Mayor
It was moved by Councillor Cllr Nigel Taylor, seconded by Councillor Rick Freedman unanimously.
Every time Dacorum's minutes name Councillor Freedman, as the council published it.
It was moved by Councillor Cllr Nigel Taylor, seconded by Councillor Rick Freedman unanimously.
Action Cllr Freedman to email the Chair, N Howcutt, C Dempsey and P Lazenby with further information on his suggestion of an audit on public consultation processes.
Councillor Elliot Chaired the meeting in the absence of Councillor Freedman.
Cllr Freedman asked a question.
Councillor Reynolds substituted for Councillor Freedman.
Cllr England advised that Cllr Freedman will replace Cllr Deacon on the Housing & Community Overview & Scrutiny Committee.
Cllr Freedman addressed Cllr Allen, Portfolio Holder of Corporate & Commercial Services and asked if the Portfolio Holder could amend his report to reflect that the ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Freedman substituted for Councillor Stewart.
Cllr Smith- Wright substituted for Cllr Freedman.
Cllr Freedman asked B Hosier to detail the consultation process, specifically how people would be notified, who would be asked for feedback, and how feedback would be collated and measured. B Hosier explained that in the case of changes with limited impact, typically the council employs a consultant to carry out the consultation, with every household impacted by the change contacted using a questionnaire with a range of questions for feedback and a free text area for general comment. In regard to a change with a wide range of impact, such as a change to tariffs, B Hosier explained that everything was done online, with adverts and notifications to direct individuals who wish to provide feedback appropriately.
Cllr Freedman further asked how feedback would be incorporated into a proposal. B Hosier confirmed that the proposal would be set out and approved by the cabinet, and questions would be asked around the proposals put forward, which the consultants would then use the feedback from to generate a report that would be published online for transparency.
Cllr Freedman noted that he had not received any items for discussion, and reiterated that these could be submitted at any time.
Cllr Freedman commented on the approach to the internal audit function and suggested that the approach taken last year would be the same as previous years with a focus on the council's consistency of operations.
Cllr Freedman stated that they have not exploited the value added function that internal audit should bring with more pronounced changes or threats that are being considered, such as the number of senior staff positions that have changed in recent years.
Cllr Freedman suggested that the internal audit process should come along with other strategic discussions to ensure this input is being given whilst these are being considered.
Cllr Freedman wondered if there should be a more visible link between parking sessions and PCNs (penalty charge notices). B Hosier agreed there would be some correlation, however noted that more PCNs were being issued for on-street parking than off-street parking, confirming that enforcement fluctuates from month to month, but that it appears people are parking more often but for shorter periods.
Cllr Freedman agreed that legal action wasn't possible for pavement parking, but suggested production of ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
In regard to 10% turnover being healthy, Cllr Freedman wondered what benchmarking was being used to use that definition, and also noted that on page 59 it was mentioned as being 15%, questioning whether that was because one figure was for a month and the other for a quarter. M Rawdon clarified that CIPD was the source for turnover of under 15% being healthy.
Cllr Freedman expressed surprise, and admitted concern that turnover had only been compared to other local councils with similar issues, but deferred to the team's assessment if it was against the UK environment as a whole.
Cllr Freedman requested a follow-up and lessons learned regarding the green bin subscription service, particularly in regards to sign-ups after the first collection and complaints received. M Rawdon agreed to take the feedback to the Head of Communications, who was not present at the meeting.
Cllr Adeleke for Cllr Anderson for Cllr Banks for Cllr Barratt for Cllr Barry-Mears for Cllr Bassadone for Cllr Beauchamp for Cllr Bhinder for Cllr Birnie abstain Cllr Chapman for Cllr Claughton for Cllr Douris for Cllr Durrant for Cllr Elliot for Cllr England for Cllr Foster for Cllr Freedman for Cllr Griffiths for Cllr Harden for Cllr Hearn for Cllr Hobson for Cllr Hollinghurst abstain Cllr Imarni for Cllr Johnson for Cllr Link for Cllr Maddern for Cllr Peter for Cllr Pringle for Cllr Ransley for Cllr Riddick for Cllr Rogers for Cllr Silwal for Cllr Sinha for Cllr Stevens for Cllr Su Mahmood for Cllr Sutton for Cllr Symington for Cllr Taylor for Cllr Timmis for Cllr Tindall for Cllr Townsend for Cllr Wilkie for Cllr Williams for
Cllr Freedman agreed that food banks are not new, but noted that in-work poverty is.
Moved by Cllr England, seconded by Cllr Freedman.
