Announcements
Cllr Pringle gave late apologies to member support during the meeting.
Every time Dacorum's minutes name Councillor Pringle, as the council published it.
Cllr Pringle gave late apologies to member support during the meeting.
Cllr Pringle and Cllr Santamaria gave apologies.
I understand there is one amendment requested to the version circulated in that one independent seat on the Housing and Community Overview & Scrutiny Committee will change, to remove Cllr Santamaria who will be replaced by Councillor Pringle.
Cllr Sammy Barry-Mears, Highfield Cllr Michela Capozzi, Tring East Cllr Toni Cox, Apsley & Corner Hall Cllr Claire Hobson, Boxmoor Cllr Lara Pringle, Northchurch Cllr Victoria Santamaria, Hemel Hempstead Town Cllr Carole Weston and Cllr Sheron Wilkie both of Tring Central 4.3 The group leaders gave apologies on behalf of their members;
Cllr Smith-Wright is to replace Cllr Pringle as the Vice Chair of Health Committee.
Cllr Pringle to check her status on the committee.
Cllr Pringle subsequently joined the meeting at 19.57.
Councillor Pringle declared an interest as the premises was close to the boundary of her ward (Northchurch) and some of the residents may live within her ward. She explained that although she didn’t know anyone personally she wanted to be transparent.
Action – JDoe to follow up regarding dentistry information provided by Cllr Pringle.
Action - Cllr Pringle to circulate report.
Cllr Pringle reiterated the concerns around communication and she noted that a particular tree of concern has now been felled.
Cllr Pringle advised that she has been trying to have this tree addressed for a number of years and she asked for a way for residents to report issues as well as reassurance that the report is being taken seriously to avoid residents continually reporting the same tree.
Cllr Pringle commented that it would be helpful to be able to look up tree reports and for it to have a prioritisation rating, as well as the opportunity to add more information.
Cllr Pringle arrived at 19:47 Cllr Banks said that on behalf of the conservative Team they welcome the Task and Finish Group.
Cllr Pringle is part of the surgery patient forum in Northchurch .
[name removed] was arrested and brought before the court, he pleaded guilty to unauthorised deposit of controlled waste and ordered to pay a £480 fine and £500 costs, with a £192 victim surcharge Regarding the prosecutions, Cllr Pringle sought clarity regarding whether fines would go into central funds.
Cllr Pringle raised concerns regarding the flexibility available for situations where a child was shared between 2 parents, potentially with only an informal agreement in place. She referenced a case where a mother was forced to move after her primary-aged child elected to live with the other parent.
Cllr Pringle queried how soon the Bedroom Tax became applicable in situations where a child changed residence, given the possibility of the child changing their mind. She questioned whether there should be an inquiry held before any permanent decisions.
Cllr Pringle noted the necessity for hard choices that might not be made if a parent was fully funded and represented in family court. NBeresford agreed and emphasised the importance of working with partners and other services rather than taking decisions in isolation.
Cllr Pringle noted it was good that the contract had been rewritten to allow work to be reallocated to another provider, but that practicalities made this challenging. She asked whether there were incentives or penalty clauses in place to help prevent any breach of contract, or compensation for residents in the event of this. MPinnell clarified that this reallocation of work away from Osborne would be substantial packages of work such as the entire kitchen programme .
Cllr Pringle praised the penalty matrix taking into account the severity of the case and harm caused to the tenant or others. She proposed adding in an aggravating feature regarding evidence of bullying of vulnerable tenants, and asked whether there were any powers to compensate the tenant in such cases. RClarke explained that the line regarding harm would encompass vulnerability, and that the Housing Act did allow the council or tenant to apply to the RPT for a rent repayment order of up to 12 months' rent.
Cllr Pringle noted that she would like to hear more about specific cases at a future date, and raised the need to publicise more widely to tenants that the council had these powers in the case of private sector properties.
Cllr Pringle proposed the motion, noting that it arises as a result following elections across the country on 4th May.
