Moved9 Sep 2026Licensing Committee
Review of licensing activity for Quarter 1 of 2026-27 financial year
It was moved by Councillor Andrews and seconded by Councillor Hill that the recommendations, as detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Moved9 Jun 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Andrews proposed, and Councillor Cox seconded a motion that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee work programme be agreed.
Named11 Mar 2026Development Management Committee
3/25/0763/FUL - Change of use of land from blocked paved pedestrian area to provide 2 police vehicle car parking spaces, marked with studs and a sign (by way of Hertfordshire County Council Traffic Regulation Order) at Block Paved Area of Tudor Square, Ware, Hertfordshire, SG12 9XF
Councillor Watson proposed and Councillor Thomas seconded, a motion that Councillor Andrews be permitted to briefly address the committee to add some context to the consideration of the application and the historic use of Tudor Square and the wider Ware town centre by the police and other vehicles.
Named11 Mar 2026Development Management Committee
3/25/0763/FUL - Change of use of land from blocked paved pedestrian area to provide 2 police vehicle car parking spaces, marked with studs and a sign (by way of Hertfordshire County Council Traffic Regulation Order) at Block Paved Area of Tudor Square, Ware, Hertfordshire, SG12 9XF
RESOLVED – that Councillor David Andrews be permitted to briefly address the committee to add some context to the consideration of the application and the historic use of Tudor Square and the wider Ware town centre by the police and other vehicles.
Moved10 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA) Policy Review
Councillor Andrews proposed and Councillor Williams seconded, a motion that the report be received and any observations from Members be forwarded to the Executive by the Director of Legal, Policy and Governance.
Moved10 Mar 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Andrews proposed, and Councillor Holt seconded a motion that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee work programme, as amended, be agreed. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Said11 Feb 2026Development Management Committee
3/24/0284/OUT - Outline planning permission for the erection of up to 36 dwellings with all matters reserved except for access at Land West of High Road, High Cross, Hertfordshire
Councillor Andrews addressed the committee as the local ward Member. He was asked questions by the Development Management Committee.
Named10 Jun 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Holt was substituting for Councillor Andrews.
Said14 Jan 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Andrews welcomed the helpful suggestion of short-timed workshop to discuss the work programme.
Said9 Jul 2024Executive
Ward Freman Community Pool Group CIO match funding support for Community Ownership Fund bid
Councillor Andrews said he was pleased to see this come forward. He said £200,000 was a lot of money to invest in an old facility. He asked if the Executive had investigated building a new facility.
Moved1 Jul 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Andrews proposed and Councillor Watson seconded a motion that the 2024/25 Overview and Scrutiny Committee work programme in Appendix 1, be agreed.
Named15 May 2024Council
Political Balance and Committee Membership of the Council 2024/25
Councillor Deering thanked the outgoing Chairmen of Committees for their work and thanked Councillor Andrews for chairing the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and setting the committee off in a good direction.
Said15 May 2024Council
Annual Scrutiny Report 2023/24
Councillor Andrews, previous Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee, introduced the report. He said that it had been an honour serving as the Chair of the committee and thanked committee members for their support and understanding for getting the committee underway with new Members.
Said15 May 2024Council
Annual Scrutiny Report 2023/24
Councillor Andrews acknowledged the support of the Scrutiny Officer.
Moved15 May 2024Council
Annual Scrutiny Report 2023/24
Councillor Andrews proposed that the recommendation in the report be supported.
Named15 May 2024Council
Annual Scrutiny Report 2023/24
He thanked Councillor Andrews for his work as Chair and looked forward to working with the new incoming Chair.
Asked15 May 2024Council
Reports by Members appointed to Outside Bodies for the civic year 2023 - 24
Councillor Andrews asked for assurance that the individuals on the outside bodies would not be changed.
Said15 May 2024Council
Night Flights from Stansted Airport
Councillor Andrews said he agreed with the point about reducing domestic rail fares.
Said5 Mar 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
UK Shared Prosperity Fund Update
Councillor Andrews welcomed the idea of supporting town and village centres. He mentioned the importance of keeping track of business support for Hertfordshire businesses in the villages that employed fewer than 20 people.
Named16 Jan 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Draft - Thriving Together 2024 - 2027 - a new Health and Wellbeing Plan for East Herts
In reply to a question from Councillor Andrews ... view the full minutes text for item 286.
Said30 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Minutes - 7 November 2023
Councillor Andrews said that the following should be deleted from the 3 rd paragraph of minute 207:
Said30 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Minutes - 7 November 2023
‘The Chairman assured Members that he was in discussion with the Leader regularly in terms of the Forward Plan and its impact on the Work Programme of Overview and Scrutiny Committee ’ Councillor Andrews suggested that there should be an amendment to delete paragraph 8 of Minute 209 (Overview and Scrutiny Committee – Draft Work Programme). He suggested that the paragraph should be replaced as follows:
Seconded20 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor E Buckmaster and seconded by Councillor Andrews that Councillor Boylan be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2023/24 civic year.
Named20 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Waste Shared Service: Client Team and Corporate Support service arrangements
In response to a comment from the Chairman, Councillor Andrews, the Shared Waste Services Manager detailed the role and set up of the client services team. She talked about the existing service differences and the difficulties this posed in terms of procuring bins and catering for residents who had additional needs. Members were advised of the minor differences in respect of how the customer service teams processed assisted collections.
Named20 Jun 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Council Tax Support 2024/25
The Head of the Revenues and Benefits Shared Service confirmed to Councillor Andrews that this report had traditionally come before Overview and Scrutiny for Members’ views before being submitted to the Executive, and the Executive were due to meet on 11 July 2023. The government requirement was that this matter was then determined by Council each year.
Moved17 May 2023Council
Consideration of the results of the Hackney Carriage Unmet Demand Survey
Councillor Andrews proposed that the recommendations in the report be supported.
Named17 May 2023Council
Consideration of the results of the Hackney Carriage Unmet Demand Survey
Councillor Wilson thanked Councillor Andrews for his excellent leadership of the Licensing Committee and said he enjoyed working with him. He said that there was a nationwide shortage of taxi drivers and it was a real problem in Bishop’s Stortford with not enough taxis available to service the train station. He said that taxis were an important part of public transport and served vulnerable people.
Named17 May 2023Council
Consideration of the results of the Hackney Carriage Unmet Demand Survey
The Chairman also thanked Councillor Andrews for his service on the Licensing Committee Councillor Crystall also thanked Councillor Andrews, Councillor Deering and Councillor Wyllie for their time as Chairmen of Development Management Committee and the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. He said it was hard to appreciate how difficult these roles were unless Members sat on the committee.
Seconded2 Nov 2022Development Management Committee
Minutes - 10 August 2022
Councillor Crystall proposed and Councillor Andrews seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 10 August 2022 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman.
Moved26 Oct 2022Licensing Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chairman 2022/23
It was moved by Councillor Andrews and seconded by Councillor Page that Councillor Bolton be appointed as Vice-Chairman of the Committee for 2022/2023. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named20 Sep 2022Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was moved by Councillor Symonds and seconded by Councillor Wilson, that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named20 Sep 2022Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Moved8 Aug 2022Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was moved by Councillor Andrews and seconded by Councillor Redfern, that Councillor Jones be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Seconded8 Aug 2022Licensing Sub-Committee
Minutes - 29 June and 8 July 2022
It was moved by Councillor Redfern and seconded by Councillor Andrews that the Minutes of the meeting held on 29 June and 8 July 2022 be confirmed as correct records and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Said8 Aug 2022Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for a new premises licence for Anthropos Festival at Hixham Hall, Hixham Lane, Furneux Pelham, Herts SG9 0LR (22/0801/PL)
Councillor Andrews expressed his disappointment that the Parish Council objector had not attended the hearing to speak to their objection.
Asked15 Jun 2022Development Management Committee
3/21/1925/FUL - Removal of outbuildings and the permanent siting of a caravan to be occupied by an equestrian worker, and associated works at The Old Turkey Farm, Brookbridge Lane, Datchworth, Hertfordshire
Councillor Andrews asked if permitted development rights should be removed or restricted in case the business did not remain in the same ownership or control.
Named9 May 2022Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was moved by Councillor Bolton and seconded by Councillor Page, that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named9 May 2022Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named22 Feb 2022Development Management Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Bull was substituting for Councillor Andrews, Councillor Devonshire was substituting for Councillor R Buckmaster and Councillor Huggins was substituting for Councillor Fernando.
Said20 Oct 2021Council
Council Tax Long Term Empty Premium
Councillor Andrews said he was concerned about the dispensation on the premium for new owners and hoped that this would not encourage sales of convenience.
Named15 Oct 2021Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was moved by Councillor Hall and seconded by Councillor Wilson, that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named15 Oct 2021Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named7 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Andrews was substituting for Councillor Devonshire.
Said7 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee – Draft Work Programme
Councillor Andrews suggested that waste and street cleansing be included as a topic for scrutiny. He referred to the steady increase in concerns expressed to him in respect of street cleansing by Town and Parish Councils and also by residents. He said that street cleansing was the main cause for concern and he referred to overflowing litter bins as well as the clearing and cleansing of public spaces and the clearing of detritus and litter from footways.
Seconded7 Sep 2021Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee – Draft Work Programme
It was moved by Councillor Snowdon, and seconded by Councillor Andrews, that the draft consolidated Work Programme be approved, subject to the addition of street cleansing and contract management to a future meeting . After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
Named28 Jul 2021Council
Adoption of Thundridge Neighbourhood Plan following Referendum
The Chairman read out a statement from Councillor Andrews, the local ward member, who had given his apologies for the meeting:
Said28 Jul 2021Council
Adoption of Thundridge Neighbourhood Plan following Referendum
Councillor Andrews felt it was an excellent Neighbourhood Plan and demonstrated the hard work that had gone into it over many years. He acknowledged the support from officers at East Herts, especially George Pavey. The plan was a wonderful exercise in community engagement and it was a good foundation and marker for the future of the community in Thundridge Parish.
Asked16 Jul 2021Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for Review of the Premises Licence for Wilkestock, Waterbridge, Frogmore Hill, Watton At Stone, Hertford, Hertfordshire SG14 3RR (21/0239/PLV)
Councillor Andrews asked about the Fire risk assessment and work due to be completed with Hertfordshire Fire and Rescue. The premises licence holder said that Hertfordshire Fire and Rescue were happy with the steps currently being taken. The Sub-Committee was advised that the fire risk assessment was a work in process and advice was being taken from an ex-fire safety Officer.
