Councillor Lynn Wetenhall
The Leader moved the recommendation, seconded by Councillor Moore.
Every time Exeter's minutes name Councillor Moore, as the council published it.
The Leader moved the recommendation, seconded by Councillor Moore.
In response to a question from Councillor Moore on the Royal Clarence Hotel, Councillor Knott advised that this question could be submitted to him in writing and he would respond as Portfolio Holder for City Development.
Councillor Moore asked a question on the Strata Business Plan, and Councillor Knott advised that this was a question for the Leader of the Council, Councillor Bialyk.
Councillor Terry moved, and Councillor Moore seconded a Notice of Motion in the following terms:
Councillor Moore asked for an expected timeline for the introduction of the negotiated stopping policy.
Councillor Moore asked about antisocial behaviour, noting that while the committee minutes explained why no changes could be made, she wished to understand how the Council’s wider objectives and licensing objectives could be considered. She requested that the chair ensure the scrutiny committee’s intentions were followed through, particularly in relation to access to alcohol in the city centre and its impact on antisocial behaviour.
In accordance with Standing Order No.8, the following question was put by Councillor Moore to the Portfolio Holder for Housing, Homelessness Prevention and Customer Services:
In asking a supplementary question, Councillor Moore thanked the Portfolio Holder for the response and requested that the information be shared more widely with residents. She noted that many residents were asking about the issue and emphasised the need to reassure the public that the Council was improving how it supported people quickly.
Councillor Moore proposed, and Councillor Rees seconded, the Green Group amendments to the budget in the following terms:
The Chair invited Councillor Moore to speak under Standing Order No. 44, who made reference to:
No Member questions were raised for Councillor Moore.
In responses to questions from Members, Councillor Moore made the following further points:
In accordance with Standing Order No. 20, the following question was submitted by Councillor Moore in relation to the Portfolio of Councillor Bialyk who attended the meeting. The question was circulated at the meeting to Members of the Committee.
Councillor Moore asked the Portfolio Holder for Climate, Ecological Change and Communities, Councillor Vizard how the Adaptation Strategy would be incorporated into city council work?
Councillor Moore asked the Leader if he was confident in the budget proposals, and to what extent the Medium Term Financial Plan (MTFP) was still relevant given the Fair Funding Review 2.0 outcomes?
The Leader advised Councillor Moore that he was confident that this would be right, and that there would be a more in-depth discussion on the matter at the Executive and the Council’s meeting to set the budget for 2026/27.
In respect of Minute No.94 – Housing Rents and Services Charges 2026-27 , Councillor Moore asked the Leader about convergence rents and was concerned that it may not be clear to tenants how much their rent would increase. The Leader advised that he would obtain details from the Strategic Director for Corporate Resources but would be disappointed if this matter had not been discussed at the Council Housing and Development Advisory Board.
Councillor Moore, as Leader of the Green Group, made the following points: thanked the Portfolio Holder for working with Councillors over a number of years; she had seen the impact of the CST and appreciated their efforts; there was a need for better advocation and joining up services for people who were street attached; and there was a gap in the budget, how would this be funded?
The Council is currently working to identify the risks. ” In accordance with Standing Order No.8, the following question was put by Councillor Moore to the Leader: “Now the Brown Field Release grant funding has been returned to Government, what options or plans are the Council considering for the future of the Council’s Belle Isle site once the depot moves to an alternative location?” The Leader responded stating: “The site would need to be subject to a feasibility assessment to evaluate site constraints and opportunities. This process would also require commercial and planning input together with any wider consultation deemed necessary.
The outcome would enable Officers to report on available land use options and associated delivery arrangements.” In a supplementary question, Councillor Moore asked the Leader: “Given that the Environment Agency said the site was not suitable for development due to flood risk what sort of feasibility do you think they would be able to undertake?” The Leader advised that he would ask one of the Directors to respond to this question outside of the meeting.
During discussion Councillor Moore asked the Portfolio Holder to provide an update on what had been done regarding following up points made previously, and when the minutes of the Community Safety Partnership would be published.
Councillor Vizard informed Councillor Moore that Safer Exeter had not met since the Customer Focus Scrutiny Committee on 25 September, but the issues were being picked up and would inform the work carried out with Safer Exeter partner organisations.
Councillor Moore asked the Leader what provision there would be to protect partisan decisions that would leave Members open to liabilities.
The Leader advised Councillor Moore that any Councillor acting within the Constitution would be protected and that he would support the recommendations of the Monitoring Officer.
Councillor Moore thanked the Net Zero Team and hoped this would have a significant impact on the emissions at St Sidwell’s Point. She felt it very important to clarify where the funds were coming from as soon as possible and asked the Portfolio Holder to provide information about the impact this would have on gas boiler use.
The Leader advised that a response to Councillor Moore would be given after the meeting.
During debate Councillor Moore was interested to hear the Leader’s opinion and understand the cautious approach to borrowing. She was concerned that this could put the Council at risk in the short to medium term.
In accordance with Standing Order No.8, the following question was put by Councillor Moore to the Leader, Councillor Bialyk:
In a supplementary question Councillor Moore stated that Exeter City Council was a significant landowner in the area and needed to be committed to working with Devon County Council. She also felt that the Leader needed to work with the Leader of Devon County Council to identify issues and asks.
Councillor Moore proposed, and Councillor Read seconded, that the committee recommend to Licensing that their policies be reviewed with regard to out of hours off-sales of alcohol. Following a vote, this was CARRIED.
