Appointment of Substitute Members
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor S Hill had been appointed as a substitute member for Councillor H M Williams.
Every time Dover's minutes name Councillor Williams, as the council published it.
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor S Hill had been appointed as a substitute member for Councillor H M Williams.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Senior Planner advised that Tree Protection Orders (TPOs) could not be imposed as a condition. However, a condition to retain the existing planting/trees and/or require a tree survey/assessment to be carried out to establish the quality and value of the trees could be added. The TL stressed that TPOs could not be required through the planning process but the retention of the trees could.
Councillor H M Williams raised concerns regarding schools, access to GPs, sports pitches and the location of M4(3) properties. The Chairman commented that access to GPs was a matter that was outside planning’s control and school places were in KCC’s hands. The Principal Planner referred to paragraph 2.82 and advised that financial contributions would be made towards primary and secondary school expansion in Deal and Sandwich (non-selective) and Dover (selective).
In response to Councillor Williams, she confirmed that the applicant would be aware of existing access arrangements and would advise the builder accordingly. She undertook to ensure that the construction management plan was updated to address these points, as well as providing further details of how the applicant would liaise with suppliers to ensure any impacts were minimised as much as possible.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Principal Planner and TL clarified that a wastewater treatment plant would recycle foul water which would then be transferred via a manhole connection to an existing sewer. The Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method (BREEAM) accreditation system required drainage systems to meet certain standards and there were several mechanisms available to control the amount of water (e.g.
Councillor Williams raised concerns that the proposal did not meet the Parish Council’s housing needs assessment, nor was it policy compliant. The TL recognised that some elements of the housing mix were not compliant which weighed against the scheme, particularly the lack of one-bedroom units. However, these negative aspects needed to be weighed against the positive and policy-compliant elements of the proposal, and it was for Members to attach their own weight to these.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Principal Planner advised that the infiltration soakaways would be managed in the same way as the attenuation pond. KCC was content with the change to the proposed drainage system and that it would not result in flooding. Furthermore, it had suggested a condition requiring details of the scheme and how surface water would be disposed of.
In response to Councillor Williams, it was clarified that the proposed mix of affordable housing was policy compliant and comprised 2 x 3-bedroom affordable social rent dwellings, 1 x 3-bedroom first home and 1 x 3-bedroom shared ownership home.
In response to Councillor Williams who queried the provision of artificial grass pitches at Freemen’s Way, the TL acknowledged that the Freemen’s Way site was up for sale. The request had come from KCC but officers would look into an alternative scheme. In the event that the applicant made a case for the scheme not being viable with affordable housing, officers would revisit the Section 106 agreement and the potential for an off-site payment.
Councillor Williams requested that the application should return to the Committee in the event that changes were made to affordable housing provision.
Councillor H M Williams requested detail of the number of properties sold and figures to be provided in writing.
It was moved by Councillor D R Friend, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams, and
Councillor H M Williams expressed concerns about the narrow width of the road and transport assessment, pointing out that there were five developments along Station Road alone. She considered the road to be dangerous and wanted to see traffic lights installed. The Principal Planner clarified that there would be a priority/give-way system that would be part of a Section 278 agreement with KCC Highways.
In response to Councillor Williams who commented that she was against having the LCD screens, the Principal Planning Solicitor advised her that Members could let it be known that they wanted the advertisement consent application to be referred to the Committee for determination rather than being dealt with by the Head of Planning and Development, exercising her delegated authority under the Constitution. If Members wished to consider both applications as a whole, they could defer this one.
It was moved by Councillor D R Friend, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams and
Councillor H M Williams noted that the site was outside the settlement boundaries and not allocated for development in the Local Plan. Once developed, the impact on the landscape would be irreversible. The site was not a sustainable location as there had been no bus service since 2022, apart from a dial-up service, and the nearest train station was at Shepherdswell .
In response to Councillor Williams, the Team Leader (Development Management) (TL) advised that the area in brown on the aerial image was woodland which was outside the application site. The greener area was the application site, but it was believed that KCC had included the brown area (where tree works had been carried out) when making its comments about BNG. He reassured Members that officers would have a full dialogue with KCC to reconcile this point and only when the matter had been agreed would planning permission be granted.
In response to Councillor Williams who requested that mature and fast-growing trees be planted, the TL advised that the Landscape and Ecological Management Plan, together with the tree planting and retention condition, would require details of trees to be submitted, to ensure that the trees were a native species and appropriate for the landscape.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded by Councillor M Bates and
It was moved by Councillor D R Friend, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams and
It was noted that in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H M Williams had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor D G Cronk.
