Six-Monthly Performance Report Deep Dives
Cllr Anderson took the reports as read and was happy to take questions.
Every time Dacorum's minutes name Councillor Anderson, as the council published it.
Cllr Anderson took the reports as read and was happy to take questions.
Councillor Anderson referred to the naming of the new unitary authorities and noted that a previous request to remove "North" from the proposed authority name appeared to have been accepted.
6.2 The Mayor invited Cllr Anderson to introduce his motion.
Cllr Anderson read and proposed his motion:
6.3 The Mayor invited Cllr Anderson to introduce his motion.
Cllr Anderson was happy to vote on amending the motion.
The Mayor closed the debate and asked Cllr Anderson to sum up the motion prior to the vote.
Cllr Anderson proposed and seconded by Cllr A Williams that Cllr Alan Johnson be nominated.
Questions were posed by Cllr Anderson 5.6 The Mayor introduced the People & Transformation portfolio and invited any questions to be addressed to Cllr Smith-Wright regarding her update.
The Motion was introduced by Cllr Anderson who explained that he was reading an amended motion agreed with Adrian England.
8.2 Cllr Symington introduced CA/35/26 Committee Timetable Cllr Allen Seconded the referral and Council agreed Cllr Anderson requested printed copies for members.
Councillor Anderson substituted on behalf of Councillor Wyatt-Lowe and Councillor Smith-Wright substituted on behalf of Councillor Symington.
The Case Officer, James Gardner, introduced the report to Members and said that the application had been referred to the Committee due to the application constitutes as a large-scale major development and is linked to a proposed planning obligation under s.106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Maddern to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Hobson and seconded by Councillor Anderson to REFUSED the Application.
It was proposed by Councillor Hobson and seconded by Councillor Anderson to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Guest and seconded by Councillor Anderson to GRANT the application.
Ward Councillor Alan Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
Councillor Anderson substituted for Councillor Elliot.
Councillor Anderson substituted for Councillor Walker and Councillor Silwal substituted for Councillor Mitchell.
It was proposed by Councillor Guest and seconded by Councillor Anderson to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Hobson to GRANT the application.
Councillor Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
Councillor Anderson substituted on behalf of Councillor Durrant and Councillor Barradell Substituted on behalf of Councillor Wyatt-Lowe.
It was proposed by Councillor Maddern and seconded by Councillor Anderson to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Guest and seconded by Councillor Anderson to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
4 6 1 Having there been no majority to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL the application, it was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Guest to REFUSE the application on for three reasons:
It was then proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Guest to REFUSE the application on the first reason only.
Standen was invited to speak to the committee, and then Councillor Anderson spoke on behalf of those Councillors that called in the decision; Councillor Douris, Councillor Elliot, Councillor Banks and Councillor Johnson.
Standen and Councillor Anderson.
Councillor Silwal substituted on behalf of Councillor Mitchell and Councillor Anderson substituted on behalf of Councillor Riddick.
24/01239/MFA Change of use from agricultural land to Suitable Alternative Natural Green Space (SANG), together with a vehicular access, car park, paths, fencing and landscaping Land at Nettleden Road, Potten End, Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire Councillor Anderson declared an interest in the item, he confirmed that he will take no part in the discussion or voting.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Hobson to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Patterson and seconded by Councillor Anderson to GRANT the application.
It was proposed by Councillor Guest and seconded by Councillor Anderson to GRANT the application.
Cllr Banks confirmed that in light of the time passed since this was originally submitted, it is apparent that Council officers have worked tirelessly to engage with residents and has asked for her thanks to be passed on to all those concerned Decision The withdrawal of the motion was seconded by Cllr Anderson and agreed.
Councillor Anderson substituted for Councillor Guest and Councillor Douris Substituted for Councillor Wyatt-Lowe.
It was proposed by Councillor Maddern and seconded by Councillor Anderson to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Maddern to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Hobson to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Hobson to GRANT the application.
Cllr Anderson referred to the parking charges consultation which is ongoing and asked; with respect particularly to his ward in Kings Langley where it is being proposed to introduce changes for the first time, not having been any before, what professional evidence did the PH use to base her decision to introduce charges in a location where there is not a demand for people to use the parking, where they will alternatively go down the road and park somewhere that they do not need to pay at all Action: Cllr Capozzi advised that as there are multiple elements to that question, a written ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Anderson substituted for Councillor Durrant.
4 6 1 Having there been no majority to grant the application it was proposed by Councillor Guest and seconded by Councillor Anderson to overturn the officer’s recommendation and REFUSE the application.
23/02805/FUL Proposed Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Station and Cafe Land opposite The Eagle Public House, Hempstead Road, Kings Langley Councillor Anderson declared an interest in item 5b and was speaking against the item. He declared that he would not participate in the discussion or the voting.
Ward Councillor Alan Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
Councillor Anderson will be substituting for Councillor Durrant and Councillor A Williams will be substituting for Councillor Walker.
Cllr Anderson proposed two additional Informatives :
It was proposed by Councillor Riddick and seconded by Councillor Anderson to DELEGATE WITH A VIEW TO APPROVAL (with the two additional Informatives ) Vote:
Cllr Anderson proposed an additional Informative:
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Guest to DELEGATE with a view to APPROVAL, (with the additional Informative) Vote:
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Patterson to GRANT the application.
It was proposed by Councillor Guest and seconded by Councillor Anderson to GRANT the application.