The Portfolio Holder responded to Members’ questions in the following terms: each department was coming up with plans, ideas, and mitigations to work towards net zero and he would respond outside the meeting with regard to what had been done differently as a result of carbon literacy training and the roadmap; Inclusive Exeter provided an important contribution and he spoke with them intermittently but would aim to provide a bridge between communities and the council as he had heard this evening that people did not feel seen and heard; he asked that Cllr Moore put her question to him via email about disposing of assets as it may fall under the portfolio of the Leader; and the oversight of the city grants also sat with the ward Councillors and the community builders. The city grants budget was approximately one third spent, and they received a healthy number of applications each round.
The Leader advised that questions submitted in advance by Councillor Moore would be answered in writing by the Strategic Director for Operations.
he highlighted the submission of Councillor Diana Moore, who was unable to attend the meeting;
In respect of Minute No.18 Chair’s Announcements , Councillor Moore asked for clarity regarding the floating restaurant and why it continued to be on the agenda.
In respect of Minute No. 45 Pendragon Road Councillor Moore asked for clarification regarding access points to the site, and the expected greenspace that would be connected to this development.
In accordance with Standing Order No.8, the following question was put by Councillor Moore to the Leader:
No interim training facilities have been requested.” In a supplementary question, Councillor Moore stated that there had been discussions about interim arrangements and the need to spend their grant by September to ensure it could be spent, she asked Councillor Wood if he would be able to have an urgent conversation with Exeter Spitfires about these issues.
Councillor Moore was disappointed that the Leader had not reached out to other groups to collect their views, and that the views they had sent in had not been reported in the Corporate Plan.
Councillor Moore asked for clarity regarding the nature outcome and hoped this would be addressed.
Councillor Moore as opposition group leader raised the following points and questions:
Councillor Moore as an opposition group leader raised the following points and questions:
Councillor Moore asked the Portfolio Holder for City Management whether the food waste roll-out would be complete this year and Councillor Ruth Williams responded that the planned end was 2025/26 but it may be that this would stretch into 2026/27.
Councillor Moore asked the Portfolio Holder for City Management what preparation was taking place for doorstep glass collection roll-out and Councillor Ruth Williams responded that there were no plans at present as there was not funding. She added that were there to be funding for extra crews and vehicles then this would be considered and that current arrangements were doing well compared to other Devon districts and black bin comparisons were comparable to others who had doorstep glass collection.
Councillor Moore proposed a motion, seconded by Councillor Holland, that the Customer Focus Scrutiny Committee request that the Executive Findings from this work are sent to government with a request that Local Authorities were given more powers when deciding when empty property rates relief can legitimately be granted.
Councillor Read and Councillor Moore accepted the amendment proposed by Councillor Pole and following a vote was unanimously CARRIED.
To do that, we need to work together.” Councillor Moore moved scrutiny procedural rule number 16 requested that any party whip be disclosed.
In respect of Minute No. 65 Portfolio Holder report – Portfolio Holder for Leisure Services and Healthy Living, Councillor Moore stated that she had asked a question regarding the governance models for the Wonford Community Hub, how that decision would be made and whether the answer would be put on the website to enable the community to understand.
Councillor Moore questioned the significant underspend in some areas of the Council budget and asked how the Executive planned to build capacity to deliver against the budget.
During debate Councillor Moore commented on the Mallinson Bridge, and asked what Exeter City Council (ECC) were doing to request that Devon County Council report to ECC and explain why these delays had been allowed to happen, and whether Mallinson Bridge must be used for walking and cycling.
Councillor Moore speaking as opposition co-leader, welcomed some of the items in this budget, particularly the issues surrounding long-term leases to secure temporary accommodation.
Councillor Moore raised that there was already a car park near the site and stated that in December 2024 the Executive agreed that in early 2025 a proposal would be brought forward for the development of this site. General Fund Report highlighted costs associated with the demolition of the bus station, roughly £46,000 spare. There was money available to turn it into a meanwhile use car park and meanwhile use gives up opportunity to explore other things on the site.
Councillor Moore, as co-Leader of the Progressive Group, stated that when she joined as a councillor she was concerned about how this would affect people, especially those who were street-attached. The data provided was very helpful, and the new community safety team had been learning how to take action under the PSPO. There had been positive feedback from businesses and it would take the whole community to deal with this and provide support.
Councillor Moore moved and was seconded by Councillor Banyard, a Notice of Motion in the following terms:
The Chair proposed, seconded by Councillor Moore and following a unanimous vote it was AGREED :
In respect of Minute No. 9 Planning Application no. 23/1007/out - Water Lane (South), Exeter, EX2 8BZ, Councillor Moore asked how the Planning Committee considered the lack of affordable housing in the Water Lane application.
In respect of Minute No. 49 Update on Exeter Community Lottery first year of operation , Councillor Moore asked if the issue raised of 52p not 60p in the pound going to good causes would be investigated as a matter of urgency.
In respect of Minute No. 49 City Wide Net Zero programme of work and update on delivery, Councillor Moore asked if it was sufficient to wait for the grid to decarbonise.
In respect of Minute No. 58 Questions from Members of the Council under Standing Order No. 20, Councillor Moore asked how the energy plant would contribute to net zero ambitions given that it would be reliant on fossil fuels.
In respect of Minute No. 4 Matter referred by Scrutiny Committees, Councillor Moore asked if commercial use of public assets could be included in the scope of the review and whether the Council could identify meanwhile uses for community groups where box-shifting was concerned. The Leader responded that he would not be prescriptive on the use of public assets and he would mention this to the team when appropriate and the Council would be open to looking at options for meanwhile uses but must be mindful of maintenance and leases.
