Application no. 45/2021/0738/ pc - 7 llys walsh, rhyl, ll18 4fr
The request for a deferral was seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Every time Denbighshire's minutes name Councillor Butterfield, as the council published it.
The request for a deferral was seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
[Councillor Joan Butterfield abstained from voting on this item because she had not been present at the above mentioned meeting.]
Discussion focused on the following – · the Scrutiny Chairs and Vice Chairs Group had previously resolved that no scrutiny committee meetings should be held after commencement of the pre-election period (18 March) unless urgent business necessitated a meeting being held, therefore the Committee’s next scheduled meeting on 7 April had been cancelled with no further meetings scheduled during the current Council term · the Scrutiny Chairs and Vice Chairs Group had allocated an item for consideration by the new Committee at their meeting in October 2022 with regard to partnership working in relation to mental health · Councillor Joan Butterfield suggested the Royal Alexandra Hospital, Rhyl as a future topic for scrutiny by the new Council given the lack of progress with the project and need to keep the matter under close review. The Scrutiny Coordinator referred to the process for allocating potential items for scrutiny via the Scrutiny Chairs and Vice Chairs Group following completion and submission of the proposal form which had been attached as an appendix to the report.
Councillor Joan Butterfield nominated Councillor Cheryl Williams, seconded by Councillor Brian Blakeley.
Councillor Pete Prendergast put forward the Notice of Motion in the absence of Councillor Joan Butterfield. The Notice of Motion was originally put forward on behalf of the Labour Group for consideration by Full Council:
General Debate – Councillor Ellie Chard (Local Member) proposed, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield, that the application be granted advising that she was fully supportive of the proposal which would be an asset to the town providing skills and employment and economic growth. She had been reassured by the measures to address flood risk and noted the existing facilities at the site and surrounding areas.
Proposal – Councillor Ellie Chard proposed that the application be granted in accordance with officer recommendations as set out in the report, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Councillor Joan Butterfield stated that there was a change to the demographics in the County, the population was aging. There was a ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Proposal – Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill proposed to grant the application in accordance with officer recommendations, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Councillor Joan Butterfield agreed strongly with strengthening the wording.
In response to a question from Councillor Meirick Lloyd Davies officers confirmed that the current LDP would continue until a new LDP had been adopted Councillor Joan Butterfield queried whether Corporate Joint Committees would have an impact on the LDP. Officers informed the committee that in the future there would be a strategic development plan for North Wales, which would sit above the local LDP, however it would not be implemented for a number of years.
Councillor Joan Butterfield declared a personal interest in agenda item 9, as she was on the Queens Market Board Councillor Pete Prendergast declared a personal interest in agenda item 10, as he was a director of Denbighshire Leisure.
Councillor Butterfield made particular reference to Condition 11 to the report, regarding the removal of structures if the attraction ceased for a period of 6 months. She asked if it was possible to add additional explanation and details to the condition.
He confirmed the Local Members to be Councillor Joan Butterfield and Councillor Alan James.
The Local Member Councillor Joan Butterfield was contented with the application. The regeneration of the Queens Building would benefit the whole of the community and surrounding areas in Denbighshire, proving a range of produce and activities. The regeneration of the site would increase the number of all year jobs available.
The Local Member Councillor Alan James reiterated the thoughts of Councillor Butterfield.
Proposed by Councillor Joan Butterfield to grant the application in accordance with officer recommendations, seconded by Councillor Mark Young. Vote – Grant – 15 Abstain – 0 Refuse – 0 RESOLVED that permission be GRANTED in accordance with officer recommendations as detailed within the report and supplementary papers.
Councillor Joan Butterfield declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 as a relative worked for Care Inspectorate Wales (CIW).
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Barry Mellor that Councillor Pete Prendergast be appointed Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Barry Mellor that Councillor Pete Prendergast be appointed Vice Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield added that for eateries, planning permission was required for tables and chairs in a defined area outside of the premises. Whilst officers were keen for a policy to be in place at the earliest opportunity the need for the policy to be robust and fit for purpose was paramount.
Councillor Brian Jones proposed, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield to approve the draft policy for consultation and support the creation of a Sub Group to include the Licensing Committee’s Chair and/or Vice Chair and representation from each Member Area Group. Upon being put to the vote it was – RESOLVED that the Committee – (a) approve the draft street trading policy (Appendix A to the report) for consultation, and (b) support the establishment of a Sub Group to further consider the policy to include the Chair and/or Vice Chair to represent the Licensing Committee together with a representative from each of the Member Area Groups.
Both Councillor Joan Butterfield and Alan Hughes confirmed they would not take part in the voting until they had received additional training which would take place prior to the Planning Committee meeting to be held in July 2021.