Moved14 Jul 2021Development Management Committee
Minutes - 19 May 2021
Councillor Andrews proposed and Councillor Ruffles seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 19 May 2021 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman, subject to the following amendments:
Named9 Jul 2021Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was moved by Councillor Hall and seconded by Councillor Snowdon, that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named9 Jul 2021Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named27 May 2021Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was moved by Councillor Wilson and seconded by Councillor Hall, that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the Sub-Committee meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named27 May 2021Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor Andrews be appointed Chairman for the Sub-Committee meeting.
Moved29 Apr 2021Council
Minutes - 18 March 2021
Councillor Andrews proposed, and Councillor Deering seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 18 March 2021 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. The motion to approve the Minutes being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, it was declared CARRIED.
Said29 Apr 2021Council
Department for Transport (DfT) Statutory Taxi and Private Hire Vehicle Standards
Councillor Andrews commented that at the time of the Licensing Committee’s consideration, there was a very low level of engagement in the consultation. He hoped that in future, a better response would be given.
Seconded29 Apr 2021Council
Department for Transport (DfT) Statutory Taxi and Private Hire Vehicle Standards
Councillor Boylan proposed and Councillor Andrews seconded, a motion that the recommendation be supported. A motion to support the recommendation having been proposed and seconded, was put to the meeting and a vote taken. The motion was declared CARRIED.
Moved21 Oct 2020Council
Appointment of s.151 Officer
Councillor Andrews proposed a motion to support the recommendation in the report.
Seconded22 Jul 2020Council
Annual Report 2019 - 20
She moved and Councillor Andrews seconded that it be noted.
Moved13 May 2020Council
Minutes of 3 March 2020
Councillor Andrews proposed a motion to amend the Minutes at Minute 375 to delete the word “are” in the first line of paragraph 1 of the proposed amendment, and to make the same change in the substantive motion which was approved, so that it read “declares that EU citizens have always been welcome in the District of East Herts and will continue to be so”.
Said13 May 2020Council
Review of Constitution
Councillor Andrews said he welcomed the report. However, he drew attention to a proposed increase in the amount of write offs for unrecoverable debts which the Chief Financial Officer had authority to decide, from £10K to £25K.
Named13 May 2020Council
Review of Constitution
Councillor Pope said he agreed with Councillor Andrews and favoured leaving the limit unchanged.
Said13 May 2020Council
Review of Constitution
Councillor Andrews said the appropriate body should receive for noting any decision for a write off of an amount of up to £10K.
Seconded13 May 2020Council
Mandating subscription to the DBS Update Service for Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Drivers
Councillor Andrews seconded the motion. The motion being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, it was declared CARRIED. RESOLVED – that from 1 June 2020 the Council adopt the policy of requiring all Hackney Carriage and Private Hire drivers licensing by East Herts Council to register to the Disclosure and Barring Update Service and maintain that registration for the life of their dual driver or private hire driver’s licence.
Said13 May 2020Council
Motions on Notice
Councillor Andrews added that he wished to place on record an acknowledgement of the great work of the postal service. Other Members spoke to voice their appreciation of other workers, including the recycling teams, those officers who had arranged for grants to be given, the planning team and planning enforcement, and the District’s many voluntary groups.
Said3 Mar 2020Council
Motions on Notice
Councillor Andrews said he had been heartened by the concession that the Council had already undertaken good work in making EU citizens feel welcome, but he wished this sentiment had appeared earlier. The council had been formed in 1972 and had joined the European Union shortly afterwards. EU citizens had always been welcomed in East Hertfordshire.
Seconded29 Jan 2020Council
Capital Strategy 2020 Onwards
Councillor Andrews seconded the motion. The motion being put to the meeting, and a recorded vote taken in accordance with the statutory requirement, the results were: FOR Councillors Alder, Andrews, Beckett, Bell, Bolton, Brady, E Buckmaster, R Buckmaster, Bull, Burmicz, Corpe, Curtis, Crofton, Cutting, Deering, Drake, Dumont, Fernando, Goldspink, Goodeve, Hall, Haysey, Huggins, Jones, Kemp, McAndrew, Newton, Page, Pope, Reed, Ruffles, Snowdon, Stowe, Symonds, Ward-Booth, Williamson, Wilson, Wyllie.
Seconded29 Jan 2020Council
Treasury Management Strategy 2019/20
Councillor Andrews seconded the motion.
Moved26 Nov 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was moved by Councillor D Andrews and seconded by Councillor T Hall, that Councillor N Symonds be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Moved26 Nov 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Minutes - 21 October and 11 November 2019
It was moved by Councillor D Andrews and seconded by Councillor T Hall that the Minutes of the meetings held on 21 October and 11 November 2019 be confirmed as correct records and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
Named26 Nov 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for a New Premises Licence for Perrins Barbers, 5 Old Cross, Hertford, Herts. SG14 1HX
In response to questions from Councillor D Andrews, the applicant detailed his proposed business ... view the full minutes text for item 37.
Named11 Nov 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor R Bolton and seconded by Councillor C Wilson that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named11 Nov 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Moved11 Nov 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Exclusion of Press and Public
Councillor D Andrews proposed, and Councillor C Wilson seconded, a motion to exclude the press and public under the relevant legislation. After being put to the Sub-committee and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Said30 Oct 2019Licensing Committee
Consideration of Responses to the Proposal to Limit Hackney Carriage Vehicle Licences to Two Hundred
Councillor D Andrews acknowledged that the lack of response suggested that those in the trade were not unduly worried about the proposed limit.
Asked30 Oct 2019Licensing Committee
Consideration of Mandating Subscription to the DBS Update Service for Hackney Carriage and Private Hire Drivers
Councillor D Andrews sought and was provided with clarification that DBS renewals would still need to be diarised by officers as the update service would not create an automatic renewal notification. The service would however dramatically reduce the time officers spent processing DBS checks and alleviate the need for drivers to attend for a face to face meeting to complete the check.
Moved23 Oct 2019Council
Appointment of Interim Monitoring Officer
Councillor D Andrews moved, and Councillor L Haysey seconded, a motion that the recommendations as detailed in the report, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Seconded23 Oct 2019Council
Review of Polling Districts and Places
Councillor D Andrews seconded the motion.
Named23 Oct 2019Council
Review of Polling Districts and Places
In reply to a question from Councillor D Andrews, the Electoral Services Officer said that a typographical error regarding the polling place for Polling District reference JG in the ward of Hertford Rural South would be corrected.
Seconded23 Oct 2019Council
Anstey Conservation Area Character Appraisal
Councillor L Haysey proposed, and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion to support the recommendations detailed in the report. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named23 Oct 2019Council
Revised Taxi Licensing Suitability Policy
Council received a report submitted by Councillor D Andrews as Chairman of the Licensing Committee, detailing recommendations from the Committee to Council on the draft Taxi Licensing Suitability policy.
Said23 Oct 2019Council
Revised Taxi Licensing Suitability Policy
Councillor D Andrews said the Council was under a statutory obligation to ensure public safety, and took this duty seriously. He commended the draft policy, and proposed a motion that the recommendations be approved.
Seconded23 Oct 2019Council
Motions on Notice
Councillor D Andrews seconded the motion, and spoke in favour of the amendment. ... view the full minutes text for item 200.
Named21 Oct 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor R Bolton and seconded by Councillor M Stevenson, that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named21 Oct 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Said21 Oct 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for a New Premises Licence Luso Flavours, 24 - 26 Hockerill, Bishops Stortford, CM23 2DW
Councillor D Andrews commented on the number of covers that could be accommodated in the premises. The applicant referred to the advice he had received from Hertfordshire Fire and Rescue and said that the premises could accommodate 30 restaurant covers and a further 20 in the café.
Said21 Oct 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for a New Premises Licence Luso Flavours, 24 - 26 Hockerill, Bishops Stortford, CM23 2DW
Councillor D Andrews expressed concerns regarding young people being on the premises unaccompanied after 8 pm. The applicant confirmed to the Sub-Committee that he would be content with a condition stipulating that unaccompanied young people should be off the premises by 9 pm.
Named4 Sep 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor B Crystall and seconded by Councillor S Reed that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named4 Sep 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named28 Aug 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Chairman’s Announcements
At the request of Councillor D Andrews, the Chairman confirmed that Members of the Licensing Committee would be allowed to remain in the meeting, with the consent of the applicants, if the exclusion motion was necessary.
Moved21 Aug 2019Licensing Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chairman
It was moved by Councillor D Andrews and seconded by Councillor T Page that Councillor R Bolton be appointed Vice Chairman of Licensing Committee for the civic year 2019/20. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Moved21 Aug 2019Licensing Committee
Consideration of the Results of the Hackney Carriage Unmet Demand Survey
The Service Manager (Licensing and Enforcement) agreed that there was a need to be flexible and to apply licensing policies in an open minded manner but that existing policies such as the vehicle age and emissions policy were already driving up standards It was moved by Councillor D Andrews and seconded by Councillor N Symonds that the Hackney Carriage trade be limited to 200 with a flexible approach being taken in terms of the application of policy in relation to wheelchair accessible vehicles and electric vehicles. The overall number to be reduced by natural wastage and that this approach be adopted as a basis for further consultation. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared carried.
Seconded24 Jul 2019Council
Establishment of Financial Sustainability Committee
Councillor G Williamson moved, and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that the recommendations as detailed in the report submitted be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Seconded21 Jun 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Appointment of Chairman
It was moved by Councillor N Symonds and seconded by Councillor D Andrews, that Councillor J Jones be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named21 Jun 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Chairman's Announcements
He explained that there had been a change to the membership of the published agenda and that Councillor D Andrews had replaced Councillor M McMullen.
Asked21 Jun 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for a Variation of the Premises Licence for The Woolpack, Millbridge, Hertford SG14 1PZ
Councillor D Andrews sought clarification from the applicant in terms of the business model in relation to the provision of children on site and the fact that in practice the pub was assuming parental responsibility. The Commercial Director (McMullens) on behalf of the applicant explained that he could not imagine that unaccompanied children would be on the premises at all and that the DPS had responsibility for such matters and would take a responsible view regarding the age of customers. He explained that children were almost, without exception accompanied by their parents.
