Seconded9 Jun 2026Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chair for the 2026/27 civic year
It was proposed by Councillor Swainston and seconded by Councillor Carter, that Councillor Horner be appointed Vice-Chair of the Overview and Scrutiny Committee for the 2026/27 civic year. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Seconded3 Jun 2026Human Resources Committee
Appointment of Vice - Chair for 2026/27
It was moved by the Councillor Connolly and seconded by Councillor Carter that Councillor Swainston be appointed as Vice-Chair of the Human Resources Committee for 2026/27. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Seconded4 Mar 2026Council
Pay Policy Statement 2026/27
Councillor Carter seconded the proposal.
Moved10 Dec 2025Council
Minutes - 22 October 2025 and 13 November 2025
Councillor Carter proposed , and Councillor Goldspink seconded a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 22 October 2025, be approved as a correct record and be signed by the Chairman.
Asked4 Nov 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Community Forum and Development Management Forum Update
Councillor Carter asked how the council decided when to hold a forum meeting and who made the decisions as to when a meeting was arranged. The Executive Member for Planning and Growth explained that the district council scheduled the forum meetings, and this scheduling depended on how many issues were at stake. She explained that Gilston was having a quarterly forum as this was one of the largest developments in the country.
Moved4 Nov 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter proposed, and Councillor Cox seconded a motion that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee work programme, as amended, be agreed. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Seconded22 Oct 2025Council
Motion to protect our rivers by taking into account the cumulative impact of sewage discharge
Councillor Carter seconded the motion.
Said16 Sep 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Scrutiny of Registered Providers' Communications Methods
Councillor Carter said that she agreed that communication was probably the key thing that upset tenants in terms of not getting issues fixed or not being able to speak to the right person.
Said16 Sep 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter said that with regards the Sustainable Transport proposal, she believed that this was part of a task and finish group held in 2017, which researched matters linked to the District Plan.
Said16 Sep 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter said that she wondered whether this matter would therefore be more usefully linked in with the planning department - in terms of evidence for the sustainable transport element of the District Plan. She said that there might be other things that the planning department wanted the committee to consider in that regard.
Said16 Sep 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter said that another big topic was artificial intelligence and asked whether Members could have a summary bulletin on this topic, to enable Members to see where it was being used, what kind of packages were being utilised, and in what areas.
Said16 Sep 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter said that people in local government and other organisations were increasingly being encouraged to use AI to summarise matters or to write notes.
Named16 Jul 2025Standards Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Carter was substituting for Councillor Burt.
Asked16 Jul 2025Standards Committee
Standards Update
Councillor Carter asked for an update on how the legislation in Standards Committees would operate under the proposed unity authority working and asked if the process would change.
Said10 Jun 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter said that she had suggested the topic of sustainable transport following a report submitted back in 2017.
Asked10 Jun 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter asked if there was a way for members to see a list of which topics the committee had consider over the last 5 years or so.
Seconded10 Jun 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Swainston proposed, and Councillor Carter seconded a motion that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee work programme be agreed. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Said12 Mar 2025Development Management Committee
3/22/2321/FUL - Demolition of care home. Erection of a 52 bedroomed care home, with hard and soft landscaping, vehicle parking, and associated works at Camellia House Care Home, 34 - 36 Hoe Lane, Ware, Hertfordshire, SG12 9NZ
Councillor Carter commented on condition 36 and swift bricks and the suggestion from various wildlife organisations that this should be strengthened so that details of integral swift bricks and bat boxes were provided before any above ground development took place.
Named4 Mar 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Burt was substituting for Councillor Carter and Councillor Holt was substituting for Councillor Boylan.
Named26 Feb 2025Council
Child Poverty in Hertfordshire
Councillor Carter supported the motion and said that the majority of children of families in poverty were working. She said the cost of living was really high and the motion called for a solution that could improve lives of children and invest in their future.
Named29 Jan 2025Scrutiny Committees
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Watson was substituting for Councillor Carter.
Named28 Jan 2025Standards Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Cox was substituting for Councillor Carter.
Seconded22 Jan 2025Development Management Committee
Minutes - 4 December 2024
Councillor Estop proposed and Councillor Carter seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 4 December 2024 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair, subject to the following amendment:
Named14 Jan 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter mentioned section 106 funding in terms of how this process worked and how section 106 monies were allocated. The Committee Support Officer invited the committee to consider the work programme well beyond March and June 2025. He referred to an action from November 2023 that the Committee review Development Management Forums within two years of when these were set up, subject to the when the Head of Planning and Building Control wished to present this matter back to the Committee.