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 7 – Finance Report (2020/21 Financial Outturn) in so far as it related to school balances – Councillor Joan Butterfield – School Governor Christ the Word Catholic School Councillor Meirick Davies – School Governor Ysgol Cefn Meiriadog Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts – School Governor Ysgol Pen Barras Councillor Emrys Wynne – School Governor Ysgol Brynhyfryd & Ysgol Borthyn Councillor Mark Young – School Governor Denbigh High School Councillor Gwyneth Kensler declared a personal item in agenda item 3 – Urgent Matters: UK Government Levelling Up Funding Clwyd South Constituency because she was Chair of Cadwyn Clwyd Local Action Group who had previously provided funding for the Four Highways project in Llangollen.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor Alan James to be elected Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield, Leader of the Labour Group, nominated Councillor Bob Murray, and was seconded by Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor Pete Prendergast, seconded by Councillor Bob Murray, to be the Vice Chair for the 2021/2022 municipal year.
Councillor Joan Butterfield highlighted the dire financial position and projected overspends earlier in the financial year and turnaround to a positive position due to the grant funding provided to the council by Welsh Government.
Councillor Joan Butterfield put forward the following Notice of Motion on behalf of the Labour Group for consideration by Full Council.
Councillor Joan Butterfield spoke in favour of the recommendation and confirmed that Rhyl Member Area Group had scrutinised the programme in depth and, whilst appreciating the significant ... view the full minutes text for item 11.
It was noted that problems may be caused on taxi ranks due to space in providing for rear access and many such vehicles displayed signage requesting sufficient distance be kept clear for that purpose · Collisions – Councillor Joan Butterfield was keen to ensure costs incurred by vehicle proprietors were kept to a minimum and asked for a further amendment to specify that in cases where a compliance test was required following a collision, the compliance test may be used as one of the regular compliance tests required. To comply with that request officers agreed to amend the relevant section to read as follows “In the event of a licence being suspended due to the nature of the damage, the proprietor shall, at their own cost, have the vehicle tested under the requirements of a compliance test at DCC Fleet Management and Vehicle Maintenance Centre. Following which, they should submit the Compliance Certificate for examination by an authorised officer prior to the licence being reinstated.
Members also noted the planned licensing training session in September and Councillor Joan Butterfield asked for an overview of the types of complaint received by the service together with the complaints process followed in that regard to be made available as part of that training session.
Councillor Barry Mellor put forward the following Notice of Motion on behalf of Councillor Joan Butterfield, who was unable to attend the meeting, for consideration by Full Council:
Councillor Joan Butterfield queried the potential impact on deprivation and whether any jobs would be lost from existing nominated testing stations as a result of a move to in-house testing. Assurances were provided that the loss to nominated testing stations related solely to ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Councillor Joan Butterfield explained about a newly formed Denbighshire panel, the Climate Change and Ecological Emergency Working Group. Assistant Chief Officer Morris requested being sighted on the Group’s activities and initiatives. There was a possibility information could be shared through the Public Services Board meetings.
At this juncture, Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor Peter Prendergast to sit on the Board of Directors and the proposal was seconded.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillors Graham Timms and Brian Blakeley to sit on the recruitment panel and the proposal was seconded.
Councillor Joan Butterfield (Local Member) as ward members she had been requested by local residents to speak against the application. The residents did hold a public meeting to discuss and their concerns with regard to the planning application. The proposed property was highlighted as having potential as a possible family homes.
Councillor Joan Butterfield, requested conditions which could be included with the application – · Parking to the rear of the property should be used by the staff and not on the streets in front of the property.
At this juncture, Councillor Joan Butterfield requested that Councillor Barry Mellor sit on ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Following discussions, Councillor Joan Butterfield requested an adjournment to consult with members of the Labour group. This was agreed by all present.
Councillor Joan Butterfield queried where to find the detail of in-county placement costs for Adults and Children’s Services to ensure value for money. It was explained that the budget book provided an annual summary but the specific placements detail was monitored by the individual service areas as part of their delegated budgets for which the relevant Head of Service was responsible.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Barry Mellor that Councillor Alan James be appointed Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Barry Mellor that Councillor Alan James be appointed Vice Chair.
However Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Alan James that in the event of any future complaint or enquiry from licensees regarding the document, the officers, in consultation with the Chair, be authorised to respond confirming that the matter would not be brought back before the Committee given that the opportunity to respond to the Statement of Policy had passed. Upon being put to the vote it was – RESOLVED that – (a) the Statement of Policy regarding the suitability of applicants and licensees in the hackney carriage and private hire trades (attached at Appendix A to the report) be adopted with an implementation date of 1 July 2019;
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed that Councillor Alan James be elected Vice-Chair of the Council for the 2019/2020 municipal year.
At this juncture, Councillor Joan Butterfield requested a recorded vote.
