Motion to promote ethical solar power in our district
Councillor E Buckmaster proposed the following amendment:
Every time East Hertfordshire's minutes name Councillor Buckmaster, as the council published it.
Councillor E Buckmaster proposed the following amendment:
Councillor E Buckmaster acknowledged the flexibility that was being introduced. He said that many Members dealt with parking and highways on a daily basis and he expressed wariness about introducing resident parking zones.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred in particular to urban areas close to transport hubs or sports clubs and the issue of how an RPZ would impact on a wider area and move a problem elsewhere.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that he wanted to clarify what it was that the committee would be considering in respect of Local Government Reform (LGR). He referred to how the council would deal with assets.
Councillor E Buckmaster emphasised the importance of understanding what was important to members and residents.
Councillor Jacobs said that LGR scrutiny proposal forms were submitted from Councillor E Buckmaster, and Councillor McAndrew, and that these forms had been circulated to the committee for comments.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that, in respect of sustainable transport, a cross-party working group had just started in respect of the local transport plan which would include elements of sustainable transport.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that he was a Member of the Chief Recruitment Committee, which had seen excellent candidates. He said he was happy to approve the appointment.
Councillor E Buckmaster felt that the report needed more clarification such as a reference to the potential future as a unitary authority. He also said that stakeholders were mentioned but it did not reference elected members and democratic processes.
Councillor E Buckmaster asked about the rights of members.
Councillor E Buckmaster thanked the parking team who were responsive and had come out to help with parking issues.
Councillor E Buckmaster asked for clarification to the changes in the Annual Report, and he asked for some of the important examples.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he understood why the scheme was being updated but questioned whether this would be easily understood by residents. He asked if there was a way of making sure people understood the implications of the changes.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that this was an important document. He said that East Herts geographically covered a third of the whole county and this was a good framework to look at planning policies from this.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he was on the previous panel and felt this was the best way to go about developing the District Plan.
Councillor E Buckmaster queried the predominant industry in Buntingford of construction and motor trade and asked if this was a factor to why there was so much house building there.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he agreed with Councillor Crystall about ending up with a proposal that served residents best.
Councillor E Buckmaster said these partnerships with Outside Bodies were really important. He referred to page 189 which had an error. The Health Scrutiny Hertford should read Health Scrutiny Hertfordshire.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that it sounded like Ernst & Young had been standing back throughout the process but was pleased to have the assurance that the recommendations were underway.
Councillor E Buckmaster said it was good for those who would qualify for the scheme. He also said that there was a retrofit guide for those who could afford to retrofit their homes.
Councillor E Buckmaster declared an interest as a Member of Sawbridgeworth Town Council, which was a beneficiary of the UKSPF.
The Chair said that there was an error in the report in that the application had been called in by Councillor Angus Parsad-Wyatt, and not by Councillor Eric Buckmaster as stated in the report.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that there was an error under minute number 109 – Local Government Funding. He said that the £6.2 billion funding gap was a national figure and not related to Hertfordshire County Council.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that the original recommendation to the Chief Officer Recruitment Committee suggested making the appointment for 18 months. He said that the committee agreed to amend to up to 18 months to ensure that the recruitment process was done as soon as possible.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that the Sawbridgeworth warding arrangements was an officer suggestion and said that Sawbridgeworth was a tight, urban area with a cohesive community. He said that the only benefit would be a shorter count. He said the community feeling was the most important consideration.
Councillor E Buckmaster said it was common practice to delegate authority to officers.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he supported the original motion. He said as a former Executive member, the council had provided £30 million to get funding out to community groups and small business. He said he was shocked by the move by the Labour government to remove the winter fuel allowance and said they had blamed it on difficult decisions.
It was noted that Councillor E Buckmaster and Jordan Morris abstained from the vote.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that he had read the minutes from the Panel’s previous meeting, and the revised policy. He said that as the portfolio holder for the previous administration he understood the importance of volunteers for BEAM, and the fine line between a volunteer and an employee. He asked if more tweaks to the policy would be made as the new facility opened.
Councillor E Buckmaster asked how casual workers were differentiated from volunteers.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that it was good to have a common approach across Hertfordshire and referred to the pledges in the Charter and said the council were already doing these.
Councillor E Buckmaster said it was appropriate to support the motion and said the financial challenge was even more difficult at the county council. He said that nationally, there was a £6.2 billion funding gap in social care.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to Item 5 and declared that he was the Chairman of the Hertfordshire Waste Partnership and cabinet member for the waste disposal authority.
Councillor E Buckmaster spoke on behalf of the Herts Waste Partnership and said that they felt three weekly collections were the way to go and there was enough ... view the full minutes text for item 77.
Councillor E Buckmaster highlighted that the engagement with officers and Members was excellent in terms of the Member Enquiry system. He said he understood the intentions of the report but thought that it was difficult for the council to brand itself as listening as decisions had to be made and the council could not please all residents. He added that residents and parish councils had told him that they felt engagement was worse now than under the previous administration.
Councillor E Buckmaster responded and said that he had heard the complaint many times and residents and parishes were not getting responses in a timely fashion.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he could not see any risk to this and wanted to acknowledge the efforts by Councillor Hopewell to move this project forward.
Councillor E Buckmaster felt that the plan was something to be vigilant about as conditions could change over the next 20 years and there could be challenges around infrastructure delivery. He said that the delivery of infrastructure was so important so the plan should be looked at closely.
Councillor Deering echoed the comments of Councillor E Buckmaster and said the Conservative group were supportive of the principle.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that it was good to see an update to this plan. He said that health and wellbeing was a broad subject and there was a balance to be struck over the role of the council. He said that there should be a strong emphasis on activity fitness, culture, the arts and planning who all have a role to play.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he felt that there needed to be a common branding of initiatives across local authorities, for example East Herts Council and Hertfordshire County Council had different tag lines for air quality.
Question 2, Councillor E Buckmaster supplementary question.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he first joined the Council in 2010 as an independent member alongside four others and he said that they formed an independent group. He said it was possible but up to the individual members.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he understood what Councillor Dunlop was saying but the decision had been made to form ... view the full minutes text for item 261.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that Bengeo Rural should be listed to complete the tax base.