Named21 Jun 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for a Variation of the Premises Licence for The Woolpack, Millbridge, Hertford SG14 1PZ
Following a suggestion by Councillor D Andrews about the possibility of obtaining enhanced DBS checks on bar staff, the Legal Officer explained the position in relation to staff and DBS checks saying that such checks were not permitted for bar staff.
Named21 Jun 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for a Variation of the Premises Licence for The Woolpack, Millbridge, Hertford SG14 1PZ
In response to a query from Councillor Andrews, the DPS explained that background music would be played outside. The Director (McMullens) commented that the level of noise would not be an issue but was prepared to accept a condition regarding the closure of the garden area.
Asked21 Jun 2019Licensing Sub-Committee
Application for Variation of the Premises Licence for the White Hart, Salisbury Square, Hertford. SG14 1BW
Councillor D Andrews sought clarification regarding why there was a need for the kitchen to be open late. The Commercial Director (McMullens) explained that access to the kitchen was need to provide, in the main, teas and coffee. At the conclusion of the closing submissions, the Sub-Committee, Legal Officer and Democratic Services Officer withdrew from the meeting to allow the Sub-Committee to consider the evidence.
Seconded20 Mar 2019Development Management Committee
Planning Applications and Unauthorised Development for Consideration by the Committee
Councillor B Deering proposed and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that a total of 6 minutes be permitted for those who wish to speak in objection to application 3/18/2253/OUT, in total. The same total period of time would be offered to supporting parties and the relevant Town/Parish Council shall be offered a period of up to 3 minutes each.
Said20 Mar 2019Development Management Committee
3/18/1960/FUL - Proposed three storey extension and internal extension of first floor level within the existing building, together with change of use from former police station, fire station and citizens’ advice office (Sui Generis) to form
Councillor D Andrews commented on the layout of the proposed parking area. He referred to the loss 41 spaces for the public that would be lost as a result of the proposed development.
Said5 Mar 2019Council
Retail Frontages Design and Signage Supplementary Planning Document
Councillor D Andrews welcomed the document and echoed the comment regarding adequate resources.
Seconded5 Mar 2019Council
Harlow and Gilston Garden Town Transport Strategy
The Leader moved and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that the recommendations, as detailed in the report submitted, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Said5 Mar 2019Council
Licensing Committee: Minutes - 14 November 2018
Councillor D Andrews stated that he fully supported the new policy which had been endorsed by Licensing Committee.
Moved5 Mar 2019Council
Taxi Vehicle: Age and Emissions Policy
Councillor D Andrews moved and Councillor C Woodward seconded, a motion that the recommendation now detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Moved6 Feb 2019Licensing Committee
Consideration of Responses to Draft Vehicle Age and Emission Policy
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor J Jones seconded, a motion that the final wording of the Draft Vehicle Age and Emissions Policy be endorsed and recommended to Council for approval. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED. Members unanimously supported the recommendations now detailed.
Said30 Jan 2019Standards Sub-Committee
Exclusion of the Press and Public
Councillor D Andrews raised a point of order on the basis that as a Member of East Herts Council he could attend any meeting of the Authority conducting any business. The Monitoring Officer stated that it was not cited in the Constitution that any Member could attend any meeting.
Seconded25 Jul 2018Council
Old River Lane
Councillor G Williamson moved, and Councillor D Andrews seconded, the recommendations as now detailed. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the recommendations were declared CARRIED.
Said25 Jul 2018Council
Members' Allowances 2018/19
Councillor D Andrews expressed the view that the previously used “multiplier” for SRAs had been easier to understand and that the emphasis should be on the responsibility of the role rather than attendance numbers. He referred to the role of Chairman of Licensing Committee and the depth of activity “below the surface” and invited the Monitoring Officer to emphasise this within the next review.
Said26 Jun 2018Standards Sub-Committee
Exclusion of the Press and Public
With the Chairman’s permission, Councillor D Andrews raised a point of order in that he considered that this Sub-Committee hearing should be heard in public due to the considerable interest in the code of conduct complaints.
Seconded16 May 2018Executive, Committees, Sub-Committees and Panels
Establishment of Sub-Committees and Panels
Councillor L Haysey moved, and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that the recommendations as detailed in the report submitted be approved. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Seconded16 May 2018Council
Review of the Council's Decision-Making Arrangements
Councillor G Williamson moved, and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that the recommendations now detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Moved16 May 2018Council
Licensing Committee: Minutes - 15 November 2018
Councillor D Andrews moved, and Councillor G Cutting seconded, a motion that the Minutes now detailed, be received. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the Minutes were received.
Asked13 Dec 2017Council
Motion on Notice - Princess Alexandra Hospital
Councillor D Andrews questioned whether the Council was in a position to instruct the NHS on anything and proposed an amendment by substituting the word “encourages” instead of the word “instruct”.
Named18 Oct 2017Council
Chargeable Green Waste Services
Councillor D Andrews believed that most residents did not use this service and so were subsidising those that did.
Named10 May 2017Council
Members' Allowances - Report of the Independent Remuneration Panel
In response to a question from Councillor D Andrews, the Head advised that the IRP’s use of the word “ disapplied ” meant “discontinued”.
Named7 Jun 2016Executive
Footway and Grassed Verge Parking Enforcement Policy
Councillor D Andrews referred to his comments made at the Environment Scrutiny Committee and suggested a different approach whereby the Council should designate areas where parking on the verge was permitted and not prohibited. The Executive Member commented that this approach had been considered and rejected by the Environment Scrutiny Committee.
Said5 Apr 2016Executive
Planning and Enforcement Review
In respect of the proposed general delegation to Officers to issue all enforcement and general notices, Councillor D Andrews suggested that the local Member should also be kept informed.
Said23 Feb 2016Environment Scrutiny Committee
Planning and Enforcement Review
Councillor D Andrews also expressed concern regarding the inclusion of Parish Councils in the process on the basis that they might be “too close” to the case and some, were not duly elected. The Head of Planning and Building Control explained that such situations occurred infrequently and why it was important to include Parish/Town Councils when matters of concern were reported anonymously. The Committee received the report and supported the recommendation now detailed.
Named16 Dec 2015Council
Chairman's Announcements
She advised that, following a draw, Councillor D Andrews and herself had been selected to represent the Authority at a Royal Garden Party in 2016.
Seconded16 Dec 2015Council
Community Governance Review Request – Bishop’s Stortford Town Council
Councillor G Jones moved, and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that a Community Governance Review of the electoral arrangements of Bishop’s Stortford Town Council (including its town boundary) be undertaken. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared carried.
Named24 Nov 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
The Monitoring Officer submitted a report reminding the Sub-Committee that, at its meeting held on 10 September 2015, it had considered eight complaints against Councillor D Andrews alleging that he had breached the Authority’s Code of Conduct.
Named24 Nov 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
The Monitoring Officer, in accordance with the Sub-Committee’s instructions, submitted information on any connection between Councillor Andrews and Riversmead Housing Association as identified in the remaining complaint.
Named24 Nov 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
The Sub-Committee noted the evidence provided by the complainant to support the assertion of a relationship between the Association and Councillor D Andrews that included a statement from a third party.
Named24 Nov 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
The Monitoring Officer reported that the Regional Director of Riversmead Housing Association had advised that, to the best of his knowledge, the only connection that Councillor Andrews had with the Association related to his role as a District/County Councillor in areas where his organisation owned/managed/developed homes.
Named24 Nov 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
The Sub-Committee noted the Regional Director’s comments concerning a possible link between an officer of the Association and Councillor Andrews through their joint involvement with the Community Voluntary Body for East Hertfordshire (CVBEH).
Named24 Nov 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
RESOLVED – that after careful consideration of the complaint and supplementary information provided by the complainant and Monitoring Officer regarding an alleged relationship between the subject (Councillor D Andrews) and Riversmead Housing Association and in consultation with the Independent Person and taking into account the Council’s assessment criteria and the approved process for dealing with complaints, no further action be taken as no evidence has been provided that supports the assertion of an inappropriate relationship nor bias on the part of the subject.
Named22 Sep 2015Community Scrutiny Committee
Annual Performance Report for Riversmead and Circle and South Anglia Housing Associations 2014/15
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews regarding references to “centralised” and loss of “key personnel”, Members were advised that both Housing Associations had centralised a lot of their key functions and this had needed time to “bed” in Councillor A McNeece referred to his difficulties in contacting Riversmead HA by telephone, adding that this might be the reason targets were not being met as people could not get through. The Manager, Housing Services stated that this issue had been raised at a quarterly meeting with the Associations. They had advised that more staff had been employed but that this had taken time to be effective.
Said22 Sep 2015Community Scrutiny Committee
Annual Performance Report for Riversmead and Circle and South Anglia Housing Associations 2014/15
Councillor D Andrews expressed his frustration at trying to engage with the Housing Associations.
Named10 Sep 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
The Sub-Committee considered a report by the Monitoring Officer on eight complaints against Councillor D Andrews alleging that he had breached the Authority’s Code of Conduct.
Named10 Sep 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
In relation to the complaint that formed Essential Reference Paper ‘F’ to the report, the Sub-Committee agreed to request the Monitoring Officer to obtain information on any connection between Councillor Andrews and Riversmead Housing Association. In so doing, it agreed to defer consideration of this complaint.
Said8 Sep 2015Environment Scrutiny Committee
Procurement of Car Park Management System
Councillor D Andrews suggested that an “arm’s length” company be established to control car parks. The Executive Member for Economic Development stated that such an approach would not fit with current legislation on the permitted operation of Council car parks. ... view the full minutes text for item 257.
Moved19 Aug 2015Development Management Committee
3/15/1226/HH – Erection of detached car port, garage block, conversion of garage to habitable accommodation and single storey front extension at Auldebyre, Clapgate, Albury, SG11 2JL
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor D Oldridge seconded, a motion that a condition be applied to control the lighting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the Committee accepted the recommendation of the Director of Neighbourhood Services as now submitted.
Named9 Jul 2015Licensing Committee
Licensing Now and Next
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews regarding alcohol being bought on licensed premises but consumed off the premises, i.e. on a table outside, the Senior Specialist Licensing Officer explained the legal position.
Named9 Jul 2015Licensing Committee
Licensing Now and Next
In response to a comment from Councillor D Andrews regarding ... view the full minutes text for item 141.
Named30 Jun 2015Standards Sub-Committee
Complaint in respect of District Councillor D Andrews
The Sub-Committee considered a complaint against Councillor D Andrews alleging that he had breached the Authority’s Code of Conduct.
