MINUTES
Matters Arising – Councillor Brian Jones stated he had not yet received the letter from the North Wales Council Leaders regarding Betsi Cadwaladr and A&E services.
Every time Denbighshire's minutes name Councillor Jones, as the council published it.
Matters Arising – Councillor Brian Jones stated he had not yet received the letter from the North Wales Council Leaders regarding Betsi Cadwaladr and A&E services.
Councillor Terry Mendies nominated Councillor Brian Jones, in his supporting statement Councillor Mendies highlighted that Councillor Jones had extensive experience as a County Councillor, together with a significant background in the commercial sector.
Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield, that Councillor Andrea Tomlin be appointed Vice Chair. There were no further nominations.
Councillor Brian Jones requested an update on the review of the current Hackney Carriage Table of Fares (Tariff) scheduled for September. The Lead Officer (Licensing) advised that a report on the outcome of last month’s Hackney Carriage Fares Workshop was being produced by the Council’s Engagement Officer for circulation to Licensing Committee members. The Council would then consult with the taxi trade on a proposed hackney carriage fare structure which would be submitted to the Licensing Committee in September for review.
Councillor Brian Jones nominated Councillor Peter Scott for the role of Vice-Chair, Councillor Merfyn Parry seconded Councillor Scott’s nomination. No other nominations were received and the Committee:
Councillor Brian Jones proposed Councillor Peter Scott to be the next Vice Chair of Council, seconded by Councillor James Elson.
The minutes of the Council meeting held on the 27 January 2026 and the Council meeting held on the 12 February 2026 were submitted Matters Arising from the Council meeting held on the 27 January 2026, Councillor Brian Jones highlighted that it was mentioned that a letter from the leaders from the North Wales Councils was sent to Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board; and that it would be shared.
Councillor Brian Jones nominated Councillor Terry Mendies, He outlined Councillor Mendies’ business experience, including running franchises in Australia and operating businesses across three continents.
Councillor Brian Jones enquired whether he should declare an interest in business item 6, ‘Contaminated Land’, on the basis of his role in the previous administration as Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment and that during his time as Lead Member he had engaged in informal conversations on the topic. The Monitoring Officer advised that he would only be required to declare an interest in the matter if he were the owner of land which had been identified as contaminated or was a relative or close acquaintance of a person involved with a site which had been designated as contaminated.
Matters arising : pages 13 to 15, item 7 ‘Renew Rhyl: Clear – Hold – Build Initiative’: Councillor Brian Jones enquired how the Council and other partners were working together to ensure that the progress made under this initiative was not lost following the project’s formal closure at the end of March 2026. In response the Corporate Director: Governance and Business informed members that a multi-agency meeting had been arranged for 16 March 2026 for the purpose of consolidating the progress made under the initiative and to explore ways by which to sustain and build on the achievements going forward through effective partnership working.
Given the deprivation in Rhyl, Councillor Brian Jones believed the funding would be allocated to Rhyl projects. Officers advised that communities of most need was a factor in considering where the funding was invested along with deliverability and other key criteria but the review of projects had not yet been completed and no decisions had been made as yet.
Councillor Brian Jones referred to an extract from the report being posted on social media which created a false perception giving rise to negative comments. In response to a question regarding the level of increase going forward the Head of Finance and Audit advised that there were factors outside the control of the Council and DLL which may impact on any further submissions together with limitations of subsidy control. An increase in funding would allow time to explore potential alternative delivery models to ensure the right model going forward.
Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in agenda item 3 because he knew the Designated Premises Supervisor through previous charity work.
Officers responded to questions from Councillor Brian Jones as follows – · the overspend of £339k in Highways and Environmental Services comprised £200k due to the continuing process to achieve savings proposals in the Public Conveniences service and £139k unachieved savings in restructuring costs · provided an update on progress with the Public Conveniences savings proposal advising that the two bids for grant funding to change the infrastructure to enable charging for facilities had been unsuccessful but the Capital Scrutiny Group had supported council funding for the payment ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Whilst there was no requirement to declare an interest, for transparency purposes, Councillor Brian Jones advised that he was a member of the same political group as one of the persons quoted in the documentation for agenda item 8 – Application for a Hackney Carriage Vehicle Licence (585581).
Despite his previous support for a fare increase, in light of the information contained within the report Councillor Brian Jones had some reservations about the best way forward. He sought further information about the general health and viability of the taxi trade in both the North and South of the county, particularly given the impact a change in fares could have on the trade itself, visitors and the most vulnerable. If the report recommendations were approved, he asked that a workshop be arranged with the licensed trade and councillors with a view to working together on a fare structure to balance both the needs of the taxi trade and taxi users.
The Vice-Chair, Councillor Brian Jones conducted the meeting in the Chair’s absence.
Prior to proceeding with the appointment of a Vice-Chair for the Committee for the remainder of the 2025/26 municipal year, Councillor Brian Jones explained that his intention had been to assume the Vice-Chair’s role solely for the May 2025 meeting in order to facilitate the meeting’s business in absence of the Chair. He had not intended for the appointment to be for the municipal year and had therefore resigned from the position.
Councillor Brian Jones seconded the nomination. No other nominations were received and the Committee unanimously:
Councillor Brian Jones paid tribute to the excellent work carried out by the Democratic Services Manager and his team.
Councillor Brian Jones noted the proposal to advertise the post in the summer (21 July – 1 September) and felt an extension was required to maximise the number of external applicants, including those from further afield.
Councillor James Elson proposed Councillor Brian Jones, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
All members present affirmed their assent to the appointment of Councillor Brian Jones.
RESOLVED that Councillor Brian Jones be appointed as Vice-Chair of Communities Scrutiny Committee for the 2025-2026 municipal year.
Matters of accuracy – None Matters arising – Councillor Brian Jones asked if the Toilet Strategy would be presented back to committee in October 2025. He stressed the importance of the Committee receiving an update. The Corporate Director Economy and Environment confirmed it would be resented to the Committee in October.
Councillor Andrea Tomlin proposed, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones, that Councillor Bobby Feeley be appointed Chair. There were no further nominations.
Councillor Justine Evans proposed, seconded by Councillor Andrea Tomlin, that Councillor Brian Jones be appointed Vice Chair. There were no further nominations.
RESOLVED that Councillor Brian Jones be appointed Vice Chair of the Licensing Committee for the ensuing year.
Councillor Brian Jones voiced his support for the report recommendation given the need to support the taxi industry in light of the change in circumstances since the last fare review in June 2024 with a significant cost increase associated with the taxi trade. He was confident that the trade would negotiate lower fares for regular and vulnerable customers when providing that service.
The Leader agreed to discuss the matter with the Deputy Monitoring Officer with a view to making representations to the reporter in that regard · Councillor Brian Jones referred to the webcast of the last Cabinet meeting when officers had stated that community groups at Botanical Gardens did not wish to engage in discussions about retaining the toilets. He advised that he was aware of community groups who did wish to engage on the matter and therefore it was inaccurate for officers to state otherwise. The Leader suggested that Cabinet approve the minutes subject to an investigation into the point made.
RESOLVED that, subject to an investigation into the accuracy point raised by Councillor Brian Jones above, the minutes of the meeting held on 29 April 2025 be received and confirmed as a correct record.
Councillor Brian Jones, Vice Chair of Partnerships Scrutiny Committee presented the report detailing the findings and recommendation of the Scrutiny Committee held on 22 May 2025 following consideration of the call-in of the Cabinet decision taken on 29 April relating to the Public Conveniences Savings Proposal.
Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in business item 7, Household Waste Recycling Centres, as he was the Lead Member for Waste, Transport and Environment at the time of awarding the contract for operating the Household Waste Recycling Centres to Bryson Recycling Limited.
Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones nominated Councillor Brian Jones for the position of Vice-Chair of Partnerships Scrutiny Committee for the 2025/26 municipal year.
Resolved : that Councillor Brian Jones be elected as Vice-Chair of Partnerships Scrutiny Committee for the 2025/26 municipal year.
· Councillor Brian Jones became a group leader at a later stage of the previous review process. He reported that the support arrangements for group leaders lacked clarity on how group leaders should resolve difficult issues within their groups.
Councillor Brian Jones stated that rural wards should be single member wards as that helped maintain local connections and knowledge, though he was pessimistic about the prospects of local councillors being able to influence the national bodies on matters like this electoral review.
Councillor Brian Jones queried the extent of the committee’s remit, which the DSM clarified, and Councillor Jones informed the committee he would be interested in reviewing the developing scrutiny arrangements for the North Wales Corporate Joint Committee.
Councillor Brian Jones requested information on a provisional opening date for the new Queen’s Market facility, along with a figure of how many businesses had signed a legal tenancy agreement to operate out of the new Queen’s Market building?
Question 2 Question put forward by Councillor Brian Jones to the Lead Member for Environment and Transport, Councillor Barry Mellor – “Could there be an explanation from the Lead Member regarding the lack of waste bin collections in Rhyl over the last two weekends - i.e.
Business item 5 – in response to an enquiry from Councillor Brian Jones on the current position regarding the review of the contract for monitoring CCTV activity in Rhyl and other towns in Denbighshire, Councillor Arwel Roberts offered to update Councillor Jones on the matter following the meeting.
The chair allowed Councillor Brian Jones to query the Rhyl Regeneration Programme and Governance, which had been delayed until March 2025. He raised concern that the projects funded by the levelling-up fund would need to be completed by March 2026. He believed that a year wouldn’t be enough time to complete the projects.
Matters Arising – Page 9: Item 7 UK Government Levelling Up Funding Award (Round 3) – Vale of Clwyd Constituency – in response to a question from Councillor Brian Jones, the Leader advised that an announcement would be made in October as part of the UK Government’s Spending Review in relation to funding and timelines.
Matters Arising – Page 11: Item 6 Long Term Plan for Towns: Rhyl – in response to a question from Councillor Brian Jones, the Leader provided an update on the item confirming that the inaugural meeting of the Rhyl Town Board had been held the previous day which had been extremely positive, and work would be ongoing to undertake the required actions by the 1 November deadline. There may be greater flexibility over the deadline given the change in the UK Government.
Councillor Brian Jones was concerned about the public perception of investment in toilet facilities when their future was in doubt.
Councillor Brian Jones raised a number of questions and concerns regarding the timescale for completing the projects listed in the report, the lack of project detail and costing, the merits of individual projects, the timeliness of public consultation at an appropriate stage in the process, and any potential impact on the funding award as a result of the change in the UK Government.
Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Andrea Tomlin, that Councillor Hugh Irving be appointed Vice Chair. There were no further nominations.
Matters arising – Councillor Brian Jones asked if the Rhyl Regeneration Project would be included on the Forward Work Programme as raised at the previous meeting. The question would be addressed under the Forward Work Programme item.
Matters arising – Councillor Brian Jones asked if there was any update regarding alternative funding streams to support keeping libraries open.
Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 9 – Review of a Licence to Drive Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicles as he became aware, once he had seen the Driver subject of the review, that he was known to him.
[Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in this item as he became aware that the Driver was known to him and he subsequently left the meeting before the decision-making stage taking no part in the deliberations.] A confidential report by the Head of Planning, Public Protection and Countryside Services (previously circulated) was submitted upon – (i) the suitability of Driver No. 550166 to hold a licence to drive hackney carriage and private hire vehicles following a complaint regarding drug use and a positive roadside drug test carried out by the North Wales Police in October 2023 ;
The Conservative Group had appointed Councillor Brian Jones to replace Councillor Scott as one of its representatives on the Committee.
Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones agreed to represent the Committee on the Corporate Support Service: People and Councillor Brian Jones was nominated to attend the Planning, Public Protection and Countryside Services Service Challenge Group.
Resolved : to – (i) confirm its forward work programme as set out in Appendix 1 to the report; and (ii) appoint the following representatives to serve on the Groups detailed below – · Capital Scrutiny Group – Councillor Joan Butterfield · Planning, Public Protection & Countryside Services – Councillor Brian Jones · Corporate Support Services: People – Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones
Councillor Brian Jones queried the position regarding the webcast of that meeting which had been removed from the Council’s website. The Monitoring Officer advised of the requirement to broadcast the meeting but there was no requirement to retain the webcast on the website and he explained the circumstances in which a webcast could be removed, including concerns regarding personal information. A copy of the webcast had been retained and in the event of a freedom of information request, consideration would be given as to whether any exemptions applied to any of the information contained in the webcast.
Councillor Brian Jones had notified the Chair that, due to a prior appointment, he would be unable to attend the meeting from the outset but would be joining later.
Councillor Gill German declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because she was a Director of Denbighshire Leisure Limited Councillor Pauline Edwards declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because she was a School Governor of Ysgol Pendref Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 – Rhyl BID Re-Ballot because he was a Director of Rhyl BID Councillor Rhys Thomas declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because he lived near to the Ystrad Road site and because he was a Director of Denbighshire Leisure Limited Councillor Emrys Wynne declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because he had a close personal association to persons living near to one of the sites Councillor Mark Young declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because he was a School Governor of Denbigh High School
Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 – Proposed changes to Hackney Carriage Vehicles Table of Fares and Charges, because as a former Cabinet Member he had been involved in discussions with a large proportion of the taxi trade with regard to the Electric Vehicle Charging Pilot.
Councillor Brian Jones stated that the Notice of Motion had been brought forward due to the outcry of local residents. Councillors Joan Butterfield and Alan James responded that, as ward members, they had not received any complaints from local residents regarding the proposed removal of the promenade kiosks. The Monitoring Officer confirmed a vote needed to take place on the amendment.
The Council had a good track record of managing projects and there were usually only a small number of ‘at risk’ projects of which officers were acutely aware and corrective action quickly taken · in response to questions raised by Councillor Brian Jones regarding the status of Rhyl specific projects, including developing ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Andrea Tomlin, that Councillor Hugh Irving be appointed Vice Chair. There were no further nominations.
In response to questions from Councillor Brian Jones the HPPPCS confirmed that the process ahead included further public consultation.
Councillor Brian Jones presented a motion (previously circulated) on behalf of the Conservative Group.
In responding to the lead member, the proposer of the original motion Councillor Brian Jones conveyed the serious doubts he held about the Welsh Government’s commitment to deliver the North Denbighshire Community Hospital Project; citing the long-standing and continuing delays to the project, and his understanding that no funding had been allocated to deliver the project. He rejected the lead members’ position and endorsed the Royal Alexander Angels’ petition for a feasibility study to reinstate bed capacity as being a viable and practical short to medium term solution.
Councillor Brian Jones asked if Members could request information on the financial impacts be included with the waste report as it was not connected to the Communication Strategy being presented. The Scrutiny Co-ordinator suggested members request a separate report on the finance aspects of the Strategy. The Chair suggested it may be the remit of the Performance Scrutiny Committee to debate that aspect of the Strategy.
· Councillor Brian Jones nominated himself to attend the Corporate Support Service: Performance, Digital and Assets and · Councillor Karen Edwards put her name forward to attend the Corporate Support Service: People.
· Housing and Communities – Councillor Cheryl Williams · Corporate Support Service: Performance, Digital and Assets – Councillor Brian Jones · Corporate Support Service: People – Councillor Karen Edwards.
Councillor Brian Jones as he was on the Project Board for one of the applications.
