Election of Chairman
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman.
Every time East Lindsey's minutes name Councillor M.B.E., as the council published it.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman.
At the Indulgence of the Chairman, Councillor Fiona Martin highlighted that concerns in relation to attendance was not just limited to Executive Board Members and that the lack of sanctions other than the 6 month rule was largely ineffective.
Councillor Fiona Martin requested it be noted that she was a landowner in the Horncastle conservation area.
· Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that her grandson participated in the Teenage Markets in Horncastle, Item 8 ‘Report of the Chairman of Executive Board’ refers.
Councillor Fiona Martin left the room at 7.51pm and re-joined the Meeting at 7.55pm.
The Chairman advised Members that she had met with Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of Overview Committee to improve relationships between the Committees and to discuss agenda co-ordination, budget planning, the Memorandum of Understanding and the report on Invest East Lindsey Limited.
Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of Overview Committee presented the Annual Overview and Scrutiny Committee Report to Council 2025 for noting, pages 69 to 74 of the Agenda refer.
During her introduction, Councillor Martin asked that her thanks be passed to all members of the Overview Committee and all Members who had engaged with the scrutiny process over the last 12 months.
Councillor Martin referred to the topics covered by the Committee and Scrutiny Panels during the year and encouraged Members to put forward topic submissions for consideration and highlighted the Disabled Facilities Grant (DGF) as a worthy subject.
In response, Councillor Martin encouraged Members to submit a scrutiny topic suggestion form for the Committee’s consideration.
Councillor Ros Jackson, Chairman of the Audit and Governance Committee, thanked Councillor Martin for her contributions to the Overview Committee and highlighted the collaborative approach taken between the two committees.
In response, Councillor Martin expressed appreciation for the supportive comments and noted that the Audit and Governance Committee already had a standing item on its work programme relating to LGR.
Councillor Fiona Martin left the room at 8.21pm and re-joined the Meeting at 8.25pm.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman and upon being put to the vote, it was
Councillor Fiona Martin asked that it be noted that in relation to Agenda Item 12 she was on the Shareholder Supervisory Board for Invest East Lindsey.
· Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of the Overview Committee thanked Councillor Simpson and the members of the panel for their input into the report and reassured Members that once a response had been received from Executive Board, the recommendations agreed would be added to the Scrutiny Recommendation Tracker for monitoring.
Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of Overview Committee presented the Annual Overview Committee Report to Council for noting, pages 35 to 44 of the Agenda refer.
During her introduction, Councillor Martin asked that her thanks be passed to all members of the Overview Committee and all Members who had engaged with the scrutiny process over the last 12 months and stated that it was refreshing to see lots of new Councillors getting involved in the process which brought fresh ideas forward.
Councillor Martin referred to the Joint Scrutiny Programme across the Partnership and highlighted that the work undertaken was progressing very well and was pleased to see that some excellent topic suggestions had been put forward from the Executive Board.
In response, Councillor Martin stated that all scrutiny reports were presented to Council, and once agreed by the relevant Portfolio Holder were added to the Committee’s Recommendation Tracker which was reviewed at each Overview Committee Meeting. This was a robust process and was pleased to report that the percentage of scrutiny panel recommendations that were accepted had risen from 80% to 90% in 2023/24.
That 3 Executive Board Members (Councillors Tom Kemp, Craig Leyland and Martin Foster), the Chairman of the Overview Committee (Cllr Fiona Martin), the Chief Executive (Rob Barlow), the Section 151 Officer (Christine Marshall) and the Deputy Chief Executive – Programme Delivery (Adrian Sibley) be appointed to the Invest East Lindsey Shareholder Supervisory Board for a term of four years.
Councillor Fiona Martin requested that it be noted that in relation to Agenda Item 11(a) she was a previous member of the Invest East Lindsey Shareholders Panel.
At this point in the meeting, Councillor Fiona Martin requested that it be noted that in relation to Agenda Item 11 (a) she was a previous member of the Invest East Lindsey Shareholders Panel, however, would remain in the Meeting to speak on the item.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman and upon being put to the vote, it was
Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of Overview Committee thanked Councillor Yarsley and the Panel for an excellent report.