Councillor Moore moved and was seconded by Councillor Mitchell an amendment to the recommendations in the following terms:
In presenting the amendment Councillor Moore stated that this would ensure that a review looked at all options.
Councillor Moore asked when there would be an SPD regarding co-living and the Leader agreed to respond outside the meeting.
In respect of Minute No. 23 Household Support Fund Scheme 7, the Leader presented the report and during debate Councillor Moore stated that she supported the fund but asked how support could be provided given that many residents were living in poverty, rather than the crisis management provided by this fund.
Councillor Wright agreed with Councillor Moore in regard to their shock at the areas of deprivation within the city but stated that targeting support where possible could be seen and committed to consider a briefing on the areas where this work could be seen.
Councillor Moore proposed an addition to the recommendations which following discussion was deemed unnecessary and withdrawn.
Councillor Moore suggested that the committee may wish to respond as a whole but upon discussion it was not deemed that there was sufficient time to do so.
Councillor Moore:- · raised the issue of data recording, remarking that Citizens Advice Exeter had sent regular updates to ECC;
Councillor Moore stressed the importance of the output of any consultation and remarked on a line in the report about the publication of complaints about consultations. The Chief Executive advised that Exeter City Council accepted that it had not been compliant with regard to the publication of complaints about consultations, adding that these would be published.
On the subject of General Fund Capital, Councillor Moore called for a more strategic approach to investment. She asked if it was possible to change the reporting format to see what was active and what was possible. The Strategic Director – Corporate Resources explained that all the reports being presented were produced for Members, adding that he was always available to provide clarity if needed and would welcome views on how to make the reports more usable.
On the subject of the Housing Revenue Account, Councillor Moore remarked that she had no seen anything from the Council Housing and Development Advisory Board ( CHaDAB ) being fed back to the Executive. The Strategic Director – Corporate Resources informed that he would speak to the Monitoring Officer about CHaDAB reporting back.
Responding to final question from Councillor Moore about how Scrutiny could be the most impactful about the Budget, the Strategic Director – Corporate Resources noted that:- · this was the first instalment of the budget monitoring exercise;
Councillor Moore remarked that the Capital Programme hadn’t been delivered because of lack of capacity and asked for Members to be kept updated on this. She also enquired which Councillors would be considering the range of options for the Budget. The Strategic Director – Corporate Resources replied that the tradition was that the ruling party or group had priority.
It was consequently moved by Councillor Parkhouse and seconded by Councillor Moore that the Customer Focus Scrutiny Committee approve the Work Plan as amended during the meeting. Following a vote, the recommendation was CARRIED unanimously.
In accordance with Standing Order No. 20, the following questions were submitted by Members:- Question from Councillor Moore to Councillor Asvachin, Portfolio Holder for Housing, Homelessness Prevention and Customer Services:- “In response to my enquiry over the summer, the Strategic Director People told me that between April 2019 - March 2024 there have been 35 homes investigated as potentially empty homes of which 17 were found to be not empty. There have been no compulsory purchases, issuing of an empty dwelling management order or an enforced sale. The Council’s Council Tax team are constantly investigating the status of properties proactively.
Councillor Moore was advised by the Chair that a written answer would be provided.
The Portfolio Holder also confirmed to Councillor Moore that ECC would be consulting with communities on neighbourhood CIL money after 2026.
Consequently, it was moved by Councillor Moore, and seconded by Councillor Fullam:- 1. that the item ‘Citizens Advice in Exeter’ be added to the agenda of the 28 November 2024 meeting of the Customer Focus scrutiny Committee; and 2. that the scoping of the item in question be delegated to the Scrutiny Programme Board at their 16 October 2024 meeting.
Proposal from Councillor Moore (as submitted) After discussion, it was moved by Councillor Moore, and seconded by Councillor ... view the full minutes text for item 34.
Councillor Moore stated that she was one of the complainants.
In accordance with Standing Order No. 20, the following questions were submitted by Councillor Moore and responses were given by Councillor Vizard, Portfolio Holder for Climate, Ecological Change and Communities.
Supplementary Question and Response Councillor Moore asked when enforcement would be put in place and Councillor Vizard answered that deadlines would be in place as with any planning application.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item as follows:- · Cllr Moore made the following points:- although parking tariffs contributed toward the transport challenges, it was important to address the volume of daily commuters coming into the city;
Councillor Moore remarked that there was a delay in the publication of the Community Safety Partnership (CSP) minutes and asked if this could be addressed in the name of good public communication.
Councillor Moore asked the Leader what involvement Portfolio Holders had in determining the various degrees of risk and testing the evidence in each risk calculation.
Councillor Bialyk reminded Councillor Moore of the context of the risk register going to Executive, explaining that, ultimately, Portfolio Holders were responsible for their portfolio area and that they were fully aware of the need to prioritise certain risks and issues.
Councillor Moore asked how the Leader would ensure that the expectations in the Budget around car parks income would be met.
Councillor Moore expressed support for the recommendations and encouraged the Council to consider extending the ... view the full minutes text for item 53.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – enquired on the how the Portfolio Holders would be involved in monitoring the reserve level for the General Fund, given there were a number of recurring items.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – commented on the Ash Die Back budget which had been unspent for a number of years and needed to be invested into biodiversity projects and tree planting to address the risk of Ash Die Back.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – welcomed the report and enquired on whether consideration had been given to extending the relationship to those community’s businesses at the quay who also made a valuable contribution to the city.
· Cllr Moore – welcomed the report and noted residents were open to the development. She commented on the issues of increased density and design in key areas and the need for having a primary care facility and commitment to including NHS facilities.