Said14 Jan 2025Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter said that it was important to refresh ideas and topics which were immediately important at a short workshop.
Seconded4 Dec 2024Development Management Committee
3/23/2185/LBC - Insertion of partition walls, flooring, kitchen/prep area, stage, bar, external flue and food storage area.
Councillor Stowe proposed, and Councillor Carter seconded, a motion that application 3/23/2185/LBC be granted listed building consent subject to the conditions set out at the end of the report.
Said4 Dec 2024Development Management Committee
3/23/1641/FUL - The demolition of existing buildings and erection of Barn 1: Office accommodation, and 6 units of overnight accommodation (with 14 beds in total) for staff, volunteers and students working on the farm site (class E(g);
Councillor Carter spoke about the positive benefits of the application for the wider community. She supported the point that had been made that the buildings were at the end of their useful life and the proposed development was a big improvement. She acknowledged the problem of availability of rural housing in rural areas for younger people.
Named4 Dec 2024Development Management Committee
3/23/1641/FUL - The demolition of existing buildings and erection of Barn 1: Office accommodation, and 6 units of overnight accommodation (with 14 beds in total) for staff, volunteers and students working on the farm site (class E(g);
Councillor Carter referred to condition 19 in respect of swift bricks and the details of biodiversity enhancements, and a request for 16 swift bricks to be integrated into buildings and for details of these measures to be submitted for approval at an earlier stage i.e., not just before occupation but before above ground development had commenced.
Moved4 Dec 2024Development Management Committee
3/23/1641/FUL - The demolition of existing buildings and erection of Barn 1: Office accommodation, and 6 units of overnight accommodation (with 14 beds in total) for staff, volunteers and students working on the farm site (class E(g);
Councillor Carter proposed, and Councillor Buckmaster seconded, a motion for an amendment to condition 19 regarding biodiversity so that the condition specified 16 integrated swift bricks with details required to be submitted before above ground development had commenced.
Said5 Nov 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
The use of Glyphosate in grounds maintenance
Councillor Carter said that Members needed to consider the use of Glyphosate not just from the point of view of financial cost.
Said5 Nov 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
The use of Glyphosate in grounds maintenance
Councillor Carter said that doing nothing was not really viable going forward due to the biodiversity emergency. She said that the increase in the use of pesticides and herbicides was about 20-fold since the 1980s, and there were different methods of controlling weeds. She acknowledged that it was a difficult problem to solve as councils had become dependent on these herbicides to manage the public expectation of no roadside vegetation.
Asked5 Nov 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
The use of Glyphosate in grounds maintenance
Councillor Carter asked if the council blanket sprayed roadsides or whether spraying was limited to areas ... view the full minutes text for item 225.
Named23 Oct 2024Development Management Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor Smith was substituting for Councillor Carter.
Asked16 Oct 2024Council
Community Governance Review - Terms of Reference and Timetable
Councillor Carter asked how the consultation would work and where the weighting would lie for changing boundaries.
Named10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter mentioned glyphosate and the officer briefing paper that had been circulated to Members. She said that she would like to see this matter come to Overview and Scrutiny Committee at a meeting.
Said10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Carter said that it would be useful to see to what extent the council was using glyphosate and what could be done to minimise it.
Named10 Sep 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Overview and Scrutiny Committee - Draft Work Programme
Councillor Horner said that he would be happy to talk to Councillor Carter about putting in a scrutiny proposal.
Moved16 Jul 2024Standards Committee
Appointment of the Vice-Chair for 2024/25
It was moved by Councillor Carter and seconded by Councillor Hill, that Councillor Clements be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Standards Committee for 2024/25.
Moved5 Jun 2024Human Resources Committee
Minutes - 6 February 2024
It was moved by Councillor Carter and seconded by Councillor Swainston that the minutes of the meetings of the Human Resources Committee held on 6 February 2024 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED. It was noted that Councillors Connolly, Deffley, Hollebon and Willcocks abstained from the vote.
Said15 May 2024Council
Minor Amendments to the Constitution
Councillor Carter said that she appreciated change was difficult but this was a new administration and opinions differ. She said she supported this change.
Named10 Apr 2024Development Management Committee
Apologies
It was noted that Councillor M Connolly was substituting for Councillor R Carter and Councillor M Adams was substituting for Councillor S Copley.
