Named15 Mar 2022Cabinet
Item from scrutiny committee - eradication of non-recyclable goods in school catering services
At the Leader’s invitation Councillor Arwel Roberts, Chair of Performance Scrutiny Committee presented the report recommending that Cabinet, on behalf of the Council, lobby Welsh Government to provide sufficient financial support to local authorities to help them eliminate the use of non-recyclable goods and facilitate carbon reduction measures in the School Catering Service, without compromising their ability to deliver a viable and sustainable school meals service.
Named15 Mar 2022Cabinet
Item from scrutiny committee - eradication of non-recyclable goods in school catering services
Councillor Roberts referred to the work undertaken with a view to eliminating the use of non-recyclable goods in the service to support the Council’s carbon neutral ambition for 2030. He reported on the Committee’s comprehensive discussion on the subject and valuable contributions to the debate from two pupils representing Ysgol Dinas Bran. Cabinet’s attention was drawn to the significant financial pressures facing the service and its reliance on income from the sale of plastic bottled drinks to provide nutritious and cost effective meals for pupils together with the additional forthcoming pressure to provide free school meals for all primary school pupils which further complicated matters.
Named15 Mar 2022Cabinet
Item from scrutiny committee - eradication of non-recyclable goods in school catering services
The Leader thanked Councillor Roberts for the report and work of the Scrutiny Committee and had been pleased to note the involvement of young people as part of that process to ensure they had a voice in matters affecting their future.
Named25 Jan 2022County Council
MINUTES
Matters Arising Cllr Arwel Roberts – Petition re: Abergele Road, Rhuddlan . A response had been received but not the one I wanted. I hope they will reconsider the situation because people with disabilities live along that road and they have to travel far just to cross that road.
Named7 Dec 2021County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
At this juncture, Councillor Arwel Roberts put forward a Petition to Full Council regarding the Abergele Road in Rhuddlan . He stated there had been a problem with drivers ignoring the speed limit along the Abergele Road and the petition was to lower the speed limit from 40 mph to 30 mph along the length of the road.
Said7 Dec 2021County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
Councillor Roberts expressed his thanks to Rhuddlan Town Council for purchasing a speed indicator device and also to Denbighshire County Council for organising the device to be located. The petition was also requesting a pedestrian crossing for walkers, residents and visitors for safety reasons when attempting to cross the road and there was a great need for more dropped kerbs for wheelchair users.
Said7 Dec 2021County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
Councillor Roberts confirmed he would pass on the petition to the highways officers in Denbigh.
Named7 Dec 2021County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
The Head of Legal, HR and Democratic Services confirmed on receipt of the petition by the relevant department, a response would be sent to Councillor Arwel Roberts within 14 days.
Named23 Nov 2021Cabinet
Meifod update
Councillor Arwel Roberts, Chair of Performance Scrutiny Committee thanked the Task and Finish Group for their work and reported upon the Committee’s lengthy discussions and further strengthening of the Task and Finish Group’s recommendations as detailed in the report, to invest in the service to ensure its reopening as soon as possible and to safeguard its future and provide a greater range of activities for service users whilst ensuring future provision conformed with relevant legislation and the Council’s Welsh Language policy. He had also been pleased to hear the views of a parent of one of the service users at the meeting.
Declared9 Nov 2021Welsh Language Steering Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Arwel Roberts declared a personal interest in agenda item 7, as he collected donations towards the Eisteddfod yr Urdd.
Asked9 Nov 2021Welsh Language Steering Committee
Mudiad meithrin
8 Councillor Arwel Roberts queried the Cylch Meithrin sites in Rhuddlan not being open since the Pandemic.
Named15 Jul 2021Performance Scrutiny Committee
Declaration of interests
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 – Councillor Arwel Roberts – Chair of the Rhuddlan Dementia Group Councillor Paul Penlington – Trustee and Volunteer for Young Carer’s Charity and wife worked for Young Carer’s Charity which provided services to the Council
Moved13 Jul 2021Welsh Language Steering Committee
Appointment of chair
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed Councillor Graham Timms for the position of chair, seconded by Councillor Ann Davies.
Moved13 Jul 2021Welsh Language Steering Committee
Appointment of vice chair
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed Councillor Emrys Wynne, which was seconded by Councillor Ellie Chair, there was no other nominations. All present were in agreement with the proposal.
Named10 Jun 2021Performance Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of vice-chair
Councillor Arwel Roberts nominated Councillor Hugh Irving for the position of Committee Vice-Chair.
Named10 Jun 2021Performance Scrutiny Committee
Declaration of interests
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda items 6 & 7 – Councillor Ellie Chard – School Governor Ysgol Tir Morfa Councillor Meirick Davies – School Governor Ysgol Cefn Meiriadog Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts – Parent & School Governor Ysgol Pen Barras Councillor Hugh Irving – School Governor Prestatyn High School Councillor Arwel Roberts – School Governor Ysgol y Castell Councillor Peter Scott – School Governor St. Asaph VP Infants School
Seconded18 May 2021County Council
Appointment of lay members to standards committee
Proposed by Councillor Barry Mellor and seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Said16 Mar 2021Welsh Language Steering Committee
Activities to promote the welsh language
Members discussed various issues arising from the report in more detail – · Councillor Arwel Roberts suggested a press article be produced on the excellent work undertaken to promote the Welsh language for inclusion in the local Welsh newspapers, such as Papyr Bro. The Welsh Language Officer agreed and also considered it a good way of promoting the council’s social media channels · the Welsh Language Officer responded to questions regarding staff induction confirming reference was ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Named5 Mar 2021Standards Committee
Attendance at meetings
The thoughts were echoed by Councillor Arwel Roberts who stated the Town Council worked well and it was pleasing to hear the observations of the Standards member following the meeting.
Said23 Feb 2021County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
Question put forward by Councillor Arwel Roberts on behalf of Plaid Group – “What changes are being considered to the services offered at present by DCC to visually impaired citizens?” Councillor Roberts confirmed he had received a response from Councillor Bobby Feeley, Lead Member for Well-being and Independence, which he would circulate to all Members for information.
Said23 Feb 2021County Council
Avoidance and reduction of plastics in denbighshire county council
Councillor Arwel Roberts introduced the Avoidance and Reduction of Plastics in Denbighshire County Council report (previously circulated). On 22 December 2020 a Special Meeting of Performance Scrutiny Committee took place and recommendations were supported as to how Council could reduce plastics.
Moved23 Feb 2021County Council
Avoidance and reduction of plastics in denbighshire county council
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed the report, seconded by Councillor Emrys Wynne.