Councillor E Buckmaster felt this was a political motion and said it was often raised by the Liberal Democrat party who failed to breakthrough in national polls. He said there were many countries with proportional representation (PR) but said they were not all good examples of decision making and it often led to the rise of right and left populist parties. He said it had been evident in the last local elections that residents were voting for specific candidates as they received more votes than the block party vote.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that the call for sites process would be crucial as previous mistakes had been made which had angered residents. He said that some urban expansions had caused issues in areas where residents warned it would happen and were now complaining that were not listened too. He said the review would be an opportunity for Members to ensure that the right developments were built in the right place because as the process continued, the options for Members narrowed considerably after statutory and legal requirements were met.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that would put into question the call for sites and questioned whether residents would understand the methodology.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that he had not heard a time frame for the process for the new scheme that the administration kept referring to. He asked for reassurance that if there was to be a pause, what the next steps were.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he was happy to support the motion and said that in his role as a County Councillor, he was involved in starting up the Local Nature Recovery Partnership which had Members on different steering groups and representatives from the Environment Agency and from each Council. He said he also chaired the Hertfordshire Climate Change Sustainability Partnership and said there was a lot of work ongoing in this area.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he was happy to support the motion.
It was proposed by Councillor E Buckmaster and seconded by Councillor Andrews that Councillor Boylan be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2023/24 civic year.
Councillor E Buckmaster asked for some clarity around the customer service functions in terms of the preferred approach that had been considered by the working group. He said that he understood the benefits of the preferred approach in terms of management alignment but that each council would function separately in some areas.
Councillor R Buckmaster said that for the purposes of transparency, she needed to declare that her husband, Councillor E Buckmaster, would be addressing the Development Management Committee as a local ward Member. She said that this had no bearing on her role as a Member of the Committee and she had come to the meeting to determine the application with an open mind.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that in spite of difficult economic circumstances, the council had completed and opened Grange Paddocks which now saw membership above pre-pandemic levels and the 3G pitch. The council’s leisure centres had exceeded the 1.1 million visits targeted in the original business plan. He said that Hartham Leisure Centre was due to open late in the summer.
Councillor R Buckmaster said that for the purposes of transparency, she needed to declare that her husband, Councillor E Buckmaster, would be addressing the Development Management Committee as a local ward Member. She said that this had no bearing on her role as a Member of the Committee and she had come to the meeting to determine the application with an open mind.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that he was present solely in his capacity as a Member for Hunsdon ward which included the proposed development areas to represent the interests of the people living in those areas and the wider community. He said that he had not shared anything of what he was going to say with any Member of the Committee.
Councillor R Buckmaster declared she had no knowledge of the email Councillor E Buckmaster had sent to the Development Management Committee before it was sent out.
Councillor Haysey proposed, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 14 December 2022 be approved as a correct record and be signed by the Chairman, subject to the amendments raised by Councillor Curtis. On being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he was happy to support the recommendations and said that the Cultural Strategy was really important and some of the funding would go towards carrying out asset mapping across the district to find out what activities were already taking place. He also said that the Climate Change strategy was important and said the projects were admirable things to support.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that he could not agree with the amendment and understood the substantial work that Officers and Members have when representations come in late.
Councillor L Haysey proposed, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 16 November 2022 be approved as a correct record and be signed by the Chairman.
Councillor E Buckmaster seconded the proposal.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that this was another great Neighbourhood Plan for the ward and thanked all those involved for their hard work in producing it.
Councillor E Buckmaster said there would be an educational element around the project. He said that a bin composition analysis had been undertaken across the county and it had found that 25-30% of waste in residual bins was food related. He said if the public disposed of waste correctly, it would mean less would be going into the black bins.
Councillor Williamson and Councillor E Buckmaster declared an interest in item 4 as they both sat on the Old River Lane Delivery Board so would not comment or vote on the item.
The Executive Member for Wellbeing, Councillor Eric Buckmaster introduced the operational report which detailed the current leisure contract awarded to Everyone Active in January 2020. He said that the report covered performance since the start of the contract, and therefore included the challenging times when the Covid pandemic caused the closure of facilities.
The Chairman said that a point had been made by Councillor E Buckmaster at LJP in respect of forced marriages.
Councillor E Buckmaster said that he was puzzled by Councillor Goldspink’s comments.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he knew Sir David Amess MP as a child and attended the same schools and he stood out at primary school. He said that much could be said about how he set an example for those following him. He said that the attack could not undermine the democratic principles of the UK.
Councillor E Buckmaster seconded the recommendation.
Councillor E Buckmaster wanted to show his appreciation for the local community group that assisted in the development of the plan.
Councillor E Buckmaster seconded the recommendations and reserved his right to speak.
c) Which Bishop’s Stortford arts organisations the Strategy team are now in contact with” Councillor E Buckmaster responded as follows:
While much of the responsibility of Child Mental Health commissioning rests with HCC, what help or support networks are available from East Hertfordshire District Council to help protect the mental health of our future generations?” Councillor E Buckmaster responded as follows:
Councillor E Buckmaster said that an amendment was not necessary as the LGBTQ community were referred to heavily in the document. He said that the strategy will be inclusive for everyone.
Could the Executive Member for Wellbeing please explain the role of our East Herts Environmental Health team, and describe any particular challenges they may have faced?” Councillor E Buckmaster responded as follows:
Councillor E Buckmaster seconded the proposal.
Councillor E Buckmaster seconded the motion. He said he had worked closely with the Neighbourhood Planning group on this matter, and was delighted it was proceeding.
Councillor E Buckmaster, the Executive Member for Wellbeing submitted a report on a review of the Street Trading Consent Policy.
Councillor E Buckmaster agreed to this correction.
Councillor E Buckmaster, Executive Member for Wellbeing, gave a verbal update on the development of Hartham Leisure.
