Minutes - 7 January 2026
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Deffley that the Minutes of the Licensing Committee meeting held on 7 January 2026 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair.
Every time East Hertfordshire's minutes name Councillor Bull, as the council published it.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Deffley that the Minutes of the Licensing Committee meeting held on 7 January 2026 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor R Buckmaster.
Councillor Bull supported the motion, noting the swifts that resided in the tall buildings at Addenbrookes Hospital.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Deffley that the Minutes of the meeting held on 22 October 2024 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken the motion was declared CARRIED. It was noted that Councillors Cox and Wyllie abstained from the vote.
It was moved by Councillor Cox and seconded by Councillor Bull that the recommendations, as detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor Buckmaster.
Councillor Bull asked about how the public and private transport infrastructure was to be improved in that particular development.
It was moved by the Chair and seconded by Councillor Bull, that the Minutes of the meeting of the Licensing Sub-Committee held on 11 July 2024 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chair.
The Chairman welcomed Councillor Bull back to the Chamber after his recent illness.
The Leader of the Council said that Councillor Bull was not well and sent the Council’s best wishes to him for a speedy recovery.
It was proposed by Councillor Connolly and seconded by Councillor Bull, that Councillor Hill chair the meeting of the Licensing Sub-Committee.
Councillor Bull also congratulated the Executive in pushing this forward and wished the community group every success.
Councillor Bull said that he admired the group for the hard work that they had done. The motion to support the recommendations having been proposed and seconded was put to the meeting and upon a vote being taken, was declared CARRIED.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor A Holt.
It was noted that Councillor M Connolly was substituting for Councillor V Burt and Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor A Holt.
It was noted that Councillor V Smith was substituting for J Dunlop and Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor T Stowe.
It was proposed by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Marlow that Councillor Willcocks be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Willcocks proposed, and Councillor Bull seconded, a motion to exclude the press and public during the discussion of the next item, on the grounds that it involved the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 1 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972 .
It was moved by Councillor Townsend and seconded by Councillor Bull that Councillor Dunlop be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor Townsend and seconded by Councillor Bull that the Minutes of the Sub-Committee meetings held on 22 May 2023 and 6 June 2023 be confirmed as correct and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Dunlop proposed and Councillor Bull seconded a motion to adjourn the meeting for forty-five minutes to allow all participants to read and digest the late additional evidence received from the Applicant. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED. RESOLVED – that the meeting be adjourned for approximately forty-five minutes.
It was noted that Councillor Bull was substituting for Councillor Holt and Councillor Smith was substituting for Councillor Burt.
It was moved by Councillor Willcocks and seconded by Councillor Bull, that Councillor Connolly be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor Deffley and seconded by Councillor Bull, that Councillor Dunlop be appointed Chairman for the meeting. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor Deffley and seconded by Councillor Bull that the Minutes of the meeting held on 27 April 2023 be confirmed be signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Ruffles that the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 23 November 2023 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Alder that the recommendations, as detailed be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
The Chairman was pleased to announce that Councillor Stan Bull had been awarded a Queen’s Platinum Jubilee Coin for his services as a Voluntary Ambulance Car Driver.
He said that Councillor Bull had been volunteering for over 22 years.
Councillor Bull explained that his work as a voluntary driver had happened by chance in that he had been working with a friend who had asked him what he was going to do when he retired. He said that he had enjoyed every minute of his time as a driver, and that it was a very rewarding job helping people. He felt that it was an ideal job for a retiree adding that two weeks ago the traffic manager for the service had said just how much he appreciated his help.
Councillor Bull said that he was very proud to receive the award.
Councillor Bull said the Council’s IT Communications were not good and gave an example of recently having to obtain a new password for his laptop.
Councillor Bull recognized that the council had to make savings and increase income through car parking charges but he was concerned about parents who use the car parks in Buntingford to drop off and collect their children.
Councillor Bull asked if smaller planning applications were being dealt with more quickly. The Human Resources Officer said that the more junior posts were already in situ to enable this, adding that these posts were easier to recruit to. The Interim Head of Human Resources and Organisational Development said that there were other recruitment tools which could be explored, including Human Resources policies which are not currently being used, for example in terms of renumeration.
It was noted that Councillor Bull was substituting for Councillor R Buckmaster.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Ruffles that the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 15 February 2022, be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Bull asked if there were any plans to move the closed tip facility at Aspenden (which is not owned by the Council) to the recycling area at Buntingford. The Health and Safety Officer said that he was not aware of any such plans, but that he would make enquires regarding this matter with the Head of Operations.
Councillor Bull said that recycling facilities at Buntingford were needed as outlining villagers also used these alongside the residents of the town. The Head of Human Resources and Organisational Development said that although there were no known plans to re site the aforementioned closed tip, there were plans ... view the full minutes text for item 27.
It was moved by Councillor Newton and seconded by Councillor Bull that the recommendations, as detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Goodeve proposed and Councillor Bull seconded a motion supporting the recommendation in the report. On being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Bolton proposed and Councillor Bull seconded a motion supporting the recommendation. On being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
It was noted that Councillor Bull was substituting for Councillor Andrews, Councillor Devonshire was substituting for Councillor R Buckmaster and Councillor Huggins was substituting for Councillor Fernando.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Dumont, that the Minutes of the Committee meeting held on 24 November 2021 as amended, be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman.
Councillor Bull asked if there was any reason for Grange Paddocks leading the table of accident statistics. The Health and Safety Officer said that this was due to the larger size of this facility and therefore its higher footfall. He said that the statistics were also affected by the swimming pool facilities at Hartham Leisure Centre currently being closed to the public due to refurbishment.
It was noted that Councillor Bull was substituting for Councillor Buckmaster.
It was noted that Councillor Bull was substituting for Councillor Ruffles.
Councillor Bull expressed concerns about the impact on the planning department and whether applications coming in would be affected. The Head of Communications, Strategy and Policy said that Development Management was being affected by a national shortage and the Council was trying very hard to recruit to vacant planning posts. He said that these posts were not being offered up ... view the full minutes text for item 256.