Said25 Mar 2015Development Management Committee
3/14/2122/FP – Two storey side extension at Pine Cottage, Ducketts Lane, Green Tye, Much Hadham, Hertfordshire, SG10 6JN for W and L Bird
Councillor D Andrews commented that he did not feel that this application was inappropriate and he was minded to support it.
Said25 Mar 2015Development Management Committee
E/13/0076/A – Unauthorised advertisements at various sites within East Hertfordshire
Councillor D Andrews praised the proactive approach of the Enforcement Team in identifying sites that needed to be tidied up.
Said18 Mar 2015Audit Committee
External Audit Update Report
Councillor D Andrews stated that Local Public Accounts Committees had a lot of potential and supported its introduction.
Named18 Mar 2015Audit Committee
Shared Internal Audit Service - Internal Audit Plan 2015/16
In response to a query by Councillor D Andrews in relation to Members’ Allowances, the Director of Finance and Support Services explained that the payroll processing of Members’ Allowances had not been audited for some time, alongside staff expenses and these had been included in the Internal Audit Plan for 2015/16.
Named18 Mar 2015Audit Committee
Annual Review of Data Quality Strategy
In response to a query by Councillor D Andrews with regard to dealing with Data Quality issues and whether Officers felt they were able to come forward to admit if a mistake had been made, the Director of Finance and Support Services advised that the Council did not have a blame culture and Officers were encouraged to come forward as soon as possible to fix the problem. If there was a repeated performance issue, then this would be picked up in the most appropriate way.
Said25 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
a) 3/14/1841/FP – Mixed use development including the conversion of the former McMullens Brewery to 7 No.
Councillor D Andrews welcomed the application and stated that he was very pleased to see this site being developed and this application would facilitate this process. He commented that he looked forward to enjoying the community use elements of the proposed development.
Named25 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
Planning Appeal: Demolition of the existing building and erection of a mixed use development comprising 101 residential (C3) apartments and employment (B1) space, along with associated highway and landscape works at Land at Crane Mead, Ware, Herts, SG12 9PY, REF: 3/14/1408/FP
Councillor D Andrews referred to the concerns Members had regarding the offer of 6 affordable housing units in a proposed development of 100 dwellings. He argued that if the scheme was not viable with more than 6 affordable housing units then the scheme was not viable at all.
Said25 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
Planning Appeal: Demolition of the existing building and erection of a mixed use development comprising 101 residential (C3) apartments and employment (B1) space, along with associated highway and landscape works at Land at Crane Mead, Ware, Herts, SG12 9PY, REF: 3/14/1408/FP
Councillor Andrews stated that the scheme must be viable as all homes were eventually purchased by somebody so were by definition affordable. He concluded that the site was eminently sustainable due to its proximity to the train station and the town centre with good facilities on hand. The site was therefore, ideal for a good mix of owner occupier, shared ownership and affordable housing.
Said24 Feb 2015Health and Wellbeing Panel
East Herts Health and Wellbeing Strategy Work Plan Review 2015-16
The Executive Member for Health Housing and Community Support and Councillor D Andrews suggested that there might be some merit in working with the CVS on such an initiative and that this should also involve the Afro-Caribbean community.
Asked24 Feb 2015Health and Wellbeing Panel
Scrutiny Evaluation and Work Programme
Councillor D Andrews asked that Money Advice and NHS Community Mental Health Trust be invited to attend HWP in 15/16 work plan.
Said4 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
3/14/1583/FP – Erection of 22 houses including 13 open market and 9 shared ownership together with a new access to Dane O'Coys Road at Land adjoining Hoggetts End, Dane O'Coys Road, Bishops Stortford, for Grange Builders LLP and others
Councillor D Andrews stated that there needed to be a sensible mix of housing and he would be reluctant to support an application where there would be no social housing on the site. He agreed that any social housing should be mixed in with the whole development.
Said4 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
3/14/1514/FP – Erection of agricultural grainstore and associated access at land adjacent to Ten Acres Nursery, Kettle Green Road, Much Hadham, SG10 6AQ for Chaldean Estate
Councillor D Andrews stated that he had been asked to address the Committee on behalf of the local ward Member, Councillor M Carver. He drew Members’ attention to the comments from Much Hadham Parish Council on page 89 of the report. He also referred to the comments from the objecting speaker regarding the impact of the proposed development on the character and appearance of the area.
Said4 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
3/14/1514/FP – Erection of agricultural grainstore and associated access at land adjacent to Ten Acres Nursery, Kettle Green Road, Much Hadham, SG10 6AQ for Chaldean Estate
Councillor Andrews commented that he was concerned that the roads were very narrow typical country lanes for the area although these lanes were relatively straight with reasonable sight lines. He referred to the fatalities highlighted by the Parish Council although two of these incidents had occurred some distance from the site.
Said4 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
3/14/1514/FP – Erection of agricultural grainstore and associated access at land adjacent to Ten Acres Nursery, Kettle Green Road, Much Hadham, SG10 6AQ for Chaldean Estate
Councillor Andrews stated that he could not comment on the issue of dust at the grain store. He referred to the issue of the noise impact and the great deal of feeling in Much Hadham regarding this application. He supported the concern that traffic did not come down Kettle Green Road into Much Hadham.
Said4 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
3/14/1514/FP – Erection of agricultural grainstore and associated access at land adjacent to Ten Acres Nursery, Kettle Green Road, Much Hadham, SG10 6AQ for Chaldean Estate
Councillor Andrews stated that he would not welcome the additional HGV movements coming into his ward, and in particular, traffic using the narrow lanes into Barwick via Barwick Ford. He concluded that there was a balance to be struck in respect of this application.
Asked4 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
Planning Appeal: Residential Development Proposals, Land East of Cambridge Road, Puckeridge (24 New Houses) Ref: 3/14/1627/OP
Councillor D Andrews sought clarification as to why the EA had given two adjacent sites different flood risk designations when they were separated by the very watercourse responsible for recent flooding. He stressed that it would occasionally be hugely helpful to have the EA and Hertfordshire Highways Officers present on occasion to explain their position to Officers and Members and the public.
Moved4 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
Planning Appeal: Residential Development Proposals, Land East of Cambridge Road, Puckeridge (24 New Houses) Ref: 3/14/1627/OP
Councillor D Andrews proposed and G Williamson seconded, a motion that recommendation (C) be amended to read that the Head of Planning and Building Control, in consultation with the Chairman of the Committee and one other Member of the Committee, be authorised to engage with the appellants in relation to all matters relevant to the appeal and to formulate, alter, amend and update the Council’s statement and evidence to be submitted in relation to any forthcoming appeal.
Named4 Feb 2015Development Management Committee
Planning Appeal – Hertford Regional College
Councillor D Andrews encouraged Officers to push hard for houses available for social rent as this was an ideal and sustainable location. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the Committee accepted the recommendation of the Head of Planning and Building Control as now submitted.
Named21 Jan 2015Audit Committee
Shared Internal Audit Service – Internal Audit Plan Progress Report
Councillor D Andrews referred to emergency planning and business continuity in the context of the recent events in South Oxfordshire. The Director of Finance and Support Services stated that Officers were confident that systems such as EDM were in place to ensure IT and business continuity but that any lessons learnt from the events in South Oxfordshire would be considered as part of our business continuity plans.
Said26 Nov 2014Audit Committee
Treasury Management Strategy - 2014/15 Mid Year Review
Councillor D Andrews stated that the Council was relying heavily on traditional methods of investment. He referred to a neighbouring authority which had invested in property and was receiving high rates of return. The Director Finance and Support Services commented that she was aware of this and that the other authority had already set up a company to facilitate its property investment approach.
Said20 Nov 2014Licensing Committee
Consideration of a Proposal to take over the responsibility of Licensing Tables and Chairs on the Highway (Pavement Licence) from Hertfordshire County Council’s Highways
Councillor D Andrews commented that careful consideration should be given to the issue of pavement advertising boards, as they were an important part of the street scene. In response to a number of comments from Members, the Senior Specialist Licensing Officer stated that a pavement licence would be necessary for tables and chairs on the highway for the purpose of people taking refreshment and that planning permission may also be necessary.
Said20 Nov 2014Licensing Committee
Consideration of a Site Management Agreement (SMA) with the Public Fundraising Association (PFRA) in relation to Direct Debit Street Collections
Councillor D Andrews expressed concern regarding the persistence of collectors who knocked on doors of residential dwellings. The Senior Specialist Licensing Officer advised that direct debit collectors visiting private dwellings were beyond the Council’s control as the SMA agreement would only cover town centres.
Said12 Nov 2014Development Management Committee
Coltsfoot Mead Wood – Provisional TPO (P/TPO) 587
Councillor D Andrews stated that he was very concerned in respect of paragraph 2.2 of the report. He commented that if the woodland was so precious, a P/TPO should have been confirmed long ago. He referred to the apparent trigger for this P/TPO being the appeal decision granting planning permission for the woodland track.
Named12 Nov 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes North London
Councillor D Andrews, as the local ward Member, shared the concern of Councillor Williamson in respect of the density of the proposed development in relation to the size of the hamlet of High Cross.
Said12 Nov 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes North London
Councillor Andrews praised the effort that had gone into this application from the Parish Council and also from David Wilson Homes. He stated that David Wilson Homes had addressed some of the issues of concern and he referred to the positive effect of the local input into this application.
Named12 Nov 2014Development Management Committee
3/14/1283/FP – Alteration of existing motor repair work shop including removal of rear projection and change of use to a 2 bed dwelling at land at Kenton House, Hare Street, SG9 0EA for Mr Madden
Councillor D Andrews referred to a degree of sympathy for this application from the Committee and he agreed with the points of Councillor Newman. .
Said15 Oct 2014Development Management Committee
Deed of Variation on a Shared Ownership Unit at 4 Lloyd Taylor Close, Little Hadham
Councillor D Andrews stated this this was an unfortunate situation and there should be checks and balances to prevent this from occurring. He commented it was for Members to reach a considered view as to whether such conditions were necessary and appropriate.
Said15 Oct 2014Development Management Committee
Deed of Variation on a Shared Ownership Unit at 4 Lloyd Taylor Close, Little Hadham
Councillor Andrews stressed that the registered social landlords and the land registry should be made fully aware in future of their obligations and, if at all possible, there should be penalties in these situations.