It was moved by Councillor J L Pout, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams and
Councillor H M Williams declared a Voluntary Announcement of Other Interests (VAOI) as she lives next to the beach huts at Kingsdown and knows users in the village.
At the meeting of full Council held on 29 January 2025, Councillor H M Williams was appointed to the membership of the Licensing Committee (replacing Councillor C F Woodgate).
Councillor H M Williams welcomed the provision of much-needed care accommodation. However, she was concerned about the routeing strategy for construction and delivery traffic and requested that vehicles be prohibited from using the Rectory Road junction with Manor Road which was effectively a blind corner. She also asked whether any of the bungalows would be built to M4(3) standard.
In response to concerns raised by Councillor Williams, the Senior Planner clarified that the rear terrace could be assessed by Building Control as part of the wider scheme of works. Furthermore, a supporting statement had been received from a structural engineer that set out the principles of work to be carried out. A retaining wall of reinforced concrete, with a sub-base of the same, would be built to support the terrace at higher ground level.
Councillor Williams raised concerns about the access which was a muddy track with no obvious owner. The proposal appeared to ignore the Kingsdown Design Code submitted to the Council the previous year and which referred to respecting surrounding buildings and maintaining open space, as well as advice given in the Homes England – Building for a Healthy Life guidance which stated that there should not be an over-reliance on tandem parking. In her view, the proposal was out of character with the area.
Councillor H M Williams raised concerns about the unsustainable location given that there was no shop or post office in Lydden and the GP surgery was apparently full. The Principal Planner advised that when allocating sites for development, the policy team had considered the facilities available in all settlements across the district. Lydden had a pub, school, GP surgery and transport connections and facilities in the wider area would also have been taken into account .
Councillor Williams asked whether there was a local need for housing and, if so, that this be prioritised. The Principal Planner advised that there were currently 105 applications for affordable housing from people expressing a preference for Lydden. She undertook to look into whether the affordable housing could be reserved for local residents.
Councillor Williams commented that she would like to see at least one of the affordable housing units built to M4(3) standards. The Chairman added that it was a new policy requirement. The Planning and Delivery Manager advised that it should be included as a condition at the outline stage as this would ensure it was then brought forward at reserved matters.
Councillor H M Williams expressed concerns about traffic congestion during the port’s busiest periods and seconded Councillor Beaney’s proposal.
In response to Councillor Williams, he clarified that if a complaint was made about the applicant using the containers to conduct business, it would be for planning enforcement to investigate and take action if appropriate.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded and
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Chairman reminded the Committee that it was not appropriate to discuss the future of the caravans as its sole remit was to consider the proposal before it and its suitability for the land. The Planning Consultant added that it was for the Committee to look at the scheme and decide whether it was acceptable or not. The retention of the caravans was a matter for enforcement and proceedings.
Councillor Williams expressed concerns about the age of the viability report which was 10 years old. During that time market conditions and the Local Plan had changed, as had the political will of the Council. Whilst she accepted there was a flood risk with the site, it concerned her that a development of 500 houses would have no affordable homes.
In response to Councillor Williams who asked whether the proposed attenuation pond would be fenced off, she advised that safety measures could be included if Members wished when further details were submitted at the reserved matters stage. In relation to education contributions, she clarified that KCC had asked only for contributions towards secondary education and not for primary. Its request would have been based on current data for the primary school and future needs and it was obviously satisfied that no primary contribution was necessary at this stage.
Councillor H M Williams commented that she found the spIit applications long and confusing and was concerned about the emergency access. In response, the Principal Planner clarified that the primary vehicle access would serve both phases of the reserved matters development and the other outline development to the south-east. The emergency access was considered acceptable by Kent County Council (KCC) Highways and would be built as part of the first phase of the development and therefore in place before this phase was occupied.
Councillor Williams voiced concerns about the sustainability of the site which lacked public transport, shops and other facilities and was served by narrow roads. The Senior Planner advised that the site was not allocated land but a windfall site. A site opposite had already been granted planning permission for 40 dwellings and would provide pedestrian access to the primary school.
Councillor Williams expressed disappointment that there was no statement from the Council’s Heritage Officer given that the proposal was in a conservation area. She did not consider a zinc roof to be appropriate for a conservation area and queried why tiles were not being used. The roof would be higher than the hedge and harmful to the amenity of two houses in Liverpool Road which looked directly onto the hedge but could not currently see the existing clubhouse.
Councillor H M Williams raised concerns about the cumulative effect of the proposals on North Road given that there were already three houses in a terrace of seven with bigger extensions and two that had first-floor terraces, built before the Article 4 Directive was introduced. One property had been allowed to build an extension and terrace in 2021 which it was now acknowledged had been in error. In contrast, South Road had fewer rear extensions and no terraces.