Ward Councillor Alan Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
The Case Officer, Nigel Gibbs, introduced the report to Members and said that the application had been referred to the Committee as it was called in by Councillor Alan Anderson, as well as the recommendation being contrary views of Kings Langley Parish Council’s objections (before noting details of 18.07.2023) Councillor Allan Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
Cllr Anderson commented that affordable housing is housing that is available socially for rent and low-cost market housing is now very rare. There is a government policy regarding starter homes, though current uptake is low across the country.
Cllr Anderson advised that the term 'social housing' has been deemed as insensitive.
Cllr Anderson requested the Herts prosperity fund and the release of CIL funds go to the June Cabinet.
Cllr Anderson asked what the plans were for member’s computers after the election.
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report as published. He praised the officers for the mount of work that gat the council to this point.
5.1 Motion One Cllr Anderson proposed the first motion that was seconded by Cllr England.
Cllr Anderson noted that he had been informed that an amendment may be proposed and advised that he would move the main motion though would not accept the amendment that he had been alerted to.
The Mayor noted that any member can propose an amendment at any point and that in the absence of any amendment being proposed then he would need to ask Cllr Anderson to expand on the motion.
Cllr Anderson presented the motion, noting that the main issue around the cost of living crisis has been the effect on retail energy prices.
It was noted that those facing increases in average monthly bills of around £6,700 a month, the government grants to households has helped considerably, and Cllr Anderson referred to those who have experienced increases of £200 per month, stating that he has been contacted by residents who have faced this impact .
Cllr Anderson noted the profits made by energy companies as a result of high prices and stated that they were now at a level that was no longer acceptable.
Cllr Anderson stated that it is important to note that retail energy prices are used to calculate inflation and that they therefore need to keep prices as low as possible. It was also noted that high energy prices are stifling the economy, and the impact on people and businesses was raised.
Cllr Anderson asked members to support the motion so they could lobby the government to ensure further support for residents.
Cllr Adeleke for Cllr Anderson for Cllr Banks for Cllr Barratt for Cllr Barry-Mears for Cllr Bassadone for Cllr Beauchamp for Cllr Bhinder for Cllr Birnie abstain Cllr Chapman for Cllr Claughton for Cllr Douris for Cllr Durrant for Cllr Elliot for Cllr England for Cllr Foster for Cllr Freedman for Cllr Griffiths for Cllr Harden for Cllr Hearn for Cllr Hobson for Cllr Hollinghurst abstain Cllr Imarni for Cllr Johnson for Cllr Link for Cllr Maddern for Cllr Peter for Cllr Pringle for Cllr Ransley for Cllr Riddick for Cllr Rogers for Cllr Silwal for Cllr Sinha for Cllr Stevens for Cllr Su Mahmood for Cllr Sutton for Cllr Symington for Cllr Taylor for Cllr Timmis for Cllr Tindall for Cllr Townsend for Cllr Wilkie for Cllr Williams for
Cllr Anderson commented that the Council has done something similar in the past and it has helped.
Cllr Anderson advised that he attended the scrutiny committee where this was considered, where a lot of comments were made about the Air Strategy that the council has.
Cllr Anderson expressed he felt it important to note that we do not have a problem with air quality in Dacorum, but we do have a couple of areas that we are focusing on in partnership with other authorities, we are acting proactively.
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report, advising that IAG met recently and suggested we make some changes to the recommendations, to take forward 1 of the playground schemes, rather than both, as both constitute £1.3m which is a large sum relative to the amount we are looking to release. Also feel strongly that we need to signal our intention to support the scheme to works at Long Marston Village Hall. The IAG recommendation was that more detail was required as part of the Long Marston bid; would ask Cabinet colleagues to show our intention of support to Long Marston in them doing so.
Cllr Anderson commented that officer resource would be required to deliver the playground project.
Cllr Williams also noted that, with immediate effect, all responsibility for the Council's non-HRA properties, being general fund properties, investment properties, and commercial estate, will move from the Place Portfolio under Cllr Anderson to Commercial Strategy and Delivery under Cllr Williams.
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report; he paid tribute to Parish Cllr John Morris who had led the project with a number of volunteers over a number of years. and was happy to take questions.
Councillor Williams was substituted by Councillor Anderson and Councillor Hollinghurst was substituted by Councillor Foster.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor McDowell to GRANT the application in line with officers recommendations.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Beauchampto DELEGATED with a view to APPROVAL .
Councillor Anderson substituted on behalf of Councillor Durrant.
Councillor Anderson declared an interest in the item as he was speaking in objection as Ward Councillor to the item; he took no part in the debate or the voting.
The Case Officer, Robert Freeman, introduced the report to Members and said that the application had been referred to the Committee as it was called in by Councillor Anderson.
Parish Councillor Alan Johnson and Ward Councillor Alan Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
It was proposed by Councillor Maddern and seconded by Councillor Anderson to DELEGATED with a view to APPROVAL in line with officers recommendations.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Stevens to GRANT the application.
Cllr Anderson queried the Fast Track appeal process.
Cllr Anderson commented that as a Council we held out for as long as we could but we cannot any further. This may encourage composting, personally stopped using green waste bin some time ago. It may not be popular but it is a fair way of doing things.
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report. There were no questions. Recommendations agreed
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report and asked colleagues to ensure they have seen the amendments to the recommendations (Cllr Anderson read out the revised recommendations for clarity).
Cllr Anderson went on to advise that after 8 months of considerable effort, the ... view the full minutes text for item CA/100/21
Cllr Anderson also noted that they are looking at non-controversial services, such as back office operations where there is no scope for differing interpretations in what is in the public interest and where there is a benefit from sharing with other authorities.
