Corporate Director for Housing · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer · Sharon Godman – Director of Transformation · Carol Squires – Director of Policy, Programmes & Performance · Susie Rundle – Head of Communication & Engagement · Richard Eyre - Head of Improvement · Alan Layton – Interim Transformation Programme · Richard Sargeant & Andy Thomas – Boston Consulting Group · Emily Faldon – Newton · Jamie McMahon – Impower Consulting The budget report was introduced by Executive Mayor Jason Perry and the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings. During the introduction, it was noted that the Council was facing extreme financial pressures, in part due to rising demand and cost escalation, which had resulted in an additional £98m budget shortfall for 2025-26 being identified. This was in addition to the £38m shortfall set out in the Medium-Term Finan
Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Jason Cummings reiterated the partnership arrangements with the NHS to ensure the funding could be correctly secured and to ensure the Council was not exposed to financial risk.
Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Jason Cummings noted their disappointment at the adverse forecast variance of £800,000 and reiterated the source of the financial pressures were in line with those being experienced across the local government sector.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised of the detailed consideration of the financial position within the Council and actions being taken across all departments, for example to reduce homelessness presentations. There was confidence that the Council could manage the position by year end without recourse for additional financial intervention from Government. It was advised that the next meeting with the Government Minister was taking place the following week.
- · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer The item was introduced by the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, during which it was noted that there had been a small negative movement of £800,000 in the General Fund forecast. This was mainly related to an increase in Adult Social Care, linked to demand management, and a small increase in Children, Young People and Education, linked to demand and increased costs, which were being seen across the sector. There had been some mitigation within other departments, which helped to minimise the increase, but the current forecast for the General Fund was an overspend of £18.4m.
- · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Elaine Jackson – Assistant Chief Executive · Dean Shoesmith – Chief People Officer · Denise Bushay – Management Development Programme Participant (Head of Early Years, School Place Planning & Admissions) · Barbara Grant – Staff Networks (Programme Manager) · Andy Griffin – Guardians Programme (Concessionary Travel Team Manager) · Ismael Musoke – Young Persons Network (Service Coordinator) The report was introduced by the Chief People Officer, Dean Shoesmith, who provided a brief overview. It was noted that although Appendix 2 set out a refreshed version of the strategy, it was intended to be incorporated within the wider Future Croydon transformation programme. The introduction was supplemented by feedback from staff members on their experiences with initiatives launched as a result of the strategy, such as the Management Development Programme, Guardians Programme, and engagement with staff networks.
For Member Petition 3 · Councillor Ria Patel would speak for 1 minute · Maysoon Delahunty and Ferial Saadar would speak for 2 minutes. · The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings and the Chair of the Pensions Committee, Councillor Callton Young, would then provide a joint response to both Member Petitions for up to 4 minutes.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, in moving the recommendations in the report emphasised the need for flexibility in borrowing. He noted that economic uncertainties, including a general election, a new government budget, and rising homelessness, had made it essential for the Council to adopt a more adaptable financial approach.
Cllr Cummings questioned why the pay bandings are not simply revised to reflect the market - rather than the Council constantly using supplements and allowances. The Council would ideally just go to market at the right salary to attract the desired quality of candidate – importantly without creating uncertainty in the contractual pay.
Cllr Cummings raised the risk of removing the cap and asked what would stop high rates being agreed. Gillian stated any increase above 20% would be going to CMT and require collective approval (agreement by the Chief People Office in Consultation with CMT). Supplements and allowances related to Director and Corp Director posts would still go to ADC for approval.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised the report detailed a £2.2 million improvement to the forecast variance for year end. This was based on small improvements in the Resources and SCRER directorates and £1.2 million corporately. Demand led pressures were ongoing in Housing, Children's and more recently in Adult Social Care.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings challenged the language of departments being stuck with overspends and advised it was a significant effort for departments to hold the current the overspend position and highlighted the financial recovery plan and actions being taken by departments detailed within the report.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings noted this was a business as usual report and there were no exceptional changes to be highlighted.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised the report had been discussed at Audit and Governance Committee, with no formal changes recommended.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings noted the importance of the interaction between General Fund and HRA borrowing and how potential future purchases were structured. The most efficient positioning would be considered and set out explicitly for the committee when any future opportunities were brought for consideration.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings reiterated that the Capital Strategy and spend was focussed on the maintenance of statutory services and invest to save opportunities. The Council was unable to justify capital expenditure beyond this. Many other local authorities were in a similar position and significantly reducing their capital expenditure.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings suggested the opposition group could support the council's requests for the new government to come forward with assistance for Croydon.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings highlighted the difficulties around tenancy agreements, service provision and relocation. Thanks were extended to all partners involved for their time and patience with the processes. The instruction from government by the Improvement and Assurance Panel had been that Croydon had to do everything possible to deal with its financial difficulties.
In response Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised a progress update on asset disposals could be circulated to members.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings supported the approach to invite management to the Committee, along with the relevant Cabinet Member. It was also suggested that the provision of benchmarking data would provide useful context to the internal audit reporting. Officers agreed to explore this for inclusion in future reporting and noted that owing to the backlog of reports it was anticipated that Croydon would be out of kilter with other local authorities.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings confirmed any investment opportunities would be taken via the appropriate governance processes and reported to Cabinet in the usual manner.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings extended thanks to officers for their efforts and engagement in the improvement work. Transformation was required to meet the Council's financial challenges and the high level of staff engagement was illustrative of the cocreation and buy-in of officers to enable this transformation to take place.
Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Jason Cummings responded stating the Council's transformation programme was ahead of any debt write off negotiations. The council could not control negotiations and Council's the focus was to achieve efficiency and service improvement through the Transformation Programme as its top priority. The prioritisation, interdependencies, resourcing and external support required for the transformation programmes was under careful consideration and there would be a stepped approach to programme roll out.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised of the £800k improvement split between several departments, but also the increased HRA overspend in relation to repairs. The report included an expanded section regarding the in-year recovery plan as previously requested by Scrutiny and Overview Committee.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised the Local Government Finance settlement was expected by 19 December 2024 and along with further detail on the output of the autumn statement, this would enable the Council to make a more accurate forecast of the year end position.
- · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Nick Hibberd – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration & Economic Recovery · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer During the introduction to the report, it was noted that there had been a small improvement in the forecasted overspend position, but there was still a significant shortfall to recover.