Councillor Bull proposed and Councillor Newton seconded, a motion that the recommendations detailed in the report be supported. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Bull said that he was privileged to have met Roger who was a very gentle and quiet man but people listened to him. He said that he always made time to attend events like the Remembrance Day Service and the Christmas Lights in Buntingford when he was Chairman.
Councillor Bull said that he had also attended some of Roger’s Church services and he said that he would be sadly missed.
It was moved by Councillor McMullen and seconded by Councillor Bull, that the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 26 May 2021 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Bull said that he hoped to see an increase in engagement from Planning, as the turnover of staff had made it difficult for Members to forge good working relationships or know who to contact for assistance with planning matters.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor R Buckmaster that the recommendations, as detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor Devonshire and seconded by Councillor Bull that the minutes of the meeting held on 23 March 2021 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor McMullen, that the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 16 February 2021 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Newton that the recommendations, as detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Bull said that there was a perception amongst some residents that applications were being rushed through without due consideration.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor McMullen that the recommendations, as detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
Upon taking a roll call of Members, it was established that Councillor Bull was absent.
It was moved by Councillor Bull and seconded by Councillor Alder, that the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 5 November 2020 be confirmed as a correct record and signed by the Chairman. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Bull asked whether UNISON believed this was a realistic and attainable increase.
It was moved by Councillor Alder and seconded by Councillor Bull that the recommendation, as detailed, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared CARRIED.
Councillor Bull asked whether the proposal to make ten Hertford Theatre staff redundant was wise, especially in view of the recent extension of the furlough scheme, and said the Council may benefit by retaining these staff. He also questioned the proposal to re-assign the staff to COVID-19 marshal roles for the remainder of their employment, given that this could potentially put staff at risk due to anti-lockdown sentiment amongst some.
Councillor Bull said he was surprised to hear that the small fire at Buntingford Service Centre was caused by a household battery, which he would not have expected to have ‘slipped through the net’.
In response to a comment from Councillor Bull, Councillor McAndrew said each Town would ... view the full minutes text for item 349.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor A Ward-Booth.
The Head of Communications, Strategy and Policy confirmed to Councillor S Bull that the way forward could be to explore the principle of shared usage of residents parking zones on a case by case basis. He said that whenever a RPZ was considered for implementation, this would always be preceded by a consultation with residents. He answered a number of other questions from the Committee on mixed use parking schemes.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull the health and safety implications were debated regarding the closure of Westmill Landfill; the fact that Buntingford Service Centre would be taking residual waste and the changes proposed by the contractor in dealing with this change.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor J Ranger.
Councillor S Bull expressed concerns in respect of the traffic movements and congestion between Whittington Way and Pig Lane.
Councillor S Bull commented that he was pleased this matter had been withdrawn. The Leader confirmed that this matter was withdrawn and would be looked at again.
In respect of Minute 223 – Buntingford Community Governance Review, Councillor S Bull declared a non-pecuniary interest as a Buntingford Town Council Member.
Councillor C Woodward moved, and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that the Minutes now detailed, be received. After being put to the meeting, and a vote taken, the Minutes were received.
Councillor S Bull expressed concern at the loss of Planning Officers and queried why they had left and that 21% across the organisation seemed a high figure for those choosing a different career. The Human Resources Officer explained that as a result of the high turnover, exit interviews were being closely monitored and results were largely positive with no trends having been identified. Staff were encouraged to complete exit questionnaires and submissions could be made anonymously.
It was moved by Councillor S Bull and seconded by Councillor M McMullen that the Recruitment, Induction and Probation Policy as submitted, be approved. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the motion was declared CARRIED.
The recommendation to close the offices on Christmas Eve was moved by Councillor S Bull but this was not supported by a seconder. Members felt that as a public service, the general public should have access to all of the Council’s services and that the enforced closure of the offices covering a five day period, could impact negatively in terms of public perception and service delivery.
The Head confirmed to Councillor S Bull that Unison had agreed in principle, to the above system of performance monitoring. The Chairman referred to the evaluation of jobs against the pay policy. The Head advised that a significant number of jobs had already been evaluated.
The Chairman and Councillor S Bull referred to the importance of securing the appropriate infrastructure.
Councillor S Bull stated that residents were concerned that the scale of the increase in dwellings outnumbered the infrastructure.
Councillor S Bull expressed concern regarding the 25% reduction in SMG posts. The Chief Executive said that for a council the size of East Herts, the organisation was top heavy in terms of its SMG posts and that she had aimed to put services together which made sense from a resident viewpoint, e.g. a new Head of Housing, Health and Community Safety.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor K Brush.
Councillor S Bull raised the issue of bullying and potential personality clashes with a manager and HR’s role in the process. The Head of HR and Organisational Development gave assurances in terms of mediation and support to both, whether this was provided internally or externally.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull regarding planning enforcement, the Director confirmed that Officers were reliant on local ward Members and the public for notification of any breaches of planning control.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull, the Director confirmed that following a query from the Council’s Solicitor that the proposed tenancy arrangements for the affordable housing were set out in the recommendation , this had been amended to 1 unit being provided as rented and 1 unit as shared ownership.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor Jones.
Councillor S Bull, as the adjoining ward Member, questioned the viability of the site as a future business premises. He commented that Hormead Parish Council and Hertfordshire Highways had not objected to the application and believed that the proposed development would contribute to the local housing need and enhance the area and street scene. He urged Members to support the application and grant planning permission.
He stated that if there had been any such testing as that referred to by Councillor Bull, then Officers would like to see the detail of that. The Director concluded that due to the rudimentary nature of the buildings it was not inappropriate for Members to reach a view that retention and conversion for employment was a less attractive proposal than redevelopment.
It was proposed by Councillor J Wyllie and seconded by Councillor S Bull that Councillor M Pope be appointed Vice–Chairman of the Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee for the 2015/16 civic year.
Councillor S Bull commented on whether the ‘3G’ all weather football pitches implemented in Hertford could also be considered for Bishop’s Stortford and Buntingford as there was insufficient provision in both towns. The Director of Finance and Support Services advised that a new service plan target had been set to consider the East Herts leisure provision across the whole District. Members were advised that a review would be considered by Community Scrutiny Committee in due course.