Cllr Freedman commented on the work to backdate training, noting that as they are coming up to a new intake, if people have not attended all mandatory courses, this is not necessary unless they are returning councillors.
Cllr Freedman suggested that the focus for DORIS should be providing training to staff and officers, and whilst it is positive for members to have access, they should be looking to direct members to in-person training.
Cllr Freedman agreed that this could be changed as the DORIS system develops, adding that with the changeover of staff for officers and for members who are unable to go in during working hours, training courses act as a positive relationship-building tool between members and officers and they should therefore avoid DORIS becoming the main delivery tool for members.
Cllr Griffiths agreed with Cllr Freedman that they should avoid creating additional work for staff, especially if no action is taken .
Cllr Freedman stated to find committed spending, they need to find if the purchase order placed on the external provider is split for each attendee or is global. If split, this information should be easy to get hold of, otherwise they will need to get this information manually.
Cllr Freedman noted that a lot of feedback is regarding the presentation of the course, though the main focus should be on the content of the course.
Cllr Freedman suggested that they could not make either approach mandatory and it would be for each political group to discuss.
Cllr Freedman agreed with the items already listed for the new member induction and recommended that they also include meeting the Member Support team and information on council communication with guidance on how emails are sent out and which addresses to send items back to.
Cllr Freedman stated that there should also be training regarding call-ins.
Cllr Freedman noted that the MDSG works well in facilitating good communication between councillors and recommended that it be used as a good example for building it up.
Cllr Freedman referred to animal control and advised of a number of links on the DBC website and those of other organisations that refer issues to the dog warden email address, which then states that the email is not monitored.
Cllr Freedman noted the data regarding Legal cases and asked if this is a highlight reel or if other cases had not been reported.
Cllr Freedman referred to the Mayoralty budget, noting that Berkhamsted Town Council have decided, given the current climate, to reduce the budget and scope in terms of Mayoral engagements, and recommended that a similar discussion be had at borough level.
Cllr Freedman acknowledged the comment and noted that his question was if the discussion was being had.
Cllr Freedman asked for further information on the tree maintenance service contract and the facilities management services contract.
Cllr Freedman made reference to the maintenance work provided to other Councils on behalf of HCC and asked if this was being carried out by the internal team or by outsourced teams.
Cllr Freedman asked if procurement decisions are benchmarked against bringing the work in-house.
Cllr Freedman commented that he would like to see the decision-making process and asked for reassurance that there is a review ... view the full minutes text for item 51.
Cllr Freedman asked how many current vacancies there are, how long it takes to fill a vacancy on average, and the percentage of vacancies versus total staff numbers.
Cllr Freedman commented on the escalation to a formal complaint, particularly regarding a resident's view of who they have complained to.
Cllr Freedman noted that sometimes residents will complain to a member and that members may treat these conversations as informal so won't note it down.
Cllr Freedman stated that they need to ensure that when a formal complaint is made, they bring in all the conversations that led up to it as residents will feel they started the process a lot earlier even if it is not treated in this way.
Councillor Stevens substituted for Councillor Freedman.
Cllr Freedman asked why multiple payment dates were set up. C Baker agreed that it would be beneficial to release the payments on one date, though the staggered payments were to ensure payments could be made as soon as possible to those who were eligible. It was also noted that payments were due to differing direct debit payment dates.
Cllr Freedman noted the time taken for debtors to pay and asked what type of debtor this includes, suggesting that they separate out the various types of debtors. N Howcutt explained that several debtor registers sit behind the report and stated that they could bring a report on debt provision after Q1 2022/23 to provide the Committee more detail on performance.
Cllr Freedman commented on RBF01 and asked if any delays on processing new claims are not causing delays to getting tenants into accommodation. C Baker advised that housing benefit claims are only made once someone is in accommodation and that new claims for housing benefit are made by a limited number of people with most housing costs now coming through Universal Credit.
Cllr Freedman commented that most wellness activities and support listed appeared to be reactive and recommended a KPI that tracks the number of adaptions requested by staff.
Cllr Freedman also suggested that they look at the difference in sickness leave between those who have had a change to where they are working versus those who have always had to attend physically. B Trueman advised that the dialogue between managers and officers is open and direct, and the culture is to be open and understanding. It’s in managers’ interests that officers are able to continue working and therefore adaptations are made where possible whilst also offering a service to residents.
An amendment to the motion was proposed by Councillor Freedman and seconded by Councillor Tindall.