Councillor Cummings moved to approve the recommendations and Councillor Denton seconded the motion.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance noted it was positive to see the committee driving performance improvements within the council.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance advised the effective Scrutiny and Audit Committee structures now in place at Croydon had been shared with the other local authorities at a recent LGA training event.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance commended the good work done by the department and advised of a potential national push by government to utilize the increase SEND budget to mitigate the DSG position.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings welcomed Scrutiny and Overview Committee's focussed approach on the key issues facing the council. Cabinet RESOLVED to;
Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Jason Cummings highlighted it was positive to see the inclusion of the Regina Road scheme contract within Appendix A of the report.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings responded that whilst a requirement under the Procurement Act the 18-month pipeline also aligned with fiscal responsibility, efficiency and transparency priorities.
Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Jason Cummings ... view the full minutes text for item 207/24
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings thanked Zawdie Campell for sharing their story and the real impact of the programme.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings noted the £3 million improvement since Period 3, split between £1.3 million of directorate performance improvements and a £2 million corporate adjustment on transformation spend. All previously planned transformation activity was still going ahead. Last year council’s forecasting had typically seen a worsening position as the year went on and therefore it was encouraging to see the improvement to the position in Period 4.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings reiterated confidence in the recovery plans and advised the council was acting as a whole to rectify the position. There remained several variables and more would be known following the government's budget statements such as the impact of any increase to employer NI contributions.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings noted the pan London pressures had been built into the MTFS. Several presumptions were built in and therefore a level of variation was anticipated. The best and worst case scenario planning was detailed at Appendix F of the report and provided an indication of the potential impact of these variables.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised there had been no debt write off impacting the council. A specific figure regarding the income from CAH could not yet be given. The risk management and work to correct accounting for CAH had been significant.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings commented the project was an example of an innovate approach to asset disposal which also improved outcomes for people in Croydon.
In attendance for this item were the following: - Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer Kiri Bailey – Head of Commercial, Housing & Litigation Law During the introduction to the report, the following points were noted: - The overall budget position had improved by £3.3m since the period 3 report, with the forecasted overspend now standing at £20.6m.
In attendance for this item were the following: - Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer Kiri Bailey – Head of Commercial, Housing & Litigation Law A copy of the presentation delivered by the Council’s Section 151 Officer, Jane West, can be found on the following link – https://democracy.croydon.gov.uk/documents/b15010/Agenda%20Supplement%20Item%206%20-%20MTFS%20Update%20Presentation%2014th-Oct-2024%2018.30%20Scrutiny%20Overview%20Commi.pdf?T=9 Following the introduction, the Committee proceeded to question the information provided in the Cabinet report. The first question asked whether there had been any indication from the Government when they would be confirming the 2025-26 financial settlement for local authorities. It was advised that no confirmation had been provided at the time of the meeting, but it was not anticipated that it would be much earlier than the previous Government, which tended to be late in December.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings confirmed the council was forecasting an overspend of £23.9 million at Period 3 due to demand led costs. A whole council approach had been adopted to address the overspend and any additional savings available via the council's transformation work were being explored.
- Executive Mayor Jason Perry Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance Councillor Andy Stranack – Cabinet Member for Communities & Culture Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer Nick Hibberd – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration & Economic Recovery Kristian Aspinall – Director of Culture & Community Safety Stephanie Wilson – Head of Culture, Leisure & Libraries Eric Bohl – Activist Group During the introduction to the report by the Executive Mayor, the following points were noted: - The Libraries Review report presented the results of extensive public consultation, engagement, independent research, and analysis, which aimed to deliver a better library service for residents across the borough.
- Executive Mayor Jason Perry Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer Nick Hibberd – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration & Economic Recovery Beatrice Cingtho-Taylor – Director of Housing, Homelessness Prevention & Accomodation Mary Larbie – Director of Housing Management During the introduction to the report by the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, the Committee was informed that the projected overspend of £23.9m, after the budgeted utilisation of £38m capitalisation directions requested from the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG), utilisation of the £5.0m risk contingency budget and utilisation of £13.0m corporate earmarked reserves, was both disappointing and worrying.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings was pleased to present to Cabinet a Provisional Outturn position which showed balance, even if supported by a £63 million capitalisation direction. Cabinet noted that this showed the approach and level of fiscal discipline that has been undertaken by all departments within the council. Cabinet were advised that there are significant pressures within year and many of those will return this year in an escalated fashion.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings responded explaining that staff vacancies is a normal part of operations in large organisations; when reviewed at the end of the year these contribute to the saving proposals for future years budgets. In regard to reserves and contingencies they are there to be used at a time when they are needed. Cabinet noted that the £15M was borrowed as at the year end position the Lime Green Road site had not completed but did so shortly afterwards.
The Executive Mayor added that in terms of the letter to MHCLG it is an ongoing conversation, and Councillor Jason Cummings confirmed that no deadlines had been missed when replying.
- Executive Mayor Jason Perry Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive Nick Hibberd – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration & Economic Recovery Debbie Jones – Corporate Director for Children, Young People and Education Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer Allister Bannin – Director of Finance and Deputy Section 151 Officer Huw Rhys-Lewis – Interim Director of Commercial Investment & Capital Alan Layton – Interim Oracle Senior Responsible Officer During the introduction to the report, the following points were noted: - Getting the Council’s finances under control remained a priority for the Mayor, with it noted that a balanced budget had been delivered in 2023-24, unlike many other London boroughs which had budget deficits.
In attendance for this item were the following: - · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Nick Hibberd – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration & Economic Recovery · Debbie Jones – Corporate Director for Children, Young People and Education · Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer · Allister Bannin – Director of Finance and Deputy Section 151 Officer · Huw Rhys-Lewis – Interim Director of Commercial Investment & Capital · Alan Layton – Interim Oracle Senior Responsible Officer During the introduction to the report by the Cabinet Member for Finance, the following points were noted:
- Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive Nick Hibberd – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration & Economic Recovery Debbie Jones – Corporate Director for Children, Young People and Education Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources and Section 151 Officer Allister Bannin – Director of Finance and Deputy Section 151 Officer Huw Rhys-Lewis – Interim Director of Commercial Investment & Capital During the introduction to the report by the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, the following points were noted: - It was highlighted that the Council’s General Fund revenue budget for 2023-24 was forecasted to balance, albeit with permission from Government for a £63 million capitalisation direction.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance noted the difficulty in framing the council tax rise and advised the response demonstrated the money had been spent in an efficient way and achieved the task of not cutting back council services further. The comments of Tony McArdle Chair of the council’s Improvement and Assurance Panel within the report were noted as articulating that if it were not for the gap in Croydon’s finances it would be operating as a normal council..