Named16 Feb 2021Cabinet
Street naming and numbering policy review
However it was accepted that the Council had the option to vary the policy for exceptional cases to allow the honouring of an extraordinary individual which was considered the best way forward · in response to a question from Councillor Tony Thomas regarding the traditional approach of naming streets after particular organisations or sponsors, Councillor Mainon stated his personal preference that streets be named with a view to describing the locality and reflecting its cultural and historical significance in line with the general principles of the policy · Councillor Graham Timms highlighted initial problems caused in translation of the English policy into Welsh and in response to questions the Performance and Systems Administrator: (1) confirmed that a suggested list of street names had been included in the policy but the list was not definitive and ‘ Heol ’ would definitely be considered, (2) agreed to ask the Welsh Language Officer to revisit Section 1.12 on development block names to ensure the most appropriate prefixes were used in the Welsh language translations, and (3) advised that use of the word “flat” and “apartment” had been based on an historic definition · Councillor Arwel Roberts had initially requested the policy be considered by scrutiny and he congratulated the Lead Member and officers on the work undertaken. He reiterated the importance of Welsh place names which were part of the heritage and culture of the area and needed to b
Named28 Jan 2021Performance Scrutiny Committee
Declaration of interests
Councillor Ellie Chard – Ysgol Tir Morfa Councillor Huw Hilditch –Roberts - Ysgol Pen Barras and his children attended Welsh-medium education Councillor Hugh Irving _ Prestatyn High School Councillor Meirick Lloyd-Davies - Ysgol Cefn Meiriadog Councillor Paul Penlington - Ysgol y Llys and his children attended Welsh-medium education Councillor Arwel Roberts - Ysgol y Castell Neil Roberts - Ysgol y Parc Councillor Peter Scott - St.
Named15 Dec 2020Cabinet
Declaration of interests
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Finance Report – Councillor Meirick Davies – School Governor Ysgol Cefn Meiriadog Councillor Arwel Roberts – Trustee Cylch Meithrin Ysgol Dewi Sant
Said26 Nov 2020Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts confirmed he had attended Strategic Investment Group at which, bridges and flood recovery had been discussed. Those items were to be sent to Cabinet for discussion.
Named5 Oct 2020Communities Scrutiny Committee
Declaration of interests
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 4 Review of Cabinet Decision relating to 21st Century Schools Programme Band B Proposals – Councillor Meirick Davies – School Governor Ysgol Cefn Meiriadog Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts – Parent Ysgol Brynhyfryd / School Governor Ysgol Pen Barras Councillor Hugh Irving – School Governor Prestatyn High School Councillor Merfyn Parry – School Governor Ysgol Bryn Clwyd and Ysgol Gellifor Councillor Arwel Roberts – School Governor Ysgol y Castell Co-opted Member Neil Roberts – School Governor Ysgol y Parc Councillor Peter Scott – School Governor St.
Named1 Oct 2020Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
Page 5 – Councillor Ann Davies,corrected the declaration of interest as her grandson was a pupil at Ysgol Glan Clwyd Councillor Arwel Roberts also corrected the declaration of interest as he clarified he was no longer a Governor of Ysgol Dewi Sant Matters Arising – Page 6 – members questioned whether any further information was available regarding Meifod Wood and other work opportunities services currently being reviewed. The Scrutiny Co-ordinator confirmed enquiries had been made with the Service Manager, Client Services who had advised that COVID had caused a delay as a number of services had closed temporarily due to the pandemic. Progress had been made regarding Popty and Y Bont .
Said30 Jan 2020Performance Scrutiny Committee
Draft street naming and numbering policy
Councillor Arwel Roberts requested that his disagreement with the policy of not replacing English street name signs, as and when they required replacing, with bilingual signs be placed on record.
Named28 Nov 2019Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
Councillor Arwel Roberts was nominated to represent the Committee on the Planning, Public Protection and Countryside Services Service Challenge. All other representation remained the same.
Named28 Nov 2019Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts had attended the School Standards Monitoring Group (SSMG) for the new Christ The Word school in Rhyl. Despite the challenge of the increased size of the school he reported positive feedback on both the new Head Teacher and school itself from a group of pupils.
Said15 Oct 2019County Council
Welsh government: national development framework 2020-2040: consultation draft
Councillor Arwel Roberts expressed concern due to ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Said18 Jul 2019Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
Councillor Arwel Roberts raised an ongoing issue of dogs fouling in children’s parks. The CDEPR advised that it would be the planning and public protection service, he also acknowledged that the service may have dropped due to the decision to stop using an external consultant.
Named18 Jul 2019Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
The CDEPR advised Councillor Roberts to complete the Members Proposal Form to request the item return to scrutiny.
Seconded9 Jul 2019Welsh Language Steering Committee
Draft street naming and numbering policy
Councillor Arwel Roberts seconded Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts’ proposal.
Said13 Jun 2019Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts reported that it was his pleasure to attend the Legal, HR and Democratic Services meeting and praised the Head of Service, for his work.
Named30 May 2019County Council
Implementation of an alternative delivery model (adm) for various leisure related activities/functions
Councillor Arwel Roberts endorsed Councillor Feeley’s comments.
Named28 Mar 2019County Council
Arrangements for election of chair and vice chair
Councillor Rhys Thomas proposed Councillor Arwel Roberts, seconded by Councillor David Williams, to be the Vice Chair for the 2019/2020 municipal year.
Named28 Mar 2019County Council
Arrangements for election of chair and vice chair
11 votes for Councillor Arwel Roberts 28 votes for Councillor Alan James Councillor Alan James was nominated as the proposed Vice Chair for the 2019/2020 municipal year.
Said13 Mar 2019Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2018/0855/ pr - land east of tirionfa rhuddlan rhyl
Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) also spoke against the application. The development would have a detrimental effect on the identity of the town, and a negative impact on the Welsh language in the area. The concerns with the traffic were reiterated.
Said29 Jan 2019County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
Councillor Arwel Roberts raised the following question:
Asked4 Dec 2018County Council
MINUTES
Page 10 (Item 3) – Councillor Arwel Roberts asked the Lead Member for Housing, Regulation and the Environment, what was the current position regarding the Empty Homes Officer. Had an officer been appointed and what was the timescale?
Said23 Oct 2018County Council
MINUTES
Page 13 (Item 5) – Councillor Arwel Roberts requested an update on the provision for children with additional education needs through the medium of Welsh.
Said11 Sep 2018County Council
MINUTES
Page 8 (item 3) – Councillor Arwel Roberts requested further details of the Task & Finish Group which had been set up by GwE for the needs of children with communication issues through the medium of Welsh.
Said19 Jul 2018Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
Councillor Arwel Roberts requested it be noted that he was extremely disappointed Kingdom did not attend the Scrutiny meeting.
Asked3 Jul 2018County Council
Declarations of interest
Councillors Brian Blakeley and Ellie Chard both declared a personal interest in Item 3 (Question asked by Councillor Arwel Roberts) as they are Governors at Ysgol Tir Morfa, Rhyl.
Said3 Jul 2018County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
At this juncture, Councillor Arwel Roberts raised a question:
Named2 Jul 2018Welsh Language Steering Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Arwel Roberts – Member of the board for Menter Iaith Sir Dinbych .