In relation to the questions raised, Councillor Martin highlighted that these should have been raised at a much earlier stage in the scrutiny process, however advised Members that the report and its recommendations would be considered by the ... view the full minutes text for item 15a
Councillor Fiona Martin thanked Councillor Bristow for chairing the Panel and highlighted to Members the history of the Council’s provision of public toilets over the last 30 years. Whilst it was considered important to review toilet provision and was a step forward, it was acknowledged that this would be a long journey.
Flood Support Councillor Martin asked it be noted that the donation of £2k should read Horncastle Town Council, not Centre. Thanks were also conveyed to all ELDC staff who worked so hard after the flood to support Members and administered the grants which had been widely and gratefully accepted It was highlighted that the Environment Agency’s (EA) report on the flooding had just been published which raised a lot of concerns and it was suggested that Overview Committee should undertake some scrutiny work around this.
· Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman asked it be noted that she was a member of the Horncastle Support Team, Minute No. 33 refers and that she was a Member of the Invest East Lindsey Advisory Board, Minute No 38 refers.
Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman asked it be noted that she was a member of the Horncastle Support Team.
Annual Scrutiny of Partnership The Membership was confirmed as Councillor Fiona Martin, Councillor Carleen Dickinson, Councillor Claire Arnold and Councillor George Horton as Substitute.
Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of Overview Committee presented the Annual Overview Committee update to Council for noting.
During her introduction, Councillor Martin thanked all Members and officers who had committed their time to the various Panels, both at ELDC and on the Joint Scrutiny Panel for the Partnership.
Councillor Martin also welcomed the new Members of Overview Committee following the elections and noted the renewed enthusiasm.
Councillor Martin asked that recognition be given to Councillor Jill Makinson-Sanders for her work as Chairman on the ‘To explore the issues surrounding caravan licensing and enforcement’ Scrutiny Panel as the final report was exemplar and a piece of work that the Council should be proud of.
· Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that she was a Member of the Invest East Lindsey Stakeholder Board, Minute No. 12 (a) refers and after taking advice from the Monitoring Officer stated that she would remain in the Meeting for this item.
At this point in the Meeting, Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman advised Members that she was a Member of the Invest East Lindsey (IEL) Stakeholder Board, and after taking advice from the Monitoring Officer stated that she would remain in the Meeting for this item.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman and upon being put to the vote, it was
Councillor Fiona Martin congratulated Councillor Makinson-Sanders on an excellent report and looked forward to receiving the response at Overview Committee.
Following a query over adding timelines to the recommendations, as a Point of Clarification Councillor Martin explained the procedure of tracking these through Overview Committee. ... view the full minutes text for item 15a
Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that she was a Member of the Invest East Lindsey Advisory Board, Minute No. 93 (b) refers.
Councillor Martin, as Chairman of Overview Committee had also expressed her disappointment regarding attendance. Notwithstanding that, a recent scrutiny panel on caravan licensing and enforcement had been oversubscribed and Overview Committee looked forward to its recommendations in due course. In terms of the effectiveness of scrutiny, it was highlighted that item 11 on the agenda, Sutton on Sea Broadway Car Park Resurfacing had been withdrawn as a result of a scrutiny review questioning the car park income for further consideration prior to consideration at the December Council Meeting.
Councillor Fiona Martin, as Chairman of Overview Committee expressed her thanks to Councillor Smith and the Scrutiny Panel and looked forward to a formal response from the Portfolio Holder for Planning in due course to enter into the Overview Committee Recommendation Tracker. It was noted that the Sustainable Product Policy had also been reviewed by Overview Committee.
· Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that she was a Board Member on Invest East Lindsey, Minute No. 26 refers.
At this point in the Meeting, Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman asked it be noted that she was a Board Member on Invest East Lindsey.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman and upon being put to the vote, it was
· Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that she was a member of the Invest East Lindsey Shareholder Supervisory Board, Minute No. 106 refers.
At this point in the Meeting, Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that she was a member of the Invest East Lindsey Shareholder Supervisory Board.
Councillor Martin, as Chairman of Overview Committee advised that this project had been considered by the Overview Committee Projects Group, comments had been taken into account and the matter would be reported back to Overview Committee.
· Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of Overview Committee asked it be noted that she was a Trustee of the Horncastle Support Team., Minute No. 77(a) refers.
At this point in the Meeting, Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of Overview Committee asked it be noted that she was a Trustee of the Horncastle Support Team.
· Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that she was a member of the Council’s Supervisory Board to Invest East Lindsey, however, was not a Member on Invest East Lindsey’s Board, Minute No.