Councillor Williams raised concerns about the extension which looked to have doubled in width and increased in roof height. It was her view that the proposals would be harmful to the visual amenity of no. 11, creating a tunnelling effect to that property. The privacy screen would make the balcony more visible from public views and the glazing was out of character with the terrace of houses.
In respect of concerns raised by Councillor Williams about the use of weatherboarding at the rear of the terrace and her suggestion that render should be used, the Planning Officer advised that, being on the ground floor, the majority of the extension would not be seen from public views. RESOLVED : ( a) That Application No DOV/23/01211 be APPROVED subject to the following conditions:
In response to Councillor Williams who sought clarification on the balcony screening, the TL advised that the screening would be slatted and provided on the western elevation of the balcony. The Chairman questioned whether, with the 1.8-metre privacy screen, there would effectively be a 4-metre fence to the boundary with no.
Councillor H M Williams referred to landscape matters and the need for significant landscaping as mitigation for the development’s visual impact. Other matters that concerned her were the removal of a hedge, poor drainage, highways and parking. In her view the site was not a sustainable one and the adverse effects of the development outweighed any benefits.
Councillor Williams raised concerns that the location was poorly served in terms of shops, schools and GP surgeries. Public transport was all but non-existent so occupants of the new dwellings would be reliant on travelling by car.
In response to Councillor Williams, the Principal Planner advised that a condition requiring a construction management plan for each phase of the development had been imposed on the outline planning permission. The Chairman added that any problems relating to another site and the developer’s adherence to the construction management plan were a matter for Planning Enforcement. The Principal Planner suggested that the Committee’s concerns around pedestrian connectivity could be dealt with by adding specific conditions or delegated to officers to finalise improvements with the applicant prior to determination.
It was then moved by Councillor H M Williams, and duly seconded that
It was noted that in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H M Williams had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor J P Loffman.
It was moved by Councillor M J Nee, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams and
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded, and
In response to Councillor H M Williams who queried a statement made by the speaker that the listed wall was going to be knocked down to accommodate building materials, he stressed that it was not part of the proposals and, in any case, would require listed building consent which was likely to be refused.
Councillor Williams queried whether the period property next door was a non-designated heritage asset.
In response to Councillor Williams, the TLDM advised that the proposed landscaping condition would seek to ensure there was suitable planting around the vehicular access. He confirmed that the obscure glazing required by condition would be a permanent feature. A late response had been received from Ringwould -with-Kingsdown Parish Council which strongly objected to the application, viewing the site as being too small and the proposal as an overdevelopment.
(Councillor H M Williams) · Southern Water – To receive an update on wastewater management and agricultural runoff. It was stated that the Environment Agency would need to be involved.
In response to Councillor H M Williams who queried how the Council could ensure that the management plan was implemented and adhered to in the future, the Planning Officer advised that the wording of the condition would secure that. She clarified that the requirement to comply with the plan would exist for the duration of the building’s use as an HMO.
Councillor Williams also expressed concerns about the standard of the proposed accommodation, particularly the amount of natural light in the dining area. In this respect, the Chairman reported that he had checked, and the proposals met all the relevant standards.
Councillor Williams raised concerns about overlooking and proposed that part of the L-shaped, floor-to-ceiling window in the corner should be obscure glazed in order to prevent this. She also requested more tree planting. The Chairman advised that the design originally submitted had been deemed unacceptable due to overlooking.
He referred to concerns raised by Councillor Williams and agreed that the lower part of the floor-to-ceiling window that wrapped around the corner should be obscure glazed. Whilst he noted that there were conditions for obscure glazing to the first-floor dressing-room window, he asked whether a barrier could be installed on the balcony to alleviate concerns around overlooking. The Senior Planner clarified that condition 4 required the first-floor dressing-room window to be obscure glazed, and condition 5 required a privacy screen to be fitted to the southern balcony prior to first use, although no details of this had been provided.
In response to Councillor Williams, the Senior Planner advised that the details of reptile translocation, including place and timing, would be included in the information submitted by the applicant, as required by the Section 106 agreement. Provisionally, a site in Staple had been identified. The issue of drainage was addressed in paragraphs 2.35 and 2.36 of the report and had been the subject of consultation with KCC and the River Stour Internal Drainage Board.
Councillor H M Williams agreed that the loss of open space, protected trees and biodiversity was a concern. Given that the Committee had no control over how the money made from the development would be spent, the school’s finances were irrelevant in the consideration of the application.
It was noted that in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor J P Loffman had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor H M Williams.