Named2 Jul 2018Welsh Language Steering Committee
Welsh language monitoring report
Councillor Arwel Roberts commended the detailed report and proposed that the committee agree the content of the report.
Said7 Jun 2018Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts reported on a recent meeting of the School Standards Monitoring Group (SSMG) in which he had participated. Representatives from Ysgol Trefnant and Ysgol Frongoch had attended the meeting and been robustly challenged on a number of aspects relating to their education provision and performance.
Named7 Jun 2018Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Roberts was of the view that the SSMG was an effective forum for raising school standards.
Moved15 May 2018County Council
Appointment of the vice-chair of county council
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed that Councillor Meirick Lloyd Davies be elected Vice-Chair of the Council for the 2018/2019 municipal year.
Seconded15 May 2018County Council
Notice of motion
Councillor Arwel Roberts seconded the Notice of Motion put forward by Councillor Huw Jones.
Named26 Apr 2018Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts and Councillor Geraint Lloyd-Williams both praised a recent service challenge meeting which they had attended. Members asked that the latest list of scrutiny committee representatives on Service Challenge Groups be circulated to them.
Moved10 Apr 2018County Council
Arrangements for the election of chair and vice-chair
Election of Vice-Chair – Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed Councillor Meirick Lloyd Davies, seconded by Councillor Ann Davies, to be the Vice-Chair for the 2018/19 municipal year.
Named20 Mar 2018Cabinet
Finance report
It was highlighted that some local businesses had also been badly affected and suggested that Welsh Government could also take that aspect into account · members were encouraged to report any highway concerns through the CRM system so that they could be appropriately logged and actioned but Councillor Meirick Davies felt that there should be a separate mechanism for urgent works required in order to avoid any undue delay · tribute was paid to the work of Highways staff in responding to the recent adverse weather conditions and maintaining the county’s roads and Councillor Brian Jones advised that the Head of Highways and Environmental Services would include Cabinet’s appreciation in his communication to all staff involved · Councillor Arwel Roberts reiterated previous concerns regarding schools in deficit and subsequent impact due to increases in the state pension age.
Said15 Mar 2018Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts reported on a recent School Standards Monitoring Group (SSMG) meeting which he had attended. Two schools had been robustly challenged at that meeting in relation to their performance in delivering education and on school management matters.
Seconded14 Mar 2018Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2018/0028/pf - land adjacent to castle hill, hylas lane, rhuddlan
Proposal - Councillor Ann Davies proposed refusal of the application on the grounds of the conservation area and highway safety, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Moved30 Jan 2018County Council
Budget 2018/19 - final proposals
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed an amendment to the recommendation that £500,000 from reserves could be passed to the education department due to the fact that there were a number of schools in difficulty and under extreme pressure.
Named30 Jan 2018County Council
Budget 2018/19 - final proposals
At this juncture it was clarified by Councillor Roberts that the additional £500,000 be transferred from balances to education to be the subject of bids by schools for additional funding to support pupils with additional learning needs.
Named30 Jan 2018County Council
Member champions
Councillor Arwel Roberts was nominated as the Learning Disabilities Champion.
Named23 Jan 2018Cabinet
Declaration of interests
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Delivery of Band B 21st Century Schools Programme – Councillor Meirick Davies – Governor Ysgol Cefn Meiriadog & Ysgol Trefnant Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts – Governor Ysgol Brynhyfryd & Pen Barras /Parent Councillor Martyn Holland – Governor Ysgol Bro Famau Councillor Arwel Roberts – Governor Ysgol y Castell & Ysgol Dewi Sant Councillor Glenn Swingler – Governor Ysgol Pendref Councillor Rhys Thomas – Governor Ysgol Twm o’r Nant & Ysgol Frongoch Councillor Tony Thomas – Governor Ysgol Brynhedydd /Child in St.
Seconded18 Dec 2017Welsh Language Steering Committee
Appointment of chair
Councillor Tony Thomas proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that Councillor Graham Timms be appointed Chair.
Named7 Dec 2017Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
Councillor Ellie Chard proposed Councillor Arwel Roberts represent the Committee at the group’s meetings.
Named7 Dec 2017Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
Both nominations were seconded and on being put to the vote Councillor Arwel Roberts was appointed the Committee’s representative on the SSMG, with Councillor Ann Davies acting as the Committee’s substitute representative if Councillor Roberts were unable to attend a meeting.
Named7 Dec 2017Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
RESOLVED that – (i) subject to the above observations and amendments, the Forward Work Programme be approved; and (ii)Councillor Arwel Roberts be appointed as the Committee’s representative on the School Standards Monitoring Group (SSMG) with Councillor Ann Davies acting as Councillor Roberts’ substitute on SSMG if he was unavailable to attend a meeting.
Named19 Oct 2017Communities Scrutiny Committee
Declaration of interests
The following councillors declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 5 – Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts – Chair of Governors Ysgol Pen Barras Councillor Merfyn Parry – Governor Ysgol Rhewl, Ysgol Bryn Clwyd, Ysgol Gellifor Councillor Arwel Roberts – Governor Ysgol y Castell & Ysgol Dewi Sant Councillor Huw Williams – Parent of child in Ysgol Pen Barras Councillor Emrys Wynne – Governor Ysgol Borthyn and he had also been involved, along with family members, in the campaign to support Category 1 education (language) in the Pentrecelyn and Llanfair Dyffryn Clwyd area.
Named17 Oct 2017County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
At this juncture, Councillor Arwel Roberts handed a Petition to the Chair due to the dangerous speed and road on a section of Highlands Road, Rhuddlan .
Named17 Oct 2017County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
Councillor Roberts was hoping the Petition would ensure speed restrictions would be put on the road. The Chair confirmed the Petition would be passed on to the relevant Department.
Said11 Oct 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2017/0705 - deansfield, hylas lane, rhuddlan, rhyl
Local Member, Councillor Arwel Roberts stated he was in support of the application following a recent Site Inspection Panel meeting.
Seconded28 Jun 2017Licensing Committee
Appointment of chair
Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that Councillor Hugh Irving be appointed Chair.
Named28 Jun 2017Licensing Committee
Review of street trading policy
Councillor Arwel Roberts did not recall the draft policy being submitted to Rhuddlan Town Council but advised that he would make enquiries.
Said28 Jun 2017Licensing Committee
Review of street trading policy
In response to concerns raised by Councillor Roberts regarding the cost of road closures for community events it was established that it was not a matter for consideration under the street trading policy but could be an issue for scrutiny to consider.
Said28 Jun 2017Licensing Committee
Review of street trading policy
Councillor Roberts agreed to submit a member proposal form to the Scrutiny Chairs and Vice Chair’s Group directly in that regard.
Moved23 May 2017County Council
Appointment of the chair of county council
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed Councillor Meirick Lloyd Davies to be elected Chair, outlining his experience and qualities.