· Cllr Moore – enquired on whether there could be a commitment to increasing biodiversity and avoiding the use of plastics in the new facilities.
· Cllr Moore – enquired on the whether maximising capital receipts would compromise the integrity of the site and was there consideration for affordable housing in this area?
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – advised that the land was within the Valley Park master plan, which needed to be considered and whether a statement needed to be made.
Councillor Moore welcomed the proposal to invite Stagecoach to the Customer Focus Scrutiny Committee and made reference to:- · the Bus Impact Plan; and · the fact that the new Combined County Authority would have Transport in its remit.
Anti-Social Behaviour in the City Centre – its causes and possible solutions While Councillors Read and Moore supported the proposal, with Councillor Moore singling out street attachment as an issue of importance, Councillor Wardle felt that the proposal would add little to what had been presented earlier in the meeting.
Budget Scrutiny proposal Councillor Moore referred to the recent meeting of the Combined Customer Focus and Strategy Committee and sought clarity on how to progress the scrutiny of the budget process . She proposed that the Customer Focus Scrutiny Committee should receive a report from relevant Portfolio Holders on options for approaches to achieve a balanced budget, followed by three spotlight reviews (i.e. one meeting) to consider each of the following:
Councillor Moore as co-Leader of the Progressive Group welcomed the report and asked that the Portfolio Holder provide an update in six months on the resettlement matching process.
Councillor Mitchell proposed and Councillor Moore seconded the following recommendation which following the vote was carried.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- Cllr Moore – thanked the officers for the work undertaken and enquired:- · what was the reason for the delay in undertaking the matching process for the homes purchased under previous funding rounds; and · why was the rent of the two bed properties proposed to be a higher than the Local Housing Allowance (LHA) level, given that housing and universal credit rent was based on the LHA level?
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – noted the onerous responsibility of the role and enquired on how Members would be advised on enabling compliance, and what would the extent of the indemnity provided would be for this role?
Councillor Moore moved an amendment for the following additional recommendations, which was seconded by Councillor Palmer:- “1. That the shareholder representative report back to Council not later January 2025, on the progress on the matters in Recommendation 4 and the Company’s ability to undertake the share buy-back;
In concluding, Councillor Moore commented:
In respect of Minute No. 9 (Informing the Audit Risk Assessment) , Councillor Moore asked what action would be taken to review the Council’s processes to help officers be aware of potentially fraudulent attempts to influence decision-making.
In respect of Minute No. 6 (Interim Annual Auditor's Annual Report on Exeter City Council 2021/22 and 2022/23) , Councillor Moore prompted the Leader for an update on the arrangements for the appointment of representatives to all relevant Council-connected companies and charities.
In his response, Councillor Bialyk remarked that the minute in question was that of a meeting he did not attend; however, he endeavoured to provide Councillor Moore with an answer at the earliest opportunity.
Councillor Moore asked the Leader about risks associated with the Exeter Development Fund, namely the proposal for the Council and other institutions in the city to put property assets into a new vehicle set up for investment by pension companies to enable property speculation and investment in infrastructure. The Leader remarked that the minutes at hand merely noted the Risk Register but advised that he would be prepared to find the appropriate forum to have this discussion.
Councillor Moore agreed with him and proposed an alternative recommendation as follows:- To refer this draft SPD back to the planning team to review this policy with a view to removing planning barriers to reducing carbon emissions, protecting and enhancing nature and addressing the climate crisis in line with the Council’s corporate objectives of Net Zero 2030 and tackling the environmental crisis.
The alternative recommendation was moved by Councillor Moore, seconded by Councillor Read and, following a vote, the alternative recommendation was lost.
In accordance with Standing Order No. 8, the following question was put by Councillor Moore ... view the full minutes text for item 40.
· Cllr Moore – enquired on the risk related to the commercial income generation and what was being done to address the ongoing issue.
An opposition group leader spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – enquired on the AV budget for equipment and whether it would be for improvements to meetings and broadcasting.
· Cllr Moore – enquired if the Portfolio Holder could report on the HRA budget, following conversations held at the Council Housing Advisory Board on the non- expenditure of sundry land maintenance in relation to trees and in respect of property maintenance. She also enquired on what the final outcome of overspending would be with the likely increased demand for repairs.
· Cllr Moore – welcomed the report but considered the government proposal to be late and too short a time period for support. She enquired if there was any data available from the previous funding schemes to inform on the level of demand and if the Council had previously been able to fulfil all the requests made.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – welcomed the report and enquired about how the measures set out in the five-year strategy would be incorporated into the new local plan.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – welcomed the figures and satisfaction levels.
· Cllr Moore –enquired on whether there were any risks to other planning applications and decision making and how it would improve team capacity. She further enquired about formalising community engagement, enhancing decision making processes and whether councillors and public could see the review panel reports and what had been agreed.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – thanked officers for the work undertaken but noted a number of issues requiring more discussion within the Council before the next draft. It was noted the local plan would go to one scrutiny committee and an ongoing series of monthly Planning Member Working Group meetings, but an agreed process for more Member inclusion was needed.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – enquired on the different options to governance arrangements and legal structures, how these might be resolved and who will be taking the project forward in regard to community involvement? She also enquired on what extent would capital be addressed to ensure community organisations do not struggle financially.
· Cllr Moore – enquired on the Sport England framework outlined in 8.12 of the report and how various issues can be brought together and related to other strategies. She further enquired if groups would be involved with the Exeter Place Board in a governance capacity?
