MINUTES
Matters arising – Page 10 – Councillor Terry Mendies referred to the minutes which stated that approval of the application would likely result in immediate enforcement issues.
Every time Denbighshire's minutes name Councillor Mendies, as the council published it.
Matters arising – Page 10 – Councillor Terry Mendies referred to the minutes which stated that approval of the application would likely result in immediate enforcement issues.
Councillor Mendies advised the Committee that enforcement officers, accompanied by representatives from Natural Resources Wales, had attended the site three days following approval of the application. He further advised that Members had received correspondence from him regarding what he considered to be an ongoing enforcement matter.
In relation to agenda item 5 – Burley Hill Garage, Erysys, Mold, Councillor Terry Mendies informed the committee, a complaint had been submitted against his conduct and predetermination. If permitted he stated he would speak on behalf of his residents before leaving the Chamber during the discussion and take no part in the debate or vote.
The Legal Officer confirmed that Cllr Mendies would be declaring a prejudicial intertest on the application. The code allowed for Members declaring a prejudicial interest in an application where public speaking is permitted to participate to the same extent as a member of the public. Having spoken on the subject, the Councillor should then withdraw from the room for the remainder of that item.
General Debate - Councillor Terry Mendies (Local Member) began by expressing disappointment that a site visit had not taken place. The Chair clarified that the decision not to undertake a site visit had been his.
Councillor Mendies confirmed that he did not support the application, noting that local residents had ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Councillor Terry Mendies was invited back into the meeting room before the meeting reconvened.
· Page 12: Councillor Terry Mendies requested that the word circulated be amended to corrected . The Monitoring Officer reiterated that accusations of falsifying reports were not acceptable under the Code of Conduct.
Councillor Mendies queried the accuracy of inspection reports referenced by the Corporate Director.
Councillor Terry Mendies nominated Councillor Brian Jones, in his supporting statement Councillor Mendies highlighted that Councillor Jones had extensive experience as a County Councillor, together with a significant background in the commercial sector.
Councillor Mendies also referred to his willingness to challenge issues and ask detailed questions when carrying out his role as an elected Member.
Prior to inviting Councillor Terry Mendies to ask a question, the Chair informed members that Councillor Elfed Williams had resigned from his position following his election to the Senedd.
The Chair then invited Councillor Terry Mendies to put forward his question.
Councillor Mendies was advised by the Chair and the Monitoring Officer to confine his remarks to the question previously submitted.
The Corporate Director for Governance and Business informed Councillor Mendies that he was entitled to ask a supplementary question.
Councillor Mendies reiterated his concerns regarding the inspection reports, stating that he believed they lacked sufficient detail and evidence, and he sought clarification on when they would be circulated.
Councillor Brian Jones nominated Councillor Terry Mendies, He outlined Councillor Mendies’ business experience, including running franchises in Australia and operating businesses across three continents.
Due to there being two nominations the Corporate Director: Governance and Business took a roll call vote of all present, there were 10 votes for Councillor Mendies, 22 votes for Councillor Feeley, and 7 abstentions.
General Debate – Councillor Terry Mendies (Local Member) advised that the application had been ongoing for nine years. He outlined the historical importance of the engine house, which formed part of a lead mine dating back to 1841. Following its closure in the 1970s, the structure had been left to deteriorate, as evidenced by photographs submitted with the application (previously circulated).
Councillor Mendies described the proposal as an ambitious project and noted that throughout the lengthy application process, the applicant had completed all studies requested by officers. He asked officers to clarify the environmental constraints associated with the application. He further stated that some of the objections were based on historical concerns from nine years ago, which had since been addressed and resolved.He confirmed that he had consulted the Community Council on two occasions, both times receiving their support for the application.
Regarding concerns about timescales and potential disruption, Councillor Mendies reported that the applicant had confirmed a Project Manager would be appointed once all approvals were in place to oversee the delivery of the development and suggested that an hours of operation condition could be attached to the permission if required.
The Chair welcomed Councillor Terry Mendies and invited him to raise a question to the Committee.
Councillor Mendies provided Members with some background information regarding Denbighshire Leisure Limited (DLL). He stated that during the workshops and discussions the previous year, his political party group had asked for regular finance updates to which he believed had not be produced. He also stated at those workshops he thought it had been agreed that the Governance and Audit Committee where to receive an update at every meeting.
Councillor Mendies thanked officers for their comments, he stressed that had not been his recollection. He thanked the Committee for the time.
Councillor Terry Mendies proposed that the applicant needed more time to demonstrate the financial viability of the application and proposed that the temporary permission at the site ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
Proposal – Councillor Jon Harland proposed the application be granted, seconded by Councillor Terry Mendies.