Named14 Oct 2014Health and Wellbeing Panel
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor J Jones was substituting for Councillor D Andrews.
Named24 Sep 2014Audit Committee
External Audit Report - Audit Findings
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews regarding the question raised by a member of the public and the publication of the accounts, the External Auditor explained that it was not usual to publish questions raised in the accounts.
Named24 Sep 2014Audit Committee
Statement of Accounts 2013/14
Councillor D Andrews drew Members’ attention to an omission within the Explanatory Forward (4. Capital Expenditure and Financing) in that the word “bridge” had been omitted from the last line.
Named24 Sep 2014Audit Committee
Risk Management Monitoring report 1 April 2014 to 30 June 2014
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews regarding Universal Credit, its “mobility” and “transferring in”, the Director of Finance and Support Services explained that Hertfordshire, as an area, was a very expensive place to live and it was unlikely that people moving into the area would already be in receipt of Universal Credit.
Named24 Sep 2014Audit Committee
Risk Management Monitoring report 1 April 2014 to 30 June 2014
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews regarding increased workload and its effect on the Council’s “Front Desk”, the Director of Finance and Support Services confirmed that additional funds had been allocated to customer services support for the last two years. The Committee approved the report, as now detailed.
Said17 Sep 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – High Road/North Drive, High Cross - Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes North London
Councillor D Andrews stated that it was sad to see that the applicant had not given significant attention to addressing the issues raised by Members as shortcomings. He commented that he was disappointed that there would not be open sustainable drainage solutions rather than closed systems.
Said17 Sep 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – High Road/North Drive, High Cross - Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes North London
Councillor Andrews stated that he would like to see a half metre ransom strip adjacent to North Drive provided as part of this application. He was also very concerned regarding the access to the site via North Drive. The Director stated that, if there were issues that Members felt that Officers had not picked up from the deferral at the August 2014 meeting, a further deferral would allow Officers to address these outstanding matters.
Said17 Sep 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – High Road/North Drive, High Cross - Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes North London
Councillor Andrews stated that he had significant highways concerns and stated that he used the main road by car and by bike and he stressed that, due to the chicanes, this could be a frightening experience.
Named20 Aug 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes, North London
Councillor P Ruffles read out a number of comments on behalf of the local ward Member, Councillor D Andrews.
Named20 Aug 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes, North London
Councillor Andrews had referred to the significant outcomes of the informed negotiations and also praised the efforts of the Parish Council, the Case Officer as well as an East Herts Engineering Officer for their contributions to this application.
Named20 Aug 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes, North London
Councillor Andrews had regretted that the applicant had not placed less emphasis on piped drainage solutions in favour of an open channel flood relief scheme, which would result in an enhanced street scene with additional biodiversity and green space.
Named20 Aug 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2223/FP – Demolition of The Bungalow, The Stables and Hazelwood Farm and the erection of 57 residential units together with access and associated ancillary works at High Road, rear of North Drive, High Cross, SG11 1AD for David Wilson Homes, North London
Councillor Andrews had also referred to the commitment from the developer to work with the Parish Council in transferring the ownership of a strip of land to ensure there could never be vehicular access to and from North Drive and to assist in the provision of play facilities for children.
Said23 Jul 2014Development Management Committee
3/14/0590/FP – Demolition of existing buildings and redevelopment of the site to provide 107 residential units, 100 sqm of retail floorspace, provision of a link road between Mill Road and Mead Lane and passenger interchange, associated car
Councillor D Andrews commented on how refreshing it was that a developer had taken on board previous concerns and had worked hard to ensure this revised application was one that Officers were able to support.
Said23 Jul 2014Development Management Committee
E/14/0093/B – Material Change of Use of land to car wash business at Former Waters Garage, 3-9 North Road, Hertford, SG14 4LN
Councillor D Andrews stated that the unauthorised car wash land use was compatible with the site in that the former Waters Garage sold cars and was also a petrol station.
Said23 Jul 2014Development Management Committee
E/14/0093/B – Material Change of Use of land to car wash business at Former Waters Garage, 3-9 North Road, Hertford, SG14 4LN
Councillor Andrews stated that there was nothing regarding the unauthorised use that caused him undue concern, particularly as issue of run off had been taken care of.
Said16 Jul 2014Audit Committee
Revision to Treasury Management Arrangements
Councillor D Andrews suggested that the Council should be investing locally in property as this would demonstrate a commitment to local residents and communities. The Director of Finance and Support Services drew Members’ attention to the proposed framework by which the Council would invest in terms of property funds and indirect investment in property and explained the differences of each. Once approved, this would allow the Council to move ahead.
Named16 Jul 2014Audit Committee
Draft Statement of Accounts 2013 - 2014
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews concerning planning income which had been offset by a number of planning appeal costs, the Director of Finance and Support Services explained how variances were managed in terms of timeframes and that many variances could be anticipated as part of the monthly healthcheck to scrutiny committees. She assured Members that monitoring and controls would ensure that the Council would have resources in the right place when needed.
Named16 Jul 2014Audit Committee
Shared Internal Audit Service - Audit Plan Update
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews regarding a follow up of various ICT reviews, the Shared Internal Audit Service Manager explained why this remained on the schedule.
Named17 Jun 2014Health and Wellbeing Panel
Chairman's Announcements
The Chairman also welcomed Councillor D Andrews to his first meeting of the Health and Wellbeing Panel.
Named2 Apr 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2268/RP – Application for approval of reserved matters in respect of 3/11/0554/OP for appearance, landscaping, layout and scale for the erection of residential development and associated roadworks, landscaping, materials and Public Ope
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews, the Director advised that the conditions dealing with permitted development rights also covered any details of gates within the site.
Said13 Mar 2014Licensing Committee
Consideration of an Approach from the Public Fundraising Association (PFRA) regarding possible Site Management Agreements (SMA)
Councillor D Andrews stated that it was not just town centres which were “plagued” with the collectors but villages too. He was concerned about the forceful tactics employed by the collectors.
Said12 Mar 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2067/FP – Construction of 2 no. detached dwellings following demolition of existing barns at Bromley Farm, Bromley Lane, Much Hadham, SG11 1NY for Chaldean Estate
Councillor D Andrews stated that he did not agree that the location of the barns detracted from the appearance of the rural area. He commented that he was supportive of the application as the proposed development was the best outcome for this site.
Said12 Mar 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2067/FP – Construction of 2 no. detached dwellings following demolition of existing barns at Bromley Farm, Bromley Lane, Much Hadham, SG11 1NY for Chaldean Estate
Councillor D Andrews stated that, whilst there were no shops and local amenities to support small dwellings, a larger family dwelling would allow a degree of self sufficiency and having dwellings on this site would be much better than what was on the site at present.
Moved12 Mar 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/2067/FP – Construction of 2 no. detached dwellings following demolition of existing barns at Bromley Farm, Bromley Lane, Much Hadham, SG11 1NY for Chaldean Estate
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor N Symonds seconded, a motion that application 3/13/2067/FP be granted on the basis that there would be no significant harm resulting from the application, which would not set a precedent and was in keeping with the surrounding area. The application would enhance the appearance of the site and would provide much needed housing.
Asked5 Mar 2014Council
Members' questions
Councillor D Andrews asked the Leader of the Council if he was aware of any steps the Liberal Democrat Members had taken to engage in this year’s annual budget-setting round.
Named11 Feb 2014Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor Mrs D Hollebon and seconded by Councillor G Williamson that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named11 Feb 2014Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named5 Feb 2014Development Management Committee
Minutes – 30 January 2014
Councillor D Andrews referred to the recommendation from Hertfordshire County Council that there was a continual review of traffic impacts.
Said5 Feb 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/1375/OP – Full permission for the erection of 180 homes, amenity land for community uses, the creation of one new access onto the A10 and closure of an existing access onto the A10 north of the site, creation of four new accesses onto
Councillor D Andrews commented that the overall scheme was highly commendable and he was largely supportive of it. He stated however, that he was familiar with the location and, notwithstanding the straight road and good visibility, Ermine Street was a derestricted road and the Throcking junction was exceptionally dangerous. He concluded that the proposed access should be reconsidered by Hertfordshire Highways.
Named5 Feb 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/1762/FP – Redevelopment of site to provide a new college building and enabling residential development of 50 dwellings, car parking, associated access and landscaping including demolition of existing buildings at Hertford Regional Coll
Councillor D Andrews referred to the overbearing impact of the proposed flats as well as the inadequate car parking provision of one space per unit, particularly in light of the enormous parking pressures on the surrounding roads. He expressed concerns that the proposed 6% affordable housing provision was inadequate and a figure of 36% would be more in keeping with the Council’s policy of 40% affordable housing.
Named5 Feb 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/1273/FP – The demolition of block of flats 115-149 Tudor Way and the construction of 11 no.
Councillor D Andrews referred to the significantly reduced space that would be available for the residents of the proposed development. He stated that the application was not one that he could wholeheartedly support.
Said5 Feb 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/1497/FP – Development of 85 no. residential apartments (Block 3) and (Block 4) in place of the Hotel and nursing home (approved under 3/12/1632/FO) with parking, access and all ancillary works at Hertford Police Station, Ware Road, Hertford, SG13 7HD for Barratt North London
Councillor D Andrews commented on the scale of the balconies included as part of this development.
Said5 Feb 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/1891/FP – Construction of detached dwelling and three bay garage at Newtons, Church Lane, Much Hadham, SG10 6DH for Mr G Newton
Councillor D Andrews stated that he agreed with all the comments made by the public speaker and the local ward Member that this application would do very little harm. He commented that he was impressed regarding the lack of objection to the proposed development.
Named5 Feb 2014Development Management Committee
E/14/0009/B – Breach of Condition 3 (restriction of use) of planning permission reference 3/06/0604/FP, following the provision of office accommodation within the upper floor of the detached garage at LongCroft, Monks Green Lane, Brickendon, Hertfordshire, SG13 8QL
In response to comments from Councillor D Andrews, the Director advised that informal dialogue with the landowner and the appellant had taken place and was ongoing. Members were advised that there was a risk that, should the current unauthorised use cease, a further breach of planning control could be reintroduced at any time and reported to Members as an enforcement matter.
Named14 Jan 2014Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor G Williamson and seconded by Councillor J Mayes that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named14 Jan 2014Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Said8 Jan 2014Development Management Committee
3/13/1721/FP – Demolition of existing buildings and erection of 2 no.