It was also noted that on Page 13 it should read ‘ Those were climate change, reorganisation of schools in Denbigh and the current war in Ukraine with regard to food security.’ Matters arising – Agenda item 7 - Application No. 45/2021/0516/ Pf - Kynsal House – Councillor Brian Jones asked if further work with the applicant on the application had taken place since the planning committee meeting. The Development Control Manager confirmed officers had been in contact with the applicant. He also informed the authorities Gypsy and Traveller liaison officer had been in contact with the applicant to discuss the options for the site.
Councillor Brian Jones stressed green energy would be needed to support communities globally in the future including the use of windfarms and on that ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
FOR – 13 AGAINST – 3 ABSTAIN – 0 RESOLVED that the retrospective application for the change of use of dwelling (Use Class C3) to form a house of multiple occupancy (Use Class C4) for 4 people at 7 Llys Walsh, 1 Lon Taylor and 3 Lon Taylor Rhyl be deferred to a future meeting for the reasons set out by Councillor Brian Jones above.
Councillor Brian Jones directed officers to section 3 of the agenda paper, in particular he requested feedback on point 3.5 which referred to Rhyl Golf Club. He asked officers to request the detail of the works at the Rhyl Golf club and land to the west of St Asaph Business Park.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report updating Cabinet on the latest cost and budget position on the Waste Service Remodelling Project and sought Cabinet approval of an updated Business Case and the delegation of authority to appropriate officers to call upon capital plan unhypothecated funding if required.
Councillor Brian Jones also added that the Council’s contract with United Paper Mills (UPM) Shotton to recycle household waste expired in autumn 2023 which was likely to result in additional financial pressure on the waste service, and any delay in the project roll out beyond autumn 2023 would result in greater costs to the Council.
[The Head of Legal, HR and Democratic Services referred to the confidential appendices to the report for reasons of commercial sensitivity and advised that any detailed questioning on those elements should be carried out in private session.] Councillor Brian Jones presented the report on the process undertaken during the fleet procurement exercise as part of the wider waste services remodelling project and sought Cabinet approval to award a contract to the preferred supplier for the 14 new 5M Resource Recover Vehicles (RRV). The tender award comprised 11 diesel 5M RRV waste vehicles and 3 Ultra-Low Emission Vehicles (ULEV) waste vehicles. Given the long lead-in times on the larger 5M RRVs and to secure the tendered prices it was also recommended that the decision be implemented immediately.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report regarding Phase 2 of the development of the new DCC Waste Transfer Station and sought Cabinet approval to award a contract to the preferred contractor via delegated decision.
At this point Councillor Brian Jones paid tribute to the officers working on the waste project with special mention to the Project Manager, particularly given the complexities and challenges involved. On behalf of the Cabinet the Leader added his appreciation highlighting the benefits of the project to residents in the long term.
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, was then invited summarise the discussion and decision taken at Cabinet on 15 February 2022. He outlined the consultation which had taken place to date and confirmed that there were no plans to purchase Grade 1 agricultural land for carbon sequestration and ecological improvement purposes.
Councillor Brian Jones requested further guidance regarding agenda item 5 – Land adjacent to Ysgol Pendref, Denbigh as he had been on the Cabinet debate. Following guidance from the Team Leader it was in his opinion he was able to make an informed decision with an open mind.
Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in agenda item 9 - Kynsal House, Vale Road, Rhyl as he had previously been contacted by residents regarding concerns at the site.
Councillor Brian Jones informed the members he had involved in discussions regarding this project. He urged members to monitor the process of the project.
Prior to bringing the meeting to a close, and in the absence of the Chair of the Licensing Committee Councillor Hugh Irving and on his behalf, the Vice Chair Councillor Brian Jones thanked members for their hard work and service on the Committee. Thanks were also conveyed to both licensing and support officers. A special mention was made to the Committee’s Legal Adviser who was attending his last meeting of the Licensing Committee with best wishes to him for the future.
Cabinet discussed the report at length and support was voiced as follows – · Councillor Brian Jones considered that progressing the project was the right thing to do for Rhyl and he had been pleased to note the support from the Welsh Government and potential for Levelling Up Funding to benefit the area; he also acknowledged the hard work of the Lead Members and officers on the project · Councillor Bobby Feeley had been disappointed to note the cost increase but recognised the global rise in construction costs;
Given that the original survey had been carried out some six years ago, Councillor Brian Jones felt there would be merit in reviewing that work to ensure the latest position was known to safeguard against future issues and enable work to be prioritised as appropriate, particularly in light of the impact and loss of Llannerch Bridge.
Members would be kept informed as the situation developed · Councillor Brian Jones reported on the success of the East Rhyl Flood Defence Scheme which had been completed ahead of time and within budget, protecting 1600 homes and businesses from coastal flooding.
Councillor Brian Jones reported on previous work undertaken with a view to reducing single use plastics leading up to the current report, and he highlighted the need to align ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Brian Jones withdrew the Notice of Motion.
Cabinet discussed the budget proposals and debate focused on the following – · at the request of Councillor Brian Jones for the benefit of residents, the Lead Member detailed the consultation carried out on the budget process and explained the acronyms used, demonstrating the involvement of all senior officers and elected members in that process together with schools and trade unions. All elected members had been given the opportunity to input into the process and additional meetings with Political Group Leaders seeking the submission of pressures/savings had also been carried out.
Councillor Brian Jones highlighted the success of Parc Adfer which was part of the North Wales Residual Waste Treatment Project located at Deeside which processed residual waste as an alternative to landfill. The increased use of the facility was a positive response to the climate change agenda.
Councillor Brian Jones seconded the proposal.
Councillor Brian Jones had been unable to fully participate in the meeting due to connectivity issues.
Councillor Tony Thomas submitted the report (in the absence of Councillor Brian Jones due to connectivity issues) seeking Cabinet agreement to the adoption and implementation of a construction standard for non-domestic new build and major extension/refurbishment construction projects to meet in use and embodied carbon targets.
Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 6 because he knew the applicant’s representative.
[Having declared a personal and prejudicial interest Councillor Brian Jones left the meeting for the duration of this item.] A confidential report by the Head of Planning, Public Protection and Countryside Services had been submitted (previously circulated) seeking determination of an application to drive hackney carriage and private hire vehicles from Applicant No. 554278. Neither the applicant nor his nominated representative was in attendance.
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, introduced the 20 th January 2021 Flood Event – Section 19 Flood Investigation Report.
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, introduced the Sustainable Transport Plan Report (previously circulated).
[This item was brought forward with the consent of the Leader.] Councillor Brian Jones presented the report seeking Cabinet’s support for the principle of replacing Llannerch Bridge (located between Trefnant and Tremeirchion ), which was lost in January 2021 during storm Christoph , subject to securing the necessary funding to do so.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report seeking Cabinet approval to the proposed tendering exercise to identify a main contractor to deliver fleet vehicles to support the Waste Model for household, trades and communal waste collections.
In adding his support Councillor Brian Jones paid tribute to the hard work undertaken in the project’s development, and whilst there was a flood risk, much work was ongoing with partners and stakeholders in order to mitigate flood risk in that particular area. Councillors Pete Prendergast and Joan Butterfield echoed the sentiments of those in favour of the proposal reiterating the skills opportunities for young people and future employment prospects, together with the positive impact on the deprivation index in Rhyl as a result.
Councillor Brian Jones deferred to NMWTRA as the experts on noise from the carriageway and also advised that the Council itself housed residents in private care homes without mechanical ventilation and where windows were not sealed.