In response to questions from the Committee, Cllr Cummings advised that the council had no plans of raising council tax above the cap in any future year at this time. The £38 million gap in the council’s finances was unsustainable going forward. However if the council could reach an arrangement with national Government to deal with this, it would be operating at the same level and subject to the normal pressures experienced by all councils.
Conservative Group Motion Councillor Jason Cummings, the Cabinet Member for Finance, in opening the debate, noted the well-documented financial history of Croydon and stressed that both parties had historically agreed that Croydon was underfunded. He argued that despite the change in government, there had been no progress on funding, and reaffirmed the need for national government support, given that the scale of the borough's financial problems exceeded local capacity.
Councillor Jason Cummings in closing the debate, reiterated that solving Croydon’s financial problems required government support. he urged for clarity on whether public communications with government should be made more open, as conflicting views had been presented during the debate.
Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings sought confirmation that there is nothing inherently different between the maintained nursery schools in how they are funded it is just due to circumstances ... view the full minutes text for item 170/24
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings noted what brilliant news it is to see this project progressing.
Councillor Cummings did check with legal officers whether it was appropriate for her to Chair the meeting and she had been informed that there was not an issue.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings provided reassurance to Cabinet that in regard to capital slippage in education anything that slipped into the following year remains within the programme. None of the construction items relate to heath and safety so there is no danger to the delays. Clarity was also provided in relation to the offer from S151 officers, this was in direct relation to conversations that take place between the Council and Civil Servants.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that it was very encouraging to see that a slightly better than balanced budget is predicated although there are still opportunities for improvement and pressures to be revealed. Cabinet noted the two significant changes from the previous month;
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings advised that the freehold is contested therefore a projected legal position will ensue, especially when issues relate to the original leases which were not clear when created and the complexities involved with fire safety. In regard to prudence, putting the costs in now is not acceptance of the end position but the correct approach to a perceived risk by this council in terms of any future impact. It is the prudence approach.
In attendance for this item were the following: - Cllr Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance Jane West – Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer Allister Bannin – Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer Debbie Jones – Corporate Director for Children, Young People and Education Susmita Sen – Corporate Director for Housing Mark Billings – Housing Solutions Transformation Lead During the introduction to the report, the following information was noted: - It was confirmed that the budget position as at period 10 (January 2024) continued to forecast an underspend, although this had been reduced from a £1.5m predicted underspend in period 9 to £1.3m.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance advised the report illustrated the council was still on a journey of improvement and noted the importance of the detailed insight provided by the external auditor reporting. The Improvement and Assurance Panel (IAP) had advised that the council was nearly in a position of business as usual, apart from its unsustainable debt burden. Officers advised the external auditor’s reports ensured continued commitment to improvement and culture change within the council.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance advised this was considered unsafe for the council’s services, a position supported by the IAP. Figures would be reassessed each year to ascertain the level of any request from central government and any future solution may include a combination of options such as further savings and debt restructure. It was n oted that the governance of transformation programme presentation (due at the June 2024 meeting) would ... view the full minutes text for item 71/24
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance advised there had been a cultural shift where officers were not fearful to raise issues at the earliest stage. Potential risks were captured on the council’s period monitoring report and were therefore more visible for monitoring and early intervention. The council’s risk champions within directorates had boosted management risk engagement and corporate directors were now seeking assurances which illustrated a culture change.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance commented on the data efficiencies Oracle could provide and the benefits of using an industry standard system for staff. The issues at Birmingham City Council due to its non-standard implementation of Oracle were noted.
The following motion was moved by Councillor Cummings and seconded by Councillor Denton to exclude the press and public:
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings informed Cabinet that the strategy intends to make Croydon the most efficient borough in London and fully expects to see other councils following Croydon’s lead. Further, only a complete transformation of how the council operates will allow the challenges ahead to be met. Steps will be taken to ensure technological advancements will be accessible, simple, easy and convenient to all residents.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings interjected that a significant number of the elements of the Transformation Plan would come through the Cabinet process individually and, as the Executive Mayor has provided a commitment to review it over all suggested elements could be labelled within the agenda to be clearer as to what is being updated.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings added that Croydon must adapt to the number of vehicles that sit in the 90% category. The category for the most polluting vehicles were not changing as those vehicles often belong to those who do not have the financial resources to purchase expensive electric cars. The proposals are an update in line with technological advances focused on those who have the resources.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings , shared with Cabinet that there had been a small improvement in the Council's overall forecast position for year end. The pressures the council are under and indeed all councils in terms of housing costs and children's & adults remain but was pleased to see no new movement within the report which will continue to be monitored as year-end approaches.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings responded that the adult savings were covered extensively at Overview and Scrutiny as part of the Financial Monitoring report. Individual figures based within the reporting pack refer to individual elements of those savings. Around 89% of the overall savings figure is being achieved and takes full account of any potential savings that may not be achieved during the year.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that overall the proposed changes were positive and would help the market in terms of procurement and future contracts which in turn should help the local voluntary sector with visibility whilst also increasing the Council's visibility in terms of what is going forward, and performance; ensuring that those procurements are done correctly and timely.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded that there is not an overall figure for contracts across the council, each department manages their own which is then scrutinised within the budget settings and savings proposals. Once the budget setting process is complete a figure can be put together on how much of the savings relate to contract savings as it would be interesting to see the overall figure.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that the programme was a useful case in point on the council journey. The system was there but not being utilised properly. The intention is to use Oracle correctly with a full implementation used to its full extent which will improve data and consistency.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded that there is not a figure attached to the £3.9 million but it is going to generate savings and those savings will be attributed to the approved efficiency overtime.
Cllr Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance commented on the significance of the completion of the 2019/20 accounts. It was expected to take several years to reach a normal cycle of reporting for the council’s accounts whilst subsequent years were completed. The judgements included in the External Auditor’s report had been anticipated and were not expected to have a significant impact.