Matters Arising – Item 5 Outcome of Performance Scrutiny Committee’s Review of Cabinet’s decision relating to the Viability Report on Cefndy – In response to questions from Councillor Terry Mendies the Corporate Director:
Councillor Terry Mendies asked that a car parking project in Eryrys be considered for PiPIF funding, how it could be included as a pipeline project and how to apply for the grant funding. Officers confirmed the proposed selection process reiterating the tight timescales with no capacity to call for new projects at this stage. However, new projects could be added to the pipeline of capital projects which could be taken forward by the relevant Head of Service and further discussed outside of the meeting.
Councillor Terry Mendies, Chair of Performance Scrutiny Committee presented the report detailing the findings and recommendations of the Scrutiny Committee held on 6 November 2025 following consideration of the call-in of the Cabinet decision taken on 21 October 2025 relating to the Cefndy Viability Report.
Councillor Mendies provided some background leading up to the Scrutiny Committee meeting itself which had been very detailed and emotional. The report referenced the lengthy debate based on the grounds of the call-in and outcome of the scrutiny process. The Committee agreed that insufficient regard had been given at October’s Cabinet meeting to the recommendations made by Performance Scrutiny Committee following its pre-decision scrutiny of the Viability Report.
Councillor Mendies also raised some concern over the financial information presented at the meeting.
The Leader thanked Councillor Mendies for the report on the scrutiny debate and the Scrutiny Committee for their work. He accepted that the matter had been scrutinised afresh and that there had been a thorough and detailed debate.
Matters arising – Councillor Terry Mendies highlighted the absence of Councillor Raj Metri at numerous Planning Committee meetings and requested the Chair write to him to enquire if he still wanted to be a member of the Committee. The Chair stated he had spoken with the Leader regarding this and would contact him again to discuss the matter.
(a) Planning, Public Protection and Countryside Services – Councillor Terry Mendies or Councillor Gareth Sandilands (to be confirmed) (b) Finance and Audit - Councillor James Elson (c) Housing and Communities Services - Councillor Terry Mendies or Councillor Gareth Sandilands (to be confirmed) (d) Adult Social Care and Homelessness – Councillor Carol Holliday (e) Corporate Support Service: People – Councillor Gwyneth Ellis (f) Education – Councillor Ellie Chard (g) Children’s Services – Councillor Andrea Tomlin (h) Highways and Environmental Services – Councillor Bobby Feeley (i) Corporate Support Service: Performance, Digital and Assets – Councillor Martyn Hogg
Councillor Terry Mendies proposed an amendment, seconded by Councillor Karen Edwards, to remove the reference to relocation expenses form the remuneration package. Upon being put to the vote the amendment was declared LOST.
Councillor Jones’ nomination for the role was seconded by Councillor Terry Mendies. No other nominations were received and the Committee:
Matters Arising: Special Meeting of Council – 26 March 2025 Councillor Mendies referred to his suggestion made at the special meeting that it might have been prudent for the county council to borrow the funding for the proposed Denbighshire Leisure Limited (DLL) business plan, and he suggested a couple of potential financial or commercial companies such as Shawbrook and Bluestone.
Councillor Mendies stated that a response made by the Managing Director of DLL during the meeting that Bluestone was a leasing company was incorrect, and that Bluestone was indeed a commercial company.
Councillor Mendies noted that this exchange was not covered in the minutes.
Proposa l - Councillor Terry Mendies (Local Member) proposed that the application be deferred and that a site visit be organised prior to the next meeting.
Councillor Terry Mendies referred to current vacant planning enforcement officer posts and requested an answer to whether the Council was actively seeking to recruit two planning enforcement officers?
Councillor Mendies asked whether, during this period of recruitment difficulties, outstanding enforcement activities could be supported by existing planning staff?
Matters Arising – Item 3: Urgent Matters X51 Bus Service into Llandegla – Councillor Barry Mellor provided a verbal update following interruptions to the bus service into Llandegla which had been raised by Councillor Terry Mendies at the previous meeting. Whilst it had not been possible to meet with all drivers, the bus company had taken action, specifically regarding a further incident where disciplinary action had been taken, and all drivers had been directed not to bypass Llandegla under any circumstances.
The Leader thanked Councillor Mendies for raising the matter and Councillor Mellor for his intervention in helping to resolve the issue, highlighting the importance of transport routes to rural communities.
The Leader permitted a question from Councillor Terry Mendies regarding the X51 Bus Service (Wrexham to Rhyl) into Llandegla.
Councillor Mendies referred to a recent complaint involving the X51 Bus Service when the bus driver refused to follow the designated route into Llandegla due to fog.