Cllr Anderson requested the following changes;
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report and his hope that the Council can support the Chair of BID to get the right result from this ballot. JDoe advised work is going on in the back ground to move this forward and get the administration arrangements in place to support the ballot process.
It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Stevens to GRANT the application in line with officers recommendations, with an additional condition preventing external storage and an additional informative in respect of refuse collections.
The Case Officer, Nigel Gibbs, introduced the report to Members and said that the application had been referred to the Committee as it was called in by Councillor Beauchamp and Deferred by DMC on 14 th July 2022 It was proposed by Councillor Douris and seconded by Councillor Anderson to GRANT the application in line with officers recommendations.
It was then proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Hobson to overturn the officer’s recommendation and refuse the application.
Cllr Anderson thanked the Enforcement Officers for their work at 1 The Orchard, Kings Langley.
Cllr Anderson: Good evening, [name removed], and good evening, [name removed]. As this question relates to a planning application which is currently awaiting determination it would not be appropriate for me to comment on the specifics at this stage The council will have regard to any comments received in response to this application and, in addition to what it says here, I'd say that any member of the public can participate in the planning process as registering to speak to the development management committee, should it get to the development management committee, and there you will have your opportunity to have your say.
Cllr Anderson advised that the Chair of the Hertfordshire Infrastructure Planning Partnership is taking part in London planning meetings and representing Hertfordshire.
Cllr Anderson stated that he would be happy to show Cllr England around Hemel Hempstead Day Centre that has a flat roof and solar panels.
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report, He said that members would be aware that they set up the Hemel Place Strategy as a major exercise to review opportunities for Hemel as a place, working with their partners across the board to look at opportunities post pandemic and planning constraints with the future in mind. It did not have a lot to add to the report apart from thank the officers for the amount of work and effort that had been put I to the marketing, and commonplace the consultants that they had commissioned to do that for them.
Cllr Anderson said that there has not been a task & Finish group as there has been nothing to report. The understanding was that as soon as there was something to report that body would resume.
Advice Cllr Anderson said that the report outlines a proposal for a new framework for the business in Dacorum and asks for our approval to establish a high level Strategic Business Board and to approve holding a business event hosted by the leader to launch the Hemel Business Board. Our Business engagement has worked really well with somethings but somethings have fallen by the wayside and are not working as well so they needed to revamp them. He was happy to take questions.
It was moved by Councillor Anderson, seconded by Councillor Barrett and unanimously;
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report and said that he thought the report was excellent and they had hoped to get the most benefit out of new development and have skills for the future.
Advice Cllr Anderson said he was pleased to present this report to members so that the Cabinet can approve it. It was an excellent scheme, not just to get solar panels across Hemel Garden Communities but across the piece as a whole. This was a form of sustainability for the future generation that he fully supports and he hoped that they could get some traction and get some panels installed on roofs that do not have them.
The following Motion was proposed by Councillor Banks and seconded by Councillor Anderson:
The amendment was accepted by Councillor Banks and Councillor Anderson, therefore the following paragraph was added to the motion:
Councillor Anderson, Portfolio Holder for Planning & Infrastructure Councillor Anderson presented a report on Planning and Infrastructure:
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report and said, as members would be aware the Local Development Scheme was the timetable of development of the new Local plan, its potentially controversial as they have a lot of developers that want their scheme and develop first and ask questions later. Also it could be controversial as they have large sections of the communities that are strongly opposed to the proposals.
Cllr Barrett or Cllr Anderson are the relevant portfolio holders to discuss this at a future meeting.
Advice Cllr Anderson introduced the report A Robinson reminded members that this was an annual report that they were required to publish and this was the 4 th one they had produced. The changes they had made were largely limited to updating information on sites, for example if sites have started on site they have made that clear. He wanted to draw members attention to four specific changes where they have removed some sites form the on the basis that they have started on site or that in their assessment they have concluded that they should not appear on the register anymore and that related to 2 garden centers that are in the borough.
Cllr Wyatt-Lowe declared a personal interest however she comes to this with an open mind and was able to take part in the discussion and vote The report was introduced by the case officer Daniel Terry It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Douris that it be Granted Vote:
For: 2 against: 5 Abstained: 1 Resolved; Refused Alternative vote to refuse It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Hollinghurst that the application be Refused Vote:
The report was introduced by the case officer Andrew Parrish It was proposed by Councillor Maddern and seconded by Councillor Anderson that the application be Granted Vote:
The report was introduced by the case officer Colin Lecart It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Williams that the application be Granted Vote:
The report was introduced by the case officer Robert Freeman on behalf of Jane Miller It was proposed by Councillor Wyatt-Lower and seconded by Councillor Anderson that the application be Granted Vote:
The report was introduced by the case officer Heather Edey It was proposed by Councillor Maddern and seconded by Councillor Anderson that the application be Granted Vote:
Cllr Anderson declared an interest and took no part in the discussion or voting.
Cllr Anderson asked if there was a location plan they can provide.
It was proposed by Councillor Williams and seconded by Councillor Anderson that the application be Granted Vote:
The report was introduced by the case officer Daniel Terry It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Wyatt-Lowe that the application be Granted Vote:
Cllr Anderson declared a personal interest as the ward Cllr however comes with an open mind.
Cllr Stevens declared a declaration of interest and did not contribute in the discussion or voting The report was introduced by the case officer Heather Edey It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Beauchamp that the application be Granted Vote:
Cllr Anderson said that it can be a sensitive area when they talk about how the committee are performing. It could be argued that, is there such a thing as a right decision, is the right decision not getting it overturned by the planning inspectorate, or is the right thing getting it right according to your own planning belief’s and judging each case on its own merits. They do have a performance indicator that’s included with the other performance indicators about the proportion of appeals allowed that is reviewed quarterly by the SPAE OSC and it’s a tricky area, and he thought that if someone were take a view that it’s a sign of good performance if no decisions were overturned then that’s great, if one was to take the view that on occasion the planning decision was different to the point where it ultimately got overturned and that could be judges as good performance.