During further debate Councillor Brian Jones considered it would be appropriate, in light of new information on the matter, for the proposed condition with regard to non-opening windows to be revisited and removed, and he also highlighted alternative means of noise mitigation measures including sound proofing/deadening barriers as opposed to non-opening windows. Officers reminded the Committee of the consultation responses to the application, in particular the Welsh Government’s response as highway authority for the A55 trunk road in which it identified an issue with noise and had directed that any permission include adequate noise mitigation measures due to the site’s proximity to the A55. Welsh Government had accepted the Applicant’s suggested noise mitigation for ventilation through mechanical means and therefore had effectively directed that non-opening windows be in place.
Councillor Brian Jones, Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, introduced the Covid-19 Active Travel Plan report. The report detailed the temporary active travel schemes that were implemented in a number of Denbighshire town centres in late 2020 and which had now all subsequently been removed.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report seeking Cabinet approval to the proposed tendering exercise to identify a main contractor to deliver Phase 2 new DCC Waste Transfer Station (WTS) at Colomendy Industrial Estate, Denbigh.
[The Head of Legal, HR and Democratic Services explained that the tender evaluation element of the report must remain confidential at this stage due to commercial sensitivity and he advised Cabinet to move into closed session if they wished to discuss that element of the report.] Councillor Brian Jones presented the report seeking Cabinet approval to authorise the contract award to manage Household Waste Recycling Centres (HRCs) following the joint procurement process with Conwy County Borough Council (CCBC) together with adoption of the Joint HRC Policy with Conwy and the 2022/23 charging schedule in order to realise the maximum savings generated from the procurement. The benefits of the collaborative approach for both Denbighshire and Conwy residents were highlighted, including cross border use of recycling centres, providing an alternative option to hiring a skip to dispose of DIY and Construction waste for a reasonable charge, and continuation of the booking system. The cost savings to Denbighshire as a result of the changes was also highlighted.
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, introduced the 9 February 2020 Flood Event - Section 19 Flood Investigation Report.
Proposed – Councillor Ann Davies proposed the application be granted contrary to officer recommendations, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
Councillor Brian Jones, spoke on behalf of the local member Councillor Tony Thomas, he agreed fully with comments raised by Councillor Barry Mellor.
Councillor Brian Jones raised that within the report BSC 5 – Deliver the Key Strategic Site that the outline planning permission had expired, and wanted to know what would be happening with the matter. The officers clarified that the permission had lapsed however the site remained within the current LDP, and officers would discuss the matters with members through the Strategic Planning Group (SPG) on how to take the matter further, and decide what happens with the site.
Matters Arising – Item 5 Llangollen 2020 Castle Street Improvement Scheme (page 9) – Councillor Brian Jones provided an update on the suggestion that the proposed new loading bay on Castle Street outside the town hall be a recessed construction. Despite best efforts it was found that following thorough technical investigations and discussions with stakeholders it would not be feasible for the loading bay to be further recessed given the detrimental impact on the tree located at the site and necessity to reset the utility services which would be cost prohibitive. However compromises had been made to the overall scheme where appropriate and Llangollen would benefit from the significant investment and improvements the project would bring.
In response to questions the Lead Officer – Corporate Property and Housing Stock advised that – · the request to waive the call-in procedure for decisions related to the tender for Lot 1 only in order to expedite that process given the timescales involved · in the event of a block of flats with a mix of both private and council tenures it was the landlord’s responsibility to repair the external envelope and therefore works carried out for council tenants could also benefit private tenants · the authority worked with Business Wales during the tender process and looked to work with all contractors who expressed an interest prior to the tender and feedback could be provided to unsuccessful tenderers on request · procurement rules required tenders via the Sell2Wales procurement portal which was not a restricted procurement process for local companies · in response to queries raised by Councillor Brian Jones regarding the reasoning behind the lack of local contractors put forward for the framework and the financial criteria set by Sell2Wales which might impact on the ability of local contractors to participate in the process, it was agreed that the Lead Officer look into those issues and report back directly to Councillor Jones thereon · the criteria for refurbishment of the housing stock followed a condition survey and was based on a long term capital programme for external enveloping and internal works to ensure compliance with the
Councillor Brian Jones proposed the application be deferred until a site visit took place at a local resident’s property.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report seeking Cabinet approval to proceed with the implementation of the Llangollen 2020 Castle Street Improvement Project. Given the estimated project cost of £1.75m and the significant community interest in the scheme a decision was sought from Cabinet to approve its implementation.
General Debate – Local Member, Councillor Brian Jones raised the issue of an access to and from the site to be located on the road known as Dyserth Bends which was an extremely dangerous road.
Councillor Brian Jones proposed the application be deferred until a site visit took place to a local resident’s property who had contacted Councillor Jones informing him he was unaware of the works taking place at Sandy Lodge. Officers confirmed notification had been sent out to the resident concerned.
Vote - For deferment – 12 Abstain – 0 Against – 6 RESOLVED that the application for the alteration and adaptation of existing Nursing Home at Sandy Lodge, Rhyl be deferred to a future meeting for the reasons set out by Councillor Brian Jones above.
In his introduction the Lead Member for Waste, Transportation and Environment in his introduction, Councillor Brian Jones, highlighted that the flooding experienced across Denbighshire in February 2020 had been a significant event. The Head of Highways and Environment (TW) introduced the Section 19 Flood Report (previously circulated) relating to the floods which had occurred as a result of Storm Ciara. Denbighshire County Council as a Lead Local Flood Authority had a duty under Section 19 of the Flood and Water Management Act to investigate flooding and publish the findings.
During debate Councillor Brian Jones questioned the initial delay in progressing the project (which had been cited as due to Covid-19) despite concerns there would be an increase in domestic abuse cases/incidents during the coronavirus pandemic. Further questions were raised regarding the increase in the number of cases dealt with over the last twelve months together with the proposed main policy changes.
However it was highlighted that the budget for the CTRS had been largely underfunded since it became part of the Revenue Support Grant which remained a pressure · Councillor Brian Jones raised concerns regarding the gathering pressures on homelessness, particularly given that the ban on tenant evictions would soon be ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Members noted the likely public interest in the Llangollen 2020 item scheduled for the next meeting and Councillor Brian Jones queried whether it would be possible to meet in the Council Chamber in order to better facilitate that particular item. It was confirmed that meetings were currently held remotely in line with Welsh Government guidance however the situation would be reviewed depending upon the circumstances at that time and the latest WG advice.
Councillor Huw Williams proposed, seconded by Councillor Melvyn Mile that Councillor Brian Jones be appointed Vice Chair.
There being no further nominations and upon being put to the vote it was – RESOLVED that Councillor Brian Jones be appointed Vice Chair of the Licensing Committee for the ensuing year.
Members discussed the report recommendations and Councillor Brian Jones felt there would be merit in forming a Sub Group with elected member representation from across the county to further consider the policy. There was some debate as to whether the Sub Group would be best served by cross party or geographical representation and it was subsequently agreed that a geographical spread would be preferable.
Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield to approve the draft policy for consultation and support the creation of a Sub Group to include the Licensing Committee’s Chair and/or Vice Chair and representation from each Member Area Group. Upon being put to the vote it was – RESOLVED that the Committee – (a) approve the draft street trading policy (Appendix A to the report) for consultation, and (b) support the establishment of a Sub Group to further consider the policy to include the Chair and/or Vice Chair to represent the Licensing Committee together with a representative from each of the Member Area Groups.
Councillor Brian Jones, stated at the meeting held in May, he requested the application at Sandy Lodge, be deferred until a site visit had been carried out at the site.
Vote - For deferment – 16 Abstain – 0 Against – 0 RESOLVED that the application for the alteration and adaptation of existing Nursing Home at Sandy Lodge, Rhyl be deferred to a future meeting for the reasons set out by Councillor Brian Jones above.