Councillor Moore, as co-Leader of the Progressive Group, made the following points:- · the CCA deal was a foregone conclusion;
Councillor Moore, as co-Leader of the Progressive Group, welcomed the report and highlighted how the MRF was a critical piece of infrastructure. She further made the following points:- · she made reference to a video produced by the Portfolio Holder for Place & City Management which challenged residents to help the Council further reduce waste levels;
In accordance with Standing Order No. 20, the following question was submitted by Councillor Moore in relation to the Portfolio of Councillor Bialyk who attended the meeting. The question was circulated at the meeting to Members of the Committee. The response of the Leader is set out in italics below: – Question What action is being undertaken by the Council to ensure that the public toilets at the bus station remain open for use?
Supplementary Question and Response Councillor Moore sought assurances that the toilets would be open soon and before the Easter weekend.
· Cllr Moore – enquired on the Portfolio Holders’ role in contributing to the review of the risk register.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – expressed concern that cycle stores in front gardens required planning permission and that dropped kerbs wouldn’t. She commented on the government consulting on permissive development rights and the potential danger of the Council policy falling out of sync with government policy.
The Leader advised that questions had been received from Councillor Moore, which the Executive had considered wouldn’t change the recommendations.
Opposition group leaders spoke on the item and made the following points:- · Cllr Moore – had submitted questions, which the questions and responses are appended to the minutes. She also enquired on whether the strategy had enough funding to be progressed.
In respect of Minute No. 63 (External Auditors – Interim Audit Findings Report 2021/22), Councillor Moore asked when the Council would be informed of the full liability of the outstanding Exeter City Living debt. Minimum Revenue Provision.
Responding to a query on a matter of process from Councillor Moore, Councillor Vizard clarified that the recommendation at Minute No. 5 (‘Capital Strategy 2024-25’) was for the Executive and not Council.
In respect of Minute No. 18 (2024/25 Strata Business Plan) , Cllr Moore asked for an update on the carbon impact of Strata activities and how this was being incorporated into their business plan.
Under Standing Order 10(5)(f), Councillor Moore clarified the reason for her original question.
In respect of Minute No. 5 ( City Wide Net Zero) , Councillor Moore enquired about :- · support for the community group in the light of funding for Exeter Connect ending; and · the alignment of the commercial objectives mentioned in the report with the objectives of the community group.
In respect of Minute No. 16 ( Review of Equality and Diversity Policy ) , Councillor Moore welcomed the policy and stressed the importance of monitoring how it made a difference, suggested this be reported to Full Council or to Scrutiny.
Councillor Moore welcomed the fact that the programme would continue and sought clarity on:- · assurances on good governance and accountability;
Councillor Moore proposed a recommendation, which was seconded by Councillor Sparling that the Executive review the position that the Capital Strategy includes an improvement to the environment as a specific objective of any capital projects over the year. Following a vote, the proposal was carried.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader enquired on the strategic risk relating to the outcome of the change process and the impact on quality of service. She also enquired on the review trigger point to ensure the risk of cuts was reduced.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader enquired about the recommendation for a public consultation on the council budget.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader enquired on the criteria and assessment for the review of capital assets.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader enquired on what advice was received for the recommendation on the climate impact council investment.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader enquired on what the annual monitoring arrangements were for assessing the impact of the policy.
In accordance with Standing Order No. 20, the following questions were submitted by Councillor Moore in relation to the Portfolio of Councillor Bialyk who attended the meeting. The questions were circulated at the meeting to Members of the Committee.
The response of the Leader is set out in italics below: – QUESTIONS FROM MEMBERS UNDER SO20 TO CLLR BIALYK Questions from Councillor Moore 1. The Exeter Development Fund ( https://www.globalcityfutures.com/case-study/next-phase-exeter-development-fund/ ) no longer features in the Regulation 18 version of the Local Plan. Please can the Leader explain why this project is not included?
Councillor Moore asked a supplementary question and referred to the Exeter Development Fund Task and Finish Group which had only met once to agree a set of terms of reference. She asked about their role and if there would be further involvement when the work was complete.
Councillor Moore asked a supplementary question regarding the lack of outcome, despite the level of expenditure. She referred to the sum still to be spent and asked when further outputs from this work might be forthcoming.
Councillor Moore asked an additional question in relation to flood mitigation measures which would come at the end of approved developments in the St Davids ward, and sought assurance that there will be more immediate measures before the Local Plan comes forward.
He reiterated that he would be happy to discuss this with Councillor Moore through the usual channels of discussion.
Councillor Moore welcomed the planned work with the community, but considered the proposal for a Climate Change Sub Committee, which had been agreed in accordance with legislation had still to be addressed, and if the matter was not to be pursued, then it would have to be overturned formally at the Scrutiny Committee.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, welcomed the report and suggested the inclusion of a work plan which focused on the project priorities to reduce emissions to benefit communities.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, enquired on whether board members were aware of the mission creep and sought assurance that the outstanding governance issues would be addressed. She also commented on the recommendation related to the climate subcommittee.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, welcomed the move from fixed term tenancies and enquired about the survivorship policy and to whom it applied.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, enquired whether the 35% housing and development liability target would be met for homes built on brownfield sites in the new local plan?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, enquired on when the programme could become a critical issue and would the priorities and proposed cuts over the next three years be made available to residents and businesses in Exeter.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, enquired on what risk analyses for non-payment from low-income homes.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, welcomed the updated strategy and enquired on the low scoring for climate change and how it would be monitored and progressed by the partner authorities.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, emphasised that staff abuse was not acceptable, however, due to some people having varying challenging and complex needs, whether there was an appeal process for complaints?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, welcomed the updates and enquired how Councillors would be updated on the progress of work?