In response to a question from Councillor Joan Butterfield, Councillor Thomas confirmed the 2% savings required from schools had been discussed at the lines of inquiry meeting with the challenge meeting focusing largely on the service responsibilities. The Chief Executive added that assurances had been provided regarding the robust financial management of schools’ budgets with financial recovery plans in place for those schools in deficit.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor Alan James, seconded by Councillor Huw Williams, to be the Vice Chair for the 2019/2020 municipal year.
At this juncture, Councillor Joan Butterfield requested a recorded vote.
Councillor Joan Butterfield confirmed a Board had been set up to deal with all aspects of the bridge for the future. The Chief Executive also confirmed that the bridge had been a unique project and SLT had commissioned a “lessons learnt” report to ensure the process would be utilised for all future projects.
Accuracy – Councillor Gwyneth Kensler pointed out on Page 1 of the minutes under Item 1 – within the paragraph for the petition there was a spelling mistake and should read “a petition was handed in by Councillor Joan Butterfield on behalf of …….” and not “on behave of …” Matters Arising:
Councillor Emrys Wynne and Councillor Joan Butterfield declared personal interests in agenda item 5- Annual report of safeguarding adults in Denbighshire 1st April 2017 – 31 st March 2018.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Barry Mellor that Councillor Alan James be appointed Chair.
Councillor Huw Williams proposed, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield that Councillor Alan James be appointed Vice Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield suggested an amendment to the Notice of Motion which would be to bring a report back to a future Council meeting with the costs involved and also report on the dialogue with the manufacturers of the products.
Councillors Joan Butterfield and Emrys Wynne both expressed an interest and following a tied vote Councillor Wynne waived his interest in favour of Councillor Butterfield.
RESOLVED that – (a) subject to the addition of the items agreed during the meeting, the work programme as detailed in Appendix 1 to the report be approved, and (b) Councillor Joan Butterfield be appointed as the Committee’s temporary representative on the Strategic Investment Group pending the Chair’s return.
Referring to the Denbighshire Homelessness Strategy and Denbighshire Supporting People / Homelessness Prevention Plan Councillor Butterfield asked whether the Authority had a policy defining residency. The Corporate Director: Communities responded that ‘residency’ sat across a number of legislative frameworks and applications had to be considered on a case by case basis. Members might want to consider the complexity by referring it to the Scrutiny Chairs and Vice-chairs Group.
Councillor Butterfield requested that the £1million homelessness grant from Welsh Government be covered by homelessness report.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor Bob Murray, seconded by Councillor Brian Blakeley, to be the Vice-chair for the 2018/19 municipal year.
Councillor Joan Butterfield put forward the following Notice of Motion for the consideration of Full Council:
Councillor Joan Butterfield had requested a recorded vote to which the Head of Legal, HR and Democratic Services stated that within the Constitution, it was required that one sixth of Members had to be in favour of the Recorded Vote to which a majority of Members agreed.
Councillor Joan Butterfield requested a short deferral of the meeting for the Labour Group to consider the two options charging a premium of either 50% or 100%.
Councillor Joan Butterfield raised questions regarding children’s services. The Contracts Officer clarified that phase 2 related to children’s domiciliary care and the community living element would be dealt with as part of phase 4, elaborating upon the expected timescales for service provision. She also confirmed that the completed contract and service specification could be made available to members.
Councillor Joan Butterfield expressed an interest in attending the SIG meetings if she was able to confirm transport arrangements.
The following councillors declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 4 – Councillor Joan Butterfield declared that she sometimes used the Applicant’s taxi service (Leddon's Taxis) Councillor Alan James declared that he used the taxi service (Town & Country Taxis) of the Applicant’s supporter who was also known to him Councillor Tony Thomas declared that the Applicant was resident in his ward.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Barry Mellor that Councillor Alan James be appointed Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Barry Mellor that Councillor Alan James be appointed Vice Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield reported that the sex establishment formerly situated in Water Street, Rhyl had been relocated outside of the county but it had operated discretely with no problems and without causing offence.
Councillor Joan Butterfield highlighted the importance of a fit for purpose policy, particularly for the larger towns, and was pleased that the policy would be brought back to committee for ratification. Whilst she did not recall the draft policy being submitted to Rhyl Town Council she would review their response and revisit the draft policy in response to the consultation.
Councillor Butterfield was particularly keen to review the proposed system of temporary block consents for street trading and suggested that a map be produced in that regard for clarity. The PPBM encouraged engagements with City, Town and Community Councils and welcomed the opportunity to discuss the matter further.
Councillor Joan Butterfield also welcomed the project which she felt was integral to the regeneration of Rhyl and thanked all those involved for their commitment and perseverance in progressing ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor Peter Prendergast to be elected Chair, outlining the personal qualities and vast experience he would bring to the position.