Cllr Pringle read out the following motion:
Cllr Pringle spoke as the proposer of the motion, stating that, as elected representatives, they welcome voters and that they represent the voices of all those in their wards.
Cllr Pringle suggested that the interim findings of the electoral commission following the introduction of photo ID was concerning in terms of how it discriminated against particular voter groups.
Cllr Pringle suggested that these groups are more vulnerable and are generally less empowered in society where there only method of having power over their circumstances is at the ballot box.
Cllr Pringle commented that it is concerning for democracy and that they must encourage participation as well as reflect the values of democracy to ensure that every single person's vote matters.
Cllr Pringle stated the preclusion of voting must not be forced on people by unjustified regulations.
Cllr Pringle advised that the basis for introducing the voter ID scheme has no clear evidence and she queried the motivation of bringing it in, noting that it did result in a number of undesirable consequences and should therefore be reviewed.
Cllr Pringle explained that general awareness of voter ID was reasonably good at 87%, though awareness was significantly lower amongst black and minority ethnic voters and young people.
Cllr Pringle commented that those in underrepresented groups were excluded even more with the most concerning being that those without valid photo ID are 13% less likely to vote.
Cllr Pringle stated that many people can't afford a car or don't travel abroad and therefore don't have a driving licence or passport and that no one should be excluded from democracy because of this.
Cllr Pringle referred to particular residents who had not been able to vote, including one resident in social housing who was also a carer and was unable to vote due to not holding valid photo ID.
Cllr Pringle referred to another resident in sheltered accommodation who was retired and was turned away for producing his National Service registration.
Cllr Pringle asked the Leader of the Council to write to the Home Secretary to demand that this impediment to people be removed, noting that these marginal numbers will affect outcomes and could disenfranchise vulnerable people.
Cllr Pringle asked how flexible and future-proof the vision is, noting that the work started a few years ago and that they are only reflecting on the long-term change catalysed by the pandemic.
Cllr Pringle queried if they should look at the plan in terms of future-proofing and lifestyle changes are still being observed so the vision needs to be innovative and flexible.
Cllr Pringle acknowledged the need to ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
It was moved by Councillor Tindall, seconded by Councillor Pringle and unanimously;
Councillor Pringle expressed concern about the increase in fees because of the cost of living crisis. She asked if there would be any assistance for those struggling to pay the increase in fees. P Wortley responded that there wasn’t support for the fee increase but explained that the fees would be payable by the site owners and he anticipated that these would be affordable.
Cllr Adeleke for Cllr Anderson for Cllr Banks for Cllr Barratt for Cllr Barry-Mears for Cllr Bassadone for Cllr Beauchamp for Cllr Bhinder for Cllr Birnie abstain Cllr Chapman for Cllr Claughton for Cllr Douris for Cllr Durrant for Cllr Elliot for Cllr England for Cllr Foster for Cllr Freedman for Cllr Griffiths for Cllr Harden for Cllr Hearn for Cllr Hobson for Cllr Hollinghurst abstain Cllr Imarni for Cllr Johnson for Cllr Link for Cllr Maddern for Cllr Peter for Cllr Pringle for Cllr Ransley for Cllr Riddick for Cllr Rogers for Cllr Silwal for Cllr Sinha for Cllr Stevens for Cllr Su Mahmood for Cllr Sutton for Cllr Symington for Cllr Taylor for Cllr Timmis for Cllr Tindall for Cllr Townsend for Cllr Wilkie for Cllr Williams for
Cllr Pringle commended the proactive steps being taken and noted how having immediate help will positively benefit outcomes for families.
Cllr Pringle asked if they would be consulting victims, their families and social services and how they will get feedback. JBartlett explained that they are looking to gather feedback from survivors as well as look at case closure processes. Feedback processes are built into the work and JBartlett confirmed that this would be done in a way that will not be too onerous on the victim.
Cllr Pringle queried if matters would automatically be referred to DBC.
Cllr Pringle requested that an automatic review take place of any serious incidents that take place in DBC properties.