Councillor Moore indicated that she wished to move an amendment to Recommendation (1), and seconded by Councillor M Mitchell to the following:- (1) the disposal of land at Mary Arches Street car park as shown on the site boundary plans in Appendix 1, the multi-storey car park site for mixed development, and the surface car park for residential use.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and in thanking the Chief Executive for the report enquired whether the cost for withdrawal could be outlined?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and enquired:- · Whether the £276,940 overspend figure outlined in 8.3 of the report for the impact of Exeter City Living (ECL) being scaled back was for the year or to date?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and enquired on funding requirements.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and enquired about general repairs which stated that 60% had been spent already, and whether tenants would be able to get their essential repairs done?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and made the following points:- · Was the Executive responsible for the risks in the corporate plan for presenting at Council for Members to vote on?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and welcomed the recognition on the imbalance in the local community threshold and enquired how a balanced community was defined? She further enquired on the basis of the calculation and whether that could be recorded with the documents and when the policy would be reviewed?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and welcomed the discount to seasonal developers ending because they were building luxury developments which were top prices for students. She raised concerns about high density Co-Living units for long term living and not providing needed infrastructure to the community.
A subsequent report would be presented to the Executive and Council for approval following the consultation Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and welcomed the principle of charging for pre application advice. She sought clarification on residents would be included in the consultation process, which she felt was essential in being open to residents and giving them confidence in the planning system.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item welcoming the report, but raised concerns about climate change relating to the MRF and district heating in system in Cranbrook, which were high in CO 2 emissions. She considered that there needed to be additional conclusions of measures for moving towards Net Zero.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and enquired if Ward Members could be involved in decisions on how Section 106 money was spent in their Ward. She also enquired about Mallison Bridge, in relation to the priorities for the cycling bridge over the canal.
Councillor Read declared a Discloseable Pecuniary Interest, as having sought to ask a question under Minute 73 (Full Draft Exeter Plan Consultation), she had an interest as a Member of the Exeter Canal and Quay Trust (ECQT) and withdrew from the room, whilst the matter was raised by Councillor Moore.
In accordance with Standing Order No. 20, the following questions were submitted by Councillor Moore in relation to the Portfolios of Councillors Bialyk, Morse and also Councillor Pearce who attended the meeting. The questions were circulated at the meeting to Members of the Committee.
Councillor Moore asked a supplementary question, whether the Leader would involve the Ward Councillors in the discussions on the Feasibility work before it was reported to the Executive. The Leader said that Ward Members along with all Members and residents will be consulted in accordance with the Consultation Charter.
Councillor Moore asked a supplementary question relating to the advanced feasibility stage, which was beyond a vision and concept and asked if Ward Members would be involved in the discussion. The Leader advised that appropriate Ward Members would be contacted for any of the sites in the city.
Councillor Moore asked a supplementary question, if the figures would be available after the meeting. The Leader stated they were not currently available.
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and raised the following points:- · the Strategy showed that areas of digital exclusion were correlated in high deprivation areas and referred to the importance of understanding the extent of digital inequality and the impact on Council services. Should the Council be asking what the impact of inequality on people’s lives was, and how the Council could support people in order to reduce demand on its services?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and sought clarification on the amendment to Standing Order No. 54 and whether the update was proposing to substitute the regulation to an earlier regulation and wished to ensure that the Council was using the correct regulations.
In respect of Minute No. 92 (Net Zero Exeter Update) , Councillor Moore moved and Councillor M.
Councillor Moore, in speaking to the amendment to the recommendations, made the following points:- · the additions were to strengthen the proposals being put forward;
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and made the following points:- · tackling the climate emergency was one of the three big challenges the city faced;
Particular reference was made to the successful development of the apprenticeships for Food Law and Health and Safety Service and building future Environmental Health Officer roles Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and enquired if the team would have sufficient resources to deliver the plan as expected?
Councillor Moore, as an opposition group leader, spoke on this item and welcomed the improvement of the air quality findings, but was mindful of the impacts of long term exposure to high levels of air pollution. She sought clarification on the air quality management area and whether that included the actions contained in the air quality management plan, and where some elements were no longer deliverable, that improvements needed be addressed.
Councillor Moore wished to propose a working group to discuss a draft terms of reference document that she had put together to bring back to the Scrutiny Committee in respect of a Climate Change Sub Committee. She commended the work of the Service Lead Net Zero and her team and stressed that the discussion should centre on consideration of the city wide work and options for resourcing and not of the City Council’s work.
Councillor Mitchell moved the following to have an in principle agreement of setting up a Sub Committee to act as a city wide forum to bring together partners with the aim of Exeter being Carbon Neutral by 2030, and a meeting be held as soon as possible with the Portfolio Holder for Climate and Ecological Crisis, the Chair and Deputy Chair of this Scrutiny Committee, Councillor Moore as the original proposer, and the Chief Executive to discuss matters including a proposed terms of reference.
Councillor Moore raised the following three questions:- (1) In relation to building greater neighbourhoods and communities, why was the risk of low land/property values and lack of investment appetite, a greater inherent risk than residents not being able to afford to rent or buy the new homes built under this approach?
In accordance with Standing Order No. 8, the following questions were put by Councillor Moore to the Leader 1.
Councillor Moore thanked the Portfolio Holder for the reply and sought a response for information on the last part of her question and the financial impact on this City Council service. The Portfolio Holder would provide a written response.
Councillor Moore asked a supplementary question on future funding and whether support for the agencies who remain as providers of exempt accommodation would be able to bill their housing benefit directly through the Government and not the Council, and also if there was any discussion with other District Councils on this matter.