Councillor E Buckmaster, Executive Member for Wellbeing, introduced the report. He stated that the strategy was designed to address nine identified health challenges as listed in paragraph 2.3 of the report. Appendix A illustrated that East Herts outcomes were better than those for England as a whole, and for the rest of Hertfordshire in relation to 11 of 32 health indicators measured; whilst Appendix B outlined the progress made in relation to each of the health challenges.
Councillor Haysey proposed, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 11 February 2020 be approved as a correct record. The motion being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, it was declared CARRIED. RESOLVED – that the Minutes of the meeting held on 11 February 2020 be approved as a correct record, and signed by the Leader.
She invited Councillor E Buckmaster to speak.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he wished to speak both as the Ward Member for the area, and the Executive Member for Wellbeing. He had been involved in a group which had helped to develop the SPD . He referred to the key words in the report regarding adopting the SPD , through a comprehensive and consistent manner.
In response to a question from Councillor Beckett, Councillor E Buckmaster said this was a matter of process, as irrecoverable debt could not, by its very nature, be recovered. As long as the process was robust, he had no objection to the authorisation limit being increased to £25K.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he understood some of the points Councillor Page had raised. However these were changing times, and adjustments to process were necessary. Council itself had the ultimate scrutiny role, however, and Members had the opportunity to ask questions and debate this report now.
Councillor E Buckmaster presented a report on the Planning Obligations for Open Space, Sport and Recreation Supplementary Planning Document (SPD). He thanked the Leader and the Executive Member for Planning and Growth for the opportunity to do so.
Councillor E Buckmaster seconded the motion. A recorded vote was taken, the result being:
Councillor E Buckmaster said that consistency was very important and referred to standardised voicemail messages as an example.
Councillor E Buckmaster seconded the motion.
Councillor E Buckmaster said these were worthy objectives, but did not necessarily need to be included in the Corporate Plan, as that document did not go into detail. Most of the District’s open spaces included such green areas, and the strategic Masterplan for Harlow and Gilston Garden Town would look at the whole site and see where such spaces should be sited.
Councillor E Buckmaster said the East Hertfordshire Year of Culture 2020 had been launched at Hertford Theatre. Many organisations had attended the event and shared initial ideas. The programme would feature different activities each month, and he asked all Members to encourage organisations in their areas to participate by registering.
Councillor E Buckmaster confirmed the programme would provide opportunities for social prescribing.
Councillor L Haysey proposed, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the recommendations, as detailed below, be approved.
Councillor E Buckmaster agreed that the principles and objectives would ensure a consistent approach. The focus was on community cohesion, environmental sustainability and community wellbeing. The guidelines could be adapted as necessary.
She moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the recommendations now detailed, be supported. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED. RECOMMENDED – that the Stewardship objectives and principles, relating to development proposals coming forward as part of the Harlow and Gilston Garden Town, be endorsed.
Councillor E Buckmaster said the Memorandum of Understanding empowered the authorities to work collectively. Each authority would retain its current powers.
Councillor D Hollebon asked the Executive Member for Wellbeing: “How do you intend to build on the successes of the Community and Wellbeing Forum?” Councillor E Buckmaster explained the purpose of the Community Wellbeing Forum. Public engagement had been discussed by the Executive Members recently, and it had been clear that m any of the Council's members already worked extremely hard to engage with communities. Much of this work took place outside the formal meetings of the Council, through organisations and clubs across the District, many of which aimed to support the most vulnerable.
Councillor G Williamson proposed, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the minutes of the meeting held on 3 September 2019 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Leader. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED. RESOLVED – that the Minutes of the meeting of the Executive held on 3 September 2019 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Leader.
Councillor L Haysey proposed, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion to support the recommendation detailed in the report. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster submitted a report for noting on a contract procedure exemption in respect of the leisure centre site at Grange Paddocks. He explained that due to time constraints due process had been conducted by obtaining five quotations and that there was a saving from procuring specialist services rather than being undertaken through the Pre-construction Service Agreement.
Councillor E Buckmaster proposed, and Councillor L Haysey seconded a motion to support the recommendation. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor J Goodeve proposed, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion to support the recommendations detailed. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster submitted a report to conclude the re-procurement of the leisure operating contract and agree the award for the operation of Hartham and Grange Paddocks leisure centres and Ward Freman pool & gym, for the period 1 January 2020 to 31 December 2034 (fifteen years), with the ability to extend for a further five years. The report also sought agreement of the award for the operation of Leventhorpe Pool & Gym and Fanshawe Pool & Gym for the period 1 January 2020 to 31 December 2024 (five years).
Councillor E Buckmaster proposed, and Councillor G Williamson seconded, a motion to support the recommendations detailed in the reports. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
In respect of Minute XX – Grounds Maintenance Contract, Councillor E Buckmaster declared an interest in relation to the contract for verges maintenance with Hertfordshire County Council, in that he was the HCC Deputy Executive Member for Highways and the Environment.
Councillor E Buckmaster said he welcomed the package of measures, which were important in keeping the District in shape and which encouraged residents’ wellbeing during challenging financial times. He thanked Officers for their work on this report. He congratulated Officers on the parks events held during the Summer and on the regular achievement of “green flag” ratings for Southern and the Ridgeway.
Councillor G McAndrew moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the recommendations now detailed be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED. The Executive approved the recommendations now detailed.
Councillor L Haysey moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the recommendations now detailed be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED. The Executive approved the recommendations now detailed.
Councillor E Buckmaster submitted a report seeking approval for additional funding for the completion of the leisure centre projects. He explained the reasons for the request were that inflation had risen more than the forecast;
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to external sites such as drop box and Facebook and queried whether this included “The Cloud” and referred to instances where he would occasionally cut and paste information for dissemination purposes. The Head of HR confirmed that the Policy implied that it referred to any external site and that the best advice would be to contact IT before using.
Councillor E Buckmaster queried if this applied to extracts from files rather than a whole file, the Head of HR said he would get this clarified and amend the policy accordingly in relation to clause 6.5 by the ICT Strategic Partnership Manager.
Councillor E Buckmaster said the site promoters would present their own IDP in their applications, which would capture specific elements, but that this document was a framework for the whole area. There was a high level of interest from the parishes involved, as ongoing stewardship as a principle which should include community ownership.