Councillor Bull commented on whether the Authority should consider a policy of banning dogs from East Herts recreation grounds due to the worsening problem of dog fouling. The Director and the Scrutiny Officer undertook to secure a written response from the Head of Environmental Services. Members were reminded that any policy change might have to be considered by Environment Scrutiny Committee in the light of provisions within the new Anti-Social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act as well as developing case law.
Councillor S Bull referred to the low satisfaction figures in relation to Ward Freman swimming pool in Buntingford, and of parents’ dissatisfaction with the viewing area. He referred to the substantial increases in planning development now and planned for the next 10 years and the impact this would have on leisure demand. The Head of Environmental Services referred to an extensive debate at a recent joint meeting of Scrutiny Committees during which, a number of Members had expressed a need to improve leisure provision, particularly in relation to football pitches and swimming.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor Alexander.
Councillor S Bull welcomed the application and stated that Hertfordshire Highways had no objections in what was one of the prettiest villages in East Herts.
Councillor S Bull praised Officers’ efforts in reducing residual waste and the use of compostable caddy liners, especially in the summer.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull regarding income from Market Traders, ( EHPI 11.1 – Rental Income from Market traders), the Director of Neighbourhood explained that this was rental income from stalls and that there had been an increase in traders.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor Crofton.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, commented that it was a shame that Officers had recommended refusal. He stated that this building had been derelict for many years and the proposed dwelling would sit well within the site and would enhance the village.
Councillor J Jones agreed with Councillor Bull as the proposed development would improve the street scene in Hare Street and he was minded to vote against the Officer’s recommendation for refusal. The Director advised that a key test was whether the building was worthy of retention and Officers did not believe this to be the case.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, referred to the meeting that took place between himself, Councillor J Jones and Officers following the Development Management Committee meeting on 17 September 2014. He explained that the meeting had been convened to discuss the Council’s case in respect of the forthcoming public inquiry regarding both planning applications and the discussions had centred on education and highways capacity and employment provision.
Councillor Bull stated that Councillor J Jones had referred to a number of other developments which he had considered had not been included in the assessment regarding education capacity.
Councillor Bull referred to the likely oversubscription of schools in Buntingford in 2014/15. He stated that Hertfordshire County Council had indicated that they would not be supporting the position of East Herts Council in not being supportive of both these planning applications.
In respect of highways capacity, Councillor Bull referred to the lack of objection from Hertfordshire Highways. He referred to the Director’s explanation of the position of Hertfordshire Highways and of an external highways consultant.
Councillor Bull emphasised that Hertfordshire Highways would not be submitting any evidence to the public inquiry of behalf of East Herts Council.
Councillor Bull referred to an unidentified tipping point that had been highlighted by traffic modelling. He stated that modelling had indicated a significant highways impact resulting from between 500 and 1500 additional dwellings or a maximum of 2000. Hertfordshire Highways had indicated however, that as yet unidentified measures could be taken to improve highways capacity.
Councillor Bull stated that the Wheatley Homes site did not deliver any additional employment provision. An employment consultant had indicated that a number of steps could be taken in addition to direct provision. An example was grant funding for additional broadband capacity or funding for improvements to the A10 single carriageway south ... view the full minutes text for item 297.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, expressed concern over the proposed 3 storey buildings in Buntingford. He stated that he would have liked to see one and two bedroom bungalows as part of this application. He also commented on whether there was any plan from Hertfordshire Highways to widen the A10 as the 3 mile section between Buntingford and Westmill was often congested and there were two dangerous summits.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, stated that, even without the proposed developments, Buntingford had experienced a 50% growth since 2011. He reminded the Committee that 1021 dwellings had already been built or had been approved since 2011 and an appeal inspector had stated that over 800 additional dwellings was unsustainable without increased employment.
Councillor Bull commented that employment land did not necessarily mean employment would be taken up. He concluded that roads were becoming congested and transport was poor at best and schools and doctor’s surgeries were also full. He urged the Committee not to inflict further housing development on Buntingford.
Councillor S Bull asked what community schemes had taken place in this year in Buntingford. Officers undertook to write to the Member.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull regarding an anticipated increase in the budget for Bed and Breakfast charges, the Director of Finance and Support Services explained that more people had been placed in Bed and Breakfast accommodation and that the Council, at the beginning of each year, had to make a number of assumptions in relation to planning its budget. The Executive Member for Finance reminded Members that they did have an opportunity to review charges at scrutiny.
Councillor S Bull emphasised that the residents of Buntingford did not want the access for this development coming out onto The Causeway.
Councillor J Jones proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that application 3/14/0910/RP be deferred to enable further negotiations with the applicant with regard to the house types proposed as part of the development.
Councillor S Bull welcomed this application as a fantastic change where there would be a tremendous outlook for the proposed apartments and he welcomed the application. The Chairman also welcomed the application as these apartments were needed.
Councillor S Bull stated that he was supportive of the Officer’s recommendation as this was an ideal site for the proposed development. He commented that he was not concerned regarding the traffic movements associated with this application.
Councillor S Bull read a statement on behalf of the Town Council, the local Chambers of Commerce and the Civic Society, which suggested that the findings were flawed and that a maximum of only 2 hectares of land should be retained for employment purposes. Officers referred to the range of assumptions within the Study and the need for a robust evidence base.
It was noted that Councillor G Cutting was substituting for Councillor S Bull.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was in attendance as substitute for Councillor E Bedford.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull concerning priority to serviceman or ex-servicemen affected by trauma, the Manager, Housing Services explained that such individuals were given additional preference including their bereaved families. There were three such individuals on the East Herts ’ register.
It was moved by Councillor T Page and seconded by Councillor S Bull that Councillor G Williamson be appointed Vice–Chairman of the Corporate Business Scrutiny Committee for the 2014/15 civic year.