Cllr Anderson referenced the appeal decision for Wilstone, he said that he felt that member should play close attention to that, they refused at committee one for a smaller number of properties in Markyate and that has now gone to appeal and they will await the decision on that.
Cllr Anderson introduced the report.
Cllr Anderson introduced the report in Cllr Barrett’s absence.
Cllr Anderson introduced the report, explaining that this is annual statement that the Council is required to publish on their website.
Councillor Anderson was taking over for Cllr Barrett that evening.
Cllr Anderson introduced the report and invited questions.
Cllr Anderson added to say that the Planning White Paper proposed scrapping the duty to cooperate all together but indications are that any Local Authority that tries to get their local plan adopted, that has not gone through that duty to cooperate exercise will have little chance of getting their plan approved.
Cllr Stevens declared an interest and did not take part in the discussion or voting The report was introduced by the case officer Daniel Terry It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Wyatt-Lowe that the application be Granted Vote:
For: 3 against: 5 Abstained: 2 The committee moved to an alternative motion to refuse It was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor McDowellthat the application be Refused Vote:
Cllr Anderson presented the report as circulated with the agenda and moved to the recommendations. In making his introduction, he referred to an amendment under the recommendation 3 of the report, where it makes reference to Section 8, this should read Section 9. He also went on to express gratitude to the public for their feedback.
Cllr Anderson invited questions.
Cllr Anderson and Cllr Barrett seconded those comments.
The following was proposed by Councillor Anderson and seconded by Councillor Williams:
Councillor Anderson said he wouldn’t accept the amendment and asked that his colleagues reject it. He explained we already had debate and Q&A’s on this very point this evening and now wasn’t the time to be prejudging whether we will be doing it or not.
Councillor Williams agreed with Councillor Anderson and said he couldn’t support the amendment. He advised he was sympathetic to the amendment but these two matters weren’t in the same Bill and if we passed the amended motion we would leave ourselves open to challenge.
Cllr Anderson requested that the Gadebridge Park Improvements be added to the September meeting.
Councillor Williams – Leader of the Council, Portfolio Holder for Corporate & Contracted Services Councillor Mrs Griffiths – Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Housing Councillor Banks - Portfolio Holder for Community and Regulatory Services Councillor Elliot - Portfolio Holder for Finance and Resources Councillor Anderson - Portfolio Holder for Planning and Infrastructure Councillor Barrett - Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services b) Proposals for the Cabinet, Chairs and Vice-Chairs and Members to serve on the Standing Committees until the Annual Meeting of the Council in 2022 were circulated as set out in Annex A to these minutes and agreed.
Following the sad loss of Councillor Graham Sutton, a couple of changes have been made to the Cabinet; Councillor Anderson is the Portfolio Holder for Planning and Infrastructure and Councillor Barrett is the Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services.
Question 1 from Councillor Symington to Councillor Anderson:
Response from Councillor Anderson : I have already provided Councillor Symington with a full and detailed answer and copied in all members. The first draft of the local plan involved considering options and the urban capacity option couldn’t be chosen as it was considerably below the governments required figure. The idea of the first consultation was to show the impact of meeting the full figure and how it would look in the borough.
Response from Councillor Anderson: The full version of the response you received made it quite clear that the Council will do everything it can to use Brownfield site before any Greenfield development is used. I can’t put it any stronger than that.
Cllr Anderson asks “Will the decision be taken to Cabinet Committee?” Mark Brookes replies saying that although it is a Council decision, it will be taken to Cabinet as this would be a sensible step to take.
Section 9 of the LGA Code of Conduct (Interests) – Cllr Silwal asks – “Does it apply if the land is in a foreign country?” Mark Brookes replies – “No it relates to land in the borough” Cllr Anderson asks – “This only relates to our roles as Councillors and therefore can we participate as private citizens?” Mark Brookes replies – “Yes, if does not affect your role as a Councillor” Section 10 of the LGA Code of Conduct (Gifts and Hospitality) – Mark Brookes notes a Key point is the increase from £25 to £50 value. Members ... view the full minutes text for item 3.
Cllr Anderson said that this report had already been written and he felt that people were getting steamed up over something that was already in progress. He explained that the first annual report on waste analysis had stated where waste went, in particular what was sent overseas and this report went to the Herts Waste Panel earlier this year. Had there been any environment item on the agenda tonight it would have been presented.
Cllr Anderson requested an item to be added to 20 April meeting;
Cllr Anderson referred to a report on waste that is due to come to committee soon.
Cllr Anderson commented that there is a lot to this matter and suggested Members might want to schedule a review of the project in the coming months as and when things develop.
Cllr Anderson suggested also inviting opposition spokespersons.
Councillor Anderson, Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services The Portfolio Holder firstly paid tribute to the staff that have managed to keep our refuse collection service going despite the ongoing covid-19 crisis. The Health and Safety Executive and Covid authorities have checked our activities ensuring that we are keeping to national rules that have been set. It means we’ve had a large increase in costs and therefore will go over budget this year, but the bottom line is that the council can be very proud of actually managing to keep all our refuse services and other services based at Cupid Green going and he was very grateful to everyone involved for that.