“That it be recommended to Council that ‘climate change’ be included in the list of functions of the Strategic Director (Place & Environment), and that the proposed changes to Article 12 and the Scheme of Officer Delegations be approved and be incorporated into the Council’s Constitution version 25a.” It was moved by Councillor S H Beer, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams, and
It was proposed by Councillor H M Williams that the addition of ‘natural environment’ should be added to the list of functions responsible to the Strategic Director (Place & Environment).
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Planning Consultant advised that the radii of the access would be widened to enable vehicles to enter and exit the site more easily and to turn better within the site. Whilst objections had been raised by local residents about visibility and the speed of vehicles entering and leaving the site, KCC Highways had raised no technical objections to the proposed access works.
Councillor Williams welcomed the provision of affordable housing and requested that it be offered to local people first. The Principal Planner advised that a condition could be imposed to restrict the height of buildings to one storey if that was what Members wanted. The idea of a local lettings plan had been discussed with the Strategic Housing Manager and the applicant who had both indicated their support in principle.
In response to a query from Councillor Williams, the Chairman clarified that any damage caused to walls or property by construction vehicles would be a civil matter between the builder and homeowner and was not relevant to the consideration of the application.
In response to Councillor Williams who asked that solar panels be installed, the Chairman reminded her that they were covered by Building Regulations and could not be conditioned under current planning policies.
She advised Councillor H M Williams that imposing a condition for hours of construction was not appropriate for a residential development of this size. If construction led to reports of noise nuisance or disturbance, it would be investigated under environmental health legislation and dealt with by the Council’s Environmental Health team.
In response to Councillor Williams, the Principal Planner explained that KCC had requested financial contributions towards the extension of primary schools in Wingham and Ash. At secondary level, the contributions would be allocated to non-selective schools in Deal and Sandwich and selective schools in Dover.
Councillor Williams voiced concerns about the development which was not in a sustainable location, there being no facilities and limited bus services serving East Langdon and narrow roads without footpaths. She also expressed concerns about the capacity of the local school which was nearly full and unlikely to be able to take children from this development. This meant that parents would be forced to drive children to school.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded by Councillor M J Nee and
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H M Williams was appointed substitute for Councillor P M Brivio.
Councillor H M Williams asked for a list of permanent and short-term vacancies. · To enquire if there was any potential for income generation from improved recycling. Members were advised that the inter-authority agreement with Kent County Council did allow the Council to benefit if recycling levels went up.
· Councillor H M Williams requested a definition for major and minor planning applications.
Councillor H M Williams supported this view and queried sewerage arrangements.
In response to Councillor Williams who mentioned the attendance of tankers on a regular basis to pump out sewage, the Senior Planner emphasised that SW had not raised any objections or concerns about the application. Imposing a condition could therefore be viewed as unreasonable.
Councillor H M Williams introduced the report on the Corporate Governance Local Code Review.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded by Councillor S H Beer, and
Councillor H M Williams introduced the report on the Revision to Contract Standing Orders.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Team Leader Development Management (TLDM) reassured Members that when details of landscaping were submitted, Officers would ensure that a suitable scheme for boundary treatment and landscaping was proposed.
In response to Councillor Williams, the Senior Planner advised that a noise impact assessment had been carried out and a condition was included to secure the recommended mitigation measures. The Chairman commented that the loss of affordable housing was regrettable but linked to policies in the new Local Plan which now carried significant weight.
In response to Councillor Williams, he advised that it would normally be expected that condition 5, which dealt with biodiversity mitigation, would include restrictions on tree cutting during nesting season. That said, it could be raised informally with the applicant. He agreed that the condition on electric vehicle charging facilities should be removed as such provision came under Building Regulations.
Councillor H M Williams declared an Other Significant Interest (OSI) in the Garden Waste Containerisation Project as a subscriber to the scheme and advised that she would withdraw from the meeting for the consideration of this item of business.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded by Councillor C A Vinson and
In response to Councillor H M Williams, she clarified that the type of window included under condition 3 would be covered by Building Regulations.
In response to Councillor Williams who raised concerns about highway safety, she advised that Kent County Council (KCC) Highways had declined to comment on the application as the scale of development was below its threshold for consultation. However, she stressed that the stables would remain in private use and consequently there should be no increase in traffic to the site. The Chairman expressed frustration that KCC Highways’ consideration of highway safety was predicated on an index that measured the number of accidents/fatalities on a road over a given period rather than using the knowledge of local residents .