Councillor S Bull read out the key points from a lengthy e-mail that had been sent to all Members of the Committee. He referred to references in the e-mail to the relative openness of the site and to the fact that it was bounded on all sides by steep banks and mature landscaping, which prevented clear public views into the site. The e-mail concluded that the application was infill development that was in accordance with policies GBC1 and OSV2 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor K Crofton seconded, a motion that application 3/14/0254/FP be approved on the grounds that that the application was in accordance with policies GBC1 and OSV2 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, this motion was declared LOST. After being put to the meeting and a vote taken, the Committee accepted the recommendation of the Director of Neighbourhood Services as now submitted.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor R Sharma.
Councillor S Bull referred to the fact that there seemed to be a number of discarded plastic recycling boxes around. The Director of Finance and Support Service stated that she would ask the Head of Service to write to the Member regarding the advice for reuse or disposal of these boxes.
Councillor S Bull stated that there were many reasons why this application should be refused and he agreed with the comments of Councillors J Ranger and J Jones. He read out a letter from a local neighbour who had 20 years experience as a chartered town planner.
Councillor S Bull commented that quite a few pubs were being lost in rural areas. He stated that many pubs displayed similar signs on private land. He queried whether the Authority could take enforcement action against unauthorised advertisements on private land.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull, [name removed] confirmed that volunteers were Police DBS checked.
Councillor S Bull referred to GP surgeries in Buntingford, Standon and Puckeridge amalgamating and queried whether a new centre was being built.
The Chairman offered to investigate the issue and let Councillor Bull know.
Councillor S Bull commented on why there did not appear to be any reference in this Service Plan regarding the maintenance of Ward Freman Pool. The Head of Environmental Services advised that general maintenance of the pools was funded and carried out by SLM as the Leisure Contractor so this did not appear in the Council’s Service Plan or the Capital Programme. The Council was responsible for replacement of major plant and the Capital programme for did include an item for the replacement of air conditioning at that site.
Councillor S Bull, as a local ward Member, referred to the representations from Buntingford Action Group for Responsible Development (BARD), the Buntingford Civic Society and Buntingford Town Council. He expressed concerns that this development would fetch traffic off the bypass back into the town, thereby creating a rat run.
Councillor Bull queried what security would be in place for the proposed pedestrian walkway and bus stopping area on the new housing estate. He commented on whether a condition could be applied to secure fencing and the locking of gates to facilitate this security.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor N Symonds seconded, a motion that application 3/13/1273/FP be refused on the grounds that the element of the development located on the ... view the full minutes text for item 525.
Councillor S Bull stated that the site was located in the village and was accessible via narrow lanes. He stated that there was no public transport in the vicinity of the site and residents had made it clear that they did not want a commercial reuse of this site, as detailed in the letters of support that had been acknowledged in the Officer’s report.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor J Jones seconded, a motion that application 3/13/2107/FP be granted on the grounds that the application was in accordance with the policy provisions of part II of policy GBC9 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007.
Councillor J Jones proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that application 3/13/1891/FP be granted on the grounds that the proposed development was in keeping with the surrounding area and would have very little impact.
Councillor S Bull stated he would be voting against this application. He highlighted the many planning issues referred to in a list of bullet points covering objections to the application in the Officer’s report. He also expressed concerns relating to the loss of community spirit should the application be approved.
Councillor S Bull expressed concerns that emergency vehicles would not be able to turn effectively in the confines of the site. The Director confirmed that the applicant had modified the application to ensure that large vehicles would be able to enter the site, turn and then exit the site in forward gear.
Councillor M Alexander proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that a further report be brought to Committee in respect of formal enforcement action regarding the office use of the garage at Longcroft as this use was not captured by the Enforcement Notice that would be issued if Members supported the Director’s recommendation in respect of E/12/0314/B.
This was seconded by Councillor S Bull.
Councillor S Bull declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in application 3/13/0513/FP, in that he received a pension from the Co-op. He left the room whilst this matter was considered.
Councillor S Bull questioned the narrative in this section and commented that a robust Town Plan existed.
The Committee noted that Councillor S Bull attended meetings of South Anglia Housing Association but that this was not a disclosable pecuniary interest.
Councillor S Bull stated that it had been fundamental to refuse the previous application on the grounds of prematurity and that it still remained a valid reason for this application. He explained that the whole site was in a rural area and that the site was less suitable than other sites in the town.
Councillor Bull referred to previous planning applications which had been approved and that housing provision was already in excess of what was anticipated in the draft District Plan. He suggested that it should be refused for a number of planning reasons including Policies GBC2 and GBC3, transport policy and policy SD1.
Councillor Bull referred to the application’s close proximity to the school, accessibility problems and the unsuitability of the ... view the full minutes text for item 222.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor T Page.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull regarding the CCTV refund of £8,000 from Stevenage, the Director of Finance and Support Services explained how the partnership refund arrangements worked.
Councillor S Bull said that he was “astounded” by the amount which was paid out in terms of benefits when displayed in this format.
Councillor S Bull expressed his dismay at the dissolution of Community Voice meetings which he felt, gave the community an opportunity to voice their concerns and needs.
Councillor S Bull declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in application 3/12/2063/FP, due to his involvement with South Anglia Housing Association. He left the room whilst this matter was considered.
Councillor S Bull commented that there were no figures in the suggested Section 106 legal obligations. He referred in particular to an urgent need for additional cemetery space in Buntingford.
Councillor Bull referred to the Buntingford Town Council’s perspective in that the land was allocated in the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007 as mixed use and therefore the principle of development was already established. He stated that the Town Council had no objections to the proposed change of use but had requested that these proposals were considered in the wider context of any future development within Buntingford.
Councillor S Bull acknowledged that this was a sensitive area and a local beauty spot. He stated however that, having heard the comments of the supporting speaker for the applicant, he concurred with the Officer’s recommendation.
Councillor S Bull welcomed the changes but expressed concerns regarding the height of some of the houses on the basis that, in future, occupiers might wish to apply for loft conversions and the effect this would have on neighbouring residents. He stated that the pitch of the roofs was very steep and sought assurance that the footpath would be maintained.
This view was supported by Councillor S Bull who referred to the hotel’s previous use as a conference centre. He suggested that the hotel was being allowed to be run down and this was having a negative impact on the community.
Councillor S Bull commented that the hotel was in a good position for further development and improvement.