Cllr Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance noted the council intended to take an adopt not adapt approach to systems and the lessons learned from Birmingham council were noted. Digital innovation would become a council wide discussion and be clearer as part of the cultural transformation strategy. Croydon was intending to embrace new technology and ways of working.
Cllr Jason Cummings commented that due to the council’s intervention status, attracting and retaining staff was compromised and therefore the delivery of the People and Cultural Transformation Strategy was key in countering recent history. It was felt that the debate regarding senior officer pay reductions at Council had been disappointing. There had been successful recruitment of senior officers and positive feedback from staff about Croydon as a workplace.
During the fifteen minutes of questions to the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings responded that:
Questions to the Cabinet Member for Finance The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, thanked staff in finance and across the Council for their hard work in preparing the budget. He said that coming up with savings to balance the budget. In response to questions, he explained the following:
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that the key momentum was to close Brick by Brick, having reflected that there had been options in managing Brick by Brick with choices to either continue working with Brick by Brick. To close was the right decisions made following the loss made which has now stopped.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded that with regards to recommendation 2.3 and any potential sale, there was opportunity for a party to purchase Brick by Brick, though noted that during the original options submitted, when reviewing market value, a decision was made to continue the build out. This report, however, sought to cover any options that may create exceptional circumstances where the council would have an offer for better value. With regards to recommendation 2.2 and the Housing Revenue Account and general funds, this regarded an assessment of the individual assets that remained by Brick by Brick to be worked through and value assessed for its use.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that there was improvement in every department, which was a great position for the council to be in. The £5 million pound in-year contingency budget was not being used to balance the budget as the council had moved to an underspend position.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded that there was no in-year impact on the £9.439 million pound in terms of the period monitoring report as it related to a prior accounting year. Relating to the COMF money, the service reviewed and assessed when allocation was to be made at a particular point in time. The impact of covid was still ongoing, and thus the continued use of the money within the time it could be spent was still mitigating the impact of covid and was being used for its original intention.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that there has been a significant improvement in governance put in place over the capital programme and the performance which went into the programme. The report highlighted that the council would be incurring a nil borrowing in the financial year of 2023/24 and 2024/25.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, added that the programme had predicted a borrowing of £164.67 million over a period of time should capitalisation carry on for £38 million pounds per year, though the council’s expectation was for this to not happen.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that the council defined its treasury management in line with the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) as the management of the council’s borrowing, investments and cash flows, including its banking, money market, capital market transactions and the effective control of the risks associated with those activities, and the pursuit of optimal performance consistent with those risks. The report highlighted the affordability prudential indicators which published the ratio of debt to net revenue stream of the general fund. This had the ratio of the Capital Financial Requirement (CFR) to the net revenue stream and also the ratio of debt.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, added that there were also existing ongoing training opportunities within the LGA which were also recommended for all Members to take for personal development.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet of the changes within the report in relation to fairness and savings. The council would continue paying council tax to all Croydon care leavers as part of the support package offered, residing inside the borough and outside of borough where they would also have to pay council tax. The previous system also meant that the council had a responsibility to pay for care leavers that came into the borough from other boroughs, and this was a change that the council had made which would add savings and fairness.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings added for clarification that in reviewing the 54 households this was in relation to a change in the automatic exclusion of the 100% council tax relief which did not preclude the use of the normal council tax support system when the financial assessment of the household council taxpayer was taken into account . The council also had a very good council tax support scheme supporting residents. Further, it was fair to review the impact, if any, this may bring in those households following this change.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that this report highlighted an update on the progress and clarity in the current position with Croydon companies. This covered the Croydon affordable homes and related companies and others that still existed. Progress was moving forward in terms of simplification and reduction agenda, though there were some delays in relation to the LLPs and which was still progressing.
· Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Nick Hibberd – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Economic Recovery & Regeneration · Debbie Jones – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Susmita Sen – Corporate Director for Housing · Jane West - Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer, · Simon Robson –Director for Adult Social Care Operations · Allister Bannin - Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer · David Courcoux - Director for Policy, Programmes & Performance · Helen Reeves – Interim Head of Strategy & Policy During the introduction to the report, the following points were noted: - The budget position at the end of Period 8 (November 2023) was predicting there would be a budget underspend at the year end, with all departmental budgets improving in comparison to the Period 7 forecast.
· Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Nick Hibberd – Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Economic Recovery & Regeneration · Debbie Jones – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Susmita Sen – Corporate Director for Housing · Jane West - Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer, · Simon Robson –Director for Adult Social Care Operations · Allister Bannin - Director of Finance & Deputy Section 151 Officer · David Courcoux - Director for Policy, Programmes & Performance · Helen Reeves – Interim Head of Strategy & Policy During the introduction to the report by the Cabinet Member and the Section 151 Officer, the following points were noted: - The Council was in a position of being able to put forward a balanced budget for 2024-25, which was not the case for all local authorities.
Councillor Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance commented on the frustration around the issues which had arisen and caused further delays and reminded the committee it could hold to the external auditors to account.
Councillor Cummings commented that the scale of recommendations and actions included within the AGS were far larger than a council in normal position and there was work to be done to return to an acceptable level of monitoring and to ensure the council was not too backward looking.
Councillor Cummings advised parking income had become a high-profile item for the council due to the large variance in the 2022/23 budget due to budgeting failures rather than the operation of the department. This position had improved and 2023/34 performance aligned with the budget. It was agreed the risk register entry required rewording.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, highlighted a point for clarification, that the council’s debt levels were not increasing, noting that the council did not expect to undertake any external borrowing which included next year as predicted within the forecasts, though it remained factual that should the council not reach its financial position in the future, the council would have to return to a position of borrowing.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, added that by being upfront, transparent, and honest with the residents of Croydon about the issues the council faced and its challenges and what it meant for residents such as council tax increase, changes within services, and recently the Regina Road redevelopment had provided assurance to residents in rebuilding trust.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, added that this may also be of interest to the Scrutiny and Overview Committee as they would also be part of the consultation.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that the service was predicting a yearend balance position which was positive, and noted that every department that had predicted a change in their position, saw a positive change with a number of departments predicting a yearend underspend position. Further, the potential impact on the contingency plan had significantly reduced to £1.5 million pounds, with the continued aim to be reduced.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded on the transformation programme addressing that the financial challenges this council was facing could have short-term decisions and changes in service provision, and for long-term transformation for the scale of savings of this council was essential to commence as early as possible, highlighting that the council would experience financial challenges for years to come as addressed within the MTFS reports.