Cllr Freedman commented that the analysis highlights current issues but doesn’t provide much detail on how to change it, and that he would like to see a record of what customer contact has been made. J Nason explained that a Customer Relationship Management system would enable them to do this and allow customers and officers to identify who was spoken to when and what information was provided. The CRM system will be part of Phase 2 and help resolve customer queries.
Cllr Freedman suggested that a questionnaire was sent prior to the training to optimise the training session. LF suggested that a drop-in session was held allowing IT and members to discuss issues and provide support. This could be a hybrid session as well to allow virtual attendance.
Cllr Freedman asked that this be extended into the evening to allow attendance for those who cannot be there during the working day and LF agreed to stay until 7-7.30pm to accommodate this. LF thought it would be helpful for those members who are proficient with the IT systems to offer support in the session to those members who are struggling.
Cllr Freedman felt a lot of time was spent on the Q&A throughout the session which meant the presentation part did not get finished as time ran out.
Cllr Freedman scans through it.
Cllr Freedman felt strongly that feedback was necessary for the training and felt it was a mark of respect for the trainer.
Cllr Freedman suggested that an embedded link is produced in the training session on Teams that allows the form to be populated and sent from your email automatically.
Cllr Freedman commented he was very much in support of The Elms and renewing the contract on 1+1 basis as it seemed a logical and reasonable approach. He wanted to flag up that if we change suppliers it is quite a risk, Dens is very good at building its brand across Dacorum as a whole and that he would worry that any new supplier would be seen as a Hemel only offer.
Cllr Freedman asked how we would ensure that any tender would look at how we could include that part of it. F Williamson said that the points made were very valid, Dens have a very good brand awareness and the hostel is managed properly. F Williamson added that any future procurement would include the brand awareness and that any new organisation would work across all of Dacorum.
Cllr Freedman agreed that the local plan date would possibly need to change, he also felt any training would need to be in a hybrid form however the users online should not be able to partake in the meeting so as not to distract the trainer.
Cllr Freedman commented that being a whole day course it will be difficult for those councillors that work, could it be delivered at the weekend?
Cllr Freedman said his idea would be that there is an event for new Councillors who join to meet up in person and to speak with Group Leaders and Officers as a “moral building” event.
Action: F Jump Cllr Freedman enquired as to the top line 2021 figures; in particular the lack of significant difference with the current year budgets. He stated an expectation to see an increase in many areas relating to slippage of works into the future year due to pandemic and other delays.
Cllr Freedman said that he has over simplified it and that he needed to look at the bigger picture over three years, then he should see a difference.
Cllr Freedman queried if the proposal for charges was compulsory but also people have discretion. O Jackson replied that the charge is mandatory but with other providers there is a tiered service, where the tenant can select the level of support they require and we would like to operate this system.
Cllr Freedman asked how the charge will be administered. O Jackson said that our income team arrange and collect the support charge, it’s applied on our housing management system Orchard and they will work closely with the tenants to ensure the charge is collected.
Cllr Freedman wondered if there will be some tenants current benefits mean that all the current charges are paid and then suddenly there is another charge they are responsible for, will there be concern amongst tenants. O Jackson replied that he didn’t think there would be concern as when they apply for the property the charge is included in the offer letter. We’ve undertaken communications to let tenants know about the charge.
Cllr Freedman was concerned for existing tenants who will suddenly get an increase in their bills, you’ve clearly tried to reduce the impact in the past and it seems fine for people moving into the property, but will we be including the charge in the maximum threshold for Housing Benefit. L Warden said we have discussed this and where a tenant has a £6 charge and Benefit would cover half of it, the Council pays the other half because they are on Benefit. If ... view the full minutes text for item 80.
Councillor Freedman thanked the officer for the report and suggested that the report should focus more on the known metrics such as how difficult is it to make contact once a tenant is identified as needing support and how much contact is required to get a response from them.
The following Motion was proposed by Councillor Freedman and seconded by Councillor Uttley:
Councillor Freedman said the motion was inspired by the RSPCA and other animal welfares charities aimed at making fireworks less frightening for animals and vulnerable people. Sadly fireworks inadvertently lead to the distress, injury and death of a significant number of family pets, farm animals and wildlife every year. He didn’t want to illustrate the evidence behind this claim especially as the motion didn’t call for any restrictions, rather it seeks to use the council’s position as a community leader to help educate people both to the dangerous side effects of fireworks but also to the safer, quieter alternatives that are becoming available.
Councillor Freedman referred to the backlog of work and the task and finish group that had been brought into look at it. He said he has had several complaints from residents when there requests haven’t received a response. He understood that works would be taking longer and work being prioritised, he asked if the team were looking at getting communication out to residents to acknowledge there is a delay in responses and planned works.