Said23 May 2017County Council
Annual review of political balance and appointment of scrutiny chairs
Councillor Arwel Roberts raised the question of who had made the decision for 8 Members to be on Cabinet. The MO/HL&DS confirmed Council had made the decision for the number of Members on Cabinet. If the number of Members were to be increased, then it would need to be put before Full Council to change.
Seconded12 Apr 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 11/2016/1258/po - land at tyn y celyn, clocaenog, ruthin
Proposal – Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts, that the application be granted, contrary to officer recommendation, subject to planning conditions (including occupancy) to be agreed with the Local Member, on the grounds that full account of the applicants’ businesses had not been made during the assessment of key tests for Technical Advice Note (TAN) 6 and that the economic benefits to the area generally outweighed particular issues in relation to that TAN.
Named23 Mar 2017Communities Scrutiny Committee
Regulation of unmanned aircraft
The Lead Member for Public Realm presented the report (previously circulated) and informed the Committee that the report had been submitted to them in response to County Council’s request - following its debate in December 2016 on a Notice of Motion put forward by Councillor Arwel Roberts seeking the flying of ‘drones’ to be banned over all public places in Denbighshire. County Council had determined that Scrutiny consider whether the Council should introduce further restrictions, to those already provided for by law, in relation to the flying of unmanned aircraft. The Head of Legal, HR and Democratic Services (HLHR&DS) had provided the Committee with a report detailing the regulatory framework relating to the use of unmanned aircraft, listing the acts and regulations which currently governed their use.
Said23 Mar 2017Communities Scrutiny Committee
Regulation of unmanned aircraft
Councillor Arwel Roberts advised the Committee that following his notice of motion he had received an e-mail from a London based global security company in relation to drone related problems, including noise nuisance. The company was offering to help individuals or ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Said16 Mar 2017Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts informed Committee Members he had attended meetings of the School Standards Monitoring Group (SSMG) focussing on Ysgol Glan Clwyd. It had been an extremely positive meeting and although the building work was yet to be completed the remodelling had been well received and the Headteacher had a positive, aspirational vision for the school’s future. In contrast, during another SSMG meeting some concerns were expressed in relation to the sustainability of the position of one Welsh medium primary school in the county due to the condition of the building and work pressures on staff.
Named15 Mar 2017Planning Committee
Declarations of interest
Councillor Joe Welch – Personal Interest – Agenda Item 5 Councillor Arwel Roberts – Personal Interest – Agenda Items 5 & 11 Councillor Ann Davies – Personal Interest – Agenda Item 11
Declared15 Mar 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 01/2016/0374/pf - land at cae topyn, off old ruthin road, ffordd eglwyswen, denbigh
Councillor Arwel Roberts declared a personal interest in this item in so far as it related to the Chapel where he often preaches.] An application had been submitted for erection of 75 no. dwellings, together with associated roads, open space and related works at land at Cae Topyn , off Old Ruthin Road, Ffordd Eglwyswen , Denbigh.
Seconded15 Mar 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 01/2016/1241/pf - site of former denbigh technology and vocational education centre, middle lane, denbigh
Proposal – Councillor Barry Mellor proposed the officer recommendations to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Said15 Mar 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2017/0055/pf - land at 31 princes park, rhuddlan, rhyl
General Debate – Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) spoke in favour of the application advising that the family had lived in Rhuddlan for generations and there was a housing need in the area. He reported that the applicant was willing to provide appropriate screening to address the issue of overlooking and ensure no adverse effect on visual amenity.
Moved15 Mar 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2017/0055/pf - land at 31 princes park, rhuddlan, rhyl
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed, seconded by Councillor David Simmons, that the application be granted subject to visual screening conditions to address overlooking concerns.
Declared15 Mar 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2017/0072/pf - land adjacent to castle hill, hylas lane, rhuddlan, rhyl
Councillor Arwel Roberts declared a personal interest because he was a Governor at Ysgol y Castell which was situated close to the application site.] An application was submitted for erection of 1 no. dwelling with detached garage and construction of a new vehicular access at land adjacent to Castle Hill, Hylas Lane, Rhuddlan .
Said15 Mar 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2017/0072/pf - land adjacent to castle hill, hylas lane, rhuddlan, rhyl
Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) agreed highlighting the historic significance of the area and his concerns over highway safety with the creation of an additional access point which he believed would exacerbate the existing traffic problems and congestion at peak times.
Moved15 Mar 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2017/0072/pf - land adjacent to castle hill, hylas lane, rhuddlan, rhyl
Proposal – Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed that the application be refused on highway safety grounds, seconded by Councillor Dewi Owens.
Named31 Jan 2017County Council
MINUTES
At this juncture, Councillor Arwel Roberts wished to thank the Head of Legal, HR and Democratic Services for the work carried out regarding “Drones”.
Named31 Jan 2017County Council
MINUTES
Councillor Roberts extended thanks to Councillor Jason McLellan and the Scrutiny Chairs and Vice-Chairs Group who discussed “Drones” and also the businesses who rely on them.
Said11 Jan 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 40/2016/0256/pc - fields south-west of borth crossroads, abergele
Councillor Arwel Roberts reported upon the site visit undertaken on 12 September 2016. He referred to numerous accidents on the carriageway and considered the site access/egress to be very dangerous. He believed granting the application would exacerbate the situation and agreed with officers that the application should be refused on highway safety grounds.
Moved11 Jan 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 40/2016/0256/pc - fields south-west of borth crossroads, abergele
Consequently Councillor Roberts proposed that the application be refused in accordance with officer recommendation.
Named11 Jan 2017Planning Committee
Application no. 40/2016/0256/pc - fields south-west of borth crossroads, abergele
Consequently Councillor Alice Jones seconded the proposal by Councillor Arwel Roberts that the application be refused in accordance with officer recommendation.
Named6 Dec 2016County Council
Notice of motion
Councillor Arwel Roberts put forward the following Notice of Motion for the consideration of Full Council.
Moved12 Oct 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 15/2016/0828/pf - 19 maes ial, llanarmon yn ial, mold
Proposal – Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Dewi Owens.
Seconded14 Sep 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 01/2016/0672/pf - denbigh museum, grove road, denbigh
Proposal – Councillor Meirick Davies proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that the application be granted.
Said14 Sep 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2016/0378/pf - land adjoining morfa lodge, abergele road, rhuddlan
Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) noted the intention to create a new access for agricultural vehicles separate to the existing access point which would be retained for the dwelling and outbuilding. He was in favour of granting the permission for access for agricultural purposes (and the annual festival) but stressed that if ever there was a change of use the permission for access should come before Planning Committee again. However he did raise concerns regarding safety of the existing entrance in use given the large vehicles using that access point.
Seconded27 Jul 2016Planning Committee
APPLICATION NO.08/2016/0487 - Tyn Y Wern, Corwen
Proposal – Councillor Meirick Lloyd Davies proposed the Officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Said14 Jul 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts reported upon the last Schools Standards Monitoring Group (SSMG) meeting advising that the two schools considered had performed very well and had been well supported by GwE. However, during meetings of the SSMGs pupil absenteeism continued to be raised as an issue of concern. The Scrutiny Coordinator advised that Communities Scrutiny Committee would be considering the School Absenteeism Policy at their meeting on 8 September 2016.