The following motion was proposed by Councillor Hale, seconded by Councillor Cummings and agreed by the Committee to exclude the press and public for the remainder of the meeting.
It was MOVED by Councillor Denton and SECONDED by Councillor Degrads and RESOLVED, to appoint Councillor Cummings as Chair of the meeting.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, Section 151 Officer, Jane West, Director of Finance, Allister Bannin and Head of Strategic Procurement, Scott Funnell were in attendance for this item at the meeting.
A copy of the presentation delivered can be found on the following link: - https://democracy.croydon.gov.uk/documents/s53260/2024-25%20Budget%20Setting%20Update%20-%20Presentation.pdf The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, Section 151 Officer, Jane West, Director of Finance, Allister Bannin and Head of Strategic Procurement, Scott Funnell were in attendance for this item at the meeting.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, Section 151 Officer, Jane West and Head of Strategic Procurement, Scott Funnell were in attendance at the meeting for this item.
In response to the supplementary question, the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, advised that he could not say much due to confidentiality but assured the questioner that due diligence was being undertaken on the project and stated that he would be willing to discuss further once the deal was concluded, negating the need for confidentiality as the information would be in the public domain.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings shared with Cabinet that the report was another overall forecast yearend balance position, highlighting that the HRA remained at the £12 million pounds overspend position as previously reported.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings , responded that the use of the economic demand reserve was used purposely for such pressures as it was impossible to predict anything that would happen in each department over the course of the year. The emergency accommodation was particularly impacted due to the asylum-seeking support where there were over 1000 cases which was producing an in-year pressure. The use of the reserve would be for these very reasons.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that the report was a standard update which was restored in the correct place within the annual schedule of financial papers. There were different rules and procedures applied across the list which related to inflation changes, legislation, cost recovery limits, subsidiaries and statutory prices which would affect many of the proposed charges. Further details were addressed within Appendix A of the report.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings responded that the changes in some of the prices related to a number of requirements where some related directly to inflation and others related to cost of service provision which vary from sector to sector. It was noted that the fees and charges report related to service provision. The Corporate Director for Adults Social Care & Health (DASS & Calidcott Guardian) Annette McPartland, added that in the adult and social care package, people were means tested on their ability to pay, though costs had increased in line with inflation, it was also in line with the costs of the care provided.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, in summary shared with Cabinet that the paper detailed the current forecast capital spending borrowing for the council, where debt and its associated costs were significant financial considerations in relation to the council’s sustainability, and therefore it was imperative that the council did all they could to manage capital spend. The forecast still resulted in an increase of the general fund debt due to the continuing need for capitalisation directions, which highlighted the ongoing unsustainable impact of capitalisation as a means of bridging the revenue gap for this council. However, the council had continued to bear down on capital expenditure, and the regular review of all capital expenses and slippage were ongoing.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, informed Cabinet that point 4.3 of the report should state: “For this quarterly update, there are 11 additions and 5 amendments to planned procurements with 6 additions and 3 amendment to contracts extensions and variations.” The Shadow Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Callton Young asked a question on whether it was agreed that the ongoing work by the Constitution Working Group and the General Purposes Committee, where recent revelations had shown that the contracts and procurement work had been snarled up by failure to delegate decision-making appropriately.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet that the report was the second of the three tranche assets, which formed a key part of managing the council’s debt levels and associated costs.
Councillor Jason Cummings was pleased with the progress made thus far and noted that the council needed to continue to with the work to ensure that the forward capital receipt targets were met.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded that with regards to the timescales for tranche 3, the intention was to complete them as quickly as possible due to the impact of reducing external affairs and borrowing and costs that were associated. Though the council had capacity to undertake this work. There was no set time for tranche 3 to be published, but it would be at its reasonable and earliest opportunity.
Councillor Cummings advised the RIPI recommendation from which the appointment of an Independent Chair has stemmed, had been to appoint a Chair who was not from the majority political group, however it had been a Council decision to appoint a completely Independent Chair. Officers agreed to provide a table within the Assurance Mapping Document with the frequency of reports received by the Committee. The Committee RESOLVED to;
Councillor Cummings noted the wider discussion on the backlog of financial accounts in the Local Government sector. The Committee heard that as a council with intervention, it was not Croydon’s intention to partake in any expedited process. The decision to complete all accounts in full had been taken to ensure clarity and understanding and the council intended to complete audited accounts for all outstanding years.
Cllr Cummings advised the Committee that whilst Croydon was balancing its budget with capitalisation direction, it was not meeting VFM and would not be able to do so until further arrangements were agreed with central government.
Councillor Cummings commented on the lessons learned from the historically insular approach within Croydon and advised of the council’s intention to integrate external challenge and benchmarking through the utilisation of initiatives such as LGA corporate peer reviews.
- · Tony McArdle - Chair of the Improvement & Assurance Panel · Brian Roberts – Improvement & Assurance Panel Member · Jason Perry - Executive Mayor of Croydon · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Debbie Jones – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Annette McPartland – Corporate Director for Adult Social Care & Health · Jane West - Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer, · Elaine Jackson - Assistant Chief Executive · Allister Bannin - Director of Finance · Huw Rhys Lewis – Interim Director for Commercial Investment & Capital The Chair of the Improvement & Assurance Panel, Tony McArdle introduced the Exit Strategy, during which the following points were noted: - It was within the remit of the Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities to determine how long the Improvement & Assurance Panel would remain at the Council, with the end date currently set for July 2025.
The following people were in attendance at the meeting to answer questions during the discussion of this item: - · Jason Perry - Executive Mayor of Croydon · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Debbie Jones – Corporate Director for Children, Young People & Education · Annette McPartland – Corporate Director for Adult Social Care & Health · Jane West - Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer, · Elaine Jackson - Assistant Chief Executive · Allister Bannin - Director of Finance · Huw Rhys-Lewis – Interim Director of Commercial Investment & Capital During the introduction to the report, the following points were noted: - The General Fund budget was still forecasting a balanced year end position, which given the current climate for local government finance, was evidence of the Council’s improved financial discipline. Other similar councils, such as Havering and Barnet were predicting £20m overspends in the current year.