Councillor Moore in asking a supplementary question enquired if the Leader will know when the site will be developed, as in principle planning permission would be for 15 years.
RESOLVED on the nomination of Councillor Fullam , seconded by Councillor Moore, that Councillor Kevin Mitchell be elected Lord Mayor of the City for the ensuing Municipal Year.
Councillor Moore also enquired about the consultancy fees spent on the review of the responsive repairs contract and the consultancy work as cost saving for service improvements for Housing Assets.
The responses of the Portfolio Holders were set out in italics below:- Question from Councillor D Moore to the Portfolio Holder for Leisure & Physical Activity (Councillor Parkhouse) Question Why, when we are all supposed to be more inclusive of everyone in society, do I as a disabled person, have to travel outside Exeter to other towns and cities if I want to attend a "Disabled Only" swimming session?" In support of the question, Councillor Moore advised that she had asked the question on behalf of a resident who had visited St Sidwell’s Point. She was aware that the resident had met with the Manager to discuss his experience “that there were a large number of disabled people in and around Exeter who would like to swim in the city pools but who would feel anxious, overwhelmed and even fearful of attending a public swim simply because the environment could be very busy and noisy at times. Additionally, people feel very conspicuous when they have to use a hoist or enter and exit the pool with assistance.
Supplementary Question and Answer Councillor Moore asked if the service would be willing to work with the residents to improve their confidence whilst at St Sidwell’s Point.
Question from Councillor D Moore –to the Leader of thr Council (Councillor Bialyk) Question Please can the Portfolio Holder provide and update on the repair of the Riverside Leisure Centre roof?
Questions from Councillor Diana Moore to the Leader - Councillor Bialyk 1. How many planning performance agreements does the Council have in place? Of these, and in principle for any future agreements, what proportion of the costs of such agreement are/will be funded by the developer?
In accordance with Standing Order No. 20, the following questions were submitted by Councillor Oliver in relation to the Portfolio of Councillor Parkhouse and also from Councillor Diana Moore in relation to the Portfolios for Councillors Wood, Wright and Morse. The questions were circulated in advance to Members of the Committee. The responses of the Portfolio Holders are set out in italics below:
Councillor Diana Moore attended the meeting having submitted a number of questions under Standing Order 44.
Councillor Moore sought further clarification on the retrofit programme and that following Council on 22 February, it was being worked on. She referred to question 3 of the response and asked if the Portfolio Holder for Council Housing Development and Services could clarify the standard to which the Council houses were being retrofitted, as it wasn’t to Passivhaus standard, as was clarified at the meetings of the Council Housing and Development Advisory Board.
He undertook to ensure a separate response would be made to Councillor Moore on the other points she had raised.
Councillor Moore welcomed the proposal but considered the report to be complex and was set apart from the goals to establish a carbon budget for Exeter as shown in the recommendations. She further considered that there was no risk analyses and sought clarification on how the report author reached the analysis of the risks outlined in Section 9 of the report and enquired on the following areas:- · What assessment criteria regarding the impact of the secondments did the Council intend to use?
Councillor Moore asked the following two questions – 1. Can the Portfolio Holder provide details of the Devon Devolution proposals that the local paper says were sent to Government by local authority leaders in Devon?
Councillor Moore thanked the Leader and referred to the level of unsustainable growth, and whether addressing climate change and dealing with the Ecological Climate Emergency would be considered as a top priority as part of any economic deal, and to clarify that an Elected Mayor was not included in the economic proposals.
Councillor Diana Moore moved and Councillor Kevin Mitchell seconded the following amendments:- Amend resolution 2 to read:
In accordance with Standing Order No. 8, the following questions were put by Councillor Diana Moore to the Leader.
Councillor Diana Moore sought confirmation as to whether any land between Exeter Ship Canal and the River Exe was being considered for development, including any infrastructure?
The Leader referred to comments he had received from Councillor Diana Moore on the proposed Charter and stated that it would be appropriate for the Scrutiny Programme Board to examine these suggestions. He welcomed the best practice approach and the feedback from the Consultation Institute and, whilst it was right to look to further improve the Charter, regard should be had to costs and the availability of existing resources.
During the discussion the following points were raised:- · some elements could be clarified and amended in light of comments from Councillor Diana Moore;
In accordance with Standing Order 20, Councillor Diana Moore submitted the following question relating to consultation and engagement, which the Leader responded to and which was set out below in the following terms:- “In October 2019 I submitted the following scrutiny proposal to set up a task and finish group to develop a framework for the Council, setting out its approach to consultation and engagement. The framework would include setting out:- · the meaning, purposes and principles of consultation, engagement and any related methodologies the Council intends to use, · what the Council and contributors might expect from participation in such processes, · how and what decisions may be influenced by such contributions or participation and where and when those decisions will be taken; and · how contributions will be analysed and how feedback to contributors and the public will be given.
Councillor Moore in asking a supplementary question enquired if there would be further consultation on the proposal and if the intended course of action was incongruous with the sentiment of consultation. She looked forward to an opportunity to offer feedback on the proposal, but felt the current process did not allow for active scrutiny on that matter. She felt confident of the shared aspiration with the Leader to ensure that consultation worked well, and asked if there would be any opportunity to comment on the report before the Executive.
Councillor D Moore - Liveable Exeter Transformational Housing Programme:
Councillor Moore thanked the Leader and referred to the high level engagement and the prospectus of the Garden City Programme and referred to the proposals and whether the local community is being or will be engaged at an early stage. It was clear that in respect of community, both in terms of current and the future that residents must have a meaningful say in developing the proposals from design to delivery to constructively contribute to the future of the city. Whilst appreciating the impact of Covid-19, which has made it more difficult to engage communities, she asked the Leader to bring forward those plans and ... view the full minutes text for item 26.