Councillor Williams expressed concerns about access into and out of the site as it was only 2.8 metres wide, meaning that longer vehicles had to swing round and mount the opposite pavement. She also raised concerns about cars parking opposite the access, and requested that a construction management plan be required. The Principal Planner reminded Members that it was an existing vehicle access serving a number of garages and conditioning a construction management plan could be considered unreasonable.
In response to Councillor Williams, she advised that it was commonplace to submit an illustrative plan at outline stage indicating how dwellings could be accommodated on a site. A parameter plan had also been submitted showing the zones allocated as open space and those allocated as residential.
Councillor Williams commented that the amount of green space provided was very small and asked that it be increased. In addition, she asked whether steps could be taken to get the three landowners to cooperate with each other. The TLDM responded that the parameter plan indicated that there would be no less than 1.2 hectares of open space which the Council’s Planning Policy team had considered acceptable.
Councillor Williams pointed out that, aside from highways, other infrastructure such as GP surgeries and additional school places were badly needed to support these new developments. The Chairman reminded Members that contributions towards infrastructure would be secured via a Section 106 agreement, a normal part of the planning process. Monies secured via these agreements were based on requests made by other bodies, such as KCC, and how they were spent was outside the Council’s control.
It was moved by Councillor C A Vinson, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams and
Councillor H M Williams read out a letter from the Chair of the Dover District Disability Association on the matter.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded by Councillor S B Blair and
In response to concerns raised by Councillor H M Williams about privacy, he cautioned against conditioning a glass panel to block off the end of the balcony as this would significantly reduce the amount of space available. He suggested that a privacy screen, of about 1.6 to 1.8 metres in height, would be as effective but less intrusive. He added that the balcony would be slightly deeper than others in the terrace which were closer to 1.3 to 1.4 metres.
Addressing concerns raised by Councillor Williams about the untidiness of the site, she stressed that this was not a material consideration and, in any case, there was a limit on how far-reaching a management plan should be, not least with regards to practical enforcement.
Councillor Williams questioned why the application was considered sustainable when the previous application had been refused on the grounds of its sustainability. The TLDM clarified that West Hougham was identified in the Core Strategy and the emerging Local Plan as a settlement with sufficient facilities and services to support further development. Along with other development planned in the village, the proposal would help to support these facilities and services.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded, and
It was moved by Councillor D R Friend, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams and
In accordance with Council Procedure Rule 13, Councillor H M Williams moved the following Motion:
Councillor H M Williams referred to comments made by Nonington Parish Council and the withdrawal of bus services since the site’s allocation. The TLDM responded that the principle of development on the site had already been established. He acknowledged that the transport situation had changed.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, he advised that a landscaping plan had been submitted which indicated that there would be additional planting throughout the site, including a significant number of trees.
(1) Councillor H M Williams asked the Portfolio Holder for Planning and Environment, Councillor N S Kenton:
“Cllr Williams will ask Cllr Kenton Portfolio Holder for Planning and Environment about the housebuilding targets for the Dover area as stated in the new local plan, recently submitted to the government. However since then, Rishi Sunak announced on 5 December that the compulsory targets will become advisory. Councils will be allowed to build fewer homes if they can show that hitting the original target would significantly change the character of an area.
Councillor H M Williams spoke against the proposal, stating that there had been several developments at Mill Hill without an increase in infrastructure such as school places, GP surgeries, etc. It was a cramped development, on a site that had not been allocated in the Local Plan, and there would be no developer contributions. Since the Council had reached its housing targets, she argued that the houses were not needed.
Councillor Williams agreed, stating that the house was not far from the conservation area and the high wall would make it look like a gated community which was out of keeping with the character of the area. Whilst the works to the house would be an improvement, the proposed wall was too high and should be reduced to one metre.
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor P M Brivio had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor H M Williams.
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H M Williams had been appointed as a substitute member for Councillor E A Biggs.
Councillor H M Williams challenged the purpose of a conservation area if it was considered acceptable to knock down part of a building that had been there since at least 1841. This particular cottage had been a feature of the area for nearly two centuries and had been built before the cottages in North and South Roads. She referred to the draft Regulation 19 Local Plan and policies that sought to ensure that alterations to buildings in conservation areas respected the historic character and appearance of the area.
Councillor Williams added that it was not about trying to match Bluebell Cottage to Violet Cottage which was not in its original form in any case. Third parties were trying to conserve a building which was in its original shape and design.
(1) Councillor H M Williams asked the Portfolio Holder for Transport, Licensing and Regulatory Services, Councillor M Bates:
(2) Councillor H M Williams gave notice under Rule 13 of the Council Procedure Rules of her intention to move the following motion:
In response to points raised by Councillor H M Williams, an apology was made for the return of acronyms to the report.