The following people were in attendance at the meeting to answer questions during the discussion of this item: - · Jason Perry - Executive Mayor of Croydon · Councillor Jason Cummings – Cabinet Member for Finance · Katherine Kerswell – Chief Executive · Jane West - Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer, · Elaine Jackson - Assistant Chief Executive · Huw Rhys-Lewis – Interim Director of Commercial Investment & Capital During the introduction to the report, the following points were noted: - The report presented the second tranche of assets targeted for disposal. As the asset disposal process progressed, it was recognised that the process would become more complex as the easier disposals had been targeted in the first tranche.
Both the Executive Mayor and the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, extended an apology to the tenants who had not been contacted before the list of assets was made public. The Council would work with existing tenants around their leases, ... view the full minutes text for item 80/23
The following motion was proposed by Councillor Hale, seconded by Councillor Cummings and agreed by the Committee to exclude the press and public for the remainder of the meeting.
The following motion was proposed by Councillor Hale, seconded by Councillor Cummings and agreed by the Committee to exclude the press and public for the remainder of the meeting.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, acknowledged the position the council was in financially and added that though support was required from central government, efforts should not be taken away from the staff to upkeep the work they had put in.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared that the Finance department welcomed the plan proposed for the council to retain position of financial stability and sustainability.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, addressed that the budget was being managed at a local level and thanked officers across the council for their collaborative work in savings.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, added that though the children and adult departments continued to overspend, this was robustly under review.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded that no direct analysis had been made to the new risk, and the indirect risk was closely monitored, at present there was no impact on council services.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared the progress of three key performance indicators relating to finances.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, addressed Cabinet that the measure was temporary and the failure to return to the normal recovery process had created a £3.6 million pound deficit which was currently sitting in the council’s books. It was noted that this was not a new approach, and the support system was already adjusted to consider those struggling to pay. Thus, recommencing this process would mean to inform effected residents of their position of their council tax account.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, informed that it was the responsibility of every person to pay the council tax they were accountable for. This would go through the normal arrears process.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, Chief Executive, Katherine Kerswell, Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer, Jane West, Director of Finance, Allister Bannin, Assistant Chief Executive, Elaine Jackson and Corporate Directors Nick Hibberd, Debbie Jones, Annette McPartland, Susmita Sen, Interim Chief Digital Officer & Director of Resident Access, Paul Golland, Head of Resident Contact, Lisa Wheatley and Complaints Manager, Kim Hyland were in attendance for this item at the meeting.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, Chief Executive, Katherine Kerswell, Corporate Director for Sustainable Communities, Regeneration and Economic Recovery, Nick Hibberd and Interim Director of Commercial Investment & Capital, Huw Rhys-Lewis were in attendance for this item at the meeting.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance noted the complexity of Croydon’s Annual Governance Statement (AGS) in comparison with other Local Authorities. The scale of actions from external reports incorporated in the AGS Action Plan reflected the historical issues in Croydon. There had however been significant improvements to the council’s governance arrangements, these were acknowledged in the Improvement and Assurance Panel (IAP) Exit Strategy report.
Cllr Cummings commented that the process of capturing all the improvement actions together provided assurance that nothing would be missed.
Cllr Cummings noted the improvements which had been made, and the expected further improvements once the project was completed.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, the Director for Commercial Investment and Capital, Huw Rhys-Lewis and the Deputy Monitoring Officer, Looqman Desai were in attendance at the meeting for this item.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded to the point raised noting that the council was not in a position to be operating in a faster and more comprehensive financial procedures in relation to the Period Monitoring Report, and was working towards efficient working using standard operating procedures with the resources available. It was further noted that due to the council’s financial position, reports were provided monthly, and published at the earliest possible opportunity. Secondly, it was to be noted that the hardship fund was specifically targeted following the council tax raise that was above the referendum level last year and should not be mistaken as a general hardship fund for the cost ... view the full minutes text for item 46/23
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, addressed Cabinet informing that the update covered a number of areas including key activities already delivered and plans for future development and delivery.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings added that the co-design requires for co-delivery, and careful monitoring would be reviewed to measure the equalities impact going forward. There was a significant journey the council was to take.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, addressed Cabinet that there had been no change for the balance position overall.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, added that the potential risks relating to vacancy levels across council was varied between departments and regular communications were held in relation to this. Further, the spending of placement costs was under intense review which related to the necessary spend for extremely vulnerable individuals and complex circumstances, and the council always sought to find the best value and reviewed provision to ensure appropriateness. In relation to the staffing overspend, this was currently under review to be reflected in future reports.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, added that the Plan B consideration was incorrect, and the data held within the MTFS was based on forecast of a deal not received from central government, and predicted the use of capitalisation directed each year to meet the gap which was not sustainable long term. The Plan A consideration focused on the long-term stability of the council and planning for the position tabled to control.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, addressed Cabinet that this report formed part of the adopted reporting process for procurement. Changes made to the procurement plan were detailed by contract within Appendix A of the report.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded that there was robust challenge method for delays. The report was a living document intended to highlight and be transparent of the current position and opportunities for current bidders. Regarding resource, the benchmarking data shows that the council was fully resourced and does not lack staff within the procurement function.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, addressed Cabinet that the report was recommending investment to develop the detailed implementation plan, to significantly improve operation across the council.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded that he had yet to consult with external auditors and would act on the recommendation.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, addressed Cabinet that the report seeks to formulise arrangements between the council and the LLP companies and covers off the delegations needed to make the amendments. Further, there were no material financial affect from this.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, clarified on the Period 2 financial report that the departmental £3.8 million pounds overspend was balanced by the use of contingency which was a normal process within the council, and the year-end position forecasted would address balance and not overspend. The update of the council tax support was noted to be shockingly low. The update was not measured as a high or low take up, though the take up only occurred after the £33 million pound worth of council tax support that was already given out in the earlier stages.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, informed that to be in a position of Period 2 where we are predicting a year end balance was welcomed and hoped for continuation of this throughout the year. The report highlighted departmental overspend which was mainly demand-led in particularly to do with placemen costs and the total year end position that generate sat within the £5 million contingency in the budget so it would not result in the year end overspend. It was noted that there was intention for all departmental budgets be helped through the course of the year with overspend pulled back in individual departments.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, added his confidence in the council’s departmental ability to deliver savings targets, in particularly within the adult’s social care department. Demand pressure sat outside of the ability for the council to control, and as such a need for service would be required which costs were being managed.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, informed that the Period 1 financial report did not provide any accuracy in figures which was reliable to make predictions and thus it was better for reports to start at Period 2. The Director of Finance, Allister Bannin , shared with Cabinet the reason for the change in format within the report, highlighting that it was best for the quantifiable and non-quantifiable risks to be added within each directorate forecast to include in the narrative to review their position that included the risks and how it was being dealt with, and not hidden within the appendices.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet of the progress made which was significant as the number of outstanding issues minimised. There were a lot of detail within the report relating to sites and the progress of its current position. Further, the long-term implications relating to leaseholders, shared ownership, and other circumstances relating to the current tenants were to be cleared and clarified.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded to the comments and noted that the progress had fit in with the financial projections in the MTFS with no delay with receipt of money or risks to the financial forecast made.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, shared with Cabinet of the opportunity for ongoing savings and ability to receive capital receipting via brick by brick. With the complications, there were no set up of separate companies, this was a more standard set up to produce a good end result for council and residents in temporary accommodation to being more suitable permanent homes.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, Chief Executive, Katherine Kerswell, Corporate Director for Resources, Jane West, and Director of Finance, Allister Bannin were in attendance for this item at the meeting.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance commented on the significance of these accounts being brought to the Committee and expected this set would be the most difficult to complete retrospectively. He thanked finance colleagues and the external auditors for their work to reach this position of agreement. The need for thorough and early understanding of how financial decisions would be accounted for in the future had been the biggest lesson learned.