At this juncture Councillor Joan Butterfield questioned [name removed] being Chair of the Standards Committee due to the fact he was Chair of the Conservative party.
Proposal – Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones proposed the officer recommendations to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Proposal – Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Stuart Davies.
Councillor Joan Butterfield suggested that the guidance document produced by officers to raise awareness of CSE within the community could be shared with schools given the links with school transport.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor David Simmons, seconded by Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones.
Councillor Joan Butterfield welcomed the project as another means of delivering the Rhyl regeneration priority. In response to further questions officers drew attention to the draft consultation document (attached to the report ) confirming consultation would commence in partnership with the Catholic Diocese of Wrexham to run from 14 February – 27 March 2017. In terms of the initial proposal for a Joint Anglican Faith School the Lead Member explained the impasse in terms of the site location.
Councillor Joan Butterfield drew attention to disadvantaged groups in Rhyl and whilst she agreed that local councillors should take the lead under the new approach, she also stressed the importance of support from the Council, particularly for groups who did not have the expertise to develop projects or access funding.
Councillor Joan Butterfield raised some general queries regarding the disposal of agricultural estates and she was directed to the Agricultural Estates Working Group.
Proposal – Councillor David Simmons proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Proposal - Councillor Barry Mellor proposed Members adopt the SPG including the amendment as stated above, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Proposal - Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed that Members approved the draft Supplementary Planning Guidance document: Recreational Open Space, attached at Appendix 1, to be the subject of public consultation over a minimum of 9 weeks.
The Chair declared that he intended to include for discussion the following matter requiring urgent attention – WHEELCHAIR ACCESSIBLE TAXIS Councillor Joan Butterfield highlighted a recent case whereby a number of wheelchair accessible taxis operating in the Rhyl area had refused to accept a booking to transport a wheelchair user. She referred to extra hackney carriage licences issued specifically for wheelchair accessible vehicles in order to provide that service and expressed serious concerns that taxis advertising that service refused to provide it. Officers were aware a number of taxis had been advertised as specialist wheelchair carriers and agreed to look into the matter further.
Councillor Joan Butterfield referred to problems with travellers having easy access to open spaces such as housing development sites and asked that this be taken into consideration as part of the process.
Proposal – Councillor Bob Murray proposed the officer recommendation to approve the draft SPG for consultation, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield. It was unanimously – RESOLVED that members agree the draft Supplementary Planning Guidance on Planning for Community Safety, as attached at Appendix 1 to the report, for public consultation.
[At this juncture Councillor Joan Butterfield left the meeting.]
Councillor Joan Butterfield declared a personal interest in this item as she was a Member of the Community Housing Trust.
Councillor Joan Butterfield declared a personal interest in West Rhyl Housing Improvement Project.
Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts proposed, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield that Councillor Raymond Bartley be appointed Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield requested an update on the former Rhyl Funfair site.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed that Councillor Win Mullen-James be elected Vice-Chair of the Council for the 2016/17 municipal year.
Proposal – Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill proposed the officer recommendations as detailed within the report, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Election of Vice Chair – Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain Jones that Councillor Win Mullen-James be nominated for Vice Chair for the 2016/17 municipal year. There were no further nominations.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed a Working Group be set up to look at the diversification of Council meetings.
Councillor Joan Butterfield reported that Rhyl Members fully supported Rhyl as a regeneration priority but expressed a number of concerns as follows – · the lack of input from Rhyl Members when formulating the regeneration plan and their lack of involvement in the project boards overseeing particular initiatives · the lack of investment in maintaining Rhyl facilities such as the Skytower and Sun Centre but investment being made to facilities in other areas of the county · concerns regarding the delay on the part of Pennaf Housing Group (including Clwyd Alyn Housing Association) in delivering the housing development aspect of the West Rhyl Housing Improvement Project (WRHIP) · highlighted the significant investment made in Rhyl West which had resulted in little or no impact on outcomes and lack of investment in other areas · welcomed the investment in the Rhyl New School but noted no further progress with the new Faith School.
(i) Councillor Joan Butterfield requested the absence of a member be discussed at the end of the meeting. This was agreed.
· Councillor Joan Butterfield also congratulated officers for their work on the Capital Plan.
Councillor Butterfield then stated that Member Area Groups (MAGs) should benefit from some of the savings. She requested that this be discussed at a budget workshop.
Proposal – Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Win Mullen James.
· Councillor Joan Butterfield, as Leader of the Labour Group confirmed that due to the Settlement from the Welsh Government being better than expected, the Labour Group were in agreement to approve the Council Tax increase of 1.5%.
Councillor Butterfield also stated that the Labour Group hoped the Settlement for 2016/17 would protect services for the most vulnerable and isolated people within the county.