(3) Councillor H M Williams asked the Portfolio Holder for Social Housing, Port Health, Skills and Education, Councillor D ... view the full minutes text for item 29.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Head of Assets and Building Control advised that there were around 50 or 60 assets that were owned by the Council but controlled or outsourced to third parties. He undertook to compile a list of these. In respect of the reporting format, the following was agreed:
In response to Councillor Williams, the Head of Assets and Building Control advised that £580,000 had been set aside for this initiative.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded by Councillor D R Friend and
In response to comments made by Councillor H M Williams about progress made in insulating homes, he requested that the Head of Property Assets attend the next meeting to give an update on housing improvements, Energy Performance Certificates and the Council’s decarbonisation fund bid, etc. The PCCSO advised that timescales and guidance on the Social Housing Decarbonisation Fund had yet to be issued. The Council was keen to get involved and had been in discussions with Folkestone & Hythe District Council which had submitted a successful bid.
It was moved by Councillor D P Murphy, seconded by Councillor H M Williams, and
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H M Williams had been appointed as a substitute member for Councillor E A Biggs.
It was noted that in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor K Mills had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor H M Williams.
It was moved by Councillor P M Brivio, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams and
It was noted that in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor K Mills had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor H M Williams.
It was moved by Councillor K Mills, duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams, and
Included in those representations were objections from Councillor D P Murphy and Councillor H M Williams. The Notice of Hearing ... view the full minutes text for item 13.
In response to a suggestion made by Councillor H M Williams, the Planning Officer confirmed that a construction management plan could be required by condition.
Councillor Williams remarked that landscaping plans had not yet been submitted for phase two of the development, and requested that Officers take the opportunity to specify that two trees per dwelling would be required. The Principal Planner clarified that there was an outstanding landscaping condition. Whilst it would not be reasonable to add a new condition, Members could add an informative in relation to the outstanding condition as it had yet to be discharged.
Councillor Williams disagreed, stating that approval could set a precedent for demolishing agricultural buildings and replacing them with unsympathetic dwellings.
Councillor H M Williams queried whether a permeable surface could be used for the driveway, and whether trees could be planted along the boundary of the driveway and the back of the houses.
Councillor Williams commented that there was a number of housing developments under way in Deal, Sholden and Great Mongeham Deal was short of the necessary infrastructure to support these developments and, in her opinion, the proposed scheme was not needed, particularly as it would lead to the loss of attractive green space and ‘suburbanise’ the area further. Whilst the green space was privately owned, it was used by local children. She also referred to the noise generated by nearby commercial and industrial units/workshops.
(2) Councillor H M Williams asked the Leader of the Council, Councillor T J Bartlett:
Councillor H M Williams did not ask a supplementary question.
Councillor Williams requested that signage to public conveniences be installed within the site. She also raised concerns about parking, particularly the pressure that would be caused by the facility on parking for patients of the nearby GP surgery. The Planning Officer advised that the site was no more than 60 metres in length and had not been a functional part of Walmer Green for some time.
Councillor Williams raised concerns that the Committee was expected to consider a complex application along with four others at the same meeting. She stressed that a separate meeting on the Betteshanger application would have been preferable.
In response to a query from Councillor Williams, she undertook to establish what long-term improvements the applicant was intending to fund at Betteshanger Country Park.
Motion 1 In accordance with Council Procedure Rule 13, Councillor H M Williams moved the Motion of which she had given notice as followed:
In respect of a suggestion by Councillor H M Williams that the parking area should be a permeable surface, the Principal Planner advised that it was the intention that some of the surface should be permeable. However, it was a KCC Highways’ requirement that some of the access and parking area be a bound surface. Nevertheless, the condition could be amended to reflect Members’ wishes on this point.
It was noted that in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor E A Biggs had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor H M Williams.
Councillor H M Williams advised that she had sent an e-mail to residents in relation to Agenda Item 8 (Application No DOV/20/01125 – Site at Cross Road, Deal). However, she confirmed that she had not predetermined the application and was approaching it with an open mind.
Councillor H M Williams stated that the dwelling was interesting but in the wrong place. The proposal was ‘nibbling away’ at the edges of the AONB and could set a precedent.
In response to Councillor Williams, she advised that no details of the driveway had been submitted, but conditions could require that it should be a permeable bound surface. She went on to clarify that applications for development along the southern side of Bewsbury Crescent had been refused and dismissed at appeal, mostly because of disturbance from driveways in close proximity to habitable rooms and harm caused to the prevailing pattern of development and the street scene.
Councillor Williams questioned why updated landscaping and equine reports had not been sought.