Councillor J Kaye moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the joint meeting held on 16 May 2018 be approved as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster asked whether the wording of the Constitution was to be changed at tonight’s meeting. The Head of Legal and Democratic Services advised that the Constitution would be amended to reflect the additional recommendation.
Councillor L Haysey proposed the recommendations, which were seconded by Councillor E Buckmaster. Council approved the recommendations as set out in the report and in the supplementary report.
Councillor E Buckmaster raised a point of order that the Minutes of Committee meetings were to be received only. The content of those Minutes was not for debate at meetings of the Council. The Chairman noted that the Head of Human Resources and Organisational Development would respond outside the meeting to any written queries.
Councillor E Buckmaster said Members had undertaken visits to art theatres around the country in order to assess what worked well. They had found that increasing such provision could multiply the benefits to the local economy and that it was important that high streets and town centres should adapt to survive.
Rather than deferring the Old River Lane development, Councillor E Buckmaster invited Members to agree it should be progressed.
Councillor E Buckmaster explained that he had attended the award ceremony at Portcullis House that morning (with other Members) and that Richard Hale School had also been nominated. He said that he was immensely proud of Mandeville School’s award adding that Richard Hale School were awarded runners up. The Executive Member said that it was a great accolade to East Herts.
Councillor E Buckmaster drew Members’ attention to a ministerial report regarding the future of town centres and the need to strike the right balance between retail and a range of other activities, such as art, culture and leisure. He added that this was a good opportunity to make a great leap forward and make sure that residents also had access to arts and culture in the district.
Councillor C Woodward welcomed the ambitious proposal and the comments made by Councillor E Buckmaster and the need to have a healthy retail development sector.
Councillor E Buckmaster confirmed that he had been approached by people who had raised the proliferation of these advertising boards as a matter of concern to them. The matter had been raised with the County Council and the boards had subsequently been removed.
Councillor G Williamson proposed and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion to support the recommendations now detailed. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to a paper from a parliamentary select committee. He summarised a number of the findings in relation to town centres and referred to a shift that was taking place, whereby there were less financial transactions and more social interactions.
Councillor E Buckmaster moved, and Councillor S Rutland-Barsby seconded a motion, to approve the Minutes of the previous meeting as a correct record. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster welcomed the document adding that he would ensure that he would circulate the document within his ward. The Leader asked the Head of Communications, Strategy and Policy to publicise the document.
Councillor E Buckmaster moved, and Councillor A Alder seconded, a motion that the recommendations now detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster, the Panel was advised that flexi time was available to all, with the exception of the Leadership Team.
It was proposed by Councillor E Buckmaster and seconded by [name removed] that Human Resources Committee be advised that Local Joint Panel supports the revised appeals policy.
Councillor G Jones moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the recommendation now detailed be supported. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor S Rutland-Barsby moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the recommendation now detailed be supported. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
He moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the recommendations, as now detailed in the report submitted, be approved. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
The Leader moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, the recommendation now detailed. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the recommendation was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster commented on his experience of the process which he found to be very constructive and commended it to other Members, where such frameworks would be coming forward.
Councillor E Buckmaster moved, and Councillor A Alder seconded, a motion that the recommendation now detailed be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to the comments of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee and how these had been taken on board.
Councillor E Buckmaster moved, and Councillor L Haysey seconded, a motion that the recommendations now detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor S Rutland-Barsby moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the recommendations now detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster supported the view of encapsulating all policies under one document. He stated that, in his view, the purpose of the LJP was for all Panel Members to achieve ... view the full minutes text for item 4a
Councillor G Williamson moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded a motion that the recommendations as printed in the report now submitted, be approved.
· Update from Executive Member for Economic Development · Corporate Service Plans 2018/19 · Draft Health and Wellbeing Strategy 2018 – 2023 · Planning Enforcement Update · Grounds Maintenance Contract Task and Finish Group Update · Update from the Leader of the Council · Presentation on Council Tax Support 2019-20 · Night Time Economy and Public Health: Impact of Alcohol Use · Climate Change: Update from the Task and Finish Group · Community Governance Review: Bishop’s Stortford · Community Governance Review: Buntingford · Community Governance Review: Eastwick and Gilston · Scrutiny Work Programme 2018/19 Councillor G Jones moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the reports be received. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster commented on the reference to a £90k underspend on capital community grants and suggested that this was a timing issue and that the budget had been spent.
Councillor R Brunton moved, and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the request be accepted and a review be undertaken as detailed in the report submitted. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
She was surprised, indeed shocked, to learn that the members of the Council’s Executive, including Councillor Buckmaster were willing to contemplate the closure of Fanshawe Swimming Pool.
Since his appointment as Executive Member for Health and Wellbeing, Councillor Buckmaster had been proactive in all matters relating to the health and physical and mental wellbeing of our residents. We hear of postcode lottery in relation to some services provided by the National Health Service, but this would be postcode lottery on fitness in East Hertfordshire. If you lived in some of our towns you will continue to be encouraged to keep fit in this extremely valuable way.
It was moved by Councillor G McAndrew and seconded by Councillor E Buckmaster that [name removed] (UNISON) be appointed as Chairman for the civic year 2017/18. After being put to the meeting [name removed] was appointed Chairman of the Local Joint Panel for the civic year 2017/18.
It was moved by Councillor E Buckmaster and seconded by Councillor G McAndrew that Councillor L Radford be appointed Vice Chairman for the civic year 2017/18.
Councillor E Buckmaster acknowledged the concerns of residents and referred to his expectations regarding one of the largest areas included in the draft District Plan.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to the Council’s ongoing work on developing a Leisure Strategy, reviewing its facilities and working with partners to ensure an emphasis on health and wellbeing and to tackle health inequality.
It was moved by Councillor A Jackson and seconded by A Stevenson (UNISON) that Councillor E Buckmaster be appointed as Chairman for the civic year 2016/17.
After being put to the meeting Councillor E Buckmaster was appointed Chairman of the Local Joint Panel for the civic year 2016/17.