Cllr Pringle noted that whilst not all domestic cases are reported, incidents may come to light through property reports. NBeresford agreed, noting that this is part of the lessons learned process and how to identify cases earlier.
Cllr Pringle then asked what needed to happen before the public could be made aware of this currently confidential matter. In response, it was explained that the Regulator of Social Housing would decide this in due course.
Cllr Pringle then asked whether her colleagues could reveal the area in which the incident leading to the report had occurred. In response, the incidence had occurred in Berkhamsted, however there had been no issues in terms of compliance in respect of the property involved in the incident.
Cllr Pringle added that the finding that this was an accidental death did not mean to say that nothing more might have been done to avoid the incident. In response, it was highlighted that further investigations would be conducted by various authorities to explore any opportunities for further improvements .
Cllr Pringle is keen that verge hardening is prioritised where electric charging points can be provided.
Councillor Pringle wondered how granular the information was about problem gambling and GambleAware were a charity with limited resources. She questioned if we had a breakdown of more detailed information of the Borough. N March advised he didn’t have that information and Licensing only dealt with the physical side of gambling.
HC/049/21 ACTION POINTS The Chairman said that the both of the outstanding actions from previous meetings were completed but would check with Cllr Pringle on that point.
Cllr Pringle echoed the comments of the previous Councillors about how much they appreciate the work that Dens has done building relationships in our communities, especially during the pandemic.
At the beginning of March 2020 lockdown when Cllr Pringle was contacting her constituents in Northchurch , Dens was supporting those who needed it so it does reach into our communities.
Cllr Pringle asked about the fire safety precautions and whether there was adequate measures in place. F Williamson confirmed that there are a number of measures in place, we’ve been working very close with the Fire Service who attend our fire safety meetings. We have a Fire Safety Strategy for the building which is operated by Dens and this has been reviewed by the Fire Service.
Cllr Pringle asked if it would be fair to say that the families have been through an ordeal, been through some awful experiences and whether there are any additional needs, for example the children requiring mental health referrals from trauma and are they getting the help that they need. M Peters advised that yes we have victims of trauma. The schools have been fantastic in meeting their needs, the children have been having talking therapies, also the Tenancy Sustainment Team is still heavily involved and Officers have built up a repour and trust, which is rare with authority and people from Syria.
HC/028/21 needs Cllr Pringle to send photos to Matt Rawdon.
Councillor Pringle spoke in support of the amendment. She said many of the residents she had interacted with were frustrated by the lack of social housing and some are living in completely unacceptable living conditions, yet the government continue to conflate the need for social housing with a free for all to allow developer’s access to our Green Belt.
Councillor Pringle questioned whether there was any opportunity to alert those bodies who assist individuals with gambling problems to this consultation and ask them for their direct response rather than just hoping they come across it and respond.
Councillor Pringle asked if the Leader could confirm that following the meeting of the Northchurch Parish Council emergency general meeting on Monday of this week, to which The Mayor had been invited, that he was able to report back to yourself the extremely poor experiences of Northchurch residents in accessing and understanding the consultation on the portal. In particular one resident, [name removed], had reported that she had taken some nine hours last Saturday to submit her response.
The Leader replied that he and The Mayor hadn’t discussed anything from that meeting so he was not aware of the issues to which Councillor Pringle was referring to. Clearly if people are taking that length of time that is very disappointing but for the majority of people online access was available. He felt there wasn’t much more he could add as he wasn’t aware of the discussion that took place at that meeting.
Councillor Pringle said [name removed] was ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
The following motion was proposed by Councillor Pringle and seconded by Councillor Taylor:
Questions from Councillor Pringle to Councillor Williams:
There is more trust at a local level and Cllr Pringle would like Dacorum Borough Council to take stock and reflect on the vital role we can play, a granular approach is needed , working very closely with schools, which is a trusted community network.
Cllr Pringle had raised previously about a communications strategy, people need to know what’s happening in their community because it’s vital that people understand the facts. Consideration should be given to a granular breakdown being published daily, with perhaps inclusion in weekly newsletters in schools and education facilities that are already being sent out, which sets out the details in the Borough to ensure that the public are fully aware of the risks and the actions they can take. M Rawdon confirmed he would raise it at Incident Management Team.