Councillor Mendies acknowledged the hard work of Councillor Mellor in resolving previous issues and asked if he would attend a meeting with himself and the bus company on the matter and stress the importance of the service to residents.
Councillor Mendies thanked Councillor Mellor for his assistance in this regard.
Question 1 Question put forward by Councillor Terry Mendies to the Lead Member for Local Development and Planning, Councillor Alan James – “In May of this year planning breaches in the county totalled 561, that had more than doubled from 250 breaches 16 months earlier. Why is that?
Councillor Terry Mendies then asked a supplementary question as follows:
“Given that these planning breaches have more than doubled and given that some of these planning breaches date back 13 years, and given that the Head of Service is taking £120,000 of tax payers money each year, does the Lead Member think that the tax payer is getting value for money?” Councillor Alan James responded to agree to contact Councillor Mendies in due course with a response to his supplementary question.
At this point, Councillor Terry Mendies raised the issue of Planning Enforcement Officers. He stated they should be revenue raisers to assist with the financial position the council was facing. Following discussions, it was stated that it would be the decision of the Chair of Council as to whether the recommendations would be voted on block or separately.
Councillor Terry Mendies stated that the Committee should not focus on the possible concerns/ issues in the future. The application was for the change of use of a property and that should be considered on its own merits.
Councillor Terry Mendies questioned if TPO 4(2024) would have an impact on the developer’s plans for the area of land near the tree. The Principal Planning Officer stated that TPO 4(2024) would not impede the Housing Development application previously granted for the area of land.
Proposal – Councillor Huw Hilditch-Roberts proposed that the application be GRANTED in accordance with officer recommendations SECONDED by Councillor Terry Mendies.
No questions were raised by the Chair or members of the Planning Committee Proposal – Councillor Terry Mendies proposed that the application was GRANTED in accordance with officer recommendations, SECONDED by Councillor Andrea Tomlin.
Question put forward by Councillor Terry Mendies – “Why has an Enforcement Notice issued to a Property in Llandegla on 7 th September 2020 not been enforced despite the notice having its fourth Birthday 3 days ago.” The Lead Member for Local Development and Planning, Councillor Alan James, responded as follows:
Councillor Terry Mendies indicated his satisfaction with the response to his question.
General Debate – Councillor Terry Mendies (local member) fully supported the application. It’s a straightforward application which was to park three coaches in a yard in rural setting, and we should be encouraging small business enterprises.
However, Councillor Mendies proposed an amendment to the application that the hours be almost in keeping with the current times of use of the yard.
At present it was - 8.00am - 6.00pm Monday Friday; 8.00am- 1.00pm Saturdays and no activity allowed on Sundays or public holidays; Councillor Mendies also outlined he was not supporting the proposal for 24/7 access to the site.
Councillor Mendies highlighting point 1.7.2 within the report which was ‘It was noted that there are still potentially some breaches of planning control on the site which sit outside of the control of this planning application. However, members are advised that these are not a material consideration in determining this application and can be dealt with separately. Members are advised ... view the full minutes text for item 5.
The Local Member, Councillor Terry Mendies stated that this was an historical application that complied with planning regulations and added that if the dwellings were built in line with the proposed plans, he could see no objections from the local community.
Councillor Terry Mendies apologies as at the last Council meeting he made an inaccurate statement concerning the Managing Director of Denbighshire Leisure Limited (DLL), [name removed]. He stated he won an award when, in fact, he received an award on behalf of the organisation of which he is Managing Director.
Councillor Mendies recognised the use of the term “gongs” was inappropriate. He had stated that DLL had been given £2.3million by DCC, this again, was incorrect.
Councillor Mendies apologised unreservedly to [name removed] for making these statements and also wish to apologise to every member because on that day his demeanour may have seemed aggressive. That had not been his intention nor was it his intention to cause offence to any individuals. If he did so, he hoped those concerned would accept his sincere apologies.
(ii) Councillor Terry Mendies informed members that on 12 January 2024, Arriva had terminated the bus service 51 going into Llandegla village. It has now been confirmed that Arriva had reinstated a skeleton service to the village.
Councillor Mendies offered thanks to Councillor Barry Mellor and also to Sara Palmer for assisting to find a solution to the issue.
Councillor Terry Mendies informed the Committee that he thought the proposed savings were admirable, however, they would not be viable.
Councillor Mendies queried the proposed redundancies as it had been indicated during the December Cabinet meeting that redundancies would the last option and that relocation would be sought in other services across the Council for staff under threat of redundancy. He queried whether if staff were redeployed whether any savings would be achieved.