Once the longer term funding position was known work would be carried out to identify mechanisms to enable the council to receive a return on that energy provision; the setting up of an energy company via a cooperative was a future option to consider · Councillor Brian Jones sought assurances that the housing team were keeping up with the latest energy efficiency developments, including the onset of hydrogen technology, in order for the council to be best placed to benefit from any future opportunities. The Lead Member and officers provided assurances in that regard confirming regular dialogue with the Welsh Government and a watching briefing on various schemes although there was some conflicting advice regarding new technologies, and the matter would be kept under close review. In terms of hydrogen ready boilers, they would likely be available some time before the infrastructure to support them and much work would be required nationally before hydrogen boilers became mainstream in the housing stock.
In-depth discussions took place and the following points were raised – · Councillor Paul Penlington asked if Councillor Brian Jones, Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment had been involved with funding discussions with Welsh Government in early 2020 as there had been additional highways funding available amounting to £65million across Wales.
Councillor Brian Jones confirmed he had written to the Welsh Government but had received no response.
Councillor Brian Jones, proposed the application be deferred until a site visit had been carried out at the site, as it would be beneficial to the committee prior to the application being debated.
Councillor Brian Jones also highlighted that he was not pleased that the local members had received no correspondence from officers since the application was submitted at the last meeting.
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed the application be deferred, seconded by Councillor Ann Davies.
Vote – Grant – 13 Abstain – 0 Refuse – 4 RESOLVED that the application for the alteration and adaptation of existing nursing home at Sandy Lodge, Rhyl be deferred to a future meeting for the reasons set out by Councillor Brian Jones above.
Councillor Brian Jones agreed ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the confidential report seeking Cabinet approval of the contract award for delivery of Phase 1 of the extension of the Colomendy Industrial Estate Expansion including DCC Waste Transfer Station.
Councillor Brian Jones confirmed that a second application for the site had been submitted and requested that both applications be presented to Planning Committee at the same time.
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed the application be deferred, seconded by Councillor Peter Scott.
Vote – Grant – 14 Abstain – 0 Refuse – 0 RESOLVED that the application for the alteration and adaptation of existing nursing home at Sandy Lodge, Rhyl be deferred to a future meeting for the reasons set out by Councillor Brian Jones above.
Page 10, Item 6, DCC’s Climate & Ecological Change Strategy - Councillor Brian Jones stated he had recently attended a meeting with the Climate Change Programme Manager, Helen Vaughan-Evans and Councillor Graham Timms. It had been agreed that during the next 12 months, the Climate Change Group would hold three meetings to assess progress.
He added that the capital element had been reviewed by the Strategic Investment Group and recommended to Cabinet · Councillor Brian Jones referred to the risk identified at section 10.4 of the report and cautioned that the acquisition of a badger license from NRW may take some time and should be kept under close review.
Councillor Brian Jones considered that Councillor Mile had made a compelling case to grant the application based on his local knowledge of the area.
Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones responded that a communication had recently been received from NRW regarding the floods in February 2020 which would be available within the next two weeks. NRW had carried out interim works in Ruthin at the point where the river broke its banks and they had confirmed a permanent solution would be in place in Autumn. The Corporate Director:
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, introduced the Denbighshire County Council’s Climate and Ecological Change Strategy (2021-2029) report (previously circulated).
Councillor Brian Jones proposed the DCC’s Climate and Ecological Change Strategy report, seconded by Councillor Christine Marston.
· The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, informed members that Welsh Government were putting initiatives in place for funding. The Head of Service was collating a business case to obtain a commitment of up to £4million per year.
Councillor Brian Jones referred to the significant amount of work carried out since the Council’s Climate Change and Ecological Emergency Declaration in 2019 which had culminated in the Strategy document detailing how the Council’s aims of becoming net carbon zero and ecologically positive would be achieved. If the Strategy was approved the Council would need to commit in the region of £9m over the next three years, with more needed in future years, and he had absolute confidence that it was the right thing to do and would stand the authority in good stead going forward.
Proposal Councillor Brian Jones proposed a deferral given the late representation from Natural Resources Wales and for the applicants to address the issue of impact of the development in respect of SAC, seconded by Councillor Bob Murray.
Councillor Brian Jones was formally appointed Chair for the meeting.
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones gave a statement regarding the recent flooding as follows:
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones introduced the report (previously circulated). The report provided details on the existing car park tariff system and policy for residential schemes. Members were reminded that a similar report had previously been presented in 2015.
Councillor Brian Jones, Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment presented the report seeking Cabinet approval to sign up to the Bus Emergency Scheme (BES) 2 to secure financial support for the bus sector and establish a relationship with Flintshire County Council as the lead regional authority.
However it was recognised that it would take time to return to some sort of normality and pre-Covid passenger levels · the importance of bus services in rural areas was highlighted which were difficult to sustain and Councillor Brian Jones confirmed that high level discussions were currently ongoing specifically around rural needs and there was also support in that regard from other lead members at regional level.
Councillor Brian Jones, Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment and the Head of Highways, Facilities and Environmental Services introduced the item. It was explained that a report on the Rhyl Cut and Prestatyn Gutter Study due to be discussed at the meeting had been delayed and re-scheduled for May 2021. The investigations into the February 2020 flood events and subsequent effect of the Covid-19 pandemic had impacted NRW’s capacity to progress the work required to complete the study.
The following issues were raised during the ensuing debate – · Councillor Brian Jones was keen to ensure that all were aware of the work of the council in maximising funding opportunities to reduce the projected overspend and mitigate the impact of Covid-19 on the authority’s finances. The Lead Member for Finance confirmed WG funding announced earlier in the year had included additional funding for loss of income for the remainder of the financial year. Most of the Quarter 1 claim had been met and the Quarter 2 claim was currently being evaluated.
Proposed by Councillor Graham Timms, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the confidential report seeking Cabinet approval to undertake the proposed tendering exercise to identify a main contractor to deliver Phase 1 / Enabling Works Contract for the expansion of the Colomendy Industrial Estate in Denbigh, including Construction of a Waste Transfer Station (WTS).
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and the Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, introduced the Tackling Climate and Ecological Change in Council Decision making report (previously circulated).
Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in Agenda Item 8 (Brynllithrig Bach Cottage, Rhuallt).
Councillor Brian Jones declared a prejudicial interest, took no part in the debate and abstained from the vote.
Matters Arising – Page 6, Item No. 4 – Following issues raised by Councillor Peter Scott regarding recent storm damage in the county Councillor Brian Jones advised that a response had yet to be received from the Welsh Government regarding funding for specific projects. The Corporate Director Economy and Public Realm added that a report was being produced to review issues arising from the recent storms which would be circulated to members to consider how to proceed.
Proposal – Councillor Tony Thomas proposed refusal, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
Councillor Brian Jones agreed with the comments that were raised by Councillor Tony Thomas. It was also raised that the current application was of interest to many people of Rhyl, who would have attended the meeting in County Hall, and stated he would prefer contentious items be discussed in physical meetings rather than remote meetings. It was also stated that the same reasons for refusal from the previous application were still applicable.
Councillor Brian Jones advised that the planned flood meeting with the First Minister had not taken place but matters had since moved on. A request for funding for specific projects arising from the storm damage across Denbighshire had been made to the Welsh Government, including bridges and highways, and a response was currently awaited. With regard to the assessment of the wider impacts the Chief Executive confirmed that the planned work had been paused as a consequence of Covid 19 but it would be revisited at a future date.
Councillor Brian Jones added his support to the report recommendations given the current flood risk and the protection to be afforded to both residents and businesses which he considered provided value for money in terms of the investment required.
Councillor Brian Jones added that the WG may be able to fully fund the schemes in future years.
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, Head of Highways and Environmental Services, Tony Ward and Wales Audit Office (WAO) representative Jeremy Evans were in attendance for the item.
· Councillor Brian Jones – agenda item 6,7,8,9 and 10 – declared a prejudicial interest as the lead member.