Ward Councillor Lara Pringle spoke in objection of the officer recommendation.
Cllr Pringle asked how the increase in domestic abuse due to lockdown had been identified. N Beresford stated there has been an increase and this has been identified via the victims and perpetrators, engagement with the Police and where we are making placements into temporary accommodation. We have also seen an increase of reports from male victims but we’ve needed to seek support from elsewhere as there are no facilities for men in Dacorum.
The Case Officer, Heather Edey, introduced the report to Members and said that the application had been referred to the Committee as it had been called in by Cllr Pringle.
Councillor Lara Pringle spoke in objection to the application.
Councillor Pringle asked the following question in writing to the Leader of the Council:
Cllr Pringle said for clarification, have we sight of the right in law not to be filmed because as I was aware of the recent training, it was made abundantly clear to all who attended that these are meetings that can be filmed and that no stipulations can be put on it.
Cllr Pringle noted the inclusion of the splash pool is considered to be an add-on, but isn’t essential to the plan and would like to say as someone who lives in Northchurch and uses Berkhamsted, it’s in incredibly high demand for children’s and babies swimming. When her children were younger, we had to go to Hemel and if there had been a facility it would have been used more, on behalf of people living in the area, that’s something we would probably really like to be included. However something that would be of great concern, you use the term the existing building and the envelope which will include the football ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Cllr Pringle said that it was mentioned that an increasing number of people were presenting as homeless and they were increasingly vulnerable and would like to explore the nature of the vulnerabilities, is it particular disabilities or age and is it related to a systemic difficulty accessing systems, whether it’s applying for houses, applying for universal credit, some people don’t have the concentration span or the ability to navigate complex systems, is it to do with private landlords tenants being more vulnerable, what is the driver and is there anything seasonal about it or is it actually more than what would be expected seasonally. F Williamson highlighted this is a countywide issue, the reports are showing that a percentage of homeless presentation in various groups, there has been an increase in single people who are presenting homeless, a number of those have either drug or alcohol dependency, a number have mental health issues. With some it’s a very complex set of circumstances, so it can be a relationship breakdown, a loss of job and therefore ... view the full minutes text for item 84.
Cllr Pringle advised she had been reading about the fixed term, it seemed that there was unintended consequences and was a little bit concerned although you are proposing to remove the shorter term and extending it to a fixed term, she is concerned about the criteria if the household had more than £16,000 saving, or a combined income of over £60,000 then they would be required to move on, would that still apply with these longer term tenancies when they came to be reviewed.
Cllr Pringle was concerned that families grow up and quite often young adults remain at home because they are saving up for somewhere to move to or to go to University and there could be a perverse incentive that if people have this information, have saved over £16,000 or that their combined income is over £60,000 they maybe they won’t save to go to University or improve their life or maybe Mum won’t take a promotion at work because their teenage child has started to have an income and they want to keep their income low. It incentivises people not to actually aspire to improving their income.
Cllr Pringle asked what complex analysis could be done because for example we talked earlier about complex problems of homelessness, the peak age for developing mental illness is 23 and young adulthood actually a very vulnerable time in peoples lives and it’s much more cost effective to have a young adult living in a bedroom in their family home, than to move out and require a one bedroom property. Is it just an absolute this is the combined family income or would the young adults income be considered not to be part of the household income, because quite often you might have a young adult and then primary school children in the same house and the family might become very stressed about what the implications of the young adult continuing to live in the security of the family home. A lot of people will presume that their children will continue to live with them until they were secure from feeling the need to ask them to leave because they jeopardise the loss of the family home.
Cllr Pringle said it came across as household in the report. V Cunningham highlighted that if it’s a joint tenancy or sole tenancy and that’s the same that’s on the Allocations Policy, so it works hand in hand with that.