Said28 Feb 2024Council
Thriving Together 2023 - 2027 - a new health and wellbeing plan for East Herts
Councillor Carter said she was pleased to see a focus on children and young people as the Director of Public Health report 2019-2020 said that 8.2% of children in East Herts were living in low income families.
Seconded28 Feb 2024Council
Pay Policy Statement Report 2024 - 2025
Councillor Carter seconded the proposal.
Said28 Feb 2024Council
Pay Policy Statement Report 2024 - 2025
Councillor Carter said the council’s staff had all worked extremely hard and had dealt with huge changes such as new digital services and a new administration. She said as a new councillor, she had appreciated their help and support.
Seconded6 Feb 2024Human Resources Committee
Minutes - 13 September 2023
It was moved by Councillor Swainston and seconded by Councillor Carter that the minutes of the meetings of the Human Resources Committee held on 13 September 2023 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Named6 Feb 2024Human Resources Committee
Human Resources Management Report for Q3
Councillor Carter referred to the workplace injury in the report and asked about the health and safety procedures that were followed.
Asked6 Feb 2024Human Resources Committee
Gender Pay Gap Report 2023
Councillor Carter asked about the aging workforce and if the recruitment of younger people would affect the gender pay gap.
Said6 Feb 2024Human Resources Committee
Gender Pay Gap Report 2023
Councillor Carter informed the committee that they would be receiving the equalities report later in the year.
Asked23 Jan 2024Standards Committee
Standards Update
Councillor Carter asked for clarification under paragraph 2.4 where complaints were described as “Member not ‘in capacity’ under s.27(2) Localism Act’. The Head of Legal and Democratic Services explained that the Localism Act recognised that councillors were not acting as councillors at all times and so any complaint against a councillor must have happened when a councillor was undertaking council business or involved with an issue that was relevant to the council. He said that this was the first test for a complaint before it could be further assessed.
Named16 Jan 2024Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Draft - Thriving Together 2024 - 2027 - a new Health and Wellbeing Plan for East Herts
Councillor Carter mentioned that she had noticed that respondents were perhaps weighted to the older age group, and she felt that this should be looked at going forward in the next stage of the process.
Asked6 Dec 2023Development Management Committee
3/23/0579/FUL - Demolition of school and erection of replacement school with associated landscaping and parking. Siting of temporary teaching accommodation during period of construction at Pinewood School, Hoe Lane, Ware, Hertfordshire, SG12 9PB
Councillor Carter asked about the anticipated lifespan of the proposed new buildings. She commented on the matter of ... view the full minutes text for item 246.
Seconded30 Nov 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Minutes - 7 November 2023
Councillor Nicholls proposed and Councillor Carter seconded, a motion that the Minutes of the meeting held on 7 November 2023, as amended, be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman.
Said12 Sep 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Pedestrian Safety
The Scrutiny Officer submitted a report that considered the issue of pedestrian safety in Hertford Castle Ward, and in particular, focussed on a number of concerns that had been raised by Councillor Carter.
Named12 Sep 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Pedestrian Safety
Councillor Carter set out the reasons for submitting this matter for scrutiny. She referred to specific evidence from Hertford Castle Ward and the evidence encouraging people to walk as well as residents feeling safe whilst walking and cycling.
Named12 Sep 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Pedestrian Safety
Councillor Carter put several questions to Hertfordshire County Councillor Phil Bibby in respect of travel policy and whether equality was given to pedestrians and cyclists and how this was reflected in budgets, whether there was any specific funding for new projects and was funding ring-fenced for pedestrians and pavement repairs. She commented that it was easier to get a pothole filled than to fix a pavement considered to be too narrow.
Said12 Sep 2023Overview and Scrutiny Committee
Pedestrian Safety
Councillor Carter commented that many motorists were driving too fast and that many communities e.g.
Seconded19 Jul 2023Development Management Committee
Appointment of Vice-Chairman
It was proposed by Councillor Hill and seconded by Councillor Carter, that Councillor Watson be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Development Management Committee for the 2023/24 civic year.
Said19 Jul 2023Development Management Committee
3/22/2534/FUL - Removal of five temporary buildings, erection of a Sports Hall with reception and administrative areas, amendments to vehicular parking and circulation, improvements to security and pedestrian connectivity, together with har
Councillor Carter said that there was a lot of traffic and congestion in the surrounding roads around dropping off time, particularly in wet weather. She ... view the full minutes text for item 101.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.