Councillor Butterfield then expressed concern regarding the Police precept. It was confirmed that Police and City, Town and Community Councils set their own level of Council Tax which was then added to the County Councils.
Proposal – Councillor Merfyn Parry proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Councillor Joan Butterfield (Local Member) referred to previous frustrations over the site’s development and was pleased that progress was now being made and wished the project every success. She was particularly pleased that the development would generate local employment which was desperately needed.
Proposal – Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones that the application be granted.
Proposal – Councillor Joan Butterfield (Local Member) considered there would be no detrimental impact as a result of the development and proposed the officer recommendation to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Cheryl Williams.
Proposal – Councillor Joan Butterfield (Local Member) had no objection to the application and proposed the officer recommendation to grant, seconded by Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones.
The following members declared a personal interest in agenda item 5 – Councillor Joan Butterfield – Governor Ysgol Tir Morfa Councillor Meirick Davies – Governor Ysgol Cefn Meiriadog & Ysgol Trefnant Councillor Bobby Feeley – Governor Rhos Street School Councillor Martyn Holland – Governor Ysgol Bro Famau Councillor Huw Jones – Governor Ysgol Caer Drewyn & Ysgol Carrog Councillor Merfyn Parry – Governor Ysgol Bryn Clwyd & Ysgol Gellifor Councillor Arwel Roberts – Governor Ysgol y Castell & Ysgol Dewi Sant Councillor David Simmons – Governor Ysgol Tir Morfa Councillor David Smith – Grandson in Ysgol Pen Barras Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill – Governor Ysgol Clawdd Offa Councillors Bobby Feeley, Hugh Irving and Julian Thompson-Hill declared a personal and prejudicial interest in agenda item 11 relating to Cefndy Healthcare. As those members had been nominated by the Council to the Cefndy Healthcare Management Board they had been granted an exemption under the Code of Conduct and permitted to take part in the debate and vote on the item.
Officers agreed to progress the issue outside of the meeting and raised the possibility of a joint approach with other local authorities and putting forward alternative suggestions for consideration · an explanation was provided in terms of member involvement on the Housing Strategy Group with those Cabinet members having elements of housing in their portfolios being involved at an early stage to provide a member perspective before the strategy was submitted through formal channels – Communities Scrutiny Committee in September and full Council in October · Councillor Joan Butterfield referred to homelessness issues and difficulties finding suitable accommodation, advising of an existing case in order to illustrate the point, and the need to address the issue as a matter of urgency – officers confirmed that homelessness had been identified as a priority within the Housing Strategy and members would have the opportunity to scrutinise the strategy at Communities Scrutiny Committee in September. With regard to the existing case referred to, it was agreed that the matter be looked into further by officers outside of the meeting · concerns were raised regarding the Council’s eyesore sites and the need for a more vigorous approach to be undertaken to address them.
At the request of Councillor Joan Butterfield the Head of Planning and Public Protection agreed to report upon the recent changes and latest position to the Rhyl Member Area Group · the two red indicators from the Residents Survey in which residents had not responded positively to the Council was queried as it seemed at odds with feedback and meetings involving members – the Strategic Planning Team Manager advised that the data was from the 2013 survey and results from the 2015 survey reflecting the latest views would be available later in the year · members reflected upon a recent training session about Corporate Parenting which had been well received and included an overview of looked after children in Denbighshire, routes into care and the support needs of looked after children and care leavers – members felt it was important to publicise and promote positive experiences and work carried out through the Communications Teams and also discussed their own responsibilities in that regard · it was clarified that the Council had protected their funding element of school budgets but had no control over cuts to other elements of school funding provided directly by Welsh Government – the management and mitigation of school budgets by the Schools Budget Forum was also discussed.
General Debate – Councillor Joan Butterfield expressed her dissatisfaction at the lack of landscaping at the development site.
Councillor Butterfield together with other members stated that the site required to be tidied and the hoardings surrounding the site either replaced, or repaired and painted in a uniform colour.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Pete Prendergast that Councillor Barry Mellor be appointed Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Pete Prendergast that Councillor Barry Mellor be appointed Vice Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Bill Cowie to amend the Dress Code to allow tailored shorts to the knee but be a bit more prescriptive i.e. no denim or sports shorts. Upon being put to the vote it was – RESOLVED that officers be asked to amend the Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Vehicle Dress Code to allow tailored shorts to the knee but be a bit more prescriptive, i.e. no denim or sports shorts.
Whilst accepting the reasons not to pursue a restriction on taxi numbers Councillor Joan Butterfield reiterated her concerns regarding ranks and advised that she would take the matter up directly with the Highways Department together with the impact of the proposal to introduce a programme of dimming street lighting in the county.
Councillor Butterfield suggested that details be provided in relation to:- · the Council's involvement with the project.