Councillor Pringle sought clarification that in order to change fees, you must have a clear policy in place and even if you don’t necessarily want to change them now it would enable us to review them going forward. N March advised that you can’t charge any fees without having a policy in place to explain and justify how you charge them. He said that the fees proposed are connected to how many units there are on sites so if a site increases in units the fee would increase.
Councillor Pringle asked if the fees were charged to the individuals running the site and then recovered through the residents. N March advised the legislation states that can only be done in the first instance, however any changes after that can only be charged at retail price index.
Councillor Pringle then asked if that could lead to viability issues. N March said part of obtaining a licence in the first place is that they have to be able show that financially it is viable for them to hold a caravan site licence.
Councillor Pringle highlighted the alarming rise in food banks. She referred to the relocation of Dacorum’s food bank and asked if the Portfolio Holder could guarantee that the new premises will be of the same capacity or greater than the current premises, and that the food bank will be fully supported for future needs.
Councillor Pringle then asked if the Portfolio Holder agreed that the rise in food bank use was alarming and suggested reviewing the forecasts to ensure we ... view the full minutes text for item 4.
Cllr Pringle asked how vulnerable people were identified. K Haswell advised that they are identified through various agencies, including Social Care and Targeted Youth Support, Police, GP’s, schools and colleges, self-referral. We work with young people with LDD, care leavers, young carers, BME and travellers.
Cllr Pringle asked if staff were aware of and trained in various autistic spectrum disorders, including how to identify pathological demand avoidance. K Haswell confirmed that they have a learning disabilities team, which all the personal advisors are trained and we have staff who run create a spark programme who are trained to the level they need to be to recognise certain traits in young persons. Also all those young people will have an allocated personal advisor to work with in tandem with professional range worker that runs the programme.
Cllr Pringle asked if a person is suspected of having an unidentified condition is there a facility to refer them for additional help. K Haswell said they would go back to the Learning Disabilities Team and talk to the personal advisor for any Education and Health Care Plan (EHCP) has been turned down, we would put forward a recommendation that it was reassessed. Also as part of our statutory work on the advice and guidance side we provide all the preparation for adulthood part of the EHCP, so we will meet with the young person, we take into consideration their views and the views of the parents/carers.
Cllr Pringle mentioned that The Swan Budget in Berkhamsted has a great reputation and is well valued by parents and children, ... view the full minutes text for item 50.
Cllr Pringle asked about the high proportion that are vulnerable does not translate into high needs for housing, clearly vulnerable people are very highly represented in that group, do they need assistance and early intervention before it gets to that stage. In particular you mentioned a number of agencies that are not joined up, does that include social services, education, CAMHS, NHS, etc. At what level is there responsibility for ensuring that these are joined up and these interventions are put in place before people actually get to this stage.
Cllr Pringle said that quite often anti-social behaviour is generated by domestic abuse where the party who’s being abused doesn’t wish to take criminal proceedings or has other reasons for example being in fear and where the tenancy is in the name of the suspected abuser is there a mechanism for the tenancy being transferred to the victim.
Councillor Pringle asked if this charges will apply for very simple questions asked by applicants.
Councillor Pringle would like to know if the costs will be based on the size of the site N.March, the cost is calculated as a flat fee for some parts of the work such as average travel time, and then additional fees are charged depending on the number of units that a site has.
Councillor Pringle would like to know who is responsible for the fees N.March confirmed the Site owner is responsible for the cost of fees associated with the licence and they are not allowed to pass this cost onto the residents.
The Case Officer, Rachel Marber, introduced the report to members and said that the application had been referred to committee as it had been called in by Councillor Pringle.
Councillor Lara Pringle spoke in objection of the application.
Cllr Pringle asked what were the main identifying source of HMO’s, also have we any idea what proportion have we identified within the Borough and how are we going to reach the hard to find ones. N Beresford confirmed there are approximately 103 licences now. We believe from a BRE stock modelling report that was undertaken several years ago, there could be up to 600 and 900 HMO’s in the area.
Cllr Pringle queried when the behaviours are taking place in the locality rather than in the property itself, are we able to take action against the tenant. L Warden advised it would be difficult to take action under the tenancy if it’s not in the locality of the property but there are other steps that we could take.