The following Motion was proposed by Councillor Tindall and seconded by Councillor Freedman:
Councillor Freedman ask if any comparisons had been done with the same period last year.
· Action: Councillor Freedman suggested speaking to the Communications team about Social Media platforms and whether they could provide internal training on this.
Councillor Freedman suggested holding an optional virtual training session on virtual meetings.
Councillor Freedman said that there had been significant changes made to rules and regulations due to Covid-19 and gave the example of Licensing. He suggested training on these changes.
Councillor Freedman said that it was important for Members to keep up-to-date so that they could inform residents.
Councillor Freedman added that changes could be difficult to predict.
Cllr Freedman echoed the thanks to staff and queried if post events, were there a number of things in the report that will have changed, also if the report was being prepared now would there be any key data you would highlight. F Jump advised that we are keeping a very close eye on the bad debts provision, it is under constant review, but realistically it ’ s too early to say exactly what the impacts are on this financial year.
Cllr Freedman noted that Universal Credit had been less adverse than had been prepared for. F Williamson advised that in respect of Universal Credit there had been a lot of F Jump presented the report and asked Committee for any questions.
Cllr Freedman asked if the Officer will be introduced to Members. M Gaynor confirmed that would be okay, many Members will know her as it’s Melanie Parr and ... view the full minutes text for item 40.
Cllr Freedman referred to recent increases in rent that has recently been communicated to tenants and asked; what sort of feedback has the Council received to that? LWarden advised that letters would have been received by tenants early this week. She confirmed a number of calls have been received with queries around service charges, but no concern of feedback has been expressed regarding increases.
Cllr Freedman expressed that he feels it is a very ... view the full minutes text for item 27.
Cllr Freedman advised he is in favour of the policy but gave some feedback that he is finding it quite difficult to scrutinise the report as there were some things that are perhaps not evident in the report. Cannot quite see what the target is, is there a target number of properties of specific sizes that we are trying to move? He added that when he read the policy it comes through very much what would happen if someone was going to move house right now.
LWarden thanked Cllr Freedman for feedback about targets, commenting that is something they will take back for consideration. LWarden then responded to the comments about waiting for a suitable property and then downsizing, advising that tenants who register to downsize will then apply for houses they see advertised that they are interested in, if they are successful, a member of the support team will contact that tenant and advise them they qualify for the incentive payment and will support them at that stage.
Cllr Freedman queried the number of new units for the Borough and how many people would benefit, will they be two person units or family units. F Williamson replied that the 280 units are not even at design stage at the moment. We constantly monitor the demand from allocations team in respect of the people that are on the active housing register, we also take regard for affordable units that are being delivered by registered providers in the area, to make sure that there isn’t an over provision of one particular unit type.
Cllr Freedman mentioned that given the amount that’s been borrowed for these units, looking at those requirements that you’ve seen so far and your expertise in the area of how much these things costs, would you be able to give a rough figure in terms of the amount of people we would expect, what I’m trying to work out is are we talking 280 retirement units or are we talking 280 family units. Most people will understand the amount of people that will be housed rather than units. F Williamson confirmed that we don’t have that level detail in the Business Plan at the moment, what we do have is some ongoing work around supply and demand, so you mentioned sheltered schemes and supported housing units and there is a piece of work that is ongoing around looking at supply and demand within that particular area.
Cllr Freedman said thank you very and that he was very glad to see that the council seized on being able to access more funds and build more, that’s certainly what we should be doing.
Councillor Freedman said that this may have been because several attendees were from Town and Parish Councils.
Councillor Freedman suggested two different Social Media sessions being offered . He said that one session could be mandatory, covering the legalities surrounding Social Media.
Councillor Freedman suggested that the second Social Media session could cover public awareness and engagement including information on using the best tools to communicate with residents.
Councillor Freedman said that, from his experience, using Facebook was currently the most useful platform for communicating with as many people as possible. He suggested that some people may be using new platforms but that his priority was to reach as many people as possible.
Councillor Freedman suggested that this year Facebook may remain at the fore.
Action: Councillor Freedman suggested speaking to the Communications team about Social Media platforms and whether they could provide internal training on this .
Councillor Freedman added that people might not be as honest in feedback if they knew that they could be identified.
Councillor Freedman said that he looked for something that he could immediately take away from courses to implement.
Councillor Freedman suggested that Members were encouraged to pre-submit questions ahead of the Planning training to make most effective use of the time.