Councillor D Moore sought some further information relating to the following which officers would respond to: - · Minute 32 - budgets relating to the public conveniences, and the income changes derived from the offer of free car parking on Thursday nights;
Councillor D Moore, having given notice under Standing Order No.44, spoke on this item, commenting on the likely impact the Exeter City Living business plan would have by moving sites to the HRA and the proportion of the £18 million that would be funded from borrowing.
Councillor D Moore, having given notice under Standing Order No.44, spoke on this item. She wanted to ensure that the purpose of the engagement was explained to participants, maximising participation in the consultation and she also referred to the potential risk of Exeter City Futures CIC or other partners not supporting the road map.
Councillor D Moore, having given notice under Standing Order No.44, spoke on this item. She enquired about the effectiveness of the new governance arrangements in holding the Executive to account, partner bodies for scrutiny and the 50 word limitation for questions.
Councillor Diana Moore requested an item be placed on the agenda under Standing Order 18 regarding progress on the use of Single Use Plastics, and to receive an update on the Motion adopted by council on 24 April 2018 – see link https://protect-eu.mimecast.com/s/18qfCr9EqcADILs7EBer?domain=committees.exeter.gov.uk Councillor Sutton thanked Councillor Moore for raising this matter and reminded Members of the Council resolution and policy which was widely welcomed and supported and she was mindful of the commitment made.
She welcomed the collection of tetra packs, which Councillor Moore had raised earlier in the meeting, and plastic and coffee shop paper cups which was possible at brightly coloured orange, collection banks in the city. Sometimes it was necessary to consider the way that products were used as it could actually take more energy to produce a paper bag, rather than a plastic one.
Councillor D Moore, having given notice under Standing Order No.44, spoke on this item. She had submitted three questions relating to city centre business. The Leader provided responses, which are appended to these minutes.
Councillor D Moore, seconded by Councillor K Mitchell, moved a Motion in the following terms:- Exeter City Council notes the purpose of the community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) is expected to “Have a positive economic effect on development across a local plan area.” The current CIL charging statement was adopted for Exeter on 15th October 2013. The rapid construction since this date of purpose built student blocks (PSPBs), particularly in the city centre wards has already bought forward a 8,017 bed spaces and 2,802 are currently in construction. That while developers have enjoyed a discount on the CIL levy compared to housebuilders, a significant number of the PBSBs been priced and marketed as ‘luxury’ accommodation.
In presenting the Notice of Motion, Councillor D Moore stated that it was a matter of importance to all. She agreed with the cross party consensus that students made a significant contribution to life in Exeter, however she had received complaints from students that the purpose built student blocks were expensive to live in and for many students unaffordable. She appreciated that it would take time for any change, but she hoped that plans to mitigate the student built blocks would be made.
Minutes are the council's own written record of a meeting. They summarise what was said rather than recording every word, so each extract is shown exactly as the council published it, with the meeting it comes from.
Every vote the minutes record at meetings Councillor Moore attended, with their own vote wherever the council lists votes by name.
| Date | Meeting | Item | Their vote | Result | Count |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Mar 2026 | Council | Executive Committee - 3 February 2026 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 25 Feb 2026 | Council | Budget 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Dec 2025 | Council | HRA Budget Monitoring Report – Q2 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Dec 2025 | Council | Treasury Management Strategy Report 2026/27 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 9 Dec 2025 | Council | Update of Exeter City Council’s Companies, Alternative Delivery Models and Charities. | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 27 Jun 2024 | Customer Focus Scrutiny Committee | Scrutiny Work Plan and Proposals Received | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 24 Apr 2023 | Planning Committee | Planning Application No. 22/1177/FUL - Land adjacent to Gras Lawn and Fleming Way, Gras Lawn, Exeter | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jan 2020 | the Council | Executive - 14 January 2020 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jan 2020 | the Council | Executive - 14 January 2020 | Carried | Unanimous | |
| 21 Jan 2020 | the Council | Executive - 14 January 2020 | Carried | Unanimous |
Meetings Councillor Moore was expected at, from each meeting's attendance record.
Present at 13 of 15 meetings in the last 12 months.
What Councillor Moore declared at meetings, as the minutes record it.
No declarations of interest by Councillor Moore in the minutes read so far.
Where Councillor Moore sits, from the attendance records.
| Committee | Role | Since | Meetings | Next meeting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Council | Committee Member | Jun 2025 | 8 | 1 Dec 2026 |
| the Council | Committee Member | Jan 2020 | 3 | |
| Planning Committee | Guest | Oct 2022 | 3 | 7 Dec 2026 |
| Customer Focus Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Jun 2024 | 3 | |
| Strategic Scrutiny Committee | Committee Member | Nov 2025 | 3 | 19 Nov 2026 |
| Audit and Governance Committee | Chair | Nov 2025 | 3 | 26 Nov 2026 |
| Annual Council | Committee Member | May 2026 | 1 | |
| Executive | Guest | Nov 2021 | 3 | |
| Combined Strategic Scrutiny and Customer Focus Scrutiny Committees | Guest | Jul 2022 | 1 |
We use a cookie to keep you signed in and run your free-paper allowance, and an optional one to count visits. You can accept all, or choose. Privacy & cookies
Keeps you signed in and runs your free-paper allowance. Always on.
Counts visits and which pages are used. First-party only, no advertising, never shared.