In closing his statement, Councillor Mendies added that the public consultation response was the largest the Council had experienced and yet the public’s responses were not being reflected in the decision taken. Concluding, he stated that there were larger projects which the Council could mothball to achieve more significant savings.
Environment and Economy responded to a question from Councillor Terry Mendies regarding the internal fit out of the Queen’s Market development. He explained that the construction phase was nearing completion and the intention had been to agree the nature of the final fit out with the operator of the facility. As the proposed partnership with Mikhael Hotel and Leisure Group had not been taken forward, work would be undertaken within the funding available to fit out the facility as appropriate to enable the facility to be opened.
It was agreed that further questions relating to other aspects of the Queen’s Market development be raised by Councillor Mendies outside of the meeting given that they did not relate to the Cabinet finance report currently under consideration.
Councillor Terry Mendies urged Members to refuse the application. He provided two reasons. The first being the application was retrospective.
Matters Arising – Page 12 - Councillor Terry Mendies asked if a written response had been provided to Councillor Chris Evans following his question and supplementary question asked at the meeting. If a response had not been sent, when would it be expected.
Councillor Terry Mendies (local member) stated he could not support the application; the local community were against the application. He believed the applicant was trying to circumvent planning law; they had sold their house and resided in temporary accommodation for six years. He stated that the only reason the application was being discussed at the planning committee was due to the enforcement notices at the site.
Proposal – Councillor Terry Mendies proposed the application be refused in accordance with officer recommendations, seconded by Councillor James Elson.
In response to a question from Councillor Terry Mendies, the Head of Finance and Audit confirmed that the public consultation on the proposals for the Long Term Empty and Second Homes Premium had been carried out with a report on the way forward to be submitted to Cabinet in July and Council in September.
Councillor Terry Mendies proposed Councillor Peter Scott be appointed Vice-Chair of the Planning Committee for the 2023/2024 municipal year, seconded by Councillor Karen Edwards.
Councillor Terry Mendies had been noted as not in attendance but he had attended the meeting.
Councillor Peter Scott was nominated for the role by Councillor Terry Mendies and seconded by Councillor Hugh H Evans. No other nominations were put forward. The Committee:
Members heard Councillor Terry Mendies along with Councillor Carol Holliday had indicated an interest to represent the Committee on the Highways and Environmental Service Challenge Group.
Members were in agreement for Councillor Mendies to attend Highways and Environmental Service Challenge meetings. It was noted a small number of services still required meeting arrangements to be made, these were dependent on the outcome of the SLT restructure which was imminent. An up to date list would be provided when arrangements had been made.
· Councillor Terry Mendies queried why Denbighshire Leisure Limited did not appear in the Capital Plan, and he reported on his efforts to secure more information on the role, activities and financing of Denbighshire Leisure Limited. The Monitoring Officer confirmed that a briefing on Denbighshire Leisure was being arranged for members.
Councillor Terry Mendies proposed Councillor Gareth Sandilands be appointed on the CSG, seconded by Councillor Carol Holliday.
Councillor Terry Mendies highlighted the impact of inflation on the £4m spend and the desperate need for investment in rural roads, providing examples of near impassable roads in the Alyn Valley ward, with some roads providing a single route, and therefore lifeline, for those communities. He suggested that the budget be revisited and, as a minimum, highway spend be increased by 3.8% in line with the proposed rise in Council Tax.
General debate - Councillor Terry Mendies raised concern on the boundary fence and who would be responsible for any damage caused by the tree.
General Debate – Councillor Terry Mendies (Local Member) confirmed his approval of the application but suggested if the application were to be granted an additional condition could be added that it complies with the SUD and drainage proposal.
Councillor Peter Scott was nominated for the role by Councillor Terry Mendies and seconded by Councillor Bobby Feeley. No other nominations were put forward. The Committee therefore:
Councillor Terry Mendies proposed that Councillor Peter Scott be appointed Vice-Chair of the Planning Committee for the 2022/2023 municipal year, seconded by James Elson.
General Debate – Councillor Terry Mendies (local member) was aware of Salem Chapel and thought that the proposed application would be beneficial to Eryrys by bringing an unused tired building back into use. The application would change the building into an asset for the village, which would help the local economy by having footfall to the local pub.
Proposed – Councillor Terry Mendies proposed the application be granted in accordance with officer recommendations, seconded by Merfyn Parry.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Mendies attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Mendies's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Mendies was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 5 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Mendies declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Mendies in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Mendies sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Performance Scrutiny Committee | Chair | Sep 2026 | 2 | |
| Planning Committee | Member | Oct 2026 | 2 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Conwy and Denbighshire Public Services Board Joint Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Member | Oct 2026 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.