Councillor S Bull supported [name removed] comments adding that it was a wonderful opportunity for young people in the area.
Councillor S Bull referred to the fact that Rialto had been in business a long time and should have known the cost of land.
Councillor S Bull referred to the fact that the property had undergone a number of improvements over the years.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was in attendance as substitute for Councillor T Page.
Councillor S Bull expressed concerns that there was a need for new employment areas in Buntingford. The Executive Member stated that the former Sainsbury’s depot in Buntingford had previously been intended for an entirely commercial use but this had now fallen through. The likely future use of the site could not solely be residential and a mix of commercial and industrial use had to be the way forward.
It was moved by Councillor N Symonds and seconded by Councillor S Bull that Councillor P Moore be appointed as Vice–Chairman for the 2013/14 Civic Year.
Councillor S Bull stated that he would not be supportive of the connection between the police and PCSOs being lost. The continued attachment to the police gave PCSOs crucial support in the work they carried out in East Herts.
Councillor S Bull referred to paragraph 2.19 of the report now submitted. He stated that some of the awards made to Councillors were for public meetings or events that could have been funded by Town or Parish Councils.
Councillor S Bull declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in applications 3/13/0513/FP and 3/13/0518/LC, in that he received a pension from the Co-op. He left the room whilst these matters were considered.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull regarding the responsibility of maintaining gardens if a housing association was involved, the Director advised that this was a privately owned property.
It was proposed by Councillor P Moore and seconded by Councillor S Bull, that Councillor E Buckmaster be appointed Vice Chairman for the 2013/14 Civic Year.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull, the Environmental Health Promotion Officer explained Circle Anglia’s role in helping residents attend a recent cooking project event, “Meet and Eat”.
Councillor S Bull stated that prematurity was a valid reason for refusing this application. He stressed that the site was in the rural area beyond the green belt and approving this application would be contrary to sustainability policy in the NPPF. The application was also contrary to policies GBC2 and GBC3 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007.
Councillor Bull emphasised that this site was unsustainable in terms of lack of transport, particularly cycle lanes. The site also lacked employment opportunities for residents and lacked high speed broadband. He stated that this site had no natural boundaries leaving this location open for further development.
Councillor Bull concluded that application 3/13/0118/OP should be refused as development on this site would dominate the town.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, stated that, since the non determination of this application in February 2013, a revised planning application had been submitted following dialogue between the developer and Buntingford Town Council.
Councillor Bull commented that, whilst the new application had made no changes in terms of landscaping, there had been an attempt to address issues of concern regarding the height and massing of buildings adjacent to the existing properties.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor G Jones seconded, a motion that Members confirm that, if they had been able to determine application 3/12/1417/RP, they would have refused planning permission on the grounds that t he proposed development would result in a cramped layout and design that would be contrary to policy ENV1 and ENV3 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007. The application was also contrary to the aims and objectives of policies HSG3 and HSG4 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007; the Council’s SPD on Affordable Housing and Lifetime Homes 2008 and the policies of the National Planning Policy Framework.
Councillor Mr Alexander proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that applications 3/12/1955/FP and 3/12/1956/LB be deferred to enable Officers to consider whether the development was the minimum necessary to provide for the repair and restoration of the listed school building and ... view the full minutes text for item 26.
Councillor S Bull stated that this application was a finely balanced judgement but he had noted that the Conservation Officer had suggested the application should be approved.
Councillor Bull also stated that Affinity Water, the Countryside Access Officer, the Herts and Essex Wildlife Trust and the Ramblers Association were all supportive of the application. He concluded that, given the support of all of these organisations, he was supportive of the Officers’ recommendation.
Councillor S Bull referred to the sad situation on this site in that the current owner had purchased the property unaware that works had been carried out without planning permission 10 years ago. He referred to the high quality of the workmanship that had been carried out to create the unauthorised wide staircase.
Councillor Bull stated that enforcement action should be deferred so that Officers could explore solutions to this very reserved case.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor G Jones.
Councillor S Bull stated that residents who wanted to see a change in his community, usually asked for the issue to be raised on a Town Council agenda. He queried whether the Community Grant Fund was the right approach.
Councillor J Ranger supported the statement by Councillor S Bull, adding that grants aimed at community organisations should be given wider publicity in the media and that the Council should be highlighting its successes where monies had been spent, including in the use of Parish magazines. The Head of Communications, Engagement and Cultural Services confirmed that more publicity would be undertaken both in the Communications Team Plan and the Rural Business Development Plan.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull regarding a decline in under 16s swimming, the Head of Environmental Services agreed that numbers were dropping, but increasing for adults. He referred to national trends, adding that SLM were doing all that they could to encourage usage, including making the facilities more attractive (tiling of the swimming pool at Grange Paddocks had just been undertaken) and scheduling more ‘fun swim’ sessions.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, commented on the height and density of the proposed development. He expressed concerns in respect of overlooking of neighbouring properties and also in respect of the proposed access, which was inappropriate for the number of vehicles that would use the site. He emphasised that Longmead was a narrow cul-de-sac with restricted views.
Councillor S Bull stated that the application would have a detrimental impact on the amenity of No 8 Longmead . He also expressed concern that the social housing element of the development was concentrated in one corner of the site.
Councillor S Bull sought clarification of who would be responsible for maintaining the footpath located to the north of the site. He concluded that the proposed development was not compatible with the structure and layout of the surrounding area.
Councillor M Newman referred to this being a reserved matters application and he supported all of the reservations referred to by Councillor S Bull.
In response to concerns from Councillor S Bull regarding the maintenance of the footpath to the north of the site, the Director advised that a condition could be applied securing the necessary arrangements and stipulating that details must be submitted to and agreed by Officers prior to any development of the site.
Councillor S Bull expressed concern at the eligibility criteria for ‘free’ transport and the different mileage charging arrangements.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, referred to the inevitability of development on this site and he praised the considerable amount of work carried out by the applicant on this application.
Councillor Bull referred to the 9% decrease in the volume of the proposed storage and distribution centre. He stated however that he remained concerned about the HGV movements to and from the site.