Councillor Brian Jones queried whether it was appropriate to require all vehicles to be tested at the Fleet Management Centre in Bodelwyddan , particularly given the distance for Llangollen proprietors. Officers explained the reasoning behind the requirement was to ensure that those vehicles incurring significant damage and subsequent repair were properly tested to a consistent standard at an impartial centre . It was noted that the Licensing Committee had previously agreed to consider moving to in-house compliance testing only and officers were currently reviewing that proposal which would be brought back to a future meeting of the Committee for further consideration · Signage/Advertising/Livery (Hackney Carriage) – members noted additional costs may be ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
In response, Councillor Brian Jones advised that work was ongoing to find a more permanent solution and in addition to the forthcoming annual visits to Member Area Groups to discuss road maintenance, a members’ workshop was also being arranged on highway matters.
The Leader advised that the First Minister had called an emergency flood summit with local authorities (to be attended by Lead Member Councillor Brian Jones) and other agencies and it was expected that funding would be forthcoming to help deal with the aftermath.
Councillor Brian Jones advised that an assessment of the damage would be undertaken as soon as possible and work was ongoing in terms of planning and focusing resources. In light of the recent storm damage to the highway infrastructure and subsequent funding pressures to be met it was agreed to include in the resolution reference to the assessment of damage and identification of savings required.
In response to his concerns regarding potholes, Councillor Brian Jones advised that work was ongoing to find a more permanent solution and in addition to the forthcoming annual visits ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
· Cllr Brian Jones informed the meeting of a proposed North Wales tidal lagoon which would benefit the coastal area from the Little Orme in Llandudno to past Prestatyn and alleviate flooding.
· Cllr Brian Jones confirmed an official response would be sent to the Friends of the Earth who handed out fact sheets at the meeting.
The Lead Member for Waste, Transport and Environment, Councillor Brian Jones, Head of Highways and Environmental Services, Tony Ward, and Flood Risk Engineer, Wayne Hope were all in attendance for the item.
Councillor Brian Jones introduced the report to provide information regarding a report by the Wales Audit Office (WAO) on the Council’s approach to flood risk management and compliance with the Well-being of Future Generations Wales Act’s sustainable development principle and 5 well-being goals.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report and new Highways Code of Practice (CoP) for formal ratification.
Councillor Brian Jones referred to the situation with the legacy tip sites and the need for a purpose built facility for highways waste and he fully supported that proposal together with replacement accommodation at Botanical Gardens, Rhyl given the very poor standard of the current accommodation.
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed the application be granted in accordance with officer recommendations, seconded by Councillor Tony Thomas.
Councillor Brian Jones added that the process of vacating the site had been handled well.
Proposal – Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill proposed the application be refused contrary to officer recommendation, on the grounds of an unacceptable impact on neighbouring amenities, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
It was noted that the regional Transport Advisory Group would be writing to the Minister for Economy and Transport highlighting those concerns and Councillor Brian Jones also agreed to write to the Minister separately on behalf of the Council in that regard · members welcomed the Schools Maintenance Grant awarded to the Council by the Welsh Government and changes which allowed funding to be directed to essential works and areas of greatest need and Cabinet endorsed the approach that no funding be allocated to schools within the 21st Century Band A programme or schools likely to benefit under Band B and recommendations of the Strategic Investment Group · some discussion focused on children’s social care, specifically placement costs, and the Director: Communities reported upon a Welsh Government Working Group to further consider that issue and commissioning of high quality providers – it was recognised that placements costs differed in areas of the UK with more populated areas having greater purchasing power.
Councillor Brian Jones expressed his disappointment at the fact that one of the Members who had put forward the Notice of Motion had refused his seat on the Working Group.
Councillor Brian Jones - declared a personal interest in agenda item number 16 as he lived in close to the proposed application.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report on the proposal for a coastal defence scheme at East Rhyl and sought Cabinet agreement to the scheme and funding requirements and to recommend to Council accordingly.
Councillor Brian Jones also referred to the likely future need for employment land and buildings in connection with projects arising from the North Wales Economic Growth Deal.
Councillor Young also congratulated HR on their Domestic Abuse training but highlighted the success of that training might lead to an increase in the figures recorded as a result of increased awareness · Connected Communities – Councillor Brian Jones reported that the condition of Denbighshire’s roads did not necessarily reflect public perception given that there had only been a minor deterioration in the county’s A roads and an improvement in B and C roads – extra funding had been made available for highways for the current financial year and changes to in-house teams would lead to improvements in addressing smaller scale road defects in the county · Young People – Public Health had set a measure for the national childhood measurement programme which coupled together children of a healthy weight with those underweight – Councillor Feeley felt that was ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Richard Mainon proposed, seconded by Councillor Tony Thomas that Councillor Brian Jones be appointed Vice Chair.
There being no further nominations and upon being put to the vote it was – RESOLVED that Councillor Brian Jones be appointed Vice Chair of the Licensing Committee for the ensuing year.
Councillor Brian Jones, Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, introduced the report (previously circulated) presenting the recommendation from the Strategic Planning Group and Cabinet regarding the Replacement LDP Draft Preferred Strategy and to seek approval to consult on the draft Preferred Strategy.
Councillor Timms expressed concern due to the fact that the Lead Member, Councillor Brian Jones, had not supported the process or the LDP and he did not propose the recommendation at the Cabinet meeting. · During the aforementioned Cabinet meeting, the webcast had ceased to broadcast due to an issue with the external internet feed which had been out of the control of the council and it had affected a large surrounding area.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report detailing the work undertaken to date on Denbighshire’s Replacement Local Development Plan (LDP) and recommendations from the Strategic Planning Group regarding the Draft Preferred Strategy for the LDP. The Replacement LDP would provide up to date planning policies and site allocations for development to address issues and needs in the county for the period 2018 – 2033. In brief, the Draft Preferred Strategy set out – Draft Proposed Levels of Growth – · 68ha of employment land to accommodate a forecasted land requirement of 47.6ha · Land for 3,775 new homes to meet a housing requirement of 3,275 homes Draft Proposed Spatial Approach – · Focus development in Bodelwyddan Strategic Site and serviced settlements: the top three tiers in the settlement hierarchy (main centres, local centres and villages) with more limited growth in other unserviced settlements (infill & small sites within development boundaries), primarily focused on meeting local needs.
At this point, the Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, Councillor Brian Jones stated that within his portfolio they had applied for additional funding but were unsuccessful in the bid.
Page 17 (Item 3) – Councillor Mabon ap Gwynfor expressed his gratitude to the Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, Councillor Brian Jones, for sending a written response to [name removed]. He expressed concern that the information should be made clearer to parents. He ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
As a point of clarification Councillor Brian Jones confirmed the new LDP would be adopted in 2021 for the period up to 2033. The Leader confirmed that Cabinet would carefully consider scrutiny’s position and valued their input into the decision making process.
The following matters were raised during debate – · the Chief Executive provided assurances to Cabinet advising that the downward trend in terms of budget pressure over the last couple of months had been largely due to the positive action taken by senior officers in managing expenditure to ensure a more robust position going forward · Councillor Brian Jones reported that Dawnus Construction, who sub contracted out the Pont y Ddraig bridge maintenance contract, had recently gone into administration. Assurances were provided that temporary measures had been implemented to ensure the bridge operated effectively and was properly maintained prior to the award of a formal maintenance contract · the Head of Legal, HR and Democratic Services also advised that Dawnus Construction was one of the successful bidders on the North Wales Construction Framework and reported upon discussions with the administrators regarding their position and legalities surrounding that process and the potential exclusion of Dawnus from the framework – in the event of their exclusion Dawnus would likely be replaced by the next highest scoring supplier · reference to an overspend relating to SC2 had been included within the report and the Head of Facilities, Assets and Housing clarified that SC2 was not overspent and explained that instead of requiring corporate cash the service had opted to subsume the entire set up costs. The provision for set up costs had been contained with
Matters Arising – Page 9: Update on the introduction of a list of designated wheelchair accessible vehicles – In response to a question from Councillor Brian Jones, the Public Protection Business Manager confirmed that a list of designated wheelchair accessible vehicles had been published on the Council’s website.