Councillor Anderson seconded the adoption of the policy and said he asked for this issue to come before the SPAE OSC when he was chairman and has seen its progress and was pleased to see the council were moving to adopt a minimum parking standard. The impact on maximum standards has been huge.
Councillor Anderson said the white paper proposes that the levy is charged as a proportion of the value of the site instead of it being a flat rate per square metre. He said this would recreate an old issue that had been resolved by the introduction of CIL.
Cllr Anderson mentioned that the report had previously been to Committee and has already been considered. The Chairman advised that not many of the Members of this current Committee were part of this committee at that time.
Councillor Anderson said he felt this was a wonderful project and would be the first council houses in Kings Langley for 40 years. He asked about the provision of solar panels and whether these could extend across all units.
Councillor Anderson said he had sympathy with the motion and with what it was trying to achieve but he couldn’t support it because it was impractical. He said ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Anderson substituted on behalf of Councillor Guest and Councillor Silwal substituted on behalf of Councillor Johnson.
Councillor Alan Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
Councillor Anderson asked if there is anything we can do to reduce the risk of another timetable slip.
Councillor Anderson referred to the cyber-attack risk on the register. Recently Middlesbrough came under a sustained cyber-attack where systems were taken down and asked if the council had learned any lessons.
Councillor Anderson said from his role as Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services, he was pleased to see the requirement for event organisers to provide bins for litter.
Councillor Anderson said he fully supported the proposal but would like to know how many introductory tenancies have failed.
Cllr Anderson said that as Portfolio Holders they were presenting what they had been doing and what was coming.
Cllr Anderson talked about the improvements that have been made at Cupid Green including the vehicle repair shops, the buildings and installing a shower for female members of staff. He also spoke about the educational waste projects they run including Love Food Hate Waste and clothes swapping events.
Cllr Anderson said that in the future we must be aware of the growing population in our area in respect of waste solutions and it is a possibility that the Government may decide standardise waste collection across the country which would bring challenges.
Cllr Anderson explained that the CSG work in many different ways and he was seeking to document some of that so that their effectiveness could be maximised.
Cllr Anderson went on to speak about protocol for dealing with graffiti and wanting to increase bio-diversity, seeing what can be done with introducing wild flowers cost effectively, he added that the council is looking to ban the release of lanterns and balloons from property and spaces owned By Dacorum Council due to the danger to animals and wildlife plus damage to property.
Cllr Anderson said that he has talked to the Water Company about the chalk streams in our borough. He spoke about the Water Gardens and how important it is that they are now maintained to the high standard they have been restored to. The Splash Park, he said, is very popular but needs to be monitored to ensure that it is being used in a hygenic way with parents being responsible for their children, so that it may continue to be enjoyed by all.
Cllr Anderson reiterated that we have an ambitious tree planting project. Trees were going to be planted and they were hoping to plant a thousand by the end of the year and planning for that is well under way, ensuring that we get the supply of trees etc , Also looking at formalising tree replacement through planning applications.
Cllr Anderson said that things they would be looking at in the future would be CO2 reduction, air quality, the climate emergency and he said that he would also like to investigate the possibility of supporting any local food schemes.
Cllr Anderson replied that they were already in place.
Councillor Anderson, Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services Councillor Anderson thanked the Mayor for attending the Best Kept Gardens Competition in Kings Langley which helped Parish colleagues raise over £1,000 for the British Waterways Experience. The money raised was considerably more than in previous years. The Portfolio Holder presented his update as follows:
Cllr Anderson said that they still intend to have a tour for the committee, once Cupid Green is in a better state and it has not been forgotten.
Cllr Anderson said that he would find out who it falls under and get back to Cllr Birnie.
Cllr Anderson told the committee that through membership of Herts Waste Partnership – a fly tipping group that does a lot of work to combat the problem, overall the the amount of fly tipping is coming down, and that needs to be recognised, although it is a very real problem.
Cllr Anderson added that it is very difficult and expensive to prosecute and that there had been a prosecution of a fly tipper this quarter.
Cllr Anderson said that when Councillors visit Cupid Green, they can see equipment to prevent this.
Cllr Anderson said that the committee scrutinised this process about two years ago.
Cllr Anderson ... view the full minutes text for item 57.
Councillor Anderson said he understood that scheme would be phased out over ten years.
J Deane said Councillor Anderson may be thinking of the link with parish funding.
Councillor Anderson said this was a good piece of work and should help to answer questions from campaign groups that suggest the council haven’t properly research the brownfield land options.
Cllr Anderson added that officers are looking at various aspects of the commercial waste service and it may be that commercial recycling could be used as an opportunity to try and get the commercial waste back that we have been losing.
Cllr Anderson added that price structures etc are being looked at to get to the bottom of the immediate problem.
Cllr Anderson said it is important to remember that we cannot just plant trees anywhere and everywhere. It is down to individual landowners and the County Council and Highways are cautious of trees with roots which can damage tarmac etc , It takes a lot of work to find suitable planting for a thousand trees and that is what is happening at the moment.
Cllr Anderson said that garages which was on that list did not come under this committee. He suggested that in terms of environmental sustainability the committee could review the Council’s private emergency plan and also the Council’s environmental management system, which gives an analysis the Council’s use of gas, electric, water etc., this is something which comes into Nigel Howcutt’s area and is something he could present.
Cllr Anderson said it is important that members who request reports lay out what information they require and what it is they hope to achieve, he added that he felt Cllr Hobson had brought together two different subjects, one being dry recyclables and the other waste reduction.
Councillor Anderson said that HMOs often get a bad reputation and hoped that enforcement would help people and would also promote HMOs a good form of housing.