Proposal – Councillor Stuart Davies proposed the officer recommendations to remove Conditions 18 and 19, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Proposal – Councillor Stuart Davies proposed the officer recommendations to remove Condition 45, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
(e) Councillor Joan Butterfield handed a petition to the Chair on behalf of the Rhyl taxi drivers who had obtained approximately 600 signatures in support of them being able to wear shorts. The Head of Legal, HR and Democratic Services, confirmed the petition would be passed on to the relevant department and the Head of the Department would respond within the next few weeks.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Bill Tasker that Councillor Win Mullen-James be nominated for Vice Chair for the 2015/16 municipal year.
In light of this incident Councillor Joan Butterfield felt that some sanction should be included in the Good Conduct Code for such cases. Members discussed whether a specific sanction could be accommodated within the Code bearing in mind the particular circumstances of individual cases and any subsequent sanction which may be imposed as a result of criminal proceedings. It was noted that imposing a suspension would prohibit any further action being taken at a later stage.
In view of the problems experienced by the high number of taxis operating in Rhyl Councillor Joan Butterfield asked that consideration also be given to re-regulating and restricting the number of taxis in the area and that a review of the size and location of taxi ranks be undertaken.
Accuracy – Page 10 Item No. 6 Budget 2015/16 – Councillor Joan Butterfield felt that the minute should be amended to fully reflect the budget debate and identify which councillors moved particular proposals.
Councillor Joan Butterfield (Local Member) referred to the history of the site and previous lack of action by the Applicant leading to a loss of confidence that the development would proceed. She felt there should be greater ambition for such a key development site and expressed concern regarding the retail impact on the town centre’s viability and sustainability of transport links. Consequently she proposed that the application be refused.
Proposal – Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Peter Owen that the application be refused, contrary to officer recommendation, based on the potential retail impact of the development on Rhyl Town Centre and sustainability in terms of vehicle, pedestrian and cycle links.
General Debate – Councillor Joan Butterfield (Local Member) spoke in favour of the application highlighting the regeneration ambitions for West Rhyl in terms of providing better quality living accommodation. She referred to condition 9 highlighting concerns raised by residents of both 7 & 8 Gordon Avenue and asked that she be involved in ensuring those concerns were addressed satisfactorily. The Planning Officer indicated that he was happy to incorporate the wishes of the Local Member when considering the impact on those neighbouring properties.
Proposal – Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed the officer recommendations to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Ian Armstrong.
Councillor Joan Butterfield asked that ‘Shoreline Management of Sea Defences’ be added as an item on the work progamme for future consideration.
Proposal – Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed the officer recommendations to grant the application, seconded by Councillor Rhys Hughes.
This was seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield. Additional wording to the Notice of Motion would be “that the council members acknowledge the excellent work currently taking place within Denbighshire but are also willing to look at further work”.
Councillor Joan Butterfield stated that the Labour Group would not be prepared to vote through any changes, especially those affecting staff and people in the community. The reason for the decision had been that whilst they accepted the Budget Workshops had been transparent, there had been no final information to any of the outcomes.
Councillor Butterfield also requested sight of the Equality Impact Assessments regarding the cuts.
The Lead Member for Finance and Assets, Councillor Julian Thompson-Hill, responded to Councillor Butterfield confirming that all information had previously been provided. The Equality Impact Assessments had been emailed to all members although some had been late.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Pat Jones that Councillor Barry Mellor be appointed Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Pat Jones that Councillor Barry Mellor be appointed Vice Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield suggested that the amended Penalty Point Policy and Procedure be provisionally scheduled for the committee’s September meeting.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor Brian Blakeley to be elected Chair outlining the personal qualities and experience he would bring to the position.
A breakdown of the information as to who would receive the funding within the private sector had been requested by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
Councillor Joan Butterfield expressed her gratitude to the Scrutiny Chairs and Vice-Chairs Group and the support officers for such a clear and precise report.
Election of Chair – Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Win Mullen-James, that Councillor Brian Blakeley be nominated Chair for the 2014/15 municipal year. There were no further nominations.
Councillor Joan Butterfield confirmed the Labour Group would not be submitting a nomination.
Councillor Joan Butterfield stated that Rhyl members would never have voted to close the Sun Centre but were supportive of officers’ actions after seeing the condition of the facility. Concerns had been raised for a number of years about CLL’s management and Labour Members called for an internal inquiry to establish the facts and ensure it never happened again.
Councillor Joan Butterfield supported the Rhyl Plan for approval and thanked officers for their guidance in its development.
This had been seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield.