Councillor D Andrews expressed his surprise to learn that the applicant proposed the destruction of 12 well maintained family homes. He questioned the density of the proposed development and the impact on the existing street scene. He also expressed concerns in respect of overlooking for existing residents.
Said6 Nov 2013Development Management Committee
3/13/1513/FO – Variation of Condition 3 (restriction of use) of Planning Approval Ref 3/06/0604/FP to provide office accommodation within the upper floor of the detached garage at Longcroft, Monks Green Lane, Brickendon, Hertfordshire, SG13 8QL for William Ashley and Partners
Councillor D Andrews commented on whether the workspace in the live work units had been fully utilised. He also sought clarification in respect of whether Members were approving the removal of an onerous condition or granting retrospective planning permission.
Named18 Sep 2013Audit Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor D Andrews was substituting for Councillor J Wyllie.
Said11 Sep 2013Development Management Committee
Minutes – 14 August 2013
In respect of Minute 190 – Applications 3/12/1955/FP and 3/12/1956/LB, Councillor D Andrews stated that although Councillor P Ballam was the local Member she was not the local “ward” Member. The Committee agreed that the word “ward” should be deleted.
Said11 Sep 2013Development Management Committee
3/11/2137/SV – Modification of Section 106 agreement in respect of the commercial buildings approved under ref: 3/04/0657/OP by the variation of a £125,000 Highways Contribution at 95-97 London Road, Bishop's Stortford, CM23 3DU for Tanners Wharf Ltd
Councillor D Andrews expressed concern regarding the wording in relation to the transfer of the freehold and suggested that the words “provided such transfer occurs within 5 years of completion of the agreement” be deleted.
Named14 Aug 2013Development Management Committee
3/13/0551/FP – Redevelopment of the site to provide 130 residential units, 100 sqm of retail floor space, provision of a link road between Mill Road and Mead Lane and passenger interchange, associated car parking and landscaping at Land jun
Councillor D Andrews referred to the proposed parking allocation of less than 3 quarters of a space per unit as being inadequate and unworkable. He also stated that a car club had been tried elsewhere in the District and had been proved to be unworkable.
Named14 Aug 2013Development Management Committee
a) 3/12/1955/FP and b) 3/12/1956/LB – Demolition of the existing outbuildings and renovation of the former Victorian School.
Councillor D Andrews referred to the significance of the buildings on this site to the Ware community. He stated that the site was in a sad and sorry state which was not good to see. He concluded that the good work of Officers and the applicant to ameliorate the impact of the proposed development meant the applications should be approved.
Said14 Aug 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/2063/FP – Demolition of existing 3 garage blocks and erection of 4 two-storey semi-detached houses with three bedrooms, private amenity space and car parking at Garage Site to the North of 9 Three Stiles, Benington, Stevenage, SG2 7LD for South Anglia Housing
Councillor D Andrews stated that he agreed with most of the objections to this application that had been summarised in paragraph 5.4 of the report now submitted. He was particularly concerned that a road width of 3.2 metres was too narrow for a modern ambulance, refuse vehicle or fire appliance.
Said14 Aug 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/2063/FP – Demolition of existing 3 garage blocks and erection of 4 two-storey semi-detached houses with three bedrooms, private amenity space and car parking at Garage Site to the North of 9 Three Stiles, Benington, Stevenage, SG2 7LD for South Anglia Housing
Councillor Andrews commented that he was particularly concerned in respect of the location, height and the access arrangements for the proposed development. He referred to the inevitable conflict between traffic, parked cars and children as there was no footpath provision in this location.
Moved14 Aug 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/2063/FP – Demolition of existing 3 garage blocks and erection of 4 two-storey semi-detached houses with three bedrooms, private amenity space and car parking at Garage Site to the North of 9 Three Stiles, Benington, Stevenage, SG2 7LD for South Anglia Housing
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor K Crofton seconded, a motion that application 3/12/2063/FP be refused on the grounds that the proposed development would result in the loss of existing parking provision and was therefore contrary to policy ENV1 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007 and the National Planning Policy Framework. The proposed development also failed to respect the existing form and character of development in the area and was therefore contrary to policies ENV1 and OSV2 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007 and the National Planning Policy Framework.
Named24 Jul 2013Council
Scrutiny Annual Report 2012/13
Councillor D Andrews commended the report as excellent and he encouraged all Members to read it. He also thanked the Scrutiny Officer for her hard work during a challenging and interesting year. He thanked Members for their input and stated that the forthcoming year would be equally challenging.
Named24 Jul 2013Council
Scrutiny Annual Report 2012/13
Councillor Andrews referred to pages 138 to 139 of the report now submitted for the areas identified by Councillors to strengthen the Scrutiny process in 2013/14. He stated that a key theme was how to encourage residents to join in the scrutiny process.
Said24 Jul 2013Council
Amendment to Constitution – Development Management Prior Approval Processes
Councillor D Andrews expressed a concern that should a premises change use from agricultural use to business use (B1), then the premises could become another use entirely should legislation be changed again in future.
Said17 Jul 2013Development Management Committee
a) 3/13/0333/FP and b) 3/13/0334/LC – Demolition of the Roebuck Hotel and erection of 2no 3 bedroom houses, 8no 4 bedroom and 4no 5 bedroom houses together with associated access, car parking, landscaping and related work at The Roebuck Hot
Councillor D Andrews stated that the Roebuck Hotel had a lot of potential and that Ware did not need more houses.
Seconded17 Jul 2013Development Management Committee
a) 3/13/0333/FP and b) 3/13/0334/LC – Demolition of the Roebuck Hotel and erection of 2no 3 bedroom houses, 8no 4 bedroom and 4no 5 bedroom houses together with associated access, car parking, landscaping and related work at The Roebuck Hot
Councillor M Alexander proposed and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that applications 3/13/0333/FP and 3/13/0334/LC be refused on the grounds that ... view the full minutes text for item 132.
Named17 Jul 2013Development Management Committee
3/13/0343/SV – Modification of S106 agreement for 3/10/1522/FP to reduce the affordable housing provision from 23 units to 13 units on grounds of economic viability at Wallace Land, Buntingford Road, Puckeridge, SG11 1RT for Rialto Homes Ltd
Councillor D Andrews referred to the viability assessment adding that he was not unsympathetic to the application but that the village needed social housing. He stated that such housing need not be cheap, adding that most were let at current market value. He referred to the costs of the archaeological works and of the need to work with the developer to find something closer to the affordable housing figure previously agreed.
Said17 Jul 2013Development Management Committee
3/13/0343/SV – Modification of S106 agreement for 3/10/1522/FP to reduce the affordable housing provision from 23 units to 13 units on grounds of economic viability at Wallace Land, Buntingford Road, Puckeridge, SG11 1RT for Rialto Homes Ltd
Councillor Andrews stated that the developers should have known that the site was opposite a major Roman conurbation.
Named10 Jul 2013Audit Committee
Update on Payments to Members for ICT Expenses – Objection to the 2011/12 Accounts
Councillor D Andrews drew Members’ attention to the fact that not all current Members were affected by the £35/month payments made outside the Members Allowance Scheme from May 2011 to 31 March 2012, as not all current Members had claimed the allowance and that this should be noted accordingly. The Manager of Corporate Risk acknowledged that this was correct.
Named10 Jul 2013Audit Committee
Update on Implementation Of 2012/2013 Annual Governance Statement Action Plan
On the issue of data protection, Councillor D Andrews referred to the “umbrella” protection now afforded by the Council to Parish Councillors.
Named22 May 2013Development Management Committee
Apology
It was noted that Councillor G Lawrence was in attendance as substitute for Councillor D Andrews.
Said12 Mar 2013Community Scrutiny Committee
Crime and Disorder Report - Police Crime Commissioner's Budget and Plan: Implications for East Herts
Councillor D Andrews advised Members that his Parish Council had sponsored a PCSO who was considered “indispensible”.
Named27 Feb 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/1417/RP – Residential development of 26 dwellings – approval of details in respect of appearance, scale and layout, following outline approval of LPA ref. 3/10/2040/FP at land off Longmead, Buntingford, SG9 9EF for Matthew Homes
Councillor D Andrews supported the comments made by Councillors S Bull and M Newman. He also commented on whether there should be a condition attached to protect any archaeological finds on the site. The Director advised that an archaeological condition had been attached to the outline planning permission and was therefore still relevant for this reserved matters scheme.
Named27 Feb 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/1150/FP – Demolition of garages and clearance of associated land, construction of affordable housing, 4 x3 bed semi-detached houses, 3 x 2 bed bungalows, and one open market 4 bed detached house on garage site and 2 adjacent plots to t
In response to a concern from Councillor D Andrews, the Director advised that bollards at both ends of the remaining grassed area in Grass Warren should prevent any cut through misuse of the area by vehicles.
Named12 Feb 2013Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor G McAndrew and seconded by Councillor G Williamson that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named12 Feb 2013Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Said6 Feb 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/1551/FP – Change of use of land for the grazing of horses and the erection of three stables incorporating tack store and hay/ feed store on a concrete base at Land off Bourne Lane, Much Hadham, SG10 6ET for Mrs C Betts
Councillor D Andrews stated that, of the considerations which Officers has been asked to investigate further by Members, the only one that was relevant was the impact of the application on the character and appearance of the area. He stated that he continued to be supportive of this application and the scheme would not have a significant impact on the surrounding area.
Moved6 Feb 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/1551/FP – Change of use of land for the grazing of horses and the erection of three stables incorporating tack store and hay/ feed store on a concrete base at Land off Bourne Lane, Much Hadham, SG10 6ET for Mrs C Betts
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor Mrs R Cheswright seconded, a motion that application 3/12/1551/FP be granted subject to conditions being delegated to Officers in consultation with the local ward Member.
Asked30 Jan 2013Council
Declarations of Interest
Councillor D Andrews asked Council to note the declaration made at the Development Control Committee meeting held on 9 January 2013 in respect of Minute 529 – Application 3/12/1040/OP.
Named15 Jan 2013Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor J Ranger and seconded by Councillor J Mayes that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named15 Jan 2013Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Declared9 Jan 2013Development Management Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor D Andrews declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in application 3/12/1040/OP, in that he was employed by the Sainsbury’s group of companies and Sainsbury’s used to own the site that was the subject of this application. He left the room whilst this matter was considered.