Councillor Jason Cummings commented that this was indication of the improvements being made within finance and the need for specific resourcing to support historic pieces of work. There had been conversations about the long-term structure of the finance team, and this would be reflected in the budget setting and Medium Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) going forward.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, stated that the increase in Council Tax was never intended to be spent on services; instead it was increased to emsure the council had sufficient funds to protect it from future financial difficulties.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, responded to the monitoring reports that through scrutiny, the understandability of the reports was to be addressed through the members and development route; additionally, the arbitrary eight-week request was difficult to maintain as the monitoring reports itself were produced based on the timeline where resources and information were available, then published in the public domain imminently upon completion for transparency.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings informed Cabinet that this report was different from the normal period monitoring report due to the short period into the year, additionally with the service closing accounts of the previous financial year, the early assessment of prediction for the year ahead with the small amount of data would be inaccurate. Period Two monitoring reports would see a return to the standard report with all information it would entail. All settings of the council financial position were included within the report including potential pressures that would arise from council specific circumstances.
Cabinet Member of Finance Councillor Jason Cummings added that transformation was a key area within the council which included significant changes for a long-term transformation. The projects applied for the funding were assessed for viability, potential savings and service improvements it may produce. Additionally, there were two pots of funds which related to transformation: a revenue of £10m pounds; and a £4m pounds capital budget which related to activities that generated physical assets as part of the transformation.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings informed Cabinet that as part of the new approach to the annual procurement plan there would be quarterly updates. In this quarter there were fourteen additions to the plan detailed within the appendix.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings shared with Cabinet that the period monitoring reports would be published following the MAB process before Cabinet and noted that Period 11 Monitoring Report went to Scrutiny prior to being heard at Cabinet.
With regards to the Asset Disposals, Councillor Cummings corrected his commitment to ... view the full minutes text for item 4/23
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings, addressed the Cabinet and stated that the housing revenue account was in line with expectation. In terms of the capital programme there was a significant gap with the current actual and forecast overspend due to the capitalisation directions which had not been applied and an underspend of £20.4 million pounds which was to be reviewed.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Cummings reinforced that that disposal value was a minimal of £50 million pounds and it was the expectation and target to overachieve against that figure. The more the council could bring in terms of assets receipt would better the model.
The Cabinet Member of Finance, Councillor Cummings informed Cabinet that Croydon had a significant number of companies that was operating, though the service were reducing the number of companies involved. The Head of Finance, Allister Bannin, referred Cabinet to the appendix which highlighted the property management companies and noted that Croydon owned come residences as a leaseholder. A representative for Croydon would attend annual meetings in relation to those properties to discuss freeholders doing improvements of repairs to roof, external walls, and windows of the whole block.
The Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, and members of the Corporate Management Team were in attendance at the meeting for this item.
Councillor Cummings noted his disappointment at the reception the report had received at Full Council and advised of the need for the organisation to accept external reporting and recommendations.
Cllr Cummings advised the monthly budget monitoring reports were previously required to go through the Mayor’s Advisory Board and Cabinet prior to Scrutiny. This process had been changed, reports were now available publicly and to all Committees following the Mayor’s Advisory Board meetings. The Committee noted it was important for the Council not to rely on External Auditors to highlight processes which undermined openness and transparency.
Cllr Cummings commented it now seemed the Council was at the end of uncovering new issues and expected to see progression of improvements over the coming year.
Cllr Cummings offered to meet with Committee members to explain the relationship and issues regarding the treatment of CAH and CAT in the Council’s accounts.
Cllr Cummings noted the large scale of the improvement actions required, that improvements would need to be made sustainability, and that it would likely take years to complete.
Councillor Cummings noted the delayed impact of external factors such as energy pricing in contract renewal and re-procurement following the end of fixed cost plans.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Cabinet Member for Finance, responded that a full investigation into how Brick by Brick was set up and managed had been undertaken, and that the council was in the process of winding down the company and seeking to minimise costs to taxpayers. Another investigation into the situation with Fairfield Halls, the Kroll Report, had also taken place, and that dramatic changes to governance arrangements had been made as a result.
Councillor Cummings assured Council that processes were being put in place to ensure that these things never happened again.
A supplementary question around the criteria for the membership of the Cabinet board was posed, to which Councillor Cummings explained the membership would be based on the positions people held within the council and would be made up of elected members and officers.
Councillor Jason Cummings presented the report to Council and introduced Paul Dossett from Grant Thornton, the council’s external auditor, to answer members’ questions on the Section 24 Notice that had been published on the council’s website.
Councillor Jason Cummings summed up the debate stating that the external auditor’s recommendations had been issued in response to serious issues and that they should be accepted by Council.
Councillor Cummings argued that it was a good opportunity to update Grant Thornton’s advice based on additional historic issues uncovered this year.
Councillor Jason Cummings, on behalf of the Administration, argued that the recent direction from the Assurance and Improvement Panel was disappointing but reasonable given the level of support required from Central Government to set a balanced budget.