Councillor Anderson asked about the annual settlement on staff pay and if there was any information for next year.
Councillor Anderson said it was frustrating that the decision gets put off.
Councillor Anderson said he welcomed this. It does need to be made clear that this is defining the area and the neighbourhood plan, in due course, is for residents and the community to get the maximum benefit out of developments. He understood there may be some controversy but it is important to get the message out there that this will benefit the community.
Councillor Alan Anderson noted that as a Chairman had not been elected prior to the meeting, he could not ask the Chairman if he could attend the meeting to raise a matter.
Councillor Anderson asked Councillor R Sutton if he could be present at the meeting.
Councillor Anderson stated that it was the opposite and, in fact, there was a lack of attendees at member development opportunities. He continued that this was concerning considering the cost of external training providers and the lack of attendance at these sessions.
Councillor Anderson suggested that member development opportunities became an item for discussion at Group Meetings to encourage attendance.
Councillor Anderson raised his issue with attending mandatory training and gave the example of GDPR training. He said that he had already attended a GDPR session within the past 18 months and therefore did not agree that he should have to attend a further session.
Councillor Bhinder agreed with Councillor Anderson.
Councillor Anderson suggested that for those members who had not attended mandatory training sessions at all, it would be preferable if they could pick a date suitable for them.
Councillor Anderson said that the presentations were really good and that the ICT handover was not that chaotic. He continued that it would have been helpful to find out more about a councillors role along with proportionality.
Councillor Anderson agreed that he had also experience issues and that the ICT team could access members’ devices remotely to help resolve any problems.
Cllr Anderson explained that as part of the Herts Waste Partnership we have to work as part of a team. It is not ideal that there is any chance our refuse being exported broad, but we have to deal with the realities of the situation. We must focus on trying to reduce that problem as much as possible.
Cllr Anderson said that a lot of proposals were seen in the consultation that took place last Summer and he felt that it had counter productive proposals which could potentially make the problem worse, such as promoting the use of bicycles on a dual carriageway. Also there was a draft proposal about closing Kings Langley and Apsley railway stations which has since been ‘binned’. He added that he felt we need to focus on finding practical measures.
Advice Councillor Anderson advised that since the appointment of Simon Smith as Transport Manager, the Council has been making a range of improvements, including initiatives such as fleet standardisation and acquiring new refuse freighters.
Councillor Anderson added that this report outlines the latest initiative which is to bring back in-house the maintenance of CSG and Cemeteries equipment. Which has been done previously under contract by Luton Borough Council since 2012, but the service is now in a position to do this work at Cupid Green Depot.
Councillor Anderson stated that the service will require three new posts and some Capital investment, this will release a Revenue saving of at least £27,000 per year. Officers will arrange the necessary Capital works if approved and the recruitment with a view to the maintenance starting in January 2020.
Councillor Anderson added that in addition to the financial saving, the benefit of doing this is also environmental and by doing things in house, we can do things locally without having to send vehicles some distance to be dealt with, so we are achieving an environmental benefit as well as the financial one.
Councillor Williams – Leader of the Council and Portfolio Holder for Corporate & Contracted Services Councillor Mrs Griffiths – Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Housing Councillor Banks - Portfolio Holder for Community and Regulatory Services Councillor Elliot - Portfolio Holder for Finance and Resources Councillor G Sutton - Portfolio Holder for Planning and Infrastructure Councillor Anderson - Portfolio Holder for Environmental Services c) Proposals for the Cabinet, Chairs and Vice-Chairs and Members to serve on the Standing Committees until the Annual Meeting of the Council in 2020 were circulated as set out in Annex A to these minutes and agreed.
Cllr Anderson asked a question regarding the pressure of work on the Local Plan – do we have to include some growth in the budget moving on.
Cllr Riddick then asked about fly tipping in Rucklers Lane, which Cllr Anderson confirmed he had also reported.
Cllr Anderson said that Nicola Loebendon assured him that the tip was being investigated and would be cleared at the end of the investigation. A question was asked regarding how many cameras we have available to deal with fly tips and how often are they moved.
J.Doe added that time is being put into the new software system and Cllr Anderson asked whether there were any timescales for this and J.Doe replied that September is the aim.
Cllr Anderson – asked whether there was any indication as to way forward with Building Control.
Cllr Anderson enquired about how many appeals were allowed or dismissed but it shows that 28% of cases were allowed on appeal.2 were allowed recently and we lost costs.
Cllr Anderson asked the officers present if they had anything to add, specific to the s J Doe gave the presentation for his service. He explained there were some updates/changes from the December meeting.
Item 7 – WORK PROGRAMME Cllr Marshall asked about the Work Plan – Cllr Anderson advised that there were a lot of guests attending the meeting in March in connection with the Air Quality item, and it would be first on the agenda.
Cllr Birnie said that he noticed car parking standards were on the Agenda for the March meeting, Cllr Anderson confirmed this and said that J Doe would be giving an interim report.
J Doe added that the SW Herts plan may have to be put back as the information may not be ready, Cllr Anderson agreed that this would be fine as it is not time critical.
Cllr Anderson said that he would like to confirm – Nigel Howcutt is the Assistant Director for Finance and Resources, not our Environmental Sustainability Officer but he will be presenting the item.
Cllr Anderson confirmed that this was all to do with accreditation for Security of Information.
Cllr Anderson said that he had received an email from the Committee Clerk the afternoon before, which said the James Doe would be unable to present reports at the meeting.
Cllr Anderson added that because of this his intention had been to cancel the two items concerned, but Cllr Timmis as a member of the airport consultative committee has some information for the meeting on the subject.