Councillor H M Williams commented that she understood that the applicant had been advised that the highway boundary would need to be established with KCC’s highway definition team. However, this had not been done. She argued that Members were required to assess the application on the basis of the details provided, and should not be distracted by technical matters that were outside their realm of expertise.
In response to a query from Councillor Williams, the Planning Solicitor advised that a decision which went against the advice of a statutory consultee, which was regarded as an expert and independent of the Council and the applicant, would be more open to challenge. Given that the Planning Officer had come to a reasoned recommendation on the application, it was for the Committee to explain why it disagreed with this recommendation.
In response to a query from Councillor Williams, the Planning Officer advised that the private road which gave access to the rear of the site was owned by Network Rail with whom the applicant would need to discuss access arrangements. In clarification, she advised that there was currently one parking space for each flat in Delfbridge Manor. The scheme proposed one space for each house, as well as three visitor spaces and a disabled parking space at the rear.
Councillor H M Williams commented that the proposed dwellings jarred with the surrounding historic terraces and looked out of proportion in the wider area. Whilst the design was acceptable, it was not right for this site. She also had concerns about the dangerous access and the high levels of traffic in the area.
In response to Councillor Williams who raised concerns about flooding, the Senior Planner advised that the existing flood defences had been built in recent times. The people who used the park were owner/occupiers who had permanent places of residence elsewhere. She confirmed that the relevant authorities would be consulted on the flood management plan to ensure that it was robust.
(2) Councillor H M Williams asked the Portfolio Holder for Environment, Waste, and Planning, Councillor N S Kenton:
In accordance with Council Procedure Rule 12.5, Councillor H M Williams exercised her right to ask a supplementary question.
The Motion was duly seconded by Councillor H M Williams.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams, duly seconded by Councillor S H Beer, that a working party be set up to develop a Food Poverty Action Plan to be reported back to the committee by May 2021.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Planning Officer agreed that top-opening windows would be preferable to sash windows in terms of reducing overlooking.
Councillor H M Williams raised concerns that there was no Council policy on HMOs, particularly as she was aware that there were existing HMOs in the same road and another was planned. It was also an issue of concern for Dover Town Council.
Councillor Williams raised concerns about the sustainability of the site in relation to traffic and flooding. The Principal Planner reminded Members that the NPPF set out three strands to sustainability – economic, social and environmental. Economically, the development would provide jobs and additional housing.
Councillor Biggs supported the proposal which would see the replacement of a redundant building, and Councillor Williams welcomed the good design. The Planning Officer confirmed that a pre-commencement condition for a construction management plan would ensure that all matters such as construction access would be addressed.
Councillor Williams raised serious concerns about the impact the development would have on existing traffic and parking problems. She queried whether there was an alternative access route to the site.
In response to concerns raised by Councillor Williams, the Principal Planner stressed that the applicant had attempted to balance the effect on properties in The Downs against the need to retain as much of the recreation ground as possible. The building had been reduced in height where it was close to those properties. Whilst the proposed building would have an impact on the properties, it would not cause a loss of light or create a sense of enclosure, and it was considered that the applicant had minimised its impact to an acceptable degree.
Councillor H M Williams questioned the sustainability of the location which was some distance from local centres of employment, with no access to trains or a secondary school. She also expressed concerns that the site had been excluded from the Ash Neighbourhood Development Plan (NDP). Her understanding was that the NDP was designed to give communities the opportunity to shape development in their areas.
Councillor Williams questioned the viability figures and whether the developer’s intention was to sell the land on. Councillor J P J Burman agreed that the proposal was out-of-keeping with the area and an over-development of the site. With no affordable housing and insufficient parking, he could not support the scheme.
Councillor H M Williams raised concerns about the siting of the crossing which was close to three junctions and bus-stops. Cars frequently sped round Castle Deal Road and there had been at least one crash and a pedestrian fatality the previous year. She proposed that a site visit should be held.
It was moved by Councillor H M Williams and duly seconded that Application No DOV/19/00487 be DEFERRED for a site visit in order for Members to receive clarification of the highway safety aspects of the proposal from KCC Highways.
In response to a concern raised by Councillor H M Williams in relation to the eaves of the dwelling extending over the adjoining land not owned by the applicant, the Planning Officer advised that the overhang was minimal and would be considered de minimus (or insignificant) in planning terms. The Chairman reminded Members that land ownership issues were a civil matter and outside the remit of the Committee. Members were required to consider the scheme before them, and suggestions to move the dwelling further away from the boundary could not be considered at this stage.