Cllr Pringle asked what could be done if the problem is in sheltered and the tenant at number 1 is causing problems at number 20, so they are still on the premises but not in their own property. L Warden said that if it was in a scheme then the locality would be used. We would also look at safeguarding, we are keen to ensure we address those types of issues quickly.
Cllr Pringle said that we have a new Officer to support tenants with applications and those who are vulnerable or with mental health problems needing significant support, will this be a permanent position and therefore a permanent cost to the Council. K Kiely replied that the Universal Credit Officer is newly in post and we are yet to see fully how her role will pan out. At the moment she is doing a lot of liaison with DWP and the Job Centre, as a lot of the issues relate to the Job Centre not understanding housing and how tenancies work.
Cllr Pringle raised concerns that there are a lot of people who can’t walk off the street if they are hungry, they have to have a referral to the foodbank and wanted to check if Officers are able to refer to the foodbank, secondly do we know how much demand has increased since the introduction. L Warden advised that the Tenancy Sustainment Team and Homeless Team are signatories so they are able to issue vouchers. There has been a 44% increase in foodbank vouchers given out between January and April.
Cllr Pringle said that she had problems getting through on the telephone system. M Rawdon asked if anyone experiences problems please let him know. L Roberts confirmed this is a netcall problem and if we are aware of the details we can make the necessary changes.
Cllr Pringle spoke about a case from a resident and her concerns about supported housing and communal areas/safety and the mix of tenants, some being young and some being old with issues. She mentioned about training for staff and safeguarding issues, explaining that frail people do not have the use of the communal facilities.
Cllr Griffith asked Cllr Pringle to bring this specific case to the Officer to deal with.
Cllr Pringle mentioned that Cllr Williams at the last meeting commented that Dacorum Borough Council didn’t need to make any plans for the possibility of a chaotic no deal Brexit, because we are not Kent.
Cllr Pringle said that Cabinet has arranged to discuss this on the 19 th of March, just 10 days before we could crash out without any deal, and asked Cllr Williams if this was too little too late and can he explain the preparations that will be put in place to advise and support local businesses affected by this and also our EU27 residents who are tenants or Dacorum Borough Council employees and our neighbours.
Cllr Pringle asked how we publicise it, is it just on the website.
Cllr Pringle asked what the criteria was for a registered bid/charity.
Cllr Pringle asked if the initial assessment fails how it is down to the council to manage it.
Cllr Tindall advised that following completion of relevant training session, he is nominating Cllr Pringle as substitute to Licensing.
Councillor Pringle proposed the motion, seconded by Cllr England;
Councillor Pringle addressed the room and set out why she feels this motion is important. The proposed motion reads;
N Gibbs introduced the item to members and said it had been referred to the committee as it had been called in by Councillor Pringle.
In her role as Ward Councillor, Councillor Pringle spoke in objection to the application.
Councillor Pringle added that she would like to re-iterate on the importance of different types of activity for the community. She referred to the importance of informal exercise, many people use instead of formal exercise. She acknowledged the importance of Cupid Green in providing the community with informal exercise such as dog ... view the full minutes text for item 237.
Cllr Pringle asked if a tenant was in multiple occupancy would vulnerable people such as those that are autistic, would they be recognised for vulnerability.
Cllr Pringle referred to enforcement, Mental health.
In her role as ward councillor, Councillor Pringle spoke in objection to this application.
The Mayor welcomed Councillor Pringle to her first meeting.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Pringle attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Nov 2022 | Council | Change to committee dates | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Pringle was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 1 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Pringle declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Jan 2024 | Alcohol and Gambling Sub-Committee, item 3 | Councillor Pringle declared an interest as the premises was close to the boundary of her ward (Northchurch) and some of the residents may live within her ward. She explained that although she didn’t know anyone personally she wanted to be transparent. |
Where Councillor Pringle sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 2 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Licensing and Health and Safety Enforcement Committee | Committee Member | May 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.