RESOLVED – that Councillor E Buckmaster and [name removed] be appointed Chairman and Vice Chairman respectively for the civic year 2016/17.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to paragraph 3.2 of the report as detailed and was pleased to see that the report acknowledged that different symptoms might manifest themselves to be wholly unconnected with substance misuse. He asked that the report provide further clarification on this, especially for example, that it might be as a result of a mental health issue. This was supported.
In response to a query by Councillor E Buckmaster, the Secretary to the Employer’s Side explained how the process worked within the shared services arrangement.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding proposed payments of £5,000 to the Section 151 Officer, the Monitoring Officer and Head of Paid Service, the Secretary to the Employer’s Side explained that was a reduction in the current payments made and was being proposed following market research and information received from Epaycheck, a public sector pay comparator, as detailed and an East of England Local Government Association (EELGA) survey.
In response to a question from Councillor E Buckmaster, the Secretary to the Employer’s Side explained that there would be corresponding changes to PDRs by those posts affected.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding “salary sacrifice”, the Secretary to the Employer’s Side explained that if this progressed, this would be presented to the Local Joint Panel for Members’ consideration. The Panel Chairman reiterated UNISON’s support of the Green Travel Plan, including the introduction of a pool car as part of sustainable travel arrangements.
Following an observation from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding the District Plan preferred options, the Panel was advised that Peter Brett Associates had suggested that it would be inappropriate to leave questions on infrastructure delivery to future Development Plan Documents. The Council would need to decide how to approach this issue in due course.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding staff who needed support in filling their roles, the Secretary to the Employer’s Side explained that the process was robust. She explained how the PDR Stage One identified needs and that Stage Two ensured that there was a link between staff performance and learning and development.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding employees who acted up in more senior positions, the Secretary to the Employer’s Side explained that such staff were remunerated. The Panel Chairman referred to his civil engineering qualifications studied over a six year period, made possible by the Professional Career Vocational Study Policy and thanked the Council for making this possible. The Panel recommended to Human Resources Committee, approval of the revised Professional Career and Vocational Study Policy as submitted and that a corporate approach to recognise staff successes be developed.
Councillor E Buckmaster suggested that the recommendation also be amended to reflect a position that the Council was working to support a totally smoke-free environment by 1 January 2017, which would give Officers an opportunity to address areas of concern. This was supported.
The Manager, Housing Services advised that quarterly meetings were held with both housing associations and that all Councillors were invited to attend (with the meetings chaired by Councillor Buckmaster).
It was moved by Councillor E Buckmaster and seconded by Councillor G Cutting that Councillor A Jackson be appointed Vice Chairman for the civic year 2015/16.
Question 5 Councillor E Buckmaster asked the Executive ... view the full minutes text for item 568.
· Health and Wellbeing related projects which the CAB supported · Training and quality · Statistical information in relation to clients with particular disabilities / health status · Mental health statistics · Addressing unhelpful behaviours · Signposts and referrals · Areas of good practice In response to a question from Councillor E Buckmaster, regarding benefits and the role of Revenues and Benefits in identifying who might benefit from debt advice, [name removed] explained that the CAS worked closely with Circle Anglia and Riversmead. [name removed] stated that a client’s debts could not be looked at in isolation but that priority would always be given to resolving high priority debts which could affect an individual’s liberty and home. She stated that the CAS was non-judgemental and rather than recommending that an individual to take a course of action they would “signpost.” [name removed] referred to the number of clients with disabilities and long term illness who statistically had more benefits and tax credit issues that many others.
Councillor E Buckmaster commented on the need to give feedback to the towns in anticipation that the information provided would empower them to empower others.
The Chairman suggested that the Member take the matter up with l Health Watch Councillor E Buckmaster felt that real progress had been made by including health and wellbeing issues in all service plans and inviting Heads of Service to discuss their plans in this area. The Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services referred to the strategic contribution that the Health and Wellbeing Panel had made as a result of its debate which he said, had raised the Council’s game in the area of public health, developing ideas, relationships and networks which had all contributed to the Health and Wellbeing Action Plan.
Councillor E Buckmaster commented on whether there was a critical mass that needed to be achieved to make the tariff switching project worthwhile. Members were advised that t he framework was owned by the Local Government Association but the procurement service was run by the North East Procurement Organisation and utilised a switching service operated by a company called iChoosr .
Councillor Buckmaster commented that it was down to Members to utilise their contacts with residents in their respective District wards.
Councillor E Buckmaster sought clarification in relation to the frequency of Anti-Social Behaviour Action Group (ASBAG) meetings. The Director of Neighbourhood Services confirmed that these would be held at six-weekly intervals.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to resource implications adding that the Council might be asked to take on a role because another provider might be failing in their task. He stated that there was a need to partner with other organisations as much as possible.
Councillor E Buckmaster queried whether enhancements to Sawbridgeworth would be progressing. The Head of Environmental Services explained that appropriate funding needed to be identified and that further discussions with the Town Council needed to take place.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding working with schools and Hertfordshire County Council to ensure the long term financial sustainability of joint use pools, the Head of Environmental Services explained that on-going discussions were taking place with two schools, both of which were uncertain about government funding regimes and that options for the future sustainability of leisure centres were being explored.
Councillor E Buckmaster asked what the situation would be if limited or no mitigation measures could be identified. Officers replied that this was a difficult question in light of the initial advice from PBA and all possible solutions would be carefully investigated. Further advice would be sought from PBA.
Councillor E Buckmaster stated how privileged residents were that East Herts had the facilities it had and referred to the problems of urban areas and food outlets and how this impacted on health. He queried whether it was possible for the cumulative effects of issues to be taken into account when decisions needed to be taken by Members. The Head of Community Safety and Health explained that licensing could only make decisions within a legislative and policy framework and that any cumulative factors needed to be evidence based.
It was moved by Councillor E Bedford and seconded by Councillor E Buckmaster that Councillor M McMullen be appointed Vice–Chairman of the Licensing Committee for the 2014/15 civic year.