Councillor Freedman asked whether it would be possible for an organisation chart to be provided on the intranet that went down to a lower level than Group Managers.
Cllr Freedman queried where almost all lines of the capital project lives in the slippage and asked if there was a way we could alter it so that effectively if you need to phase it to when the Council needs to have the resources available to be able to build things, but we had another part on the realistic expectation on the side, would help to be able to read this. If that’s not possible maybe having something that would actually giving predictions of any actual overspends, the way I’m reading this at the moment, every time I’m seeing the slippage, I’m thinking there’s potentially bad news that we’re not going to see until the last year that something is reported. It might make the report a little bit easier.
Cllr Freedman said he was interested in the examples that had been used for service charges in the report, for example you’ve used sprinkler systems would be considered a service charge because it’s a benefit to the tenants.
Cllr Freedman felt it was a good example of something that a landlord should be providing and would challenge whether costs like that should be included in the service charges. L Warden replied that there is a list of approved services that are considered under a service charge, at the moment we have very few sprinkler systems, but they require quite a lot of additional maintenance and upkeep and yes it is the responsibility as the landlord to provide that but that doesn’t change the fact that we also have pay for that service. That is something that we can pass on to tenants, because otherwise all of our tenants would covering the charges of that through normal rent, but they wouldn’t be receiving any of the benefit of that.
Cllr Freedman said he had used that as an example, but he thinks it’s contentious to say that it’s a benefit, so I’d be glad to get the list. The question is who has decided the list and has it been held up to scrutiny, probably tenants and leaseholders would be a good place to see that.
Cllr Freedman understands it’s a cost but we’ve also seen from previous comments on service charges that the money that we raise on service charges is not reserved for use on these things and therefore right at the moment you are producing a surplus.
Cllr Freedman is not arguing about the principle of service charges, but there is some subjectivity on what a tenant is going to consider a service charge, especially given what the private sector would regard a service charge. L Warden advised that the items need to be serviced is reproduced from the service cost for residential premises via statute and case law via the former Institute of Rent Officers Educational Trust 1994, that’s the best guidance that’s been produced, there’s not that much guidance on service charges for tenants, there is a huge list of items, we’ve made a decision not to apply all of those. We are concerned about making sure that things are affordable for our tenants, that’s a priority for us.
Cllr Mahmood was substituted by Cllr Sobaan Mahmood and Cllr Stevens substituted for Cllr Freedman
Cllr Freedman queried that there was no benchmarking on qualitative measures, for example, how many repairs fixed first time and stakeholders saying when a job is completed or not. Also the number of calls falling so drastically they must be doing quite well. I Prendergast confirmed that the measures for first time fix is about 87%, which is above the national average and the target set KPI for the contract which is 81%.
Cllr Freedman asked if there was anything on refused jobs, what happens if tenants call up and say I would like a plasma screen TV installed and we say no, are those numbers already included in the statistics or have they been filtered out. I Prendergast confirmed they are still in the core statistics as they are straight off the telephone lines, so they can’t tell what the call was about.
Councillor Freedman asked whether any of the previous member development opportunities had been oversubscribed.
Councillor Freedman noted that it was up to Group Leaders to make that call and in ensuring compliance from members in attending training.
Councillor Freedman added that it may be useful to liaise with officers and Group Leaders to select dates for sessions so that the maximum number of members could attend.
Councillor Freedman noted that the budget was being underspent anyway.
Councillor Freedman noted that it would have been useful to have been given ICT equipment first to use when meeting people in the marketplace for the first time. He continued that it would have been helpful to have a way in which to record names and numbers of officers that he met at the marketplace.
Councillor Freedman added that the titles of groups and distinguishing between each of them was difficult. He said that the induction was very useful and that there was a lot to learn.
Councillor Freedman said that the presentations were excellent but that it would have been useful to have a way in which to record the information.
Councillor Bhinder agreed with Councillor Freedman and noted that the volume of information could be overwhelming for a new councillor.
Councillor Freedman asked if members could be told about training for officers and whether members could also sign up to these sessions.
Councillor Freedman noted that if a members’ problem was with Direct Access, that ICT could not connect remotely.
Cllr Freedman mentioned the over-recovery on service charge ... view the full minutes text for item 38.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Freedman attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Freedman's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Freedman was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 7 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Freedman declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Freedman in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Freedman sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Finance and Resources Overview and Scrutiny | Chair | Dec 2022 | 3 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 2 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Strategic Planning & Environment Overview & Scrutiny | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 2 | |
| Audit | Vice-Chairman | Sep 2026 | 2 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.