Officers also reported upon the scope of the consultation to inform Cabinet Briefing and Councillor Brian Jones confirmed that the North Wales Transport Advisory Forum had also considered the proposals and would provide an input to enable Cabinet Briefing to consider Denbighshire’s position. Members noted that there were some positive aspects arising from the proposals including standardising policies and procedures across Wales to ensure a consistent approach, greater enforcement powers for local authorities, the sharing of information for safeguarding purposes, and modernisation of processes. However members stressed the importance of local control, knowledge and accountability and firmly believed that local authorities should continue to have responsibility for taxi and private hire licensing within their areas, believing them to be best placed to effectively deal with local issues and influence local outcomes, ensuring greater control over the taxi and private hire trade in the county.
Councillor Brian Jones referred to the practice of operators offering cut price fares and he highlighted associated problems in that regard which might escalate in the future. Officers advised that the hackney carriage tariffs set by the Council related to the maximum amount which could be charged and operators were free to charge less than the tariff set. Officers also confirmed they had not been made aware of any problems associated with the practice of undercutting fares during recent times.
“Could the Lead Member please explain the policy regarding the school transportation of epileptic children and young adults who require rescue medication in Denbighshire?” Response by the Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, Councillor Brian Jones:
“What about specifically in relation to rescue medication for epilepsy?” Councillor Brian Jones confirmed he would send [name removed] a detailed response within 7 days.
As Lead Member for Highways, Councillor Brian Jones shared those concerns going forward and highlighted the need to keep the matter under close review to ensure sufficiency of the highway infrastructure given the anticipated increase in traffic arising from future housing developments.
How does our county recycle this type of wrapping paper?” Response by the Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, Councillor Brian Jones:
General Debate – Local Member, Councillor Brian Jones asked members to consider the point about guidance and informed Committee he was against the application. He stated that due to the size of the two storey extension, it would unacceptable for someone to lose so much light.
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed refusal of the application, against officer recommendation, due to the loss of daylight/sunlight and overbearing impact on the neighbour, seconded by Councillor Tony Thomas.
Matters Arising – Special Cabinet (15 October 2018) – Councillor Brian Jones noted the end of the meeting had been recorded as 6.10 p.m. and felt it would be prudent to use twenty-four hour clock in future to avoid any confusion.
In response to a question from Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones regarding the independent report into the flooding at Ffordd Derwen , Rhyl, Councillor Brian Jones confirmed that a letter to residents was imminent · in response to questions raised regarding the Llantysilio Mountain fire, the Leader advised that a report would be submitted to Communities Scrutiny Committee in February 2019 in order to consider the impact and lessons ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Brian Jones proposed the item be deferred pending the erection of the chimney.
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed deferral of the application, seconded by Councillor Julian Thompson- Hill.
Councillor Brian Jones sought assurance that the concerns of individuals who had raised concerns / objections had been addressed.
Councillor Brian Jones added that budgeted income had been set too high and would be revised in the next financial year to reflect the reduction · Streetscene – Councillor Brian Jones elaborated upon the £200k cost required to remedy an issue with ‘Legacy Tips’ in order to meet statutory requirements · Waste – the pressure in 2018/19 would be funded from the Waste Reserve and a budget pressure of £850k had been included in the Medium ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Proposal - Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
Proposal – Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill proposed to refuse in accordance with the officer recommendation, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed to refuse in accordance with the officer recommendation, seconded by Councillor Christine Marston.
Councillor Brian Jones – Agenda Item 5 – Member of Rhyl Business Group Councillor Tony Thomas – Agenda Item 5 – BID Group Member/Business Owner Councillor Emrys Wynne – Agenda Item 7 – Family member employed by Council Councillor Richard Mainon – Agenda Item 13 – Daughter formerly employed by Bodelwyddan Castle Trust
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report regarding the future operating arrangements for the Council’s three Household Recycling Centres (HRC) in Ruthin, Denbigh and Rhyl.
The position was carefully monitored and officers worked with schools to ensure robust recovery plans were in place; the responsibilities of the Governing Bodies in schools financial management were also highlighted · there had been a reduction in the Education Improvement Grant from the Welsh Government for which exit costs of £15k had been predicted – in cases where grant funding ceased the work subject of that grant funding also ceased but some consequential costs, such as redundancy, had to be met by the Council · Highways – the impact of the reduction in the amount of work and re-imbursement coming from the North and Mid Wales Trunk Road Agency was highlighted and Councillor Brian Jones advised that the amount would be adjusted accordingly · Agreed Savings – in terms of the service efficiencies agreed for 2018/19 whilst some of those savings would have some potential level of impact on services it was considered they would not have a significant impact on service delivery – all savings green or yellow could be achieved without detriment to front line services – the Head of Finance agreed to check whether the deletion of a Service Manager Post (Ref CSS E001) had been included in the costs for restructuring the Provider Services Management Team (ref CSS E002).
Proposal – Councillor Alan James proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
Proposal – Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill proposed, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones that the application be deferred pending a site visit to take into account matters in relation to highway safety and the impact on adjoining properties.
During consideration of the report members discussed the following – · the reporting mechanisms for monitoring performance and progress in delivering the Corporate Plan was clarified which involved reports to Cabinet, Scrutiny Committees, Corporate Governance Committee and Senior Leadership Team · Councillor Bobby Feeley provided further information on matters relating to her portfolio including extra care housing developments which would help to reduce residential care home stays; a project to further support carers; positive feedback for Single Point of Access and Locality Teams in supporting people’s independence, and a range of other ongoing work to effect improvements · Councillor Brian Jones advised that the Highways Strategy had been subject to a positive scrutiny process and an illustration of street works was being presented to the Member Area Groups; he also reported upon progress with the surface dressing programme · the Plan was deliberately ambitious and challenging and had been aligned to the Public Service Board objectives in terms of prioritising Resilience and Connected Communities; the Chief Executive added that the Plan had been given top priority and provided assurances regarding its future delivery · Councillor Mabon ap Gwynfor questioned the acceptable performance status for Connected Communities given the unacceptable condition of the B4401 road and lack of action in addressing those concerns. The methodology
Councillor Brian Jones agreed to take up the issue with regard to the B4401 and encouraged complainants to log incidents on the CRM system · officers confirmed that the overall figure for new council housing included buying back of former council houses and agreed to clarify the issue in future reports · Councillor Rhys Thomas asked Cabinet to bear in mind that even though the report was measured against overall national targets, there were areas of underperformance in individual communities which should not be overlooked.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report seeking approval to commence a procurement to establish a transport dynamic purchasing system (DPS) to operate learner transport and local bus services across Denbighshire.
Councillor Brian Jones confirmed that the previous level of income was no longer achievable and the issue was being reviewed by the service. The Head of Finance added that the pressure would be considered as part of the 2019/20 budget process.
Proposal – Councillor Peter Evans proposed the application together with the amendment to Condition 21 as stated by the Senior Highways Engineer, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones.
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Alan James.
Councillor Brian Jones requested confirmation from officers regarding the highway and access routes to the site. In response, the Senior Engineer- Highways clarified that the trunk road was the responsibility of Welsh Government, and that they would have been consulted on planning applications relating to the site. With regard to the application, no objections had been raised.