It was moved by Councillor P Moore and seconded by Councillor P Ballam, that Councillor E Buckmaster be appointed Vice–Chairman of the Health and Wellbeing Panel for the 2014/15 civic year.
RESOLVED – that Councillor E Buckmaster be appointed Vice–Chairman of the Health and Wellbeing Panel for the 2014/15 civic year.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding links to other organisations providing a carers service, [name removed] confirmed that had a variety of links with other organisations to ensure that the right kind of support could be given at the appropriate time.
Councillor E Buckmaster stated that there were a lot of similarities between St Albans’ public health initiatives and those of East Herts. The Environmental Health Promotion Officer said that he and his counterpart at St Albans had met a number of times and hoped that they could both learn from each others’ practices. In response to a query regarding comparative specific policies or actions, the Executive Member for Health, Housing and Community Support commented that St Albans carried out more Task and Finish groups and brought in more partners for discussion on a particular plan or action.
It was moved by Councillor R Beeching and seconded by Councillor E Buckmaster that Councillor C Rowley be appointed Vice–Chairman of Environment Scrutiny Committee for the 2014/15 civic year.
Councillor E Buckmaster congratulated Officers on the report and the positive results achieved. He queried what had been done to ensure the public knew what they could and could not recycle, especially in respect of the changes to soft plastics. The Head of Environmental Services outlined what steps had been taken to create public awareness including placing “stickers” on the blue lidded bins.
Councillor E Buckmaster commented that he was sure that Sawbridgeworth Town Council would cover the costs of the grass cut once a year.
Councillor E Buckmaster suggested two initiatives in Sawbridgeworth, which would benefit from improvement; The Green and the toilet blocks.
Councillor E Buckmaster and J Wing also paid their tributes.
Councillor E Buckmaster believed that Nigel exemplified the best of being a community councillor.
It was moved by Councillor K Crofton and seconded by Councillor E Buckmaster that Councillor R Beeching be elected Chairman of the Council to hold office for the civic year 2014/15.
Councillor E Buckmaster, as a local ward Member, referred to the debatable designation of this structure as a residential annexe. He stated that he felt that this application should be refused. He referred to the frustration of local residents with this application and he commented that, should residential use of the annexe become permanent, then full planning permission should be applied.
Councillor E Buckmaster agreed that direct debit collections needed more rigorous regulation and he referred to the need to engage with the PFRA on this issue.
Councillor E Buckmaster provided an oral report on the ongoing work of Hertfordshire Health Scrutiny Committee (HSC). He advised that he had attended a budget scrutiny meeting held over one and a half days and provided a summary of that meeting in terms of its format and outputs achieved.
Councillor E Buckmaster drew Members’ attention to a number of recommendations which had emerged from the meeting such as the need to prioritise mental health, the need to support the “Thriving Families” programme and closer partnership working to avoid duplication.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster, the Director of Finance and Support Services explained sources of Fees and Charges and Council Tax.
Councillor E Buckmaster stated that he would be disappointed to lose the arrangement completely.
Councillor N Symonds, the Chairman of the Health and Wellbeing Panel, stated that Councillor E Buckmaster had chaired the 15 October 2013 meeting of the Health and Wellbeing Panel. She provided a verbal update on the recent work of the Panel and advised Members that she had been a member of a Hertfordshire scrutiny group which had visited the Hertfordshire Ambulance Service call centre.
Councillor E Buckmaster suggested that the Council should seek within its CIL specification, whatever was necessary to fulfil the needs of any large scale future development. The Head of Planning and Building Control explained that the Council could not seek to fund the same infrastructure from both a CIL and Section 106 agreement, i.e. not for the same purposes. He further explained the difficulties associated with producing a District Plan up to the year 2031 including the difficulties faced with costing infrastructure needs so far into the future.
Councillor E Buckmaster supported the “dashboard” format but suggested that the word “value” be amended to “achieved”.
In the Chairman’s absence, it was noted that the Vice-Chairman, Councillor E Buckmaster , would be chairing the meeting.
Councillor E Buckmaster commented that the Food Hygiene and Houses in Multiple Occupation report had been included on the agenda as a result of a direct request from Members at the planning meeting noted in the last paragraph of the minutes of the previous meeting. It was noted that a Staff Wellbeing Day had been arranged for 17 October 2013 when a number of initiatives would be available to encourage wellbeing and monitor levels of fitness.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding the Council’s standing in terms of the number of houses in multiple occupation, the Environmental Health Manager (Residential) explained that this was usually affected by whether a town had a university as this would increase HMO demand. She explained that Bishop’s Stortford was affected because of its proximity to Stansted Airport.
Question 2 Councillor E Buckmaster commented that Public health delivery was currently going through many changes, and was under great pressure to make improvements. He asked whether the Executive Member for Health, Housing and Community Support could comment on the role of East Herts Council in the Public Health arena, and in particular, the part that we as individual Members can play in the process.
Councillor E Buckmaster complimented the Scrutiny Officer and stated that the report was very readable and should be shared with residents.
It was proposed by Councillor P Moore and seconded by Councillor S Bull, that Councillor E Buckmaster be appointed Vice Chairman for the 2013/14 Civic Year.
RESOLVED – that Councillor E Buckmaster be appointed Vice Chairman for the 2013/14 Civic Year.
Councillor E Buckmaster provided an update following a tour of the Princess Alexandra Hospital on 20 March 2013. Of particular concern, was the hospital’s need to find £17million in savings in order to achieve trust status.
Councillor E Buckmaster added that the availability of digital information was also a contributing factor.
Councillor J Wing echoed these comments and Councillor E Buckmaster congratulated her fundraising achievements.
It was moved by Councillor E Buckmaster and seconded by Councillor C Woodward that Councillor R Beeching be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Council to hold office for the civic year 2013/14.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster, the Licensing Manager commented that the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act did not apply to Taxi Drivers. Members were advised that the risk categories proposed by the Task and Finish Group focussed on the risk to the public rather than the severity of a taxi driver’s previous offences and subsequent convictions.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding bins which might have a built in compartment for paper, the Head of Environmental Services referred to a system in use by Welwyn Hatfield Council whereby the bins had basket insert for paper. He undertook to investigate this if Members wished. He informed Members that there were a range of options for the provision of these, from providing them ‘by default’ to every household with the new wheeled bin; making them available upon request free of charge or making them a chargeable option. ... view the full minutes text for item 614.