The Chairman of Overview Committee, Councillor Fiona Martin presented the Annual Overview Report for the period August 2020 to July 2021 for noting. Members noted that the report had been endorsed by the Overview Committee, Overview Committee Minute No. 39 refers.
During her introduction Councillor Martin made particular reference to the joint scrutiny undertaken with Boston Borough Council (BBC) on the proposal for South Holland District Council (SHDC) to become part of the Alliance.
Councillor Martin advised that it had been a pleasure to work jointly with BBC and looked forward to undertaking further joint scrutiny work across the Alliance in the future.
Councillor Mossop, as Vice Chairman of Overview Committee extended his thanks to Councillor Martin for her work and endorsed the plea for more volunteers.
2) That Councillor Fiona Martin, as Chairman of the Joint Scrutiny Panel of the Strategic Partnership be nominated to respond to any questions on the scrutiny process relating to the South East Lincolnshire Councils Partnership .’ RESOLVED 1) That Council Procedure Rules be suspended to allow Group Leaders or their nominees to speak for longer than 5 minutes on one occasion.
2) That Councillor Fiona Martin, as Chairman of the Joint Scrutiny Panel of the Strategic Partnership be nominated to respond to any questions on the scrutiny process relating to the South East Lincolnshire Councils Partnership.
The Chairman of Executive Board invited Councillor Martin to comment as a ward Councillor for Horncastle.
Councillor Martin supported the recommendation and agreed that full involvement of the ward Councillors was essential and looked forward to the knowledge gained being used to benefit other town centres. The Portfolio Holder for Better Ageing was supportive and considered this was a great opportunity for Horncastle and hoped this would lead to the establishment of a trade association.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman and upon being put to the vote, it was
The Chairman of Executive Board invited Councillor Martin as Chairman of Overview Committee to present the report.
In her introduction, Councillor Martin made particular reference to recommendation 8; early consideration by Overview Committee in future work to enable a timely response. The recommendations were noted as:
Finally, Councillor Martin also expressed her thanks to the Scrutiny Panel and to Rebecca James for her assistance. ... view the full minutes text for item 91a
Councillor Martin, as Chairman of Overview Committee echoed the comments of the Chairman of Executive Board in conveying thanks to all staff.
Councillor Martin also wished to mention the Housing Standards Team for their excellent work in Horncastle.
Councillor Martin highlighted two final scrutiny reports on the agenda this evening which demonstrated that scrutiny work was continuing. The Member Point Brief later this week would advertise for scrutiny topics for the coming year and Members were encouraged to put any topics forward.
The Chairman of Executive Board acknowledged the report and passed his thanks to Councillor Martin as Chair of Overview Committee and the Committee for their work in supporting the Executive Board.
Councillor Parkin as Vice Chair of Overview Committee, wished to recognise the leadership shown by Councillor Martin as Chair of Overview Committee, particularly at this difficult time.
In response, Councillor Martin as Chair of Overview advised that the Overview pre-meeting had discussed previous recommendations in respect of the impact of Covid 19.
Councillor Martin advised that it would be helpful if any Member who had chaired a recent Scrutiny Panel and considered it worth reflecting on recommendations would contact herself or Alison Penn.
Finally, Councillor Martin thanked all for their positive comments and kind words and agreed that 70% was a respectable percentage.
The Chairman of Executive Board invited Councillor Fiona Martin as Chairman of Overview Committee to comment.
Councillor Martin advised that the Budget Report had not been presented to Overview Committee at this point. Discussions had taken place with the Portfolio Holder for Finance and the S151 Officer with a view to timetabling in consideration by Overview in future. It was noted that the draft Budget would be included as part of the next Reserved Member Day in February to which all Councillors were invited.
Members received an update from Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of the Healthy Conversations Working Group.
(Councillor Martin left the Meeting at 8.53pm).
(Councillor Martin entered at 8.58pm).
Councillor Martin abstained as she had not been absent from the room for part of the debate.
Councillor Fiona Martin, as Chairman of Overview Committee was pleased that work undertaken by the Scrutiny Panel on East Lindsey District Council’s Relationships with Housing Associations, as noted at Council on 18 th July 2018, Minute No. 31a refers had formed the basis for this report.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman and upon being put to the vote, it was
Councillor Martin asked that further discussion took place on the allocation of seats to the Employment Committee with regard to the Liberal/Democrat and New East Lindsey Independent Group. It was noted that this would be discussed at a future date.