Councillor Bull praised the applicant for reducing the visual impact of the application by substituting the proposed multi storey car park with a surface level car park. He expressed concern however, that the access was still from London Road as opposed to access only from the existing roundabout. He stated that he would like the application to be implemented with the minimum possible disruption for residents.
In respect of the draft Chapter 5, Councillor S Bull expressed concerns which he undertook to forward to Officers in writing. Members were advised that an amendment to recommendation (B) was being proposed, the effect of which would be to allow a further period of Member consultation until 21 December 2012 for any factual errors. Any comments made would be reported back to the next Panel meeting.
Councillor S Bull sought and was given clarification that the Council’s Landscape Officer had no concerns relating to the protection of trees subject to appropriate conditions. The Director referred in particular to conditions 7 to 11 in respect of trees and landscaping matters on the site.
Councillor S Bull stated that he was very impressed with the applicant’s proposals, especially in respect of the workforce opportunities, particularly for young people. He appreciated the residents’ concerns in respect of the narrow road access but felt that he could support the Officer’s recommendation for approval.
Councillor S Bull stated that he supported the views of the local Member and would be voting to refuse this application.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor M Alexander seconded, a motion that application 3/12/1485/SV be refused on the grounds that the Council was of the view that removing the restriction could lead to a harmful impact on the residential amenity ... view the full minutes text for item 398.
The Chairman reminded Members of the briefing due to be held on 17 October 2012 in respect of the Sainsburys site in Buntingford, at the Community Centre on the Bovis Estate and directions were available from Councillor S Bull.
Councillor S Bull praised Officers for safeguarding the conservation area. He referred to paragraph 4.1 of the report now submitted and queried whether it was correct that the illuminated advertisements were already in place and the only change was the name of the Post Office.
Councillor S Bull commented that the unauthorised development had been in place since May 2011 and the appellant had been given ample time to remove the marquee.
Councillor S Bull commented that this building had been in situ for very many years and it was not possible to determine the use of the building from the main road. He stated that, if Officers were satisfied that the appellant had not demonstrated a continuous use of the site for the required 4 years, then he would support the recommendation for enforcement action.
Councillor S Bull praised the difficult work carried out by the Enforcement Officers. The Chairman echoed this praise on behalf of the Development Control Committee.
It was noted that Councillor C Rowley was substituting for Councillor S Bull.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull regarding Housing Benefit, the Director of Internal Services stated the Council’s performance was broadly in line with other Local Authorities.
Councillor S Bull expressed his satisfaction that Albury Parish Council was supportive of the application. He stated that noise resulting from children and young people playing was a fact of life and he would be supporting this retrospective application.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor M Alexander seconded, a motion that o bjecting speakers would be permitted 10 minutes in total with the applicant being offered the same total time. This arrangement would apply to both applications and all speakers would be expected to provide a summary of the points they wished to raise. If there was obvious duplication then multiple speakers would be expected to coordinate to share the time allowed.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull, the Director stressed that no responses had been received from Standon Parish Council.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull, the Chairman confirmed that any further outstanding issues on this site would be addressed under delegated powers.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor G Jones.
Councillor S Bull commented that he was of the opinion that Braughing had taken its fair share of development and he had every sympathy with the residents but could not think of any planning policies for refusing the applications.
In response to queries from Councillor S Bull and N Symonds, the Director stated that the density of this development would be approximately 33 dwellings per hectare and the details of the colours of building materials was open for agreement with the developer.
Councillor S Bull praised the applicant and stated that the application should be supported as the outcomes for the rural area could only be positive.
Councillor M Newman proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded a motion that applications 3/12/0587/FP and 3/12/0588/FP be approved for a temporary period of 10 years.
Councillor S Bull stated that he did not agree with the previous comments of Members and he was of the view that the proposed development was out of keeping with the existing Grade II* Listed Building.
Councillor S Bull referred to the project aimed at encouraging people not to smoke. The Environmental Health Promotion Officer stated that those individuals were encouraged to seek the advice from professionals. The use of electronic cigarettes was discussed.
It was moved by Councillor R Beeching and seconded by Councillor C Woodward that Councillor S Bull be appointed as Vice Chairman for the Civic Year 2012/13.
RESOLVED – that Councillor S Bull be appointed Vice Chairman for the Civic Year 2012/13.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was in attendance as substitute for Councillor G Jones.
Councillor S Bull stated that the site was within the green belt. He expressed a degree of sympathy with the applicant but commented that he was unaware of any policies that could be used to overturn the Officer’s recommendation.
Councillor J Taylor proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that, in the event of an appeal against refusal of planning application 3/11/1190/FP, Officers advise the planning inspectorate that the appeal should be addressed by means of a full public inquiry.
Councillor M Alexander proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that the Head of Planning and Building Control be granted delegated authority, in consultation with the Vice-Chairman of the Committee, the Executive Member for Community Safety and Environment and the local ward Members for Walkern and Watton -at-Stone, to make appropriate operational decisions in relation to the appeal, including the sign off of submitted documents and the level and degree of representation.
Councillor S Bull also spoke in support of the application.
Councillor S Bull expressed concerns that this application constituted overdevelopment of the site and was contrary to policy GBC3 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007. He commented that the Parish Council had objected to the application and believed that the dwelling would be out of reach for first time buyers.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor J Demonti seconded, a motion that application 3/11/2006/FP be refused as the proposed development was contrary to policy GBC3 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007.
Councillor S Bull queried the cessation of free swimming for the 60plus age group. [name removed] explained that this was consistent with what was happening with other contracts locally. In terms of encouraging the 60plus age group to swim, he explained that the swimming timetable had been amended by the inclusion of another swimming “slot” for this age group.
Councillor M Alexander proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that the Committee accept the Officer’s recommendation as detailed in the report now submitted.
Councillor S Bull commented that Riversmead Housing Association was a very responsible organisation and Hertfordshire Highways had not sought to restrict planning permission for this application.
Councillor Bull also stressed that the scheme, if approved, would be temporary for one year.
Councillor G Jones proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded, a motion that there be no change to the ... view the full minutes text for item 595.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was substituting for Councillor Page.