He asked that further thought be given to better signage on Council vehicles such as “Don’t drop litter – £80 Fine!” In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding premises owners being brought before a Licensing Sub – Committee if they failed to keep their area around their premises clean, the Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services undertook to write to the Member once he had clarified the position. He explained that the real issue was engaging with people to modify their behaviour, suggesting that there was also a need to work with schools on this issue.
Councillor E Buckmaster stated that it was a question of engaging with the wider area. [name removed] explained that there was a lot of information which was widely available, including surveys which had been undertaken and in schools, which helped provide a view of health and wellbeing of young people. He explained that there were opportunities to open up dialogue to probe further into the health of young people.
Councillor E Buckmaster stated that the Sawbridgeworth Bus No.2 Service would shortly be launched and would link with the CVS.
Councillor E Buckmaster moved, and Councillor M Wood seconded, a proposal that the complaints process include a best endeavours timeframe of three months for investigations to be reported back to Members. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, this proposal was CARRIED.
Councillor E Buckmaster commented on the low operational performance of the parking enforcement contract. The Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services explained some of the constraints the Authority was bound by in terms of parking enforcement. Members were advised that the £86,000 underspend had occurred as the mobile camera enforcement and vehicle removals policies had not yet gone into operation so had not incurred any operational costs this financial year.
In response to a comment from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding the savings from any extension to the contract, the Head of Environmental Services confirmed that there would be a reduction in the annual contract charge.
Councillor E Buckmaster stated that, in relation to Minute 187, Gambling Act 2005: Statement of Licensing Principles, it was Councillor N Poulton who had seconded the motion regarding the wording in respect of Casinos on page 74 of the report.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster, regarding a review of licences, the Licensing Manager advised that the Council, acting as a responsible authority, could seek a review of a licence following noise complaints.
Councillor E Buckmaster explained that there was a need to continue to give good service and move towards reducing the level of subsidy that the Council now provided in terms of fees and charges. The Committee agreed that the proposed increase of fees and charges be supported for progression through the budget process.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding the two recent planning applications for doctor’s surgeries in Bishop’s Stortford and the lack of a “joined up” approach, [name removed] stated that primary care was covered by the Commissioning Board and the Care Commissioning Groups ( CCGs ) were expected to support the work of the Commissioning Board. [name removed] emphasised the difficulties experienced in respect of securing new premises for doctors’ surgeries.
Councillor J Wing referred to [name removed] even-handed advice and Councillor E Buckmaster spoke of the help he had given to newer Members.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster, [name removed] confirmed that the “Green Deal” was non-profit making and clarified its role and the Council’s role in the process of furthering the initiative.
Councillor Buckmaster expressed the need to ensure safeguards were in place to prevent exploitation of vulnerable households.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster concerning value for money, the Head of Environmental Services confirmed that the contract included a price escalation clause which was aligned to the retail price index.
Councillor J Taylor proposed and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded, a motion that the wording in respect of Casinos on page 74 of the report now submitted be deleted from the Statement of Licensing Principles.
In response to a comment from Councillor E Buckmaster, the Interim Licensing Manager confirmed that the existing garage in Bishop’s Stortford and the new garage had been in discussions regarding the current situation.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to the need to emphasise community engagement. In respect of social media tools, it was important for users to be clear as to whether they were expressing policy or opinion. Finally, he suggested the need to measure response rates as a key influencer.
In response to a question by Councillor E Buckmaster , the Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services advised that the Urban Transport Study had been delayed and was not expected to be concluded before the Autumn 2012.
In response to a question from Councillor E Buckmaster , the Chief Executive and Director of Customer and Community Services explained the leisure contract subsidy arrangements.
Councillor E Buckmaster emphasised the importance of reaching the right people with this campaign to avoid inadvertently upsetting residents who already recycled as much as they could under current arrangements.
Councillor E Buckmaster commented on the order of the statements and wondered whether the last statement on economic vitality should appear at the top of the list. He also suggested strengthening one or two, by for example, including reference to reducing traffic congestion and air pollution. Finally, he commented that cooperation with other bodies on transport strategies should be included.
Councillor E Buckmaster thanked the Leader and spoke of the past year as a rewarding experience.
Councillor E Buckmaster declared a personal interest in application 3/11/2156/FP, in that his son was a Member of the Sawbridgeworth Scouts Group.
Councillor E Buckmaster, as the local ward Member, stated that the future of the scouts in Sawbridgeworth was very much at risk. He referred to the very special circumstances that had been highlighted by the public speaker. He also stated that the concerns of the Officers centred around inappropriate development in the Green Belt and the proximity of the site to local residential dwellings.
Councillor Buckmaster commented that almost every church, pub, school and community hall was surrounded by residential dwellings and would experience many more comings and goings than a scout hut in this location. In reference to parking concerns, he believed that there was sufficient parking within two minutes of the site.
Councillor Buckmaster also stated that flooding would not be a problem as the building would be sufficiently high up within the site so would not be at risk. He referred to East Herts Local Plan Policy GBC3, which stipulated that development could be permitted on Green Belt land if development was for small scale facilities for outdoor sport and recreation.
Finally, Councillor Buckmaster commented that Councillor R Beeching had also written a letter in support of the application.
Councillor E Buckmaster queried what new initiatives’ SLM might be undertaking. [name removed] provided a summary.
In response to queries from Councillor E Buckmaster and T Herbert regarding the definition of affordable housing and its application, the Housing Services Manager explained the Council’s policy. The Housing Services Manager referred to the District’s high levels of rent and property prices and the disparity in incomes which was particularly hard for young people.
Councillor E Buckmaster declared a personal interest in the matter referred to at Minutes 462, 473 and 505 – Replacement Gym Equipment at Fanshawe and Leventhorpe Pools, in that he used the gym at Leventhorpe .