In response to questions assurances were provided that – · flood prevention works would be considered as part of the design stage and coastal erosion had not been identified as an issue · the desired location for the aquatic centre was near the sky tower but could change depending on the view of the preferred development partner · the popularity of the skate park had been recognised and appropriate alternative sites would be considered during consultation with its users · a condition survey of the Sun Centre, Nova and North Wales Bowls Centre was being carried out which would be followed by an options appraisal for members’ consideration. [As the North Wales Bowls Centre was a community facility in good condition members were keen to for it to re-open as soon as possible.] Councillor Joan Butterfield welcomed the development of facilities in Rhyl but highlighted a number of issues – · the need for a master plan for Rhyl rather than different isolated projects · no reference having been made to the Sun Centre and the importance of the Sun Centre opening next season · concerns regarding the proposed location of the aquatic centre which would result in the loss of valuable car parking provision · reservations regarding the sustainability of similar leisure offers in Rhyl and Prestatyn , and · her view that the Rhyl and Prestatyn Champions should be members of the Coastal Facilities Project Board (CFPB).
It was noted that Communities Scrutiny Committee would be scrutinising the management of fly tipping at their next meeting · in response to an issue raised by Councillor Bobby Feeley the HHES reported upon the tendering process and award of the contract for supplying hanging baskets to Aberwheeler Nurseries · the Leader highlighted the importance of developing a link with town and area plans at an early stage within the strategy and the HHES confirmed that many of those plans already contained a number of public realm actions · with regard to the Street Sign Audit Councillor Huw Jones reported upon the work of the Bilingual Forum in order to take forward the language issue · Councillor Joan Butterfield highlighted forecourt trading as an issue in Rhyl Town Centre and asked that it be included within the Strategy.
Councillor Butterfield acknowledged the ... view the full minutes text for item 7.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Pat Jones that Councillor Barry Mellor be appointed Vice Chair. Upon being put to the vote an equal number of votes were cast for each candidate.
Whilst accepting the need to make savings, Councillor Joan Butterfield stated that the Council’s most valuable asset was its staff who were also facing financially challenging times and had been demoralised and their worth undermined. She did not agree with the proposed approach to implement the identified workforce efficiency savings and felt that more should be done to achieve acceptance collaboratively by amicable agreement. She referred to her membership of the Local Joint Consultative Committee (LJCC) citing this forum as the most appropriate place for meaningful debate on the matter.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Bob Murray that Councillor Brian Blakeley be nominated Vice Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield suggested that, in relation to this, changes made to the Rhyl Going Forward project had resulted in very little progress having been made.
The Scrutiny Coordinator agreed to resend the contact details for the Project representative to Councillor Butterfield.
In reply to concerns raised by Councillor Butterfield regarding the pay structure for staff employed in private Homes, the CD :MWB explained that the construction of the fees creates an assumption regarding the levels of pay provided. She explained that if there was evidence of failure to meet the level of skills to provide the service this would result in contract and regulatory monitoring issues which would be pursued.
Consequently, the Committee nominated Councillor Butterfield to meet with Outreach representatives on the Committee's behalf and report back to the Committee in due course.
Councillor Joan Butterfield added that funding would also be sought for projects identified in the Rhyl Going Forward Delivery Plan ... view the full minutes text for item 6.
Accuracy – Page 7 – Item No. 5 Review of Three Licences – The Chair referred to the duplication of the Driver Number which needed to be amended. [Driver No. 040298 at (3) Appendix 2 should be amended to No. 040448.] Councillor Joan Butterfield advised that her apologies for absence at the last meeting had not been recorded within the minutes.
[ Councillor Joan Butterfield asked that it be recorded that she voted against the above resolution.] At this juncture ( 10.40 a.m. ) the meeting adjourned for a refreshment break.
Councillor Joan Butterfield referred to the licensing training required by all committee members and queried the role of observers at Licensing Committee and the extent their involvement was permitted in matters being considered. The Principal Solicitor agreed to check the issue with the Monitoring Officer and report back.
Councillor Joan Butterfield highlighted particular problem areas at Brickfield Pond and Marine Lake and sought assurances that XFOR would not only be concentrating only on easy targets but on difficult problem areas. The H :P &PP reported upon the work of XFOR in tackling the issue of dog fouling confirming they had been instructed to be visible in all communities and not just to target easy areas.
Councillor Joan Butterfield suggested that the younger councillors be specifically invited to interact with that delegation and engage with the young people.
Councillor Joan Butterfield stated that members in the north of the county were of the view that the report was urgently required. The Corporate Director: Customers (CDC) responded by suggesting that the report could be received in December rather than January; and a report on Etape be deferred until January to make room on the agenda. However, this would depend on sufficient information being available to justify consideration of the day care services report in December.
Councillor Butterfield referred to the involvement of registered social landlords and queried whether their views would be taken into consideration and the possible merits of referring the issue to the Partnerships Scrutiny Committee was discussed by members, but a referral was not agreed.