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Welsh in Education Strategic Plan 2017 – 2020 – Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts – Governor/Parent of child in Denbighshire school Councillor Brian Jones – Parent of child in Denbighshire school Councillor Tony Thomas – Parent of child in Denbighshire school
He added that the merits of a three year budget instead of a one-off annual budget settlement for local authorities had been discussed by the Welsh Local Government Association · Councillor Brian Jones advised that Welsh Government officials would be attending a meeting of the Performance Scrutiny Committee on 7 June to discuss highway funding and he would raise the point about the need for timely funding allocations in order to plan effectively for highway works.
Councillor Brian Jones, Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, introduced the report presenting the Supplementary Planning Guidance (SPG) Note: Clwydian Range and Dee Valley Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) – Adoption of finalised document.
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 – Rhyl Underground Car Park Refurbishment – Councillor Meirick Davies because he was Chair of the North Wales Fire Authority Councillor Brian Jones because he was a Rhyl Town Councillor Councillor Tony Thomas because he was a Rhyl Town Councillor Councillor Arwel Roberts declared a personal interested in agenda item 7 – Finance Report because he was a School Governor (Ysgol Dewi Sant & Ysgol y Castell)
The letter to Welsh Government regarding the Local Development Plan had since been circulated to all members by Councillor Brian Jones.
The following matters were raised during debate – · the additional funding recently announced by Welsh Government for schools and highways was welcomed but it was hoped that in future years any additional provision would be allocated earlier in the financial year in order to better aid financial planning · Councillor Brian Jones reported that savings had been made through core funding and management costs to reduce the shortfall in the Major Projects Team from £165k to £115k. There was also a need to reduce the income figure for the Major Projects Team in the ensuing year in order to better reflect the current position · it was currently projected that the effects of the recent adverse weather on the winter maintenance budget could be contained within existing resources although the matter would be kept under close review and the Welsh Local Government Association had requested financial help from Welsh Government in order to help pay for the impact of the severe weather · concerns were raised regarding the impact of the adverse weather in terms of highways, woodlands and footpaths together with the need for an appropriate repair and maintenance programme, to include cost implications, in order to address those issues. The wider impact on other council services was also highlighted such as those heavily reliant on income generation which would be significantly affected by closed facilities.
It was highlighted that some local businesses had also been badly affected and suggested that Welsh Government could also take that aspect into account · members were encouraged to report any highway concerns through the CRM system so that they could be appropriately logged and actioned but Councillor Meirick Davies felt that there should be a separate mechanism for urgent works required in order to avoid any undue delay · tribute was paid to the work of Highways staff in responding to the recent adverse weather conditions and maintaining the county’s roads and Councillor Brian Jones advised that the Head of Highways and Environmental Services would include Cabinet’s appreciation in his communication to all staff involved · Councillor Arwel Roberts reiterated previous concerns regarding schools in deficit and subsequent impact due to increases in the state pension age.
Response by the Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, Councillor Brian Jones:
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Peter Evans that the application be deferred pending resolution of the odour nuisance.
Councillor Brian Jones presented the report outlining proposals to replace the Local Development Plan Steering Group with a more focused Strategic Planning Group to lead on the development of a replacement Local Development Plan (LDP).
Councillor Brian Jones presented the confidential report seeking Cabinet approval to award contracts for local bus services in accordance with Contract Procedures Rules to the most economically advantageous tenderers.
Councillor Brian Jones abstained from voting on this item.
The following matters were raised during debate – · it was clarified that an element of the funding costs had been retained through the contract for the Rhyl Harbour Development and Rhyl New School projects which would be released following completion of the final snagging elements · with regard to the pressures and projected shortfall in income for the Major Projects Team (Highways and Environment) Councillor Brian Jones advised there may be future opportunities for the team which were currently being explored.
Councillor Brian Jones, Lead member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, introduced the report.
Regarding the housing element, Lead Member Councillor Brian Jones, who was a Rhyl Local Member, would be a member of the Board.
Councillor Brian Jones, Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel, presented the report and confirmed the draft document would be translated following Committee approval.
Councillor Brian Jones, Lead Member for Highways, Planning and Sustainable Travel introduced the report presenting the draft Supplementary Planning Guidance Note: Clwydian Range and Dee Valley Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) – consultation document.
An application had been submitted for the development of 0.05ha of land by erection of 1 dwelling (outline application including access, layout, scale) at land adjacent to 21 Stanley Park Avenue, Rhyl Councillor Brian Jones (Local Member) spoke in favour of the application, following discussions with neighbouring occupants also in favour of the development.
Proposal – Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Alan James that the application be granted in accordance with officer recommendations of the proposed development in planning terms.
Proposal – Given the planning history and officer recommendation, and the fact that the development would generate jobs for the area, Councillor Tony Thomas proposed, seconded by Councillor Brian Jones, that the application be granted.
Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Arwel Roberts that Councillor Hugh Irving be appointed Chair.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Jones attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Jones's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Jones was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 1 of 4 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Jones declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Oct 2025 | Licensing Sub Committee, item 2 | Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in agenda item 3 because he knew the Designated Premises Supervisor through previous charity work. | |
| 22 May 2025 | Partnerships Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in business item 7, Household Waste Recycling Centres, as he was the Lead Member for Waste, Transport and Environment at the time of awarding the contract for operating the Household Waste Recycling Centres to Bryson Recycling Limited. | |
| 6 Dec 2023 | Licensing Committee, item 2 | Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 9 – Review of a Licence to Drive Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicles as he became aware, once he had seen the Driver subject of the review, that he was known to him. | |
| 6 Dec 2023 | Licensing Committee, item 9 | [Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in this item as he became aware that the Driver was known to him and he subsequently left the meeting before the decision-making stage taking no part in the deliberations.] A confidential report by the Head of Planning, Public Protection and Countryside Services (previously circulated) was submitted upon – (i) the suitability of Driver No. 550166 to hold a licence to drive hackney carriage and private hire vehicles following a complaint regarding drug use and a positive roadside drug test carried out by the North Wales Police in October 2023 ; | Left the room |
| 19 Sep 2023 | Cabinet, item 2 | Councillor Gill German declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because she was a Director of Denbighshire Leisure Limited Councillor Pauline Edwards declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because she was a School Governor of Ysgol Pendref Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 – Rhyl BID Re-Ballot because he was a Director of Rhyl BID Councillor Rhys Thomas declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because he lived near to the Ystrad Road site and because he was a Director of Denbighshire Leisure Limited Councillor Emrys Wynne declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because he had a close personal association to persons living near to one of the sites Councillor Mark Young declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 – Ysgol Plas Brondyffryn Project because he was a School Governor of Denbigh High School | |
| 13 Sep 2023 | Licensing Committee, item 2 | Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 – Proposed changes to Hackney Carriage Vehicles Table of Fares and Charges, because as a former Cabinet Member he had been involved in discussions with a large proportion of the taxi trade with regard to the Electric Vehicle Charging Pilot. | |
| 9 Mar 2022 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal interest in agenda item 9 - Kynsal House, Vale Road, Rhyl as he had previously been contacted by residents regarding concerns at the site. | |
| 8 Dec 2021 | Licensing Committee, item 2 | Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 6 because he knew the applicant’s representative. | |
| 15 Jul 2020 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Brian Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in Agenda Item 8 (Brynllithrig Bach Cottage, Rhuallt). | |
| 15 Jul 2020 | Planning Committee, item 6 | Councillor Brian Jones declared a prejudicial interest, took no part in the debate and abstained from the vote. | Took no part |
Where Councillor Jones sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cabinet | Member | Sep 2026 | 3 | 15 Dec 2026 |
| Communities Scrutiny Committee | Member | Sep 2026 | 1 | 3 Dec 2026 |
| Denbighshire Further Education Trust Fund | Aelod | Mar 2020 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.