Councillor E Buckmaster declared a personal interest in the matter referred to at Minutes 462 and 473 – Replacement Gym Equipment at Fanshawe and Leventhorpe Pools, in that he used the gym at Leventhorpe .
Councillor E Buckmaster – Member of the Stop Harlow North Campaign.
Councillor E Buckmaster stated that he had attended a workshop at the QE2 Hospital with Councillor N Symonds.
Councillor Buckmaster emphasised that there had been agreement that communication methods such as the internet and social media should be used as much as possible to keep costs down.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster, the Community Planning and Partnerships Manager confirmed that if Officers were provided with more flexibility then any under spend could be used in future rather then being lost at the end of the year.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster, Members were advised key staff were accredited Officers with authoritative status to address anti-social behaviour. They are permitted to confiscate alcohol and to request the address of anyone committing anti-social behaviour, for example. Powers for individual officers varies depending on nature of job.
Councillor E Buckmaster expressed concerns that the proposed development was unduly overbearing in relation to the surrounding street scene. Councillors Beeching and Buckmaster urged the Committee to refuse the application.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding the issue of a varied legal agreement stipulating that the financial contribution of £29,561.44 be spent on play facilities within the vicinity of the site within a timescale of 10 years, the Director advised that this wording would ensure that if the contribution was not used within 10 years, the funding could be used to upgrade high street play space as a fall back position.
Councillor J Demonti proposed and Councillor E Buckmaster seconded a motion that applications 3/11/0987/FP and 3/11/0988/FP be deferred to enable Officers to undertake negotiations with the applicant to seek variations in the proposals with regard to the location of the vehicular access and t he height, location and potential for landscaping of the proposed two storey parking structure.
It was proposed by Councillor N Symonds and seconded by Councillor E Buckmaster that Councillor R Beeching be appointed Vice Chairman for the Civic Year.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster regarding the inclusion of health and alcohol initiatives, the Director of Neighbourhood Services provided an update in terms of his involvement on a Health and Inequalities Panel which looked at best practice and worked closely with the NHS.
In response to a query from Councillor E Buckmaster concerning new users, The Artistic Director said that from the figures on the database, 85% were new users.
· Development Control Fees · Fees and Charges · Land Drainage Functions · Council Email Addresses · Sunbeds (Regulation) Act 2010 In response to a question by Councillor E Buckmaster, the Monitoring Officer confirmed that existing Environmental Health staff would be trained to undertake duties in respect of the new sunbeds regulations.
Councillor E Buckmaster stated that the Sawbridgeworth Community Voice was well supported.
Councillor E Buckmaster referred to a scheme operated by Swindon Council. He undertook to provide the Director of Customer and Community Services with the information.
He referred to the recent by-election in Sawbridgeworth ward and welcomed Councillor E Buckmaster to his first Council meeting. He also referred to Councillor D A A Peek’s illness and expressed the Council’s best wishes to him.
Councillor E Buckmaster opposed the proposal for Members’ questions to not be read out, on the basis that it would disadvantage the public watching the webcast. He believed that the proposed change on supplementary questions detailed at paragraph 4.1.3 of the report, was unnecessary as the Chairman had this right in any case.
In response to a question from Councillor E Buckmaster, the Director of Internal Services confirmed that the establishment and application of earmarked reserves would still be subject to approval by Council.
Councillor Mrs M H Goldspink echoed the comments of Councillor E Buckmaster in respect of Members’ questions and believed that approving this change would be a disservice to the public. In respect of the scrutiny process, she believed that the proposed change would hamper the opportunity for Members to contribute to the decision-making process if items were not submitted to scrutiny.
He advised that notification had been received that Councillor E Buckmaster had joined the Group of Independents. As a consequence of this, the proposed allocation of seats was detailed in the report now submitted.
Council noted that the Group of Independents had nominated Councillor E Buckmaster to serve on Community Scrutiny Committee. All other places remained unchanged.
He also welcomed Councillor E Buckmaster to his first meeting of the Executive since his election to the District Council.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Buckmaster attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Sep 2016 | Council | East Herts Draft District Plan – Bishop’s Stortford – Settlement Appraisal and New Draft Chapter 5 | For | Carried | 26 for, 11 against, 2 abstained |
| 4 Mar 2015 | Council | Council Tax 2015/16 | For | Carried | 37 for, 0 against, 2 abstained |
| 5 Mar 2014 | Council | Council Tax 2014/15 - Formal Resolution | For | Carried | 36 for, 0 against, 2 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Buckmaster was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 2 of 6 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Buckmaster declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Mar 2025 | Overview and Scrutiny Committee, item 370 | Councillor E Buckmaster declared an interest as a Member of Sawbridgeworth Town Council, which was a beneficiary of the UKSPF. | |
| 4 Jul 2022 | Executive, item 69 | Councillor Williamson and Councillor E Buckmaster declared an interest in item 4 as they both sat on the Old River Lane Delivery Board so would not comment or vote on the item. | |
| 3 Sep 2019 | Executive, item 125 | In respect of Minute XX – Grounds Maintenance Contract, Councillor E Buckmaster declared an interest in relation to the contract for verges maintenance with Hertfordshire County Council, in that he was the HCC Deputy Executive Member for Highways and the Environment. | |
| 29 Feb 2012 | Development Management Committee, item 647 | Councillor E Buckmaster declared a personal interest in application 3/11/2156/FP, in that his son was a Member of the Sawbridgeworth Scouts Group. | |
| 14 Dec 2011 | Council, item 499 | Councillor E Buckmaster declared a personal interest in the matter referred to at Minutes 462, 473 and 505 – Replacement Gym Equipment at Fanshawe and Leventhorpe Pools, in that he used the gym at Leventhorpe . | |
| 6 Dec 2011 | Executive, item 461 | Councillor E Buckmaster declared a personal interest in the matter referred to at Minutes 462 and 473 – Replacement Gym Equipment at Fanshawe and Leventhorpe Pools, in that he used the gym at Leventhorpe . |
Where Councillor Buckmaster sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview and Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Sep 2026 | 4 | |
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 3 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Local Joint Panel | Committee Member | May 2021 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.