Said9 Jan 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/1804/RP – Erection of 81 dwellings and associated details of appearance, landscaping, layout and scale (Phase II) at the Former Trinity Centre, Lady Margaret Gardens, Ware, SG12 7TL for Croudace Homes Ltd
Councillor D Andrews also expressed concerns regarding the site access and the density of the proposed development. He also stated that the parking provision of 1.67 spaces per dwelling was a concern, especially when considering the distance between the site and Ware train station and other local amenities. He also commented that many of the residents would work up or down the A10 corridor and would require at least one car per household.
Said9 Jan 2013Development Management Committee
3/12/1805/FP – Use of part of ground floor for the purposes of childcare on a domestic premises for up to 20 children at Dhoon, Epping Green, Hertford, Hertfordshire, SG13 8NB for Samantha Baker
Councillor D Andrews expressed similar concerns regarding the enforceability of the conditions and the impact of the application on neighbour amenity.
Named10 Oct 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0424/FP – Closure of railway foot-crossing and construction of a new footbridge with ramped access at Johnsons Railway Crossing, Bishop's Stortford for Network Rail
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews, the Director stated that the most relevant issue for Members was the making good of the site. Officers had suggested a landscaping condition to encourage appropriate treatment for the area surrounding the footbridge. Officers had anticipated this might very likely involve the planting of grass.
Asked10 Oct 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/1278/FO – Removal of condition of planning reference 3/97/1447/FO to allow the petrol filling station to operate 24 hours a day, 7 days a week at Tesco Stores Ltd, Lancaster Way, Bishop's Stortford, CM23 4DD for Tesco Stores Ltd
Councillor D Andrews sought clarification regarding the operating hours of the store and petrol station in relation to hours applied for as part of this application for a removal of a planning condition. He commented that a 24 hour filling station was unnecessary in this location due to the facilities at the nearby M11 junction.
Said10 Oct 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0868/AD – Proposed two externally illuminated fascia signs, two externally illuminated panel signs and five non-illuminated panel signs at Post Office, Baldock Road, Buntingford, SG9 9BL for Mr Basra
Councillor D Andrews stated that the existing signs detracted from the existing street scene and commented on whether these signs would be removed so that the façade was more in keeping with the street scene.
Seconded10 Oct 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/1214/FP – Erection of detached double garage at 12 Thornfield Road, Bishop's Stortford, CM23 2RB for Mr W. Parry
Councillor G Jones proposed and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that application 3/12/1241/FP be granted as the application was not detrimental to the street scene, subject to a condition relating to planting to screen the proposed detached garage.
Said10 Oct 2012Development Management Committee
E/11/0058/B – Unauthorised advertisement by changing coloured lighting to the front elevations of The Navigator Public House, Bridge Foot, Ware, SG12 9DW
Councillor D Andrews commented that the Committee had previously approved enforcement action for the removal of two lights opposite this site, which was in a conservation area. He stated his unhappiness with the unauthorised changing coloured lighting.
Declared26 Sep 2012Council
Declarations of Interest
In respect of Minute 335 – Action Plan to Support the East Herts Housing Strategy, Councillor D Andrews disclosed a pecuniary interest in that he was a board member of South Anglia Housing Association.
Named21 Aug 2012Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee
Council Tax Support
In response to a comment from Councillor D Andrews, the Committee requested that Members be kept informed regarding the timing of any letters that were sent to residents.
Named20 Aug 2012Highways Joint Member Panel
Section 106 Contributions
In relation to GSK Park Road, Ware, Councillor D Andrews pressed for a traffic study to be carried out.
Asked20 Aug 2012Highways Joint Member Panel
Vote of Thanks
Hertfordshire County Councillor D Andrews asked that a vote of thanks be recorded to Officers of East Hertfordshire and Hertfordshire County Council and colleagues for all their efforts over the years.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0145/FP – Change of use from residential to D1 (use as a meeting hall) temporary consent for 3 years at The Bungalow, Ermine Street, Colliers End, SG11 1ET for Hertford Gospel Hall Trust
Councillor D Andrews commented that the former bungalow was in a poor state of repair so therefore any change of use was not inappropriate. He stated that the development referred to in the report was in fact the provision of a parking area to facilitate the proposed use.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0145/FP – Change of use from residential to D1 (use as a meeting hall) temporary consent for 3 years at The Bungalow, Ermine Street, Colliers End, SG11 1ET for Hertford Gospel Hall Trust
Councillor D Andrews stressed that the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007 stipulated a presumption against development in rural areas aside from land required from agriculture, forestry or small scale community facilities. He stressed that this application fell into the category of a small scale community facility.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0145/FP – Change of use from residential to D1 (use as a meeting hall) temporary consent for 3 years at The Bungalow, Ermine Street, Colliers End, SG11 1ET for Hertford Gospel Hall Trust
Councillor D Andrews commented on the suggestion that the parking area was not in keeping with the open rural character of the site. He stressed that the applicant had commented to him that the parking area would be flat.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0145/FP – Change of use from residential to D1 (use as a meeting hall) temporary consent for 3 years at The Bungalow, Ermine Street, Colliers End, SG11 1ET for Hertford Gospel Hall Trust
Councillor D Andrews also stated that the current access track was in a very poor condition and the use of ‘ grasscrete ’ or similar materials would render the parking area invisible from a very short distance.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0145/FP – Change of use from residential to D1 (use as a meeting hall) temporary consent for 3 years at The Bungalow, Ermine Street, Colliers End, SG11 1ET for Hertford Gospel Hall Trust
Councillor D Andrews emphasised that sustainability would not be an issue given the limited bus service provision in the area. Residents, as was often the case across East Herts , had no option but to use the private car to get to this location, especially on Sundays.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0145/FP – Change of use from residential to D1 (use as a meeting hall) temporary consent for 3 years at The Bungalow, Ermine Street, Colliers End, SG11 1ET for Hertford Gospel Hall Trust
Councillor D Andrews stated that Hertfordshire Highways and the Hertfordshire Biological Records Centre had not objected to the application. He stated that the impact of the application on the character and appearance of the area would be very minimal.
Moved18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0145/FP – Change of use from residential to D1 (use as a meeting hall) temporary consent for 3 years at The Bungalow, Ermine Street, Colliers End, SG11 1ET for Hertford Gospel Hall Trust
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor Mrs R Cheswright seconded, a motion that application 3/12/0145/FP be granted on the grounds that the proposed development was acceptable as a small scale community facility in the rural area.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0791/FP – Erection of extension to provide 43 en-suite bedrooms at Fanhams Hall Hotel, Fanhams Hall, Fanhams Hall Road, Ware, SG12 7PZ for Exclusive Hotels
Councillor D Andrews, as the other local Member affected by the proposals, commented that the Conservation Officer had identified merit in the proposed development and also referred to the importance of economic viability for East Herts.
Moved18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0791/FP – Erection of extension to provide 43 en-suite bedrooms at Fanhams Hall Hotel, Fanhams Hall, Fanhams Hall Road, Ware, SG12 7PZ for Exclusive Hotels
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor M Newman seconded, a motion that application 3/12/0791/FP be granted on the grounds that there were very special circumstances, in that the application supported the economic viability of Fanhams Hall Hotel and East Herts and the benefits of the application outweighed the harm to the Metropolitan Green Belt.
Named18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0268/FP – Change of use of reservoir field to allow the siting of 5 static holiday caravans in the form of log cabins and of a reception building, together with reshaping an existing reservoir to allow for use for angling, associated g
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews, the Director stressed that, in relation to the issue of farm diversification and the viability of the business, the Council’s legal team had advised that it was possible for funds to be set aside in the form of a bond, which would subsequently be released to ensure the removal of the log cabins were the business to fail.
Named18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0922/FP – Change of use to community youth cafe (D2) with coffee shop facility for local shoppers and businesses (A3), and new shopfront at 76 South Street, Bishop's Stortford, CM23 3AZ for Bishop's Stortford Community Church
Councillor D Andrews referred to the proposed A3 use and commented on the size of extraction and filtration equipment. He stated that the equipment should be in proportion whilst being sufficient to prevent harm to the neighbourhood should another user of the site wish to cook and prepare more food on site than was proposed by this application.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0272/FP – Alterations to and retention of the service road, together with associated re-grading of the deposited material at Old Clay Pit, St Mary's Lane, Hertingfordbury, SG14 2LE for Mr Daniel Green
Councillor D Andrews expressed concerns regarding the likely numbers of vehicle movements required to move 2000 tonnes of material in and out of the site on roads that were wholly unsuitable for such activity. He also expressed concerns as to how the quality of the clay material could be monitored.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
3/12/0272/FP – Alterations to and retention of the service road, together with associated re-grading of the deposited material at Old Clay Pit, St Mary's Lane, Hertingfordbury, SG14 2LE for Mr Daniel Green
Councillor D Andrews commented that he was concerned that the conclusion of the 6 month time limit would be in the winter and queried whether deposits of clay material should be avoided during the winter.
Said18 Jul 2012Development Management Committee
E/12/0190/B - Unauthorised erection of an entrance gate to development at Crosier Place, St John Street, Hertford, SG14 1RX
Councillor D Andrews stated that, whilst he had some sympathy with the residents of Crosier Place, East Herts was an inclusive District where crime was low and detection rates were on the increase. He expressed concern that a gated development had been created on this site. He commented on whether rising bollards could be installed to avoid the current fortress-like appearance of the site.
Seconded11 Jul 2012Audit Committee
Appointment of Vice Chairman
It was moved by Councillor N Wilson and seconded by Councillor D Andrews, that Councillor W Mortimer be appointed Vice Chairman for the Civic Year 2012/13.
Named11 Jul 2012Audit Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor D Andrews was substituting for Councillor A Warman .
Asked11 Jul 2012Audit Committee
Update on Implementation of Annual Governance Statement Action Plan
Councillor D Andrews queried why there was not a supplementary link to the site to act as a backup in such circumstances. The Director of Internal Services stated that the company had explained why a second link could not be installed.
Named11 Jul 2012Audit Committee
Update on Implementation of Annual Governance Statement Action Plan
Councillor D Andrews referred to home workers and their reliance on IT. The Director of Internal Services confirmed that the telephone project had been given a high priority, as home workers could not work without telephones.
Said4 Jul 2012Council
Overview and Scrutiny Annual Report 2011-12
On behalf of the Scrutiny Chairmen, Councillor D Andrews thanked all Scrutiny Members for their contributions throughout the year. In particular, he thanked the Scrutiny Officer for her superb support.