During discussion, Councillor Martin as previous the Chairman of Overview Committee made reference to the proposed dates for Overview Committee and requested that these were discussed further to enable a better spread of Overview Meetings throughout the year. The Chairman of Executive Board had no objection to this.
Councillor Martin asked it be noted in respect of Item 108, Compass Point Business Services Options, that she was a Director of Compass Point Business Services;
The Chairman of the Conservation Panel, Councillor Fiona Martin presented the report of the Conservation Scrutiny Panel.
In introducing the report Councillor Martin extended her thanks to all involved in the scrutiny exercise. This was noted as a challenging piece of work, but completed within the timeframe allowed. The responses to consultation were attached as an Appendix to the report presented.
Councillor Martin drew Members’ attention to the conclusion on page 196 that recognised the important role that these areas played in promoting and enhancing the district. N.B.
Councillor Martin advised that her experience of the process in Horncastle was most positive and hoped that Alford would have a similar positive experience.
Members received a verbal update from Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of the ‘East Lindsey Conservation Areas’ Scrutiny Panel.
Members received a verbal update from Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman of the ‘East Lindsey Conservation Areas’ Scrutiny Panel.
Councillor Fiona Martin asked that it be noted in respect of Minute No. 29, Delegated Authority for Horncastle Town Council to make planning decisions, as a Member of Horncastle Town Council that she would remain for the debate but not vote on the item.
In his introduction the Portfolio Holder for Planning in moving the proposal to approve recommendations 1, 2 and 3 as set out at page 39 of the Agenda, advised that it was a rare privilege to stand in front of Members and recommend adoption of the Local Plan, noting that only Councillor Fiona Martin had served throughout its entire compilation.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin be elected Chairman and upon being put to the vote, it was
Myers Members recalled that the planning application for this cul-de-sac of all six properties was approved at Planning Committee in October 2016 after being called in by Councillor Martin in order to assess the impact on the neighbours. Whilst this new application to amend two of the plots had not been called in the applicant was related to a staff member of the planning department.
· Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that she was a Director of Compass Point Business Services Ltd., (Minute No.
Councillor Martin asked it be noted with regard to Minute No. 90, Compass Point Business Services (Options), that she was a Council Appointee to the Board of Compass Point Business Services and would not vote on the item;
· Councillor Fiona Martin (Chairman) asked it be noted that she was a Director of Compass Point Business Services Ltd., and would not Chair this item to enable her to partake in full discussion, Minute No. 68 refers;
Councillor Sarah Dodds, Vice-Chairman took the Chair due to Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman declaring an interest as a Director of Compass Point Business Services Limited (CPBS).
· Councillor Fiona Martin asked it be noted that she was a Director of Compass Point Business Services (CPBS), Minute No. 34 refers.
· Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman asked it be noted that she was a Director of CPBS, Minute No. 11 refers.
It was Proposed by Councillor Sarah Dodds and Seconded by Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E that Councillor Anthony John Howard be elected as Chairman of the Council.
Councillor Martin, in seconding Councillor Howard advised that Councillor Howard had been an excellent Vice Chairman of the Council for the past year and had also been an excellent Mayor of Mablethorpe and Sutton.
Organisation Places Nominations(s) Received Appointment 2017/18 Age UK Lindsey 1 Councillor Graham Marsh Councillor Graham Marsh Alford Grammar School Foundation 1 Councillor Sarah Devereux Councillor Sarah Devereux Compass Point Business Services (East Coast) Limited 2 + 1 Officer* Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E.
Councillor Paul Hibbert -Greaves Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E.
Members must be serving Members of the East Lindsey District Council Overview Committee) Councillor Jill Makinson -Sanders Councillor Councillor Pauline Watson Councillor Councillor Pauline Watson Councillor William Gray (Res.) Lincolnshire Flood Risk and Drainage Management Committee 1 + Substitute Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E.
Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E.
Overview Committee comments had been provided to Executive Board and Councillor Martin made particular reference to:
· Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman asked it be noted that she was a Director of CPBS, Minute No. 94 refers.
Councillor Martin asked that it be noted that she was a Director of Compass Point Business Services (East Coast) Ltd as a non pecuniary interest in respect of Minute No. 101, Compass Point Business Plan.