Cllr Anderson explained that Luton is the only airport in the country that is not governed by national legislation.
Cllr Anderson proposed that with the Committee’s approval he wanted to make both the Assistant Directors aware that if a report is not produced before the meeting, then that item will not be taken at the meeting. It would have to be received on the Friday before the meeting. He added that there would be times when just a presentation was sufficient but if there is a report to look at they would like to see that information prior, including any slides.
Cllr Anderson said that Paragraph 3.1 – Assertion meeting SLA’s – Members are asking for things to be done but it isn’t happening. How does that square with the assertion that the service is reaching its delivery plan?
Cllr Anderson gave the example that a church fence had fallen which was the responsibility of Dacorum, a replacement had been requested three times but nothing had happened.
Cllr Anderson pointed out that the cost of officer time should be considered.
Cllr Anderson said that it would not be a matter for this committee but if anyone felt it was in the Public interest they could challenge it.
Cllr Anderson said that it was the first trial that he could remember where we have actually stopped the trial and he would share the residents frustration being told that they cannot recycle anymore and asked was the trial only stopped due to financial reasons .
Cllr Anderson asked if this enabled the authority to deal with issues where people just allowed dogs to roam off their property.
Cllr Anderson proposed that the proposal was supported with the kennel club wording but also with the proviso that we are able to report specific bins or inadequate bin coverage.
Cllr Anderson asked if we are able to do something about this using the local planning process.
Cllr Anderson asked if it was known how much we hadn’t received in relation to CIL receipts – when we first started we did struggle to collect quite a large amount.
There are some outstanding debits but nothing older than 6 months Cllr Anderson asked if the only one that was outstanding was the Beacon Development in Apsley . J Doe explained that development has not yet started so it is not yet due.
Cllr Anderson said that on the point of expenditure he was slightly concerned with an issue in Berkhamsted which a letter in the local paper suggested that a major improvement that was necessary was being held back because no CIL funding was being released to make it happen, and he thought it may have involved the surgery although he cannot remember. He added that although he knows we are not going to get the amount of money through CIL that we need he wonders whether he wonders if we could take a tiny proportion of it to get some big wins and whether there was any opportunity to do that.
Ward Councillor Alan Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
Councillor Anderson asked about the commercial waste annual income target.
F Jump said it was currently £1.1 million Councillor Anderson suggested the budget setting process might be making life harder by being over optimistic.
Councillor Anderson said that the Splash Park had been a huge success.
Councillor Anderson said that E Walker was currently off and sent best wishes for a speedy recovery on behalf of the committee.
Councillor Anderson asked about the recent PH decision in relation to temporary staff.
Councillor Anderson asked why was it necessary to make the slip road into the car park so long and take out so many of the trees softening the urban landscape.
Councillor Anderson pointed out that any queuing traffic would simply backup through the traffic light controlled pedestrian crossing anyway.
Councillor Anderson said the slip road was quite close to the crossing.
Councillor Anderson suggested that the slip road turn be closer to the car park.
Councillor Anderson advised that the traffic would backup through the pedestrian crossing anyway.
Councillor Anderson said an interim report might help.
Councillor Anderson asked about the policy on the colour of the street nameplates. The council’s planning policy states that, because of its historical past, the nameplates in Kings Langley should be royal blue with white writing.
Councillor Anderson asked members to submit any suggestions for the work programme to himself or K Mogan. The Planning, Development and Regeneration Q4 Performance report had been deferred to the July meeting.
The Chairman of the Strategic Planning and Environment Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Anderson gave an update to the committee covering all Overview and Scrutiny committee’s full reports can be found in the agenda
Councillor Anderson said that Councillor C Wyatt-Lowe had attended an appeal hearing on behalf on the council this week and no costs had been awarded against the council. He also queried the council’s website as when you go to land charges, the website provides a list of private companies.
Councillor Anderson said parking standards had been deferred on the work programme and understood the reasons for it but asked for assurance that it hadn’t been forgotten. He said he was ... view the full minutes text for item 49.
Councillor Anderson thanked C Thorpe for clearing the roadkill he reported in his area. He asked for an update on the dog waste bins.
Councillor Anderson asked if it had been decided on whether the borough council would be emptying the bins that are owned by the parish councils.
Councillor Anderson said he had received comments from residents in Kings Langley about the event not taking place there.
Outcome Councillor Anderson thanked C Thorpe for his very full and comprehensive presentation. The Strategic Planning and Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee approved the report.
Councillor Anderson asked members to raise any issues they wished to add to the work programme for the next civic year.
Councillor Howard chaired the meeting in the absence of Councillor Anderson.
Councillor Anderson introduced the item. The Government's consultation had run out some weeks previously, and it was concerning both that the committee had missed an opportunity to have its say on the consultation, and that the Government will have come under intense pressure to re-raise the lower housing allocation for Dacorum. He felt there was an opportunity to lobby the Government out of the consultation window, and tabled a draft letter appealing to the Government to retain the lower figure.
Councillor Anderson asked J Doe if any harm could be foreseen if the committee was to send the letter as tabled (see Appendix A).
Councillor Anderson asked the committee for its support in sending the response to the government.
Councillor Anderson said he would redraft the letter and send to members via email.
Councillor Anderson said the government were in favour of growth.
Councillor Anderson said that M Brookes has conducted a scrutiny review and one of the suggestions was to remove the quarterly reports from the work programme as it was felt they were not achieving anything. The idea was for scrutiny committees to scrutinise single issues.
Councillor Anderson said he would report the committee’s comments back to M Brookes.