Named28 Jun 2016Cabinet
Final revenue outturn 2015/16
Councillor Arwel Roberts detailed his concerns regarding the route for pupils from ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Seconded22 Jun 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 03/20160063 - ross newydd, abbey road, llangollen
Seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Named22 Jun 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2016/0200 - land at marsh road, rhuddlan
General Debate – Local Member, Councillor Arwel Roberts, confirmed that he had received a number of messages from local residents in support of the development. A large number of elderly people resided in Rhuddlan and the development would ease the pressure of them travelling to Rhyl or Prestatyn for their shopping.
Moved22 Jun 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2016/0200 - land at marsh road, rhuddlan
Proposal – Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Cefyn Williams.
Named9 Jun 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of vice chair
Councillor Raymond Bartley nominated Councillor Arwel Roberts, seconded by Councillor Gareth Sandilands. No other nominations were received and it was, therefore;
Named9 Jun 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of vice chair
RESOLVED that Councillor Arwel Roberts be appointed as the Performance Scrutiny Committee’s Vice-Chair for the 2016/17 municipal year.
Said9 Jun 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
12 April, 2016 Councillor Arwel Roberts stated that the point he had raised during the meeting regarding the number of Performance Scrutiny Committee Members sitting on the Task & Finish Group had not been included within the minutes.
Said9 Jun 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
Councillor Arwel Roberts stated that the issue of the Rhuddlan to Ysgol Dewi Sant route was still to be resolved. Members expressed their concern and that the safety of the children was paramount.
Said9 Jun 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
Councillor Roberts advised that the temporary school transport arrangements to take children from Rhuddlan to the school, which he had arranged, were unsustainable in the long term.
Seconded8 Jun 2016Licensing Committee
Appointment of chair
Councillor Bill Cowie proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that Councillor Cefyn Williams be appointed Chair.
Seconded18 May 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 41/2015/1229 - the warren, mold, bodfari
Proposal – Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that the application be deferred to allow further discussion to take place.
Moved18 May 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 15/2016/0009 - pen y coed, eryrys, mold
Proposal – Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Barry Mellor.
Seconded10 May 2016County Council
Appointment of the chair of county council
Councillor Arwel Roberts seconded the proposal adding Councillor Davies would be an excellent Chair for the Council and was happy to support the nomination.
Said28 Apr 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Roberts stated that officers were currently monitoring the situation at Ysgol Gellifor and Ysgol Bryn Clwyd, Llandyrnog as both schools currently shared the services of a temporary Headteacher .
Seconded20 Apr 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 43/2016/0106/tp - 113 meliden road, prestatyn
Proposal – Councillor Peter Evans advised that he had visited the site and was happy to propose the officer recommendation to grant the application which was seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Said20 Apr 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2016/0180/pf - 43 heol hendre, rhuddlan
General Debate – Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) noted the comments submitted by Rhuddlan Town Council and advised that he had taken no part in that debate. Having visited the site he had no objection to the application.
Moved20 Apr 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2016/0180/pf - 43 heol hendre, rhuddlan
Proposal – Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Cefyn Williams.
Asked12 Apr 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Declaration of interests
Councillor Roberts asked to have it noted that he thought this was very unfair.
Seconded12 Apr 2016County Council
Arrangements for the election of chair and vice-chair of council
Election of Chair – Councillor Martyn Holland proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts, that Councillor Ann Davies be nominated Chair for the 2016/17 municipal year. There were no further nominations.
Seconded12 Apr 2016County Council
Committee timetable 2016/2017, annual review of political balance and appointment of scrutiny chairs
At this point, Councillor Meirick Lloyd Davies nominated himself to become a Member on Standards Committee, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts. There was a unanimous show of hands in agreement.
Asked17 Mar 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
Primary School Transport – Councillor Arwel Roberts enquired on the current position with respect to the school transport provision for children from Rhuddlan attending Ysgol Dewi Sant , Rhyl. His concerns related to the fact that free transport was due to be withdrawn at the end of the spring term and that parents were still awaiting notification on whether they would be entitled to transport, either free or concessionary, from the beginning of the summer term. He was also concerned that he as one of the local members was not being kept informed of matters relating to this issue and that, despite cross-party support for his recommendation at the last meeting that the Council use its discretionary power to arrange concessionary travel for the pupils, nothing seemed to be happening.
Named17 Mar 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
Councillor Roberts indicated that he wished scrutiny to look at the matter again. The Scrutiny Co- ordinator requested that he complete a ‘scrutiny proposal form’ to enable the Scrutiny Chairs and Vice-Chairs Group to consider his request. The Chief Executive suggested that scrutiny may wish, if the route was deemed safe, to consider the effectiveness of the new arrangements in due course.
Named17 Mar 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
He assured Councillor Roberts and the Committee that local Elected Members would be advised of the outcome of the road safety assessment and any associated decision before parents. He also undertook to investigate the claim that officers had not been willing in this case to share information with local members, and report back to members on the issue. He assured members that as a matter of courtesy officers would usually keep local members informed on matters in their wards.
Named17 Feb 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 40/2015/1150 - ty fry inn, ty fry lane, bodelwyddan
Councillor Arwel Roberts supported Councillor Alice Jones’ proposal.
Said17 Feb 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2015/1075 - tirionfa, rhuddlan
Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) stated he was against the development, as were Rhuddlan Town Council. He stated the allocated site was farming land and should not be utilised for a residential development.
Said17 Feb 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2015/1075 - tirionfa, rhuddlan
Councillor Roberts raised the issue of the land being marsh land, the fact there was no GP in Rhuddlan, and the local schools were full.
Said17 Feb 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2015/1075 - tirionfa, rhuddlan
Councillor Roberts stated he wished to have sight of a road traffic survey.
Named17 Feb 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2015/1075 - tirionfa, rhuddlan
Councillor Ann Davies (Local Member) also stated she was against the development for similar reasons as stated by Councillor Roberts.
Moved17 Feb 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2015/1075 - tirionfa, rhuddlan
Proposal – Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed, seconded by Councillor Alice Jones that the application be refused, contrary to officer recommendation.
Seconded17 Feb 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 46/2015/0984 - land off cwttir lane, st. asaph
Seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Named28 Jan 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Declaration of interest
Asaph VP Infants Councillor Arwel Roberts – Governor Ysgol y Castell & Ysgol Dewi Sant Councillor Gareth Sandilands – Governor Ysgol Clawdd Offa The following co-opted members declared a personal interest as follows – Debra Houghton – agenda items 7 & 8 – Governor Denbigh High School & Ysgol Pendref Dawn Marjoram – agenda item 8 – Governor Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn John Piper – agenda items 6 & 8 – Governor Ysgol Tremeirchion and child uses free school transport
Named28 Jan 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Election of vice-chair
Councillor Gareth Sandilands proposed, seconded by Councillor Meirick Davies that Councillor Arwel Roberts be Vice-Chair.