Councillor Martin re-joined the Meeting at 6.47pm.
Councillor Martin asked that it be noted with regard to Minute No. 83 (Budget) that she was a Director of Compass Point Business Services (CPBS).
Councillor Martin highlighted a typographical error to the report of the Working Group as the incorrect date had been entered into the header of the document, this should read 22 February 2017.
· Councillor Fiona Martin, Chairman asked it be noted that she was a Director of Compass Point Business Services.
It was proposed and seconded that Councillor Fiona Martin, MBE be elected Chairman and upon being put to the vote, it was
It was Proposed by Councillor Cullen and Seconded by Councillor Martin M.B.E., that Councillor Howard be elected as Vice Chairman of the Council.
Councillor Martin added that Councillor Howard had done an excellent job previously as Mayor of Mablethorpe .
(Director positions) The appointment of the Chief Executive to the Board of Directors is referenced in the Council Constitution Councillor Paul Hibbert -Greaves Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E.
First College Councillor William Gray Councillor Helen Matthews Greater Lincolnshire Local Enterprise Partnership Councillor Craig Leyland Health Scrutiny for Lincolnshire Councillor Pauline Watson Councillor Neil Jones (Sub) Lincolnshire Police & Crime Panel Councillor Graham Marsh Lincolnshire Flood and Drainage Management Partnership Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E.
He added that Councillor Leyland and Councillor Martin had signposted the ... view the full minutes text for item 15a
In seconding the Proposal Councillor Fiona Martin extended her thanks to the team in Horncastle who had worked on the plan, and also to the Officers at East Lindsey District Council. Following which, it was agreed that thanks be placed on record to those involved in this work.
Finally, the Chairman extended his congratulations to the Horncastle Neighbourhood Development Group and asked Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E. to pass on congratulations to the Group.
In the absence of the Portfolio Holder for Partnerships, Councillor Graham Marsh and the Director of Compass Point Business Services, Councillor Fiona Martin M.B.E., the Portfolio Holder for Finance presented the report.
o Councillor Fiona Martin declared an interest as a Member of the Compass Point Business Services Board.
Councillor Guyatt to pass to Councillor Martin list of ideas for 2016 scrutiny panels in the 1 st week of January for the 3 rd February Overview meeting. · Completed. This action had been delayed due to the delay in firming up the draft budget.
At this point Councillor Martin declared an interest as a Member of the Compass Point Business Services Board.
Councillor Martin, as Chairman of Overview Committee referred to recommendation (d) of the report, ‘ A managed approach to community use of car parks for events/activities – No change to current policy, but the current process be reviewed to ensure it is consistent across the district, and appropriate to the needs of the event and the location. ’ Councillor Martin highlighted that this was not picked up within the covering report to Executive Board and welcomed clarification of this, along with provision of a timeframe for changes as part of the written response to Overview Committee on 3 February 2016. The Chairman of Executive Board advised that this would be picked up through the Portfolio Holder Meeting, this being the most timely way to action changes to fees and charges. Following which, it was RESOLVED That the appreciation of Executive Board be formally recorded for the work of the Scrutiny Panel in bringing forward its recommendations;
Councillor Martin was pleased to report that the current round of scrutiny committees was oversubscribed and a similar enthusiasm was evident for training provided in the Induction period and the recent Report Writer training.
Councillor Fiona Martin, M.B.E.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor M.B.E. attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
No recorded votes at Councillor M.B.E.'s meetings yet.
Meetings Councillor M.B.E. was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 12 of 18 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor M.B.E. declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
| Date | Where | What the minutes say | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Feb 2016 | Overview Committee, item 64 | o Councillor Fiona Martin declared an interest as a Member of the Compass Point Business Services Board. | |
| 3 Feb 2016 | Overview Committee, item 67 | At this point Councillor Martin declared an interest as a Member of the Compass Point Business Services Board. |
Where Councillor M.B.E. sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overview Committee | Chairman | Oct 2025 | 10 | 8 Dec 2026 |
| Council | Committee Member | Oct 2025 | 7 | |
| Executive Board | Observer | Sep 2025 | 3 | 9 Dec 2026 |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Guest | Feb 2026 | 1 | 13 Jan 2027 |
| Scrutiny Panel - Car Parking in East Lindsey | Committee Member | Sep 2025 | 3 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.