The Committee agreed to appoint Councillor Dewi Owens to the Schools Monitoring Group, and to appoint Councillor Joan Butterfield to the Corporate Equalities Group, with Councillor Owens as the named substitute.
Councillor Jones had stated that Councillor Joan Butterfield had referred to a letter circulated to Councillors by Bodelwyddan Town Council in which Councillor Butterfield felt it suggested that “”some wrong doing” was being done by Denbighshire County Council.
Councillor Butterfield did not refer to “incorrect processes” as was recorded in the minutes.
Councillor Jones clarified that in response to Councillor Butterfield, she had stated she had no input into the letter and had not therefore stated that Council had done anything wrong. This was in the context of commenting on the letter.
Councillor Jones also stated if Councillor Butterfield had mentioned “incorrect processes” it would have prompted her to give an alternative response.
Members were advised that there had been a lengthy discussion on ICCs at the service challenge meeting with a number of funding models being explored · Councillor Joan Butterfield referred to the Rhyl Town Centre Regeneration Project and sought clarification regarding the project specification, timescales and costing. It was agreed that the Scrutiny Coordinator look into the matter and report back thereon. Members highlighted the importance of monitoring such schemes to ensure that they were carried out in accordance with the required specification, in an appropriate timeframe and within budget · progress made with the former North Wales Hospital , Denbigh was considered and members were advised of the latest position.
Councillor Joan Butterfield reported upon the benefits of SMART working introduced at Rhyl Town Council which was working well.
Councillor Joan Butterfield queried whether there was any flexibility in the scheme to address social deprivation and Mr.
Councillor Joan Butterfield highlighted the lack of track facilities in the county and advocated taking up the option of a running track to meet those needs. She also sought assurances that maintenance costs had been included within the budget projections. The H :CM &L advised that a running track would be considered in the future if the scheme generated enough income to cover the cost of investment.
Councillor Joan Butterfield reported that some councillors had received a letter from Bodelwyddan Town Council which suggested that incorrect processes had been followed.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Brian Blakeley that Councillor Barry Mellor be appointed Chair.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed, seconded by Councillor Brian Blakeley that Councillor Barry Mellor be appointed Vice Chair.
In view of the price competition between taxi firms and the fact that the licensing authority had no control over such promotions, and given that the majority of responses received to the consultation had opposed any increase in fares and charges, Councillor Barry Mellor proposed, seconded by Councillor Joan Butterfield that the proposals detailed in 5.2 of the report be rejected and the current fares and charges be retained. Consequently it was – RESOLVED that the proposals as detailed in 5.2 of the report be rejected and the current fares and charges not be increased.
With regard to Part 3, Table 1, 11 – the discharge of any function relating to the control of pollution or the management of air quality, Councillor Joan Butterfield advised that the Licensing Committee had not previously considered matters of that nature. The Principal Solicitor agreed to check that reference with the Deputy Monitoring Officer.
In response to a suggestion from Councillor Butterfield it was agreed that the Committee receive ... view the full minutes text for item 8.
Councillor Joan Butterfield proposed Councillor Jeanette Chamberlain-Jones be elected Chairman outlining the personal qualities and experience she would bring to the position.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Butterfield attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Butterfield's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Butterfield was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 1 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Butterfield declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Sep 2021 | Planning Committee, item 2 | Councillor Joan Butterfield declared a personal interest in agenda item 9, as she was on the Queens Market Board Councillor Pete Prendergast declared a personal interest in agenda item 10, as he was a director of Denbighshire Leisure. | |
| 8 Jul 2021 | Partnerships Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Councillor Joan Butterfield declared a personal interest in agenda item 6 as a relative worked for Care Inspectorate Wales (CIW). | |
| 20 Sep 2018 | Partnerships Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Councillor Emrys Wynne and Councillor Joan Butterfield declared personal interests in agenda item 5- Annual report of safeguarding adults in Denbighshire 1st April 2017 – 31 st March 2018. | |
| 18 Oct 2017 | Licensing Committee, item 2 | The following councillors declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 4 – Councillor Joan Butterfield declared that she sometimes used the Applicant’s taxi service (Leddon's Taxis) Councillor Alan James declared that he used the taxi service (Town & Country Taxis) of the Applicant’s supporter who was also known to him Councillor Tony Thomas declared that the Applicant was resident in his ward. | |
| 26 May 2016 | Partnerships Scrutiny Committee, item 2 | Councillor Joan Butterfield declared a personal interest in this item as she was a Member of the Community Housing Trust. | |
| 26 May 2016 | Partnerships Scrutiny Committee, item 4 | Councillor Joan Butterfield declared a personal interest in West Rhyl Housing Improvement Project. |
Where Councillor Butterfield sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conwy and Denbighshire Public Services Board Joint Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Member | Oct 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.