Named28 Jan 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Election of vice-chair
In the absence of any further nominations and upon being put to the vote it was – RESOLVED that Councillor Arwel Roberts be appointed Vice-Chair of the Performance Scrutiny Committee for the remainder of the 2015/16 municipal year.
Named28 Jan 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Primary school transport
The report had been requested by Councillor Arwel Roberts in light of recent changes to transport provision in the Rhuddlan and Dyserth areas and included reference to the legislative basis for providing school transport as detailed in the Learner Travel (Wales) Measure 2008. Members were advised that the policy on Primary School Transport had not changed in the recent September 2015 revision. However, following this review the Service did ensure that Primary and Secondary transport to the ‘nearest suitable school’ was being applied correctly.
Named28 Jan 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Primary school transport
Councillor Arwel Roberts quoted from a recent National Assembly for Wales’ Children, Young People and Education Committee’s Inquiry into Welsh in Education Strategic Plans (WESPs) which referred to local authorities’ discretionary powers “to provide free transport to Welsh-medium schools regardless of the distance criteria in order to promote access to education and training through the medium of Welsh” and to their “general duty to promote access to education through the medium of Welsh when exercising functions under the 2008 Learner Travel Measure.” Members raised the following points – · that the Authority should utilise its discretionary powers in this area as despite proposed improvements to the crossing by Bryn Cwybr , the route would still be a hazardous one at that point and also at Bryn Cwnin · similar problems could occur in relation to other primary school routes · queried whether the policy was consistent with the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents’ ( RoSPA ) guidance · questioned whether the application of the policy in this particular instance was placing policy before children’s safety · queried whether all policies in the field of education complemented each other, as in this case it seemed that the primary school transport policy seemed to be at odds with the Welsh in Education Policy.
Said28 Jan 2016Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts reported upon on the last Schools Standards Monitoring Group involving Ysgol Bryn Hyfryd and Ysgol Emmanuel which had proved interesting and informative.
Named26 Jan 2016County Council
MINUTES
Page 10, Item 6 – Third Bullet Point Councillor Arwel Roberts as whether detailed information had been provided.
Said20 Jan 2016Planning Committee
MINUTES
Page 20 – Application No. 40/2013/1585/PO – Land East of Bodelwyddan – Councillor Arwel Roberts spoke on behalf of Councillor Alice Jones requesting that an item on the ‘Community Planning in Progress Group’ be added to the agenda for the Elwy Member Area Group (MAG) meeting in February. The Head of Planning and Public Protection advised that the Elwy MAG would not be meeting in February but confirmed the item had been added to the agenda for the March meeting.
Seconded20 Jan 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 46/2015/0969/pf - former pilkington special glass site, glascoed road, st. asaph
Proposal – Councillor Meirick Davies urged members to consider the detrimental impact on the residential amenity of Derwen Deg and he proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that the application be refused, on the grounds that the application did not comply with LDP Policy RD1 (i), (iii), (v), (vi), (viii) and (xiii).
Named20 Jan 2016Planning Committee
Application no. 45/2015/0780/pr - ocean beach site, wellington road, rhyl
Councillor Arwel Roberts concurred with that view and requested that consideration be given to finding a Welsh name for the site. The Development Manager confirmed that the developers were in agreement with the council’s bilingual policy and would discuss the issue with members when seeking advertisement consent.
Named10 Dec 2015Performance Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
The Scrutiny Co-ordinator informed members that Councillor Arwel Roberts had chaired the above meeting in the absence of the chair and that this should have been reflected in the minutes.
Named16 Nov 2015Communities Scrutiny Committee
Call-in of the cabinet decision of 27 october 2015 relating to ysgol llanfair dyffryn clwyd and ysgol pentrecelyn
Councillor Arwel Roberts, as the lead signatory of the ‘notice of call-in’ was invited to present the case to review Cabinet’s decision. He emphasised that whilst he and his co-signatories welcomed the decision to build a new area school they were disappointed that the new school would be a Category 2, dual stream school, to replace the current Category 1 (Welsh Medium) and Category 2 schools. They were of the view that this approach undermined national policy.
Said17 Sep 2015Partnerships Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
Councillor Arwel Roberts confirmed that each Town Council were in support of the initiative. Rhyl Town Council would have finances for only 20 cameras.
Said17 Sep 2015Partnerships Scrutiny Committee
Minutes of the last meeting
Cllr Roberts confirmed Rhuddlan Town Council would not enter into an agreement until all Rhuddlan CCTV cameras were in working order.
Seconded16 Sep 2015Planning Committee
Application no. 05/2015/0353/pf - pen y graig (south west of plas tirion) glyndyfrdwy, corwen
Proposal – Councillor Cefyn Williams proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that the application be granted subject to a condition to secure ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Said16 Sep 2015Planning Committee
Application no. 40/2014/1445/pf - land at ty fry inn, ty fry lane, bodelwyddan
General Debate – In the absence of Councillor Alice Jones (Local Member), Councillor Arwel Roberts spoke on her behalf and referred to an email sent to committee members detailing her concern over the use of the Ronaldway road by delivery vehicles.
Moved16 Sep 2015Planning Committee
Application no. 40/2014/1445/pf - land at ty fry inn, ty fry lane, bodelwyddan
Proposal – Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed, seconded by Councillor Meirick Davies, that the application be granted in accordance with officer recommendations subject to an additional condition restricting traffic movement of delivery vehicles entering and exiting the site via Ronaldsway to ensure the safety of road users.
Seconded8 Sep 2015County Council
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
Proposed by the Leader, Councillor Hugh Evans and seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Seconded15 Jul 2015Planning Committee
Application no. 05/2015/0040/pf - land off green lane, corwen
Proposal – Councillor Stuart Davies proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts, that the application be granted, contrary to officer recommendation, on the basis that flood risk could be mitigated in this case via conditions attached to planning permission, and that power be delegated to officers and local members to apply planning conditions to the consent.
Said15 Jul 2015Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2015/0364/pf - 6 grove terrace, princes road, rhuddlan, rhyl
Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) also spoke in favour of the application and felt a precedent had already been set in the area.
Named30 Jun 2015Cabinet
Declarations of interest
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 – Councillor Joan Butterfield – Governor Ysgol Tir Morfa Councillor Meirick Davies – Governor Ysgol Cefn Meiriadog & Ysgol Trefnant Councillor Bobby Feeley – Governor Rhos Street School Councillor Martyn Holland – Governor Ysgol Bro Famau Councillor Huw Jones – Governor Ysgol Caer Drewyn & Ysgol Carrog Councillor Merfyn Parry – Governor Ysgol Bryn Clwyd & Ysgol Gellifor Councillor Arwel Roberts – Governor Ysgol y Castell & Ysgol Dewi Sant Councillor David Simmons – Governor Ysgol Tir Morfa Councillor David Smith – Grandson in Ysgol Pen Barras Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill – Governor Ysgol Clawdd Offa Councillors Bobby Feeley, Hugh Irving and Julian Thompson-Hill declared a personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 11 relating to Cefndy Healthcare. As those members had been nominated by the Council to the Cefndy Healthcare Management Board they had been granted an exemption under the Code of Conduct and permitted to take part in the debate and vote on the item.