Councillor J Cummings also stated that collaboration had improved on previous years and that he pledged to continue to do cross-party engagement to improve outcomes.
In providing an introduction, the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings, highlighted that the challenging financial position of the Council was well know, as was the request made to the Government for additional support in becoming financially sustainable, which included writing off part of the Council’s debt. Although the situation in Croydon was challenging, when compared to comments made on Slough and Thurrock Councils in the letter from Government, those made on the progress achieved by the Council were the most positive and reflective of the movement over the past three years.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer, Jane West and Catherine Black, Head of Payments, Revenues & Benefits and Debt attended the meeting for this item.
Councillor Jason Cummings, Chief Executive, and Corporate Director for Resources & Section 151 Officer, Jane West attended the meeting for this item.
During the fifteen minutes of questions to the Cabinet Member for Finance, Councillor Jason Cummings responded that:
Councillor Jason Cummings explained that, even if the Conservative group voted in favour of the amendment the Green group had made it clear that they did not support the Executive’s budget proposals, and so they could not support the amendment, even though they were happy to work collaboratively on these issues going forwards.
Showing the latest 300 of 362.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Cummings attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 Apr 2026 | Council | Appointment of Honorary Recorder | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Croydon Pay Policy Statement 2026-27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Members’ Scheme of Allowances 2026/27 | Carried | 64 for, 3 against | |
| 10 Dec 2025 | Council | Appointment of the Interim Chief Executive | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2025 | Council | Proposed Changes to the Constitution - Tender and Contract Regulations (TCRs) Refresh | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Jul 2025 | Council | Council Debate Motions | Carried | 34 for, 0 against, 33 abstained | |
| 16 Apr 2025 | Council | Council Debate Motions | Lost | 31 for, 32 against | |
| 28 Feb 2024 | Council | Scheme of Members' Allowances | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2024 | Appointments & Disciplinary Committee | Outcome of the Hazel Simmonds Employment Tribunal Case | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Jul 2023 | Council | Council Debate Motions | Lost | 31 for, 35 against | |
| 8 Mar 2023 | Council | Council Tax and Budget 2023-24 | Carried | 35 for, 34 against | |
| 1 Feb 2023 | Council | Recommendations deferred for Debate | Lost | 34 for, 35 against | |
| 1 Feb 2023 | Council | Council Debate Motions | Lost | 34 for, 35 against | |
| 14 Dec 2022 | Council | Disclosure of Interests | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 14 Dec 2022 | Council | Recommendations from the Executive or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | 30 for, 29 against | |
| 25 Jul 2022 | Council | Council Debate Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 May 2022 | Council | Election of Civic Mayor (Chair of Council) 2022/2023 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 May 2022 | Council | Election of Deputy-Civic Mayor (Vice-Chair of Council) 2022/23 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 May 2022 | Council | Political Balance of Council and Composition of Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 May 2022 | Council | Appointments | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 May 2022 | Council | Members' Scheme of Allowances | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 23 Mar 2022 | Council | Council Debate Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 31 Jan 2022 | Council | Appointment of Corporate Director of Resources and Chief Finance Officer (S151) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 31 Jan 2022 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 31 Jan 2022 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Dec 2021 | Council | Health & Wellbeing Board Annual Report | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Dec 2021 | Council | Director of Public Health Report 2020/21 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Dec 2021 | Council | Polling Places and Polling Districts | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Dec 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Oct 2021 | Council | Appointments of Interim Statutory Chief Officers | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Oct 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision- Part One | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 11 Oct 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision- Part Two | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 16 Sep 2021 | General Purposes & Audit Committee | Production of Formal Minutes for Council and Committee Meetings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Mar 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Mar 2021 | Council | Scheme of Members' Allowances 2021-22 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Mar 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Mar 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Mar 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 8 Mar 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Jan 2021 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Oct 2020 | Council | Governance Review implementation progress update | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 12 Oct 2020 | Council | Recommendation of the Appointments Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 28 Sep 2020 | Council | Arrangements for the Appointment to Interim Head of Paid Service | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Jul 2020 | Council | The use of Special Urgency for Key Decisions 2019 - 20 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Jul 2020 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Jul 2020 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 13 Jul 2020 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Jul 2020 | Council | Political Balance of the Council and Composition of Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Jul 2020 | Council | Appointments and Remote Attendance at Council Meetings | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 6 Jul 2020 | Council | Resolution to Extend 6 Month Rule | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Jan 2020 | Council | Polling District and Polling Place Review | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Jan 2020 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Jan 2020 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Jan 2020 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committees to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 7 Oct 2019 | Council | Council Debate Motions | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 May 2019 | Council | Admission of Honorary Aldermen and Alderwomen | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 May 2019 | Council | Political Balance of the Council and Composition of Committees | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 20 May 2019 | Council | Appointments | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 4 Sep 2018 | Scrutiny & Overview Committee | Call-In : Acquisition of the Freehold interest in the Croydon Park Hotel as a commercial investment | Carried | 3 for, 2 against | |
| 23 May 2018 | Council | Election of the Mayor | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2018 | Council | Announcements | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 26 Mar 2018 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committee referred to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2018 | Council | Council Tax and Budget | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Feb 2018 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committee referred to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2018 | Council | Urgent Business (if any) | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2018 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committee referred to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2018 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committee referred to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2018 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committee referred to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 29 Jan 2018 | Council | Polling Districts and Polling Places Review | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 30 Oct 2017 | Council | Recommendations of Cabinet or Committee referred to Council for decision | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Cummings was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 22 of 32 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Cummings declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Cummings in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Cummings sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cabinet | Committee Member | Jun 2017 | 101 | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | May 2017 | 79 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Appointments & Disciplinary Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 65 | |
| Civic Mayoralty & Honorary Freedom Selection Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2023 | 5 | |
| Council Tax Setting Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2026 | 1 | |
| Scrutiny & Overview Committee | Guest | Sep 2018 | 16 | |
| Appointments Committee | Committee Member | Mar 2020 | 9 | |
| General Purposes & Audit Committee | Reserve | May 2017 | 6 | |
| General Purposes & Audit Committee - Mayoralty & Honorary Freedom Selection Sub-Committee | Committee Member | Dec 2017 | 4 | |
| South London Waste Partnership Joint Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2022 | 2 | |
| Planning Sub-Committee | Guest | Dec 2020 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.