Councillor S Bull stated that this application should be approved as granting this scheme would ensure the area would be cleaned up as the site was currently in a poor state. He commented that there were special circumstances for approving this application.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor J Taylor seconded, a motion that application 3/11/1765/OP be approved on the grounds that the impact on the openness of the site would be broadly neutral in comparison to the existing extent of built form, if not redeveloped, the condition of the site would continue to deteriorate, the development would not contribute to the merging of neighbouring settlements, the site constituted previously developed land and was therefore suitable ... view the full minutes text for item 522.
Councillor S Bull stated that Hormead Parish Council had commented that the pumping station was in a very attractive part of the parish and had requested that fencing sympathetic to the surrounding rural environment be provided to minimise its impact. He queried whether this request could be applied to this application.
In response to a further query from Councillor Bull, the Director stressed that the Parish Council had not stated what type of fencing would be preferred. Members were advised that Officers felt it was inappropriate to attach any conditions to the recommendation in relation to the style of fencing on the site.
Councillor S Bull commented that such applications should be welcomed in rural areas, particularly in light of the current financial climate.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor M Alexander seconded, a motion that application 3/11/1716/FP be deferred to allow the applicant to submit further information to prove that there was clear evidence that the proposed enterprise had been planned on a ‘sound financial basis’.
Councillor S Bull – member of Buntingford Town Council and local community centre.
The Chairman thanked Councillor S Bull for standing in as Chairman for the 20 September 2011 meeting of the Committee.
Councillor S Bull stated that Buntingford also had a very active Youth Council.
Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in application 3/11/1280/OP in that he was an acquaintance of the applicant and owner of the adjacent Tyre and Exhaust Business.
Councillor S Bull echoed the points raised by Councillor Basra, in particular, the point about the acceptable access from Baldock Road. He stated that the Environment Agency, Hertfordshire Highways and Buntingford Town Council had raised no objections.
Councillor Bull also urged the Committee to support this application.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor M Newman seconded, a motion that outline application 3/11/1280/OP ... view the full minutes text for item 412.
Councillor S Bull commented on whether the appellant had been given a reasonable opportunity to rectify this breach of planning control. The Director confirmed that there had been no response from the appellant to written correspondence from Officers.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor Mrs R Cheswright seconded, a motion that Enforcement Action be authorised in respect of E/11/0174/A in respect of unauthorised development at The Brambles, 117 High Street, Buntingford.
Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in the matters referred to under minute 383, in particularly the appeal decision in respect of application 3/10/2103/FP in that the appellant was Buntingford Town Council.
Councillor S Bull chaired the meeting.
Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in the matter referred to at Minute 306 – Monitoring and Review of the Homeless and Homeless Prevention Strategy Action Plan 2008 - 2013 on the grounds that he was the Council’s representative for South Anglia Housing Association.
Councillor S Bull appealed to Members to ensure they completed the Community Safety Questionnaire that had been circulated. He also urged the Committee to encourage the public to complete the questionnaire.
Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in application 3/11/1033/FP in that he was acquainted with many of the residents of Greenways, Buntingford.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member expressed concerns that the proposed flats would be visually intrusive and the development would be clearly visible from the A10. He emphasised the importance of the road markings being put in place at the bottom of Greenways as soon as the applicant started to implement the application.
Councillor Bull also emphasised the importance of appropriate screening of the development to protect the privacy of rear gardens. He stressed that obscured windows should be in place where there was a risk of overlooking.
Members were advised that the concerns of Councillor Bull were all covered by the conditions detailed in the report now submitted.
Councillor G Jones proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded a motion that application 3/11/0725/FP be refused on the grounds that the siting of the proposed dwellings would result in a harmful impact on the amenity of the occupiers of 14 and 18 Maple Avenue by virtue of their proximity and potential for overlooking, and would be harmful to the existing largely open character of the surroundings and would thereby be contrary to the aims and objectives of policies ENV1 and HSG7 of the East Herts Local Plan Second Review April 2007.
Councillor S Bull declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application 3/11/700/FO in that he was involved with the trust that had sold this site to the applicant. He left the room whilst this matter was considered.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, expressed concerns that vehicles would not be able to safely negotiate the archway to access this site. He referred to other access openings for this site.
Councillor S Bull proposed and Councillor Mrs R Cheswright seconded, a motion that application 3/11/0334/FP be granted as the balance of issues weighed in favour of taking a sensible approach and approving the application for safety reasons. The planning conditions would be delegated to Officers.
It was noted that Councillor P Moore was substituting for Councillor S Bull. Paul Thomas sent his apologies as he was on annual leave.
It was moved by Councillor Mrs D Hone and seconded by Councillor P Ruffles that Councillor S Bull be appointed as Vice Chairman for the Civic Year.
RESOLVED – that Councillor S Bull be appointed Vice Chairman for the Civic Year.
It was noted that Councillor S Bull was present as his substitute.
It was moved by Councillor Alexander and seconded by Councillor S Bull that Councillor S Rutland-Barsby be appointed Vice-Chairman of the Development Control Committee for the civic year 2011/12.
Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in application 3/10/2040/OP in that he was an acquaintance of the applicant and some of the objectors on this application.
Councillor S Bull, as the local ward Member, stated that this site was not within the settlement boundary of Buntingford. He believed that the application was not sustainable due to the poor levels of public transport and employment opportunities in the vicinity of the site. He expressed concerns in relation to the impact on Monks Walk, particularly around school times as the site lines made this a dangerous access situation.
Councillor Bull commented that there was a much safer access onto Baldock Road and Greenways. He felt this could be more satisfactory for the residents of Longmead. He also stated that he was pleased that both the entrance and exit from the site would be available in future.
Councillor S Bull expressed concerns that 3 storey houses of this scale were way out of context in a village like Braughing . He also stated that insufficient car parking was proposed, considering this application was for 5 bedroom houses.
In response to a query from Councillor S Bull, the Chairman confirmed that no representation had been received from Benington Parish Council.
Councillor J Taylor proposed and Councillor S Bull seconded a motion that application 3/11/0065/FP be approved and the conditions and, if required, a section 106 legal agreement be delegated to the Head of Planning and Building Control in consultation with the Chairman of the Development Control Committee.