Said11 Jun 2015Performance Scrutiny Committee
Urgent matters as agreed by the chair
Councillor Arwel Roberts introduced the call-in request and began the debate by outlining the four points which were the grounds for the call-in.
Named11 Jun 2015Performance Scrutiny Committee
Director of social services annual report 2014/15
The Council’s Welsh language portfolio holder, Councillor Huw Ll Jones, attended the Service’s Welsh Language Monitoring Group and Councillor Arwel Roberts would be in attendance in the near future. The Group monitored the Service’s compliance with the “ Mwy Na Geiriau – More Than Words” Action Plan.
Named2 Jun 2015Cabinet
Declaration of interests
Asaph VP Infants Councillor Merfyn Parry – Governor Ysgol Bryn Clwyd & Ysgol Gellifor Councillor Arwel Roberts – Governor Ysgol y Castell & Ysgol Dewi Sant Councillor David Smith – Grandson in Ysgol Pen Barras Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill – Governor Ysgol Clawdd Offa Councillor Cefyn Williams – Governor Ysgol Bro Dyfrdwy Councillor Huw Williams – Son in Ysgol Pen Barras
Seconded12 May 2015County Council
Appointment of the vice-chair of county council
Councillor Arwel Roberts seconded the nomination referring to Councillor Davies’ work for the community.
Named16 Apr 2015Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
The SC requested that Councillor Roberts complete and submit a Member’s proposal form if he wished the matter to be considered by the Committee, following his deliberations with the respective officer. The Chief Executive explained that following consideration of the budget proposals, and as a result of financial constraints, the Council was no longer providing a pest control service. However, in an attempt to assist customers one of the telephone numbers provided directed customers to the National Centre for pest control which was based in Birmingham.
Said15 Apr 2015Planning Committee
Site development brief 'rhuddlan triangle' - adoption of final document
Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) also spoke in favour of the SDB but highlighted the risk of flooding associated with the area and the need for traffic management if the site was to be developed including easing congestion, road improvements and access to the site.
Seconded14 Apr 2015County Council
Arrangements for the election of chair and vice-chair of council
Election of Vice Chair – Councillor Martyn Holland proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that Councillor Ann Davies be nominated for Vice Chair for the 2015/16 municipal year.
Seconded18 Mar 2015Planning Committee
"conservation areas" supplementary planning guidance - adoption of final document
Seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Named10 Dec 2014Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2014/0830/pc - ciet(uk) ltd, old water works, abergele road, rhuddlan, rhyl
Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member) referred to the site history and current context highlighting the difficulty in balancing the need for business and safeguarding residential amenity. Consequently he asked that deliveries to the site be restricted to between 0900 and 17.00 Monday to Friday.
Said10 Dec 2014Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2014/0953/pf - 6 grove terrace, princes road, rhuddlan, rhyl
Councillor Arwel Roberts advised that he had not been present at the recent site visit and his attendance had been wrongly recorded in the supplementary papers.
Seconded10 Dec 2014Planning Committee
Application no. 44/2014/0953/pf - 6 grove terrace, princes road, rhuddlan, rhyl
Proposal – Councillor Ann Davies proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts, that the application be deferred.
Seconded10 Dec 2014Planning Committee
Application no. 01/2013/1599/pf - the forum, 27 - 29 high street, denbigh
Proposal – Councillor Meirick Davies proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that the application be deferred.
Seconded10 Dec 2014Planning Committee
Application no. 01/2013/1601/lb - the forum, 27 - 29 high street, denbigh
Proposal – Councillor Meirick Davies reiterated his view (under the previous item) that inadequate plans had been provided with the application and he proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts, that the application be deferred.
Seconded10 Dec 2014Planning Committee
Application no. 41/2014/0757/pf - yew tree, bodfari, denbigh
An application was submitted for erection of replacement two-storey dwelling and garage (amendment to previously approved scheme under ref no. 41/2013/1498/PF) at Yew Tree, Bodfari , Denbigh Proposal – Councillor David Simmons proposed the recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Seconded12 Nov 2014Planning Committee
Draft site development brief: rhuddlan triangle
She proposed the officer recommendation as detailed within the report which was seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts (Local Member).
Named12 Nov 2014Planning Committee
Draft site development brief: rhuddlan triangle
In welcoming the SDB Councillor Roberts put forward a number of ideas including the establishment of a tourist centre, retail and souvenir shops in order to attract visitors into the town together with landscaping measures near the riverside and a jetty. He also questioned residential provision and mitigation measures to manage flood risk. Members discussed those issues further during general debate and sought clarification in that regard.
Seconded12 Nov 2014Planning Committee
Draft site development brief: rhuddlan triangle
Proposal – Councillor Ann Davies proposed the officer recommendation, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts. It was unanimously – RESOLVED that members agree the draft Site Development Brief for the ‘ Rhuddlan Triangle’ site and the accompanying Strategic Environmental Assessment screening document (as attached to the report) for public consultation.
Seconded12 Nov 2014Planning Committee
Application no. 15/2014/0969/pf - llys armon, llanarmon yn ial, mold
Proposal – Councillor Huw Williams proposed the officer recommendation to grant, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Seconded15 Oct 2014Planning Committee
Application no. 15/2014/0888/pf - land adjoining canol y cae, village road, eryrys, mold
Proposal – Councillor David Simmons proposed the officer recommendations to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts.
Named2 Oct 2014Performance Scrutiny Committee
Provisional external examinations and teacher assessments
The HoE reported that as yet there was no update from the Welsh Government regarding children with special needs in special schools having to sit the same tests as those who have not which has a negative impact on the Authority’s perceived performance Councillor Arwel Roberts wanted to clarify a point he had raised at a recent Cabinet meeting, that when he said that Ysgol Brynhyfryd should teach through the medium of Welsh 100% of the time, he meant the Welsh Stream rather than the whole school. The Head of Education offered to facilitate a visit for members to Ysgol Brynhyfryd to see and meet pupils in the Welsh Language stream throughout the school. A number of Members indicated ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Said17 Jul 2014Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
Councillor Arwel Roberts requested that the School Transport Policy be an item for future scrutiny and the Chief Executive reported upon areas of the policy currently under review. It was agreed that the draft new policy be presented to scrutiny before submission to Cabinet for approval. Members also noted the proposal that all future education items be considered by this committee.