Councillor Williams concurred with the concerns raised about the equine consultant’s report. In relation to highways, she felt that local views had been ignored and overruled. Reports from residents and the local town and parish councils were that the local road network was already full and would not be able to cope with the proposed development.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Principal Planner clarified that the Aylesham community development post was funded by Section 106 monies rather than the Council due to the scale of the development, and in recognition that new residents needed support with integrating into the existing community. Councillor J P J Burman raised concerns about the transparency and relative inaccessibility of the bidding process for development contributions, particularly for smaller community groups.
It was noted that in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H M Williams had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor K Mills.
Councillor H M Williams commented that the proposal was an over-development of a small plot.
Councillor Williams welcomed the proposed development, particularly the good level of affordable housing provision. She noted that if it wished to serve alcohol, the clubhouse would need to apply for a licence which would set its hours of opening. In order to allay residents’ concerns, she suggested that a condition should be added to allow local residents to be involved in the group tasked with managing the operation of the clubhouse.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the PTDP clarified that 58 two-way traffic movements were predicted in peak hours, with half travelling via Cross Road and others via St Richard’s Road where some traffic was likely to split. The actual impact of these movements would diminish quickly as vehicles dispersed through the road network. He was of the view that there would not be the level of pedestrian flow to justify installing an additional pedestrian crossing in St Richard’s Road to accommodate those walking from Cross Road to the shops and facilities in Mill Hill.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, it was confirmed that racing days were limited to 52 days per year and could not be increased without applying for a variation to conditions. The additional days of activity sought were all of average noise levels that were below or equal to average background noise levels. In addition, there would be 49 silent days when there would be no activity on the site.
Councillor H M Williams raised concerns about the pressure already placed on local infrastructure by recent developments in Walmer and Mill Hill.
Councillor H M Williams suggested that it would be helpful if the operator and the Council wrote to local residents to explain the service they were providing and provide a list of contacts in the event of problems. The Planning Consultant clarified that this would not meet the criteria for a condition but could be included in the management plan, along with details of meetings.
Councillor H M Williams expressed concerns about the distance between the two dwellings. She was of the opinion that the proposal was too large a dwelling on a cramped site and would have an overbearing effect on no. 18. She proposed that the application should be refused.
It was proposed by Councillor H M Williams and duly seconded that Application No DOV/19/00455 be REFUSED on the grounds that the proposed dwelling would have a dominating and overbearing effect on no. 18 Malvern Meadow and a harmful impact on the street scene.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, it was reported that the arrears on income due on the Council’s properties had reduced to 2.38% in September. It was agreed that the report be noted.
It was noted that, in accordance with Council Procedure Rule 4, Councillor H Williams had been appointed as substitute member for Councillor J P Haste.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, the Principal Planner confirmed that the developer would be making a financial contribution towards the Market Place surgery in Sandwich. Whilst it was accepted that the most direct route to the village centre was along a lane with no footpaths or street-lighting, there were other routes into Eastry that did have footpaths and lighting. Pedestrian access to the nearest bus-stops on Gore Lane could be achieved.
Councillor H M Williams agreed, adding that the proposed block of flats did not reflect the character of the area, as required by the NPPF, which comprised large family houses. Moreover, it was incorrect to describe the location as sustainable when it was poorly served by buses and the cycle path was unlit at night. Whilst the proposed design was good for an urban setting, in her view it was not appropriate for a seaside location.
In response to Councillor Williams, the Principal Planner clarified that KCC had only requested a financial contribution for Sir Roger Manwood’s and not for Sandwich Technical College.
In response to Councillor H M Williams, it was clarified that homeless applications were assessed to establish whether the applicant was already homeless or would become so in the near future . If living in a property, a typical scenario was that applicants had been served a section 21 notice by the landlord who wished to sell the property. Their circumstances, such as children or a medical condition, would then determine whether they were given temporary accommodation.
Councillor H M Williams advised that she had submitted comments in relation to Agenda Item 8 (Application No DOV/19/00259 – Kingsdown & Ringwould Primary School, Glen Road, Kingsdown ). However, she confirmed that she had not predetermined the application and was approaching it with an open mind.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Williams attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor Williams's meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor Williams was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
No meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Williams declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Mar 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 114 | Councillor H M Williams declared a Voluntary Announcement of Other Interests (VAOI) as she lives next to the beach huts at Kingsdown and knows users in the village. | |
| 11 Sep 2023 | Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 31 | Councillor H M Williams declared an Other Significant Interest (OSI) in the Garden Waste Containerisation Project as a subscriber to the scheme and advised that she would withdraw from the meeting for the consideration of this item of business. |
Where Councillor Williams sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Climate Change Project Advisory Group | Committee Member | Jun 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.