Named4 Jul 2012Council
Investment Strategy
Councillor D Andrews referred to the informal investment board meetings and suggested that the Chairman of Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee should be invited to attend as an observer. The Executive Member had no objections to this suggestion and referred to the expertise that was available.
Said26 Jun 2012Environment Scrutiny Committee
Contract Performance Environmental Operations
Councillor D Andrews commented on whether Officers could update Members in respect of the current position regarding the treatment of weeds across East Herts. The Head of Environmental Services undertook to respond to this query after the meeting.
Said20 Jun 2012Development Management Committee
a) 3/12/0542/FP and b) 3/12/0543/LB - Single storey rear orangery extension at New Hall Farmhouse, Fanhams Hall Road, Wareside, SG12 7SD for Mr and Mrs Clayton
Councillor D Andrews stated that he would be prepared to support the application at this stage, particularly as there was the added protection of the referral to the Secretary of State. He commented that a refusal would perhaps be a little harsh and requested that Officers drill down on the specific concerns that lead to the recommendation for refusal.
Moved20 Jun 2012Development Management Committee
a) 3/12/0542/FP and b) 3/12/0543/LB - Single storey rear orangery extension at New Hall Farmhouse, Fanhams Hall Road, Wareside, SG12 7SD for Mr and Mrs Clayton
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor M Newman seconded, a motion that applications 3/12/0542/FP and 3/12/0543 be granted ... view the full minutes text for item 94.
Asked19 Jun 2012Health and Wellbeing Panel
Review of East Herts Public Health Strategy : 2011/12 Action Plan Year End Review
Councillor D Andrews queried the comparison of statistics relating to deaths from smoking with those from road accidents. The Environmental Health Promotion Officer undertook to review these figures.
Said29 May 2012Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee
Review of Comments, Compliments and Complaints April 2011 to March 2012
Councillor D Andrews stated that 62 complaints was a low figure and constituted excellent performance.
Said29 May 2012Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee
East Herts Communication Strategy 2012
Councillor D Andrews commented that the Members Information Bulletin would be reviewed as part of the strategy.
Said29 May 2012Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee
2011/12 End of Year Service Planning Report
Councillor D Andrews commented that the automated telephone system appeared to be working well.
Said29 May 2012Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee
2011/12 Performance Outturns
Councillor D Andrews stated that EHPI 181 – time taken to process Housing Benefit/Council Tax Benefit new claims and change events was also off target but only by a very narrow margin.
Moved23 May 2012Development Management Committee
Tree Preservation Order (TPO) – Resurvey of TPO Nos 49, 167, 171 And 345
Councillor D Andrews proposed and Councillor M Alexander seconded, a motion that tree ‘T4’ be excluded from TPO 569 at Saffron Meadow, Standon .
Seconded16 May 2012Council
Appointment of Vice-Chairman of the Council for the Civic Year 2012/13
It was moved by Councillor P Phillips and seconded by Councillor D Andrews that Councillor G McAndrew be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Council to hold office for the civic year 2012/13.
Asked7 Mar 2012Council
Members' questions
Question 1 Councillor D Andrews asked the Leader of the Council if he would join him in acknowledging the service done to local government by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government in having the foresight and the political courage to incorporate the abolition of the Standards Board for England in the Localism Act. A flawed Board that had been set up in the 1990s by new Labour and had proved to be ineffective, in fact, many thought a costly disaster and, far from the lofty aims of policing local government. It had instead, become a byword for witch hunts and ridiculous complaints to embarrass opponents, at no little cost to the Exchequer and at great cost to local democracy.
Named7 Mar 2012Council
Members' questions
Councillor D Andrews referred to a recent local report in which 20% of the current Council had been referred to the Standards Committee by a lone member of the public at a cost of several thousand pounds. He asked the Leader if he agreed that hard working Councillors would be relieved that they could get on with their work in making often difficult decisions for the greater good, without fear of being reported to the Standards Board by people who disagreed with them and local democracy.
Said6 Mar 2012Executive
Residents Survey 2010 Analysis and Action Plan
Councillor D Andrews, as the Chairman of that meeting, highlighted the enthusiasm of Members for further investigation into the choice based lettings scheme and giving greater emphasis on the awarding of points on a more local basis than the District level.
Named28 Feb 2012Community Scrutiny Committee
Health Engagement Panel
It was noted that Councillor G McAndrew had been in attendance at the meeting on 12 December 2011 and not Councillor D Andrews as shown in the minutes. The would be asked to amend the minutes as necessary at their next meeting.
Said28 Feb 2012Community Scrutiny Committee
Community Safety Review: Report of the Task and Finish Group addressing the issue of reassurance
Councillor D Andrews, the Chairman of the Task and Finish Group, stated that it was a question of continuing to work with partners to target decreasing resources at public reassurance to get the message across that East Herts was a safe place to live and work.
Named14 Feb 2012Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor G McAndrew and seconded by Councillor J Ranger that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named14 Feb 2012Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED – that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Said14 Feb 2012Scrutiny Committees
2011 Residents Survey Analysis and Action Plan
Councillor D Andrews commented that the survey seemed to indicate that some residents felt that the Authority was not doing enough to communicate with residents and publicise the Council’s functions across East Herts.
Named17 Jan 2012Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor D Hollebon and seconded by Councillor G McAndrew that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Named17 Jan 2012Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
RESOLVED - that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Said16 Jan 2012Highways Joint Member Panel
Section 106 Contributions
Councillor D Andrews stated that in relation to the GlaxoSmithKline monies, these were being held back because of the Asda development and the issues around Fanshawe Crescent and Park Road and residents concerns. He asked Officers to investigate the situation.
Named16 Jan 2012Highways Joint Member Panel
Section 106 Contributions
Officers referred to a previous briefing prepared for Councillor D Andrews and the need to have sufficient funds to design and implement schemes to ensure criteria placed on S106 monies was met . The Panel supported a meeting with Officers and the local member to discuss further.
Said22 Nov 2011Community Scrutiny Committee
Community Safety: A Focussed Review - Task and Finish Group Interim Report
Councillor D Andrews commented that Special Constables should not be seen as a replacement for PCSOs as they only worked about 4 hours in a given week, although they ... view the full minutes text for item 440.
Asked9 Nov 2011Development Management Committee
3/11/1421/FP - Erection of Marquee between March and August for events and hire at Bishop's Stortford Rugby Club, Silver Leys, Hadham Road, Bishop's Stortford, CM23 2QE for Bishop's Stortford Rugby Club
Councillor D Andrews sought and was given clarification that there would be no permanent foundations underneath the proposed marquee.
Named9 Nov 2011Development Management Committee
3/11/1421/FP - Erection of Marquee between March and August for events and hire at Bishop's Stortford Rugby Club, Silver Leys, Hadham Road, Bishop's Stortford, CM23 2QE for Bishop's Stortford Rugby Club
In response to a query from Councillor D Andrews, the Director stated that the conditions could be firmed up to state that any planning permission would be for a limited period only, expiring on 10 November 2012 and the marquee would be in place from 1 March to 31 August 2012.
Said9 Nov 2011Development Management Committee
P/11/0015/A - Unauthorised display of placard advertisements within the District of East Hertfordshire District Council
Councillor D Andrews praised the work of the Enforcement Team in tackling the problem of illegal signage across the District.
Said9 Nov 2011Development Management Committee
P/11/0015/A - Unauthorised display of placard advertisements within the District of East Hertfordshire District Council
Councillor Andrews stated that he was particularly frustrated by the signage that was attached to Highway furniture. He referred to such activity as an offence under the Highways Act 1980.
Named12 Oct 2011Development Management Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor D Andrews was in attendance as substitute for Councillor Demonti.
Said1 Aug 2011Highways Joint Member Panel
East Herts Parking Management
Councillor D Andrews said he had some concerns to raise on Location 16 and had already organised a meeting with Officers and requested to be kept abreast of developments at Location 20.
Named22 Jun 2011Development Management Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor D Andrews was in attendance as substitute for Councillor Burlton.
Seconded22 Jun 2011Development Management Committee
3/11/0674/FP - Erection of 14 dwellings with parking, landscaping and associated works at Western House Hospital, Collett Road, Ware for James McConnell, Bellway Homes
Councillor M Alexander proposed and Councillor D Andrews seconded a motion for an additional condition that, p rior to the commencement of the development, details of the emergency vehicle access onto Lime Close shall be submitted to and approved by the Local Planning Authority. The details submitted shall ensure no pedestrian access between the site and Lime Close.
Seconded22 Jun 2011Development Management Committee
3/11/0544/FP - Re-surfacing of existing car park at Grange Paddocks;
Councillor G Jones proposed and Councillor D Andrews seconded, a motion that application 3/11/0544/FP be deferred to enable further details to be submitted in relation to proposed lighting (including hours of operation), the route of the footpath and timescale for the provision of the temporary parking.
Said6 Jun 2011Highways Joint Member Panel
Petitions
Hertfordshire County Councillor D Andrews thanked the Petitioners for their hard work. He was horrified at the evidence submitted. A Member of the public said that she had written to the companies whose lorries were parked, stating the difficulties they caused but nothing had transpired.
Named6 Jun 2011Highways Joint Member Panel
Quarterly Progress Report
Hertfordshire County Councillor D Andrews was advised that the lamp column replacements had been tested for their integrity. It was noted that a programme to introduce part night lighting at certain locations across Hertfordshire was now being implemented.
Asked6 Jun 2011Highways Joint Member Panel
Integrated Works Programme / Forward Works Programme
Hertfordshire County Councillor D Andrews asked Officers to confirm whether Great Amwell was within his Division.
Named9 Mar 2011Development Management Committee
Chairman's Announcements
The Chairman thanked Councillor D Andrews for standing in as a substitute Member for this meeting.
Declared9 Mar 2011Development Management Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor D Andrews declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application 3/10/2047/FP in that he worked within the Sainsbury’s group. He left the room whilst this matter was considered.
Declared9 Mar 2011Development Management Committee
Declarations of Interest
Councillor Andrews declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application 3/10/1295/FN in that he was a governor of Richard Hale School. He left the room whilst this matter was considered.
Named15 Feb 2011Scrutiny Committees
Appointment of Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor C Woodward and seconded by Councillor D L E Hollebon that Councillor D Andrews be appointed Chairman for the meeting.
Showing the latest 300 of 306.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.