Councillor S A Bull declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application 3/11/0039/RP in that he was a member of the Charity Trust that owned the land on which the houses would be built.
Councillor Bull left the room whilst this matter was considered.
Councillor S A Bull briefly summarised the planning history of the site.
It was noted that Councillor S A Bull was substituting for Councillor P R Ballam.
Councillor S A Bull stated that a pub in this location would be a key hub for Stocking Pelham. He urged the Committee to overturn the recommendation and approve the application then delegate the conditions to Officers. He stressed the continued loss of the pub would kill the community of Stocking Pelham.
Councillor Mrs M H Goldspink supported the views of Councillor Bull, and expressed concerns in relation to what would happen on the site if this application was refused. She stressed this pub was a very important community facility which should be supported.
Councillor S A Bull proposed and [name removed] seconded, a ... view the full minutes text for item 595a
Councillor S Bull referred to the problems of public transport in East Herts and the lack of information made available to residents in terms of what transport was available to hospitals.
Councillor S Bull referred to the difficulties parents had in being more active given the present day pressures on them in terms of both parents having to work. Officers acknowledged this stating that it was about making things manageable, e.g. that the family could all go for a walk to promote physical activity. The Environmental Health Promotion Officer explained that rates of physical activity had risen slightly according to the 2010 Active People’s survey conducted by Sports England, but there was still more which could be done.
Concerns were also expressed by Councillor S Bull who referred to the fact that some people were able to get transport via an ambulance from a GP referral service. He referred to the fact that it was about communicating this information to residents who were not aware of what help they could get especially, to and from hospitals.
Councillor S A Bull expressed concerns that, although he had sympathy with the applicant, approving this application could open the floodgates for inappropriate green belt development.
Councillor S A Bull highlighted the importance of affordable housing so that young people could continue to live in such villages.
Councillor S A Bull stressed that traffic from the site should be made to use the Buntingford bypass rather than coming through the High Street. He referred to the significant local objections that had been raised against the application.
Councillor Bull referred to the need to reduce the bunding close to the site access. He expressed concerns in relation to the impact of the application on the countryside and also the traffic implications of extra vehicles exiting onto the A507. He expressed concerns in relation to the sustainability of the application, which was more of a commercial use than farm diversification.
Councillor S A Bull proposed and Councillor R N Copping seconded a motion that application 3/10/1932/FP be approved subject to the conditions now detailed.
Councillor S A Bull expressed concerns relating to noise and health and safety if children could put their hands through gaps in the exposed unit. He stated that the unit should be boxed in and concealed as it was currently dangerous.
Welcome Councillor S Bull, the Chairman, welcomed all present and outlined the format and subject matter for the meeting. He stated the Officers were available to talk about the Core Strategy Issues and Options Consultation Document and the Parking Strategy.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Bull attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Sep 2016 | Council | East Herts Draft District Plan – Bishop’s Stortford – Settlement Appraisal and New Draft Chapter 5 | For | Carried | 26 for, 11 against, 2 abstained |
| 4 Mar 2015 | Council | Council Tax 2015/16 | For | Carried | 37 for, 0 against, 2 abstained |
| 5 Mar 2014 | Council | Council Tax 2014/15 - Formal Resolution | For | Carried | 36 for, 0 against, 2 abstained |
| 19 Feb 2014 | Council | Consolidated Budget report 2014/15 and Medium Term Financial Plan | For | Carried | 36 for, 2 against, 0 abstained |
Meetings Councillor Bull was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 0 of 4 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Bull declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 Oct 2018 | Council, item 219 | In respect of Minute 223 – Buntingford Community Governance Review, Councillor S Bull declared a non-pecuniary interest as a Buntingford Town Council Member. | |
| 6 Nov 2013 | Development Management Committee, item 329 | Councillor S Bull declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in application 3/13/0513/FP, in that he received a pension from the Co-op. He left the room whilst this matter was considered. | Left the room |
| 14 Aug 2013 | Development Management Committee, item 181 | Councillor S Bull declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in application 3/12/2063/FP, due to his involvement with South Anglia Housing Association. He left the room whilst this matter was considered. | Left the room |
| 19 Jun 2013 | Development Management Committee, item 68 | Councillor S Bull declared a disclosable pecuniary interest in applications 3/13/0513/FP and 3/13/0518/LC, in that he received a pension from the Co-op. He left the room whilst these matters were considered. | Left the room |
| 9 Nov 2011 | Development Management Committee, item 405 | Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in application 3/11/1280/OP in that he was an acquaintance of the applicant and owner of the adjacent Tyre and Exhaust Business. | |
| 12 Oct 2011 | Development Management Committee, item 364 | Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in the matters referred to under minute 383, in particularly the appeal decision in respect of application 3/10/2103/FP in that the appellant was Buntingford Town Council. | |
| 20 Sep 2011 | Community Scrutiny Committee, item 301 | Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in the matter referred to at Minute 306 – Monitoring and Review of the Homeless and Homeless Prevention Strategy Action Plan 2008 - 2013 on the grounds that he was the Council’s representative for South Anglia Housing Association. | |
| 14 Sep 2011 | Development Management Committee, item 286 | Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in application 3/11/1033/FP in that he was acquainted with many of the residents of Greenways, Buntingford. | |
| 22 Jun 2011 | Development Management Committee, item 98 | Councillor S Bull declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application 3/11/700/FO in that he was involved with the trust that had sold this site to the applicant. He left the room whilst this matter was considered. | Left the room |
| 25 May 2011 | Development Management Committee, item 25 | Councillor S Bull declared a personal interest in application 3/10/2040/OP in that he was an acquaintance of the applicant and some of the objectors on this application. | |
| 24 Mar 2011 | Development Management Committee, item 662 | Councillor S A Bull declared a personal and prejudicial interest in application 3/11/0039/RP in that he was a member of the Charity Trust that owned the land on which the houses would be built. |
Where Councillor Bull sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Nov 2022 | 3 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Development Management Committee | Substitute | Sep 2026 | 2 | 16 Dec 2026 |
| Human Resources Committee | Committee Member | Feb 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.