Said17 Jul 2014Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Committee representatives reported upon their attendance at meetings as follows – Councillor Arwel Roberts reported upon a meeting with the Head of Children & Family Services and Lead Member for Social Care to discuss performance relating to holding child protection conferences which had been raised at the Committee’s last meeting. He praised the work being carried out and was satisfied staff were doing an excellent job. The Scrutiny Coordinator drew members’ attention to the Committee’s information brief (previously circulated) which provided a statement from the Lead Member in which she explained that whilst striving to comply with performance indicators, there would be the odd occasion when it was more purposeful to delay slightly rather than proceed to conference without the participation of a key player.
Said12 Jun 2014Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor A Roberts advised that he had attended a meeting with Rhyl College and referred to the excellent work being undertaken.
Said27 May 2014Cabinet
Street naming and numbering policy
Councillor Arwel Roberts explained why he had raised the issue of street naming at the Bilingual Forum and thanked officers and Councillor Huw Jones for their work in producing a policy which supported the Welsh language and bilingualism.
Said13 May 2014County Council
MINUTES
Councillor Arwel Roberts stated with regards to item 11 Independent Remuneration Panel for Wales, he had asked for an amendment and had not raised an objection.
Said8 Apr 2014County Council
Independent remuneration panel for wales
At this juncture, Councillor Arwel Roberts raised an objection.
Named8 Apr 2014County Council
Independent remuneration panel for wales
Councillor Roberts recommended additional salaries should not be paid to Chairs of Committees due to the current economic climate and the fact it would be a financial saving to the Council.
Said20 Mar 2014Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
Councillor A Roberts advised that he had recently attended School Standards Monitoring Group (SSMG) meetings at which the performance of two schools had been examined in detail.
Said18 Feb 2014Cabinet
Proposal to close ysgol clocaenog and ysgol cyffylliog and to establish a new area school
Councillor Arwel Roberts spoke in favour of the proposal highlighting the inadequacies of the schools’ facilities and benefits of a new school for pupils.
Named14 Feb 2014Religious Education (SACRE)
Election of new vice-chair - from the lea representatives
Councillor Arwel Roberts was nominated and seconded as Vice-Chair.
Named14 Feb 2014Religious Education (SACRE)
Election of new vice-chair - from the lea representatives
RESOLVED that Councillor Arwel Roberts be appointed as Vice-Chair of SACRE.
Named24 Oct 2013Performance Scrutiny Committee
Feedback from committee representatives
· Flying Start · West Rhyl Housing Programme · World War 2 trench being put in at Bodelwyddan Castle Councillor Arwel Roberts had recently attended a meeting of the School Standards Monitoring Group (SSMG) and commented that the Lead Member and Head of Education were very thorough in their questioning and challenge of the school representatives in attendance. The schools in attendance were Ysgol Esgob Morgan, St. Asaph – this was a happy school and a good school - and Ysgol Gallt Melyd –a very good school.
Named12 Jun 2013Licensing Committee
Application for a licence to drive hackney carriage and private hire vehicles - applicant no. 047324
[Councillor Arwel Roberts took no part in the discussion or voting on this matter as he had not been present throughout the entire proceedings]
Named10 Jun 2013Religious Education (SACRE)
Wales association of sacres (wasacre)
Members discussed attendance at the next meeting and considered the background and experience of the candidates and it was – RESOLVED that – (a) Reverend Martin Evans-Jones, Councillor Arwel Roberts (morning session) and Philip Lord attend the next WASACRE meeting on 19 June, and (b) Mark Brown, Mary Parry and Judy Harris receive Denbighshire SACRE’s vote for election to the WASACRE Executive Committee.
Named24 May 2013Performance Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of vice chair
Councillor A Roberts had circulated his CV to Committee members prior to the meeting.
Named24 May 2013Performance Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of vice chair
Councillor Roberts was nominated and seconded for the office of Vice-Chair, no other nominations were received and it was:
Named9 Apr 2013County Council
Arrangements for election of chair and vice chair at annual council
Councillor Gwyneth Kensler proposed, seconded by Councillor Huw Jones that Councillor Arwel Roberts be nominated Vice Chair.
Named9 Apr 2013County Council
Arrangements for election of chair and vice chair at annual council
In accordance with the Council’s Constitution a secret ballot was undertaken for the proposed Vice Chair and the name of Councillor Arwel Roberts was eliminated.
Named9 Apr 2013County Council
Corporate plan 2012 - 2017, year 2 delivery document
Councillor Arwel Roberts was doubtful of the effectiveness of the Area Plans’ capacity to address specific issues and cited an example of an untidy plot of land in Rhuddlan .
Named19 Mar 2013Cabinet
Capital plan
Councillor Eryl Williams reported upon the criteria in order to access 21st Century Schools funding and responded to a question from Councillor Arwel Roberts regarding progress with the development at Ysgol Glan Clwyd. With regard to capital works he explained the process of prioritising school improvement works in general and following schools review in order to improve standards.
Asked21 Feb 2013Performance Scrutiny Committee
Corporate plan 2012 - 17 baseline report
Councillor Arwel Roberts queried the research being undertaken by Glyndwr University regarding the indicators to be used for the priority to ensure access to good quality housing. The CIM advised that the Council had been working with the University to develop data sets in order to provide the necessary indicators. The intention was to provide a measure of the current supply of social housing, affordable housing and market housing together with a measure of housing need and pent-up demand.
Named18 Dec 2012Cabinet
Finance report 2012/13
Councillor Arwel Roberts hoped that no schools would lose out over the new funding formula and Councillor Williams responded that schools had agreed the changes to the formula.
Said20 Nov 2012Cabinet
Anti-fouling strategy
Councillor Arwel Roberts stressed the need to enforce the Dog Control Order in Rhuddlan Playing Fields which was being violated.
Said20 Nov 2012Cabinet
Anti-fouling strategy
In terms of communication, Councillor Roberts highlighted the need for accurate translations and appropriate contact with Town and Community Councils.
Named26 Jul 2012Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny work programme
(e) Councillor Arwel Roberts be appointed the committee’s representative on the Schools Standards Monitoring Group and Councillor Richard Davies be appointed as substitute member, and (f) the Chair, Councillor Colin Hughes be appointed the committee’s representative on the Corporate Equalities Group and Councillor Geriant Lloyd-Williams be appointed as substitute member.
Named28 Jun 2012Performance Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny committee work programme
Hughes as the Committee's substitute representative on the Group in the event of Councillor Roberts being unable to attend. Following further discussion, it was:- RESOLVED – that:- (a) the Planning Enforcement item be deferred until ... view the full minutes text for item 10.
Moved19 Jun 2012Licensing Committee
Appointment of chair
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed, seconded by Councillor William Cowie that Councillor Cefyn Williams be appointed Chair.
Moved19 Jun 2012Licensing Committee
Appointment of vice chair
Councillor Arwel Roberts proposed, seconded by Councillor William Cowie that Councillor Cefyn Williams be appointed Vice Chair.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.