In his role as ward councillor, Councillor Anderson spoke in objection to the application.
Outcome Councillor Anderson thanked D Skinner for all his hard work on the committee. The Strategic Planning and Environment Overview and Scrutiny Committee approved the report.
Councillor Anderson thanked E Walker for including the accident data in the report as requested.
Councillor Anderson thanked the department for all their hard work despite the staff vacancies and issues faced.
Councillor Anderson said this point flags up the importance of members taking the time to read the constitution.
Councillor Anderson advised against this as this would stray into the Housing and Community Overview and Scrutiny Committee’s remit.
Councillor Anderson asked if councillors could have a copy of the brownfield sites identified for development in their ward J Doe said this shouldn’t be a problem. Constitutional amendments are also required before permission I principle can be granted to sites and this will go to Cabinet and Council for approval.
Councillor Anderson said this topic had come up in last week’s Member Development session and thanked E Walker for a great presentation.
Councillor Anderson said it would be interesting to see how this huge project would work and how many residents would be left on black sack collection afterwards.
Councillor Anderson suggested that it would be useful if J Doe could arrange to send members a distinction of the two categories.
Councillor Anderson encouraged the committee to look at the work programme and wanted members to become more proactive in requesting items to scrutinise to add value to the scrutiny process. Also, if any members identify a training need then contact Member Support who can organise the training.
Councillor Howard chaired the meeting in the absence of Councillor Anderson.
Councillor Howard said that herself and Councillor Anderson had sat with officers to devise a work programme for the rest of the year and had hopefully included items that members were interested in.
R Herbert then introduced the item and said it had been referred to committee as it had been called in by the Ward Councillor Alan Anderson.
Councillor Anderson noted the council had met the annual target of 430 new homes.
Councillor Anderson asked for an update on the Hand Arm Vibration prosecution.
Councillor Anderson asked if the Assistant Directors had anything to add from the presentation members had just heard.
Councillor Anderson asked if a separate report could be brought to this committee on the detail of the White Paper.
Councillor Anderson asked if D Austin could explain what ‘cessation of Primary Authority function’ means.
Councillor Anderson said he was fearful of the objectivity of the partnership when it was first formed and that it would put huge pressure on authority staff.
Councillor Anderson asked the committee if the order of the agenda could be changed and the committee hear the Luton Airport report first. The committee agreed.
Councillor Anderson asked Councillor Timmis to make her presentation. He said she was here tonight as a member of the London Luton Airport Consultative Committee who has played a part in lobbing the airport on behalf of Dacorum.
Councillor Anderson then invited Andrew Lambourne from LADACAN to give his presentation.
Councillor Anderson advised members that as the site included Council owned land, the committee must be careful not to stray into commercially sensitive information.
Councillor Anderson invited the members of the public to speak:
Councillor Anderson congratulated officers on keeping track on the Act especially as it hasn’t been dealt with via a White Paper and it’s all very confusing. A Stratgeic Housing Land Assessment was completed a few years ago and would this be used as a starting point for the brownfield land register.
Questions and answers Councillor Anderson asked if they had an indication of the view from Herts Highways.
Councillor Anderson asked if the three storey office building on London Road had been granted permission.
Councillor Anderson said he was concerned about the plot of land on the corner of the crossroads. This should be protected as it is a key gateway into the town.
It was proposed by Councillor C Wyatt-Lowe, seconded by Councillor Mrs Bassadone and agreed that Councillor Anderson be appointed Chairman.
Councillor Anderson explained that he had suggested having this meeting as it had been some time since they had a meeting of the Overview and Scrutiny Chairman and they used to meet often. He advised that it had also been opened up to regulatory Chairman as the topics being discussed affected all of the committees. He explained that the proposal was to ask all committee members to complete a questionnaire, which could be anonymous if required, and he asked members for their comments and if they supported this proposal.
Councillor Anderson advised that this information could already be found on the DBC website.
Councillor Anderson asked if the officers could speak to other local authorities and investigate the kind of questions they have asked if they have carried out a similar review.
Councillor Anderson highlighted the three aims and objectives for this review:
Showing the latest 300 of 330.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Anderson attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Nov 2022 | Council | Change to committee dates | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Anderson was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 5 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Anderson declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 31 Oct 2024 | Development Management, item 5a | 24/01239/MFA Change of use from agricultural land to Suitable Alternative Natural Green Space (SANG), together with a vehicular access, car park, paths, fencing and landscaping Land at Nettleden Road, Potten End, Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire Councillor Anderson declared an interest in the item, he confirmed that he will take no part in the discussion or voting. | |
| 30 May 2024 | Development Management, item 5b | 23/02805/FUL Proposed Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Station and Cafe Land opposite The Eagle Public House, Hempstead Road, Kings Langley Councillor Anderson declared an interest in item 5b and was speaking against the item. He declared that he would not participate in the discussion or the voting. | |
| 17 Nov 2022 | Development Management, item 4b | Councillor Anderson declared an interest in the item as he was speaking in objection as Ward Councillor to the item; he took no part in the debate or the voting. | Took no part |
| 2 Dec 2021 | Development Management, item 5i | Cllr Anderson declared an interest and took no part in the discussion or voting. | Took no part |
| 21 Oct 2021 | Development Management, item 5f | Cllr Anderson declared a personal interest as the ward Cllr however comes with an open mind. |
Where Councillor Anderson sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 2 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Strategic Planning & Environment Overview & Scrutiny | Chair | Sep 2026 | 2 | |
| Electoral Review Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 1 | |
| Standards | Committee Member | Oct 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.